@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

I find this argument poor in everything except rhetoric.

Plenty of human behaviors, such as urbanization, farming livestock or just plain old existing, even just using antibiotics to treat illness, all serve as incubators for disease and potential for future pandemics.

I reserve that argument for actual bioweapon labs, or "legitimate" labs that engage in gain-of-function research.

Besides, I'm aiming to be a shrink, and while I can't deny I'll get customers because of people grappling with non-standard sexualities, I'd likely get more of them if it was cracked down upon and their desires repressed.

If I see a guy using !!! in any context, I'm going to rip off his pants to see if he has any balls underneath them.

As for the handwriting, it looks pretty gender neutral to me, but I am a doctor, so maybe I have brain damage from reading notes left by consultants who should have retired after their cerebral palsy got this bad..

On a side note, I occasionally visit /r/GoodNotes, a sub for discussion regarding said note taking software which I rely on heavily myself, even if I'm using the obsolete 5 after the 6th version moved to an abominable subscription service. It's 80% women shilling Etsy sticker packs of ridiculous ornamentation and others posting "aesthetic" notes showing off their handwriting or typography. I am forced to retreat in confusion, given that my use case is purely agglomeration and annotating the terabytes of medical notes I need for yet more exams.

I'm well aware of that (it would exceptionally awkward professionally if I wasn't).

The reason we are so cautious these days is because of the epidemic of bloodborne disease that lax monitoring of donations or other sources of contamination engendered.

I suspect that blood contamination was the most likely way for a non-gay person to get AIDS at the time, but I haven't looked at the actual data, it's more of a historical curiosity now.

What do you mean by "sodomy"? Homosexual sex? I don't find that offputting, and I find it quite telling that any criticism of gay culture is routinely conflated with criticism of homosexuality.

Sure, I retract the insinuation that your opposition to homosexuality was based off a disgust response to their sexual activities, even if that's common enough in practise.

I find it extremely hard to believe you can get these sort of numbers only through stigma, and unwillingness to get checked.

I make no such claim, after all I pointed out that disbarring gay men from blood donation might be a sensible decision, at least after a proper cost benefit analysis.

I'm happy to provide compassion for people who got infected or died, but if you're asking me for compassion, you have no right to throw the "why should I give a fuck" argument at me.

I'm not asking for compassion, merely tolerance or live and let live. While compassion can be helpful for that purpose, it's not strictly necessary.

but I think it's important to point out you not caring in not a valid argument for others to not care.

My argument is that when people do things you consider viscerally disgusting yet do little to no tangible harm to you, you shouldn't complain, or feel free to complain, but don't legislate against it.

Now, there are plenty of arguments about the secondary effects from the disintegration of the social fabric, changes in the dating scene and politics and so on, but once again, that's not something suitable for legislative solutions.

I prefer people who vehemently disagree with me yet agree to live and let die, versus those who concur with me so far yet are utterly inflexible in that regard, if they're not a literal mental clone of me, we're going to part ways sooner or later, and possible even if that's the case.

In turn, you or anyone else finding sodomy offputting isn't a particularly valid argument for me caring (to the extent that any argument can be called valid)

The other issue is that I don't know how sustainable "live and let live" even is. No one talks about the AIDS epidemic as "haha, who cares, they've made their choices!" the very people that demand I live and let live because it doesn't affect me personally, also demand that I see AIDS response as a giant moral failing of society.

I wasn't around at the height of the AIDS epidemic, or at least I was only a toddler. So I can only speak for myself. As far as I'm aware the (potentially justified) stigma against AIDS caused a lot of unnecessary human suffering and even death, especially since it made people unwilling to get checked.

These days, HIV infections are manageable, more of a nuisance rather than the life sentence they once were, and on medication you can live an entirely normal life. We're likely on track for a complete cure soon enough, and there have been sporadic success stories.

I'm not against measures like barring MSMs from blood donation and the like if they're at an excessive risk of spreading the disease, but that falls under an imminent threat to public health, not a minor inconvenience. As for anyone who catches it these days by fucking without a condom, my sympathy, while not non-existent, is slim nonetheless.

The spirit of ‘16 knows that the vast majority of homosexuals, male and female, were sexually abused as children, because homosexuals are vampires who “reproduce” through sexual molestation. This is only the tip of the iceberg, (or the icestein, or the icenthal, if you prefer.)

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0145213415003828

Proportionally few boys were the subject of official notifications for sexual abuse (14.8% of maltreated boys, and 1.4% of the birth population); proportionally very few of these sexually abused boys (3%) went on to become sexual offenders; and, contrary to findings typically reported in retrospective clinical studies, proportionally few sexual offenders (4%) had a confirmed history of sexual abuse. Poly-victimization (exposure to multiple types of maltreatment) was significantly associated with sexual offending, violent offending, and general (nonsexual, nonviolent) offending. We found no specific association between sexual abuse and sexual offending, and nor did we find any association between sexual abuse and sexual offending specifically within the poly-victimized group. The total number of sexual abuse notifications did make a small unique contribution to the variance in sexual offending compared to other offending. Implications concerning maltreated boys and male sexual offenders are discussed.

Indian Administrative Service officers, a brutally meritocratic branch of the government existing as a leftover from colonial days, have a reputation for being highly competent, and if not incorruptible, markedly less so than the norm.

When one of them offends a politician, for whatever reason, be it political or just being a PITA when it comes to corruption and associated bribery, the preferred method of dealing with them is shunting them off to oversee a backwater since they're almost impossible to fire. Some poor bastards have been kicked about all over the country on a nigh monthly basis.

Pretty far from it, I might agree with the descriptions of certain facts, but I'm a billion lightyears away on the implications of said facts or my reaction to them. I mostly follow him because he writes interesting fiction and political commentary, which is fun to read if nothing else, even if it can be bitingly insightful.

While I might agree with things like HBD, I'm still a classical liberal with libertarian sympathies, not a reactionary, even if returning politics to what I consider ideal would be a "reaction" in some aspects.

The spirit of ‘16 is the realization that feminism, colorblind anti-racism, and the entire LGBTQ bbq are all one thing, they’re a package deal, and the moment you judge people “not by the color of their skin,” that’s the same moment that a woman starts to need a man like a fish needs a bicycle, and that’s the same moment that love is love, even when that purported love is constituted by piss orgies, anal prolapses, and deliberate self-infection with HIV.

While in our modern cultural milieu, all of the above are almost universally interlinked, my bugbear with any of them is that they're taken too far, rather than me denying women equal rights or considering alternate sexualities sinful. I'm certainly not colorblind anymore.

As for whether gay men having piss orgies or fucking till their assholes big enough to drive through, why should I give a fuck? If they're not raping me, I have no reason to care.

I respect the right of anyone to self-infect with anything, as long as it's not contagious by normal means, and in the case of HIV, as long as they disclose to potential partners or refrain from donating blood and the like. Is it deeply stupid? Of course. I don't think that's grounds for it to be illegal by itself, until it infringes on my safety or freedom. Since the piss orgy relates to the nothing-burger of monkeypox, which didn't spread significantly outside the gay community, it doesn't reach that level of concern.

The spirit of ‘16 knows that the vast majority of homosexuals, male and female, were sexually abused as children, because homosexuals are vampires who “reproduce” through sexual molestation. This is only the tip of the iceberg, (or the icestein, or the icenthal, if you prefer.)

I am strongly sceptical of this claim, and even before I read it, I ran into a research paper on Twitter that claims otherwise.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0145213415003828

Proportionally few boys were the subject of official notifications for sexual abuse (14.8% of maltreated boys, and 1.4% of the birth population); proportionally very few of these sexually abused boys (3%) went on to become sexual offenders; and, contrary to findings typically reported in retrospective clinical studies, proportionally few sexual offenders (4%) had a confirmed history of sexual abuse. Poly-victimization (exposure to multiple types of maltreatment) was significantly associated with sexual offending, violent offending, and general (nonsexual, nonviolent) offending. We found no specific association between sexual abuse and sexual offending, and nor did we find any association between sexual abuse and sexual offending specifically within the poly-victimized group. The total number of sexual abuse notifications did make a small unique contribution to the variance in sexual offending compared to other offending. Implications concerning maltreated boys and male sexual offenders are discussed.

I'm going to do the opposite and argue against the SWH, since I consider it to be false in terms of sweeping conclusions, and at most true in largely inconsequential ways.

Why? Well, for starters, I speak two very different languages fluently and am conversational in a third, I'd hope that engenders some insight, even if I'm not a linguist.

My English vocabulary probably outweighs my Bengali one by at least one OOM, so occasionally I find myself trying to translate from one to the other, and till date, I haven't found a single word that is utterly untranslatable, in the sense that even if there's no single word for it, you can't get the meaning across through analogy or chaining concepts together.

For example, neither Bengali nor Hindi (and many other related languages) has a (common) word for yesterday or tomorrow like English does. There might be one, I'm no linguist, but at least it doesn't come up in normal speech. Instead we use the same word "kal" for it, and grasp from context whether it's upcoming or referring to yesterday. Does this mean Indians as a whole are broadly incapable of understanding the distinction between yesterday and tomorrow? Of course not, it's contextual as I just said.

I expect that for any language with major adoption, it's almost always possible to translate between them and there are almost no thoughts or concepts that a speaker of one can hold that the other can't.*

*Here come caveats. Notice I said major, and not some dying tongue spoken by some 95 yo last of the Mohicans ass mf or an uncontacted Amazonian tribe. Speakers of such a tongue might suffer from outright paucity or poverty of concepts, to the extent that for an adult speaker, it might be exceedingly difficult, if not impossible, to translate from a more full-featured language. Or perhaps you want to consider someone who is non-lingual or wasn't successfully socialized at all like a feral child. But my argument is that for most languages and for almost all purposes, you can build up a common framework and use it.

I recall one example of the SWH being some flavor of Australian aborigine that didn't use left or right, instead always orienting themselves according to the cardinal directions of the compass, including a very accurate ability to keep track of that while indoors or otherwise unable to just track the sun or stars in the sky. Big deal, that isn't so much as an utter inability on the part of the rest of us as much as a skill we hardly have reason to develop, even if it comes more naturally to some. Imagine taking a tribe of the former, blindfolding and spinning them around in circles till they're utterly disoriented, and then letting them loose in an enclosed structure. I expect that they'd end up arbitrarily choosing a direction as "north" and orienting around that, and make the environment rapidly update fast enough, and they'd likely develop self-referential notions of left and right.

Overall, I don't think the hypothesis is particularly impactful, especially when people use it to explain sweeping cultural claims. At most, the weak form of the SWH is true, and that only says that cognition can be guided by language, not necessarily limited or restricted by it.

Hence half jokingly! It might even be the best decision at the time, but it's hard to be sure until I'm a wage slave in the NHS. Childcare costs are exorbitant, until it's factored in from schooling.

While my parents currently declare (performatively) that I and my brother were enough to handle and they won't be saddled with more, well, evolution will have the last word when they're cooing and cawing over the grandkids haha. I just hope they're healthy enough that they can feasibly take that on.

I was initially as perplexed as you were, but it seems the crux is present value, which in this case is precisely the amount handed to you today.

I strongly suspect they're going to be far more tame, at least in areas relevant to the current Culture War. Towards the middle of V's life cycle, they removed dialogue because of excessive use of people calling others niggers, even if the users were black. I don't think this was in response to any actual backlash, they just felt like getting with the times.

I'm grateful that India has largely avoided the dissolution of the extended family and the associated problems that Westerners have been grappling with for the past, let's say 70 years or so.

It's not that it isn't happening, far from it, but most parents and grandparents can trust that they'll likely have a home with their children when they're too old to take care of themselves. In turn, obnoxious practises like kicking your kid out of the house when they turn 18 to fend for themselves would be considered scandalous here, you're expected to support your children till they have completed the lengthy period of schooling and higher education required for them to maximize their potential productivity (not that I don't think parents shouldn't have the right to do so, I simply think that's a terrible idea that should deserve scorn).

Of course, every week I encounter an elderly person wasting away, their children having abandoned the nest and flown off to fairer shores, worst case leaving this benighted land for the West. It's still not the expected outcome by an means. Even then, at least low skilled labor is cheap enough that most of them can afford attendants or caretakers.

Personally, while I come across as unabashedly pro-West in most regards, I find myself bound to criticize the most pernicious practises. Living with a large family can be stifling, but it has great benefit in terms of pure peace of mind. If you need to leave your kids at home, they usually have an uncle or aunt to keep an eye on them, often a grandparent or two, and cousins their own age to keep them company. If you fall sick, or lose your job, you know your kin will bat for you. Then you save money on buying a house, since a sufficiently large one can have room for an extended family to shack up together, though that's getting rarer as home ownership is increasingly a sign of personal status. (Once again, I'm not claiming any of this is utterly foreign in the West).

My grandpa, as healthy as can be possible at the ripe young age of 95, has been immensely lucky to have his kids and grandkids living with him for most of his life, despite the usual expectation that both of his daughters would eventually marry and move out to live independently if not with their husbands. I can't imagine he'd have lived this long if that wasn't the case, little can be more corrosive than loneliness. This is still unusual, it required son-in-laws who are uncommonly accepting of living somewhere where they're not the nominal head of household, even if nobody has ever brought that up as a negative where I've heard it. Maybe it was more uncommon a decade or two back.

Even as I prepare to leave myself, it eases my pain to know that my parents, while not as healthy as can be desired (mom's liver is on the way out, and I pray the sheer horror that is a liver transplant doesn't make me shy away if I'm the one who needs to donate)*, they're well educated doctors who can look after themselves for the next decade or two without me needing to lose sleep over them.

On the other hand, rearing kids as two working professionals in the UK fills me with a different kind of dread, and I have jokingly suggest that I drop them off shortly after birth with my Indian family until they're semi-autonomous. How the fuck do people manage that? I'm willing to take the blow in terms of lifestyle and free time that having kids requires, even two or three of them, but it's still daunting to the max. Oh well, at least I know I don't need to save for their college fund..

At any rate, this is all temporary. Our medicine is at an awkward stage where we can treat or mitigate many individual illnesses that would once have shuffled the elderly off this mortal coil, without being able to fix the underlying problem of aging. This has always been a doomed endeavor, akin to never doing preventive maintenance on an old beater and then replacing parts as they fail. Eventually it all catches up and the whole thing falls apart no matter how many times you change out the oil and put on a coat of paint.

I doubt we're solving aging in the remaining time till superhuman AGI, which ought to solve that problem shortly, even if only by killing everyone so there's no one around to grow old and decrepit, but steady advances in consumer robotics suggests that in a counterfactual world where we don't have a full blown Singularity in a decade or two, we're likely still not going to have the shortfall of people willing to accept shit wages for a shit job. Maybe we'll find other ways of improving the QOL of the elderly short of reversing their age, but I'm confident this state of affairs won't last, even if it's only going to get worse over the next few years.

*Scott's donation of a kidney appears trivial next to that, the odds of death are uncomfortably high, as are the sequelae, despite the liver being the only major organ that regenerate

Israeli tanks have APS like Trophy that in theory mitigates a lot of the risk from RPGs.

Their vehicles are also designed to ensure crew safety above all else, even after a disabling hit.

Combining this with their low appetite for loss of human life, it might make sense to minimize the inevitable infantry casualties from dismounts accompanying vehicles by sending them in solo. Might, I have no specific insight into the outcomes of their doctrine, but for all the footage Hamas releases of close quarters RPG hits on such vehicles, footage of the burning wreckage in the aftermath seems lacking.

At the end of the day, there's no good way of clearing an urban hellhole, short of nuking it.

This is almost certainly true, especially in prison, where murderers and violent drug offenders luxuriate in having someone below them on the totem pole to bully.

Let's say Jeffrey Epstein wants to have sex with your wife, and will pay both of you $2m. She says she'll do it if you agree. Do you?

He can fuck me in the ass afterwards for free if the price is $2m. I can only quietly give a thumbs up to any person here for whom that isn't life changing money, I'm in no position to say no.

At any rate, my attitude to a family member, even a daughter, doing sex work is pretty much the same as one of them working as a janitor. I don't think it's intrinsically bad, but I'd rather they didn't do it, unless they were paid a sum that outweighs the negative consequences in terms of lower respect from society and everything else. In principle I see nothing wrong with it.

Have you ever considered getting an ADHD diagnosis?

Why yes I have, if only because I actually have ADHD. If I didn't, I'd probably still find a way to get some, and it's frankly astonishing to me that despite how much academic pressure and intense competition there is in India, more students aren't on them. ADHD is practically unknown to the average person.

I think I might actually have ADHD or some kind of disorder given how far above my baseline it got me.

Not much evidence of ADHD by itself, the drugs are powerful and work on both the neurotypical and ADHD alike, and I am lukewarm on claims that it makes a qualitative or quantitative difference for the latter. In my particular case, it takes me from someone who can't read a textbook unless their life depends on it (or I have an exam in a few days) to someone who can grudgingly study for anywhere from 2-6 hours a day, averaging maybe 2 hours of genuine maximal effort. I think it takes me from a literal 2%ile score to something around 50% on conscientiousness, which is a massive difference, outright life changing.

What's your overall opinion on the matter of taking drugs to be a better wage slave?

If it helps you get on the grind, fuck everything else and go for it. Be careful not to use excessive doses, moderate use in amount while spacing it out to delay tolerance.

Do you feel irrationally anxious about food waste? Even though individual food waste is probably a tiny fraction of all the waste that happens in a modern economy? The idea of food waste gives me the heeby jeeebies and this is most likely because I've been indoctrinated as much as a child. It just feels "wrong".

Yes, I always clean my plate where possible, even if I'm past comfortably full, but I try to pack it away or save it as leftovers if the remaining quantity warrants it.

I have literally never used a discrete alarm clock in my life.

Despite my better judgement, I am still willing to enter into the old atheism versus religion debate on occasion haha. To the credit of the religious on the Motte, most of them are far better informed on both the actual tenets of their religion, as well as the ideas behind modern science or information theory, such that the arguments encompass fields that you don't seen on any old debate on Reddit. I would much rather argue with a Steelman than a Strawman, even if I'd prefer neither exist.

Despite the fact that number of people whose minds I have changed is ~0 (and vice versa, really, if I'm being honest), such debate helps keep me sharp and articulates intuitions I've built over the years in an adversarial environment. Certainly while I'm open to them expressing their beliefs, I am inevitably against leaving them critically unopposed.

I had thought atheism thoroughly won the religion-vs-atheism wars of the 2000s, but I guess I was watching different screen from everyone else.

I'm only barely old enough to see the tailwinds of that period, back when /r/Atheism was a default subreddit. I have little to opine other than what Scott has already written, that the Atheists won, in the sense that fundamentalist Christians were stopped from enforcing many of their more insane policies on the wider populace, but the movement was eventually subsumed into what we might current recognize as Wokism, which is a damn shame.

Frankly, humans are capable of astonishing feats of compartmentalization, likely an adaptive mechanism to put a ceiling on how bad a viral memeplex can be for the typical host. Leaving aside religion, the fact that my uncle, a microbiology professor, can believe fervently in homeopathy while otherwise being completely sane, would make me despair if it were not for the fact that humans have been mostly getting saner over time, even if we could be in a minor period of backpedaling on that front.

https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/10/30/new-atheism-the-godlessness-that-failed/

If by chance you haven't read this, I strongly recommend it!

I only have limited psychiatric experience, but the handful of schizophrenics I've encountered in India had what any Western doctors would consider "Western" schizophrenia symptoms, including my friend who just tried to commit suicide that I personally diagnosed. That means the hallucinations were outright malign in nature, or certainly delusional in a negative way, as opposed to claims that they can be benign or even helpful.

For what it's worth, they didn't know they were schizo till they had the diagnosis, so it's not like I expected them to be culturally primed to interpret it in that light.

Overall I personally find the claims dubious, but I can't conclusively rule it out.

This is a relatively new measure enforced on new accounts, I think their comments are being manually approved by the mods, or if that's not done, showing up after 24 hours.

Tell me about it, there's a reason I don't hang out on the Indian end of the Internet 😩

I think he considers "effectively enough" to encompass having a gun and shooting at the police or social services worker who came to check on why he hasn't been attending school lol

"One of my points was a widow of a dead dude, people will support; a man who failed, people will tell him to suck it up and figure it out."

Inflation has hit the once post-scarcity market for punctuation hard.

I can't say I disagree. But they both are presumably relevant here, and most guys don't even try experimenting with other men, so it's not like I can point at them.