@ymeskhout's banner p
BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				

				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

				

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				
				
				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

While I am certainly unhappy about the enforcement of gender roles, I’m also unhappy about being born into a physical sex without having the ability to change it. There’s a number of physical differences between men and women, the biggest being the reproductive system and physical characteristics.

Ok? I'm unhappy that we can't fly, that we age, and that we can't eat and talk at the same time. In the context of decrying the sex-change limitation as "morally abhorrent and the equivalent to a dystopian caste system" you make it sound like an artificial man-made limitation rather than just a reflection of reality's limitation. I find this particular thread confusing.

But as a trans woman, I’ve dated feminine-attracted bisexual men and get treated completely differently. I’ll admit I do enjoy the gender roles when it comes to relationships; I like masculine men who know how to flirt and seduce me, who take me out on dates, make me feel safe and protected, find me attractive as a feminine person, and want to have sex with me the way a straight man wants to have sex with a woman.

I appreciate the insight into your experience here. I had a trans friend describe her motivation for physical transition as an exercise in signaling — the equivalent of a hat that says "please be patient I have autism" but for her it communicates something like "speak to me in a softer and less rowdy tone". It sounds very similar to what you're describing here. There are gender roles that you find yourself drawn to, but they're not adequately communicated to others if you presented as a man. Accordingly, your feminine appearance serves as a billboard-size instruction manual to others on how you prefer to be interacted with in the context of relationships.

Is that a fair paraphrasing? As a masculine presenting male, I can still empathize with this experience and the difficulties it may generate because I also prefer typical gender role dynamics. I enjoy being assertive and dominant in my dating relationships and tend to date feminine women. It's very easy to advertise my preferred approach given the way I look. I imagine if my preferences were more submissive I'd probably would want it reflected in my expression somehow (though that wouldn't explain to me wanting/needing to identify as a completely different gender).

Yeah, I completely do not understand it. It seems like if anything, even a high-quality phalloplasty "penis" would just be a constant reminder of all the other things you can never have, no matter how much cash you sink into it. I once attended a queer-friendly amateur porn festival and one of the entries involved a transman with a hormonally-enlarged clitoris "fucking" a tiny fleshlight all while saying things like "yeah take that big dick yeah". I was deeply disturbed by the delusion on display (and also by the tiny fleshlight).

Yeah, ditto. Given the current state of technology, I'd make for an extremely ugly transwoman given my current male body and bald head. That combined with the complete lack of articulable benefits (see OP) are more than enough to make this an obvious decision. But if I somehow hypothetically woke up as a female with near-equivalent status/benefits to what I currently enjoy now as a male, part of me would be thrilled at the unique perspective on the human condition I'd have access to. For the same reasons as before, I'd like make for an ugly transman in that hypothetical scenario (testosterone makes it much much easier to pass) and I wouldn't be able to articulate any reasons for the transition.

The problem with Ozy's argument is that it's pure question begging. It boils down to flatly asserting that some people absolutely 100% experience this super deep "internal gender feeling" and if you don't well then that just means you're "cis by default" and you'll never understand what this (absolutely not made up!) experience feels like. It's completely unfalsifiable; the argument defines refutation as literally impossible. And even within this rubric, Ozy runs into other problems once they realize that "not having internal gender feeling" applies to cis people and also to this other (absolutely not made up) class of people called agender. Does this mean that cis people are just agender? No, absolutely not, because Ozy asserts "of course agender people are not cis." How do we know that's true? It just is! Agender people will tell you as much!

How do any of these flat-out assertions help convey any insight or information? It's indistinguishable from religious awakening stories about how you can believe in god if only you'd open your heart and pray.

I've said before that my response to "what if you woke up as a woman?" would be "am I hot?" because that would be far far more consequential on whether I would enjoy the experience or not. If yes, then goddamn that would be such an enlightening scenario to experience. I have no interest in dicks now but hell I might even fuck a dude just to see what the hype is all about.

I too feel absolutely nothing about sports, but there's nothing inscrutable about a sports fan experience to me. I can understand "excitement" and "emotional investment" and "suspense" and then draw parallels from there, and crucially I can make predictions (Bob will be sad if his team loses). There are no equivalent parallels available to describe the alleged "gender identity incongruence" (or as I argued in the OP, there are no ways to describe it that don't sound idiotic and regressive) but Ozy uses this inability to convey this experience to double down on the entire enterprise by claiming that some people are just incapable of understanding.

Interestingly enough, I don't know if you noticed the contradiction in your post about "gender euphoria". I too share a love for firearms and yes, that hobby is indeed male-coded as hell. You know what else is male-coded as hell? Sports! If firearm enthusiasm can give you gender euphoria, would it not follow that the absence of sports enthusiasm would give you gender dysphoria? The lack of consistency there indicates that the euphoria might not necessarily be predicated on how congruent your enthusiasm is with accepted gender conventions.

(funny enough, transwomen have been a ridiculously disproportionate portion of my shooting range partners)

I don't claim to have any unique insights into physical gender dysphoria, so there's not much more for me to say except to acknowledge the distress is real and to advocate treating the condition the same we treat other types of physical dysphoria. I've already conceded that body modifications are not necessarily reliant on stereotypes.

You're right that our ability to change society and its gendered expectations is virtually nil. But what you described as the equivalent of a "dystopian caste system" wasn't the caste system itself, but rather the inability to change castes (Imagine if we applied that standard to actual dystopian caste systems, like India's, where the first line of criticism is decrying the inability for Untouchables to self-identify as Brahmins).

Based on how you describe "opting out" of sex, it sounds like you're using 'sex' to mean 'gender role' rather than referring to gamete size like I am. Correct me if I'm wrong but if so then I would be very curious to know what exactly you mean when you say that you had "no choice to opt out or change or try other [gender role] options". What exactly did you want but were unable to have prior to transitioning? What exactly were you able to gain only after transitioning? I'm very curious to know!

Ah that makes more sense, I misunderstood

I saw the note that you were not arguing at the object level, I was addressing whether the framework was coherent on its face or even if it's distinguishable from the gender stereotype framework. I don't believe that gender stereotypes are arbitrary or unmoored from reality (they actually tend to be very accurate). So for the same reasons you'd encounter bimodal distribution in mental traits, you'd encounter one for gender stereotypes as well. I don't see how it's possible for either framework to be "objective"; you have to make some discretionary decision about which mental traits to consider and then make some decision about how far of an outlier you need before the category can flip.

None of these scenarios need to be thought of as unique to the trans experience. What if someone wants you to call them a specific nickname and you don't? What if someone wants you to refer to them as Doctor and you don't? What if you go home with someone thinking you're about to have sex but they introduce their husband and try to rope you into a threesome? What if you meet someone from an online dating app and they look nothing like their photos? Etc etc.

As an aside, I find the idea of being unwillingly born into a sex that defines so much of your life, socially and physically, with no choice to opt out or change or try other options, to be morally abhorrent and the equivalent to a dystopian caste system.

I addressed this in my post at length. It sounds like the issue you have is with the societal expectations so I don't understand how transition "solves" the issue. How is your position distinguished from how Iran deals with gender noncomformity?

I agree. I think it's coherent to use "gender" to refer to a role or set of expectations, but that necessarily only exists in other people's perception of you. You can certainly change perceptions, but that's something that needs to be demonstrated, not demanded.

A trans person is someone whose mental traits break from this typical correlation, i.e., their mental traits fall in the opposite mode of the bimodal sexual distribution.

Rebecca Reilly Cooper addressed this in her presentation and I agree with her arguments. The analogy is that while the average man is much taller than the average woman, this doesn't mean that very tall women are therefore men. The logic with this model is so illogical and convoluted that I don't know how to describe it, maybe question begging? It doesn't make sense to create a category on one thing (sex) only to then question someone's membership within that category because they happen to be an outlier on a secondary characteristic.

Historically, male or female would be a genuinely meaningful category that placed certain rights and obligations on you. I'm not sure that the elimination of that has been psychologically good.

I think the nuance here is drawing the meaning more from the specific relevant traits rather than assuming the entire category. I've been involved in fairly tepid scenarios where an amount of physical violence was about to become very necessary and the people you'd want to step up (read: those physically capable of doling out the violence) generally meet their obligation.

You can observe this even in an ideal citizenship scenario. We're not going to expect equal obligations from everyone just because they're a citizen. Rather, we do indeed take into account each citizen's capabilities for what they can contribute (e.g. only men are drafted into military service, but even within the broad 'men' category, we make exceptions for the very young and the very old).

So the distinction I would offer would be "I am stepping up to potentially dole out violence, because I have the physical traits capable of doling out violence" rather than "...because I am a man."

I never understood why anyone finds Ozy's post in any way illuminating:

I think you could probably tell them apart by asking them the old “what would you do if you suddenly woke up as a cis woman/cis man?” If they instantly understand why you’d need to transition in that circumstance, they’re regular old cis; if they are like “I’d probably be fine with it actually,” they might be cis by default. (Of course, the problem is that they might be a cis person with a gender identity who just can’t imagine what gender dysphoria would feel like. Unfortunately, I am not allowed to stick random cis men with estrogen and find out how many of them get dysphoric.)

(I’m noticing some similarities, as I write this, to what I’ve read about what being agender feels like– although of course agender people are not cis. If my agender readers could confirm or deny the similarity, that’d be helpful.)

Ozy doesn't break stride when coming across this apparent contradiction. If you're not ok with the hypothetical, you're "plain old cis". If you are, you are "cis by default". Or maybe you are agender? Who knows let's move on. This is what I meant by "argument by assertion".

As I said a few days ago, the transgender philosophy begins wherever they are and ends wherever they want to be. Applying it to uses outside that scope throws up unanswered questions and contradictions because it wasn't made for more general uses and so it fails in other applications. It was constructed to serve their immediate ends and no more.

Your post describes an extreme level of cynicism that I also happen to share. Very well put. You've established a coherent and plausible explanation for the constant...weirdness in this discourse. But even if I share your cynicism, I still find it worthwhile to take the high-road approach and assume the very very best before I knock it down.

I acknowledge I elided the distinction between a simple preference versus something that interferes with normal living but I don't see why that matters here. All I'm saying is that we have a bunch of conditions that are broadly categorized under the same "unhappiness with one's body" umbrella and there's a wide variance with how much they interfere with everyday living. My argument doesn't hinge on putting "gender identity" in one bucket versus another.

I'm not seeing what's illogical. If they moved too quickly or too aggressively, that would've garnered understandable outrage. But it's also true that they severely undercut their claims of emergency by taking so long. Given those constraints there was no obvious right and wrong decision, they were going to face flak no matter what.

The other explanation for why they took so long to get the documents back is precisely because they wanted to proceed as gingerly as possible. They escalated only after the year-long tactic of "please please please give back the documents" didn't work.

I assumed the issue away for purpose of this post, but I would love to see someone try and defend Trump's obstructionary maneuvering here.

I agree, his inexplicable refusal to return the documents and the comically inept ways he tried to hoodwink his own lawyers are the only distinction anyone really needs.

I too believe Clinton's conduct was abysmal and would've been thrilled to have seen a prosecution on the very obviously sketchy private server affair but Trump's absurdly hilarious comically ham-fisted obstruction attempts are the only aspect you need to draw a distinction.

The law on Reporter's Privilege is inconsistent, and it's weakest when it comes to criminal investigations. Some journalists vow to fight any subpoena they receive for their secret records, but not every subpoena is going to be worth the headache and legal jeopardy.

That being said, the selective enforcement argument does not seem to be very persuasive

I should've made it more obvious that I don't find the selective prosecution arguments at all persuasive (Trump's case can be entirely distinguished with his inexplicable refusal to return the documents and the comically inept manner he tried to hide stuff from his own lawyers). I was trying to steelman the argument and assumed it was true in order to discuss the other question.

I personally would be in favor of far less apprehension with prosecuting government officials. If we assume that Clinton, Biden, etc. all get prosecuted for mishandling records with a similar zeal, how much of an effect would it have in mollifying those that believe Trump is the victim of unwarranted legal action?

I've been ruminating on a question about Trump's prosecution. One of the common arguments I've come across is that prosecuting Trump is improper because it's just political retaliation falsely disguised as a neutral and dispassionate application of the law. In support of this argument, you could cite the fact that the apparent mishandling of government records occurs fairly regularly by similarly-positioned politicians (Clinton, Biden, Pence, etc.) and yet its enforcement appears to be selectively doled out. This is potentially also supported by the fact that, speeding tickets notwithstanding, no other US president (former or sitting) has ever been charged for anything before. The fact that US institutions chose to break such a long-standing norm at this particular moment seems a bit too much of a coincidence to believe it was done with honest motivations.

Assuming all of the above is true, are there any limiting principles? Until something happens for the first time, it remains by definition "unprecedented", so if your rule is based solely on precedence then nothing would ever be allowed to happen unless it has already happened before which doesn't seem workable. Another consideration also is just because something hasn't happened for a very a long time, it doesn't mean it accidentally created an inviolable precedent that can never be broken now. For example, the crime of piracy is one of the few specifically mentioned in the Constitution and it used to be regularly prosecuted way back in the day but there was a very long lull before the feds dusted it off to go after some Somalis.

I don't think anyone would agree that a permanent bar was created, because that would bestow elected officials and political candidates the extra benefit of potentially perpetual & absolute immunity from all criminal liability, including for conduct that happens after they leave office. In its most absurd implementation, this hypothetical system would allow any criminal a "get out of jail" card just by declaring election candidacy.

So if the longstanding norm against prosecution can indeed be broken, then under which circumstances? For Trump's supporters, I suppose one possible answer is that he has been the target of such a relentless and unprecedented avalanche of (presumably bad faith) lawfare — Russiagate, impeachments, etc. — that trust in the system has been depleted to the point that all action against him should be assumed to be ill-disguised political retaliation as a rule. Assuming that's true, then what? Should the rule be that other politicians can be prosecuted but that Trump should have a carve-out in consideration of the unusually aggressive persecution he had to endure? If so, how serious of a crime would this cover? How long should this immunity last for? Should everyone who faces relentless persecution be afforded similar benefits?

I understood this much better after reading the paragraph from your 2016 comment, which I actually agree with completely. I concur there is a glaring hypocrisy with how political leaders get a free pass, in line with a long-standing complaint of mine. That Trump could serve as the mirror to the system's hypocrisy is an incredibly prescient and astute observation of yours.

The only disagreement I have draws on a parallel from my work. I've said many times before that almost all my clients are not just guilty of doing the Thing, but spectacularly obvious about it. It doesn't take any effort from cops to crack the case if (HYPOTHETICALLY) it's a stabbing that occured in broad daylight in view of a dozen cameras, several dozen witnesses, and with the perpetrator yelling his own name. But despite that ridiculous advantage, I still see cops exercise little compunction about violating my clients' rights often for no real benefit, also a long-standing complaint of mine.

The two factors combined often put me in a bind where the cops may have violated my client's rights, but my client was such a dumbass in other ways that I can't do much about it. An illustrative example would be cops coaching a witness to make a false identification about an assault, but my client's well-documented alibi is that he was dealing drugs in another part of town.

That's how I feel about this Trump indictment, did he have to make it so comically easy for the system to go after him?

Amazingly prescient, wow.