Stitcher feed hasn't been updating for some reason but I'll try to get it fixed. Please let me know of any other technical difficulties.
The popcorn tastes unusually good this week.
This may be seen as consolation: the Law remains the substantial aspect of the culture, and enterprises of these Twitter radicals are simulacra, a painted mask that can flake off under real heat. But consider: a Law becomes void if enough people deny its legitimacy. We shake our heads at quaint laws that have stayed on the books; and they are typically worked around, reduced to trivia, almost fiction. In other words: the mask and the shoggoth can trade places. Like in Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius, fiction can consume reality; yesterday's modus tollens will become modus ponens and so on.
I should point out that this has already happened in certain parts of the law. I mentioned this in my review of David Bernstein's Classified book:
The most cogent illustration for how race categories metastasize into a distraction is by examining government-mandated "minority preferences." In the early 1980s, Congress tasked some federal agencies (primarily the Small Business Administration and Department of Transportation) to set aside a portion of their grants to businesses that are "owned and controlled by socially and economically disadvantaged individuals." These programs are usually referred to by the moniker Disadvantaged Business Enterprise, or DBE. Almost immediately, "socially disadvantaged" was interpreted to refer only to racial discrimination, and the relevant regulations declared that any enterprise owned by a racial minority would be presumptively deemed "disadvantaged." Bernstein does not directly provide an explanation for this peculiar shift, but in all likelihood proving whether someone has been "socially and economically disadvantaged" for each individual applicant would likely have been too administratively burdensome to be practical. Yet this also meant the opportunity to have a nuanced investigation into the question of disadvantage was entirely quashed by just checking the right box.
A federal law meant to address "disadvantage" was functionally transformed into a sort of racial reparations program. If whites/men by definition cannot be "disadvantaged", then no harm done apparently. DBE funding is definitely a place where the "racism equals power plus" crowd achieved a practical victory within the legal system. The legal acrobatics around racial discrimination in college admissions are another.
Interesting, thanks for linking. I can understand colleges not caring to change themselves, but does he ever describe whether the colleges are ignoring court orders?
Yep, so has David French. I agree with their efforts.
If they aren't going to be held responsible, it would be good to examine why that is
The most obvious answer is that you're legally shit out of luck if the government fails you. @gattsuru posted clear and egregious examples of governments utterly failing at their most basic duty of protecting their citizens, including Warren v. DC. That's a case where three women called the police during a home invasion. The cops showed up, casually looked around, then shrugged and left. The three women were beaten and raped over the next 14 hours. SCOTUS told everyone to pound sand because the state doesn't owe you shit.
Though practically abhorrent, the ruling is legally well-founded. With sovereign immunity as the well-established default, there's nothing within the four corners of the constitution that imposes any obligation on the state to lift a finger. The attenuated recourse is that maybe someday enough people are pissed that they get voted out of power. Passing a law or an amendment could fix this issue, but there isn't much appetite for it.
I hope you understand that I'm not disagreeing with you.
All I was saying is that if officials are not being prosecuted here, it's not because the statute is lacking.
If you make it possible to sue police officers for honest mistakes
That's basically the same steelman I offered, but I don't understand this part. Who actually thinks that getting rid of QI means that cops can be punished for honest mistakes? My interpretation of "honest mistake" would be something less than negligence, but even if we assume the latter, is there a profession that is currently facing short-staffing because of worry over negligence liability?
So you made an assumption I wasn't talking about budgets but included an entire comment about budgets as the bulk of your reply? Do you do that sort of thing much?
I apologize if my comment wasn't clear. I should have been more explicit that I did not know what exactly you were referring to with the "zero support from cities" phrase. The reason I included the comment about budgets was to demonstrate the difficulties inherent in responding to ambiguous statements, such as: "I think by Y you mean X, but Z facts contradict X, so my interpretation of Y is probably wrong."
your phrasing that qualified immunity is bad bc you highlighted the worst aspects of it and leaving out everything else. Maybe you don't know what chesteron's fence is? Would that be very difficult for you to ask?
Fair point, I had a mistaken understanding of Chesterton's Fence and I either should've asked or looked it up. I definitely have examined why Qualified Immunity remains in force, but none of the theories paint the people involved in a good light. Put simply, QI exists because institutions have an inherent bias in favor of agents of the state and against the typical victims of state violence. The best steelman I can contemplate about QI is that there is a benefit to having a police force that errs on the side of too much force rather than too little, and that allowing victims of state violence to pursue compensation would harm everyone because it will result in a police force that is too skittish. I ultimately don't find this argument convincing for several reasons, namely because it's self-serving and because this hypothetical concern does not appear to be reflected in professions that lack QI. For example, if you asked doctors whether they'd support a law that made them immune from liability, I see no reason why any of them would say no, and I would expect them to raise similar objections (e.g. "why would anyone risk operating on a patient if they can sued?"). There may be problems with the medical industry, but I can't identify a concern that is a result of doctors being too afraid to do their job for fear of liability, so I don't see why this objection should be taken seriously when raised by other professions.
You're correct, I linked to a more complete answer.
While you seem very opinionated on the subject and know more about it than I do. Phrasing things like that tunes a lot of people out.
It's true that I am very opinionated, but I try to be fully transparent about why I believe what I believe. That way you don't have to have to take my word for anything and the foundation of my opinions are susceptible to attack (as intended). What phrasing are you referring to?
The rest of your post is difficult to respond to because I assume you're being intentionally hyperbolic with your phrasing. This can be fun/useful as a stylistic point sometimes, but too much and the lack of clarity becomes a hindrance to discussion. For example, I don't know what "zero support from cities" is supposed to mean. If I encountered the phrase "the government has increased its support to NASA", I think a reasonable interpretation is that NASA was given more resources in the form of a higher budget. But if we examine that facet, we see that the vast majority of cities are increasing their police budgets, including in blue enclaves like Los Angeles (up 9.4% from 2019 to $3.86B), San Francisco (up 4%), and Chicago (up 15%). I assume you'll respond to say that you were referencing something other than budgets, but it would be helpful for all if you just wrote plainly from the beginning.
You're correct to point out that my answer was incomplete. The default state is sovereign immunity, where anything the government does is by definition not illegal or criminal. Of course, governments can choose to waive immunity, which is why people are allowed to sue a city bus for running them over or something. For criminal prosecutions, there is a legal obstacle and a practical one. Sovereign immunity protects criminal prosecutions, as is the case in a recent SCOTUS case involving prosecution of a Turkish bank and as Nicaraguan President Manuel Noriega tried to have happen. Those examples are both foreign sovereigns, and the law for domestic sovereigns is a bit more complicated and depends on the jurisdiction. Sometimes criminal laws create an intentional double standard depending on whether the person committing the act is an agent of the state or not, as was the case until recently in Washington state where a police officer charged with murder required the prosecutor to prove "evil intent" (something not required when prosecuting a peasant). Beyond the state-specific carve-outs, there's the practical reality of governments generally being reluctant to punish one of their own. This reluctance is sharpest with police officers given the intimate working relationship they have with prosecutors. It still happens (as it did with Chauvin) but only in extreme circumstances, not as a matter of course.
Those reasons explain why criminal prosecutions are both legally and practically rare, something which would be politically difficult to change, because why would the government choose to ruin a good thing? At this point the only alternative method of redress if a government official commits a wrong is a civil suit. §1983 and similar laws explicitly waive sovereign immunity to allow civil suits, and made the field wide open. The text plainly stated that any citizen could sue every official acting under color of any law for any violations of any rights. And as relative outsiders, civil attorneys wouldn't have the same reluctance about going after "one of their own". That's at least the ideal, except as you saw, Qualified Immunity has significantly gutted §1983's previously open field to the point where it's functionally worthless.
Qualified immunity doesn't explain the whole story, but it is a significant reason behind the nobility's lack of accountability.
Those are all very good points. I wouldn't say that a conviction here would be easy, but prosecutors have chased after plenty of far more ethereal charges before (and sometimes won). All I was saying is that if officials are not being prosecuted here, it's not because the statute is lacking. Compare that to the Loudoun County Schoolboard issue, which was stymied by the lack of a witness tampering law on the books in Virginia.
What are the obvious reasons? I'm aware of qualified immunity being rolled back in only a handful of jurisdictions. Were you referring to something else?
Thanks for this, how does it work exactly? Does it always allow you to circumvent paywalls?
Washington has an evidence tampering criminal statute. Although the statute says physical evidence, there's at least once case where someone was convicted for trying to break a cell phone to hide incriminating text messages. I'm sure a creative prosecutor can find way more relevant statutes.
Ever heard of Qualified Immunity? It protects state agents from consequences of conduct which, if done by a peasant, would otherwise result in criminal sanctions. Detectives can lie on the stand, prosecutors can hide exculpatory evidence, jail officers can scald the skin off a prisoner, cops can even kill people, and there's basically nothing you can do about it.
edit: this answer was incomplete, I expand upon it here.
People in the private sector get fined and jailed for fucking up all the time, and there doesn't seem to be a shortage of competent applicants for those positions despite the risk. Why not?
Don't sanction the city, sanction the people. The city didn't delete texts, people did. Throw those people in jail, fine them until they are destitute, and make an example that misconduct is punished personally.
I completely agree, but Qualified immunity would like to have a word with you. If cops can steal $225k during the execution of a search warrant with no repercussions, what makes you think anything anything would happen here?
Even if you're trouncing your opponents in a lawfight it can be smart to settle because juries are weird and unpredictable.
Remember Seattle's CHAZ/CHOP? After the place was cleared, a bunch of local businesses and property owners sued the city and now they all reached a settlement. One part that definitely didn't help Seattle were tens of thousands of deleted text messages:
The city of Seattle has settled a lawsuit that took aim at officials’ handling of the three-week Capitol Hill Organized Protests and further ensnared the former mayor and police chief, among others, in a scandal over thousands of deleted text messages. The Seattle City Attorney’s Office filed notice of a settlement Wednesday in U.S. District Court, just three weeks after a federal judge levied severe legal sanctions against the city for deleting texts between high-ranking officials during the protests and zone that sprung up around them, known as CHOP.
[...]
Attorneys for the more than a dozen businesses that sued the city, led by Seattle developer Hunters Capital, sent a series of letters to the city in July 2020 — after another lawsuit over the violent police response to the protests — demanding that any evidence pertaining to the city’s alleged support and encouragement of the zone’s creation be retained, according to the court docket and pleadings.
U.S. District Judge Thomas Zilly concluded last month that officials ignored the notifications, sending the so-called Hunters Capital lawsuit to trial on two of five claims and dismissing three others. In doing so, Zilly issued a blistering order that leveled crippling sanctions against the city for the deletion of tens of thousands of text messages from city phones sent between former Mayor Jenny Durkan, former police Chief Carmen Best, fire Chief Harold Scoggins and four other ranking city officials during the protests.
The judge found significant evidence that the destruction of CHOP evidence was intentional and that officials tried for months to hide the text deletions from opposing attorneys.
Great post! I really appreciate the absurd amount of effort you put into your posts.
it's not clear how well the whole framework operates to resolve or discourage abuses of the court system. In this specific context, there's also quibbles about how much a million dollars matters to Facebook, compared to the cost of just their testifying internal experts nevermind the rest of the court case, but there's a deeper issue.
I agree. I have to assume that Facebook and Gibson Dunn went through all this obstructionist trouble because it was financially worthwhile. Just based on the ridiculous $725 million settlement amount, this had to have paid off dividends. The sanction in this particular case is less about the monetary amount and more about how the scathing rebuke from a federal judge can open the floodgates in future litigation. I imagine there is a certain apprehension from judges about pissing off Big Law, but if I was an attorney seeking sanctions against either Gibson Dunn or Facebook, you bet I will repeatedly drone on about how "parties/counsel have repeatedly engaged in this kind of behavior, as evidenced by the sanctions imposed recently". I have to deal with (what I think are) prosecutorial misconduct issues at work, and I constantly file motions complaining about issues I know will go nowhere. The best that I can hope for from the bench that is almost entirely former prosecutors is that eventually the pile will get too big to ignore.
Even as someone that's put a decent amount of effort into learning the lingo, it's hard to remember how rough a lot of the standards and formatting are for outsiders, here.
The points you bring up are something I hadn't considered. I really dislike the convention of inline citations in legal opinions, but I assumed everyone glossed over them like I did. I can see it being an issue if for example a citation to a transcript isn't recognized as such by the reader. That's relevant context missing. The problems with the different numbers you see on opinions is something I struggle with myself whenever I encounter an outside jurisdiction, but isn't really an issue if you're reading just one document no? I completely overlooked the problem with how certain common words have very specific legal meanings ("motion" is the most obvious).
I don't deny what happened to Clement and Murphy was very odd and reprehensible, and I agree that getting booted from Kirkland & Ellis was definitely a set-back. Nevertheless, their new boutique firm seems to be doing well and growing fast.
Still curious about these questions:
-
You said that lower courts tend to apply very different standards of discrimination based on race. Can you provide any examples?
-
You said that very few attorneys are willing to take these cases lest they be subject to cancellation. What is it about the Pacific Legal Foundation that lets them thrive despite this spectre? What can other organizations do to replicate their resilience?
True but has it been established that the likelihood of success is low? SCOTUS already explicitly prohibited discrimination against men. @YouEssAyyy posted an example of a white man winning a $10 million verdict for anti-white and anti-male discrimination. Apples are there to be picked.

No, someone else pointed this out. I'll need to get that and Stitcher fixed but meanwhile the other places should work.
More options
Context Copy link