they apply very different standards of discrimination based on race. The lower courts ALSO tend to do this.
Can you provide any examples?
The Seattle case I linked above is being pursued by the nonprofit Pacific Legal Foundation. They're also responsible for similar cases, like litigating anti-Asian discrimination at Thomas Jefferson High School and California's "women in boardrooms" quota law. Somehow they seem immune from the spectre of cancellation you're describing. What do you think explains their unique bravery?
My impression is that employees pushing this stuff don't bother asking the in-house attorney because they don't even suspect that it's illegal.
It's well established that there has long been a concerted effort by the left to narrow the definition of racism to ONLY apply when the discrimination is done against an oppressed racial minority. Under the revised definition, "anti-white racism" cannot be a thing. Although this redefinition may be fashionable among certain circles, it has never been reflected in anti-discrimination law within the United States. All the relevant civil rights laws I am aware of prohibit discrimination on the basis of race, full stop, without any qualifiers. Yet the "racism = power plus prejudice" crowd appears to be under the mistaken impression that discrimination against white people is legal.
A significant portion of the contemporary DEI training curricula is blatantly anti-white, and I've been curious why there have not been more legal challenges on that front. Part of it, I assume, is that any plaintiff who takes on this role will be subjected to a vicious public campaign of hate, as happened with Abigail Fisher in 2016, derided with nicknames like "Becky with the bad grades" and so on.
We haven't really had a case that dealt with the particular type of DEI training that became prominent after the 2020 summer protests/riots. One lawsuit recently filed in Seattle might be an interesting test case for this. Robby Soave covers this:
According to Diemert, a supervisor berated him for refusing to step down and yield his job to a person of color. He says he was asked, "What could a straight white male possibly offer our department?" And he says he was frequently made to participate in RSJI training, which involved insulting games and activities designed to address his alleged complicity in white supremacy.
[...]
RSJI's explicit mission statement was to inject race-based considerations into government work. One document summarizing the initiative's priorities listed colorblindness, not as a positive thing, but as a hindrance to be overcome. Another described colorblindness as "centering whiteness." Diemert says that his former colleagues took this mission very seriously. In fact, he discovered that one coworker had rejected a qualified white applicant from a public assistance program specifically because of the applicant's race. "I asked her, well, this doesn't make sense to me," he recalled. "Why did you deny this person? And she said, well, because they have white privilege." Diemert says he reported the matter to his supervisor—it was, in his view, obvious racial discrimination—but nothing was done about it.
I don't believe the legal system is a panacea, but it can offer a useful contrast in terms of how arguments that may be popular on Twitter get handled inside a courtroom. A related example that comes to mind was when a leftist activist tried to use a copyright lawsuit as a pretext to punish Sargon of Akkad but instead lost badly and was forced to pay $38k in attorney's fees. So I'm excited to see a real life lawyer try to defend Seattle's anti-white training in court. Should be fun.
Sorry, my original comment was mod-hatted and referenced the wrong part of the rules as you point out. I thought I caught my error fast enough with my edit. You are correct that a submission statement is not necessary, it's still appreciated though.
The rules do say:
A submission statement is highly appreciated
You can add a quick comment to your post either with your own words or just copy a block quote.
It might be best to read the excerpts in context. Chang's 370-page (!!) deposition is here. In fairness, the deposition took place on Dec 2021 and she was asked about an email she sent in 2013. I personally have no difficulties recalling rough details about cases I worked on in that time period and Chang also had the benefit of spending 9 hours "preparing" for the deposition with Gibson Dunn attorneys and also had ready access to emails she herself wrote. I flatly don't believe she's being honest here.
As a related follow-up to my recent post on a judge sanctioning Trump and his attorney for almost $1 million, another judge (Obama appointee FWIW) has also levied a $1 million sanction on Facebook and their attorney, the powerhouse law firm Gibson Dunn.
Here's the link to the 53-page opinion. The core issue is a discovery dispute, something trivially common with civil litigation. Some people sued Facebook for privacy violations following the revelations that Facebook may have been less than honest about what user information they share with 3rd party app developers (related to the Cambridge Analytica scandal). The plaintiffs were legally entitled to discovery, which is the vehicle that allows them to ask Facebook to disclose records that may be used against them in litigation. As an example, consider something minor like a trip and fall case in a grocery store involving cantaloupe displays. Once they get past the initial stages by demonstrating they probably have a valid claim, the person suing the store can investigate the issue by demanding that the store turn over all relevant evidence, including emails, memos, text messages, calendar invites titled "we need to address the cantaloupe display problem" and so on. Unless the information is protected by some sort of legal privilege (e.g. the manager of the store emailing the company's attorney for legal advice) then the store is required to hand over the rope that may be used to hang them. Some of the stuff uncovered can be extremely damaging and for that reason alone you can imagine why there might be some reluctance on the part of the store. Too bad, so sad.
That's basically what happened in this case, spanning across more than three years: a fuckton of stonewalling from Gibson Dunn and Facebook employees who were deposed for questioning. For example, the plaintiffs found evidence that although Facebook claimed they closed an access loophole for information about users' friends, they actually kept the gates open (referred to as "whitelisting") for some 3rd party apps they considered especially valuable. This example from page 27 is illustrative of the stonewalling:
Several months earlier, the plaintiffs had deposed Chang. When asked whether she was “making a recommendation [in the email]…for how to deal with integrations that involve strategic value,” Chang responded, “I don’t remember specifically, so I don’t know how to answer that.” Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 106. She didn’t “remember enough to say” that the email was about the loss of access to read stream and friend data permissions. Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 107. Indeed, she could not recall what it meant to use “read stream and friend data” at all. Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 108. When asked if she could offer her “best understanding” of what her email meant, she said she couldn’t “speculate.” Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 108. When asked, “Tell me everything you can remember about your involvement in figuring out which partners should continue to have access to friends permissions,” Chang responded, “So, again, I don’t remember.” Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 119.
Chang’s testimony about her email is representative of her deposition more broadly: Although Facebook’s internal documents suggest that Chang was extensively involved in the whitelisting process, she remembered almost nothing about it. See, e.g., Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 170–71. At one point in the deposition, Chang testified that she could not remember what the term whitelisting meant at all. Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 220. She had no memory of the deprecation of friend permissions. Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 96. She did not remember that Facebook had ever allowed apps to access friends’ information. Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 70. Although she was being deposed in a case involving the Cambridge Analytica scandal and said she had met with Facebook’s lawyers for around nine hours to prepare, she claimed she did not know that the scandal was related to Facebook’s practice of sharing friends’ information. Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 17, 292–93.
Chang resisted other questions as well. When asked if the email was “the best evidence of what you were thinking at the time you wrote” it, Chang responded, “I don’t know.” Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 133. When asked if there was anything that could refresh her recollection, Chang responded, “I don’t know what I don’t know, so I can’t make that assumption that I would know.” Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 134. When asked if the email was a “good guide of what you were thinking about the topics discussed,” Chang said that would require her to “speculate.” Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 135. When asked again, Chang said she didn’t know what “good” meant. Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 136. At another point in the deposition, Chang said she didn’t know what the phrase “general understanding” meant. Dkt. No. 1103-24 at 76.
I recommend reading the full opinion† as it has a lot more juicy examples. Facebook already agreed to settle this case for $725 million, so a $1 million penalty is basically a rounding error at this point. Still, it is very unusual for a judge not just to openly lambast but also personally sanction a big law firm like Gibson Dunn. There's an impression among big law firms that they're too important to scold and part of what justifies their eye-watering bill is that you're summoning an esper to the lawfight that will browbeat and flatten your opponent through sheer presence. It's difficult to walk away from the judge's opinion in this case with any ideation that either Facebook or their lawyers were acting in good faith, so the penalties seem more than appropriate here. Sanctions against attorneys are extremely rare, generally they only happen if you fuck with a client's money, so I'm hopeful this is an omen towards more frequent attorney spankings. I have nothing to worry about myself because it's not like leopards would eat my face.
† I know I'm a lawyer but I personally find that the vast majority of legal opinions I encounter are written with the aim of making them readable and accessible by the general public. Am I off-base?
I've heard this possibility floated by others but it doesn't seem plausible in this instance. There was virtually no pushback I could identify, and we instead got a LOT of obfuscation over the core issue.
Back in the 2020's polarizing summer of rage, there was a moment of outrage that was uncharacteristically unifying: The Smithsonian's "White Culture" infographic.
As I wrote at the time, the lessons imparted by this purportedly "anti-racist" infographic are virtually indistinguishable from what real life white supremacists would argue. The List immediately offended everyone and the Smithsonian quickly walked back, claiming it was misunderstood.
Fast forward to a few days ago when Ryan Grim published an exclusive interview with Tema Okun, the original creator of The List, claiming that everyone got it "all wrong." If the goal was to get me to click well it fucking worked because I listened to the entire podcast episode and...I have no idea in what way Okun's work was at all misinterpreted or otherwise gotten "wrong".
Let's start at the beginning. I previously tried to track down The List's origin but gave up after I only found xeroxed pamphlets. Turns out that Okun wrote The List in a fit of frustration, without any research whatsoever:
I went to a meeting and it was a very frustrating and horrible meeting. And I came home and I sat in front of the computer. And the article literally came through me onto the computer. It was not researched. I didn't sit down and deliberate. It just came through me. And I've never had that experience with my writing, before or since.
So she just pulled this out of thin air, but notice what she considers as validation that she was onto something (emphasis mine):
The tragic relevance of the list was reinforced a few years later when I was co-facilitating a workshop at a national conference of progressive attorneys and law students. We asked participants to work in small groups, looking for ways in which these characteristics show up in their personal and organizational lives. Asked to report, one young student spoke for her group, sharing that the list represents all the characteristics taught by law schools as essential to success in the profession. And that's exactly the point -- our institutions not only value these characteristics, they to some extent require them and constantly reproduce them in order to benefit from them, which is why they are so prevalent in our culture and institutions.
The burning question on my mind throughout, a curiosity Grim apparently does not share, is what makes any of this part of "white" culture? They finally try to address a concrete example, sort of, when they discuss how "urgency" as a value of "white culture" is lampooned. Grim sets the stage by citing examples of how The List is weaponized by bad actors seeking an excuse to shirk at work (e.g. "deadlines are white culture"). But as proof that urgency is a value of white culture, Okun cites a non-sequitur story about how some lawyers at a legal nonprofit got distracted from a anti-racist workshop to address an activist's arrest. The conceit on display here is jaw dropping, Okun is literally complaining about an emergency interrupting* her own anti-racist workshop*:
And when we as facilitators tried to say: Can we take a pause, and just sit down together and figure out what we're going to do in a way that meets this dynamic that we've just been talking about? The answer was: No, we don't have time, we can't possibly do that, we don't have time, no, no, no.
So in the middle of a workshop meant to help and support them to deal with the ways in which their culture was perpetuating racism, they were unable to stop. And that's what I mean by There's just the sense that things are so urgent, we can't possibly pause for anything. So we lose the ability to pause for anything. And people get run over in that situation. And it just keeps things in place.
I don't know if I'm stating the obvious here, but nothing about this tells us that "urgency" is bad per se, let alone how any of it is a value of "white culture" specifically. It seems at least possible that the activist's arrest was more important than her training, even from the narrow perspective of "perpetuating racism", but Okun appears incapable of entertaining that idea.
Ryan Grim is not someone I would have recognized as wary of critiquing leftist shibboleths, but I have no explanation for the uncharacteristic lack of pushback he displayed throughout the interview with Tema Okun. If anyone was looking for evidence that the DEI industry is and has been a sham with self-perpetuation as its primary measure of success, Okun's own words are the rotary excavator digging its hole.
What you outline is plausible, but doesn't seem very significant of a risk to me. Sales pitch bots are going to be an annoyance that users would want to avoid, so that would temper any platform that doesn't do a good job of reining them in. Canned responses as you point out already exist now and at least for business communications I don't think recipients will care who generated what. The concern here is more about friendly communication, and humans have a long tradition of using costly signals as a way to communicate care (see e.g. how "handwritten letters" remain valued).
This was very interesting and gratuitously well-sourced!
Accusations of biased coverage aren't mentioned at all - just some talk about how offensive the guy was. And for background, part of the reason this was a big deal at the time is that Republicans (who controlled congress) wanted to defund NPR at the time. Getting an NPR exec admitting they don't need federal funds was a useful anti-federal funds argument.
Even if we assume I'm correct in that the biased coverage portion is indeed misleading, what you presented is compelling evidence that it was not at all one of the main takeaways of the video. I appreciate and applaud you for taking the time to look into the contemporaneous coverage. It would still be interesting to see if we could put our respective assessments to the test (show a random audience the portions about funding and ask them what impression they walk away with) but the video is too old to make sense to people now.
I think releasing unedited footage should definitely happen more, and I already acknowledge this is a routine problem in other media outlets. The Katie Couric 'Under the Gun' example is the one that pissed me off the most, and this one from MSNBC trying their damndest not to let the audience know the guy openly-carrying an AR-15 outside of an Obama rally was black is probably the all-time most acrobatic example I can think of.
But Veritas has not been consistent with releasing unedited footage. I note this example above but when Wisconsin's GOP attorney general asked for the full unedited tapes of a Democrat operating talking about planning voter fraud, O'Keefe claimed to have complied but only provided edited segments (see pages 5 and 10 in their case report). I can understand being cagey about releasing unedited footage to the public at large, but can't think of a legitimate reason O'Keefe would withhold information from law enforcement (O'Keefe's excuses about not including parking lot portions etc are just not credible given his past videos).
[BTW to your credit @jfk, I previously believed that Veritas has not released any unedited footage since 2011. You pointed out enough examples to poke holes in that broad statement.]
I guess we're just watching two different movies on the same screen. I did not get the "only applies in one direction" point from this at all.
There's a an inherent challenge in discussing what is or isn't "misleading" because neither of our opinion will be conclusive. Before my last reply I (briefly) did try to look up what the contemporary conservative coverage about the NPR video was at the time, just to get a sense of what the main takeaways presented were. I gave up because archival searching is tedious and difficult, but I think that would be a good data point to see what message the video imparted on its audience.
I mean yes, they could release a 2 hour long video instead of 10 minutes of highlights, most of which is boring. And they did (they always do). I feel like your complaint is simply that 10 minutes of highlights can't capture everything. I feel like your complaint is simply that 10 minutes of highlights can't capture everything.
It may be difficult but it's feasible to edit 2 hours down to 10 minutes while remaining authentic to the original material. Editing gives people a significant amount of leeway to artificially construct what message the audience walks away with and it's a big reason I generally avoid watching documentaries. The gold standard for me in this area would be to confirm that the person being edited agrees the edited version remains a fair and accurate representation of their statements. I recognize this may not always be a realistic option (namely because people will lie just because they're objecting to being exposed) but it seems feasible in most cases.
There's also the added issue that Veritas has not been consistent about releasing unedited versions of their sting videos. One notable example is from 2016 where a Democratic operative was apparently caught on video discussing how to commit voter fraud. This is and was something that caught the attention of law enforcement, but when Wisconsin's GOP attorney general asked for the full unedited tapes, O'Keefe claimed to have complied but only provided edited segments (see pages 5 and 10 in their case report and if you're not already fully exasperated by Timbah's videos there's additional context here).
So let me ask some concrete questions:
- Based on the Veritas video, I think he believes Republicans are racist. Do you think this is false and I've been fooled by Veritas?
- Based on the Veritas video, I think that he personally - but not NPR - has significant negative feelings towards Republicans. Do you think that is false and I've been fooled by Veritas?
The answer to both is that I don't know if it's false. I certainly think it's plausible and perhaps even likely, based solely on my operating stereotype of an NPR executive, but I wouldn't be convinced of this just from watching the edited footage unless I assumed it was telling me the full story (and you know my opinion on that).
I don't have an objection to editorializing, and if O'Keefe believed that the NPR exec was just laundering his disdain for Republicans by quoting a sock puppet, Veritas could just say so. They could have added a text disclaimer ("Note: he's referencing a conversation with a top-level donor but we think that's just a cover story") without adding to the length of the video. Had they done that I wouldn't have an objection. They didn't, likely because it would run counter to their cinéma vérité brand where only the footage does the talking.
Andy Ngo is notoriously opaque with his news commentary but I think the point he is trying to convey is clear when he posted a video of Muslims burning a Danish flag in protest of the guy who burned a Quran. I imagine the reaction to burning a Danish flag is a shrug, and so whatever point the Muslim protestors thought they made just ends up further exposing how alien their incomprehensible rage is.
I think his conduct in the video above is commendable but I still think he's too often a bad faith actor. One example happened after the spat between DeSantis and Disney, where Rufo jumped in to mention that a Disney employee has been arrested for child sex crimes at least once a year for the past decade, omitting that Disney employees 190,000 people and how that would compare to an average baseline.
I have to give credit where credit is due and say that's an admirable display of conduct from Rufo. I wish he'd spend less time with Chinese cardiologist insinuations and more on what the video showed.
I didn't know about these comments before and they seem even worse in context:
When Hussein opened the floor for questions, the first was from Mark Berkson, chair of Hamline’s religion department. “I’ve taught Islam at Hamline for 22 years,” Berkson began. “This event was organized in response to something very particular. This wasn’t hate speech or vandalism or violence.” Berkson’s core objection was that, contrary to Hussein’s claims, there has been historically, and is even now, substantial diversity of opinion within Islam on the extent to which images of the Prophet are forbidden. “What does one do when the Muslim community itself is divided on an issue? There are many Muslim scholars, and experts, and art historians, who do not believe that this was Islamophobic.”
At this point in the video recording of the conversation, a woman’s silhouette moves into view and approaches Berkson; she apparently intends to stop him from talking. “It’s OK,” Hussein said, and Berkson went on: “In this particular case we have a work of art considered a treasure and masterpiece by scholars, painted by Muslim artists for a Muslim king that honors the Prophet —”
Hussein interrupted him. “You can stop.” Then: “Here’s what I’m going to tell you. If you share pedophilia in this school as an art, I’m happy for you to show the picture of our Prophet. But if you don’t do that, then you’re not going to disrespect our Prophet.” Hussein then launched into a long, rather confusing comparison involving Hitler. After all, he said, some people — some white Minnesotans, even — think Hitler was good. But that wouldn’t justify teaching a pro-Hitler class! “If you ask me right now, I’ll come back with a 26-page paper telling you why Hitler was good. That does not make it right.”
The Chronicle seems to be the only place that printed this quote, and I'm really curious why the audio/video was not released anywhere else.
You might recall that an adjunct professor was let go from Hamline University after a Muslim student complained about a depiction of the prophet Muhammad shown in class. The immediate responses were not terribly surprising to me. Given past incidents, I assumed that college administrators would have an interest towards affirming the student's complaint, no matter how unreasonable it was. This panned out, with the university president issuing a very bizarre statement where she presented non-sequiturs like:
To suggest that the university does not respect academic freedom is absurd on its face. Hamline is a liberal arts institution, the oldest in Minnesota, the first to admit women, and now led by a woman of color. To deny the precepts upon which academic freedom is based would be to undermine our foundational principles.
What do the demographics of the university president have to do with academic freedom? Fuck if I know.
Similarly, I also assumed that non-profit organizations would have an interest to bolster their profile by seizing upon the incident. This too panned out, with the local Minnesota Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) chapter condemning the professor as Islamophobic. The local chapter's executive director even dismissed the fact that the professor went out of her way to add a content warning and said "In reality a trigger warning is an indication that you are going to do harm."
Since then, things have changed. First, the national CAIR organization felt the need to step in and rebuke the local chapter, and issued a (tepid) defense of the scorned professor. Then, Hamline University faculty just voted overwhelmingly (71-12) to ask the president to step down. For a defense of freedom of expression, the statement they issued is (at least on its face) pretty good.
Both of these developments surprised me, and it made me wonder whether this is a sign of a potential turning point on the topic of suppressed freedom of expression on campus.
I really sincerely appreciate that you took the time to research this fairly. The transcripts you provide are accurate but I'm not sure how they're relevant to this point. The overarching insinuation is that NPR is biased towards Palestine/Muslims and against Israel/Jews, so it's neither notable nor surprising for the NPR execs to deny that Jewish funders affect the coverage. That's perfectly in line with the suspicion that NPR is heavily biased in favor of Palestine (which I don't think is at all unreasonable). The full context here would be to include all the times that NPR execs deny that any donor can influence coverage. The fact that Veritas excluded the six denials about all donors from the edited video but chose to include the laugh line about National Palestinian Radio appears to have been done deliberately in order to leave the viewer with the impression that their "donors don't affect coverage" line only applies in one direction.
And if you watch the full video you get the broader point being made: NPR guy hates the tea party and white Republicans, but he's totally cool with Muslim Brotherhood guy and admits Jews control the newspapers.
This is another example of the deceptive editing. The full unedited Veritas video is 2 hours long and is still available here. At the 2:34 mark of the edited video, the NPR exec is portrayed as disclosing that he personally believes Republicans are intensely racist. The full video at the 33:30 mark shows him explicitly stating that he's relaying what someone else, a top Republican donor, believes. Maybe the NPR exec is lying and just using a fictitious sockpuppet to launder his own beliefs, but if that's the suspicion, why not let the audience decide instead of just editing the ambiguity out?
I don't know, I can't read minds. The fact that Trump walked back his accusation seems especially notable, since it's not something he does very often. But again, what does the "empty huge jar of cookies" correspond to in the analogy you gave?
I'm guessing the 300lbs fat kid is the FBI/CIA, but what does the "empty huge jar of cookies" correspond to?
Nancy Pelosi does have a USCP security detail but she wasn't home. You could make the argument that they should offer 24/7 security for all members of congress and their family, which isn't completely unreasonable, but I'm not sure there's an appetite for such an expenditure. The house did have cameras but no one paid attention to it until after a USCP officer noticed flashing police lights (monitoring 1,800 cameras efficiently takes a lot of staffing).
I don't know what Musk's or Biden's unattended home security protocol is like but what you described wouldn't totally surprise me. Security isn't a free lunch, and it's not unfathomable to conclude it's not worth it.
Maybe I overlooked something, but where does the edited Veritas video show the NPR exec stating they won't let a donation influence their coverage?

Can you provide examples of the legislation you're describing? I've never heard of it before. By making Title IX employees mandatory reporters, was the hope that they'll start focusing on discrimination against men? Why would anyone think this was a viable plan? Just yesterday Stanford University denied a request to open a Title IX investigation into Professor Michele Dauber for bias against males despite fairly blatant evidence.
More options
Context Copy link