@ymeskhout's banner p
BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				

				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

				

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				
				
				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

This is an intensely idiotic plan. Whatever randos end up on the jury are very likely to not know anything about SBF, let alone any of the exquisite exculpatory fantasies he cooked up in his substack. And besides, it's not like he'd be barred from presenting a defense at his trial.

Look on the bright side, at the least the cardiologists treating his lawyers will make bank.

Small programming note: I migrated the hosting from SoundCloud to Substack because the latter is free and I was paying $16/month for the former. I don't recommend going to the Substack page directly because their "email delivery model" doesn't really make sense to me for podcasts but if I did everything right, new episodes should automatically spread to whatever podcast app you already use (basically everyone copies whatever Apple Podcasts has) but let me know if you encounter any issues.

The infrequent release schedule has basically been my fault entirely, busy and blah blah blah. I know I said this before, but we at the Bailey cooked up a new workflow for producing episodes more frequently that I am very optimistic about, but we'll see how well that works out!

Of what I wrote, what do you disagree with?

I concede your point.

Yes it's exactly this. It's widely applicable idea and I didn't want to obfuscate it by just referring to it by its pet name.

I can't remember if I already posted but I wrote a book review for David Bernstein's Classified which talks about how utterly incoherent the US racial taxonomy is. To answer your direct question, according to the US federal government, Lionel Messi would be racially white but ethnically hispanic.

For one thing, the categories are not consistently delineated. Some are geographic (Asian), some are cultural (Hispanic), and others are racial (Black). To illustrate some of the absurdities, consider what box someone indigenous to Brazil would check. The most obvious answer, Hispanic, is not necessarily correct because some federal agencies do not include Portuguese cultural heritage within the definition. Further, Hispanic is explicitly heralded as an ethnicity designation that is separate and distinct from race (it’s anyone’s guess what the difference between the two is — Directive 15 doesn’t say — and many forms have eventually collapsed the two questions into one). Lastly, American Indian would not apply either, because lobbying by federally recognized tribes has relegated this definition to include only North American indigenous people.

None of this really makes any sense, but these categories are "good enough" for a gigantic multicultural nation of 330 million people. You can choose to have more granularity in your racial taxonomy, but there is literally no limit to how deep you can go.

I find this phenomena truly bewildering, transmogrifying the availability heuristic with confirmation bias. Are people suddenly collapsing more than before? I have no idea, but the boosters of this claim tend to offer anecdotes rather than any sort of systemic data. Assuming the sudden collapses are indeed happening more than usual, are they due to vaccine risk? Same here, I have no idea if that's true, nor how exactly one would reach this conclusion. We know that humans are mortal and susceptible to dying (sometimes suddenly even) from many causes. Why are vaccines conclusively and exclusively heralded as the cause? No idea.

If you want generalizable tips for a normal person it would be:

  1. You should not rely on anecdotes to establish a trend

  2. If there is indeed a trend, you should only adopt a particular cause if you have good reason to dismiss other explanations

Horseshoe theory is such a good way to describe the convergence. I myself try to maintain a distinction between man/woman and male/female but even someone as pathologically fastidious about words as me fails regularly.

My apologies, I did not articulate my observation very well. I can acknowledge that Prescod's career seems fine, but that appears to be primarily due to just how much of a bully she is. With regards to her ability to persuade others, her refusal to admit wrong seems like an obvious liability on that front. Yes, she has a platform but to me that just lets her repeat catechisms to an audience already in deliberate pursuit of confirmation bias. So I concede that never admitting wrong can have specific benefits in certain facets of life that rely upon a brash persona. It's still overall a bewildering decision to make.

Fascinating article on the apparent controversy of naming a telescope after James Webb, former head of NASA throughout the 60s (content warning: NYT).

Broadly speaking, Webb is accused of anti-gay bigotry. There does not appear to be any dispute that the US government, as part of investigating federal employees who were suspected of being Communists during the red scare, also fired employees accused of being gay (estimated to be around 5k-10k total over 20 years). The origin of tying the accusation directly to Webb appears to have been borne out of a misreading:

But as the telescope neared completion, criticism flared. In 2015, Matthew Francis, a science journalist, wrote an article for Forbes titled “The Problem With Naming Observatories for Bigots.” He wrote that Mr. Webb led the anti-gay purge at the State Department and that he had testified of his contempt for gay people. He credited Dr. Prescod-Weinstein with tipping him off, and she in turn tweeted his article and attacked Mr. Webb as a “homophobe.” Those claims rested on misidentification and that portion of Mr. Francis’ article has been deleted without notice to the reader. Mr. Francis declined an interview. As Dr. Oluseyi discovered and NASA’s report confirmed, it was not Mr. Webb but a different State Department official who oversaw the purge and spoke disparagingly of gay Americans.

So someone made a claim and someone else looked into that claim and conclusively found the evidence lacking. Research isn't easy and it's reasonable to expect some mistakes, and I find nothing embarrassing or humiliating about just admitting error. But instead of just conceding their belief rested on a faulty premise, the Webb-is-a-bigot crew refused to let go of their favored conclusion and went searching for other reasons why they were right all along.

In 1953, President Dwight D. Eisenhower signed an executive order that essentially barred gay Americans from federal employment. It applied to all federal agencies and remained in effect throughout the 1960s, when Mr. Webb led NASA. In 1963, police arrested a NASA budget analyst, Clifford Norton, in an anti-gay sting in Washington. He was forced out of his job. Critics say Mr. Webb stood silent. Mr. Odom’s report for NASA, however, found no evidence Mr. Webb knew of this case in an agency of many thousands. In any event, he would have had no good option, said James Kirchick, author of Secret City: The Hidden History of Gay Washington. “It is unimaginable that a high-level functionary would have stepped in and blocked a broad federal law that applied to every agency,” he said.

And of course, people tried to come up with other reasons why a telescope should not be named after Webb:

Sarah Tuttle, an astrophysicist at the University of Washington, characterizes the question of whether Mr. Webb was a homophobe as unanswerable and a distraction. The point, she said, is that the bar should be set higher. Previous telescopes were named after physicists and astronomers — Edwin Hubble and Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar. Why not name in that tradition? “This controversy should restart the discussion about why on earth this telescope is named after him,” said Jason Wright, a Penn State astrophysicist who signed the critics’ petition.

Things got especially dark for Oluseyi, the guy who fact-checked the original claim. First they claimed his fact-check was an ill-disguised attempt to justify historical homophobia, then rumors spread around academia of some sexual harassment and mishandling federal funds. And so on.


So that story is entertaining on its own right, but it's also an interesting examination of the best ways to respond when someone points out an error of yours. Speaking for myself as someone who jumps at the opportunity to self-label as an egotistical narcissist, it seems like adopting a regular habit of admitting mistakes is plainly self-serving. It's almost a cheat code for how well it can bolster one's credibility, and I don't understand why it's not more common.

The basic contours of being motivated to save face are obvious enough, sure, but the part that continues to be absolutely bewildering to me is that dogged stubbornness only makes you look worse! I'm guessing there must be some other benefit here (assuming, of course, people who refuse to admit error are behaving remotely rationally) but I can't understand it.

No worries, you were at least correct about my worldview and how that might extrapolate to "pro-defendant/anti-justice-system", so that was at least a reasonable assumption. Very very few of my clients are innocent. The main grey area is usually "yes they did the thing, but is it a crime?" scenario, most often self-defense cases. I wrote about how useless I generally am for my cases if you're interested: Eleven Magic Words

There’s a big difference between these two scenarios: 1. Salas and one or more accomplices invaded someone’s home, and in the commission of that home invasion somebody was shot. Police couldn’t determine, given the evidence at their disposal, which one of the home invaders fired the shot, so they couldn’t pin the murder on Salas specifically. 2. Police could not muster the evidence to actually place Salas at the scene of the home invasion.

With felony-murder rule, they wouldn't need to prove who actually fired the shot at all, only that 1. someone died 2. while Salas was intending to commit a felony 3. the felony had the likelihood of getting someone killed. Given that someone died and that home invasions are inherently risky, the weakest link in that chain seems to be whether Salas was "intent on committing a felony" when the people were killed. So the reason they lacked evidence could also be "3. Police could not muster the evidence to indicate that Salas was at the home with the intent of committing a felony." There are a number of ways this could be the case, and I'm happy to rattle off some hypothetical examples if you're interested. Also, even plain vanilla murder charges don't need proof about who specifically fired the shot. More than one person can be convicted of committing a murder and if you're interested I can look up some real life cases.

I’m aware that there is the possibility that he took a plea deal for a crime which he didn’t commit in order to avoid the possibility of being convicted of an even worse crime that he also didn’t commit. The probability of this just seems far lower than I think you believe that it is.

This is a possibility, yes. What probability do you place on it? My anecdotal experience from my work is that the "factually innocent" client exists but is extremely rare. What probability did you think I placed on it?

Setting aside the questions above about evidence for the moment, if I was to summarize your position it would be: you agree with the felony-murder rule as it is but that you'd rather see the death penalty rather than the current "25 to life" sentence. Is that a fair characterization?

The article in question also mentions that five years after the original home invasion which resulted in the murder of two people, Salas then plead guilty to a second home invasion in which yet another person was murdered.

I agree the article is worded ambiguously but I didn't read that as describing two separate incidents but the article was repeating itself when describing the charging timeline. Either way, the prosecutor's statement for why they offered home invasion plea deal is that they lacked evidence to proceed with murder charges. I understand what you desire in terms of punishment, but how do you deal with the evidence issue?

As you correctly point out: lack of evidence of him directly committing the double homicide is no defense against felony murder charges. Based on my non-lawyer understanding he is indeed guilty of that crime. I don't think that the prosecutors had to let him off on that.

To get a felony-murder conviction, you have to prove (paraphrasing) that someone was trying to commit a felony crime and did so in a way that made it very likely someone would get killed or seriously hurt. I don't know anything about this case but if the prosecutors were pursuing murder charges on a felony-murder theory, the lack of evidence described could have been as far upstream as unable to prove he was even at the house (let alone that he was there to commit a felony, let alone that he pulled the trigger, etc.).

Based on the objectives you outline, electing tougher prosecutors who are more enthusiastic about pursuing even edge case charges would likely get you what you want. But this might be a risky gambit which could result in more acquittals if prosecutors are pressing their luck by overcharging or pursuing cases with bad evidence. Would you agree that's a concern? Separate from overplaying their hand, would you have any other concerns about tougher prosecutors?

The US (including Illinois) already has in place the felony-murder rule which can be used as a very broad penumbra to charge any participants of a crime with murder, regardless of their direct action or intent to kill. This was used to nail Roddie Bryan with life in prison in the Arbery case, even though he was far away from the shooting that killed Arbery. So it seems to me there are already well established laws that can punish people, even if they are only tangentially involved in someone's death. Do you disagree?

Illinois already has a 25 years to life prison sentence for felony murder. To @vpn 's credit, they included a link about the 2009 incident and what the prosecutor said about that case:

As in all cases, this matter was litigated based on the facts, evidence, and the law. After a thorough review of the case, including the defendant's role for the crime that occurred in 2010, we concluded that the evidence did not meet the burden of proof to move forward with the murder charges for Samuel Salas. On September 19, 2018, Salas pled guilty to the felony charge of Home Invasion and was sentenced to 8 years in prison after the court accepted the defendant's plea as a resolution to this case.

According to the prosecutor, the issue was lack of evidence, but it's plausible the prosecutor is now either lying or being misleading to cover their ass. Do you find their justification credible?

Since the law on the books already has the prison sentence you desire, what would you want to see change to make it easier to get convictions? Are there any downsides to making it easier to get convictions?

[tagging @Hoffmeister25 for similar reply]

Do you know why he was only sentenced to 8 years for a previous double murder and home invasion? What change in policy would you propose?

My main point though is that I think society will trend toward more law-and-order as video surveillance becomes ever more ubiquitous. If this video didn't exist, no one outside of the victims' families will think twice about it. But because it does, it will surface and resurface across social media until the end of time, and no amount of narrative from academics and pundits will compete with the visceral viewer reaction that some people are simply evil and need to be locked up for life or executed. Perhaps one day we'll all be effectively wearing body cams if/when AR glasses become mainstream. I believe that future will spell a permanent end to the political expediency of criminal justice reform, at least in the way that opponents label it as being weak on crime.

The guy was caught on video and is now held without bail. What policy failure point are you identifying here?

Just because something serves a social use doesn't mean it can't also pose a threat to safety. Both can be true at the same time.

For the record, I have no issue at all with LoTT posting about “they are having a drag show at school X at time Y” even if there were dozens of credible shooting or bomb threats. They have the right to post that information, and what other people do with that information isn't LoTT's responsibility. I also have no issue with posting publicly available flight tracking data, but I also don't believe that's in any way shape or form a threat to anyone's safety (it also doesn't matter if it is).

I have no idea why you would think this is a remotely acceptable response. You can dispute someone's purported mischaracterization of your position without telling them to fuck off. Banned for a day.

I sort of vaguely was aware of this story but my initial read was skepticism because it seemed just way too blatant. In case anyone is curious about my thought process, I wondered whether Sweeney either took down his own account, or intentionally got his account suspended some other way (the publicity motive seemed plausible to me). But it does appear to be true that Twitter indeed updated their terms of service specifically to prohibit sharing live location information. I find all this confusing because Musk's tweet about his commitment to not banning Sweeney's account still hasn't been deleted. I can understand Musk being annoyed at Sweeney's account, but this seems like a needlessly pointless way to burn credibility, and just weird and erratic behavior from Musk. He's the face of a $44 billion company, what exactly is the end game here? One last thing that remains curious to me is why would facebook and instagram also prevent people from sharing the elonjet account? It doesn't make sense that they would want to carry water for Musk, so I wonder if something else is going on.

When Musk first took over Twitter, this was my prediction:

Musk presents himself as a free speech absolutist, which is encouraging to me, but I'd be concerned about the conflict of interest. I anticipate there will be some accusations of throttling unfavorable opinions about either him or his companies

I didn't expect a speedrun

If I had to summarize my post it would be "I started to suspect that motteposting was potentially arguing in bad faith or being inconsistent, so I laid a trap to see how he'd react to his own argument. Despite what I emotionally desired, motteposting demonstrated commendable consistency, although there were a few questions at the fringe. In the course of the discussion, he also changed my mind about something. The end."

it doesn't read like any other 'I've updated my mistaken beliefs' post I've ever read

I don't know what this means, what exactly do you find suspicious?

if you wanted to talk about bias and credulity, it would have been simple. All you would have to do is - instead of using @motteposting's post - use your own posts. It's not easy to spot our own biases, but it isn't impossible either.

I think I understand the general pushback against focusing too much on a single user's actions but I believe it was appropriate here because it's difficult to discuss these topics in the abstract. And I'm not at all opposed to examining my own biases, but I have to admit that I have blindspots like everyone else. I like to think that I'm sufficiently scrutinizing but that's going to reek of "we've investigated ourselves and concluded we did nothing wrong."

I'll answer your questions in turn:

Why do you think Hutchinson's claim is plausible when it is based on hearsay about hearsay?

There's two parts here, Hutchinson's claim of what she heard, and whether what she heard actually happened. On what she heard, Hutchinson to me came across as credible because she doesn't appear to have either a motive or a history of lying. She described the events with sufficient detail, and named every person that was privy to the conversation. She provided this testimony under oath and was annoyed at being subpoenaed. As falsification, if Hutchinson wanted to lie and make up something damning about Trump to get back at him or whatever, the far easier thing for her to have done would be to talk about a scenario that did not involve her listening in on a conversation with 3 other people (who are available to refute what she said). If I was playing the role of Lying Hutchinson, I would've conjured up something salacious that only Trump would be in the position of denying (e.g. sexual harassment).

Regarding the claims about the steering wheel lunging incident, it seems plausible to me. Trump does not strike me as someone with good temperament control, especially in private away from the cameras. There was testimony from other people that corroborated how thrilled he was about what his supporters were doing on J6, and how much he wanted to be in the thick of it. The other testimony also established how surprised his security detail was when he declared during his speech that he was going to walk down to the capitol, because they had not prepared anything like that. Two secret service agents claimed to contradict Hutchinson's ultimate lunging claim and apparently said they were willing to testify back in June, but they haven't materialized. All that leads me to think it makes sense that Trump really wanted to go to the capitol, that his security detail said no, and that he's impulsive enough to act out the way he did.

What exactly about these two events do you think is similar aside from the use of unsubstantiated evidence?

At the time I wrote it, the parallels were kind of basic and mostly along the lines of "This person we know little about made a claim with no real corroborating evidence, should we believe them?" I realized after that there was a lot more corroborating evidence from Bobulinski I didn't know about (motteposting's first reply to me didn't mention any of it).

Why would you present the lack of written proof of the back room deal as evidence it didn't happen when you know they tried to make sure there was no written proof of their back room deals?

The lack of written proof wouldn't necessarily settle the issue on its own, but my operating assumption is that a deal like this would leave a paper trail of some kind, and all we had were very vague terse lines about "H holding 10 for the big guy." I did not know about their insistence not to discuss the deal in writing until I saw the Gilliar text messages after, and also Hunter saying somewhere that Joe Biden prefers talking on the phone. That is a compelling explanation for why the paper trail I was looking for and expecting would not exist.

Most importantly - if you really agree that nepotism is bad, and a really bad look for a president, then why do you find the Biden laptop scandal uncompelling?

Because they've had access to so much of Hunter's files for so long, my assumption is that the CEFC deal is is the most damning thing they could nail on Joe Biden (since that's the real goal). But the CEFC deal was only talked about and never happened. I also find 2rafa's idea that Hunter was largely talking a big game about his dad's involvement to generate clout to make a lot of sense given the lack of solid detail of Joe Biden's involvement. Even with their insistence not to discuss the deal in writing, I know from experience that people fuck up and break security protocol, and I still would expect some sort of corroborating evidence that Hunter was funneling money to his dad (e.g. "can't smoke crack 2nite, gotta wire $ to dad" or something). What we're left with is that "Joe Biden was at least contemplated to receive a cut of a deal that fell through" which seems like a dud.

The other dimension is considering the baseline. I was happy that Biden won the election, but only because it meant Trump lost. Biden is kind of boring which I do find refreshing, but as a libertarian I'm struggling to think of any of his policies that I actually support, and I'll never forgive him for his role in vastly expanding the carceral state. As a person, although he seems to have calmed down in recent years, his habit of sniffing girls/women's hair was really bizarre, and I'm still inclined to believe Tara Reade's accusation that he tried to force himself on her.

Which is why it almost feels unfair, akin to beating a dead horse, to even mention the Trump family nepotism, because it's so wildly and flagrantly out of proportion. Trump hires his own family as White House advisors, doesn't release his finances, doesn't put anything in a blind trust, openly invites foreign dignitaries to stay in his hotels, neither he nor his family stop from using his name to secure deals across the world, and etc etc. The comparison here is comically unfair. I expect a certain level of corruption from politicians (and I find things like Clinton's ridiculous $500k speaking engagement fees and government officials retiring into cushy "consulting" gigs to all be deplorable) but I'm never going to see "zero" so I'll settle for "way less than the other guy".

And have you really updated your belief if you think Bobulinski was telling the truth but otherwise maintain the exact same position you did before?

I didn't know about Bobulinski until motteposting mentioned him. When I initially looked at his claims I saw some things that didn't add up and concluded that he might be twisting the truth for his own clout. Later examining other evidence I wasn't aware of changed my mind and I revised my conclusion to Bobulinski most likely telling the truth. I'm not sure what you mean by "exact same position". If you're talking about Joe Biden's involvement, see the previous answer.


I genuinely really appreciate you taking me to task on the above topic. Answering your questions prompted me to seriously reflect on my position, and I really wish more people did that to me.

Do you believe the proclivity for peddling influence is different enough between those two groups that it warrants separate heuristic categories?

By contrast, "Trump opponent peddles influence to foreign potentates via family venture(s)" had already turned out to be true at least once on the Presidential stage, and politicians being prosaically corrupt in that fashion is entirely plausible anyway. I don't think being inclined to believe the former over the latter, even given the same caliber of direct evidence against each, is remotely worthy of criticism. For it simply rests on eminently reasonable priors, plus plenty of previous evidence in the former case.

I appreciate that you took the time to respond and for outlining your heuristics transparently, but I'm having trouble understanding how your heuristics for prima facie assessments map exactly. I agree with you that politicians being prosaically corrupt is entirely plausible, but I find it odd that you specifically cleave along the "Trump opponent peddles influence" axis. What is the basis for carving out a territory shaped like that? Unless you can explain how members of a group share a trait relevant to the prediction, it seems like a suspiciously arbitrary designator.

For example, if I made the claim that "Trump peddles influence to foreign potentates via family venture(s)" would you find the claim on its face plausible because you use your "politicians are corrupt" heuristic or implausible because it doesn't match your "Trump opponent peddles influence" heuristic?

I think this theory makes sense. There are a wide avenue of opportunities available to Joe Biden to really rake in the cash if he wanted to that don't involve trusting his drug addicted son to pally around with shady characters. The lack of motive seems strong to me. I'm guessing the fact that he hasn't been as mercenary as the Obamas and Clintons might have something to do with waiting until after he's done being president to cash in.

I concede that Joe Biden was at least contemplated as being part of the CEFC deal that fell through, that much seems clear to me. Whether that was just bloviating big talk from Hunter, I don't know but it seems plausible as you explain. I'm not aware of any other evidence that Joe Biden actually profited from anything that Hunter cooked up, but I suppose that's possible if the regular practice is under the table kickbacks as is alleged in the CEFC deal. The amount of Hunter's private information that they've had access to makes me think the "big guy" email is the worst thing they could find (though to be fair there's repeated allusions about making sure not to discuss details in writing), and overall I don't really find the story all that compelling, especially when compared to what the baseline nepotistic corruption might be (say, for example, the kids of another president).