I think I understand but not completely, what "contradictions" are you referring to? It seems that you're saying Trump's inevitable impeachment would be a good thing insofar as it would highlight how normally permissive the regime is about prosecuting politicians?
I tackled that with the Facebook feed evolution which used to be plain vanilla chronology for a brief moment IIRC. But pretty much everyone (Twitter, FB, IG, Reddit, etc.) fully embraced algorithm feeds and it has been the de facto standard for a long time now. The only simple feeds that are still popular are podcasts, which are by far the most enduring RSS implementation. I guess email newsletters are another example of a successful simple feed (and somehow key to Substack's success) but I do not understand them and I'm horrified by the thought of cluttering my inbox with hot takes.
Sorry, I don't know which part is confusing. You described a shift in norms about how seriously the prospect of prosecuting politicians used to be treated. I was asking about what you thought contributed to this shift, including asking what you thought the popularity of the "lock her up" chant indicated (e.g. did it contribute towards causing the shift or is it the symptom of something else? etc). Let me know if that makes sense.
none of that justifies actual legal moves against Trump by Democrats in power.
Sure, I never said otherwise. Assuming the shift @ControlsFreak describes is real, I was curious about how it came about. Would you agree that the frequency of the chant contributed something to moving the overton window?
I explain in my other response here. I can't offer a theory for something I don't fully endorse. The purpose of questions is to gain answers, hence why I asked someone who did endorse the theory for an explanation.
That was one theory but I'm open to others, hence the question. Just because I don't mention other explanations doesn't mean I've already dismissed them as possibilities.
I'm not denying your observation, I actually think it's probably true though there are too many variables to control for conclusively. I also agree with you that at least some of the current charges against Trump are questionable (Stormy Daniels hush-money payment is the prime example).
Regardless, I was curious about the progeny of this apparent shift that you describe. Would it be fair to characterize the "lock her up" and "because you'd be in jail" comments as just bloviating on Trump's part? The fact that there's no evidence that Trump tried to push for any prosecution against Clinton while he was in office supports this. Even so, the fact this bloviating was such irresistible ambrosia for his base indicates it was tapping on some deep-seated desire among at least some Americans to prosecute and jail politicians from the other side. Would you agree?
At that point it's an interesting question how much we can blame this on a sort of "lab leak", a meme that went unintentionally viral.
I'm not assuming anything, I'm asking about where this apparent shift came from.
Back in the days before it was fashionable to prosecute Trump and anyone related to Trump, when the possible charges were against Hillary, it was a grave and serious thing to prosecute politicians, especially when they had possible elections in front of them. "That's the stuff of banana republics!" they said. "That's, like, what Putin does!" they said. It was "deeply dangerous for democracy". Whether or not our democracy was legitimate was supposedly hanging in the balance, depending upon whether their preferred candidate was charged with a crime. You don't hear that anymore.
Do you have any theories for why this changed? Were there any chants at political rallies or something agitating for this shift in norms?
This is an elegant explanation of this issue
What juries think is almost irrelevant since only a tiny sliver of cases make it to trial (~2-5%). Criminal history matters because it's the overriding factor prosecutors decide on what to charge and how judge decide on sentencing. People with no record tend to get a lot of leeway for their first crime, with almost everyone giving the benefit of the doubt and assuming it was a freak accident. For repeat offenders it's a lot of "here we go again".
As other posted pointed out, you can't make a quantitative pronouncement about a national system that deals with millions of defendants with just two cases. The theory that black defendants are getting special treatment by the criminal justice system is laughable by national statistics. It also definitely does not match my own caseload even though I'm in a super lefty jurisdiction though my own cases are far from representative (I tend to disproportionately get firearm cases and clients with "difficult" personalities). If I had to conjure up the "perfect" defendant, the biggest decisive factor by a mile would be a clean criminal history. Every other trait is basically noise.
I understand your point better now, thanks for clarifying. The thing to keep in mind here is "memes > societies" have the same tension as "genes > organisms". Genes have an interest in replicating and their "interests" often align with the "interests" of the organism insofar as a healthy organism is more likely to replicate the genes, but not always. Similarly, the interests of memes/ideas and societies will often align insofar as a healthy society is more likely to replicate its driving ideas, but not always. It's important to avoid confusing what the driving force is in each scenario is.
So in your trans/gay example, I agree with you that the sterilization seems like self-sabotage but only if you're considering genes as the unit of inheritance. If you shift your framework to consider the idea as the unit of inheritance, then it doesn't matter if the idea's carrier ends up being a genetic dead-end. Mechanically this is not that different from how deadly viruses work; the goal for the virus is to spread, if the host dies in the process oh well.
That said, I have no idea if that's what's happening in this instance. Trans is too recent a phenomenon to study properly from an evolutionary lens, but homosexuality has been posited to exist because it must confer some indirect advantages (basically, the childless gay uncle becomes free to help raise his nephews). Regarding the topic of immigration, I'm largely in agreement with @atokenliberal6D_4 's take:
Right now, that happens to be egalitarian, individualistic, diversity-focused-melting-pot meritocracy. A modern society's most important resource is it's human talent, the more extreme-outlier the talent is---the Von Neumanns, the Einsteins, the Edisons---the more important. Therefore, the society's values should be focused as much as possible on developing this talent within and converting it from outside. Make sure it can rise from as large a percentage of the population as possible, make sure it's motivated and rewarded as much as possible, make sure that it's as attractive as possible for talent from outside to convert and join, make sure you're looking in varied enough places that you don't miss unexpected sources of talent, etc.
I appreciate the links, I wasn't aware of them. I didn't think that I hit upon anything especially novel but I was surprised that I wasn't able to find a name for this concept (chatGPT kept claiming this is an example of the Marxist idea of "historical materialism" which is not accurate at all).
I agree with your assessment about the current optimal state of affairs, and the potential for that to change.
One of the common complaints about evolutionary psychology is that it presents unfalsifiable "just so" explanations (I linked this above). There's a risk that my argument veers into similarly unfalsifiable territory if I add the disclaimer that my theory is severely under equipped to deal with short-term cultural changes. We're just way too immersed within the soup to be able to tell "why" a cultural trait is spreading.
Similar to genetic natural selection, there are too many possibilities for harmful traits to nevertheless replicate just through random chance. Or sometimes harmful traits replicate because the debilitation they cause make them a reliable signal, known as handicap principle.
Can you be more specific about which ideas you view as similar to sabotage? You're referring to immigration but I'm not quite sure what the contours of your concerns are.
If you're a member of a species whose brains are as big as they are probably mostly due to intra-species conflict, whose civilizations all evolved out of military necessity, advocating for pacifism seems rather against the grain of.. well... everything.
Exactly, I don't disagree. For pacifism as an idea to ever stand a chance to replicate, the circumstances surrounding the necessity of conflict had to change significantly. That was my point.
Do you think it's immoral that corporal punishment has been outlawed?
I don't understand the context you're asking about, the phrase is most often used to refer to school discipline but corporal punishment there remains legal in much of the US. Did you mean for adults? Compared to incarceration, I'm partial to the idea that it can be just as effective a deterrent at a significantly cheaper cost, as evidenced by the use of caning in Singapore.
This is a niggling point but it's hard to wrap my mind around evaluating whether a restriction imposed on the government (outlawing corporal punishment) can be evaluated as a question of morality. It's less about whether it's right or wrong and more about what's effective policy in that case.
I clearly have many strong opinions on a range of subjects, so I don't know why you would think that I'm impartial or prone to equivocation.
Obviously there were some "pioneers" on the question of slavery, and nothing I wrote should imply that morality evolves in uniform homogenous stages. The whole premise of natural selection is variance within the pool.
I should've specified this but when I said slavery became politically untenable I meant it from the standpoint of enforcement costs. Slavery isn't totally "free" and any state that implements it has to wrangle with the serious risk of mass uprising and devote resources to police it. When John Brown conducted his raid in 1859 that was strong evidence that the viral meme of abolition was spreading to infect crazy white guys too, a sign that enforcement costs will continue to mount.
Also, your argument does not explain other phenomena, such as the increase in concern with the human rights of people in far off lands whose oppression, if anything, benefited Western interests economically.
Signaling behavior tends to be more compelling the costlier it is, so that could explain this and value rationality. But similar to genetic evolution, we can apply concepts like spandrels or genetic drift to explain why useless or harmful ideas nevertheless replicate. That's always a possibility when you don't have an intelligent designer at the helm.
I think you're interpreting my use of "accidental" too narrowly, I don't mean it in the sense that things just randomly happen but simply stating that some consequences are collateral and not the central intent. A military conquest doesn't have as its core mission "make sure to kill all the bards and poets that espouse pacifism so that this idea doesn't spread", but nevertheless it will remain a collateral consequence.
I don't think my morality system is opaque, you're welcome to test that by asking me questions. I didn't have any untried/untested morality in mind when I wrote this, primarily I was contemplating how convenient and easy it is for me to oppose slavery given the material comforts I am afforded.
This all has the effect of every trans discussion being several long posts drilling down on what a particular interlocutor actually believes and at some point the thread dies when it becomes necessary for the TRA poster to actually start throwing some of the popular trans movement under the bus for ideological consistency. It's a tactic that produces a movement that can argue for or against anything whenever it is convenient.
Too real. I've had countless conversations with trans people where some variant of "oh haha yeah those people are crazy and don't represent my views at all" comes up. Ok fine but why are those people so prominent? This cannot be explained as just a right-wing ratfucking conspiracy to discredit the movement by signal-boosting the crazies. Because the way these episodes typically play out is that virtually no one from the trans side is willing to scold the crazies publicly and (most pertinently) it's not like there's a coherent explanation or framework for basic questions over what transgender identity even means that everyone can conveniently point to. Even if you take only what the relatively sane authority figures on the trans side say, you still end up with an incoherent and contradictory soup that is impossible to reconcile.
You say that "Hitler was a mess and riddled with countless inexcusable flaws". Can you elaborate on what you mean by flaws? You also praise Hitler for his "fatherly" motivations, which you believe are sincere and unimpeachable. What part of his implementation, if any, do you disagree with?
I interpreted "enemy" to be another word for "opposite interlocutor", doesn't have to be antagonistic
I think the trans movement has a lot of these and it makes it very difficult to argue against either as a whole or in detail.
This is precisely what inspired this post. I had a post sitting in my drafts for months, largely because of an ever-present concern that I was weakmanning or otherwise nutpicking the crazies. I tried to map out the movement and figure out who should be representative, but then even purported authority figures say absolutely insane shit (e.g. the head psychologist of a major hospital's gender clinic talks about babies giving "gendered signals" because they took off a barrette or some shit).
I have no idea who I'm supposed to turn to, so I wrote this instead.
My main confusion with this post, though, is seeming to conflate positions with arguments. The DTP example seems like it refers to different sets of claims of what to do rather than reasons why we should it.
For the DTP example, the issue exists with both positions and arguments. There's the "should we defund the police?" position question, which definitely gets muddled with whether it means "slashing budgets to 0" or just "changing definition of 'police' to no longer include 911 dispatchers". But even if you pick one DTP position and hold it static, there's still going to be sanity variance within the respective arguments, such as "crime will disappear once we get rid of capitalism" versus "there may be downsides but we'd be better off on net without police given that they steal more than robbers do".

I generally agree with your characterization. With regards to which chants become reality, I wouldn't know either. I had a recent post about why some ideas become viral which might explain some of the circumstances.
More options
Context Copy link