@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

Thank you!

Schizophrenia is an exceptionally shitty illness, especially since it has no outright cure and you can only try to contain disease progression. It takes about 25 years off your life on average from the combination of meds and poor life decisions.

The meds are often terrible to be on too, they just beat having uncontrolled schizophrenia.

I yelled at my Dad, cuz my Dad was talking with Adam and dropped that I'm an Atheist. Like do you want me to get stabbed Dad?

Atheists truly are the most persecuted minority, about tied with Gamers 🙏. I'm glad you didn't get stabbed, and while my friend isn't normally violent, who knows what the fuck can happen during an episode. Assuming I have the luxury of choosing a specialization in psych, I'm going the ADHD route, the biggest headache the doctors have is teen pregnancy and poor compliance with meds haha.

Well, my parents are doctors who are quite well advanced in their careers.

I think it would be possible for me to hire one personally for about 50 to 100 dollars a month assuming you want them full time. In comparison, my salary is about 600 dollars a month. I haven't checked the latest currency conversion rates, but that's a fair place to peg it.

With double salaries, it becomes significantly easier, not that I particularly prioritize it. Labor is cheap in most of the third world.

There's no way to get an "I", a first-person perspective, in a materialist ontology, any more than it's possible to get moral realism.

I actually agree with everything you said up till this paragraph for what it's worth.

But my stance here is we don't know. It's not obvious to me that this is in fact true, for the same reason that people sincerely believed that the spark of life that gave beings motion was qualitatively different from "mere" physics. I reserve judgement till we have a GUT, or a Superintelligence of our own tells me otherwise. In the absence of understanding everything else perfectly, it seems like a far better stance to simply reserve judgement.

And once again, it really is no excuse to just choose any old ontology you feel like, especially when you consider more concrete variables like predictive accuracy and the like.

I'd go so far as to say that Christian metaphysics is no better at answering this. You lack a mechanistic explanation of how souls work, and a natural language description doesn't count even if the language seems simple enough.

The elephant in the room here, the simplest ontology that nobody wants no believe -- maybe that nobody can believe: Solipsism. Why believe in the existence of anything external to yourself at all? A universe with just one thing is simpler than any hypothesis other than one with nothing (not tenable for the obvious reason). It can easily account for all your putative observations (i.e. they are not actually observations of anything at all). And yet, despite the talk of Boltzmann brains, which is functionally the same thing (if you are just a brain in the void, why do you think your observations of the laws of physics have any meaning -- and thus why is the fact that QM may permit Boltzmann brains any evidence whatsoever about whether you might be one?), I don't think I've heard people insist that solipsism is the only rational position

I am aware of the existence of Boltzmann Brains, and it certainly throws a wrench in my certainty of anything really.

But as a merely practical matter, I treat it as moot till our decision theories or probability theories are up to the task. How do the ?infinite set of possibilities here line up with the other infinities in more reasons for solipsism that are Simulations, Multiverses and so on?

I have no clue. But practically, I have no way of finding out short of trying to kill myself, and I'm not that curious about it.

It's me being mildly exasperated that you even asked in the first place, since the answer was in fact in the original text.

I agree we've otherwise said our peace.

Oh I left him with plenty of company, more than he'd like for sure.

I made sure I was there until his parents arrived, and they arrived to find an ambulance waiting for them, but he wouldn't get in on my say so and believe me I tried.

At this point his family are fed up with him, and the mental health facilities around here are pretty poor. I'd encourage him to be committed, but I don't think it would work and he doesn't deserve to be locked away indefinitely.

His dad is a doc too, so it's his headache how to proceed. I just spent 3 or 4 hours there, leaving only when help was at least theoretically available, and I have work later anyway.

I honestly don't have any clue if we even have an equivalent for suicide watch, but I wouldn't put much stock in it either. You guys underestimate how shit the psychiatric services are in the third world!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodicy

Not only is it an argument, it's a valid one that's been grappled with by theologians for millennia. I think it's a waste of the time in the context of the Abrahamic God, who can't be blamed for it by the simple logic that it doesn't exist.

As for whether it's persuasive to you, I can only shrug, and say you're potentially being obtuse or simply can't follow a clear argument.

I watched him take out like 40 pills, 10 of them each would be dangerous, and I have no idea what I could have done if he'd taken them all before I could stop him, short of forcing him to puke and giving CPR 👀

The part where he threatened to go for the knife was the worst, though I didn't think he would actually stab me. God knows he's as thin as a beanstalk, so I'd take my odds in a fight.

Like the worst part was when I initially assumed he'd already ODd and was waiting for the ambulance, and he excused himself to drink water. Imagine my reaction when I noticed he wasn't back in 10 minutes and when I went to find him, he's busy making that cocktail for himself. When he gets better I'm going to whoop his ass myself for putting me through this 🙏

Ichythosis Bad.*

God Good. God Strong.

How God Let Bad Thing Happen? Ugg no understand. Why other Uggs claim God Good as well as Strong If God No Help Innocent Baby?

*citation not needed

I just ~successfully talked my schizophrenic estranged best friend out of killing himself, or at least stopped him midway through the process. I suppose my involvement is a mixed bag, because I was the one who initially diagnosed him as a schizo and sent him to a shrink, which is why he he had antipsychotics at hand alongside benzos and SSRIs. Eh, you can't win them all.

It would be exceedingly rude of me to bill him for the services, so I'm going to go home and take a well deserved nap before I have to go back to work.

At least I know I'll be a good (licensed) psychiatrist, they call on me everytime someone with some kind of psychiatric comorbidity acts up and I get them calm and compliant in minutes 🙏

As I was telling @Meriadoc yesterday, if I ever meet the Omnibenevolent loving Creator who created ichthyosis vulgaris, I'll kick them in the Holy Nuts. Until then, my sheer disdain for Him is made obviate by the fact that He's fictional.

It's right there dude.

fully organic, non-GMO

Good things those are all nonsensical to worry about eh?

A physician at the time probably had a live-in cook and nanny to handle all the domestic work.

Well this physician has all of those, not that I'm in the West. Might not be feasible on a UK salary, but if an American doctor cared, they could afford the same too. Especially if they're a double income couple.

A lot of that work has been automated but you still see billionaires pushing buttons to call elevators for some reason.

Presumably because it's an utterly trivial inconvenience? Mechanical lifts were likely far harder to operate safely back then. It's not like it even saves them much in the way of time to tell someone where they're going versus pressing a single button..

Entertainment is cheaper? Are the 2020s versions of Lord of the Rings equivalent to the 2000s? Are the 2010-20s versions of Star Wars equivalent to the previous ones?

I suppose it's really nice that we have access to both eh? Anyone not enamoured by the current Star Wars soyslop can watch the older movies too, and cheaply.

The amount of media available for consumption only tends to increase, and faster than you can watch it all.

The reason 1 and 0 are bad ideas because of Bayesian updates work, 1 implies infinite certainty, and 0 implies infinite disbelief. When you contend with a merely finite amount of evidence, no matter how vast it is, it moves the needle not one inch.

For any other values, at least in theory, a sufficient amount of evidence makes two entities with different priors converge. If they're ideal Bayesian agents, then they can just talk to each other and end up at the same spot by the Aumann Agreement Theorem, not that I can particularly follow the latter myself. The former is robustly true.

As for how that works in human neurology? No clue. But we know that LLMs initialized from random weights manage it, something to do with them being biased for simplicity in their world models, and that seems to work in practise. Presumably humans do something similar too, since we have some mechanism for teasing out useful ontologies, and it doesn't have to be particularly complex, since random noise can be coaxed there with simple algorithms.

That's small enough I have no shame in calling it miniscule, but YMMV.

That the person allowing it to exist isn't omnibenevolent or at least not that and capable of doing anything about it?

That is such a profoundly obvious takeaway I don't see how you miss it. It it's genuinely new to you, it's the problem of theodicy if one wants to use complex terminology for no good reason.

God isn't complex. God is simple

Oh not this again. No, just claiming this doesn't make it so.

I'm not sure I want to be giving lessons on Kolmogorov complexity and minimum signal length, but consider why the more mathematically or comp sci literate among the religious aren't making this argument.

It's not just that it's a difficult and finicky concept, it is, I only have a passing understanding of it.

To put it as simply as I can, imagine you're trying to watch the Titanic, or rather send someone a copy. There are a lot of tricks involved in shrinking the size of a video so it can be sent more easily, but one of the more questionable things you can do is to send someone a very small file, that by itself seems like gibberish, but if they have a very complex video watching software, it can interpret it as the movie using information they already have. Similarly, you could also send a large file to a small piece of software and get the same result. However you will quickly find that trying to make both small doesn't work, you'll find that in both theory and practise, trying to shrink things further requires you to severely degrade the quality of the video itself over all else.

Or perhaps the person has already seen the movie and has a vivid imagination, then you can tell them "watch The Titanic in your head" and they can do just that. In this case, the data about the movie primarily exists in their brain.

The point of this analogy is that just because something sounds "simple" or "complex" to us in colloquial speech, doesn't mean it is is so in reference to the more rigorous and mathematical definitions I'm employing.

Maybe the word "God" sounds super simple to you, but your brain is buzzing with enormous amounts of context about what it means and implies, including the usual caveats about what it doesn't actually mean what it clearly implies, such as an all powerful and all loving deity letting evil of any form exist.

So the complexity is being smuggled in, like some wily pirate chopping a video up into multiple parts so they can innocently look at any one when asked and claim it's far too simple to be a Blu-ray rip of a copyrighted movie.

virgin birth

For certain widely accepted definitions of virgin.

Oh, Catholicism certainly hasn't come around on that.

I stand corrected, not that it does anything good for my opinion of said religion.

Hmm.. I suppose losing one's monopoly on potential virgin births has gotta suck.

I can't say I disagree, as an aspiring psychiatrist who currently has to occasionally write diet charts.

Well, at least the drugs work, regardless of the theoretical grounding of more hand-wavey stuff like therapy.

In the latter case, it's not just that the sticker price of food has increased, which it certainly has, it's whether it's increased grossly disproportionate to the increase of wages. And even then, as others have shown, the cost of food is a minuscule portion of most individual budgets unless they're really addicted to DoorDash.

Things where I am suspicious about what the experts say:

I can't say I disagree but for the majority, I'd go so far as to say that instead of being merely suspicious, I'm in flagrant opposition.

On the matter of COVID death rates, it depends on whether you are considering the initial claims of CFR in the first few months, or the more reasonable values that emerged later down the line. A 0.1-0.5% CFR seems reasonable enough to me, at least until the vaccines came out.

As for economics, shrugs, I'll care to be better informed when I'm in a position to dictate fiscal policy for any organization larger than my household. I'm content in crossing the very low bar of being better than average.

Wait. Aren't you an economist or trained in the field? It deeply concerns me that you too are forced to believe the last claim, but then again you economists are a contentious lot, each content to claim the other is ruining a noble field.

On the other hand, I'm hardly as uncertain when it comes to claims that are tangentially related to medicine, doctors do tend to agree on most things that matter, for noble or ignoble reasons I guess!

Buddy, I regret to inform you that you're seeking a Fully Generalized Solution to Disagreement, and if I or any other Mottizen had it, you'd know, if only because we'd be on stage for the Nobel Prize for Peace.

And I'm one of the people who pushed back on the narrative that the US is doing poorly. I lied, or at least was inaccurate, because the ratio of downvotes to upvotes reveals that as a pretty good scissor statement, and blackpills me harder on the quality of general epistemics than even the typical American Idiot claiming their lives and that of most other people in the States are getting harder when it comes to finances.

Oh well, I guess we all have to settle for doing our thankless jobs on the margins.

But, as someone on the other side of the belief equation, it screams emotionalism compromising your sense of 'rational' skepticism.

I will point to Yudkowsky claiming many times over that rationality and emotions aren't necessarily mutually incompatible.

Maybe I wouldn't kick such an Eldritch horror from beyond time and space in the nuts, perhaps because it doesn't have one, but I am sorely tempted at times to do so for the mere humans running cover for its actions.

In other words, if you were faced with being absolutely wrong about your agnosticism, you really wouldn't stop for an istant, temper your contempt for a moment, to scratch the possibility your view of the problem of evil, of theodicy, was also incomplete?

Certainly. I would still expect very good answers for all the pain and suffering I've personally endured and on behalf of all others.

Things I might settle for? An answer to theodicy I guess, or a signed disclaimer from my past self acknowledging what the fuck I was putting myself through after a veil of ignorance.

That doesn't change that I find the current proposals made by the religious morally outrageous to the max, claiming that things are working as intended is one of the biggest hurdles to endeavors to making them better. Religious people are consistently some of the biggest hurdles to technological innovation and human advancement I've had the displeasure of seeing, not that they hold sole claim to that dubious distinction. If you're tempted to disagree from your own emotions, then pray tell how Christians came around on IVF.

I am always puzzled by people angry at a god they don't believe in. I think the anger and disbelief undermine eachother.

The latter is true. I'm not actually currently angry at something I don't believe exists. It's in the scenario where I'm proven wrong that the boiling hatred arises, even if I wouldn't claim to not be amenable to explanations.

I am the only SMH I have access to, unless I end up cloning myself, but it certainly doesn't seem to me like I'm any less effective or efficient, or even particularly stressed.

Maybe the latter, but I strongly prefer useful stress that motivates me in getting to the bottom of the mystery to blissfully becoming beholden to what pundits claim. And if I think that the stress itself isn't useful because I'm genuinely out of my depth, then while I can't guarantee it, I'm pretty good at just not worrying about it too much.

So it could be if we all had trustworthy authorities above us, as a hypothetical child might have an ideal father. If someone can outsource his cognition on trustworthy black boxes then a whole world of rationality opens up where you can think about more and truly important things.

I don't really disagree, but such an entity doesn't exist, and likely won't until we make an aligned superintelligent AGI for ourselves. I'd still prefer to just make myself smarter with its aid so I can figure things out for myself.

In the interim, it's not particularly unbearable to stand on my own two feet atop my brains, and it beats the available alternatives I can see!

Hmm, I was going to dispute this, but on reflection I think you're right, even if my exhausted brain isn't processing things very well.

I appreciate the thoughtful answer, and I will apologize several months late for getting prissy with you in the last debate. From my perspective, you seemed to be intentionally obtuse, but in light of further interaction it was probably not intentional or just us unable to find a productive framework for discussion.

In a void, any system of logic is valid, but in reality we at least understand which of the basics are actually valid and which are just worthless theory.

This assumes that things like privileging hypotheses that are compact in a computational sense and better describe available evidence is sensible for the purposes of navigating reality.

They are. That still doesn't remove the inherent subjectivity about caring about it!

That should be a blazing red flag the moment you bring worth into the picture! Taboo the term and its synonyms and I guarantee you'll flounder.

The fact that we both agree this is a good belief to have doesn't make it objective, nor does my further confidence that most intelligent entities capable of achieving their goals would agree too.

In other words ubiquity of a property in the set of entities likely to exist is not the same as objectivity. Nor does plain old utility.

I suspect a sufficiently intelligent being could take base-level axioms of morality (maybe "suffering bad", "pleasure good", and "meaning good") and build them out using logic into a provably correct moral system.

I can see that you understand perfectly well that that the axioms themselves are arbitrary, and it confuses me that you don't take that to the logical conclusion here.

The Socratic Method never bottoms out, any more than you can manually count till infinity.

Some axioms are clearly better than others on metrics we care about, but they themselves do not determine said metrics after all. In maths the goal is to build the most complicated yet elegant edifice you can with as few axioms as you can get away with, because if an axiom turns out to be flawed in some manner, then you've just fucked everything over.

At most you can build a perfectly consistent model of morality, while Godel carefully watches and waits to jump your ass. It doesn't make it any more objective than simply stating that you believe because you believe. Nothing can.

Our moral theories are much less advanced than our logical theories, so I can't offer much evidence for this belief, save that morality just doesn't feel subjective to me.

Feelings are really not a good idea when it comes to navigating the world. The map must look at the territory from time to time, we can't sit in a dark room and develop an accurate idea of the world outside by going off vibes alone.

I am content in knowing my moral intuitions are inherently subjective, and that doesn't stop me from promoting them to others in the hopes they agree. I'm glad that's the case, because it simply can't be otherwise as far as I can see it.

A hole shaped like God as you metaphysically postulate can no more be filled than one requiring squares to have three sides. At most you can develop neurosurgery good enough to staple it shut.

I realize this is possibly an insane cognitohazard. "God hides from those who aren't ready for him. No I'm not ready for him. Yes I believe in him anyways. Of course controlled randomized studies don't produce evidence for God; we're not ready for that kind of evidence, and that method of finding evidence proves it."

This really looks unjustified to me, clear evidence that you're presuming the results of a thought experiment or hypothetical and then reasoning backwards to justify it.

The fact that I now believe you to be arguing in good faith makes this observation several orders of magnitude more confusing, and corrosive to my "soul" in the sense that it's almost Cosmic Horror that entities so similar to me in terms of intellect and origin can have such alien views. It's little consolation that I'm the moral mutant if you look at the set of all humans to exist, even if most of them would be utterly confused by why you had to resort to such complex arguments when as far as they were concerned, religion was true in the same mundane way we believe in gravity.

What exactly changed such that we lack the privilege to watch water turn to wine or the seas part? Are angels allergic to plates of silver salt or CCDs in digital cameras? It's not just that they ceased outright after Jesus was offed, miracles have been claimed to occur right until we can verify them.

The claim that we only deserve subtle theological arguments or personal revelations seems deeply silly when your religion abounds with the opposite, and it's more like the panicked justifications of a battered housewife claiming she deserved it rather than a convincing argument as far as I'm concerned.

At times when I am morally stronger, I see quite a lot more evidence of God, in ways which are quite difficult to discount as placebo or confirmation bias

If I ended up in such a scenario knowing what I know of biology and wider reality, I would put more stock in the notion I was going insane.

There is something objectively beautiful about the movement of planets around their stars, the capacity for a single cell to grow into trillions working in harmony, and the delighted laughter of babies. An empty universe feels objectively worse than one where complex and beautiful phenomena arise.

To get me to agree, find and replace objective with subjective.

There's a very strong reason that religious people generally also do not claim to have seen angels, and I generally discount even the ones who do. Too much evidence before you're ready is harmful.

You can't deny which side has the higher base rate and even includes their existence in their model of reality.

accepts things I currently consider self-evidently wrong (the belief that consciousness is nothing special, or that morality is subjective).

I am agnostic on the former, and everything I've said so far is an attempt to justify the latter, in good faith, not that I think you think that I'm not arguing from it.

The God I believe in is essentially a superintelligence anyways. I don't think magic or divine power exist separate from the laws of physics at all--if/when we learn them they will just be more laws of physics.

God has plenty of baggage that a mundane Superintelligence as we can reasonably postulate would lack. Sure, from the perspective of their playthings, it makes little difference, but the gulf between being fuck off powerful and omnipotent is as large as that between 10^87 and infinity.

If you want to start gathering evidence, I'd suggest explicitly creating a model of the world without God, and one with God, and living for a day as if there's maybe a 1% chance the latter is the correct model. This might mean praying with real intent for 30 seconds and then noting the results, slightly modifying your system of ethics to do something virtuous you wouldn't normally consider worthwhile, or simply making an extra effort to be consistent about your own code of ethics. I guarantee the results will be positive and worth the effort.

I am not sure I am even capable of doing the former any more than I can, at will, convince myself there's a 1% chance I'm hallucinating the sofa I'm sitting on. I think @FCfromSSC claims to be able to do things along those lines, but it's a power I lack.

I do a decent job of aligning to my own personal code of ethics, or at least there's nothing obvious I could do right now that I am not already trying to do, being bottlenecked more by my own ADHD and akrasia!

Take enough steps, note enough times that each step made under the assumption God is real has both made life better and provided a tiny piece of evidence in favor of that conclusion, and remaining on the path becomes the obvious course of action.

This is a fundamentally unsound approach in the same manner as convincing yourself you have an invisible bodyguard is. Sure, you might save time on your walk home by happily taking shortcuts through a deserted alley, and that might increase your overall QOL for a bit till you confidently refuse to hand over your wallet to a mugger.

Then you die, and don't get to find out much of anything at all because Heaven or Hell probably don't exist.

Given this all started as an argument about reconciling rationality with religion, I would claim this is an example of sacrificing epistemic rationality for instrumental rationality, it might even be a sensible tradeoff, but you pay the price eventually.