@token_progressive's banner p

token_progressive

maybe not the only progressive here

0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 October 25 17:28:07 UTC

				

User ID: 1737

token_progressive

maybe not the only progressive here

0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 October 25 17:28:07 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1737

I'm amused that most of the replies answer a slightly different question than you asked: they answered about knowing people who don't own a smartphone and you asked about people who don't carry a smartphone everywhere. The implication being that the idea of owning a smartphone but not carrying it everywhere isn't really an option.

Not that I'm trying to claim any kind of moral high ground here: I'm definitely in the "carry smartphone everywhere" category. The only exception is leaving it in a bag when I'm doing something active enough that having a smartphone in my pocket would be annoying. I don't have a smartwatch, but some people I know use them for that situation (I think only people who are on call).

While I'm sure any American version of this would give the voting power to the same investment companies that get the voting power on the shares held by pensions and 401(k)s (e.g. Vangard, etc.), and not the government, it certainly would be amusing if the "free market" reworking of social security ended up being a very socialist policy.

More out of curiosity than anything else, what queer spaces do straight people want anything to do with?

I'm just relaying the (a?) classic gentrification story: the weirdos make good art / make the place "cool", more mainstream people notice and eventually overrun the place, outnumbering the people who made it cool in the first place, the vibe is dead. When it happens to a neighborhood, it's (negative connotation) gentrification. But the same pattern happens to social spaces. I've heard people talk about it in relation to kink communities and music subcultures.

That is, straight people aren't drawn to the space because it's queer, from their point of view the queerness is coincidental and often invisible. Of course, this is also the story queer people tell themselves; maybe the queer people aren't actually as cool as they think they are.

Part of the problem here is that the optimal number of men (from the point of view of the organizers of the conference) is not zero. Having some allies that get their messages about gender discrimination out of the conference is very much so a goal of the conference, albeit not a primary one. Even if they could devise a rule that banned men but not "real" non-binary attendees, it's not actually what they want.

It seems like the actual solution probably looks like getting rid of the recruiters and thereby removing that incentive to attend from people not interested in the supposed main point of the conference.

(This feels parallel to discussions I've been involved in about non-queer people in queer spaces. Although I haven't personally seen such a space get overrun with non-queer people, my understanding is that they generally either have to fight hard to stay queer by being very explicit about being a queer space or end up splitting off and creating a new Really Queer This Time(tm) space every once in a while.)

This seems to be missing part of the feminist argument which is that the advice they complain is "victim blaming" is often tied to claims that the advice doesn't actually affect the chance of rape. Which is also related to redirecting the discussion to claims that stranger rape is rare, so advice geared towards avoiding it is a useless distraction.

I'm going with Poe's law here. From the abstract, I assumed that paper was a joke, but I can't find any clear evidence either way.

Mathematical logic is a pretty wide field of which boolean algebra is only a small part of the basics.

Spoilers for a 21 year old anime but in .hack//SIGN, which takes place almost entirely inside a video game, in the final episode, it's revealed that the male main character who is stuck inside the video game and has amnesia and is actually female. This is partially played as surprising because there's a romance subplot between him and a female character, so surprise same-sex relationship. But also, it's just shown in the final scene, there's no follow-up. May even be after the last dialog in the show.

Does this only apply to women's attire? i.e. is a man dressed sexy (whatever qualifies as such for this context... shirtless and showing muscles, wearing an expensive suit, etc.) in public also advertising himself as open to advances from any women he might encounter while out and about?

I understand interpreting attempts to appear attractive as an invitation to interact in a context like a bar or a party, but even there, I'd think the more relevant signal would be being at the bar or party without a visible date. Them being more attractive of course would increase your desire to interact with them, but I don't see why it necessarily is a signal of their desire to be interacted with.

Would you mind at least translating the headline? So far I got

  • HISD = Houston Independent School District. I think that's saying it's the public school district covering Houston (and some of its suburbs?) and the "Independent" part is just part of how school districts are named/organized in Texas?
  • NES = New Education System... whatever that is?
  • SD = School District

This is enough of a problem that GitHub Codespaces exists, advertised as solving exactly this problem, so it's not just you.

Some of this is just experience / familiarity with the tooling. While I agree with other comments in the thread that for professional development, I'm usually working on the same codebase for a while (and when I do spin up on a new codebase, they're sufficiently used to getting new hires set up that they have written instructions), for working in random open source repos, getting set up is usually a few quick rounds of installing whatever packages it complains are missing at most. And while not universal, a lot of GitHub repos do have instructions in how to get started working in the repo.

For a Python project, it's surprising you need anything more than the latest Python and pointing virtualenv at the requirements.txt file. I assume there were some dependencies that couldn't be installed that way for some reason.

(You mention in another comment that you're on Mac... which I've never used for development but I've fairly frequently heard of Linux devs switching to Mac saying the dev support is close enough to Linux and they like the rest of the OS better... so I assume it's plenty usable as a dev platform.)

This seems like a strange perspective to me. Or maybe I'm missing your point. The Culture War isn't about the positive and beautiful because, and maybe I'm stretching the metaphor here, war isn't positive and beautiful.

Plenty of people are making beautiful arts and crafts of various kinds to enrich their lives and the lives of those around them. That's just not Culture War material.

Seemingly-unrelated-but-actually-quite-relevant question: Why do you find the Chinese vaccine efficacy statistics untrustworthy?

Multiple comments in this thread were taking for granted that all official information out of China is a lie. I was assuming we were including their vaccine studies in that. It seemed simpler to just cut out that part of the discussion.


Why are other vaccines not like this?

There's at least two things going on here:

  1. Coronaviruses move really fast and cause noticeable symptoms and transmission very soon after exposure. A major factor in their success is outracing the immune system.
  2. We only very recently got the testing technology to easily test for infection, so we simply don't know the impact on infection of most vaccines. We tested that people don't get noticeably sick and we observed that herd immunity / ring vaccination seem to work in practice, so they're apparently reducing transmission, but it's not something we've tested for historically. Fun fact: IPV (the inactivated Polio vaccine which given by injection and used in most countries including the US) doesn't prevent infection or transmission; it's just extremely effective against severe disease. We have no clue if it's effective against mild disease because no doctor has ever seen a patient with a mild cold and thought "I better run a PCR test for Polio".

Why does this aspect not work anymore with Omicron? Why does the updated vaccine not work the same way?

Because the protection from infection was always a misinterpretation of the data (I haven't actually listened to them but there's TWiV T cell episodes dated August 2020 and they've been patting themselves on the back for getting the story right from the start). It's a little complicated because there's two separate things going on at the same time that can be difficult to disentangle: the virus is changing over time and protection from infection (which only applies to a sufficiently similar virus anyway) decreases over time.

Antibodies are the reason why once you've gotten a virus, your immune system actually clears it out completely (for most viruses, if your immune system is actually functioning right) and you don't get that virus again soon. But antibody levels fall quickly (on the order of months). Maybe not to zero, but to low enough that within about 3-6 months, they're no longer high enough to protect you from infection by a coronavirus. A likely evolutionary explanation for this is that many viruses mutate fairly quickly, so keeping the antibodies around for an old version of a virus is not super useful (it's also possible antibodies against coronaviruses specifically go away faster because the immune system somehow recognizes it as virus likely to mutate, but that's purely speculation my part). The balance is that the immune system keeps around memory B cells which can ramp up production of known antibodies if a sufficiently similar infection is detected, but that takes on the order of days to produce a significant level of antibodies.

For the first about two years of the pandemic (i.e. pre-Omicron), SARS-CoV-2 didn't mutate to evade immunity much, probably because it had plenty of naive hosts to target, so there was limited selection pressure for immune evasion, so antibodies against the original strain in the vaccine remained fairly effective, but, importantly, this was irrelevant 3-6 months after a person's most recent vaccine dose / significant virus exposure, since those antibodies would have gone away by then. So the initial 90%+ protection from infection numbers were on people who were very recently vaccinated with a strain closely matching the circulating strain. Now there both are multiple circulating strains and they are changing too quickly to develop and distribute a vaccine before it changes enough that the vaccine effectiveness against infection would be significantly reduced. Additionally, Omicron seems to actually be better at evading the immune system, not just better at evading immune memory from insufficiently similar strains of SARS-CoV-2, so the best case is not as good.

The bivalent vaccines did provide some protection from infection: see this study (mentioned briefly in this episode of TWiV) which found it reduced the chance of a PCR positive when BA.4/5 (i.e. the strain it was targeted against) was dominant by 29%, when BQ was dominant by 20% (but with the 95% confidence interval going down to 6%), and when XBB was dominant not at all. So, uh, it's doing something, but nothing to write home about, even if you were somehow able to come up with a new vaccine every 3 months, 29% protection from infection just isn't worth it, especially when protection from severe disease remains strong.

Yes, science has an answer for that: protection against severe outcomes appears to be mainly due to T cells, which take too long to react to an infection to clamp it down enough to never be detectable. T cells react to infected cells so there's no mechanism for them to prevent an infection, but when we say "prevent infection" we actually mean "prevent detectable infection", so it's imaginable that some T cell-virus interaction could fit that definition, although that does not seem to ever be the case for SARS-CoV-2 and other human coronaviruses. (I haven't listened to the episode yet, but a recent paper found that some people's T cells are effective enough to significantly decrease the chance they will get symptoms from SARS-CoV-2.) Antibodies and memory B cells (which produce antibodies after detecting a previously seen infection) are also involved and may be more important in other viruses---and are easier to study so they get more press---but do not appear to be the primary part of the immune system preventing severe disease from SARS-CoV-2, although the short boost in antibodies from the vaccines are what caused the temporary protection from infection that was observed with the vaccines.

My information comes from listening to the podcast This Week in Virology, which is a group of virology researchers discussing papers. Specifically, you can look in their archives for episodes tagged t cells. Although it's a podcast, each episode has a summary page of what was discussed and links to the papers. They recommend using the YouTube speech-to-text feature if you want a transcript.

This is false. Needless to say, we don't have studies (at least not ones we trust) on the effectiveness of the vaccines China used. But we do have studies showing the ones the United States used remain highly effective against severe disease and death.

There's actually some weak evidence the Omicron-updated vaccines are worse against Omicron because we made them a half dose of the old vaccine and a half dose of the Omicron-adjusted version, which might be more similar to giving the vaccine at a half dose. (There is evidence the updated vaccine did a better job of protection against infection for Omicron... but it was never very high, never lasted very long, and the study suggested the currently circulating variants have drifted far enough that there's no measurable protection against infection anymore... probably will see a slight bump with the next formula update, but that's mostly a research curiosity.)

continued to have prominent "Thank you for wearing a mask!" decals on the door

I see a lot of those signs around and very few people wearing masks. At least that wording doesn't imply that you're required to wear a mask, but it's still weird and annoying to have those signs up if they don't mean it. Especially since some spaces actually do require masks, but the signs are everywhere, so they're meaningless.

I still haven't heard a remotely sane answer for why vaccines had to be agonisingly slowly tested while the bodies piled up, because mumble mumble bioethics consent

It sounds like you think the vaccine trials could have gone faster by doing challenge trials? I'm not sure that's true, but even if we could have gotten the vaccines approved faster, I'm not sure that would have sped up the rollout much: for several months after approval, they were hard to get because there just weren't enough doses manufactured (first doses in around December 2020, took until May or June to really get everyone access (so by then the prioritized high-risk groups had gotten access); and that was with throwing money at ramping up manufacturing before approval). Maybe there was some way to throw even more money at manufacturing them faster, but my understanding is that really wasn't the case since there were supply chain issues like suddenly needing a lot of specialized machines for vaccine manufacturing, and ramping all of that up could only happen so fast.

And that's not even accounting for the potential absolute disaster of rolling a vaccine out to everyone that didn't actually work, or worse, actually was dangerous, which, in addition to the first-order effects, could have super-charged the anti-vaccine movement.

I'm confused. I didn't reply to your comment and I don't see how your other comments in this thread relate.

Despite your woke-as-religion argumentation, you seem to be missing the "Original Sin"-analogue: a major part of the woke worldview is that everyone has internalized biases and everyone should be a work-in-progress of improving themselves by trying to reduce those biases but they will never be 100% successful. From this assumption, they conclude that attempts to ignore group identities will inevitably fail and that creating an unbiased system out of biased individuals requires explicit attention to bias.

The economics of streaming services have always seemed really weird to me. The incentives for the services are for consumers to subscribe for as many months as possible and watch as few shows as possible (zero, optimally). That doesn't seem like a formula likely to lead to high-quality shows, and yet Netflix, Amazon, and Apple have all produced a fair amount of high-production-value (i.e. at least expensive, if not to your taste) shows. I can't see how that can be sustainable for companies where they don't get any direct payments in exchange for making good shows. This feels like the stage in taking over a market segment where the companies produce high-quality products cheaply to gain market share / starve out competitors before slowly getting worse.

It doesn't seem to be possible to fund TV shows via a more direct "customers pay for the show" model for whatever reason (probably too much up-front cost, so it would look like a really expensive Kickstarter campaign trading on the reputation of the show runners with a release 1-2 years after payment?), so I don't have a better idea, unfortunately.

A key demand has been surrounding generative AI. Actors do not want companies to create their own AI replicas of actors, nor to use generated voices and faces.

I'm having trouble finding the demands actually clearly stated, but everything I've seen has been about actors not wanting companies to create their own AI replicas of actors without paying actors royalties for using them or allowing any limitations or creative control over how they are used (e.g., so it could be legally used to fake up video of the actor supporting any product or political position).

As a pure, "don't use AI at all" claim, this doesn't actually make sense. Why would the studios want to make AI replicas of minor actors no one can recognize when they can use generative AI to create virtual actors that look like no real person? Either (1) they're seriously trying to claim the right to not pay big stars for AI replicas, (2) they want AI replicas of everyone who might one day be famous, or (3) they are worried about the legality of existing AI systems and want a data source they know they have rights to.

(Of course, while deep fakes do already exist, there's also the complication that this contract negotiation has to cover future AI technology that doesn't exist yet, so it's hard to be precise about exactly what uses they're worried about.)

This chart

Your link is broken since Twitter blocked non-logged-in users, so I can't use Nitter to view it. I did try to use a Twitter login I had lying around and the page wouldn't actually load.

Let us not mince words: the role of holistic college admissions is to examine people as whole individuals, to account for every second of their lives and every bit of their cultural context, and to rank them from best to worst. Or, more precisely: to justify and to reify the values Harvard and its co-luminaries use to select best and worst.

No, it isn't. And you clearly show in the rest of your post that you know this is not true. Harvard is not taking a ranked list of individuals and selecting the best N from the list and accepting them or trying the compute the equivalent. They are trying to select the best student body of consisting of N individuals. I'm sure they have some rather high minimum quality bar to be considered, but after that, they're optimizing for group dynamics and various axes of diversity.

Now, if only there was a way to live in the Bay Area without fighting junkies and opioid zombies..

I'm honestly not sure if this is a joke or not. But if it isn't: you don't have to do anything special to avoid that in the Bay Area. If you're in the areas frequented by street homeless people, there's a lot more of them than there were a decade or two ago, but you can just ignore them.

On the other hand, the cost of living compared to the salaries in the Bay Area seems like a pretty bad deal, so I wouldn't recommend living there if you don't have a good reason to do so.

I'm not sure how much it makes sense to use polling data to predict other kinds of events. My understanding is that using polling to predict elections makes sense because you're essentially running the election early on a sample, so going from there to estimating the election results is what statistics is good at. And there are a lot of polls on elections people care about so you have enough data to do something with.