self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
aligning conflicting interests isn't "needless," it's an imposed cost and whether or not it's worth it is up to the parties involved, in this instance the person who owns the ship picking a captain to helm the ship
You can see that my claim is that the cost is grossly excessive to the benefit.
if jets came about during a time when it took 6 months to a year to return the jet to the owner, I have little doubt there would be a similar tradition
The current turnaround time for a new bleeding edge jet is measured in years, the pilots are expensive, the jets are ridiculously so. They still come with ejection seats.
additionally, given the likelihood hotel staff is ever put into the position to choose to die with the guests is extremely small, the benefit of instilling "the guest is God" in them likely have strong benefits with little costs the overwhelming vast majority of the time
And it's not possible to instill the belief that "the guest is God" without demanding that they die for them? What else might also be inculcated if the satisfaction of guests is elevated above all else, the staff expected to sleep with them or let them stay for free? There are obvious bounds on their hospitality.
traditions don't exist for the hell of it; this is chesterton's fence
I can only groan. As is the case for all fully-generalized counterarguments against doing anything ever, it counts as weak evidence for that claim. There are plenty of utterly retarded, harmful and destruction-worthy traditions, both that existed in the past, like sati, and those that exist today, like female genital mutilation.
If you put such a high premium on arguments from tradition, then I'll quote the reasoning of the British officials who put in place the ban on burning widows alive when their husbands passed:
Be it so. This burning of widows is your custom; prepare the funeral pile. But my nation has also a custom. When men burn women alive we hang them, and confiscate all their property. My carpenters shall therefore erect gibbets on which to hang all concerned when the widow is consumed. Let us all act according to national customs.[To Hindu priests complaining to him about the prohibition of Sati religious funeral practice of burning widows alive on her husband’s funeral pyre.]
So my custom, as is the custom of the Rationalist movement in the many forms it has had over the centuries, is pointing out civilizational inadequacies and behaviors that have become maladaptive, assuming they were even good for anything in the first place.
Malpractice insurance works, offing doctors who failed to cure the Pharaoh didn't. So too for imposing legal or financial liabilities on ship's captains being reckless, not asking them to die for it.
Yeah, I don't see that working very well, certainly not enough to justify a needless death. Most captains are probably getting their ships sunk as little as feasible. Those who are feckless enough to not care probably aren't going to stay around except at gunpoint.
Consider why fighter pilots are given parachutes, surely they'd fly better if they knew they were guaranteed to go down with their jet?
I despise the idea that the Captain must go down with their ship. What's that going to achieve? Sure, their duty might incorporate sticking around as long as possible to arrange an evacuation, but when that's done, they don't have any responsibility to feed the fishes.
I can't speak for India
I can, and I can assure you that close to ~100% of the hospitality staff are booking it in this scenario.
I am modestly libertarian, so I have no fundamental disagreement with 3rd parties providing licenses or the insurance route, I just happen to think government licensing is adequate and the majority of the debate is over whether refusals to license based on specific diseases like autism or sleep apnea are warranted.
an impromptu cadre of hotel employees will have to suffice
The only justification I've seen for mandatory tipping!
I suspect that insurance companies would ask you to take a driving test, how else are you they supposed to know you have the minimum acceptable levels of competence, before further actuarial concerns?
I'm certainly not going to engage with that topic any longer, everything worth saying has been said, either he'll note the several megabytes of text telling him to find something better to do with his life or he'll go off and potentially kill himself.
Hardly any good beaches I'm afraid, and I've been to most. In contrast, my recent trip to Thailand had me blown away by how picturesque the beach and emerald waves were, it's like they threw a photoshop filter on reality there. The closest could be the beaches on the Andaman islands, but they're within spitting distance of Thailand anyway.
That's entirely ignoring the maintenance of most beaches, they're not usually clean.
It is not necessarily the case that non-discrimination on ethnic/religious grounds is sacred to them, they might simply put a high premium on it and accept the other negative consequences as acceptable. I am using "sacred" in the sense of something very deeply cherished, just to make myself clear in case a few pedants show up. US immigration is/was selective enough that that they were content with the status quo prior to the "Muslim ban", which only targeted a few specific countries and not even the bulk of Muslim majority nations.
I do not expect any of the people cited to be so inflexible on the matter that they'd advocate for card-carrying members of ISIS to be fast-tracked.
So what are your lesser known examples of Place vs Place,Japan?
My toilet vs "Toilet", Japan. Indian toilets come with bidets as standard, and believe me you don't need them to come with all the bells and whistles the Japanese ones do if your primary concern is getting your butthole squeaky clean.
For reference I said:
That's a relatively new one in these parts eh? Leave aside arguing why my ideology is superior, let me claim that yours is just as bad. I can see this is an immensely convincing argument.
Quoting you saying:
Unfortunately, your atheism is at least as unbacked by evidence and reason as either. You are personally as irrational as the trans ideologues, but you give yourself a pass out of pure self-serving smugness.
Hmm.. Did you happen to notice that @Goodguy was claiming that trans ideo was comparably awful to Catholicism, while condemning both? And not being an adherent of either?
And that my gripe with you is that you are presumably a Christian or at least religious, and your sole argument in that specific comment was claiming atheism is just as unfounded as religion, while being religious?
In other words, "both of you suck" versus "you suck just as much as I do". The former is, well, a just a value judgement, whereas the latter is what I expect someone to jump to when they've got nothing else worth saying.
You do you, but I'm leaving, my time to pointlessly quibble here is limited since I have no expectation of an eternal afterlife, or at least one not of our own making, and it's not here yet.
The reason I describe it as a property and not a complete metaphysical system is because are there are literally zero people on the planet who belief in only atheism when it comes to their ontology/epistemics/metaphysics to the exclusion of everything else.
What on earth is such a creature supposed to be? They have literally no other fundamental ontology except being convinced of the absence of the supernatural? You'd expect at least object permanence.
Presumably, then, you would agree that when you say "evidence", you're not meaning "scientific evidence", for that would immediately fall directly into the obvious trap of mistaking methodological constraints for metaphysical theory. So, uh, what do you mean when you speak of "an overwhelming preponderance of evidence"?
I would refer you to the part where I clearly stated that religions are not purely metaphysical and have claims that are based off events in the real world. If some hypothetical religion did not claim to describe any events in reality, then good for them I guess, but that's basically just fiction, and I'm not inclined to go around claiming Harry Potter is a lie. It is the glaring deficiency of such evidence, which may or may not be scientific but is certainly Bayesian, that I'm indicating as a reason to think religions are false.
At any rate, I've said my peace.
Trust me, if they're coming for us (they haven't come for me yet, India hasn't succumbed to wokism), I'm more than happy to close ranks. Consider this more of a dispute about epistemic standards than anything else.
After all, while I am OK with the nominal goal of trans people of changing sexes, and even endorse it from the perspective of transhumanism as just as valid as any desire to change the limitations of one's flesh, I demand they pass biologically before I will accept them as actually now the opposite sex, mere self-identification works for football clubs, not sex.
In other words, I think there is a non-negligible subset of trans people who feel genuine distress at being their natal sex, and would likely have that distress relieved by physical transition, but I have no issues with AGPs either, I simply resent being dictated that they're now women without possessing the relevant attributes of femininity.
So, HlynkaCG, I don't get why we keep having these discussions, you just assert a bunch of things that are patently false, and then repeat them a few months later after they're corrected.
At this point I'm just tempted to make a FAQ-style compilation to save my breath later.
Attempting to use one's right hand isn't the same as being right-handed! A person who is left handed can very well claim that they're so, without anyone asking how they're quite so confident in that fact, since they've never experienced the internal qualia of being right handed so they can claim that they somehow know that's not what they're feeling in the first place.
It's not news to me that this isn't the stance or primary concern of trans ideologues, I oppose them myself after all, it's my specific objection to your use of the fundamental inability for us to inhabit many counterfactual mental states as the primary criterion for denying the existence of innate senses of gender, regardless of whether that's a real thing. It has far too much collateral damage at the very least, as I've attempted to show.
Also, it's telling that you didn't come to say that... to Goodguy, who, after all, did nearly nothing but say that someone's ideology is just as bad as another one. Big oof by you, but telling of the fact that you're far more critical of things you're predisposed to disagree with than things you're predisposed to agree with.
What exactly is it telling of? If you wish to call it hypocrisy, feel free, but I can wholeheartedly assure you that people will leap to the defense of things they care about/prefer more than those they don't.
I am on record defending particular ideologies/movements I strongly dislike from false accusations.
For a recent example, when another atheist reclaimed religion as innately irrational, I strong disagreed, there's nothing wrong with the concept of religion from the standpoint of rationality, it's the belief in it in the face of the monumental amount of evidence against the supernatural elements seen in believers that makes them irrational. Belief in the supernatural ceases to be irrational when there's net positive evidence of supernatural events.
I see nothing wrong with claiming that religion/Catholicism is as bad/unfounded as trans-ideology and Wokism, or at least comparable in terms of harm, certainly in terms of the basis of their claims where it pertains to empirical reality.
My objection to you is that you didn't submit anything more than post-modernist nonsense about how, since atheism makes metaphysical claims, it's just as unfounded as religion. That is not the stance of anyone who has more convincing examples to show me, and believe me plenty of religious people try to do that, I and many others are atheists because such evidence is utterly inadequate for the magnitude of the claims
It is a property possessed by all metaphysical systems that do not posit supernatural elements. If I really must choose between the two options you've provided, it's the latter.
The null hypothesis. To recycle a very appropriate quip, atheism is no more a religion than a TV's screen being off is a television channel.
It is inherently an aspect of any metaphysical system that doesn't have explicitly claim the existence of supernatural elements, at the very least those that imply any interference, past, present or future, with the evolution of the world.
I suppose "he started it" isn't a valid defense is it? Leaving aside that that's true, I admit I do know better.
I commit to ignoring Hlynka in the future, since I cannot believably claim to extend him the same degree of charity or patience as I usually provide and as dictated by the norms of the Motte. If I find a polite and acceptable way of drawing attention to his consistent pattern of ad hominem attacks, outright racism, refusal to remember rebuttals to the claims he's made before and everything else, I might reconsider, but none come to mind.
What experiment have you conducted which demonstrates equality between methodological constraints of science and metaphysical theory of ontology?
Metaphysics is not physics, hence it's not amenable to exploration by such means. But religions are not exclusively metaphysics, almost all of them, and certainly Christianity, claim tangible effects in the real world that is tantamount to a divergence from mere mechanistic evolution of physical processes. They certainly have apologetics by the bucketload for why such interventions are beyond the ability of scientific empirism to evaluate in terms of plausibility.
A religion stripped of physical implications or supernatural influences on reality is simply a philosophy, and those can only be adopted or denied, not proved or disproved.
Unfortunately, your atheism is at least as unbacked by evidence and reason as either.
That's a relatively new one in these parts eh? Leave aside arguing why my ideology is superior, let me claim that yours is just as bad. I can see this is an immensely convincing argument.
There is an overwhelming preponderance of evidence that the universe operates according to a mechanistic evolution of relatively simple laws of physics, with no external intervention at all.
Recently, I've concluded that I basically agree with Bankman Fried. Most books could have been a 6 para blog post instead.
I don't necessarily disagree, it certainly doesn't seem to me that non-fiction books are optimizing very hard for succintness.
And that reading for the sake of it is like driving to the grocery for the sake of it. Its a means to an end.
I mean, I disagree, because if you consider simply driving, or even walking or running, many people find it intrinsically enjoyable. At any rate, I can't say you're not well read despite not finding it intrinsically motivating, so who am I to judge?
I'd rather croak ;)

I am not talking about "that era", I am talking about today.
And there was law enforcement back at the time, regardless of how difficult it was, desertion or dereliction of duty was very much punishable, and most often such people had families back home so they didn't have the luxury of being guaranteed to go off scott free.
More options
Context Copy link