@ymeskhout's banner p
BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				

				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

				

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				
				
				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

It depends on what you consider a "lie". Two potential examples come to mind with the first being an ACORN lawyer, Juan Carlos Vera, who took down information about the (fake) sex trafficking coming in through Tijuana and immediately reported it to law enforcement. Even after this information came out, O'Keefe still kept implying that Vera was indeed an enthusiastic participant in sex trafficking. The second example comes from the NPR sting, where Veritas used deceptive editing to imply that NPR executives were very eager to accept a $5 million donation from a Sharia group in exchange for coverage input.

What kind of security do you envision in a private residence like this?

You demonstrably are conflating "not enough evidence to believe x is true" with "believes x is false". It would be useful for you to understand the distinction between the two and it's why I included a link to Russell's teapot. Otherwise you'll continue to risk wasting time shadowboxing against positions which might not even exist.

This is a very useful counterpoint, and I admit that I don't have much immediate knowledge about generic "hacking", which is why I was primarily relying on what other experts thought. My rough, even child-like, understanding of what large language models can potentially accomplish is quickly "read" an entire code database and find exploits a human might not ever have thought of. In my first draft I even included a link to TLA+ which seem to accomplish a primitive version of this (I tried to watch an intro to TLA+ video and...had no idea wtf it was talking about). As a gut intuition feeling, it seems likely that LLMs would have an easier time pointing out the problems on an already existing code than writing the (working) code from scratch. Is that off-base?

... also, man it must take a while to write up long, referenced posts like the above. My paragraph took a solid 20 minutes (although with distraction from some of the blogposts), and its writing quality isn't as good.

thanks, my time-tracking software tells me things I don't want to know 😩

So there might be astroturf efforts going on we know nothing about.

Very true

Maybe, but even if this deepfake was way more convincing from a technological standpoint, it still would get immediately neutered by how Elon Musk responded.

Trump: Obama has a teapot orbiting the earth

NASA: We've checked our records and we've never launched a teapot, nor have we ever ever received reports of an orbiting teapot

Trump: Well I didn't mean that literally, also it was just based on a hunch

@No_one: Notice how the French have not denied launching a teapot into space? How suspicious.

Your evidence for the claim that the Trump campaign was wiretapped is that the FBI/CIA has not denied asking the British to wiretap the Trump campaign? It's totally possible I'm misreading you, but if not...what?

I don't have much to add except to say this is an excellent post. Well researched and showcases the different facets of this topic with commendable agility.

I read that clause way too fast and didn't realize this gives them a way to police offline conduct of OGL license holders. Obviously they can't go after everyone, so they probably added this "at our discretion" clause so they have a convenient out anytime a DnD person becomes too much of a PR problem for them.

I don't know enough about federal criminal indictments in general to have an opinion on this. "Speaking indictment" appears to me to be more like a term of art descriptor than an exact distinction.

I'm not clued in enough on TTRPGs to know, but was there ANYTHING that was either released or in the works that could have plausibly been covered by the "no hateful content or conduct"?

My impression is that they threw that in there as a boilerplate precaution but then when they got the vicious backlash about OGL they tried to use it as a figleaf defense in the form of "why's everyone mad? we just wanted to ban hateful conduct". That might be true, but I'm still intensely curious if there was any agitation over some RPG in the works with TERF goblins or something.

I don't have much of an opinion of it. What they call speaking indictments looks like it has about the same amount of detail that I see in charging documents I deal with every day in state court. In your link it's clear why the prosecutors assumed a jury trial would never happen, so adding details into an indictment makes sense. Shrug? Sorry, I'm not sure what you're asking.

The last time you accused me of lying about other people's positions, lying about other people not giving me arguments, lying about not being provided insight into specific concerns, I responded to you in detail. None of your claims about me lying held up. Anyone is welcome to follow the link and check themselves.

So, cards on the table. You claim that your persistent refusal to engage with the actual substance of my arguments is borne out of a commitment to principle. It's what you say but how would you convince someone that you're telling the truth? Because the only other times I've ever encountered anything close to the position you're claiming to adhere to is from online activists (typically leftwing) who respond with some variant of "It's not my job to educate you" when their positions are scrutinized. It's reasonable to surmise that anyone offering that response is using it as a deflection tactic to avoid having to defend their beliefs, most likely because they know their beliefs are too weak to stand up to adversarial scrutiny.

I can't prove this conclusively because I can't read your mind, but I strongly suspect that your refusal to provide arguments because I'm purportedly acting in bad faith is just a pretextual excuse (a lie) used by you as a dodge to avoid defending your beliefs or having them scrutinized. I suspect that anti-Trump arguments in particular make you upset, but because you are unable to construct a legitimate counter-argument, you resort to a dogged and persistent response campaign which compensates for the lack of substance with a heavy dose of vitriol.

One reason I believe this is because I can't think of any good explanation for you to be so persistently tight-lipped across several years all within a forum specifically dedicated to debate and discussion. If you have an argument, just please for the love of god say it. Your excuses make no sense in this context.

Another reason I believe this is because despite the wide-array of topics I write about, what consistently acts as a trigger for your grudge with me is almost exclusively when I write about either Trump or the 2020 stolen election theories. I suspect, given your scope of attention, that you have an emotional attachment to this topic which is why it reliably elicits a hostile and angry response from you. Those posts of mine are probably the ones most exhaustively sourced, which is inconsistent with why they would be the most likely to anger you.

Another reason I believe this is because while your refusal to engage would make sense in isolation, you replace this with significant efforts towards vague denunciation riddles with lengthy wordcounts. If your goal was to save yourself from wasting time, this is incongruent conduct. It's not clear what, if anything, you gain from this behavior.

Another reason I believe this is while I can understand why someone might want to avoid typing out a long response, you flatly and explicitly have refused to even link me to sources. Some of your responses to those requests include:

This is a patently bewildering position to hold and I can't think of any scenario where it makes any sense, except one where you are concerned that I would eviscerate your sources (flattering, admitedly). Given the circumstances, I cannot fathom an explanation more charitable than this, you are literally the only person I've encountered in this forum with a self-imposed policy against linking sources. It's wild.

I've outlined the reasons for why I hold my suspicion, and it's a suspicion I believe is especially well-founded given the scope of time involved. Suspicions can be rebutted with evidence, and I will remain open to any arguments and heavily encourage anyone and everyone to point any faults with what I've outlined above. If I am wrong and my suspicion turns out to be misplaced, I will emphatically apologize. Unless there is some new developments, my hope is that this will by my last word on this (very tiresome) saga.

I think you're referring to this thread from November, which reminded me that I already addressed the concerns you outlined. I'm assuming you missed it but I'm glad we can finally clear up our misunderstanding.

Did you sign an NDA or something? Would you answer my questions if I gave you a dollar? Is there a hint system phone line I can call? You're not making this puzzle game fun at all.

You and I also both know that the same post was preceeded in the same post thread by object-level feedback of argument noting specific cases in context that you were doing what you were accused of. We both know you have been previously reminded of this, just as we both know that you will, in the future, claim that you have never been responded to and that claims of previous feedback that you yourself have linked to was fictitious.

I can respond with nuh-uh and then you can respond with yeah-uh and I can respond with nuh-uh again or....you can just answer the question. The amount of effort you continue to put into evading this very very very simple question makes me conclude you're being deliberately obtuse to obfuscate the fact that you lack evidence for your assertions.

I'm trying to read and understand what you're writing to the best of my abilities. I'm just asking "what am I missing?" and it's not helpful for you to play a game of riddles. It doesn't make sense why you'd waste so much time and energy evading questions with purportedly trivially obvious answers.

This is as good of a place as any to say. While I had nothing at all to do with past mod actions giving you and other users warnings for calling me a liar, I've strenuously disagreed with that and have asked the mod team to stop enforcing that rule with me. You are welcome to accuse me of being a liar, although ideally you showcase evidence to prove your point. You can even call me a liar without evidence if you so desire, no matter how silly that might look.

I didn't expect such a gracious response, my apologies for misreading you.

Can I? Sure. Will I? A waste of time when you are involved, given your pattern of conduct which has been noted repeatedly over the years even if you have also repeatedly denied the feedback. Improving your character to have fewer petty swipes at your other posters would be a start.

I know this isn't the first time you respond with this line, but nevertheless it continues to be an amazing and revealing response. You keep claiming that I'm ignoring/denying feedback, but man oh man it would be so much easier for both of us if you just actually respond with this fictitious feedback I'm apparently ignoring instead of wasting your time thinking up increasingly creative ways of dodging the question. See you on the next rotation buddy <3

Thanks, I still think asking for feedback is worthwhile because it gives people the opportunity to rebut the conclusion that they're only upset because I criticized something they like. If they refuse to do so, that's on them. If they provide helpful feedback, then it's a win for both of us.

FWIW (and @ymeskhout can confirm this) I have privately voiced my objection to this kind of "calling out" of people just because you've had an argument with them in the past.

This is true. I've maintained my disagreement with the idea that it's bad form mainly because I would welcome anyone doing the same to me. I make it a practice to proactively acknowledge my own errors and edit corrections when appropriate (just go through my comment history), and don't understand why people here of all places react so negatively to being caught credulously repeating false claims. I would emphatically and earnestly praise anyone who owns up to mistakes and being stubborn about it is just childish and dishonorable behavior that I don't think it belongs in this forum.

without regard or even accurate reflection of previous engagements

Is this what you believe I do? I'm honestly surprised to hear this accusation coming from you. I specifically praised you in this post as a good example of someone who asked me pointed questions here which prompted productive introspection on my part. Having my beliefs scrutinized is something I genuinely wish happened to me more often. You never responded to that post (and I didn't necessarily expect you to) but I thought my responses to your questions were thorough, and I would be curious to know what your opinion on that effort is. You are also more than welcome to call me out on any other specific examples you have about me either disregarding or inaccurately reflecting on any engagements.

Thank you. It's certainly possible that some partisans want to react to arguments they don't like by throwing a tantrum instead of engaging with the argument itself, but given the amount of productive feedback I received in this thread, it's worthwhile to remain receptive to valid criticism and acknowledge it.