Recently I watched a debate between friend-of-the-motte Aella and infamous Canadian radical feminist Meghan Murphy on the subject of the ethics of the sex industry. I found the debate infuriating to listen to, so I wrote way too many words breaking down my issues with it, namely outlining Meghan's extremely dodgy arguments. Much of the ideas contained herein would be well-worn to most of y'all but enjoy either way. Excerpted to avoid character limit (Zorba please save us!!):
I can't help feeling a tinge of awkward self-consciousness whenever I describe myself as part of the modern-day "Rationality" movement. As I've said before, it's perfectly reasonable to be suspicious of a group with such a self-serving and masturbatory name, because isn't everyone in favor of rational thinking? The core lessons of rationality are --- or at least should be --- dreadfully pedestrian: you should test your theories with evidence, you shouldn't believe things that aren't true, you should make logically coherent arguments, threatening to kill someone is not a valid rebuttal to their arguments, et cetera forever.
Like I said, boring stuff that you would expect from any public intellectual or anyone with even a passing familiarity with logic and critical thinking. It's at least one reason why I didn't really understand or appreciate why Eliezer Yudkowsky spent so much time writing The Sequences, a long series of blog posts that aims to break down rationality into delicious bite-sized chunks. But I live in a bubble full of rat nerds, and sometimes I get shocked awake with some cold water thrown at me. In this post, I want to highlight one recent episode that particularly stood out to me as emblematic of the evergreen utility of rationalist concepts, and it's the debate between Aella and Meghan Murphy on the ethics of the sex industry (prostitution and pornography) on the Calmversations podcast hosted by Benjamin A. Boyce.
To set things up, Meghan Murphy is a feminist thinker who has written extensively about the harms prostitution and pornography have imposed (primarily) on women, including arguing in favor of a total ban on pornography. Aella has worked as a prostitute and produced porn, and her positions on the sex industry are significantly more positive. I should say that I'm friends with Aella, but that hasn't stopped me from pointedly criticizing her ideas before. I reached out to Meghan Murphy by email, and although this post will be rather critical of her reasoning, she should absolutely be commended for responding to my questions despite the severe snark I previously tweeted her way.
I should also make it clear that any criticism should be construed narrowly, and is not meant as a broad denunciation of either Meghan's work in general nor --- crucially! --- her specific criticisms about the sex industry. I want to make sure this point is heavily emphasized, as one of the most useful (and, unfortunately, least adopted) tools in rationality is the ability to cut discussions into discrete pizza slices, such as abstracting from the object level to the meta level, or decoupling distinct ideas from each other. This is an invaluable practice in any discourse because humans are prone to irrational distractions, and very often we get reflexively defensive and assume that an attack on an argument or premise is an attack on a conclusion. To use the parlance, someone could be "accidentally right" and reach a true conclusion despite using faulty logic. So just because I criticize someone's argument does not mean that their conclusion is false.
Make Your Belief Falsifiable (i.e., Make That Motherfucker Burnable)
If I had a rationality genie grant me one wish, it would be to force everyone to make their theories falsifiable. Put simply, all it means is that if you present a theory, you should be able to articulate at least the theoretical circumstances by which your theory would be "falsified" --- proven wrong. Carl Sagan elucidated an excellent illustration of falsifiability when he described the dragon in his garage.
Consider if we were in the same house and I claimed the roof was on fire. Given what you know about the potential risks of fire, you may then want to evacuate the house, or (if you're feeling frisky) perhaps decline any water and just let the motherfucker burn. But if you look around you and point out that you don't see any flames, don't smell any smoke, nor do you hear any fire alarms, you've reasonably falsified my claim. If my response is to claim the fire I'm talking about is invisible, doesn't produce any smoke, and doesn't trigger any fire alarms, you'd be right to dismiss what I'm saying as complete fucking nonsense because I'm not conveying any useful information to you. A theory that is unfalsifiable is like a compass that always points north no matter what direction it's facing; it's useless precisely because it's "true" no matter what.
One of the very first topics Aella and Meghan broached in their debate was on the subject of the effects of pornography on its users. Meghan's argument is fairly straightforward (2:23): she believes that a consistent exposure by men to violent and/or extreme pornography (and reinforced by orgasmic dopamine feedback loop) would encourage men to replicate the acts depicted on screen in real life. Meghan repeats a version of this argument several times, and ties it explicitly to child abuse (11:51):
I think that the theory of men seeking out barely legal porn and the amount of men who look for child porn, even online, proves that there's a lot of men who are seeking out girls and underage women online to jack off to. And I think that we know that molestation and child abuse and sexual abuse and men predating on young girls, or like young women, to young women is a pretty big problem in our society. So I think that adding porn to that mix is for sure not helping and probably making it worse.
This is a logically sound and straightforward argument and, most importantly, testable and falsifiable. If Meghan argues one reason that porn is bad is because it causes bad things, then a falsification would be the absence of said bad things. But when Aella asks Meghan "What kind of data would make you update your mind?" Meghan responds "No data" and blithely asserts "I think it's bad for men to jack to barely legal porn."
The same happened when I reached out by email and asked about her position vis-à-vis the harm on women within the industry. Meghan has demonstrably changed her mind on several issues over time, so I cannot accuse her of being completely immune to new evidence or arguments. Her initial approach to porn involved "feminist porn" projects in school and reading articles by "empowered" sex workers and academics about female agency and how we need to flip the script on the "victim" narrative. But over time, she couldn't shake off the persistent and gnawing discomfort she had with pornography and eventually connected with and interviewed women who spent many years in the sex industry, who did frontline work, and academics who extensively studied the sex trade (along with reading a lot more second-wave analysis of the topic). In other words, Meghan discovered new evidence and arguments that made her change her mind.
I asked Meghan to explain the apparent contradiction between claiming that no data would change her mind, while simultaneously lucidly explaining how data did indeed change her mind. Meghan's answer was not responsive to the issue; she reiterated that no data would change her mind because her position is based on ethics.
As shown in numerous instances throughout the debate, Meghan readily provides evidence and support to explain why she is against the sex industry (31:23):
I mean, I talked to lots and lots of women in prostitution. Women who've worked as high-end escorts, women who've worked in the street, women who worked in the Downtown Eastside, women who worked in brothels. And they all said they didn't want to be there. They all have suffered immense physical and emotional trauma. Most of them came from physical and emotional trauma. Most of them came from homes where there was sexual abuse. And it was really a scary, horrific experience for them that is very difficult to get out of. So I think most of the women who are in prostitution and pornography don't actually want to be there.
But does this mean you can Believe All Women™ regarding what they say about the conditions of the sex industry? Of course not, because Meghan preemptively applies a strict credibility filter, her version of "No True Prostitute" (37:35):
the poor tend more to claim they’re religious while the rich are more likely to practice their religion.
Is this established as true? I assumed that atheism heavily correlated with education and wealth.
I haven't watched either, but would Yellowstone and Hillbilly Effigy count as examples of them trying to broaden their reach? I assume there's plenty of money to be had by serving that demographic, so I'd assume the hurdle is the myopic biases that (typically liberal) media executives have.
Yes!! What you describe is what, to me, should be the platonic ideal of narrative media. There's something almost deliriously wholesome about discovering a shared tenet of an alien human culture. The purposes here isn't to cement a permanent kumbaya sentiment, but solely to be reminded of how predictable we humans can be despite the kaleidoscope of superficial cultural differences we conjure up. The real differences are important as well, and highlighting both aspects is foundational to presenting a rich palette of human experience.
I don't want to experience a story (movie, tv, books, whatever) where the "diversity" of characters is just an algorithm that goes through the finished script and randomly assigns different identities, with no regard for how their experience changes.
There are so many other media examples that come to mind. One is the Isreali TV show "Shtisel" which depicts a strict ultra-orthodox Jewish community. I know nothing about their lives, but I absolutely resonated with and understood the main character's experience, as he struggled to balance familial obligations while chasing after romantic infatuation. And the differences were illuminating as well. I would notice innocuous details that were not remarked upon by the characters (such as the separate beds for husband and wife) and it would only pique my curiosity to figure out why.
Another is the Australian Aboriginal movie Ten Canoes (2006) [full movie link]. It's a simple story, set in an authentic ancient aboriginal past, and refreshing to me just how funny it can be despite the enormous cultural gap inherent.
Imagine how deprived, how barren, any of this would be if the only difference was a superficial adornment to meet a diversity quota.
Thanks! And yes, that's an accurate description of the division. Because of Morocco's ties to the West, it's impossible to interface with the rich and powerful without adopting their secular mores. I don't know enough about Malaysia, but I wonder if the upper class attachment to Islam has anything to do with maintaining business/political relations with their devout Indonesian neighbors (edging out Pakistan as the biggest Muslim country in the world).
Part 2 [continued from above]
Maybe now's a good time to talk about how corrupt Morocco is. Not only can you bribe cops, bureaucrats, judges, officials, whoever to make problems go away, it's expected of you to make anything happen. Because corruption is, by definition, surreptitious and thus difficult to observe and measure directly, the best evidence normally available are studies like the Corruption Perception Index, which rely on subjective reporting. On that ranking, Morocco places eighty-seventh out of 180 countries for honesty. But perception doesn't tell us the full story on corruption, so I want to take this opportunity to cite what is perhaps my favorite economics study, based solely on its ingenious methodology.
Diplomats enjoy legal immunity, and for a while this extended even to banalities like parking tickets. Researchers examined the pattern of parking violations of United Nations diplomats working in Manhattan and used it to construct a plausible heuristic for each country's social norms for corruption — the idea being that a history either of no violations or no unpaid tickets (despite the lack of legal penalties) would indicate a low propensity for corruption. By the unpaid tickets standard, Morocco ranked #13 in the world for corruption.
This illustrates the other way the legal system is functionally bifurcated: money. The ban on unmarried couples staying in hotels is one of the laws that, at least on paper, applies equally both to Moroccans and foreigners. But officials know not to do something as idiotic as enforcing fornication prohibitions on dumbfounded white people just there to hashtag-Marrakesh and, most importantly, spend money. Everyone knows not to kill the golden goose of tourism, but equally as important is not to slut-shame it either.
Similarly, Muslims — which all Moroccans are legally assumed to be unless officially denoted otherwise — are purportedly prohibited from purchasing alcohol of any kind in Morocco, and yet this decree is flagrantly and openly violated every day. Alcohol bodegas are found on almost every corner, and none of the proprietors inquire about the Shahadah at the point of sale. Same with Moroccans rich enough to eat at a restaurant — they're presumed to be secular enough to be trusted to peruse the wine list. Either way, there's enough lucre to grease the wheels and keep the coppers at bay.
The economist Bruce Yandle coined the term "Bootleggers and Baptists" to describe a type of regulatory capture. Baptists are the ones pure of heart, who want to ban alcohol for moral reasons. Bootleggers are the profiteers, who want to ban alcohol for their pecuniary benefit because they have a competitive advantage working within an illicit market. The ones who want to uphold the law work synergistically (if unintentionally) with the ones seeking to break it for profit. The movement to repeal Morocco's hotel law has made some progress, but it has also been hit by pushback from Baptists and Bootleggers alike. The Baptists are ever concerned about the youth's downward trajectory into degeneracy, and anxious about transforming the Kingdom's hotels into functional brothels (which, given the lack of hook-up venues, is not an unreasonable concern). The Bootleggers are hoteliers who benefit from the "double-booking" trick and government officials reluctant to give up a source of extorted bribery. Meanwhile, the loopholes built into the system mean that the law really only applies to the poors, so who cares?
I'll end with a story an aunt relayed to me, which perfectly illustrates the bizarre amalgam of business-as-usual corruption within Moroccan law enforcement.
My aunt was driving with her friend to another city, miles away from her home. A cop pulled her over for speeding. The traffic code is enforced under penalty of a fine, with the money paid directly to the officer (I know, it's nuts). If you don't happen to have the money on hand, not a problem — they'll just confiscate your actual driver license and hold it at the local Sûreté Nationale bureau until you can come back with the funds.
Problem number one: My aunt did not have enough to pay the full traffic fine amount, the functional equivalent of about $40, and having her license confiscated this far away from her home would be an enormous hassle. While the cop was away, her passenger helpfully suggested offering a $10 bribe to the officer. But problem number two: My aunt had only a $20 bill, with no way to make change. Ten dollars would be a perfectly appropriate amount for a bribe, but getting only a 50% discount on the traffic fine felt like an awful bargain.
The cop heard all this. He popped up and said, "I have change for a twenty." My aunt kept her license that night.
Sexual Panopticon in the Kingdom of Morocco
“Are you guys having sex in there??”
[I wrote this for Jesse Singal's newsletter in December, now unlocked for everyone]
Let's talk about sex. Specifically, let's talk about the bizarre dynamics of how sex is policed in the Islamic Kingdom that is my homeland.
Morocco's government is explicitly religious — there is no such thing as separation of Mosque and State. The constitution establishes the King as Amir al-Mu'minin, the supreme commander of the faithful. Morocco isn't alone here, as Muslim countries are notable not only for formally adopting a state religion but for regularly using government violence to enforce pious conduct among their populaces. This kind of enforcement is facilitated by a population's homogeneity — ninety-nine percent of Moroccans are Muslim and drawn from the same Arab-Berber ethnic stock. Given these factors, you might expect a very strict, orthodox version of Islam to reign, but the truth is a little more complicated.
Saudi Arabia stands out for its uniquely puritanical approach to Islam (known as Wahhabism), and for the notoriety of its religious police force (known as the mutawwa'in). The stories you've heard about Islam in general are probably true. Alcohol is haram. Pork is haram.Premarital sex is hella haram (unless you get a temporary marriage with a prostitute), and don't get me started on the premarital sex with a drunken pig hat trick. Some edicts are easier to enforce than others (say, by monitoring agricultural supply chains), but because fornication usually happens behind closed doors, the mutawwa'in schlep around Saudi Arabia's public spaces to cut off the problem at the source: ensuring no unrelated people of the opposite sex ever get a chance to interact alone. The authorities will do things like surveil entrances to shopping malls and make sure single men never set foot inside unless they're accompanied by a female relative. Any boy and girl caught on a date at a park or wherever might get forcibly escorted to the local police station. (Paradoxically, this obsession with disrupting such dyads might have the unintended consequences of making it easier for gay men to date — no one bats an eye at two dudes hanging out.)
Morocco is significantly chiller on this front. Compared to other Muslim countries, Morocco is known for being fairly relaxed — the land where women can wear bikinis to the beach and are not legally prohibited from operating motor vehicles, and where men and women freely comingle in public without the threat of being caned.
What accounts for this? It's Complicated™, but one explanation has to do with tourism. As the birthplace of Islam, Saudi Arabia welcomes millions of visitors for the Hajj — the annual pilgrimage to Mecca. Because this enormous "tourism" economy comes preinstalled, the country has long been kind of hostile to and uninterested in Western tourism (entire cities, like Mecca and Medina, are completely forbidden to non-Muslims).
In contrast, Morocco's location as one of the gateways to the Mediterranean is consistent with its long history of welcoming Western visitors (fun fact: it was the first country to recognize the newly independent United States back in 1777). Morocco often ties Egypt for first place as the most popular tourist destination in Africa, with millions of visitors every year, despite not having any pyramids. The economy's heavy reliance on tourism necessarily encourages tolerance of foreign kafirs purely as a cynical, pragmatic matter.
The puzzle about how the government can have its cake (enforce religious mores) and eat it too (don't scare the tourists) nevertheless remains. One way it tries to solve this conundrum is simply by explicitly bifurcating the legal code, with some laws carving out broad exceptions for foreigners. It's impossible to keep this laissez-faire approach exclusively quarantined just to les étrangers, and so the tolerance for secularism necessarily bleeds out somewhat.
While Morocco may lack Saudi-style Sharia SWAT teams, a distributed network of civilian snitches can step in to fill the void wherever the government's efforts at morality policing fall short. In 2016, two gay men were violently beaten by neighbors who shouted on the now-unavailable video "this is not manliness" throughout the attack. The assailants were the ones who summoned the police, who then arrested the victims for "sexual deviancy." For economic reasons, but also to avoid the impropriety of scandal, single adults in Morocco are expected to reside with their families and move out only when they get married. Studies have consistently established that the most reliable form of birth control is to live in your parents' apartment with your four siblings. And so landlords in Morocco will flat-out refuse to lease apartments to unmarried individuals, especially women, for fear of potentially bringing dishonor to their roof. Good luck finding a place to hook up with your Minder match.
"What about hotels?" you sheepishly ask. You naive fool, they're way ahead of you. The ultimate example of this public-private partnership enforcement is Article 490 of the penal code, which prohibits unmarried couples from renting hotel rooms. Anyone caught is liable to jail terms, and hotel keepers are legally required to ask for marriage certificates, with police officers checking their logs every week to ensure compliance.
I was subject to this myself. The last time I visited my homeland, I briefly stayed with my sister at a hotel. I announced myself at the front desk, and upon realizing that I, a full-blooded male with no wedding ring, was going to reside in the same room as a female who also lacked a ring, the clerk gave me a raised eyebrow. You'd think our sharing a last name would have been sufficient evidence for the front desk, but given the prevalence and acceptance of cousin marriage in this area, I was required by the keeper to provide proof of sufficient consanguinity. Season two of the masterpiece TV show Ramy portrayed the titular character confronted by Cairo hotel staff about him shacking up with his cousin (spoiler: they were indeed fucking). [I can't say enough good things about this show, and I have emphatically written my praise for its contribution toward providing "true" diversity in media.]
The encounter was surprising (and terrifying) enough that some viewers expressed incredulity at this plot point, but rest assured, it's a depiction of something very real.
A cousin of mine — male, single, unmarried, and on the aforementioned form of parental cohabitation birth control — told me his favorite method for finding a place to hook up: Arrive separately to the hotel, get two separate rooms, and sneak into the same room when the coast is clear. If somehow the double-booking scheme falls through, you can get the hotelier to look the other way with a fistful of dirhams.
Maybe now's a good time to talk about how corrupt Morocco is.
[continued below due to character limit]
This is true, but it's a hard balance to strike. For example there's this case from 2009 in Washington state where a woman claimed to have been raped at knifepoint. The cops didn't believe her and threatened her with criminal charges for filing a false police report if she didn't retract her story. She retracted, and it wasn't until many years later that they caught the rapist in another state and found in his possession photos of the woman tied up in her apartment — exactly as she first reported it.
If you steal something and you are caught, the law doesn't say "it's enough that we took back what you have stolen and also everybody knows you're a thief".
This is actually often the case. Shoplifting is a hassle to prosecute unless it involves high-value items or becomes enough of a nuisance for the store. My shoplifting clients (almost always drug addicts) have gotten caught perhaps a dozen times for each prosecution they face. I've personally seen security guards forcefully take back the items and then let the person go because it wasn't worth calling the cops over it. Same with many other low-level crimes like trespassing or whatnot. Unless the business or the local authority is willing to eat the costs of enforcement (and certain places are if they're rich enough) a lot of petty crime will go unpunished.
(Side note: a lot of places explicitly prohibit their security from placing hands on thieves for lawsuits reasons, but not from the thieves, but rather from their workers getting injured).
But 95% of criminal convictions don't even see the trial - why nobody tries to at least get some guilty pleas on perjury?
It's just unusually hard to prove. Specific intent crimes are hard, proving materiality is hard, and combine that with all the other rules of evidence hurdles and it's rarely worth it. If there's clear evidence of perjury, they likely also committed other more serious crimes, so why bother? One recent prominent exception involved the police officer who arrested Sandra Bland, probably because it was a high profile case and the only thing they could really nail him on. The link cites an article that found between 1966 to 1970 there were only 335 criminal perjury cases total.
I think unless she proves she was struck by a bout of very convenient amnesia, it is pretty clear she knew the messages in fact existed. I mean, if somebody actually wanted to do it.
Miller's case is a slam dunk example of perjury, she would have no defense. The only remaining question is whether the prosecutors will bother.
I wonder though why there's no interest in prosecuting perjury at all and why we are still pretending testimony is worth anything if lying under oath has almost no consequences.
Many reasons. Perjury is extremely difficult to prove because of the knowledge element: someone has to make a statement that they knew was false at the time. How do we know that they didn't just misremember, or that they were mistaken, or that they were misled? Etc. Getting slam dunk evidence otherwise is very rare.
The other reason is that if the lying was self-evident, the negative consequences are already ensured. A lying defendant gets convicted. A lying victim gets their aggressor acquitted. A lying businessman loses the contract dispute lawsuit. A lying cop will likely never get to testify again, which means basically permanent desk duty or finding another job. And so on.
But another possibility is that regardless of how much public scrutiny their might by in terms of population numbers, there's not going to be any meaningful outrage in ways that matter, and more importantly the scrutiny that they do get they want.
This is a fair point, speaking generally. I'd like to think that every new scandal of outright venality moves the impression slightly at the margins. And the scrutiny I'm referring to applies to the defense attorney's role as well. The federal public defender bar (private and public) have a well-earned reputation of being the gold standard in the field, and that's only maximized when each one knows that every filing of theirs is going to be picked apart by an interested public (as happened in the post above!). To your point however, despite a cavalcade of outrageous conduct, there hasn't been much broad appetite to meaningfully change how the FBI operates. Just like prosecutorial misconduct, any spike in interested remains niche and therefore easy to ignore.
In a world where both the state and the individual investigator or prosecutor could be liable for large amounts, does this result in more enforcement? Or does it result in a far heavier thick blue line, where every release to defense attornies goes through four layers of 'did you redact that important thing
I didn't think about this point and I have to concede that's a strong possibility. It's basically a battle of equilibria to see whether greater openness forces greater transparency or higher efforts to maintain secrecy.
Cops are almost never criminally prosecuted for anything done in the course of their job (in part because prosecutors and cops work closely together), and perjury is virtually never prosecuted against anyone period. You're right that QI might not apply towards Miller's specific actions, because lying on the stand is clearly established as bad. However, I can't really articulate the specific harm that Miller's lying (what we know about) directly caused, so I'm not sure that Nordean can recover much. And because the discovery happened by accident, it doesn't really affect how other agents are deterred from pulling the same shit.
In terms of other consequences, I do expect Miller's career to be somewhat stunted. She can never again be called to testify in any case without the defense attorney being able to impeach her credibility by bringing up the Nordean trial saga.
After defense attorneys began to press Miller about the attorney-client messages on Wednesday afternoon, prosecutors objected, and Kelly halted the trial to permit the parties to debate the matter.
lolol this is apex whining
I can't think of any explanation except that it was a fuck-up. The original plan was to create a new log of messages with almost everything deleted and then pretend that's the only log in existence. The defense attorney would have no way of knowing any better. The plausible deniability idea doesn't make sense here because the hidden rows directly contradicted the testimony she gave in court (which Judges actually do tend to care about).
Note also that, if it is too easy to successfully sue public officials, then those officials will be extremely reluctant to pursue miscreants with deep pockets.
I hadn't considered this point before. It seems salient but can you expand upon it a bit?
It's true that there are plenty of attorneys who make a good living off of §1983 (see Benjamin Crump) but that's not really indicative of anything on its own. Lawyers are able to shift between practice areas fairly easily, and so each practice area has a self-correction mechanism in place in case any particular market gets too saturated. Ideally we'd compare the number of attorneys pursuing §1983 claims to some sort of baseline expectation, but I admit I don't have a good suggestion.
These are great resources and it's a big omission on my end that I neglected to find them on my own. Had I been asked to estimate how often QI is granted, I probably would've said 70-80%, which is clearly erroneous on my part. I'm guessing my mistake was probably borne out of the availability heuristic combined with never thinking to conduct a systemic research (something I regularly excoriate others for not doing). QI is still prevalent, and I do wonder how much it discourages marginal cases from ever being filed. Either way, I was wrong with my comparison so thanks for bringing this to my attention, I will edit my post above.
This is a bit splitting hairs over lingo but you're probably not asking about mistrials. They're virtually never in the defendant's favor because it gives the prosecution an opportunity to start over, which generally gives the government an advantage since they had a glimpse into the defense strategy. The ideal resolution here would be a dismissal, which would be final because jeopardy has attached due to the jury trial starting.
It's a bit terrifying to me how well @KulakRevolt took to Twitter, like a fish discovering water for the first time. One of his threads was effusively praised by Scott Adams during one of his livestreams, and he's also followed by Jordan Peterson of all people.
Anyway, my question is, why don't more culture warriors pursue this path, of exemplifying why their chosen philosophy is good? Am I wrong that it's the most convincing way to advocate for one's ideals? Or maybe everyone is indeed trying to do this, and most just don't seem very effective from my particular vantage point / vis-a-vis my conception of the good life?
Out of everyone that have met me, I wonder what a sample would think with regards to how well I am exemplifying my philosophy (and, whether they can even identify it)?
I don't know if this is missing context but I was talking about my work as a criminal defense attorney. I wasn't talking about FBI agents, these were just some random detectives. Across hundreds and hundreds of cases, I watch a lot of very boring video footage that mostly shows my client acting like a total dipshit and the cops being dutiful about their jobs and I get lulled into a sort of slumber. So when I do see clear instances of casual misconduct, for a moment it feels like I'm the victim of a optical illusion because it's just so damn unusual to get it on video.
The good news in this [real case I'm being super vague about] is that my job is explicitly not to assume good faith. So I conducted my own investigation and felt confident enough I did my homework before launching my broadside motion. The cops did not do well during cross-examination and the judge agreed with my argument and explicitly found them to be lying. They were very much not happy with me given the career consequences involved.
I think part of the reason Miller was comfortable lying so fragrantly is because she's not used to facing (and can reasonably expect to never) any real sort of consequence for misconduct. Part of that reason is because of the insular nature of the field (who among the people she works with are going to rat her out?) and part of it is the lack of discouragement that comes from real accountability (QI). Getting rid of QI on its own won't be enough to help uncover the misconduct, for that you need more open discovery rules such as the open-file rule. I'm indifferent on whether agents or their agency should burden the liability. At minimum, I'd want to see something closer to law enforcement facing the same accountability rules as doctors and I don't care if it's hospitals or malpractice insurers that shoulder the financial hit. Another option is to have a more robust method of criminally prosecuting obvious malfeasance, but given how the apparatus is currently constructed (cops and prosecutors are besties), I don't have a viable plan to put that into action.
Where do you see me giving the FBI any good faith? The post your responding to was a story expressing skepticism to the point of disbelief because the misconduct I witnessed was conducted so casually that I wondered if I was missing something (I wasn't).

Argh, I didn't phrase this right. What I meant is referring to a compass with a stuck needle, where you use it to claim that every direction it points to is north.
More options
Context Copy link