@ymeskhout's banner p
BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				

				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

				

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				
				
				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

Interesting. In WA immigration bar complaints were 4.6% of the total.

I'm not even sure I can go in and be a juror without getting held in some form of contempt. If it happens to be a law I don't think is right, then I am not going to send someone to jail, regardless of the evidence.

Being late to court or disobeying the gag order while the trial is pending might get you held in contempt, but jury nullification won't

All of this talk coming from the prosecutor in New York that no one should be above the law is just disgusting coming from someone who has absolute immunity.

I didn't think about that. Rich.

You're embarrassing me. Thank you.

Helping criminals is not the end goal here, it's just an incidental effect. Lots of things help criminals even though the demographic is not the core intended beneficiary. For example, the fact that police need a warrant to search a home.

If nothing’s going to change and the lawsuit will land in the garbage anyway, why overturn the rule at all? It’s not like it’s a good thing when de facto and de jure diverge. Lawyers do not need any more pay-to-play weapons to fuck with the system.

There's two factors at play. There's the institutional fatigue that lands most lawsuits in the garbage, and then there's the actual Law™ in terms of how each lawsuit should be evaluated. I don't have any quick fixes to get rid of the fatigue, but even today it doesn't get rid of every lawsuit. Sometimes things get through. Adding yet more filters on what the legal standard the system is allowed to use just winnows that flour sifter even further.

t’s possible to think of a dozen theoretical cases in which DAs not having immunity would either be hugely inefficient (anyone who could afford it would sue if they felt their case was handled poorly) or have a chilling effect on the justice system (by allowing DAs to be much more easily threatened or intimidated, as you note).

That's the theoretical fear, but given the presence of the institutional Fatigue I mentioned, it's difficult for me to imagine a world where these frivolous lawsuits actually have an impact. Even if we assume that judges allow the worst civil lawsuits to plod along, what exactly is the concern? Normal people like doctors, construction contractors, accountants, etc all face fairly high litigation risk, and they seem to manage the lawsuits ok. It's reasonable to assume that prosecutors would face an even higher risk given the number of angry people they would deal with, but concretely what exactly will be the impact of that? I'm trying to imagine what the worst case scenario would look like, but for anything salient to come up you'd have to start assuming that judges (who are mostly former prosecutors) will start entertaining frivolous complaints at an alarming rate.

I didn't notice that and unless I see some information showing otherwise I'm going to assume it's probably a coincidence.

I agree, but I'm willing to give partial credit.

My source came from a CLE citing official state bar statistics. I can't imagine how immigration would come anywhere near criminal or family in absolute numbers, maybe they meant relative numbers? There's way more prosecutions and custody disputes than immigration proceedings. Representation is rare in the latter category and the biggest losers get deported out of the country, too far to bother with a bar complaint.

Earlier this year, the Indian government asked Twitter and YouTube to take down a documentary critical of Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Both complied. Two weeks ago, Twitter also complied with a request from the Indian government to block 122 accounts supposedly critical of India's actions in Punjab.

I don't run an international social media company but I imagine there are no obvious choices to make when a government makes a demand and threatens to jail your employees if you don't comply or has police raid your offices. You could close up your offices and not have any employees anywhere in the country, but then you risk having the government retaliate by just blocking access completely, as several countries have already.

Google also dealt with this dilemma in China. In exchange for access to a potential market with 1.3 billion people at the time, Google agreed in 2006 to offer a version of its services that hewed to the CCP's severe censorship requirements. They gave up in 2010 after they found out that several Chinese activists had their Gmail accounts hacked (presumably by the CCP). From a purely financial perspective, it probably would've been in Google's best interests to dutifully continue complying with CCP's censorship regime and just look the other way. That they didn't is commendable from a principled perspective, but it's also not obvious to me whether China's population would have been better off with a hobbled obedient Google versus nothing at all.

Despite the hostility in India, (old) Twitter wasn't a total doormat and did pushback against censorship efforts by suing the Indian government over its takedown law. This lawsuit was something that Musk specifically complained about while he and Twitter were lawfighting about the sale, as stated in the counterclaim he filed:

¶ 181. In 2021, India’s information technology ministry imposed certain rules allowing the government to probe social media posts, demand identifying information, and prosecute companies that refused to comply. While Musk is a proponent of free speech, he believes that moderation on Twitter should “hew close to the laws of countries in which Twitter operates.”

¶ 182. As a result of India’s new rules, recent public reporting suggests that Twitter has faced various investigations by the Indian government, requests to moderate content, and requests to block certain accounts.

¶ 183. India is Twitter’s third largest market, and thus any investigation into Twitter that could lead to suspensions or interruptions of service in that market may constitute an [Material Adverse Effect].

Musk was clearly worried that (old) Twitter was rocking the boat too much in India. Even as a free speech maximalist, I don't see an obvious choice here. There's an obvious tension between standing on principle while also not jeopardizing your wallet at the same time. One has to give, and there's nothing inherently embarrassing about that given the stakes at play.

Fast forward back to the present, in the context of India's recent takedown demands, I wouldn't have an objection if Musk came out with a statement that said "Although we disagree with the demands of the Indian government, we are exploring our legal options but have no choice but to comply in order to avoid jeopardizing access to 1.4 billion people." That's regrettable from a free speech perspective, but what else can you do? But as far as I can tell, Twitter has kept quiet and refused to say anything about its role in facilitating government censorship.

In contrast to the delicate diplomatic game Musk has to play in India, Musk faced no such concerns when speaking about the US government's efforts to take down information it didn't like. Matt Taibbi covered exactly this topic in Twitter Files No. 6, describing how the FBI made several removal requests to Twitter, not all of which were complied with.

Since Musk was the source for the Twitter Files documents, it's reasonable that as the owner of the company he would have a sharp financial interest to be extremely selective about what gets disclosed to journalists. Similarly, since Taibbi was one of the journalists handpicked by Musk to receive such a scoop, Taibbi might have an aversion from criticizing the actions of Musk-owned Twitter too strongly. So when the news about India's removal requests came out two weeks ago, MSNBC's Mehdi Hasan sarcastically tweeted "I'm sure Taibbi is all over this.", referencing the conflict of interest at play. Taibbi responded "Why don’t you invite me on your show to talk about it? Since you’re so absolutely sure of what I’ll say." and Hasan complied.

In terms of how this specific question played out, you can see for yourself at this timestamp. Hasan asks if Taibbi is willing to criticize Musk for complying with the Indian government censorship requests and Taibbi declines, claiming he doesn't know enough about the story to have an opinion. It bears repeating that the whole reason he asked to be invited on Hasan's show was to talk about India's censorship! Not knowing enough to have an opinion is fine, but this apparent gap in Taibbi's knowledge seems rather suspicious. Given his reporting, he clearly has an interest in reporting on the relationship between Twitter and censorious government requests, but apparently his curiosity stops at this particular line?

Taibbi's was clearly not happy with the interview but his follow-up statements kept avoiding the central reason he asked to be interviewed, the censorship by India's government. He pivoted instead to talking about the numerous mistakes MSNBC has made over the years which, sure, ok, but a dodge is still a dodge.

Consider a parallel scenario, involving TikTok employees. It's the easiest own maneuver, but watch how the CEO of TikTok transmogrifies into a human pretzel in front of Congress when asked about Uyghur persecution in China. The same thing happened to TikTok's Head of Public Policy last December, where he kept trying to backflip out of his skin. The evasion in answering the Uyghur question is reasonably interpreted as strong evidence that TikTok executives are afraid of being fired for acknowledging something so verboten by the Chinese state. A clear demonstration of how much control the CCP has over the platform.

So with that in mind, I think the best conclusion one can draw from the evidence above is that Taibbi feels constrained from criticizing Musk because Musk is too valuable a source. That on its own does not negate or render false the Twitter reporting he has already done, but it seems obvious that he's not playing with a free hand. Journalism is especially reliant on credibility and trust because so much of it happens behind curtains. For whatever cannot be corroborated by outside sources, we have to trust that a journalist is engaging in enough due diligence in vetting sources and investigating claims. Taibbi is seriously jeopardizing his credibility here, and I can't see how the pay-off is worth it.

[P.S. While writing this, Taibbi announced that he will leave Twitter after the platform started blocking links to Substack. That fact that he is willing to speak up against Musk/Twitter slightly mitigates my overall criticism of Taibbi's integrity.]

Given...certain recent events, there might be a renewed interest in discussing what redress (if any) we might have when a prosecutor misbehaves. Billy Binion of Reason Magazine tackled one of my favorite hobby horses in a highly recommended feature article: Absolute Immunity Puts Prosecutors Above the Law

I've written about the problem of having government officials with no accountability, from the standpoint of Seattle officials deleting evidence and within the context of the doomed over-prosecution of Kyle Rittenhouse. Nobody voluntarily seeks accountability when they don't have to, and so there's nothing surprising about the state, with its purported monopoly on violence, choosing to shield one of their viceroys. If you have any interest in fixing this oversight, one of the problems you'll encounter (as I wrote in the APAB post) is how selective the outrage is. Except for the principled civil libertarians screaming into the void, no one else cares about a leopard's diet until the moment the first layer of facial epidermis is being torn off.

Let's set the scene by highlighting Binion's main example:

When a storm flooded Baton Rouge in 2016, Priscilla Lefebure took shelter with her cousin and her cousin's husband, Barrett Boeker, an assistant warden at the Louisiana State Penitentiary in Angola. During her stay at her cousin's house on the prison grounds, Lefebure later reported, Boeker raped her twice—first in front of a mirror so she would have to watch, and again days later with a foreign object.

Lefebure's allegations led to a yearslong court battle—not against her accused rapist but against District Attorney Samuel C. D'Aquilla, who seemed determined to make sure that Boeker was never indicted. As the chief prosecutor for West Feliciana Parish, which includes Angola, D'Aquilla sabotaged the case before it began.

When a grand jury considered Lefebure's charges, D'Aquilla declined to present the results of a medical exam that found bruises, redness, and irritation on Lefebure's legs, arms, and cervix. Instead, he offered a police report with his own handwritten notes, which aimed to highlight discrepancies in her story. D'Aquilla opted not to call as witnesses the two investigators on the case, the nurse who took Lefebure's rape kit, or the coroner who stored it. And he refused to meet or speak with Lefebure at all, telling local news outlets he was "uncomfortable" doing so.

After that fiasco, Lefebure sued Samuel D'Aquilla in federal court, saying Boeker falsely claimed his encounters with her were consensual and sought D'Aquilla's assistance in blocking rape charges. According to the lawsuit, D'Aquilla was happy to help. Lefebure accused D'Aquilla of violating her rights to equal protection and due process by deliberately crippling her case against Boeker.

Lefebure's lawsuit against D'Aquilla bounced around for several years before getting denied on the theory that as a prosecutor, D'Aquilla enjoyed absolute legal immunity. If you want to get away with raping someone, it's a boon to have friends in high places that can pull some levers for you. Even better if this friend can get caught pulling levers and nevertheless retain absolute legal immunity for pulling said levers.

Absolute immunity is exactly what it says on the tin, it's absolute. Even though the federal law §1983 allows a lawsuit against "every person", the courts over the years responded with a litany of "well it doesn't really mean that":

The Supreme Court announced the doctrine of absolute immunity for prosecutors in the 1976 case Imbler v. Pachtman. The Court ruled that a man who had spent years in prison could not sue a prosecutor who allegedly withheld evidence that ultimately exonerated him. The justices approvingly quoted a sentiment that Learned Hand expressed as a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit in 1949: "It has been thought better to leave unredressed the wrongs done by dishonest officers than to subject those who try to do their duty to the constant dread of retaliation."

I have to admit there is a kernel of reasonableness within this doctrine. Attorneys can be subject to discipline by their licensing authority if it receives a complaint, and probably to nobody's surprise the two fields of law that combined generate almost half of all bar complaints are criminal law and family law (the latter is toxic for its own reasons). I've said before that my clients have almost always done the thing they're accused of, but if you take some of my more sociopathic convicts at their word, it's everyone else's fault. Of course. The only reason they got convicted is because their lawyer sucked, or the judge was biased, or the prosecutor was evil, or whatever. And so on. People sitting in prison have nothing to do, which is why almost a quarter of all federal lawsuits are filed pro se by prisoners. Bar complaints follow a similar pattern.

As a public defender, it's not a matter of if you'll get a bar complaint, but rather when and I've already had a couple myself. Theoretically, it would be dreadful to have to deal with the spectre of retaliation from unhappy defendants that Learned Hand warned about, but all my complaints were summarily dismissed without my input. There is so much garbage shoveled in by bored inmates that a fatigue miasma sets in over the entire disciplinary field. Almost nobody involves takes anything seriously, including potentially some of the meritorious ones. There goes yet another one whining about their rights being violated, sure.

When federal judge Richard Posner retired from the bench in 2017, he cited serious concerns with the deplorable way his fellow judges treated pro se lawsuits. It's that fatigue again, and according to Posner the judges came up with as many roadblocks and technicalities to ensure the definition of a line to be the shortest distance between a pro se lawsuit and the recycling bin. True to his word, he did set up an organization to offer free legal counseling to pro se litigants, only to quickly shut it down after they were drowning with overwhelming demand.

You can see an illustration of how the assembly line shredder plays out in this case out of Louisiana. In the middle of a misdemeanor trial, the judge granted a "mistrial" to help the prosecutor come back with felony charges. This is as crystal clear a textbook violation of the double jeopardy clause as you can get, but every single state appellate judge (who are also protected by absolute immunity) just kept rubber stamping 'DENIED' without providing any explanation. This defendant was lucky enough to actually have a lawyer handle his appeal and he eventually won after sitting in prison for only 840 days. On paper, 28 USC §1657 states that criminal conviction appeals must be expedited. In reality, fuck you. The federal judges on this appeal took their sweet time, and apparently saw nothing wrong with dealing with civil matters first. It's yet another criminal complaining about his rights. Ho-hum.

The reasons SCOTUS outlined in Imbler v. Pachtman in favor of giving prosecutors absolute immunity was a generalized concern that if prosecutors had to worry about personal liability, they might avoid presenting relevant evidence as a pre-emptive precaution. Further, judges dealing with post-conviction appeals might have their focus "blurred by even the subconscious knowledge that a post-trial decision in favor of the accused might result in the prosecutor's being called upon to respond in damages for his error or mistaken judgment". If the way bar complaints and pro se petitions are treated today is any indication, it's not obvious to me that any floodgates would open here. The system already knows how to use a garbage can.

It's also not clear that the purported justification even matters here when the doctrine is blatantly self-serving. You can't sue judges and prosecutors for misconduct because fuck you that's why. Maybe the other reason this doctrine remains is that it's a Faustian bargain. Similar to the justifications for Qualified Immunity, occasionally putting our blindfolds on when an emissary of the sovereign commits a sin is just the price we pay for our undisturbed slumber. Our legal system promises equal treatment under the law, at least on paper. If we can't be selective about allowing only the Right People to pursue legal vindication against our esteemed pillars of the courtroom, it might potentially be used to help actual criminals. And we can't have that, can we?

A former sexual partner was going to basically do revenge porn to him and do a tabloid write up on having sex with him. That’s revenge porn. Not on video by textually.

Talking about having sex with someone is your definition of revenge porn?

I generally agree that this case is embarrassingly weak. Internal corporate accounting standards are way outside my pay grade, but how is hush money pursuant to an NDA not a legal expense though? If it's apparently illegal to label it as a legal expense, what exactly should it have been labeled?

Federal judges do indeed have a habit of rubberstamping unopposed motions to seal and this becomes the status quo up until the moment a journalist (or Eugene Volokh) catches wind of it and files a motion to unseal. The caselaw is very solidly in favor of open access, and so judges kind of act embarrassed at being caught with their pants down and make a big stink about having to grant the motion to unseal.

In this case, my guess is that SFFA didn't really want to agree to seal the document, but also didn't want to make a big fuss about a collateral issue since they were going to remain in front of that same judge (also, agreeing to seal sometimes comes along with settlements). The only people who are positioned to push the issue are outside observers like journalists, but they need to be lucky enough to know about it in the first place.

Affirmative Action or Transparency, Pick One.

In the hierarchy of court systems, lower-level courts (typically referred to as trial courts or district courts) handle the dirty work of sifting through an ass-load of witness testimonies, pretrial hearings, exhibit litigation, etc. across what can amount to months or even decades of lawfights. For context, one of my felony criminal trials took about 4 days of testimony and generated about 1000 pages in transcripts. A civil trial with well-heeled and sophisticated litigants is going to kill way more trees.

Normally, appellate courts (such as SCOTUS) don't want to concern themselves with the nitty gritty detail of what exactly was said at every hearing of every trial. Generally speaking, appellate courts will only deal with questions of law rather than of facts, so if they're going to get anything at all, appellate courts want a tidy streamlined package of only the bare minimum information they'd need to answer the limited questions in front of them.

Public trials are one of the bedrocks of the American legal system. Even if you're not directly involved, the presumption for any legal case is one of transparency and the exceptions are limited. During a trial, jurors are expected to come to a decision based solely on what was admitted into evidence in front of them, and so whenever the parties have to discuss whether the jurors are allowed to see anything, this naturally has to be done outside of the presence of the jury (known as a "sidebar"). Keeping the jury out of the loop is routine, but lasts only until their job is done, and sidebar conversations are absolutely still part of the open record.

The only other shroud used by the court system is sealing. The most common applications, such as redacting bank account information or social security numbers, are banal and trivial to justify. At least on paper, if a court is going to seal anything, it must make a determination that there is an "overriding interest" requiring secrecy that trumps the presumption of openness. But in practice, parties routinely ask the court to seal either dockets, and sometimes even ask to seal the motions to seal (Eugene Volokh has done heroic work on this front, watching dockets across the country like a hawk and regularly filing successful motions to unseal).

The big affirmative action case before SCOTUS at the moment involves a lawsuit against Harvard for anti-Asian discrimination. SCOTUS made the unusual step of requesting everything from the trial court. The only reason this would happen is if SCOTUS has a reason to think they're not seeing the full picture, and at least in this case it seems like the trial judge has indeed been trying to hide some skeletons. Jeannie Suk, a Harvard law professor, has been watching this case with interest and noticed that the transcripts for the multiple sidebars were automatically sealed by the judge. Suk wrote about her efforts to pry open this sealed vault and what she found hidden inside.

What was Judge Burroughs trying to hide? I eventually obtained the joke memo and the surrounding e-mails, and what I read didn’t strike me as having been worth the fight to keep them secret. But the fight itself showed that both Harvard and the court expect the public to operate on trust that their decisions are not biased—an expectation that is all the more troubling as the Supreme Court’s likely ban on using race in admissions will drive the consideration of race further underground.

William Fitzsimmons began working in Harvard admissions more than fifty years ago and has been the dean of admissions and financial aid since 1986. The federal official who wrote the joke memo, Thomas Hibino, worked at the Boston location of the Office for Civil Rights, eventually serving as the regional director; he retired in 2014. Earlier in his career, he had worked at the Japanese American Citizens League. After Hibino oversaw the federal investigation into Harvard’s alleged discrimination against Asian American applicants, decades ago, he and Fitzsimmons became friends, and by 2012 their exchanges included banter about lunch dates and running races together, and teasing when one opted to sleep in. But the relationship wasn’t all palling around, because Hibino was still at the federal agency regulating Harvard. In April of 2013, he wrote to Fitzsimmons, “Regarding the impact of legacy on Asian American applicants, what proportion of AA applicants are legacies and what proportion of white applicants are legacies? Of course I’m happy to talk about this if necessary!” More than anything, the e-mails reveal the coziness of the federal regulator toward the regulated entity.

On November 30, 2012, amid a friendly back-and-forth about lunch plans, Hibino e-mailed Fitzsimmons an attachment that he described as “really hilarious if I do say so myself!” Hibino explained, “I did it for the amusement of our team, and of course, you guys”—presumably Harvard admissions officers—“are the only others who can appreciate the humor.” The joke memo had been written on Harvard admissions-office stationery, during the earlier investigation. It was purportedly from an associate director of admissions and parodied the admissions officer downplaying an Asian American applicant’s achievements. The memo denigrated “José,” who was “the sole support of his family of 14 since his father, a Filipino farm worker, got run over by a tractor,” saying, “It can’t be that difficult on his part-time job as a senior cancer researcher.” It continued, “While he was California’s Class AAA Player of the Year,” with an offer from the Rams, “we just don’t need a 132 pound defensive lineman,” apparently referring to a slight Asian male physique. “I have to discount the Nobel Peace Prize he received. . . . After all, they gave one to Martin Luther King, too. No doubt just another example of giving preference to minorities.” The memo dismissed the fictional applicant as “just another AA CJer.” That was Harvard admissions shorthand for an Asian American applicant who intends to study biology and become a doctor, according to the trial transcript.

Like Suk, I can't think of any possible justification to keep something like this hidden under seal. In a case about racial discrimination against Asians, it seems patently absurd to claim how Harvard officials and federal regulators pally around and openly mock Asians is somehow not relevant to the issue. It seems plain to me that the judge chose to hide it because it's embarrassing and inconvenient to Harvard. Anti-Asian bias also came up from education officials in the Thomas Jefferson High School case, where text messages plainly revealed their intent was to reduce the number of Asian students enrolled.

I'm very much against Affirmative Action policies. Although I'm not opposed in principle to remedial measures designed to narrowly target affected groups (although the amounts were pitiful, see Japanese internment compensation), painting entire groups with such a broad brush doesn't work when we have such an incoherent taxonomy of race. Beyond that, although Affirmative Action is often cited as evidence of a "woke pro-minority" institutional bias it seems just as plausible to conclude that privileged white people are hiding behind the "black and hispanic" veil as a way to disguise their motivation to avoid having to compete against Asians for the top spots (I'm open to evidence showing one way or another).

Harvard plainly wants to be able to discriminate on the basis of race. They may offer lofty justifications about why their particular kind of racial discrimination is justified or warranted or morally right, but no one is obligated to accept their statements at face-value. The fact that Harvard (with the help of a federal judge) is working so hard to avoid transparency only makes suspicion that much more warranted as a response to their actions.

That would more accurately be described as a type of agnosticism. A particular type, in fact.

There's already a designation between implicit and explicit atheism and similarly between strong and weak agnosticism (unknowable versus unknown, respectively). The line between weak agnosticism and implicit atheism is blurry to non-existent.

It is fair, but the skepticism should be narrowly deployed to only apply when the person is citing their personal experience or asking you to trust their reporting without showing their work.

Also notice how Murphy shifted the goal posts.

Yes she did, many times! Anytime she cites the experience of women she talked to about the industry, that's data. I even asked her and quoted her explanation for how she arrived at her position to begin with.

By saying "no data will change my mind" Meghan Murphy is being honest about this being a values disagreement, and saving you time that you'd waste on digging out studies, which won't have an impact on the discussion. More people should follow her example, to be honest.

There's nothing wrong with having a values disagreement but Meghan is not being honest about her stance here. If she was then she wouldn't be citing studies and evidence to argue her point, only to retreat back into the values cave when pressed.

We might be quibbling over definitions here but I'm using 'data' rather broadly. In your example, how would you evaluate someone's testimony without some sort of empirical data or observation about their testimony or demeanor?

Well goddamn, fascinating that it's mandated in racing because it doesn't block visibility.

This critique is vague on the details. What about her surveys exactly are so bad that we learn less than nothing?

This is tough to answer because whenever I visit I get the inimitable privilege of having a bevy of family members eager to have me stay with them. That said, I don't think I've ever heard much complaints from Western tourists when they visit Morocco because the places everyone go to are generally completely authentic.

Maybe the most eye-wateringly touristy area is Marrakesh, but I found it really fun to visit as a native for the first time. The main market square is not some Potemkin village; it's a real bona fide market square that the locals go to, and despite the allure of appealing to Western wallets, you see plenty of street storytellers drawing huge crowds of bystanders by telling poems/jokes/stories in the local language.

I'd say almost all the main cities with medinas (Marrakesh, Fes, Rabat, etc.) are solid destinations because it's such a unique urban landscape. Sale is personally my favorite place, in part because it's not a tourist area, but because that also means it doesn't have a cadre of police officers around to chase off the riff-raff. Casablanca has some neat places but mostly it's just a big boring modern city with modern conveniences (my grandpa's house got demolished and is now a Starbucks).

Oh, and make sure you eat all the street food. Seriously, it's all amazing and safe. I asked my cousins for advice on which street vendors I should stay away from to avoid getting sick, and they completely did not understand the premise of my question. It might be a cultural thing; there's no shortage of scammers and pickpockets in Marrakesh, but apparently fucking with food is just unconscionable.

Russell’s teapot, even though it’s considered exemplar of unfalsifiable, is only non-demonstrable. It could be falsified, but we don’t have the tools to do it.

This is how I understood Russell's teapot. Wikipedia describes the example as claiming "to illustrate that the philosophic burden of proof lies upon a person making empirically unfalsifiable claims, rather than shifting the burden of disproof to others."

I think it's important to distinguish between what's theoretically unfalsifiable and what is practically unfalsifiable, as they address different concerns. Your Shakespeare example is in the latter category, and there would be no basis for me to dismiss it because it's (theoretically) non-falsifiable, and I would actually find Jon's arguments compelling. Despite my stated adherence to (theoretically) falsifiability, I don't see the contradiction here. I can acknowledge that some theories are very difficult to prove one way or another because of practical difficulties in gathering empirical data, but that's not an outright bar against believing anything (with proper qualifiers of course). Even if we lack tight data, we can fill in the gaps with other tools like logic and intuition.

The distinction between Jon and Meghan is that Jon acknowledges the practical difficulties yet nevertheless is still willing to brainstorm ways to gather data.

there seems to be good data that shows that porn trains the brain to be a cuck (more here). It would not be too much of a leap to then go : "violent porn trains the brain for violent sex".

If it's true that porn trains you to be a cuck, then wouldn't it follow that violent porn trains you to be a voyeur of violence rather than a participant?