@ymeskhout's banner p
BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				

				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

				

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				
				
				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

That's a crazy case, I never heard of anything like that before. At least at the federal level, the maximum penalty for refusing to obey an order is 6 months. It's 18 months if you refuse to testify in front of a grand jury. So maximum limits can be one option for mitigating the potential of abuse.

My favorite case in this genre comes from when our boy Rudy was still a federal prosecutor back in 1985. Four people robbed a bank of $11M, but one of them was acquitted at trial. They only recovered $1 million and so the last guy was ordered to testify where the money was, and since he was acquitted he had no right to remain silent. He refused, the court jailed him for contempt, but eventually reluctantly had to release him because:

I am equally satisfied that he spoke the truth when he told me that he would stay in jail as long as I deemed necessary, but would in no event respond to the government's demand that he testify. His motives are clearly ignoble (the desire ultimately to obtain the fruits of his friends' criminal activity), but that is beside the point. I cannot conscientiously find that there is any realistic possibility that further confinement will induce testimony.

To clarify, the clerk talked about here is for Judge Engoron in the New York civil fraud case. His gag order was issued orally and only restricts "personal attacks on my members of my court staff", it doesn't even prevent Trump from shit-talking the judge. Do you think this order is constitutionally overbroad?

I don't understand this worldview. Are you implying that we have somehow fallen from grace compared to our hallowed past? The law has always been whatever [insert powerful institution] says it is, and that's always been overridden by whoever has the biggest gun. Genuinely, when has this never been the case in human history? If you want to argue that it has gotten worse, then I'm very curious to hear your evidence.

"Reasonably foreseeable witnesses or the substance of their testimony" could include a vast number of people - what's to say Chutkan can't come down on him for even the mildest political attack ad by saying that Biden is a potential witness for the prosecution?

I agree this includes a vast number of people, and that's one reason I don't support this part of the order. For context, it bears mentioning that Trump is absolutely being treated with kid gloves on by the system. You can ask any defense attorney what would happen to their regular joe client if they started attacking the prosecutor, the judge, the clerk, or any of their families. It's absolutely inconceivable that any random schmo pulling that would not be jailed immediately. Courts routinely and reflexively keep people behind bars ahead of their trial date for things far more petty. I remind you that there's 400k people in jail right now in the US who haven't been convicted of a crime yet, some absolutely because they're too dangerous to be let out, and some because they can't scrounge the $100 needed to bail out).

I think this is a reasonable position. My pushback is that the purpose of gag orders are to prevent the harm before it happens, rather than punish it afterwards. As @AshLael echoes, witness intimidation is extremely difficult to prove. The only times I've ever seen charges filed for this is when the guy was dumb enough to threaten a witness on a recorded jail phone call. Other times, witnesses refuse to testify fairly commonly. They either just make themselves difficult to reach, or outright refuse (one guy told the prosecutor in one of my cases out right "That's my aunt, I'm not testifying against her" and they dropped the charges even though there's no nephew/aunt privilege). So if a witness is unavailable, we very often have no idea exactly why.

The other issue gets into how gag orders are enforced. This is generally shuffled under the broad "contempt" power of the court, and overwhelmingly the punishment for violating a court order is either a revocation/modification of your pretrial release conditions (as happened with SBF) in criminal trials, or monetary penalties or default judgments in civil cases. Outside of the pretrial release context, actually jailing someone who violates a court order is extremely rare, and that's because generally as soon as the threat to liberty looms over someone then they're entitled to an attorney and due process protections similar to an actual trial (jurisdictions vary on this). A gag order or the like sidesteps some of those concerns by warning the person ahead of time that they'll be punished if they do X, and knowing that they're being watched tends to have good dissuasion power on its own.

Setting aside the difficulty in proving witness intimidation, there's going to be a calculus on the part of the defendant. For your "criminal enforcement" plan to work, the penalty for witness intimidation has to be at least as bad as the crime they're accused of, and then you have to add more time to factor in the chance they won't get caught. If the crime is already a life sentence, then there's no deterrence to witness intimidation. That's why courts deal with this concern in criminal trials by just keeping the person in custody before the trial. Again, better to prevent it from happening than try to punish after the fact.

So overall I don't see a practical solution to this concern except through a pre-emptive order.

So to avoid the common pitfalls in discussions like this, set aside Trump for a moment. Should judges have any authority to impose gag orders? If so, what limits should be in place? After working out the questions in theory, how does your position apply to Trump?

I never clerked but yes I totally agree, I said Trump's post about the clerk was totally inane. Judge Engoron's gag order was remarkably restrained.

I recognize that I'm not Trump's target audience for these types of antics but for me it just emphasizes how much he's flailing in that case. He can't plausibly claim that his 10,000 square foot apartment is actually 3 times that, so he just lashes out at random nobodies. Presumably he's trying to paint a vast conspiracy levied against him but I don't understand how anyone can be convinced of that with the photo he posted.

Trump got hit by two gag orders from two different judges. The precedent in this area of law is severely underdeveloped, both because so few defendants get gagged, and of those who do very few have the resources or energy to mount an appeal. Jacob Sullum writes a great overview of the issue:

U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan, who is presiding over Donald Trump's trial on federal charges related to his attempted reversal of Joe Biden's 2020 election victory, yesterday imposed a gag order that bars the former president from "publicly targeting" witnesses, prosecutors, or court personnel. Trump lawyer John Lauro vigorously opposed the order on First Amendment grounds, saying it would stop his client from "speak[ing] truth to oppression." While that characterization exaggerates the order's impact, constraining the speech of a criminal defendant, especially one who is in the midst of a presidential campaign, does raise largely unsettled constitutional issues.

Chutkan's order was provoked by Trump's habit of vilifying anyone who crosses him, including Special Counsel Jack Smith ("deranged"), the prosecutors he oversees (a "team of thugs"), and Chutkan herself (a "highly partisan" and "biased, Trump Hating Judge"). "IF YOU GO AFTER ME, I'M COMING AFTER YOU!" Trump wrote on Truth Social after his indictment in this case. The next day, The New York Times notes, "a Texas woman left a voice mail message for Judge Chutkan, saying, 'If Trump doesn't get elected in 2024, we are coming to kill you, so tread lightly.'"

So to avoid the common pitfalls in discussions like this, set aside Trump for a moment. Should judges have any authority to impose gag orders? If so, what limits should be in place? After working out the questions in theory, how does your position apply to Trump?

I think gag orders can be appropriate in a very limited set of circumstances. For example let's say a newspaper owner is charged with murder in a small town. He should always have the absolute and unrestricted right to discuss the allegations against him and mount a defense in public. There are some areas where it starts to get cloudy for me, like for example if he hires an investigator (legal & appropriate) to dig into the history of the main witness against him (legal & appropriate) and he gets his hands on her diary (potentially legal & potentially appropriate). He then spends the lead-up to the murder trial publishing massive coverage the lurid details of all her sex kinks and fantasies, which isn't implicated in the murder charges. To me this starts to look like witness tampering/intimidation, where the defendant is humiliating a witness with the intent to discourage her from giving testimony.

So my answer is here would be yes, judges can impose gag orders but they should be extremely narrow. The operating principle should be to always allow defendants to discuss the direct charges against them, including the ability to discredit witness credibility. There's a blurry line between when someone is discrediting a witness on relevant matters, and when they're just trying to make their life hell to discourage them from testifying. An example of this blurry line is what happened to SBF, where his pretrial release was revoked in part because he leaked Caroline Ellison's diary to the NYT and because he seemed to have been coordinating testimony with FTX's general counsel.

So with that out of the way, how does it apply to Trump? Judge Chutkan's order restricts him from making statements that "target" the prosecutor, court staff, and "reasonably foreseeable witnesses or the substance of their testimony". Practically speaking, it goes without saying that it's a terrible idea to talk shit about the court or prosecutor while your case(s) is pending. There are some obvious areas where Trump's commentary is inane and irrelevant, like posting a photo of a judge's law clerk and claiming she's "Schumer's girlfriend", or posting about the prosecutor's family members. Discrediting witnesses is harder to draw a clean line on, because again there's a gradient between discrediting and intimidating. I think Trump should have the absolute and unrestricted right to discuss any of his charges and discredit any evidence and witnesses against him. While I disagree with that part of the ruling, I don't know how I would rephrase that clause, and so my reaction is that in these close cases we should default to allowing speech rather than restricting it.

Edit: @guajalote changed my mind on the propriety of Judge Engoron's order prohibiting "personal attacks on my members of my court staff". I agree that criticizing government officials should always be protected, even if the speech is targeting irrelevant or uninvolved individuals. A narrower order prohibiting incitement would've been more appropriate.

Maybe! I don't know what the future holds or why SCOTUS decided to take this case so quickly after Bruen. If the goal of the pro-gun Justices was to strike down the DVRO ruling, it highlights the absence of a coherent position on this issue. I'm against categorical prohibitions (like banning all felons from possessing a gun, no matter how old or non-violent their charge is) but open to individualized prohibitions (like disarming someone experiencing psychosis) and this would actually be in accord with some early history of gun prohibition in this country. I'm not sure the pro-gun Justices are willing to bite the bullet on this one, so I won't be surprised with future 2A rulings that are the equivalent of "guns are a right, but not like that!"

Excellent pushback as always! There is indeed active belligerent resistance. The reason I am still hopeful is that prohibitions like the felon-in-possession were treated as sacrosanct for decades and had virtually no judges willing to even entertain the notion. I know the bar is low but the fact that the edifice is being chipped away even for bad optics cases like someone subject to a DVRO is groundbreaking stuff. I would have never predicted that to be on the table a few years ago.

You're correct, that was an error on my part. I'm now very curious as to how difficult to prove those cases. And since it's a federal prohibition and universal background checks are a state law, that would add another hurdle for enforcement.

Excellent overview. DVROs can also be imposed as part of a standard practice whenever someone is charged with a DV crime. Defendants are then placed in an awkward position if they're asked whether they're following the court's order. There was court in Washington state that issued a ridiculously long and thorough decision on this issue, ruling that this type of practice was a clear violation of the defendant's right not to testify against themselves.

I'm in a state with universal background checks, and virtually all the guns that get recovered from crime scenes had been reported stolen eons ago. If the cops find a non-stolen gun, they nominally have the ability to retrace its journey by using the serial number to look up the FFL paperwork. In practice, they tend to find absurdly long gaps in the record. The guy with the gun can just say his uncle gave him the gun years ago, and it's near impossible for a prosecutor to refute that. The "family member" transfer exceptions are a huge loophole since a cousin can gift a gun to their cousin who gives it to their cousin etc. and even if that happened 100 times it would still be perfectly legal. Also, most states don't have universal background checks! So someone potentially could just say "I acquired this through a private sale when I was driving through Ohio" [Edit: woops, I was wrong about this h/t @The_Nybbler] and good luck refuting that.

I agree with you that blue states and jurisdictions continue to try their hardest to gum up the works, I cited several examples in my last paragraph. Do you think any solution is possible?

For me I think the problem is that none of the conservatives on the court really wants unrestricted firearm ownership. Obergefell's ruling is very simply stated: you cannot deny marriage to gay couples. In contrast there is no similarly bright line rule applicable to 2A. Bruen still requires a meandering and torturous analysis about finding historical analogues and then squinting to determine if it's close enough. On top of that the opinion is littered with arbitrary exceptions about "sensitive places", and while Bruen mostly dodged the question about felon-in-possession, other courts seized upon the Heller language about "law-abiding citizens" to imply that felon-in-possession laws are still valid.

You could issue a ruling that just says "No one can ever be prohibited from possessing a firearm" and "No places can ever prohibit possessing a firearm" and that wouldn't have any ambiguity at all. Except there's no appetite for allowing criminals the right to open-carry in courtrooms, and so we're stuck with this twisted flowchart instead.

You present a cogent argument for narrowly interpreting 2A. For this to make sense though, you have to interpret "the right of the people" in 2A to really mean "the right of the States" and that's when you run into big problems. If you read the rest of the Constitution and the Bill of rights, there's multiple references to "the people" and none of them make sense with that substitution. Consider 1A ("...or the right of the States peaceably to assemble") or 4A ("The right of the States to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures") or the neglected 10A which explicitly distinguishes States from the people. It seems odd to me to think that the Founders were willing to throw casual usage of the people all over the place, but when they wrote 2A they meant it in this very specific way and didn't bother putting an asterisk or anything.

The first time was in 1910 and the Speaker filed a Motion to Vacate against himself. Basically he was daring unruly representatives to challenge him publicly, and ultimately they fell in line. Couldn't be farther from our present situation.

Goddamn that's a baller move

Clarence Thomas's Gun Control Snare

So the Bruen decision came out more than a year ago, and it has scrambled how courts deal with gun control laws.

Step back first. The way courts typically evaluate laws that putatively infringe on a constitutional right was through an analysis called strict scrutiny. Basically, take any constitutional guarantee ("Congress shall make no law...abridging the freedom of speech...") and add an "...unless it has a really good reason!" exception. This isn't an exaggeration. Courts were allowed to give the government a free pass on constitutional infringements provided the state's efforts were "narrowly tailored" and "necessary" to achieve a "compelling state interest".

But what counts as a compelling reason? Who decides which laws are narrowly tailored? It's judges, all the way down. For something like freedom of speech, there's a robust enough appreciation that you can expect a reasonable amount of skepticism among the judicial corps against efforts by the government to muzzle expression. In practice, strict scrutiny generally functioned as decently high threshold, unlike its contrasting rational basis test which practically was a free pass for the government to do whatever.

But what about topics a little more heated, like guns? Judges have been squishier and far more willing to accept the government's justifications that a given legal restrictions was "necessary". Hell, some judges even weaseled their way into ditching strict scrutiny in favor of the more permissible intermediate scrutiny. Judge VanDyke of the 9th Circuit lampooned this doormat reflex in his 2022 McDougall dissent (cleaned up):

Our circuit has ruled on dozens of Second Amendment cases, and without fail has ultimately blessed every gun regulation challenged, so we shouldn't expect anything less here. As I've recently explained, our circuit can uphold any and every gun regulation because our current Second Amendment framework is exceptionally malleable and essentially equates to rational basis review.

The cases VanDyke cited illustrate the problem well. The 9th Circuit has ruled it's ok to require people to demonstrate either "good cause" or "urgency or need" to the government before they're allowed to carry a gun outside their home. Set aside whatever negative sentiments you might have about guns, and instead imagine the reaction if similar restrictions were imposed on newspaper licenses. Imagine having to convince a cop that you have "good cause" to start a blog. Constitutional guarantees are worthless if they're predicated on a government agent agreeing that your reason for exercising them is good enough.

The practice of circuit judges shrugging off challenges to gun control laws with "I don't know man this seems totally reasonable to me" went on for several years, and I can only imagine it pissed off the pro-2A wing of the Supreme Court. Sure, Trump's appointments eventually meant they had the numbers on their side and so a very favorable 2A opinion was inevitable, but a stern rebuke of "We really mean it this time!" didn't seem like it was going to work in getting the circuit courts to stop fucking around.

So when they finally got their chance, SCOTUS tried a different approach. Instead of just triple-underlining and double-highlighting the words STRICT SCRUTINY, Clarence Thomas writes the majority opinion that created a brand new analysis wholly unique to the Second Amendment: gun control laws can only be constitutionally permissible if they're consistent with "historical tradition of firearm regulation." Any law being evaluated must therefore have a historical analogue, and the closer the analogue was to the year 1791 (when 2A was ratified), the better.

I was thrilled with Bruen's result, but puzzled by its reasoning because it seemed to just recreate the circumstances that led to the "fake strict scrutiny" problem. It turns out Bruen had way more of an effect than I anticipated. Clarence Thomas is a fascinating figure in many ways, in part because he's America's most powerful black conservative, who just happens to draw direct inspiration from the black nationalism Malcolm X espoused. I have no idea if this was intentional, but Thomas laid out a beautiful carpet of caltrops that the government couldn't help but step on over and over again.

What followed Bruen was a litigation maelstrom. Government attorneys across the land scoured dusty historical tomes, in search of whatever they could get their hands on and use as justification. The first problem they ran into was there just weren't that many laws on the books around the time of the Founding, let alone laws that specifically governed firearms. Generally speaking, Americans were free to strut about town with their muskets in tow, no questions asked. The lawyers had to cast a ever-wider net to snag anything relevant, desperately expanding their search way beyond 1791 to include things like an English prohibition on "launcegays" from 1383. When they did find timely laws, they ran into a second and far more pressing problem: the laws regulating firearm possession were...awkward. Really awkward.

Judge Benitez overseeing the ongoing Duncan case ordered the state lawyers to compile a list of every single relevant law they could find, and the 56-page spreadsheet they created is incredible. It's not surprising to find governments actively disarming disfavored groups, it's another to see the arbitrariness outlined so starkly. Modern gun control critics have regularly pointed out how skewed enforcement can be, particularly along racial lines. And because Bruen requires historical analogues, lawyers defending gun control restrictions had no choice but to immerse themselves unhappily within its sordid origin story.

Numerous early laws specifically prohibited only "negroes, mulattos, or Indians" from carrying firearms (1792 Virginia law, 1791 Delaware law, 1798 Kentucky law, etc.), or specifically targeted only slaves (1804 Indiana law, 1804 Mississippi law, 1818 Missouri law, etc.). California had it out particularly for those with "Spanish and Indian blood" (aka what the law called 'Greasers') and prohibited them from possessing firearms in 1855. These are all laws favorably cited in courts today.

When tasked to defend §922(g)(3), the law that prohibits anyone who is an "unlawful user" of a controlled substance from owning a gun, government lawyers tried their best with what little they had. The closest analogues they could find were colonial laws that prohibited actively drunk people, "dangerous lunatics", or what they termed "unvirtuous citizens" from possessing a gun. And you know that's BASICALLY the same thing as preventing the occasional marijuana smoker today from ever having a gun. The judge wasn't convinced.

After languishing in a stalemate for decades, the legal precedent around gun laws has dramatically changed in very quick order thanks to Bruen. Prohibitions on drug users were struck down, a (limited) prohibition for non-violent felons was struck down, and so were prohibitions on individuals subject to domestic-violence restraining orders (for now...). Courts are normally slow to move, but these developments have happened at blazing speed, and it's only the beginning as there's still plenty of ongoing litigation.

None of this means that gun control advocates have given up, far from it! @gattsuru has extensively catalogued numerous ways anti-gun politicians and judges putting in absolutely heroic efforts to gum up the machinery, however they can. Judge VanDyke publicly accused his colleagues on the 9th Circuit of some robe & dagger procedural shenanigans putting the thumb on the scale in the Duncan case. Meanwhile, legislation of dubious constitutionality gets passed faster than it can be struck down and the NYPD is somehow approving fewer gun permits than before (maybe because their approval stamp fell behind a desk, or something?). The efforts Gattsuru highlighted are definitely a hurdle but we'll see if they're the beginning of a new stalemate, or just desperate cadaveric spasms. For now, I'm going to continue enjoying the spectacle of government lawyers arguing with a straight face to a judge that pot smokers are the historical equivalent of dangerous lunatics.

I'm confused because this is how @raggedy_anthem described "Neighbor"'s behavior:

My husband and I introduced ourselves to a new neighbor while he was working on his car on the sidewalk. We were hoping to establish enough of a rapport to ask him to stop parking illegally, blocking the whole sidewalk, and leaving the trash from his car detailing in our garden bed. Perhaps someday we can even talk politely to him about the broken bottles and used condoms we clean up after his hangouts with his friends. When we gave him our names and asked for his, he refused to even look us in the face. He mumbled that we could call him "Neighbor."

...and I don't see any felonious conduct described. You did say in your comment that his homicide should be excused if it happened as a result of him menacing your wife but a) raggedy_anthem never described any menacing and b) menacing would presumably already be covered under current laws governing justifiable homicide. So in terms of proposed policy changes, I'm not understanding what you want to be different.

You're right, that did happen in some places. I was pushing back on the idea that it was the primary business plan, by highlighting what the law actually was in major cities when they entered the scene.

I agree with the commentators that dispute calling Uber a fraud. Further, you also gloss over just how much of a legal grey area they operating in when they started. New York City is famous for its highly restricted taxi licensing, but even there you've always had the ability to schedule a pre-arranged ride through private livery drivers. This was referred to as "black car service" because the market tended to favor high-end vehicles driven by dressed-up chauffeurs. The big advantage for a taxi license was the ability to pick up customers through street hails or cabstands, and so there wasn't much of a conflict or overlap between the two markets. They existed more-or-less in harmony for decades because "calling ahead" was too much of a pain in the ass and too bougie to be a threat to the taxi industry.

Obviously that changed with smartphones. Suddenly the ability to "call a car" became way way easier, and taxis had the right to worry but they couldn't do shit about it. The regulations that allowed pre-arranged rides existed for decades did not have a "unless pre-arranging gets too easy!" clause. On top of that, Uber's business model had additional layers of protection because of their defense of "We don't own or operate any 'taxis' that's crazy, we just connect you with 'drivers' who will take you places". Taxi companies desperately tried to sue Uber for numerous violations, but they lost every single lawsuit.

Hat trick club

So what standards do you want the state to use in determining which homicides it should let stand?

The Free Heroin Clinics that currently exist in Switzerland are only open to clients as a last resort if other treatment plans have failed. I couldn't find much data on cessation, but also the primary goal of heroin-assisted treatment is the dreaded "harm reduction" buzzword which includes reducing overdoses, reducing crime, and freeing up addict's time to maybe become a normal part of society. Maybe that helps some people quit, but it's perfectly possible for some clients to have no interest in being opioid-free and just remain in the program indefinitely.

The yearly cost FYI for HAT is around $13k/year, or about 3x what methadone programs cost, namely due to the higher staffing required.

Thanks, this shifts my belief towards accepting "tough on crime" as the more likely explanation.

The Transcription tab should be visible now, not sure what happened

That's an accurate breakdown, but how will people pay for the protection agencies? They can have varying levels of protection available, but if someone is poor enough (or the services are expensive enough) what options do they have?