the risk of any real consequences for getting caught, must have been minuscule
Yep. It's extremely rare for me to find evidence of police misconduct in my own cases but one of them happened to get news coverage because I got a great ruling all thanks to some very very lucky video footage. But when I first watched the footage I couldn't believe I was interpreting what I was seeing correctly. Everyone seemed to chill that I wondered for a long time "it's not plausible that they're casually [redacted] on video, I must be misunderstanding something."
Much of the criminal justice systems operates on an assumption (or rather, an aspiration) that prosecutors and law enforcement should be trusted to carry out their duties honestly. While I don't believe this assumption is worth much, it's the reality we live in given the limited avenues for redress available. For one, prosecutors and judges have absolute immunity for misconduct, and law enforcement has qualified immunity for misconduct (which, practically speaking is basically absolute immunity with a few extra steps Edit: as @Gdanning mentions here, I significantly overstated the equivalence here). If you get fucked over by any of them, tough luck. Two, law enforcement has a close working relationship with prosecutors, and most judges are former prosecutors. Because of how the adversarial system is structured, there's a systemic bias against ruling in favor of defendants' (read: criminal's) rights. This is especially a problem when you consider that literally the only source of search and seizure precedent comes by definition from criminals asking a court to ignore damning evidence because it was illegally seized.
I just described a system where the levers of power are held by a fairly cloistered group of people, and it all skews heavily on the side against the meek defendant. There are indeed some attempts to artificially inject fairness into the system. Because civil lawsuits are assumed (not always reasonably) to involve two opposing parties on roughly equivalent footing, the evidentiary standard there is preponderance, which is basically 50% plus one. But for criminal trials, where it's the full weight of the government bearing down on a single person, it's beyond a reasonable doubt, which is basically you better goddamn be real fucking sure. Another difference pertinent for this post is what would be referred to as Brady obligations, where prosecutors are obligated to turn over every evidence which might be helpful to the defendant (who, unlike a civil litigant, has no equivalent obligation to the other side).
For the most part, verifying that a prosecutor has met their Brady obligations is near-impossible. Prosecutors are considered part of law enforcement, and they naturally have access to an entire universe of information which the other side will never see (for example, details about ongoing investigations which would tip off the subjects if it was revealed prematurely) so whether or not they've turned over every Brady material is an exercise in trust. I have to trust that the prosecutors aren't lying, and that they reviewed all the evidence they have and made a fair assessment on whether or not it's exculpatory. This is why virtually every Brady scandal involves exculpatory evidence that came to light accidentally. A fuck-up, in other words.
And oh man was there ever a fuck-up.
This happened this week during the jury trial of Ethan Nordean, a Proud Boys leader charged with seditious conspiracy stemming from his actions in January 6th. I haven't followed his case at all, but his defense attorney just filed this banger of a notice regarding the testimony of FBI agent Nicole Miller. As a government witness, Miller has an obligation to turn over any written statements she made regarding the subject of her testimony (this is known as a Jencks obligation). FBI agents use an instant messaging system called Lync, and Miller handed over a spreadsheet with 25 rows of Lync messages. Miller testified that this was her entire Jencks obligations, and she denied withholding any messages about Nordean's conspiracy charges, denied withholding any messages about whether anyone listened in on attorney-client calls, and denied withholding any messages about whether any reports (dear heavens) were falsified. And so forth. Miller just said no, absolutely not, no way.
Normally this is where the story would end, except Nordean's attorney revealed that the spreadsheet Miller had sent contained about a thousand hidden Excel rows, many of which absolutely one hundred percent directly contradicted Miller's testimony. For example, there were messages about:
-
An agent asking Miller to edit a confidential informant report to remove mentioning the agent was present
-
An agent reviewing attorney-client communication about trial strategy
-
Agents openly expressing doubt about a Proud Boys leader's involvement in a conspiracy
And so on.
I'm certainly excited to see how Miller tries to get out of this vise. My assumption is that the prosecutor will dismiss charges against Nordean in a feeble attempt to make this go away (or a judge can do it for them, which is what happened with the Bundy ranchers).
It's certainly fucking funny that an FBI agent tried hiding Excel rows thinking they were deleted (this is known as the peek-a-boo fallacy). More seriously, FBI agents are acting this brazenly even though they're well aware how much public scrutiny is directed towards J6 cases. I think one can reasonably assume they'd have even fewer scruples in cases involving defendants no one gives a shit about.
Some jurisdictions (starting with North Carolina in 2004) have what's called an open-file discovery rule where everything in the case file (no matter how banal) is provided to the defendant by default. Tucker Carlson got access to and released footage of Jacob Chansley (aka QAnon shaman who was sentenced to 41 months in prison) calmly walking inside the capitol, which appears to contradict his charging documents. More relevantly, Chansley's attorney apparently never got that footage before. I assume the government will now argue that the footage they kept hidden wasn't that exculpatory but really, that should always be up to the defense attorney to decide.
Of course, even if open-file became the norm, law enforcement will get wise not to put incriminating statements on paper (hot tip: when doing FOIA requests, pay attention to any email or text that asks to speak on the phone about a sensitive subject). So beyond open-file discovery, I'd also keep riding my other cute little hobby horses and argue this is another reason to jettison qualified/absolute immunity. Anyone disagree?
the first premise of my statement rejects this exact assumption of good-faith governance as unjustifiable. your response was to reassert that assumption without substantiation.
No, I don't have to assume good faith. All I'm asking is for you substantiate your asserted premise. If you're saying that they did abdicate their duties and incentives, it would be helpful to explain why instead of just saying saying so.
US, why?
I agree that Oberlin's statements are even more damning in context, but as you saw in the court decision each claim was evaluated in isolation. The "long history" claim was found to be defamatory on its own (¶33), without including the specific allegation of assault (which was dealt with separately in ¶34, with the claim about the owner dealt with separately again in ¶35). Your argument that the comparison is unwarranted because Oberlin's statement contained specific allegations of assault/choking is demonstrably not true. Setting that disagreement aside, do you, personally, believe that Oberlin claiming the bakery had a "long account of racial profiling and discrimination" on its own should count as an actionable statement of fact for purposes of defamation? Yes or no?
It is, indeed, much different from the MSJ in the present case.
Certainly, and the circumstances are very different too. For one, that was the defendant's MSJ. Plaintiff MSJs for defamation are virtually unheard of, because defamation is so fact-dependent and MSJ require there to be virtually no disagreement on the facts.
This is true, it's generally very difficult to win a defamation case but then again few cases have the treasure trove of evidence that Dominion got a hold of.
Do you agree that Oberlin should not have been found liable for defamation based on the statement I highlighted? Like you mentioned, it's like "racism".
Well, the issue is there was no water main break but they did stop counting / sent people home so the question is why. Perhaps it was merely incompetence but it just looks suspicious. Once again, none of this is proof. And until you have proof the election result should stand.
Well it's helpful to specify suspicious of what, exactly? The theory (as best as I can understand it) is that someone made up a story of a water main break to get poll watchers to leave, in order to...pull out suitcases full of ballots in front of several security cameras? The water main break / overflowing urinal story makes a lot more sense as an instance of a game of telephone combined with the media's shoddy record with reporting breaking news.
Also, Giuliani didn’t publicize the story.
Sorry I wasn't clear, Giuliani publicized the "suitcases of ballots" security camera footage.
I concede that I have a very difficult time understanding your posts, and it's possible it's a 'me' problem (English is my third language after all) and I'm sorry it comes off as if I'm acting in bad faith. If you ever change your mind, I think a very useful thing you could do is structure your arguments in a more transparent manner, something I try to do as well. For example:
Premise A > Premise B > Conclusion
So for the above you could say something like (I don't know if this is your actual point, it's just an example):
-
Premise A The leaky urinal was first reported by the media as a water main break
-
Premise B The water main break prompted poll watchers to go home
-
Premise D Only election officials could have reasonably been the source of this original information to the media
-
Conclusion Therefore, the changing story is evidence of election officials fabricating a plumbing emergency to get election scrutinizers to go home
...and so forth
I don't know if I have a critical thinking fetish or something, but I find the structure above significantly more elegant and transparent, and I wouldn't need to ask so many annoying questions in my attempt to understand your point.
You can admit that surely
I already did two posts above in an edit
I asked clarifying questions because the posts were quite ambiguous. Understanding the specific point being made allows me to better engage with the direct content.
TTV nevertheless decided to go public by releasing a widely-publicized documentary, despite acting as if assisting law enforcement is just a step too far. Their behavior makes perfect sense when you realize only the former makes them money.
You'd eliminate the or statement.
Ok that does indeed make it more factual by mitigating some ambiguity. But if so, you're presenting an extremely high standard for defamation, one I don't believe is reflected in any jurisdiction. For example, the statement from the Gibson's Bakery (linked above) that it had a "long account of racial profiling and discrimination" is similar to what you described as:
basically like saying "racism". They guest then states a wildly speculative position that contains a mixture of facts and opinion.
The court in that case found that it was a statement of fact. If you were to apply the standard you outlined in a consistent manner, you would disagree with that part of the Oberlin decision. Am I incorrect?
It looks like a political document masquerading like a legal document.
I'm assuming that you could only come to this conclusion if you've read multiple defamation motions summary judgment in order to get a sense of what the landscape looks like. If so, can you link to a MSJ that you believe meets your standards?
in what universe is it reasonable to believe that the media reported anything other than what they were told by the election officials?
Because there were other people at State Farm arena, including members of the press. Anyone one of them could have seen the overflowed urinal and assumed it was a water leak, or heard it from the janitor, or whatever. I don't get what this episode teaches us except that we should be skeptical of breaking news, I gather you disagree? If we somehow had a Zapruder film of the men's bathroom from that night, what would it tell us?
Probably for the same reason the media gets any other developing story wrong, like when they first reported the San Bernardino shooters as "three white men". It's a game of telephone and a rush to be the first with a scoop, and I don't understand why you'd find this bit so salient. If you're being consistent, would you then also have reason to suspect Rizwan Farook and Tashfeen Malik were not the real shooters?
I apologize, I realize now that I misread your response. I didn't realize that your "Don't restart counting..." was a direct response to my "What do you wish was done differently?" and I lost the conversation thread in between checking notifications.
I understand that Powell is disfavored nowadays but she remains relevant as a showcase for the intense credulity many showcased at the time (including at the highest level of government). I recognize her existence is inconvenient for those who wish to believe election fraud allegations were made in good faith, but it's nevertheless still reality. It's not a weakman if it was enthusiastically endorsed at the time. The water main break story was first publicized by Giuliani claiming they were pulling out suitcases of ballots. Giuliani is also an example of somehow displaying intense credulity (or at least motivated reasoning). The water main break story keeps getting replayed and I still don't understand what the core claim is, aside from just vaguely generating smoke. @zeke5123 said "still hasn’t been fully explained" but I genuinely have no idea which part is missing, which is why my questions were about the investigation and how it could've been done differently.
I don't think that it makes much sense though from the POV that others could have replicated the GPS data and said it was false.
The geolocation data doesn't need to be false for TTV to be lying about its salience. The dozens of motivated orgs you reference did try to investigate the allegations and they didn't find anything worth pursuing. I seriously have no idea what the parallel to the race IQ debate you're making is, but I agree with this:
You have to look at where incentives are.
TTV financially depends on a credulous audience to make their money. This audience will only pay attention if the story TTV is hyping up is kept on life support. Since TTV is lying about the evidence it has, they would be conclusively outed as frauds if they show it to law enforcement. Since their interest is in continuing to make content for a gullible audience, they have an anti-interest in helping law enforcement. TTV then either make up excuses for being cagey or just lie out right about helping law enforcement when they didn't. Their audience is already self-selected for gullibility, so TTV's excuses maintain some currency where it matters.
I appreciate you took the time to dive into this. To help us both, we can reference as a template the standard utilized in the Gibson's Bakery defamation lawsuit that Oberlin University lost. Starting on page 11 of the appeal, you can see an example of how to determine whether a statement is factual, and an important factor is whether or not it's "verifiable". So something like "this painting is beautiful" is not verifiable, while "this painting was made by Bob" is.
I would agree with you that Baritomo's "irregularities" is too ambiguous to be a statement of fact.
Regarding Powell's statement:
"That is where the fraud took place, where they were flipping votes in the computer system or adding votes that did not exist"
If you believe this is too speculative to be considered a statement of fact, how would you edit the sentence to make it less speculative? I highlighted the pertinent clauses and I literally cannot contemplate how to make it any more of a statement of fact. Either fraud happened or did not. If the fraud happened, either it happened in the computer systems or not. Either Dominion flipped votes or not. Either they added votes or did not. Virtually everything she said is a statement of fact, and I don't know by what standard you're using to say otherwise.
Regarding Dobbs' example, I don't know how else to interpret the phrase "which were designed to be inaccurate" except to describe intent. Either the system was designed or it wasn't, and if it was designed either it was designed to be inaccurate or it wasn't. This is especially lucid considering it's in the context of Powell's theory that she's "identified mathematically the exact algorithm they used and planned to use from the beginning to modify the votes in this case to make sure Biden won"
Your last paragraph is what we in the business call conclusory. You're just making a claim without explaining its basis. I don't know your expertise with defamation law, but if you can confidently assert that the MSJ is not "related to the law in any way" I would assume you can show your work easily. Quoting a 90s comedy unfortunately doesn't count.
Do you believe that it's just too implausible to think TTV avoided providing evidence to law enforcement because...they lied about ever having any? You do realize that your explanation is just replaying the dragon in my garage story of excuses almost beat by beat. If that doesn't interest you, I also have an old family recipe for steamed hams.
if you don't want people accusing you of fraud, don't engage in fraud-like activity in the first place.
This is really good advice in general, except it wouldn't have mattered here. Sidney Powell accepted a source on election fraud that claimed they got their info from the wind and she still accused people of fraud in a very public and legal manner. Some folks in this crowd were primed to believe anything unfortunately.
Sure, I said I'm open to innocent explanations. I don't know what the innocent explanation to someone choosing to devote the time to responding, but instead of addressing an uncomfortable question, they pull a "look over there!" move
What do you believe is missing? What do you believe should have been done differently with the investigation (if anything)?
I don't understand why you are being so vague. The uncharitable explanation is that you wish to avoid having your opinion scrutinized. So:
Which one are you referring to and why didn't it pass muster? What do you wish was done differently?
The attempt to refute the water main break story never passed mustered.
Which one are you referring to and why didn't it pass muster? What do you wish was done differently?
An unanswered question is very weak evidence of someone doing so because they're uncomfortably challenged because there's plenty of innocent explanations for why someone wouldn't respond (e.g. touch grass, etc.). The context of what I was responding to here is an instance of someone having the time and nevertheless acrobatically evading the question. This scenario is strong evidence of my assertion.

It will never stop being funny that fucking Call of Duty felt the need to weigh in
More options
Context Copy link