self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
DM me the day before you set out, I'll bother to make the account on Manifold so I can get some fake internet points.
If the misfortune of others makes you feel better, a decent apartment or house in one of the major Indian metropolises costs about as much one in SF or London. And we make a tenth the money!
Come to the US, we’ve got cost disease!
Praying I can make it as a doctor, and then contribute to the rising cost of medical care 🙏
I dabbled in learning programming for a few weeks, but a few Leetcode easies in, I realized that with current visa restrictions being what they are, there's no way I can get credentials or competency high enough that I can beat the millions of other Indian programmers fighting for the same deal.
It's entirely possible she has concrete reasons, but doesn't wish to tell you because it might hurt your feelings or she's afraid you'll rage over it.
There's no point pressing it, and there plenty more fish out there either way.
2/3 is a passing grade right?
To go off on a tangent, as much as I am a human-supremacist who goes fuck yeah everytime we get one over the aliens, photogenic or not (Avatar 2's opening sequence almost made up for the ham-fisted morality tale that followed), Quaritch is wrong.
Pandora, to put it bluntly, doesn't work as anything but an intentionally crafted artifact of an immensely superior technological civilization.
A Hive Mind of that scale simply doesn't evolve according to natural selection, and remind me what incentives prey animals have for letting predators plug in to their US ports? That is simply not something that happens in isolation. Leaving aside the fact that they have a form of immortality when they upload their minds to join their ancestors (!!!).
The Na'vi are also morphologically distinct from the overwhelming majority of Pandoran fauna, they're bipedal with 4 limbs, while the majority are hexapedal.
And why exactly are there room-temperature superconductors just hanging around everywhere and forming floating rocks? Apparently they're not found in the rest of the universe.
By far the most sensible answer is that the modern Na'vi are the Amish analogs of an advanced K2 or K3 civilization, that chose to consciously hew to a naturalistic aesthetic while keeping plenty of their creature comforts, all while designing the ecology and their AI to keep that status quo indefinitely.
Where did the rest of them go? Who knows, but the idea of the Na'vi being naturally evolved eco-hippies makes no goddamn sense. Glass the planet and take their resources, but you better go up the tech-tree fast if you have the sense to worry about a counter-attack from their distant kin.
While using civilians as human shields is certainly morally dubious, continuing to use them after your opponent calls your bluff and it makes no further difference is even worse.
So my sympathies for Hamas, negative as they were, can only go one way.
No I don't believe you, it's a type of dinosaur 😌
Yeah, Scott is talented in both prose and poetry to a level I struggle to see myself ever reaching, but that's alright, I'm content in being far above average myself.
I could be wrong, but I don't think there's ever been a Motte specific meet up.
Your best bet is to wait for a Lesswrong/ACX meet up, I'm 100% certain that happens in SF on an annual basis, and there's bound to be some overlap!
I've seen plenty of claims that Hanania is a troll, but I unironically espouse most of the controversial things he says that might be dubbed inflammatory.
Technology solves our problems faster than it creates new ones, and barring the threat from an unaligned AGI (a big one, even if my p(doom) is only around 30% these days), I look forward to us dragging ourselves up to the stars by our bootstraps.
Man, what's with you and like 3 others suddenly landing significantly better jobs? I'm getting envious myself haha.
As for art, I think barring a few pieces I've saved over the years, I'm going to have an AI make something bespoke for me, you could give that a try.
Even in a near ideal case, it depends on your definition of "human". I don't think baseline humans will be calling the shots for long either way.
Even a raw mind upload is unlikely to be competitive with dedicated AI, but at least they're cheap to run, and I personally intend to upgrade myself till the distinction between me and a SAGI is more of an academic distinction. But we're mostly powerless, so what can we do but enjoy the show? The next decade is going to be the epitome of "may you live in interesting times".
I did actually try using GPT-4 for the same purpose, with a bit of coaxing and pointing out BPE errors, it did produce what seemed like hexameter, but I couldn't get anything close in terms of quality. Eh, let's see how 5+ handle it.
My condolences, especially since most "Conservatives" would find plenty of your views not particularly likeable!
Indian physician @self_made_human and the American combat veteran @JTarrou whether this has been true for them. While I'll definitely contend that extended exposure to the hospital system as a healthcare provider or worker (rather than as a patient) isn't quite as bad as war, I will say that you see some shit and that it is difficult to describe in words.
My experience as a front-line doctor in a 3rd World Country, an essay initially posted on the Motte subreddit as I was delirious from an ortho rotation tied with gyne for the worst months of my life. I'm still proud that the original prompted Scott himself to show up in the sub to respond with positive encouragement! (In the unlikely event he's reading this, I'm doing much better, it's a wonder what working in a service with a budget more than lost change behind the couch can do haha).
Was it fucking awful? If you're someone who doesn't particularly like reading (what are you doing here again?), then yes, it was fucking awful, and I struggle to imagine an American/Western doc will see anything this bad unless they volunteer for a mission to Haiti or some other hell-hole. Still better than working in the ER during a war, but all the worse for being a represenation of the status-quo for a billion people who can't afford better.
I'm not a soft person, but my heart is thoroughly sclerosed after the whole ordeal, not that I suffer from anything like PTSD or the like. Humans can get used to almost anything, and fast.
As a guy with most of a medical degree
As one with one and change, I certainly agree. Humans are both surprisingly resilient and also extremely squishy, and you don't fuck with blunt-force trauma to the cranium if you can help it.
I count myself lucky that I'm a peaceful person who hasn't thrown a punch in anger since middle-school, if I'm risking my noggin it better be for more than a drunken brawl.
The SSC/ACX discord has a whole bunch of memes about our very own Skook, he's notorious for his ad-Hock insanity well before he showed up here.
Assuming this one is original (or not), it still made me chuckle!
This is a flaw of pretty much any poll or quiz, regardless of the nominal goal it seeks, the average person is an attention deficient idiot whose eyes glaze over the moment they spot a caveat in the wild, so everyone is forced to sacrifice clarity for the sake of just getting more responses.
I'm a Bayesian, and I implicitly consider what I think is the most likely/representative scenario. I think the odds of someone serving a shit-cake is far higher if they know they're in an environment where it's not going to make someone puke, and that informed my answer (a solid triple upvote because I'd be mildly tickled at the idea myself, combined with not considering it offensive or worthy of condemnation).
Similarly, I assume the woman euthanizing the puppies isn't being actively malicious, and if they ended up un-adopted in a shelter, most of them would be put down by other means. I imagine the researchers who made the poll were more curious about the visceral gut reaction to the idea of poor little puppies being stoned to death as opposed to trying to tease out more subtle moral considerations, and while I'm a fan of dogs in general, I don't think the scenario I envisioned is condemnable.
You think I'm aware of what Manifold is without getting that much? I'm simply too lazy to bother when it's something as profoundly stupid as the Hock!
And maybe the direction that society is going with its condemnation of male pride and (seeming) reduction of joie de vivre will prove to be disastrous in the future.
Even if I exist in severe epistemic uncertainty about the possible future of the globe, I can categorically exclude "business as usual" from the consideration.
We're well on course for a Singularity, and if it's stopped, it will be forcibly, we have AI that is on par (and better than the average human) at most cognitive tasks that don't require physical embodiment, and even for those that do, robotics is (not) falling over itself to catch up, especially by hooking LLMs into the motor function loop.
This implies either the biggest boom of all, or the population of humans of any description plummeting to nil in short order, my median timeline for grossly superhuman AGI is like 3 or 5 years at this point. It's no longer an AI/fusion is 20 years away for 50 years kinda deal, we've yet to even grapple with the long-term consequences of what we have today, if progress abruptly stops.
Either way, humans, at least for the purposes of the economy, will become entirely obsolete, and even duties like child rearing or childbirth will no longer require us, be it because AI nanny bots are filling the roles of disinterested daycare workers on the cheap, or because we have working artifical wombs or find a way to make child rearing so undemanding on parental lifestyle that the natural desire of women keeps them coming. After all, most women in the West who get polled say their ideal number of desired offspring is >2, even if they're not doing a good job of reaching it. Wealth has a bimodal association with fertility%2C%20the%20difference%20in%20the IR) , you have poor junkies churning them out, and billionaires who sire on a whim, it's the unlucky few~ many stuck in between who face painful tradeoffs in terms of QOL.
Given that automation will likely provide a QOL for those who can avail that is closer to the billionaire (or at least multi-millionaire) end of the spectrum..
As far as I'm concerned, the majority of the "disastrous consequences" you point to are the outcome of a lack of humans needed to fuel the fires of industry. Onerous burdens of maintaining the decrepit elderly, a lack of growth and innovation, these all cease to matter in the least when humans no longer contribute the bulk of cognitive labor, or even physical labor.
Further, I expect genuine extensions to lifespan with extended healthy lifespan boosted too, or even biological immortality, at which point the number of health, productive people will either stabilize or keep on increasing, and in my opinion, cause the population to skyrocket as people cease exiting the gene pool.
With timelines so short, we simply don't have the time to suffer, barring countries like Japan and potentially China that got on the gerontocrasy fast-train decades back. The median Westerner is unlikely to even notice a decline as it is smoothed out or even turned positive from increased productivity.
This has plenty of other implications, such as the current tendency to import large amounts of unskilled labor from the Global South only becoming a drain sooner rather than later (though it's likely we'll be wealthy enough it won't particularly matter), leaving aside that even skilled workers like myself are soon to be obsolete.
As I see it, religion is a viral memeplex that may have once served a beneficial purpose in history, but has long outlived its usefulness, in much the same manner as certain retroviral fragments help produce a placenta and keep the uterus congenial for pregnancy, but become potential proto-oncogenes when we're out of the cradle.
At the very least it's a deeply flawed worldview, for all that smart and thoughtful people I genuinely respect here succumb to it, and I think we're better off without it. If evolution has cursed the average human with a God-shaped Hole, then in the absence of said God (or at least one not of our making), I'm getting myself a secular excavator, while being thankful I don't suffer from the same design flaw.
Or we could all die, I guess, the Amish might disdain electricity, but it's not like a misaligned superintelligence cares. In the extremely unlikely event our naively project population trend lines persist decades into the future, I still think the proposed cure is worse than the disease, even if religiosity in the West has largely adapted in much the same way as cowpox to not be as pernicious to the host.
I'm certainly aiming for 3 kids, not that I think I'll have time to even raise one past toddlerhood, and since the future belongs to those who show up, I'm ensuring a front-row seat with the family even if it's crowded with Hasidic Jews and the like.
I do prefer the older ones myself, even if I'd class this as A tier content, those were S in my opinion.
I've had no real issues 99.9% of the times I've used them in the ear canal, barring this particular incident with the leftover alcohol, and one time my mom cheaped out and bought the cheapest Chinese variant on Amazon.
The latter dislodged in my ear, and after I didn't pay too much attention, developed into a bad case of otitis media that had the ENT doctor who examined me suspect it was a fungal infection until the syringing brought out a moldy lump of cotton that had been festering in there for 6 months. So do check if all of it came back out with the wax!
There are 8 billion people out there, so even discounting Lizardman's constant, there are probably a handful about. I don't think they have any meaningful influence for the most part (I dimly recall one of them being involved in an AI company of note, but I don't remember who or which)
"While on a live on-air tv show, a man kills a baby rabbit with a knife."
It doesn't specify whether this was done for shock value, not that you can rule that out. I don't see it making a difference myself, I value the life of a rabbit at roughly nil either way.

What's money good for if you can't spend it?
Then again, I count myself lucky that I'm not particularly consumerist, and barring buying a nicer house or car, my most expensive hobby, video games, has little to offer beyond splurging maybe 10 grand total on a top of the line PC, a ridiculous monitor and so on.
At least that's the case unless my income increases by an OOM or two, I'm sure I can find more hobbies to splurge or then, or donate some of it for political causes I care about.*
Fine liquors, ridiculously expensive clothing, fancy vacations, none particularly appeal to me, not that I'd complain if I got them.
*And invest heavily into index funds and tech companies but I intend to do that even with my minimal money, when I have more of it.
More options
Context Copy link