@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

How do you stop yourself from just doing stuff constantly?

"Problems I wish I had" for most of the money in the world haha

In your case, I would advise committing to a specific chunk of time, say an hour or two, which you mentally label as "me time" and steadfastly refuse to do anything remotely describable as productive during it. Maybe get your wife to scold you if you lapse. Specific mental compartmentalization should work better in a highly conscientious individual, but what do I know about that? ;)

It just seems like an unnatural way to live, but I find the idea of not feeling productive to be almost more exhausting.

Being extremely intelligent and talented, running ultra-marathons or winning Nobel Prizes aren't natural either. Consider yourself immensely blessed that your particular eccentricities are highly conducive or even outright optimal for what might loosely be termed as success.

If you had tangible and debilitating results from your diligence and workaholism, such as stress, excessive fatigue or mood swings, I'd advise you to take it more seriously, but in this case my stance is more "this isn't a problem to solve, or worth solving" in the first place.

Edit:

If I don't have work I'll invent new work for myself to do, even if it's just typing up essays for here.

Not that I seem to have much time to read anymore anyway, but if I'm hanging out with someone and they step out to the bathroom I'll pull out my phone and start studying something on Wikipedia or a think tank or whatever. The idea of not filling idle moments with something ostensibly productive is alien to me.

It's funny how these particular behaviors are applicable to me, someone with ADHD, but for entirely opposite reasons. For example, I just spent a few hours studying on Ritalin, and while the drug hasn't worn off completely, here I am procrasturbating by posting on the Motte. Many (most) of my posts, good or bad, are written when writing seems like a refuge from the work I should much more sensibly be doing.

If I'm not busy doing something else or engaged in conversation, you'll be finding me on my phone, binging on Insight Porn, Wikipedia included, but this is because I hate being bored, and for the life of me can't understand people who praise it, be it for its own sake or because it serves as a generator of creative ideas (which I disagree with to a degree).

A great deal of my childhood, before I had omnipresent portable electronics, was spent day dreaming, and I would devour literature of all descriptions voraciously, to the chagrin of my teachers when they caught me reading novels under my desk. Sometimes, when I think life is shit, I remember just how awful it must have been to be so terminally bored, be it in my childhood or as the norm for most of human history.

A pejorative term for Google Glass users, particularly those who wore them to public and shared private spaces.

Discord has an experimental chat summarization feature using LLMs that keeps you abreast of lengthy threads if you join in later.

I think eventually we'll have an equivalent on other chat apps, especially one capable of notifying you only when something of note happens. Sadly I don't think anything actually exists along those lines right now.

Feeling Rational:

For the n+1-th time, emotions are not incompatible with rationality. They can be appropriate or inappropriate, relevant to reality or not, but they're not irrational by default.

Further, presumably @zataomm takes umbrage to arguments that rely entirely or mostly on emotion, not a claim that emotion is entirely out of place in an argument.

Your response to him reeks of the "Ah yes you claim to hate society, yet you participate it, curious" meme.

Funny you should say this, since about an hour back, I was woken from a much needed nap by a panicked nurse in order to attend to a cancer patient, and arrived to see her grossly decompensating, with particular issues that made most of the initial resuscitation measures I'm in a position to provide useless.

I lost a bit of hair over how I was supposed to treat her, but was incredibly relieved to discover that, despite the nurses losing their shit, she was a palliative patient who had just had her End of Life and DNR forms filled by her family after the consultant in charge had informed them that all hope was lost as the brain mets gradually ate away at whatever made her human.

No amount of medical care any ICU could provide would save her or make her whole, at most we could prolong the process by keeping a living corpse hooked up to a ventilator at ruinous cost and taking space better served with the living. That calmed me down, even if this was the first time I had to deal with a dying patient entirely alone with nobody to back me up, I've read the guidelines, I know the drugs, and after some faffing around because apparently the oncology ward of the fanciest hospital in my part of the country didn't have syringe drivers capable of providing subcutaneous meds (utterly ridiculous, but they almost certainly have them in the ICU, but she was categorically forbidden from being transferred there), I managed to figure out a protocol that would ease the pain, or at least any residual discomfort someone who hadn't been conscious for days and never would be again might feel till her lungs filled with fluid and her heart became fitful and her ribs were no longer a cage for her soul.

So there you have it, I'm complicit in killing someone today, and I think it was a good decision, or at least the least bad of the options at hand. That's euthanasia for you, the modal case, representative of the end of suffering for millions.

It still hurt, at least for me, you'd think that working in an Onco ward would dissipate delusions that you can make sure your patients always walk out hale and hearty, but I did enter the profession because I'm proud to heal people. If that's not possible, may they pass gently into the good night, rage is more appropriate for the living who must deal with the banal, apathetic cruelty of an unfeeling world.

The problem is that very, very many people are flaky and short-sighted. Death is a one way trip, with no ability to undo a mistake.

Speaking very broadly, since practised and legal norms vary so grossly, euthanasia for the atypical cases where they're "physically" healthy involve lengthy periods of consultation and various opportunities to back out, though I think Canada has a more streamlined process, for better or worse.

So it's typically the case that multiple earnest medical professionals and social workers will repeatedly inquire as to the continued choice of the person to continue on the course. Even then, in my opinion, if someone who doesn't have a lack of capacity earnestly tells me they want to die, I wish to do my best to accommodate them promptly, even if I won't literally pull out a gun the moment they say so. This decision is obviously dependent on factors like acute pain or a severe bout of acute depression, where I can reasonably expect that treating them or will reasonably make the patient desist from their demands, but there's nobody who just kills people who have acute pain that I'm aware of, usually it's chronic and refractory to treatment.

People make plenty of decisions that they might vacillate on before death, the act of dying isn't special in that regard even if I agree it's rather terminal. They might want to adjust their will as they succumb to dementia and lose capacity to do so, they might want to feel the arms of a lover estranged for decades, it's the very lucky few who get to leave with no regrets at all.

Should their be due process and a period of waitful watching? I would certainly endorse that, but if someone over a span of weeks, months or even years keeps asking to die, I'm going to live and let die. That's how I address:

Do we really want to kill people who are edge cases and who may just be going through a bad period?

As for-

Excessive worrying might be improved through mental health care or altering people's news diet.

I can only chuckle ruefully at the idea that the majority of people who opt for euthanasia haven't had "mental health care" and oodles of it. They're usually refractory to treatment in the form of drugs, therapy and even physical interventions like ECT. They've failed to work.

I doubt the average neurotic woman with Trump Derangement Syndrome or even those who become anti-natalists or anti-humanists are lining up to kill themselves.

Shouldn't we try to fix society instead of killing the people who are unhappy because of societal pathologies?

That's a false dichotomy in my eyes. We can do both, and should do both.

That the group with a desire to die is disproportionally poor, urban and single, suggests a strong societal component is at play.

All associated with severe unhappiness and poor life outcomes and for good reason. Being poor, "urban" and single against your wishes sucks.

If you have a means of turning such people into rich, rural and married individuals, then I'm willing to hear it, but I doubt anyone does short of waiting for the world to get much wealthier.

I'm a 4th generation doctor, and certainly the kids of doctors are over represented in med school, not that I have firm numbers at hand, let alone for the US.

Saudi Arabia laughs at you in fuck-you money. Most of the Gulf States rely on second class citizens/migrant workers while their primary citizens lounge about on welfare if they wish to.

I'm pretty sure myself that a civilizational war of such proportions would see the US military mobilized, and the majority of its standing forces assigned.

I'm not sure how I can convince you of that, concrete evidence is obviously lacking, but I'm confident of that fact in the same manner I strongly believe that the discovery that the sun was going to blow up in 20 years would motivate NASA to accelerate manned space flight programs. While it's not quite as unlikely, it's in the same <1% zone.

Too dumb for crime, at the very least.

As someone who has mild ADHD himself, I can understand why you don't want them on the battlefield.

War is long periods of boredom interspersed by short periods of terror, and if it wasn't obvious, boredom or focusing on incredibly boring tasks like guard duty or keeping watch would be an issue for someone with ADHD.

Of course, that doesn't particularly matter since we have drugs for the problem, drugs that work pretty goddamn well, are quite cheap, and would be kept in stock anyway if only for high value people like fighter pilots who can't afford to be tired and jet-lagged. A hundred dollars or less than a kilo of Adderall added to the logistics burden, and your ADHD trooper is ready to go, and he might even sneak a few to his buddies, regardless of regulations, and likely improve their overall performance in the process. I don't think the US of all nations is in a position where that's an onerous requirement, not when during WW2 they had ships dedicated to refrigerating ice-cream.

I play a lot of milsim video games, which while certainly not a proper substitute for war, are slower paced and more methodical than most games. I can certainly tell the Ritalin makes me a better virtual soldier, and even for those with significantly worse ADHD, they're likely to perform to par if you dose them up enough.

It's certainly not a burden so terrible that you should be turning them away during a recruiting crisis!

Then reframe it to be "the section of the West that is willing to take up arms against a hostile Islamist takeover", and I, and probably @ImmanuelCanNot, would still agree that that's true. Not that I think such an outcome is particularly likely.

A "Those who Walk Away from Omeals" society in which one person is sacrificed for the salvation of the remainder, is disfavoured to a "Harrison Bergson" society or our current one on either egalitarian grounds, or deontological ones.

I strongly disagree, and would go so far as to say that the only way this can be held true for our modern society is through willful delusion.

It requires that everyone suffer to some degree, and many significantly, to produce our material comforts. How many minimum wage workers in the West are particularly enthusiastic about their jobs? How many people do exactly the same things they would if they had infinite wealth and no need to labor for a living? Vanishingly few, none if you consider where said wealth came from.

I posit that almost anyone who had a tangible option of introducing Utopia at the cost of one suffering child would pick that option, either in a heartbeat like myself, or after much groaning and wringing of hands. It's only because it's a work of fiction that people can convince themselves that they'd do otherwise.

Accursed Americans, even your metaphors don't work in metric!

I was mildly tempted to respond with "donate to the IDF" myself, but for better or worse I restrained myself since I could clearly see that that wasn't in the spirit of what you sought, even if I think it's true.

I suppose it depends on how much risk you're willing to take that supplies bought with your money will be misused, barring something particularly specific like a charity that hands out tampons, I suspect that it's going to get yoinked, and in that specific example, intentionally. (Russian conscripts were given tampons and pads by their families when bandages were in short supply, but sadly a material made for soaking up blood isn't very good at staunching a bleed)

Keep in mind that even benign items can be seized and sold on the market for money, and I doubt Hamas has many qualms in that regard. Besides, the IDF isn't particularly funding constrained, at least within the range of any potential donations you might make, unless you're a billionaire I suppose.

This only makes sense if you are assigning respect entirely based on honesty/loyalty/commitment, and not at all on things like caring about the welfare of other people.

I disagree with this framework, or at least find it overly broad. I weight sincerity in ideals strongly, not exclusively when it comes to assigning respect.

Consider it akin to the perspective of the relationship between Patton and Rommel. From what I've heard, both respected each other a great deal, perhaps more than they did the average general on their side. This respect did not stop them from ordering their forces to shoot at each other in the field, or make them betray their own side.

While I'm lucky enough not to find myself holding a gun and facing off against a Jihadist, I would have no qualms in killing them if it came to that, whereas I have little desire to enter a war with the average Muslim unless they raise arms against me and my ideals by force.

You can respect an ideological opponent and still hate their guts till death resolves the issue once and for all.

The fact that taboos can and do die is proof enough that this objection is insufficient, since someone/some people had to convince a society to stop holding it.

If you see a clearly maladaptive trait or behavior in the wild, your priors are not particularly swayed by such considerations.

I acknowledge that Chesterton had a point about his Fence, my issue is with people who turn them into castle walls with spikes.

I don't think Singer was lazy in the least, and he has a sufficient body of literature out there for anyone who wishes to find proof of effort outside of a tweet. I guess that's one of the perks of being a renowned philosopher/ethicist, not having to repeat yourself that is.

He'd certainly recoil with horror given my interpretation of the fact that for most moralities, it's inconsistent to decry bestiality but endorse meat eating, but we both agree it's an inconsistency worth resolving, even if in polar opposite ways.

He's got to at least make a cursory comment about zoonotic disease risks to be taken seriously.

Really? You think that would appease everyone?

Very well, let's pretend he suggested that people fucking animals wear a condom. Problem solved, or at least solved to the same extent as things like animal husbandry or keeping pets still contribute to zoonotic disease, and vanishingly few condemn them on those grounds.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I sincerely doubt that if Singer had amended his statement to endorse only bestiality where prophylaxis was used, you'd be swayed one jot more than you were..

Singer's point hinges on the assumption that we, as a society, share an utilitarian ethic, which we don't, really, even if we often use utilitarian argument to try to justify moral points that are really based on other moral criteria.

I disagree that this is necessarily a consequence of utilitarianism, be it in the original Benthamite sense or the offshoots endorsed by Effective Altruists who extend utility to animals.

For one, I'm very much not a utilitarian, merely a consequentalist, which is a much broader category (I'd go so far as to say most Deontologists are just the same in denial). Of course, I draw the opposite conclusion he does, namely that it's okay to both eat and have sex with non-human animals, even if I don't claim either are morally laudable, merely neutral.

Now this is perfectly true in the case of Singer himself, but I consider a world where prawns and pigeons are given significant moral weight to be abhorrent in themselves, especially when you multiply by total population.

In the end, the societal function of the prohibition against having sex with animals, like the prohibition against personally causing animals unnecessary pain, is a sort of a sieve meant to bring out and weed out insane persons before they cause harm to people. It's very obvious when we're talking about torturing animals - how often is stereotype of serial killers torturing small animals as kids before graduating to people as adults referred to in the media, how example? - and having sex with animals, in addition to arousing a strong disgust reaction, is also something that's considered the providence of insane people of the sort that no longer understand or care about the correct delineation of people from animals.

I strongly believe that you're confusing the goal with the outcome in a very important sense.

For the overwhelming majority of human history, and in many parts of the globe, cruelty to animals was believed to be no big deal at all. The average person happily threw stones at cats or watched dog fights, and if you used enjoyment of the same as a heuristic to root out psychopathy, you'd find it to be incredibly useless.

However, when a society has moved in the direction of considering such acts morally reprehensible and simply Not Done by good upstanding folk, is it any surprise that those who still do it aren't "good upstanding folk"? They're clearly abnormal in some regard, since they are either too impulsive or too dumb to consider the consequences of their action, and both strongly correlate with other things we consider bad like cruelty towards humans.

If you declare shaving your head to be a clear sign of Nazism and demand all desist, then many people who would otherwise have shaved theirs don't any more, and voila, finding a skinhead is close to proof of NatSoc sympathies.

The majority of humans start out inclined to be at least a little cruel towards animals, and in most places, they're socialized out of it, and those who persist have something wrong with them. That does not necessarily mean that it's the cruelty to animals that causes psychopathy or sociopathy, for much the same reason that, protestations of ardent vegans aside, the typical meat eater isn't particularly more likely to be a sadistic serial killer.

On a more personal note, I love dogs and find cruelty towards them abhorrent, but I wouldn't go so far as to say it should be banned. I get no pleasure out of tormenting most creatures, and the closest I ever get is when, after concussing but not outright killing a mosquito, I've occasionally in the past torn off its wings and watched it suffer with mild smugness. Or perhaps when I make sure the tics I occasionally pick off my dog die just a little more painfully (do they even feel pain? Doesn't particularly matter) than they could have.

I invite anyone and everyone to demonstrate how I've been less than upstanding in my interpersonal relations or as a citizen, regardless of whatever heterodox views I hold.

But atheists are eager to attribute this kind of proclivity towards sadism and murder as a reflection of terrible conditions that they must be living under.

As an atheist myself, I certainly don't succumb to this failing. If one sincerely believes in that their holy book is the Word of God and doesn't contort themselves into knots when the literal interpretation is inconvenient, then yes, performing jihad or other activities offensive to modern western sensibilities is the right thing to do.

I agree with Yudkowsky that the men who flew the planes into the WTC were many things, but not cowards.

Since I aim to be sincere in my beliefs with minimal delusions of convenience, I respect such adherents more than insincere mealy-mouthed Cultural Catholics or the "moderate" Muslims who eat pork, smoke and drink while nominally calling themselves Muslim. Do I get along better with such people than a Hamas operative? Of course, doesn't mean I don't respect them less.

As has been discussed before, religion both shapes and is shaped by the human carriers of its memeplex. Beliefs and traditions that are grossly bad for flourishing (in the sense that the humans who believe them tend to die early without reproducing), tend to be marginalized or explained away. Despite believing that Life is Dukkha, the average Buddhist doesn't have the stomach to starve themselves to death. Things like excessive fasting, self-flagellation and the like usually die out, but as always, there's plenty of ruin in a civilization, and plenty of bad things persist or arise de novo.

Think of it as exactly analogous to the competing drives of a virus seeking to infect humans. On one hand, they want to maximize the number of copies of themselves, on the other hand, they wish to persist (in a metaphorical sense, virii don't actually want anything at all).

If a virus disregards the health of the host and maximizes reproduction, then it usually causes debilitating illness or even death, and in most cases, prevents further spread of the virus.

Hence, in combination with host-immunity, viruses tend towards becoming as benign as possible. This is not out of any charitable inclination, since they're strictly agnostic to the host's wellbeing, it just happens to be robust way of ensuring its own goals are met.

The typical mainstream religion today is cowpox to the smallpox of a brand new cult, it has adapted to not get too much in the way of human desires and affairs, or provoke frenzied behavior that leads to itself dying out or being stamped out.

On the other hand, for a new virus/cult, it might make sense to maximize infectiousness or zeal in the early stages when it has to overcome other competitors, and then let itself mellow out when it's dominant.

I personally know plenty of moderate Muslims, both at home and abroad, and they don't strike me as particularly evil people, the majority have, with various degrees of self-doubt and internal conflict, adopted the tenets of their religion that aren't too much of a hindrance for normal life while avoiding the drive to murder and kill in the name of the Prophet. They might be more zealous than average, or at least the average Muslim is compared to the average Hindu/Jew/Christian/Buddhist, but Islam is a religion that was designed to minimize value drift, as the Prophet declared all prophets after him as false, and their culture strongly endorses a literal interpretation of the Koran and Hadith, not that that removes all room for sectarian splits. There's also the strong stigma against apostasy, making the average lukewarm Muslim keep the branding from convenience if nothing else.

Even then, that can't last forever under the cold imperatives of incentive, and I don't think Islam is worth losing too much sleep over, certainly not to the extent the majority of its adherents deserve to die, even though I don't disagree that they're not the most desirable immigrants to the West, not if you want to keep liberal culture intact.

Disgust isn't the reason, disgust is part of the heuristic.

You can substitute the "only reason" or the "main reason" in my argument, that was my intent at any rate.

Disgust isn't a particularly good heuristic by itself, and while optic nerve signals are usually thanklessly at work doing useful things, if you start seeing the walls move or figures appear, such conflict with your normal priors and common sense should suggest it's more likely you're going crazy or being tricked than otherwise, the same when disgust isn't backed up by proper empirical considerations.

They probably got there by engaging in bestiality, meaning the law prevents some such people from existing in the first place.

I think the overwhelming majority of people are unlikely to even want to engage in bestiality in the first place, and by my lights, the practise itself does little harm to anyone or anything I care about.

If I was put in a position where everyone else around me was fucking pigs, I'm not joining in, and if I'm Isekai'd into the body of a young Boris Johnson, I doubt I can even get it up.

Thus I don't particularly care about the creation of new people who engage in bestiality, since I deem anyone almost anyone who does finds it attractive abnormal in the first place!

This is the classic "If you ban it people will still do it, but more dangerously" argument. Sure, some will, but trivial inconveniences matter a lot. The numbers would decrease. The whole point is to decrease the number of people doing it.

I'm not one of those people who naively (or maliciously) claim that abolition or prohibition doesn't/can't work. The existence of Bukele's regime is certainly an example when it comes to drug related crime.

The issue is whether the costs associated with enforcement are worth it, and in this regard, I say that's not so. You can get fentanyl off the streets by shooting all the dealers and their customers or subjecting everyone to random stops and searches regularly after removing due process, but such a measure is most likely a pretty bad idea.

Further, the issue here is that bestiality is easy to conceal. It's not like building a personal nuclear reactor or even building an indoor weed farm, barnyard animals or pets are everywhere, and the kind of surveillance necessary to eliminate all potential bestiality is perfect panopticon in nature.

And often, unless caught in the act, there is little to no concrete evidence of the "crime", especially in animals bigger than a dog.

It isn't particularly possible to eliminate and (in my opinion) not desirable to eliminate, hence my claim that it should be de-criminalized. I'm not demanding wider society accept it or endorse it. Plenty of things are legal yet frowned upon, and I have no stake in the matter that makes me want more.

The example that keeps coming to mind for me in this discussion is polyamory.

The majority of Rationalists aren't polyamorous, even if polys are over represented therein.

To me, the overall Western attitude towards polyamory is perfectly acceptable, modest to strong societal disapproval yet no meaningful legal consequences when it's not outright non-consensual cheating in a marriage.

In other words, I'm not asking people who disapprove of bestiality to like or endorse it, merely to tolerate it without judicial punishment.

I find it mildly confusing* and don't particularly see the appeal, but once again, to each their own.

*In a colloquial sense, I understand the potential evo-psych arguments for why men prefer to be dominant and women submissive in such regards, and the reverse is likely a benign misfiring.

I'm not inclined to punish them, and besides, what's the point? They might enjoy it if you spank them ;)

It drives me nuts that tabletop gaming has largely become the refuge of soyfacing idiots who demand everything be sanitized and cleaned for them.

There's not much of a TTRPG scene in India, but if I have the misfortune to run into the types who demand the kind of accomodations you've linked to, I'm either kicking them out or leaving the session.

Bloody hell, one of the documents in the tools and resources folders suggests that horror have a specific content warning.

This is a combination of Eternal September reducing the IQ of the average internet user from the potential >130 peak in the earliest days to being barely above average today, as well as the evolution of linguistic norms as well as a general acceptance of more casual conversational styles.

I'm a stickler for correct grammar myself, and it causes me psychic damage when other Indians butcher the language, even if I acknowledge there is no "objective" correctness in language, beyond being able to accurately convey meaning. English is a fucked up language, where words often don't sound like they're written, so I can hardly hold it against those who fuck it right back haha.

It drives me berserk when my smartphone's autocorrect fucks up a perfectly grammatical sentence, but then again it's how I wrote 200k words of my novel and most of my Motte posts, so I guess it's a net positive..

It's poor form, and worthy of mod action for me to make such claims about you, but I'm a fan of self-identification in most things, and I'm not going to protest particularly hard about well the shoe kid leather gloves fit.

What I do resent is the implication that just because I don't condemn bestiality out of hand, that makes me a goat fucker.

It anyone thinks, by insinuation or association, that I advocate for fucking the other kind of kid, let it be clear that the argument was once again in the context of the merits of decoupling, and why a knee-jerk reaction to the idea of a "6 year old having sex" might be dumb if, after cognitive/physical enhancement, said six year old was smarter than Von Neumann and had the physical body the average 25 yo would kill for. Notice the notable absence of any implications for what sex with the current average 6 year old child would entail, and the only reason I bring up that hypothetical is because I think cognitive enhancement is both a very much doable technology today, and one that will be increasingly robust in mere decades. Or you might just imagine a child born, if not on Mars, then in the orbit of Jupiter, where "6 years" means something very different to what it does today. Does a change in fact change the implication? If so, congratulations and welcome to decoupling.

This simple inability to entertain hypotheticals or consider where heuristics fail makes me more disgusted by low decouplers of any ideology than I am of someone who decides to shag their sheep. At least he's not really hurting my sanity in the process.

See, regardless of whether or not you wish to describe yourself as one, the fact that you make these arguments reveals you to be a high decoupler yourself! (This is a good thing)

It's not healthy to engage in a sexual relationship with an animal (citation needed), any more than it's healthy to engage in a sexual relationship with a pillow, a baby, a robot, a comatose person, or any other entity without the ability to reciprocate and give you the emotional connection which naturally accompanies such a relationship. Sex is one of the most intimate possible acts (along with motherhood) and humans are naturally wired to seek emotional connections to accompany the physical connection, and vice versa.

What about one's hand? That's common enough isn't it?

Masturbation/onanism was decried as a sin till within living memory, and still is by some, yet society didn't breakdown when people no longer felt shame about rubbing one out. If you think that doesn't count, look at vibrators or dildos (the former might cause desensitization if overused).

I do not think the average person is meaningfully harmed by sexual intercourse with something that doesn't reciprocate, not to an extent worth noting.

Further, I'm asking that people who already have urges to copulate with animals be allowed to do so without judicial punishment, if not social ones, and in societies, both historical and modern ones like Afghanistan where the practise is widespread, the people who have sex with animals are usually attempting to substitute for a lack of availability of real human women, at least for men, and have few qualms about sending their beloved to the abbatoir when they outlive their usefulness. The average haji goat fucker simply doesn't have access to women, which might explain why they're angry disaffected young men throwing their lives away.

If someone prefers animals over the opposite sex, they're too far gone for it to matter, and will likely just do it in secrecy.

For the overwhelming majority inclined to even try it, bestiality is a poor substitute for normal sex, but like a polyamorous relationship with Rosie Palm and her five sisters, they think it's better than nothing.

I think you are overconfident about your own ability to do so.

I mean, I'm certainly aware that there are likely plenty of deeply cherished beliefs I hold about the world that are likely false, for statistical reasons if nothing else. I think I do a decent enough job on updating as the evidence comes in, I demand an absence of intentional delusion in myself and bemoan those who practice it, how successful I am at that, who ever knows?

I personally think disgust is a terrible reason to prevent consenting humans (or a human, who presumably consents, and an animal, whose consent I don't care about) from doing as they please with each other. This might well be a moral anomaly, but it's an anomaly that allowed for the creation of modern civilization as the overwhelming trend has been for people to mind their own damn business, even if we're in an era of relative backsliding. I am close to a maximalist on the front of interpersonal liberty, even if I am more than willing to consider externalities.

It's striking how at least two people here have brought up the risk of zoonotic disease in the context of "objective" arguments against bestiality, and that strikes me as clear rationalization of a disgust response, did they even bother thinking for one moment how that might be prevented, or have they even seen data suggesting the increase is significant? For the former, I brought up the solution of condoms, and there you go, the problem's largely solved, beyond the residual risk from simply having other species in close proximity, which is a sin of everything from pet ownership to animal husbandry.

If the average person is harmed by thinking too hard for themselves, that's awful, and I can grant that might well be true. I still demand that those who can do better be allowed to opt out in one way or another, and I think we're lucky enough to live in an age where humans will be raised above their current limitations in many regards.

As much as I often disagree with @BurdensomeCount, I am sympathetic to his argument that those who are capable of being free-thinkers not be held down by those who can't resist licking live electric wiring. I'm not particularly beholden to the classist aspect of it either, just general intelligence, or a willingness to accept that negative outcomes are of their own making if it backfires.

Such people must exist, they're the scientists and innovators who bear the rest of us bastards along with them. Technological progress relies on challenging accepted notions, and while not everyone can do the same on the moral front, for the same reason the average person isn't a good PhD candidate even after grade inflation, I demand a right to try, or leave be the people who do.