@ymeskhout's banner p
BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				

				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

				

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				
				
				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

but thought they'd be forced to eat their own mistake cuz it was in the contract.

Sorry to say, but it's not clear your mom was in the clear. What you're describing is a classic palpable unilateral mistake, where the remedy a traditional court would likely impose is either modifying the contract to make it "make sense", or canceling it completely. In general, contract law does not treat kindly people who think they've potentially hoodwinked the other party. It's not obvious to me that this result was caused by arbitration.

I was specifically meaning to respond to the idea that people without lawyers or legal training should just start yolo-ing arbitration demands to orgs like PayPal doing shady stuff to them, which I don't regard as terribly helpful advice in light of my experience.

I understand your point, but what's the alternative? and what do they have to lose?

How embarrassing for me to have forgotten that link, it's perfectly on point. I don't think I fully appreciate how much of a setback a trivial hurdle can be. My economics brain thinks "durr cost went up by only 2.6%" which obviously does not reflect in reality for how people are really affected. So it's naive for me to think this can be solved as a call to action to individual users, it's just not at all a realistic ask. This does mean that the pendulum can swing back if you have someone doing the grunt work and creating an accessible tool. This NYT article from 2020 talks about how this happened with DoorDash, but it also talks about a startup called FairShake that tries to automate the dispute resolution process and makes money by taking a cut.

Because of the 6th amendment, criminal defense is very likely the most lawyered practice area possible. And because that's the realm I'm familiar with, I have a very skewed perspective of the "typical" case. I've seen a fair share of pro se petitions scrawled out in prison stationery, but those are extremely rare outliers.

Reading your post and being reminded of "Beware Trivial Inconveniences" makes me realize how much of a blind spot I have about the paperwork filing capabilities of the average person. Yeah, it's no surprise at all that they'd get clobbered. But the problems you're describing seem to be irrelevant to the choice between arbitration and traditional courts though. In either arena, having a dedicated professional is going to be an advantage. I'm not sure how you'd even begin to address that imbalance unless you significantly expand the public defender corps to cover more areas. Or maybe ban all lawyers.

Thanks for sharing this, that sounds like an obviously frustrating outcome. Knowing very little about rental disputes, I also thought about the "meeting-of-the-minds" problem Syo brought up being an issue. I guess the strongest argument against your mom is that she must've known it was a mistake since the garage was part of an enticement deal. I'd be interested to know how arbitration outcomes compare to real courts for this issue, judges there aren't particularly known to be deferential to tenants.

You're right about the intent behind "statute of frauds" although minor quibble is that it only applies to rental agreements longer than a year. But even where SoF does not apply by default, any contract can include something similar through an "integration clause" that says nothing outside the four corners of this written agreement counts (e.g. oral modification, or some other verbal promise).

I echoed the exact same concern about the lack of transparency in arbitration. Do you have a source on how arbitration is more expensive than litigation? It makes sense that arbitrators would be more expensive than judges who are paid a public salary, but that wouldn't be the full analysis. After all the most common benefit cited for arbitration is that it's much cheaper overall when you take into account the full costs (including attorney's fees) because the process is significantly less cumbersome than traditional courts. And in the specific context of whether consumers should initiate arbitration more, the cost is irrelevant if the companies are the ones footing the bill.

Still, I don't expect FIRE to use or even advocate for arbitration, but when they issued a statement on PayPal this is what they said:

Advocacy groups have also criticized the lack of due process provided to users who are suspended or banned. In many cases, PayPal doesn’t even tell users why it took action against them, other than to say they violated the acceptable use policy. Last year a coalition of groups including EFF and the ACLU called on PayPal and Venmo to “provide more transparency and accountability around its policies and practices for account freezes and closures, including publishing regular transparency reports, providing meaningful notice to users, and offering a timely and meaningful appeals process,” consistent with the Santa Clara Principles on Transparency and Accountability in Content Moderation.

I asked FIRE for specific proposals to improve due process and appeals they had in mind but they never responded. EFF/ACLU/FIRE can write all the letters they want, but companies have no reason to pay attention. Maybe someday they'll manage to pass some legislation that addresses this issue, but I don't see that happening anytime soon. So meanwhile, why not tell people about the tools already available?

Both your explanations are reasonable. Still, it wouldn't hurt if people tried to put up a fight more often with more companies. That would give us useful information.

I conceded that my legal background definitely gave me a strong edge here, but I think that was primarily in reducing the intimidation factor. Arbitration is intended to be a departure from the procedure labyrinth and inscrutable legalese that you find in traditional courtrooms. I would love to see how someone who isn't a legal professional wrangles with this process but I could not find any examples in my search.

I wrote for Singal-Minded (non-paywalled) on the topic of PayPal suspending accounts for what appear to be politically motivated reasons. I describe my experience with PayPal suspending my own account a few years ago, and how I managed to get it back:

I called, emailed, and waited on hold, but never got a straight answer from PayPal’s customer service drones. They endlessly repeated that I had violated PayPal’s acceptable use policy as if it were some mantra. If I asked for any detail whatsoever, their response had the tone of a schoolteacher frustrated at having to explain repeatedly to the same kid that crayons should not be shoved up one’s nose. I knew what I did to get my account deleted, apparently. If I wanted to hear it from them, I’d need a court order.

I took inventory of my options.

Here is what I did not have: money in the account, any serious reliance on it, or any wisp of nostalgia for the 14 years we shared.

Here is what I did have: too much free time and a whole heap of pettiness to propel things forward.

So I made a crazy decision. I read PayPal’s User Agreement.

PayPal, like many other companies, have a mandatory arbitration clause in their user agreements that require you to "agree" to waive your right to sue them in court if you have a dispute. I took PayPal up on the offer to settle our shit via arbitration but we never got that far because they quickly caved. I was prompted to write about all this after I met Colin Wright and offered to help him deal with his own PayPal bullshit. From my perspective, he refused my help but nevertheless kept writing opeds about the issue and soliciting donations. I heavily insinuated that he was intentionally holding on to his victimhood status as a grifting strategy. Turns out, I was wrong.

Colin has brought up the issue publicly multiple times since then (writing about it in Quillette and the New York Post for example), but he never responded to my email until I reached out to him for comment on this piece. He did share correspondence with me where prominent free speech attorneys told him, in an apparent contradiction to my claims, that he had no viable legal recourse to getting his account reinstated. I had transmogrified into a gadfly in his mentions, heavily implying Colin was intentionally choosing not to solve the problem, but I was off-base with my insinuation. Colin was bombarded with countless random people (besides just me) offering their one weird trick to solve the problem, and he had no reason to believe any of them knew something that experienced advocates did not. Colin has now initiated dispute resolution with PayPal using the steps I gave him, and I’m intensely curious to see how it will play out.

As best as I can tell, virtually nobody thinks to try to address the issue of politically-motivated corporate censorship with the tools already available to them. Not even FIRE talked about arbitration dispute resolution. This leads me to think this a low-hanging fruit counter-attack that's just ripe for the taking.

Edit: I found out about another instance of someone taking a company to arbitration and winning. See also the hacker news thread, esp. thathndude's posts where they explain how hiring an attorney (even one that doesn't do anything) can result in absurdly higher settlements.

And an important virtue of enforcing the rules against “minor” offenses like jumping the turnstile, peeing on the street, or carrying an open container of alcohol is that it’s easy to visually verify who is and isn’t following the rules. If someone isn’t following the rules, police officers can stop them and search them, and if they’re carrying an illegal gun, they can arrest them. Without this kind of low-level stop, the only way to get illegal guns off the street is by stopping people at random — which realistically means racial profiling. That is bad. People have a very legitimate interest in not being stopped and frisked merely for belonging to a particular demographic group. Where progressives have gone too far is in extending this consideration to people who are in fact committing crimes, when those are exactly the people you want to stop.

The bolded part is such a bizarre claim in this context. The only way that random stops can lead to racial profiling is if the law enforcement apparatus is somehow biased. Assuming that's true, how exactly would that bias disappear when pursuing low-level stops? It's impossible for cops to be everywhere and to enforce every possible offense in existence, so naturally they have to make some discretionary decisions. They need to decide what neighborhoods to patrol, what time to do so, what to be on the look out for, and what offenses to prioritize. That's a ton of opportunity for bias to seep in (again, assuming bias exists). In contrast, it's at least theoretically possible to construct a truly random stop system, and you can do so simply by significantly reducing the amount of police discretion by turning them functionally into unthinking robocops. At the beginning of every shift a computer uses RNG wizardry to pick a random part of the city and then tasks cops to stop people based on random arbitrary characteristics (e.g. stop the third person wearing blue, stop the 36th person walking in a northeast direction, etc.).

The majority of shootings are committed with illegal handguns, and we need constitutionally and morally permissible ways of discouraging people from carrying them. Rigorously enforcing boring rules is one of the best ways to do that, because the people shooting each other out there are mostly not mastermind assassins.

Gun possession on its own does not hurt anyone. The argument in favor of enforcing simple possession is as an upstream attack to preemptively address the potential for harm. The problem with this "precog" approach is exactly how indiscriminate the enforcement is. Even if it was enforced by unbiased automatons, a stop-and-frisk system cannot differentiate between the "good guy with a gun" and "bad guy with a gun". It ensnares everyone, regardless of their potential for violence. These kinds of "precog" justifications highlight how much of a waste of time gun control is in general, and how unjust it is. Which is why it's so wild to see folks like Yglesias essentially agree with me, but instead of using it as an opportunity to rethink the wisdom of gun control policy, he just bites the bullet and accepts that indiscriminate enforcement as a necessary evil.

most of his supporters were not dissuaded by such a thing

What would you estimate the baseline unrest to be? Do you think Bolsonaro's actions reduced, amplified, or did not affect unrest?

I know this is low effort, but it's nice to see a show that does a race swap actually explain it with good world building and even incorporate it nicely into the story.

From the archives The Value of "True" Diversity in Media:

I remember watching the first season of Mr Robot (another fantastic TV show). The show is about an introverted brilliant hacker. He also sometimes works with a hacker posse, and aside from the one neckbeard, the other members are an attractive white lady, an older black man, and a shy Iranian woman who wears a hijab. I remember how jarring it was to see the group being presented as "elite hackers". It just didn't seem believable. I am obviously operating on stereotypes, but I think the show creators were operating on the complete opposite which ran past the threshold line of belief suspension. It felt like they were pressured to have as much of a technicolor cast, maybe for legitimate reasons of not following a group of dweeby unattractive dudes, but also to avoid the bad optics.

But in the process it just felt cheap. Whenever I saw the hijabi, I just kept thinking "What is she doing here? Why is she involved? What is her interest in all of this?" to the detriment of being engaged with the story. None of it really gelled.

[...]

Maybe the objection that I have is that very few narratives try to engage deeply with the character's backgrounds when they make a deliberate effort to differentiate them. I can think of two brilliant examples. One is "Justin Bieber" from Atlanta portrayed by a black actor. It's so weird, and so unexplained, and so startling, but it fits completely within the surreal ethos of the show and I agree it puts the real Justin Bieber's behavior in a different context. The other example, and one of my favorite from recent memory, is HBO's Watchmen. I don't want to spoil too much, but it deftly handles the premise of "real life vigilante crime fighters" and seriously grapples with the idea of exactly who would feel the need to put on a mask to fight crime. There is a VERY big difference practically speaking of a black person putting on a mask to fight injustice, and a white billionaire doing the same. It puts into question why the latter would ever feel the need to hide their identity because they definitely would not face the same hurdles or tackle the same problems.

So basically, I like the idea of "diversity" in media depictions, but it has to be more than just set dressing. It has to feel that you went out of your way to diversify because you wanted to seriously engage with how their role would be different, instead of just working your way up a quota.

We need more BS policing of people statistically likely to be real criminals, and less BS policing of suburbanites who might have an oz of weed in their pocket or might blow a .08.

Without an AI police overlord running things, what specific instructions would you give police departments now?

all the talk from @ymeskhout and various others about how Jan 6th is the greatest threat to democracy since 9/11 or Pearl Harbor

You have a nasty habit of making shit up about me

Sure. Stop lying.

Stop lying about other people's positions are when they give it to you. Stop lying about people having never given you other arguments in the past. Stop lying that you haven't been provided insight into the specific concerns.

For reference, the above is what you asked me to stop doing.

For posterity's sake, I already responded (multiple instances and down thread) to each comment you are linking to in your post. It's refreshing to see you link to actual examples rather than speak in vagueries.

  1. I looked through and I could not identify any false statements I've made about other people's positions, so that part is taken care of. Anyone who disagrees with this assertion is welcome to demonstrate otherwise by pointing with some specificity.

  2. I've never made the claim that people have not given me arguments in the past, and that would be an especially silly to say given that you're linking to a thread where...I respond to people's arguments. So that part is also taken care of.

  3. Ditto with me claiming to not being provided with insight into specific concerns, as the thread shows otherwise. The one aspect I'd agree with is that I don't believe I've gotten a reasonable attempt to answer some variant of this question: "We still come back to the same question. Why are these supposed blockbuster claims ignored by every level of the institutions this country has built specifically to ferret this out?"

Overall, this is good news! You've had some concerns about me lying, and those concerns appear to be misplaced, so maybe we can be friends now. Of course, I suspect you will remain perennially angry with me unless I adopt wholesale whatever preferred conclusions you have about the topic. That has been my operating theory for a long time. If that's the case, I think that's really silly and there's nothing else to discuss. Please just admit it and save us both the time.

But! If my suspicion is terribly misplaced, I will forever maintain an open invitation for you to describe (in precise detail) what exactly I can do to change your opinion of me. In this (very long) thread from Aug '21, I invited @motteposting to outline what evidence and arguments I should consider. Who knows if they found my attempts satisfactory, but anyone can click and decide for themselves how diligent my efforts are, and whether or not I operate on good faith. I'm not trying to hide the ball here.

The modal reaction I have to when I get a new case is "Why in the fuck did you do this? What the fuck were you thinking?" and I only represent the people that survive.

fair point

I offer the link in the interest of transparency. People can click the link and read it themselves, I'm not hiding the ball. I think it's an illustrative exchange, because you've expressed clear enmity towards me for several years. Again, people can click and read themselves and you can write and explain yourself. Maybe some people will get it, maybe they won't. That's up to them.

I remain surprised by just how much outright hostility and anger I've engendered from you. I try my best to use clear language, precise terminology, links to sources, citations to evidence, et cetera. I have made earnest attempts at reading your posts multiple times and I am here again to say that I do not understand your positions. I think the clarifying questions I ask are simple enough, and you've either refused to answer them or you have and I'm just incapable of understanding them.

On the specific topic of 2020 elections, I've engaged with motteposting and shakesneer and others various times over the years. Even when I maintain my disagreements, I rarely walk away completely befuddled from what they've written. I have no explanation for why your posts are so inscrutable to me, but they are. It's up to you to choose if this continues to be a worthwhile use of your time.

ymeskhout can't select weak arguments when he's responding unless he ignores some and focuses on others, and he's responded to enough of the claims that it doesn't look to me like he's cherry-picking weakmen.

To be fair it's just not possible for me to address every argument with equal measure, even if it happens to be within my wheelhouse. That I've cherry-picked weakmen always remains possible, and people should call me out if they see it. But even if I'm guilty of that, it would only be relevant if I'm using the weakmen as a way to bury the rest of the group. It would be wrong for me to claim I destroyed a battalion by citing my victory over some toddlers in a wrestling match. So to speak.

The issue here that I found acutely frustrating is the resistance on display in letting go of specific premises, not necessarily overall conclusions. To use a deliberately outlandish example, someone arguing "J6 defendants are treated unfairly" links to video footage of Hillary Clinton using a hot iron to torture a MAGA prisoner. I swoop in with my google-fu and point out that the video is actually a scene from a porn with surprisingly high production values. A satisfying ending to this story is possible: the person who linked the video can just say "Damn I was wrong!" and we both can just move on, skipping into the horizon.

There are several things that I think definitely should NOT happen. One, I cannot cite my deboonking to claim I've conclusively proven that J6 defendants are actually treated fairly. That wouldn't follow, especially if I'm deliberately ignoring other, much stronger arguments. Two, the person who posted the hot iron porn shouldn't refuse to admit they were wrong on that premise. This evasiveness serves absolutely no purpose in this space, and it's startlingly immature. And three, now also would not really be the time for them to pivot towards dredging up ancillary reasons for why their conclusion still remains correct.

The last point especially seems like a clear "arguments as soldiers" situation. I gather that people get reflexively defensive when they believe their conclusion is under attack, and so the instinctual reflex is to retreat into another defensive line (hey-o fortification metaphor!). Either way, I try to make an effort to announce what my aims are. You'll know if I'm coming after your conclusion.

I've never used TikTok, in part because I see so many through twitter already

This is my experience exactly. I hated the shit out of the suggested posts side hustle, just show me my cousin's baby photos goddamn it

This means I no longer routinely use Facebook or any of their products, even though I've been a piece of their captured audience for more than 15 years.

Yeah this is really weird to me. I quite enjoyed facebook for many years, as it was the only reasonable way I could keep track of people I knew above my Dunbar limit. It was genuinely quite pleasant to get a drip-trickle of new information about people I knew, like oh neat they went to Spain, oh dang that's some insane workplace drama, oh wow they have triplets! And EVERYONE used it, so it worked almost perfectly as an address book of sorts.

The downside for me started maybe about 5 years ago, where instead of seeing my friends' status updates, I was increasingly bombarded with seeing their 'likes' on thoroughly shitty meme pages. It just felt so depersonal all of a sudden. I had to duct tape a variety of browser extensions to get it anywhere near usable but it just got worse. The vibe felt off, maybe it was just the culture war but people felt increasingly nasty and hostile, just shoving outrageous clickbait into everyone's face and saying "LOOK AT THIS SHIT". I truly hated it.

Nowadays it's desperately trying to claw onto attention by pretending it's TikTok, so I just get inundated with videos about pugs acting silly. I keep it around as an archive I guess, and it's still useful as very limited address book. But besides that, it's more or less useless.

Which brings me to the biggest loss of all: events. Oh my god, events. This was the best feature by far. Because everyone had a facebook account, the default assumption was that you will create a page on facebook for all your parties. And jesus fucking christ it cannot be understated how amazing of a feature it was that you could see who was going!!! I admit it, if I was on the fence about a party, I'd trawl through the 'attending' tab to see if any hotties were going. Facebook also let me know what their favorite bands were. I'd show up to the party already equipped with a solid opener.

Those were the days, and there's no comparable replacement for events. RIP.

It seems possible that the Chinese agents could surreptitiously sneak in some code to suppress certain content, but how would that remain undetected to the higher-ups or other employees? In contrast, if you have the 100% owner establishing a policy from the top, it's much easier to implement (granted the risk of a leak remains sky-high).

So it looks like Elon Musk officially owns all of Twitter now, and he's already fired the CEO, CFO, and policy chief. I don't have any strong opinions on this, but does anyone want to stake some predictions?

Musk presents himself as a free speech absolutist, which is encouraging to me, but I'd be concerned about the conflict of interest. I anticipate there will be some accusations of throttling unfavorable opinions about either him or his companies (RIP rogue driverless Tesla videos). I think the tension between unrestricted speech and a quality user experience will continue to be a problem, as I can't identify an obvious solution. Blue checkmarks are making hilariously cataclysmic remarks but I predict Twitter will remain a favored haven for the journalist class.

"Harsh punishments for political reasons" here means "harsher than the left is punished". You have to make a comparison (and once you do, "don't look up charges" then becomes relevant).

Edit to your edit: how am I supposed to know/assume this? Besides asking for clarification, what else am I supposed to do here?