self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
Did you take that seriously? I would hope not, because the joke was that it's hard to get responses from participants in euthanasia because they're dead. If it's meant to be an educational aside, I appreciate it.
You know, now that I think about it, I think 50% of this was going off the memory of an AAQC of yours. Had to be you.
I suppose that means I remembered enough of it not to bring dishonor upon your name. And thank you for being polite enough not to point that out first.
But I don't just give it a prompt! 80% of the text is mine, at the absolute bare minimum. I'd say 90% is closer to the average. That is me attempting to estimate raw words, the bulk of the 10% is alternative phrasing.
My usual practice is to write a draft, which I would normally consider feature complete. I feed it into several models at the same time, and ask them to act as an editor.
(If this was Pre-LLM era, I would probably be continously updating the post for hours. I still do, but the need to fix typos and grammatical inconsistencies is decreased by me being a better writer in general, and of course, the LLMs. All I'm doing is frontloading the work)
I also, simultaneously, feed them into a more powerful reasoning model such as o3 or Gemini 2.5 Pro for the purposes of noting any flaws in reasoning. They are very good at finding reasoning flaws, less so at catching errors in citations. Still worth using.
I then carefully compare the differences between my raw output and what they suggest. Is there a particular angle they consider insightful? I might elaborate on that. Would this turn of phrase be an improvement over what I originally wrote?
Those are targeted, bounded changes. They are minimal changes. They don't even save me any time, in fact, the whole process probably takes more time than just letting it rip. If I was just uncriticially ripping off an LLM, the it would be a miracle if every link in the previous post worked, let alone said what I claim they said.
Does this dilute my authorial voice? To a degree, yes, but I personally prefer (90% SMH and 10% half a dozen different LLMs) to pure SMH, and certainly better than any individual LLM.
I consider this a very different kettle of fish to people who simply type in a claim into ChatGPT and ask it to justify it to save themselves the hassle of having to write or think. self_made_human is the real value add. The LLMs are a team of very cheap but absent-minded editors and research interns who occasionally have something of minor interest to add.
Why do you think I bothered to show that I have independently come up with all the thoughts and opinions expressed in this essay? I literally did all of that years ago, and in some cases, I forgot I had done the exact same thing. I could have easily just copied most of that and gotten the bulk of the essay out of it.
At the end of the day, my anger is mostly directed at the lazy slobs who shovel out actual slop and ruin the reputation of a perfectly good tool. At the end of the day, it is your perogative to downweight my effort-posts because a coterie of LLMs helped me dissect and polish them. I am disappointed, but I suppose I understand.
Edit: The present >80 and the average ~90% only applies for specific comments. I can only stress that the majority of all commentary by my digital pen is entirely human written.
I think being depressed is very good reason not to agree to people's pleas to die right away! It is a mental illness which twists your cognition. It should be difficult to kill yourself on the grounds of depression.
I do not think it's an absolute indicator to ignore someone, if used in the literal sense. You have to keep in mind that the BATNA for these patients is jumping in front of a train. That makes absolutist stances less than actionable, in the pragmatic sense. If you want to achieve this in the real world, you need to lock some people up for the rest of their lives on those grounds alone, and I think letting them kill themselves might well kinder in some cases.
Look, I think it's quite clear that my statement about tigers was hyperbole. You seem like a perfectly nice guy, while I wouldn't jump into the ring to save you, I'd throw rocks (at the tiger) and call for paramedics.
That is the nice thing about being able to compartmentalize one's combative online persona from being an actually nice and easy-going person in reality. There are very few people I would actually watch and let die, and they're closer to Stalin than they are to people I disagree with on a forum for underwater basket weaving.
But when you imagine talking to your own grandmother - a perfect example of a novice user - what do you do?
If this were a perfectly realistic scenario, my conversation would go:
"What the fuck. Is that a ghost? I thought your ashes were somewhere in the Bay of Bengal by now."
Do you understand why I paraphrased what is usually a more nuanced context-dependent conversation IRL? If my granny was actually alive, I would probably teach her how to use the voice mode in her native language and let her chill.
And I have to say, if I told you I'm not biased towards Teslas, Elon doesn't send me cheques, and in fact I just paid money for one, how wide would your eyes go as you attempted to parse that?
Uh? I don't know. If you have a reputation for doing that, I genuinely do not recall. I am very active here, but I do not remember that without actually having to open your profile.
I was going to write that myself if I wasn't so lazy. Thank you/curse you for scooping me, and I obviously agree.
I will note that this is a concern I have intentionally and prominently addressed. I am personally okay with euthanasia as a cost-saving measure, keeping someone on the verge of brain death in the ICU is both expensive and futile. Doubly so if the savings are used to extend more lives on net.
As it stands, I am willing to compromise on my fantasy of euthanasia booths next to children's parks if that's the cost of making it available in more jurisdictions. What I proposed is a version specifically designed to appease the squeamish, while still being something I am content with myself. This involves removing or minimizing financial incentive to individuals or even most parts of the system.
To the extent that this calls for amendments in places with legal euthanasia, well, it does do that. It's just not as pressing as elsewhere.
At the end of the day, most moral systems reduce to normality, outside of edge cases which are, well, edge cases. If you're not cooking my dog, and I'm not feeding yours poison, we'd get along regardless of the underlying reasons.
I've cried myself hoarse trying to reason with people who reflexively think LLM=bad. They're tools, tools that have serious flaws, but which are so useful it makes you wonder how you managed before. It's like trying to navigate the internet before Google.
I suspect that if Scott, Gwern, or any of the other big names were obscure today, and broke containment, they'd go nuts trying to fend off accusations of being AI. There is good reason why the LLMs were taught, intentionally or inadvertently, to mimic such a style. Nearly formatted essays with proper markdown are not the sole domain of AI. They make things more pleasant, at the cost of a very small amount of individuality. I promise you that every one of my essays screams self_made_human regardless of how many models I ask for advice. You should take it as a compliment, in this particular scenario.
Who am I to tell you what's massive or not? When you see how the elderly, who make up a very large chunk of all deaths these days, actually go out, it really doesn't surprise me. I would start raising eyebrows past 20%, and be alarmed past 30. This is implying business as usual, not something like the Culture's post-scarcity, where people almost never die natural deaths, and euthanize themselves when they're bored. We'll figure that out if/when we get there.
This is akin to going to a waterslide at a theme park and complaining the slope is slippery. You do not know how bad mental illness can get if you think "mental illness" is some privileged form of disease. I'd take many forms of cancer over schizophrenia.
So life sucked for her. Life sucks for a lot of people.
I stubbed my toe this morning. That puts me in the same category as people screaming from the agony of testicular torsion, childbirth, or a subarachnoid hemorrhage. It is helpful to deny them painkillers because I've walked it off.
I do not understand how you fail to see that the degree of sucking matters. If your mother complains of a mild headache, you pop down to the chemist for some Tylenol. If she is screaming with an arrow in her guts in the middle of the Amazon, you would be very kind to give her the opportunity to extend her life for a few minutes or hours, at least an opportunity to let her demonstrate moral character in the face of adversity.
American healthcare is not anything like European healthcare— ours is a private, for-profit system designed to cut the costs of healthcare and to ensure profits for hospitals and insurance companies.
Oh no. You're taking the claims about the American healthcare system at face value.
I'm going to dial @Throwaway05 for backup/moral reassurance. I'd say *page */bleep but the US is a more enlightened regime:
The American healthcare system is incredibly socialist. Is there a better word for a regime where you can walk into any hospital clutching your gut, and they legally must treat you, even if you look and smell like a hobo and throw feces at them? Where the hospital isn't allowed to throw you out, or means test you for such trifling things as the ability to pay for care? Where hospitals, and by extension, actual paying customers, must subsidize/swallow losses in case their patient wanders out and says fuck you to collections? Assuming you even got an address or ID to send those?
Buddy, that's socialism masquerading as capitalism, with only the polite and respectable actually going through the whole charade. You should see what happens in India, where we're not quite so keyed into the kayfabe - despite having both entirely free public care as well as a booming private sector. We'd laugh at the softness. They'd kick your ass to the curb, and the cops would come and laugh.
Treating cancer is expensive: hospital stays, chemotherapy, pain management, in home care between visits, blood work. Giving an elderly cancer patient an overdose of morphine is cheap.
The government, and by extension, the humble net tax-payer, faces the same dilemma in the UK. We do not kill people just to save money. To the extent that mere prioritization of finite funds kills people, it's in the name of saving more lives than we let die. My bosses do not get a raise or a cut of the savings. To murder anyone would take the collusion of, at minimum, the nurses and resident doctors on the ward. Worst case you rope in the family and pharmacy. It takes working here to truly grok how ridiculous such a proposition is, the nurses will throw you under the bus for looking at the patient wrong, let alone killing them.
I'm lucky. By the time they end up in the dementia wards (autocorrect really wanted to make that dementia wars, which is a colorful turn of phrase), they're too far gone to beg. Most of the time. I assume if I had spent a year in your shoes, I actually could retire.
I understand. The only reason I don't fear dementia more is because of a genuine confidence that it will be a solved problem by the time I'm old enough to be at risk. This almost certainly holds true for you too, modulo all the assumptions that lead me to have that belief in the first place. A mere example would be the recent discovery that semaglutide reduces the relative risk of developing Alzheimer's by 50%.
I have seen so many people utterly hollowed out by the illness. It is an unavoidable perk of the psychiatry of old age. The lucky are those who are far gone, they are past all but the most primal of pain or pleasure. The prick of a needle, as I pull blood like an anorexic vampire, the recognition that a smile means friendliness. Their inner world seems to have shrunk to a point. It is often better for them, and certainly for everyone else, when they are physically frail. A robust body attached to a shattered mind is a uniquely challenging combination.
We had a gentleman who was 95, and as strong as an ox. He broke two noses on the ward before nearly dying of a stroke. I went on vacation and had every confidence he wouldn't be around when I came back. Nope, he shrugged it off, and everyone was happy to have him back even if it came at the cost of their facial features. It takes a certain kind to work in that field in the long-term, I'm not cut out for it.
My own grandpa, who I love dearly, is at the same age. Covid killed him, if not physically, then the enforced idleness killed the man he was. More man than me, mostly gone now. It was the clinic and regular interaction with his patients that kept him truly alive, and the decline was obvious when it stopped. It's enough to make me cry, and I try not to think about it if I can help it. When he sees me, all he remembers is that I'm back from the UK, and his only concern is when I'll visit again. This loops every five minutes. It is enough that he can do this, and I get to hold his hands one more time. They're very similar, those hands. His and mine. He had a good run, almost 92 years of putting others to shame. 3 where the survivors finally lapped him. Outlived his enemies (the very few he had), most of his very many friends, but not his family. He has the comfort of his two daughters these days, if not the grandson he loves the most. He was the kindest man I know, he used to feed honey to the bees by the window sill, and the angriest I've ever seen him was when he tried to do the same to a wasp and it stung him for his kindness. God, I wish things were different. The universe is cruel, and physician heal thyself? Fucking hell, I can't heal the people I actually love. What good are these hands after all?
I digress. It is easier to talk about the problems of others. It helps me pretend to have a degree of clinical detachment, and gives time for the tears to dry.
The worst-off are those who know, or even suspect. The disappointment on their faces when the diagnosis is disclosed, the scans finally in. The furtive glances at their loved ones, the attempts to put on a brave front. Some sob. Some smile and talk about the weather. None really withstand the blow, but most come to terms with it. Then the dread sets in.
Putting myself in their shoes, it is the present, horrifying knowledge of what they are and what they are becoming, a slow-motion unraveling they are forced to witness from the inside. They are passengers in a vehicle that is slowly, but unstoppably, falling apart around them. Is it any surprise that many come to terms with the inevitable, and seek to go out on their own by wresting the wheel into the nearest tree? Can't blame them, poor bastards, even if it's my job to stop them. I wish it wasn't my job, and I wish my job allowed me to let them exercise the last bit of agency they have left.
It has been a generation! In some cases, multiple:
The Netherlands legalized euthanasia in 2002. Belgium in 2002. Switzerland has allowed assisted suicide since 1941.
If this a slippery slope, then at the current rate of progress we might have Dyson Swarms before the Netherlands breaks double digits for proportion of deaths conducted by MAID.
Switzerland has octogenarians running hobbling around who don't remember a regime before euthanasia. It also has a rather high proportion of the elderly, which suggests they're not being culled when inconvenient.
Can I make guarantees that societal norms won't change, and in a direction either you or I will disapprove of? Who can? The legalization of gay marriage hasn't, as far as I'm aware, causally produced a legalization of pedophilia or beastiality as some feared. I consider my claims very strong evidence, it's harder to get stronger.
You can't launch many rockets if your standard for rocketry is that we must perfect the design before putting a single nozzle on the pad. You will not enact any social change at all, out of an overabundance of caution. I consider this regrettable.
I am getting deja vu, and not just because of sleep deprivation.
As a matter of fact, I have previously addressed the exact same case. In short, I think the doctors did the right thing.
https://www.themotte.org/post/1701/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/302719?context=8#context
An article about her case, published in April, was picked up by international media, prompting an outcry that caused Ter Beek huge distress.
She said it was understandable that cases such as hers – and the broader issue of whether assisted dying should be legal – were controversial. “People think that when you’re mentally ill, you can’t think straight, which is insulting,” she told the Guardian. “I understand the fears that some disabled people have about assisted dying, and worries about people being under pressure to die.
“But in the Netherlands, we’ve had this law for more than 20 years. There are really strict rules, and it’s really safe.”
Under Dutch law, to be eligible for an assisted death, a person must be experiencing “unbearable suffering with no prospect of improvement”. They must be fully informed and competent to take such a decision.
...
Ter Beek’s difficulties began in early childhood. She has chronic depression, anxiety, trauma and unspecified personality disorder. She has also been diagnosed with autism. When she met her partner, she thought the safe environment he offered would heal her. “But I continued to self-harm and feel suicidal.”
She embarked on intensive treatments, including talking therapies, medication and more than 30 sessions of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). “In therapy, I learned a lot about myself and coping mechanisms, but it didn’t fix the main issues. At the beginning of treatment, you start out hopeful. I thought I’d get better. But the longer the treatment goes on, you start losing hope.”
After 10 years, there was “nothing left” in terms of treatment. “I knew I couldn’t cope with the way I live now.” She had thought about taking her own life but the violent death by suicide of a schoolfriend and its impact on the girl’s family deterred her.
She has a point. If you're not familiar with the management of severe depression, then by the time you reach ECT, you've exhausted all the options. I don't know if she tried things along the lines of ketamine or psychedelics, but those don't work for everyone.
She's tried everything, it didn't work, and she's clearly suffering immensely.
This woman, the purported victim, seems entirely lucid and defending the medical establishment that's carrying out her wishes. What more can you possibly ask for? It is clearly not spur of the moment decision, she's engaged with the options that the medical field can offer her.
The only thing that I would (personally) say that strikes me as untrue is that there "there's no hope". I think I have strong reasons to hope got a cure for depression, but that isn't a certainty, and could take decades even for myself.
If someone doesn't have the same degree of confidence in future medicine or a technological singularity, then I think that's acceptable shorthand. Strictly speaking, there's always a possibility that someone might just develop a brain tumor that makes them not depressed (or at least makes them manic), but that's not particularly reliable.
It wasn't seen as a failure, if there was no punishment
I can only address this if you link to the specific instance(s) of this happening.
The governments don't run on Open Source. If euthanasia was legalized with the intention of lowering healthcare costs, even if based completely on the own initiative of the patient, it's still meets the criteria for a systemic failure. However, without access to all communications and private conversations of all public officials involved in the decision, proving it will be impossible, and so your request is unreasonable.
This is, as far as I can tell, a fully generalized counter-argument against having a government at all. Or at least an argument for inventing mind reading devices and strapping them to every politician and bureaucrat. Once they're invented, we can re-examine this, and with my mild approval.
Why is cost-cutting inherently a bad thing? If drug X comes out that roughly does the same thing as drug Y, why would it be bad for a healthcare system to preference one over the other? Money matters (citation not needed), money saved somewhere can, at least theoretically, be spent elsewhere. If we're not spending tens of thousands of $currency on keeping someone who is going to die in a few days or months alive for the sake of it, then that money is available for other tasks.
For the sake of pragmatism, I don't care very nearly as much about why things are done, as I do about how they're done or their outcomes.
You should at least provide a plausible explanation of how these doctors came up with the idea to offer euthanasia in these cases, that doesn't condemn the system. My most mundane one is that they got a pamphlet telling them to shill it, so they shilled it. That's still a systemic failure.
What. I think it's a tad-bit much to expect me to do that. You can Google that yourself, I fail to see what I can add since I live and work in jurisdictions where euthanasia is yet to be legalized.
But, in short:
-
Is patient sad/in pain? And not just a stubbed toe, to the point they're asking for the release of death. Or don't have the cognition left to ask.
-
Can we do something about that?
-
Have we tried? Anything left to try?
-
Consider euthanasia based on previous points.
-
Talk to them, their family, and a few lawyers before proceeding.
I didn't decide to do anything at all. I'm talking about an existing system, which was created over decades by people with far more degrees and alphabets after their name. Give me ten years, maybe 20,before I get there.
It is obvious to me that even attempting to frame the system-as-it-exists as exclusively deontological or utilitarian/consequentialist is at least partially a category error. There are a lot of sticky fingers in that pie.
What I am advocating for is a better system overall. I think the existing system is okay. Not great, not terrible. Hence the critique.
we'd be living in ancap insurance-ocracy, not what we have today.
Would it surprise you to find out that I would actually prefer to live there? One of the many reasons I dream of moving State-side is because it's the closest any country has ever come to embodying those aspirations.
You'll just have to take my word for it, I'm afraid.
As far as I'm concerned, the most compelling reason to not worry too much about anything but the most-blatant usage of LLMs is that it is almost impossible to tell. There are obviously hints, but they are noisy ones. Anyone who opts to be careful can get away with it easily. About 70% of our effort-posts, if posted on Reddit, would immediately face accusations of being AI. Even things written in, say, 2020.
I am deeply annoyed by implicit accusations of cheating by generating even a substantial portion of my work with AI, or worse, trying to disguise and launder LLM-usage. I consider even the weaker claims that I use LLMs to help me write to be as farcical as accusing SS of being an anti-semite. For once in my life, like him, I'd go "yeah? And?".
(This is not a personal attack on you, I know we have probably irreconcilable differences of opinion, but you're one of the "LLM-skeptics" here who is open to alternative arguments and willing to engage in proper debate. My blood pressure doesn't rise when talking to you, and I'm grateful for that)
I've already shared screenshots. I would even share the very first draft, which I was writing in the text box as a response here. This post is from 4 hours back, and about an hour before I submitted the final essay. I think that's a sufficient amount of time to write said essay from scratch. I can't fake the time stamps without a time machine, and even GPT-5 can't build those yet. I think it's the version in one of the Gemini 2.5 screenshots, but god only knows at this point. I'm not kidding about staying up still almost 7 am.
If after that much time and hard work, I face such concerns, then what can I even say? I bother now both because I'm definitely not getting any sleep, and so I have something to link to if this happens again.
I have custom instructions that specifically tell ChatGPT not to use em-dashes in conversation with me. As the screenshots attest, it doesn't give a single fuck regardless of the model. In a way, it's actually gotten worse, because when I first put that there it usually listened.
I checked, and yes, at some point in the half a dozen loops of iteration, my initial bullet points turned into a listicle. That bit is, in closer inspection, sloppy. At the very least, those additional (explanations) in brackets doesn't add to the essay. Mea culpa. I would normally remove them when I do edit passes, but I feel that it would dishonest for me to make changes, it would, even if not ended to be, come across as an attempted cover-up.
I seriously seriously doubt these words were typed by human fingers
A critique I have consistently received is using run-on sentences and too many commas. I make an intentional effort to replace it with dashes (and even I've got an allery to em-dashes), semicolons, colons or parentheses.
I tried to use our search function to find comments by me which include "-", because I expect that it would demonstrate a gradual and natural increase in my usage over the years. Sadly it doesn't seem to work, perhaps because the system doesn't index individual characters.
Aaaand even if somehow those words were typed by human fingers, you would never have written anything nearly close to this essay if it weren't for the corrupting influence of AI. Talking to robots has corrupted and twisted your mind, away from a natural human pattern of thought into producing this meandering and listless form that somehow traces the inhuman shape of AI generated text. It lacks the spark of humanity that even the most schizo posters have: the thread of original thought that traces through the essay and evolves along with the reader.
... I obviously disagree. One man's "twisting of a natural mind" is another man's polish and increase to readability.
On more neutral terms: prolonged exposure to a tool also moulds the user. I have been using LLMs since the GPT-3 days, and some aspects of their writing have been consciously or accidentally adopted. What of it? I hadn't really noticed em-dashes before ChatGPT made them notorious, and by then even I felt nauseated by them. Bullet points and lists have their advantages, and I will die on the hill that they deserve to exist.
At the end of the day, this is a debate I'm not particularly interested in. I'm on record advocating for looser restrictions on the usage of LLMs, and I enforce the rules (which are, at this point mostly a consensus on the part of the mods, and not on the sidebar). I am not, in fact, above reproach, and I am answerable to the other mods for personal wrongdoing. I deny that said wrongdoing happened.
you would never have written anything nearly close to this essay if it weren't for the corrupting influence of AI
I invite you to look closely at all the examples I linked above. None of this is new - at worst, I self-plagiarized by finally collecting years of scattered posting into one place.
There's a rationalist shibboleth that I am very fond of: "The optimal amount of X is not zero"
This isn't a call for nihilism or a license for carelessness. It's a recognition that we live in a universe of trade-offs, and that clinging to a perfect "zero" in one narrow domain can inadvertently cause immense harm in others.
For some very high stakes activities, it really ought to be extremely zero over human timescales. For example, if there is an automated system that is responsible for initiating a response to a nuclear strike, I sincerely hope that the failure rate is 0.0... per annum, for several zeroes. Stanislav Petrov was responsible for preventing an accidental nuclear war because he correctly diagnosed that the Soviet early-warning system was malfunctioning.
The lower the stakes, the more the leeway for failure or unpleasant outcomes. If you truly wanted a government that never "systematically" murders someone (and we're assuming that murder is definitionally objectionable), then your best bet is to get rid of government altogether. I suspect that doing so will just lead to an increase in the number of murders overall.
Consider medicine, my home turf? What is the acceptable rate of iatrogenic death, i.e patients killed by the treatment meant to save them? We know for a fact that surgery has a non-zero mortality rate. Anesthesia can kill. Drugs have unexpected, fatal side effects. We could reduce iatrogenic deaths to absolute zero tomorrow by simply banning all surgery, all anesthesia, and all prescription medication. The number of people who would then die from otherwise treatable conditions would be rather large. We accept a small, managed risk of systemic medical error because the alternative is a certainty of systemic medical neglect. That is the only sensible way of going about such things without, as I've said before, literally infinite money/resources.
(This is why deontology is insane. The Pope might not want any orphans to starve in Africa, but he doesn't pawn off the Pope Mobile to pay for it. At least adopt something more sensible like Rule Utilitarianism/Consequential ism or even Virtue Ethics. It is easy to say that the optimal number of starving orphans is zero, far harder to make it happen without sacrificing more important concerns)
Even the legal system, in your own example, abides by Blackstone's ratio. A certain number of the innocent will accompany the guilty, be it to the gallows, a short stint in prison, or in paying fines. To reduce the rate of wrongful conviction to literal zero would be to dispense with a legal system. Guess what that does to crime statistics?
If I had to put a number on the "acceptable" rate of systematic murder, the most obvious way to peg it is by calculating the number of non-systematic murders that would occur. I think I can slightly bias the conversion ratio, but in both directions. I am quite unlike to be either systematically or unsystematically murdered myself, but I guess I'd prefer the latter for the sake of fairness, should Rawls drape a veil over me.
If you have any evidence of systematic failures of the Canadian system, as opposed to anecdotes, then I would be happy to see them. Any large system would have failures, and eye-catching, condemnation worthy failures to boot.
(and just because you filtered out the em-dashes doesn't mean I don't see what you did there)
Is this a claim that this essay was mostly, or even substantially AI generated? If so, that would be false.
I have no qualms about stating that I use AI, but for the purposes of proof-reading, stylistic suggestions/polish, critique, or research. In fact, I've been an open advocate for doing so. What do you think this post suggests?
I'm happy to provide affirmative evidence. I've uploaded an album of screenshots. You can see the embryo of my original draft, further refinements and conversations with o3 where I did my due diligence. As a matter of fact, I spent at least an hour tracking down sources, and groaning as I realized that the model was hallucinating. If this essay is LLM-slop, then please, explain.
In fact, I can go further:
https://www.themotte.org/post/1701/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/302888?context=8#context
https://www.themotte.org/post/1701/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/302842?context=8#context
https://www.themotte.org/post/1701/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/302567?context=8#context
Or one can simply look up everything I've ever said about euthanasia on this forum:
https://www.themotte.org/search/comments/?sort=new&q=author%3Aself_made_human%20euthanasia&t=all
You will find what I hope is extremely strong evidence of me formulating and discussing similar views months/years back, often with identical wording. Short of video-taping myself while writing each and every comment, there can be no stronger proof.

Hang on, please explain to me, ideally without referencing slippery slopes at all, what is the precise issue with this 29 year old woman with depression being offered euthanasia?
I try not to brow-beat people with my credentials any more than I can help, but I have experience in both psychiatry and being severely depressed. It would take far worse to make me seek euthanasia, but my depression wasn't as bad as it can truly get. Some forms of dysfunction and agony can truly be hard to discern from a distance. You see a pretty young woman in the prime of her life being consigned to death by uncaring doctors.
I see a tortured soul, who has consented to her doctors trying everything they can feasibly try. If you don't believe me, you can look at the article. Her every day is utter misery, we have no idea how to fix her, at present. And we've tried, tried oh so hard, with no results. I had reasons to cling to life even when my brain screamed it was pointless to get out of bed, I do not care to dictate beyond a very limited extent, how much others should really tolerate.
She is an exception. 99.9% or more of depressed people are not recommended euthanasia. She went through all the loops and hoops, she didn't change her mind. Her very right to do so was challenged, and when I initially engaged with the article, being adjudicated in a court of law. The rules are being followed.
More options
Context Copy link