Transgenderism is religious dogma taken to its logical extreme. The fundamental thesis of the religion is complete mind body dualism. They see humans as a blank slate soul that randomly attached to a body and thereby has had many constraints and suffering imposed on it. Their goal is to liberate the free soul from the constraints of the physical world. The view can't be understood outside their theology.
As much as I want to avoid weakmanning, this does seem to me to be the most coherent description of gender ideology. People just happen to be born into the "wrong" body (for some reason, don't ask why) which clashes with their innate gendered soul. Thankfully we have medical technology to fix that I guess.
I can confidently say we are in the midst of a full-bore Communist revolution.
What definition of communism are you using?
Even with gibberish like that, a better response would be "I have no idea what that means". That's at least an actionable piece of feedback that you can work with.
From Quillette, an MIT professor describes the outraged reaction from fellow philosophers when he argued that a woman is an adult human female.
Back in 2019 Alex Byrne wrote one of my favorite essays on the incoherence of gender identity and as far as I can tell no one has managed to offer a solid refutation. Byrne follows up by discussing the difficulties he's had in getting a chapter and a book published on the topic, and his travails are equal parts infuriating and hilarious. For example, consider how a fellow colleague was treated once the crowd got wind that her book might be a bit too critical:
The imminent publication of Holly Lawford-Smith's Gender-Critical Feminism was announced that same month, and almost immediately no less than two petitions of complaint appeared, one from the OUP USA Guild (the union representing the New York staff of OUP), and the other from "members of the international scholarly community" with some connection to OUP. The latter petition expressed the scholars' "profound disappointment" at OUP's forthcoming publication of Lawford-Smith's book, and suggested various "measures the press could undertake to offset the harm done by the publication of this work." OUP needed to confess to a mortal sin and repent. None of the scholars had read the book that they so confidently denounced (since no copy of the book was available for them to read), but this is a mere detail.
This trend of protesting a book before anyone even reads it will never stop being funny to me. Byrne expected his book to go through several revisions and by his account he was happy to accomodate feedback. His reviewers, though, were not:
Publishers often commission reviews of a manuscript from (anonymous) experts in the relevant field, and I had to go through that time-consuming process yet again. It was also rather risky, since—as by now you are well aware—the experts in the philosophy of sex and gender tend to brook no dissent. Responding to the (hopeful) publisher’s question, “Will it make for an outstanding book in your view, or simply a work of average quality?”, one expert wrote: “Neither. It is of extremely poor quality.” Another question: “What would you highlight as the ONE feature about this book that might make you recommend it over other titles available?” “None. It shouldn’t be published.” Lastly: “Is there anything superfluous that could be left out?” “Everything—see above.”
Of course, there is nothing wrong with harsh criticism; I have doled out plenty of that myself. Maybe my book deserves it. But a reviewer is expected to give reasons for her verdict—that helps both the author and the publisher. If I had made, as the reviewer said, “sweeping claims” that are “often false,” or had “seriously misunderstood” arguments on the other side, it would be a simple matter to give examples. But the reviewer supplied none: not a single quotation, page number, or chapter reference. From my experience publishing in this particular area of philosophy, this lack of engagement was par for the course. In fact, I found the reviewer’s hyperbolic report reassuring: if I had made mistakes, at least they were not easy to identify.
"What is wrong with my argument?"
"Everything."
"Can you be more specific?"
"Just all of it, it's just bad."
This is the kind of sophistry one would expect from random online arguments, and I'm sure you can identity similar instances even in this very forum. The take-away I'm generally left with is that Byrne's interlocutors are an amalgamation of intellectually fragile individuals. Conclusory statements rather than specifics are a transparent indication that you are aware your arguments will crumble when exposed to a light breeze. Protesting rather than arguing are a transparent indication that you are unable to defend your ideas on their own merits.
All this seems painfully obvious to me as an outsider, and I'm baffled why anyone engages in this ablution pantomime. Who could it possibly convince?
Freddie DeBoer recently put out a banger of a post called "A Conversation About Crime" about the absolute intellectual void behind the "defund the police" movement. The whole thing is worth reading in full, but I'll include the parting shot here:
Look, I’m gonna level with you here. Like the vast majority of leftists who have been minted since Occupy Wall Street, my principles, values, and policy preferences don’t stem from a coherent set of moral values, developed into an ideology, which then suggests preferred policies. At all. That requires a lot of reading and I’m busy organizing black tie fundraisers at work and bringing Kayleigh and Dakota to fencing practice. I just don’t have the time. So my politics have been bolted together in a horribly awkward process of absorbing which opinions are least likely to get me screamed at by an online activist or mocked by a podcaster. My politics are therefore really a kind of self-defensive pastiche, an odd Frankensteining of traditional leftist rhetoric and vocabulary from Ivy League humanities departments I don’t understand. I quote Marx, but I got the quote from Tumblr. I cite Gloria Anzaldua, but only because someone on TikTok did it first. I support defunding the police because in 2020, when the social and professional consequences for appearing not to accept social justice norms were enormous, that was the safest place for me to hide. I maintain a vague attachment to police and prison abolition because that still appears to be the safest place for me to hide. I vote Democrat but/and call myself a socialist because that is the safest place for me to hide. I’m not a bad person; I want freedom and equality. I want good things for everyone. But politics scare and confuse me. I just can’t stand to lose face, so I have to present all of my terribly confused ideals with maximum superficial confidence. If you probe any of my specific beliefs with minimal force, they will collapse, as those “beliefs” are simply instruments of social manipulation. I can’t take my kid to the Prospect Park carousel and tell the other parents that I don’t support police abolition. It would damage my brand and I can’t have that. And that contradiction you detected, where I support maximum forgiveness for crime but no forgiveness at all for being offensive? For me, that’s no contradiction at all. Those beliefs are not part of a functioning and internally-consistent political system but a potpourri of deracinated slogans that protect me from headaches I don’t need. I never wanted to be a leftist. I just wanted to take my justifiable but inchoate feelings of dissatisfaction with the way things are and wrap them up into part of the narrative that I tell other people about myself, the narrative that I’m a kind good worthwhile enlightened person. And hey, in college that even got me popularity/a scholarship/pussy! Now I’m an adult and I have things to protect, and well-meaning but fundamentally unserious activists have created an incentive structure that mandates that I pretend to a) understand what “social justice” means and b) have the slightest interest in working to get it. I just want to chip away at my student loan debt and not get my company’s Slack turned against me. I need my job/I need my reputation/I need to not have potential Bumble dates see anything controversial when they Google me. Can you throw me a bone? Neither I nor 99% of the self-identified socialists in this country believe that there is any chance whatsoever that we’ll ever take power, and honestly, you’re harshing our vibe. So can you please fuck off and let us hide behind the BLM signs that have been yellowing in our windows for three years?
I was wondering why this case hadn't settled earlier, because my assumption was that Fox would've been willing to shed a depressing amount of money to avoid the embarrassing discovery disclosures. All the big pundits appear to have an extremely low opinion of their audience but maybe even that wasn't going to change anyone's mind (curious, has Carlson or Hannity or Ingraham or etc ever comment about those disclosures?). My corollary assumption was that Dominion was seeking vindication because their entire brand had become too toxic to any election official even thinking about using their services, so they had no reason to settle. I figure this settlement finally got high enough for them to quit the business entirely if they need to, and they've basically already got the news coverage they would've dreamed for with the internal text messages they publicized in their motion for summary judgment.
Edit: Jacob Sullum did a great write-up on Fox's unenviable position right before the start of the trial. Their defense was severely constrained. They didn't even try to argue the Dominion claims were true, for obvious reasons. The only plausible saving grace they could've aimed for was the "neutral report privilege" but courts already rejected that defense, I'm guessing because Fox stepped over the line from just reporting that someone made an allegation, to endorsing the allegation itself. So there wasn't much that Fox was left to argue, and the already public evidence was really bad:
As Davis noted, Dominion has presented evidence that many people at Fox were either skeptical of the claims about the company or dismissed them outright. Ten days after the election, Fox's fact-checking "Brainroom" said there was "no evidence of widespread fraud" and "no credible reports or evidence of any software issues." It added that "claims about Dominion switching or deleting votes are 100% false" and called assertions about supposedly deleted Trump votes "mathematically impossible."
Six days later, Fox Corporation Chairman Rupert Murdoch privately called the story "really crazy stuff." That same day in a text conversation with fellow Fox News host Laura Ingraham, Tucker Carlson flatly stated that "Sidney Powell is lying." Ingraham agreed that Powell could not be trusted: "Sidney is a complete nut. No one will work with her. Ditto with Rudy." In a deposition, Fox News host Sean Hannity said he "did not believe" Powell's claims "for a second."
In response to a post-election tweet about "vote dumping" from Maria Bartiromo, fellow Fox News host Brett Baier told Jay Wallace, president and executive editor at Fox News and Fox Business, "none of [it] is true as far as we can tell." In a December 1 email, Baier said Powell's claims "can't be remotely true." Lucas Tomlinson, another Fox reporter, responded that the allegations were "100% not true" and "complete bullshit."
Gary Schreier, second in command at Fox Business, "believed the allegations were false at the time of airing," Davis noted. John Fawcett, an associate producer for Lou Dobbs Tonight, told colleagues that Powell seemed to be "doing lsd and cocaine and heroin and shrooms." In a text to Dobbs, Fawcett suggested that Powell "could be losing her mind." He noted that her story "doesn't make sense" and added, "I just don't think she is verifying anything she is saying." Tiffany Fazio, executive producer of Hannity's show, called Giuliani's account of systematic election fraud "comic book stuff."
Dominion will try to persuade the jury that executives and producers who made such statements should be held responsible for allowing Powell and Giuliani to spout defamatory nonsense. It also will argue that the hosts who gave them a forum should have known better.
"In response to text messages and emails of various FNN [Fox News Network] employees questioning the veracity of the claims," Davis noted, "FNN has generally the same answer to all: FNN was waiting for the evidence. Because the election results would be verified in mid-December, FNN employees believed this was an appropriate length of time to wait and see if that evidence came to light."
Fox also argues that Dobbs and Bartiromo, both of whom seemed to accept Powell and Giuliani's tall tale, were true believers. "Ms. Bartiromo testified that she 'cannot sit here and say [she knows] what happened in the election even to this day,'" Davis noted, quoting Fox's lawyers. "Similarly, Mr. Dobbs still believes the election was stolen."
As Fox sees it, the implication is that Dobbs and Bartiromo neither knew the Dominion story was false nor promoted it "with reckless disregard of whether it was false or not." The latter requires that they "entertained serious doubts as to the truth of [the] publication or had a high degree of awareness of [its] probable falsity." And while other employees were less credulous, Fox argues, it was reasonable for them to keep giving Powell and Giuliani a forum until it was clear that they had no evidence to support their claims.
Normal people routinely reason backwards from their preferred conclusion, and judges are no different. Unfortunately their word is often final, so tough shit. This has been and remains the status quo, and wordy legal analysis can often just be a figleaf facade to obfuscate the real reasons a judge wants to rule a certain way. For example much of 19th century UK law used the generic 'he' pronoun but Parliament passed the Interpretation Act in 1850 that said "Words importing the Masculine Gender shall be deemed and taken to include Females." [So does that mean when the law said that "Every Man shall ... be entitled to be registered as a Voter" meant women could vote? LOL of course not. Ok, so that does that mean a female tavern owner could not be convicted of harboring a prostitute because the law only said 'he'? LOL of course not. They can do what they want because fuck you that's why.
Sometimes judges get caught in an inescapable vice they just can't get out, like the time the 9th Circuit was forced to rule that second-degree murder was not a crime of violence.
[OK, it's slightly more complicated than that. The technical explanation is that under the federal sentencing guidelines, you would get extra time imposed if one of your prior convictions was a "crime of violence", which was defined as a crime that either was "murder" (generically defined) or at least had an element of use of force. The problem is that under some state law, you could be convicted of "felony murder", which does not require use of force, and also does not meet the "generic" definition of "murder".]
FYI you linked my Taibbi/Twitter post, prosecutorial immunity is here
PSA: Reminder that we have a semi-official podcast called The Bailey. Please message me here or email me at ymeskhout@gmail.com if there are any topics you'd like to discuss. Especially so if it's something I've already covered that you disagree with me strongly on, I imagine there would be significant interest in putting me in my place! If it's a topic I'm unfamiliar with, it would be helpful to also suggest discussion compatriots you think would be a good fit.
Maybe one could say that after getting a really good story from Musk Taibbi would be reluctant to hit back at Musk. But you seem to have started the story too soon.
Yes exactly on the first sentence. I don't understand what the last sentence means, too soon for what?
To my knowledge, he has never written about India. Contra your belief, this Indian issue isn’t central to Taibbi’s beat. Taibbi’s beat (if there was one) was how the US government was effectively (with the help of media) circumventing the 1A.
This is a plausible explanation for Taibbi's omission and if he just said "The reason I don't cover the issue is because XYZ" I might be inclined to believe him depending on the reason. That he chooses to stay silent instead makes me suspicious, combined with the other evidence I outlined.
Moreover, as has been pointed out the whole “Indian Twitter story” was a red herring designed to try to ignore Taibbi’s reporting.
Sure, Hasan's intent was probably to find an excuse to ignore Taibbi's reporting. I don't share Hasan's intent, as is obvious with what I said about the Twitter Files. But it's not a red herring if the topic is whether Taibbi's is avoiding covering certain topics because he's worried about upsetting the wrong people. That's central to the argument and here's the relevant part of my conclusion again:
4 Journalism is especially reliant on credibility and trust because so much of it happens behind curtains. 5 For whatever cannot be corroborated by outside sources, we have to trust that a journalist is engaging in enough due diligence in vetting sources and investigating claims.
I'm still not clear if you disagree with any of it. I put numbers to make it easier.
But you are using an entirely dishonest, red herring to cast aspersions? I think that is shameful.
What is dishonest? What is shameful? I've already said my piece about the Twitter Files but you still seem to think I have this hidden agenda. I've read your post several times and while I understand you strongly dislike my conclusion I can't summarize much beyond that. It would be helpful for you to be specific and avoid conclusory language (e.g. "darkly hinting" "bullshit Indian story" etc).
Finally, do you trust mainstream media on say covid vaccines?
This is a very broad question: do I trust who on what exactly? Generally speaking I have very low trust in most science journalism, with very few exceptions.
Why do you think Indian Twitter situation was brought up?
The theory is that Taibbi was happy to cover what Old Twitter did because it made Musk look good, but he doesn't want to cover what New Twitter does with India because it makes Musk look bad. In the absence of Taibbi providing a more convincing explanation for his actions (he hasn't) that's the conclusion the evidence I outlined above leads me to.
How does Taibbi’s “unwillingness” to attack Musk affect his Taibbi’s credibility?
His unwillingness to attack Musk is not really the issue, it's the lack of curiosity about Twitter's actions that I find suspicious as I said above. He seems to be deliberately keeping his head in the dark about a story central to his beat, most likely to avoid having to (negatively) opine on New Twitter's actions and upsetting Musk. It's Not Good when journalists choose to avoid covering certain topics because they're worried about upsetting the wrong people because it might lead to some stories being suppressed. That's Bad.
Is it his general credibility or Twitter specific?
Both, but primarily Twitter-related. Given how much aversion he has demonstrated to upsetting Musk, I'd be worried that if he came across a Twitter scoop that happens to make Musk look bad he'd be inclined to bury the story. There are a few journalists who I would be inclined to take at their word when they report something via anonymous sourcing or something similarly unverifiable but I wouldn't trust Taibbi's reporting on a given topic without some serious corroboration.
If Twitter specific, then any story in particular?
As I said before: "For whatever cannot be corroborated by outside sources, we have to trust that a journalist is engaging in enough due diligence in vetting sources and investigating claims." In terms of past Twitter stories, I don't have any reason to believe there were based on fabrications. I didn't pay attention closely but Taibbi appears to have provided authentic documents and none of the employees involved disputed their authenticity as far as I am aware. I am also not aware of any follow-up reporting by others that poked any significant holes in Taibbi's reporting. The only remaining concern would be matters of omission but I'm not aware of any issues at the moment.
darkly hinting at “credibility” problems without really doing the work to show why failure to criticize Musk makes Taibbi’s reporting less credible outside of asserting that he isn’t playing with a free hand because he doesn’t want to criticize Musk over a bullshit Indian story
I'm not "darkly" hinting at anything, I said my conclusion outright. You're just asserting that I'm not doing the work without explaining how exactly the approach I laid out is deficient. Here's the relevant part of my conclusion again:
4 Journalism is especially reliant on credibility and trust because so much of it happens behind curtains. 5 For whatever cannot be corroborated by outside sources, we have to trust that a journalist is engaging in enough due diligence in vetting sources and investigating claims.
Ignore Taibbi for a second, is there anything you disagree with there as a general principle? Maybe you do agree with the premises but disagree that they apply to Taibbi? It would be helpful if you specified because I can't tell.
What you left out is that Taibbi under oath (which was backed up by Michael S. also) stated that they received a massive trove of info that would’ve been hard to pre-select, there was zero limitations on what they could write, and whenever they asked for more info they got it.
I'm assuming you're talking about the congressional hearings? I didn't watch those hearings so I have no idea what they said in it. I laid out my arguments why I believe Taibbi is being so evasive and "but he said under oath" doesn't address what I actually said.
Moreover, Taibbi provided receipts. Do you think he made them up? Do you think Musk made them up? To date, people with knowledge have only challenged the context (unsuccessfully in my opinion).
What receipts? What context? Are you talking about the Twitter Files? I don't have any basis to doubt the veracity or authenticity of the Twitter Files.
As best as I can tell, you seem to be under the impression that I have a hidden argument buried within my post. I believe what I wrote is clear enough but if there's any confusion on your end you can just ask me to clarify. It would be more helpful to keep the conversation focused on what I actually wrote rather than what you think I wrote.
Me:
That on its own does not negate or render false the Twitter reporting he has already done
You:
If Taibbi doesn’t respond, the mainstream media is able to make this absurd claim that Taibbi isn’t willing to criticize Musk and because of that unwillingness Taibbi’s story is bullshit.
Taibbi failure to criticize Musk doesn’t change the merits of the story
I never claimed that Taibbi's story is bullshit or that his unwillingness to criticize Musk changes the merits of the story, I said the opposite. You said my conclusion is exactly the problem but I'm not seeing where we actually disagree here. Most of your post is about what MSNBC, Hasan Mehdi, and the mainstream media believe but I'm none of those people and unless I actually endorsed their opinions/arguments as my own, they're not my responsibility.
I'll try again. Here's my conclusion again, but with each clause numbered. Can you please just reply with which number you take issue with?
So with that in mind, I think the best conclusion one can draw from the evidence above is that 1 Taibbi feels constrained from criticizing Musk because Musk is too valuable a source. 2 That on its own does not negate or render false the Twitter reporting he has already done, but 3 it seems obvious that he's not playing with a free hand. 4 Journalism is especially reliant on credibility and trust because so much of it happens behind curtains. 5 For whatever cannot be corroborated by outside sources, we have to trust that a journalist is engaging in enough due diligence in vetting sources and investigating claims. 6 Taibbi is seriously jeopardizing his credibility here, and I can't see how the pay-off is worth it.
Advertisements are an imperfect proxy for volume because of how many lawyers are provided for free or low-cost. Criminal law is the obvious aberration, because around 80-90% of defendants qualify for a public defender. Some states and nonprofits also provide legal aid. My guess would be that immigration and family law are probably on similar footing on that front. The only other consideration I can think of is that immigration lawyers will chase after specific demographics, and that concentration will naturally encourage advertisement spending.
At least based on my caseload, I can more-or-less confirm the impression you have about dipshits versus reasonable cops (although obviously the YouTube crowd is going to select for outrageousness).
I don't think the system could handle giving all those suits any kind of fair consideration.
Why not? I already mentioned that judges are primed to toss lawsuits in the garbage. If you get rid of absolute immunity, you'll get rid of a major legal hurdle, but there's no reason to think that the practical bias will change materially. Judges will have one less easy excuse to use the shredder, but they won't have none. If the video footage you cite is as clear as you describe it, why wouldn't a judge (who is already primed to favor police testimony) agree?
Maybe I'm misunderstanding something but I can't tell what the foundation for your assertion is. You're just labeling the question to be a disingenuous attack (how?) that says nothing about his credibility (why?). Looking at my conclusion below, can you be specific about which part of it you take issue with?
So with that in mind, I think the best conclusion one can draw from the evidence above is that Taibbi feels constrained from criticizing Musk because Musk is too valuable a source. That on its own does not negate or render false the Twitter reporting he has already done, but it seems obvious that he's not playing with a free hand. Journalism is especially reliant on credibility and trust because so much of it happens behind curtains. For whatever cannot be corroborated by outside sources, we have to trust that a journalist is engaging in enough due diligence in vetting sources and investigating claims. Taibbi is seriously jeopardizing his credibility here, and I can't see how the pay-off is worth it.
Fair point about COVID. This was percent of all complaints filed that year.
Check out this example where a guy generates a frontend for a social media site connected to a working database with just voice commands, in less than five minutes.
You may be useless eventually, but for now LLMs are a labor saving tool. The better comparison for now is that you need to pick up and learn to use the chainsaw. It doesn't know where to point itself, yet.
Absolutely, that's how I see it. I don't think that came across as much as I wanted, but I am legitimately excited about the developments. ChatGPT is not good enough to generate interesting prose on its own, but I already use it as a pseudo-editor and thesaurus and summarizer as an occasional supplement to my writing. There's definitely an element where it feels like "cheating" but I'm not a Luddite and that's not going to be enough to stop me from using the chainsaw.
Part of the ennui here is just impatience. The tools out there already have obvious capacity but awful UI, and enthusiasts have to stitch together a workflow across several command line prompts to get something useable. It's not so different from the Louis CK airplane wifi segment, I want it now and there's a reluctance with trying to chop down a tree with a hand axe when the chainsaw is in the mail.
2021
Interesting, I hadn't heard of that case before. Thanks for linking.
Do you believe the same thing about the Uyghur question posed to TikTok executives?
But he couldn't care less about India, why would he?
But he does care about India, at least not pissing off its government. As I said above, he faces a dilemma with no obvious solution given the serious amount of revenue involved.
True, as a user I would likely benefit. As an owner, I might have other incentives though. I don't know how accurate these numbers are but roughly Twitter gets 53% of its revenue from the US and 16% from Japan. The specifics from India are not listed but as the 3rd largest market it's bound to be a significant amount.
Well, for one thing, a prosecutor who is subject to suit would be very reluctant to look sideways at anyone with deep pockets. Those people would therefore have de facto immunity for criminal behavior.
You made the same point last time in the context of QI and I have to concede it's likely to be a valid concern. My inclination is that it would still be worthwhile to get rid of absolute immunity, in part because money already affords a shield now.

It doesn't have to be fear necessarily, all it requires is a modicum of incentive. About 4 years ago I applied to work at this advocacy nonprofit and literally the first question they asked me at the interview was "what is the definition of equity?" Once we got into more substantive questions the interview went great but man that first question really threw me for a loop and caught me off-guard. My confusion was likely visible because my initial instinct was to wonder why they were asking me about a financial term. I eventually mumbled an answer about how equity was "equal opportunity" which (LOL) was not the right answer and I could tell I disappointed some people. I never used "equity" in my daily life and I had to look up the issue later to figure out that the question was used as a cultural shibboleth: if you give the right answer, you signal the right tribal affiliation.
More options
Context Copy link