Generally yes. RPC 1.6 is what governs here and the only exception to confidentiality that comes close to what you're describe is:
A lawyer may reveal information relating to the representation of a client to the extent the lawyer reasonably believes necessary...to establish a claim or defense on behalf of the lawyer in a controversy between the lawyer and the client, to establish a defense to a criminal charge or civil claim against the lawyer based upon conduct in which the client was involved, or to respond to allegations in any proceeding concerning the lawyer's representation of the client
The comments on the rule (#10) seem to imply that the complaint from the client needs to be at least somewhat formalized through a proceeding of some sort. So while the "controversy" language seems a bit permissive, there's also the strong professional incentive to not be known as the lawyer that will sing a song about his client every time he's fired.
I have to deal with this all the time because it's common for unhappy public defense clients to try and get their lawyers fired. Generally the song and dance I have to do is make vague allusions that there has been a "complete breakdown in the attorney-client privilege". In some rare circumstances, judges have asked for more detail, and so to cover my ass I ask them the judge to sign a court order forcing me to disclose confidential information (crucially, I have the right to disobey this order if I wanted to). I then submit a sealed declaration that only the judge will read with a lot more details, but even in those circumstances I try not to get too carried away.
That's fine but there's a lot of gaps here papered over by assumptions. Do we know that any files were withheld? If files were withheld, do we know it was because of Baker's FBI connection? We don't know the answer to either question and Musk can trivially clear up both, but he hasn't. Don't you find the lack of detail from Musk to be suspicious? His actions do not comport with someone heralding himself as a vanguard for transparency.
because the chances for a random people from this sub being able to get the evidence you're asking for are basically nil
The obvious solution to not having evidence to support a position is to not hold the position. It's ok to say "I don't know" and that seems to upset a lot of people who really want to adopt their preferred conclusion, lack of evidence be damned. Along that line, I don't know what me being purportedly "neutral" has to do with anything, I've never spoken to Weiss or Singal about any of this and don't intend to. The reasons for why I'm skeptical of Musk's claim stand on their own, and you're still welcome to poke holes in what I said even if you haven't tried to already.
To be fair Cassidy's claim was that someone (Tony Ornato) told her someone told him he saw someone do something. The only thing that is reliant on her credibility is the "someone told her" part of the chain. Ornato seems to have met with J6 committee and may be testifying soon, so he would be someone that can refute Cassidy's claims.
Yes, I mentioned Gilliar's text messages already above. It's one of the reasons why I updated my position to believe Bobulinski is most likely telling the truth.
He didn't conclude that, read his post again. He explicitly calls this a "hypothesis".
To the extent that post was a pure hypothesis, this is a fair point. But I also assume that if he's posting a hypothesis it's because he finds it at least somewhat persuasive which is why I framed my mirror attempt as "one possible explanation" and asked if he found any of what I wrote convincing. The idea was to see how motteposting reacts to motteposting's hypothesis.
Do you think Baker had a waiver in writing from Elon Musk?
I really don't know how companies deal with conflict checks but before Musk the entity that would need the waiver would be the "company" as represented by its governing body. I don't know if the company switching ownership requires Baker to proactively get a new waiver, or whether it's assumed that it's Musk's responsibility to check at that point. His previous work as FBI's general counsel was not exactly a secret.
Would you, as a lawyer, be comfortable sliding yourself into a "vetting" position for the new case? If you were, would you really be surprised if many other people were unwilling to give you a blank benefit of the doubt?
Absolutely not, and I'd agree it's reasonable for people to be suspicious of me. I would be shocked if Baker was the only general counsel available to do this work, because "doc review" is extremely tedious work reserved as the lowest level of hell for attorneys. My assumption (depending on how big the volume of files is) would be they had a team of review attorneys do a first pass review of the disclosures and only after that was done did upper legal management step in for a spot check.
I keep wondering why my position is apparently so inscrutable to people because I never said that conflict of interest doesn't exist. I already said above "I think it's plausible that Jim Baker would at least have a strong motive to conceal things that would impugn the FBI which is his previous employer, but motive is not the same thing as commission." I think the pushback I'm getting on this issue is maybe that "I don't have enough evidence to believe Baker was acting in bad faith" is being interpreted as having a silent "therefore, he acted in good faith" follow-up.
Who is the "other side" here? You're right that I didn't email Baker and ask him if he was up to some bullshit, but I also would not expect him to either answer me or answer me honestly. The side that I am on remains "I don't have enough evidence to believe Musk at his word" and I haven't heard any explanations for why you think I'm overly skeptical.
I admit this is all very entertaining to watch. The journalists/whatever that made pyrrhic hay about being principled platform refugees were on Twitter in the first place entirely because that's where the eyeballs are. Twitter's entire competitive draw is its massive engagement potential. I can't imagine that the Mastodon migration is all that sustainable if all you're going to end up with are balkanized circle-jerk sessions. Similar to the selection problems that befell Gab, Parler, Voat, etc. it doesn't seem like you can build a successful platform unless it is predicated on being broadly accessible to everyone.
I don't think I encountered anyone asserting that Baker acted in good faith. If someone made that claim then yes I would demand to see evidence. If they don't provide evidence I have no reason to believe their claim.
I ran a little experiment this week. Deep within a thread from last week @motteposting and I were discussing the Hunter Biden laptop story. The quick context necessary here is that some emails discussing a deal with the Chinese company CEFC mentioned "the big guy" getting a 10% cut of the deal. I already think it's obvious that Hunter Biden was getting sweetheart board of directors positions and other highly lucrative financial opportunities almost entirely because of who his father is. But the theory here is that it wasn't just Hunter cashing in on his name, but that Joe Biden was explicitly contemplated as receiving kickbacks from these kinds of deals.
[For the record I agree that exploiting one's own political positions for monetary gain is not good. Even if nothing untoward actually happens, it's still a really bad look for the son of a president to be involved in deals and investments, especially with foreign governments where the influence-peddling concern would be at its apex.]
The evidence that motteposting presented that Joe Biden is indeed the "big guy" is that one of the people involved in negotiating the CEFC deal, Tony Bobulinski, personally confirmed that fact. I hadn't heard of Bobulinski before and didn't know why I should believe what he said. You can click through the thread for the details but I highlighted a few reasons why I would be skeptical of Bobulinski, but none of it was really a smoking gun. If you were to ask me to describe my actual belief it would be "Bobulinski's claim is certainly plausible but this other stuff kind of contradicts him so overall I'm skeptical but leaning towards not believing him." Motteposting was definitely not as skeptical as I was, and I found it curious that he (sorry if I misgendered you) appeared primed to believe Bobulinski in ways that seemed highly credulous.
This reminded me of another instance where someone's credibility was being evaluated as a result of a bombastic claim they made. Think back to six months ago, when Cassidy Hutchinson was in the news. For those who don't remember, Cassidy is the White House aide who gave the bombshell testimony about Trump lunging at the wheel of his Secret Service vehicle and at an agent when he was told he wasn't going to the capitol on January 6th. Everyone here knows I really don't like Trump so theoretically I would be primed to believe something that paints him in an embarrassing light. But similar to Bobulinski, I never heard of Cassidy before and don't know who she is but my opinion of her claims regarding the steering wheel incident hasn't changed: it cuts against her that she's relying on hearsay within hearsay ("someone told me someone else said this happened") but she at least names every level of the hearsay. Immediately after her testimony came out, multiple news outfits cited an anonymous source close to the Secret Service that two agents were prepared to testify that the lunging incident never happened. As far as I can tell these agents never came forward publicly but maybe that's still in the works. Similar to Bobulinski above, if you were to ask me to describe my belief it would be "Cassidy's claim is tenuously supported but is neither implausible nor substantially contradicted, so I would lean towards believing her but wouldn't bet the farm."
So back to the thread about Bobulinski, instead of writing my own position about him transparently, I wrote this instead:
One possible explanation is that Bobulinski is apparently still very upset with Jim and Hunter Biden over a deal he missed out on. He said himself the two brothers "defrauded" him of at least $5 million. This seems like good evidence he's at least partly motivated by payback. The Hunter Laptop saga hasn't really delivered and people lost interest over the years, which means right-wing pundits like Tucker Carlson and Sean Hannity are especially excited to herald Bobulinski with a moment in the spotlight. It doesn't matter if all that Bobulinski has is uncorroborated gossip, they know they can shore up ratings by resurrecting a dead story on a political figure their audience loathes.
If any of this comes across as weirdly stilted, I was intentionally trying to mirror what motteposting writing about Cassidy Hutchinson:
Simpler hypothesis: Cassidy Hutchinson is a former employee of Meadows’s who had a falling out with him and was subsequently passed over for a post-WH job in Trumpworld. This is her revenge tour. And the January 6th Committee is only too happy to turn to tabloid gossip because their ratings sucked and it worked well for some of their members three straight years during the Trump-Russia conspiracy theory heyday.
My suspicion was that motteposting was primed to believe Bobulinski and not believe Cassidy solely because he liked one conclusion but not the other. Obviously the two scenarios are not precisely comparable 1:1 but I think they have enough clear parallels for this to be an instructive exercise. If I'm being fully honest, the scenario I would find the most emotionally satisfying and personally motivated towards pulling off would be where motteposting blunders haplessly into my trap and exposes himself as a complete hypocritical partisan about the standards of credibility he applies. I must admit that I did not get that, and I'll specifically give credit for things he did that were commendable.
The first thing motteposting hones in on is that Cassidy has a motive to lie. The evidence he cites is entirely just this:
But there was a falling out between Hutchinson and Meadows in 2021, a former White House aide told CNN. She was supposed to become permanent staff at Mar-a-Lago, but those plans fell through, the outlet reported. The New Jersey native has yet to hold a full-time job since leaving the White House, the Washington Post reported.
So an anonymous source told CNN that Cassidy was supposed to have a job at a Mar-a-Lago but didn't, and now she's still unemployed. Based on this alone motteposting comfortably claims that Cassidy's testimony is "her revenge tour". I can see how being passed up for a job might make someone bitter, but it seems highly implausible that's enough to motivate someone into a public scorched earth campaign of defamation (and this didn't come out until later but the Daily Caller obtained text messages where Cassidy expresses annoyance at being subpoenaed to testify).
In contrast, Bobulinski claims Hunter Biden "defrauded" him of $5 million, which seems a much sharper indication of personal animus. To motteposting's credit he at least gives a concession of this point with "Maybe so. That's something to take into account." and "I agree that his motive for revenge means what he says should be taken with a grain of salt." But why is this not enough to conclude "This is Bobulinski's revenge tour" in the same way he concluded about Cassidy?
The second thing mentioned is that Cassidy's audience (J6 committee) is motivated to accept her lies because their TV ratings suck. That's a plausible explanation but it seems to apply at least as much to cable news pundits who rely on a content pipeline constantly running for their living. But unlike with Cassidy, motteposting does not appear to think audience credulity is a salient point in Bobulinsky's case.
I think motteposting made some good points about the structure of the CEFC deal. The fact that Hunter Biden was getting double the shares (20%) compared to his partners is compelling evidence he was going to hold it for someone else. If that's the surreptitious structure, then it makes sense for Joe Biden's name not to be on the agreement itself. There's good reasons to not believe Gilliar's denial that Joe Biden was involved, since there are text messages where he tells Bobulinski not to talk about Joe Biden's involvement except in face-to-face. Bobulinski also appears to be cooperating with the FBI and I agree that raises his credibility. Overall, motteposting did a good job convincing me that Bobulinski is telling the truth and that Joe Biden was at least contemplated to receive a cut of a deal that fell through. I updated my belief to "I have questions about some details but Bobulinski is probably telling the truth."
It still seems that motteposting was unusually primed to denounce Cassidy as a vindictive liar on a revenge tour. I think it's helpful to investigate to what extent our biases motivate us towards credulity and away from skepticism when presented with conclusions we already favor. If you ever suspect me of doing that, you should call me out.
Yes, governed by model RPC 1.7 and 1.8 but I don't know how they would be applied for a general counsel exactly. Conflicts are most often considered "waivable" where so long as you have the informed consent in writing from the client it's not a problem. Conflict check is a tedious responsibility for support staff at law firms. I very briefly worked at a law firm after already being a public defender, and the staff asked me for the names of the hundreds of defendants I represented so they could check for conflicts (and if there are any, basically have me quarantined from those cases). I was lucky that I had kept a spreadsheet but I don't know how normal people would have dealt with that.
My position on whether Baker acted in good/bad faith is "I don't know." I don't know the guy, I don't know how he reviewed the Twitter files, I don't know if he withheld anything improper, I don't know why he was fired, I don't know what explanations he gave Musk that were so unconvincing, and so forth. No one is obligated to give me evidence but if you want to sway me to one side or another, I need something stronger than "Elon Musk said so and we should take him at his word despite the absence of corroborating evidence he could trivially provide." So, until something else happens, I'll stay in the IDK camp.
Yes my assertion is indeed "It doesn't make sense to think the general counsel of a company is not supposed to be vetting files before they are disclosed to an outside party" and I stand by that position. You saying that I'm wrong is not enough to make it so. Can you actually explain how I'm off-base? As best as I can tell so far the issue seems to be that I'm not credulously accepting whatever Elon Musk said. I already explained why I'm suspicious of his claims, which part of my argument do you object to?
I'm not sure how you misread what I wrote to this degree. The post you are directly responding to explicitly said that it's possible that Musk fired Baker for lofty high-brow reasons. It's perfectly reasonable to place the burden of proof on the one making an assertion and my assertion in this case is "I don't have evidence to believe that". What objection do you have with my assertion?
You are instead asking me to provide evidence that Baker was fired for petty reasons, or that Baker acted in good faith. I never asserted either positions! I don't know if either of those things are true! How many different ways do I need to say this?
"You retweeted something I think is a partisan screed" is not an argument. You can continue scrying the tea leaves or you can actually address what I, myself, actually wrote and argued. I already laid out my position above and you've side-stepped addressing it. So once again:
Which part of the above exactly do you take issue with?
If Musk has evidence Baker acted badly (which I already said is perfectly plausible) there's nothing stopping him from showing it. He's not showing it. I don't think it's unreasonable for me to withhold judgment and not take Musk at his word when he's being so vague and cagey.
Which part of the above exactly do you take issue with?
I don't see how my retweets of what other people said are relevant. If you have an objection to something I myself actually wrote then just make your argument about what I actually wrote. No need to play offense archeology across other platforms, it's not like anyone can accuse me of being too terse to quote.
Baker managed to usurp that lawyer without Musk knowing, and immediately interferred in the process in ways Musk and Taibbi and the original lawyer agreed wouldn't happen.
I was not aware of this, where did you read this?
I think you meant "we can assume it's because you weren't doing your job the way he wanted you to". If so then yes, I agree, but that would be an unremarkable observation. The real question is what exactly Elon Musk was upset about that led to this guy's firing. Musk has fired Twitter developers that criticized him or talked back at him. It's his right to fire them, but it comes across as petty and vindictive. Because he has a very recent history of this kind of retribution against his employees, I don't think it's reasonable for me to assume that Musk fired Baker for lofty high-brow reasons. It could be true, but I don't have evidence to believe that at this point.
I agree with this. Even though Baker is general counsel, it's reasonable to want someone else from legal to review these files. But a blanket disclosure without any review at all would be so fucking idiotic and generate completely pointless and unnecessary legal liability from random things like social security numbers, privileged employee info, trade secrets subject to NDA, etc being released.
Because he wasn't supposed to be vetting them. Somehow he managed to insert himself into the process, against the wishes of Elon, and began slow walking and obfuscating access to the documents Elon wanted the journalist to have.
This doesn't make sense, Jim Baker has been the Deputy General Counsel and Vice President of Legal for Twitter since June 2020, he's absolutely supposed to vet records that will be released to an outside party. That's basically foundational to his job as general counsel for a company. Some of the things a general counsel would want to review are relatively banal (e.g. employee SSN) and others would be making sure that a disclosure doesn't violate an NDA, disclose trade secrets, or otherwise runs afoul of the overbearing National Security Letter gag orders.
The point of a legal department is to protect a company from legal liability, and releasing these files without any lawyer reviewing the disclosures would have been an idiotic move. So unless Musk specifically asked to release the files without involving legal, it's presumed that the legal department would do its job. That Taibbi seems surprised by this makes me think he doesn't understand what a general counsel's job is.
Musk claims that Baker's explanations were "unconvincing" but why should we take him at his word? He could easily tell us what the reasons are. I think it's plausible that Jim Baker would at least have a strong motive to conceal things that would impugn the FBI which is his previous employer, but motive is not the same thing as commission. If Baker did indeed conceal things from the reveal, then Musk can just tell us. If Baker did indeed have unconvincing reasons for being involved, then Must can just tell us. The fact that he's light on the details makes me think Musk's reasons for firing him may have been more personal than anything else.
This comment got a number of reports and rightfully so because it's basically boo outgroup fan-fiction. In general you should avoid making predictions in the vein of "I'm confident this person I don't like is going to do this bad thing in the future." Predictions are fine, but since you're not a clairvoyant you should temper your assertions accordingly and also proactively bring evidence to the table.
This is just a warning.
The Stefanopoulos interview (~8 minutes long) was so bad. I have my biases as a lawyer but a good interview should absolutely feel like a cross-examination, and Stefanopoulos did a great job at repeatedly hammering the same questions SBF kept evading. You can see the dude's gears working in the video as he keeps stumbling into pincer attacks.
Did you know that it was Trump who chose to file this lawsuit? Perhaps you're confused and thinking about a different case?

I don't hold the position that there's nothing to see here, I don't know! Musk could clarify so much here but it's suspicious how light on the details he is, so my position remains "I don't know" for the many reasons I outlined. You still don't even bother trying to explain why my skepticism is misplaced beyond heuristics like "we should assume Musk had a good reason for firing someone". It's weird.
More options
Context Copy link