@ymeskhout's banner p
BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				

				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

				

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				
				
				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

Hello everyone, I continue to have no idea what Dean is talking about, either in the post above or in the many responses to me (ex. most recently here). I know that Dean does not like it when I talk about 2020 election fraud theories, but I have no idea exactly why. This is a saga that has been going on for almost two years now, and I keep linking to this exchange in May 2021 as illustrative.

For example, Dean accused me of being selective with what theories I cover. When I asked which ones I should pay attention to, his responses were: "I'm not particularly interested in trying to feed you sources to be judged by you on your standards on credibility to consistency standards you impose that helpfully weed out things other people might care about and could even be true." and "I am uninterested in providing you sources on other people's positions given your conduct on this topic."

I don't know if I'm off-base here, but this reads to me as "It's not my job to educate you" which does not strike me as helpful or productive. Does anyone disagree with my interpretation?

I still continued trying to figure exactly what I should do differently. When I asked if focusing on Trump's theories was valid, Dean claimed accused me of incompetence and bad faith because "you are supposed to know that a lot of what Trump says is nonsense no matter what he talks about" and then I'm accused of lying about something (no idea what exactly): "In two sentences you have given what could be called lies about other peoples positions already given to you. This faux ignorance of other people's posts made just hours or minutes ago, and significant mis-representation of what has already been given to you, robs an exchange of sources or justifications of any value."

I've confessed that I don't know what I'm supposed to do differently. I mean, besides adopting Dean's preferred conclusions of course. Short of that, can ANYBODY provide ANY insight into the specific concerns and what EXACTLY I should do differently? I love feedback! Especially when I can understand it.

If you think its acceptable to put rapists and burglars on home confinement, that means you think those are in the same tier of crime as picketing congress.

I'm really having trouble following your thread because your responses seem to respond to a new collateral topic in each iteration. The point you made above, as I understand it, was to present home confinement as something reserved for high-profile cases by citing to a manual from 1987. When I pointed out that no actually, home confinement is the norm for low-level crimes nowadays, and also if you want a more recent reference point for how it works at the federal level you can look at what the Bureau of Prison did because of the pandemic, you shifted your point. You then claim that I think rapists and burglars are on the same tier as picketing congress. What? No, that's not the point at all. And this is getting into quibbling territory, but the feds virtually never deal with rapes and burglaries unless those things happen on federal property or somehow involve crossing state lines. And besides, the BOP pandemic home confinement release plan explicitly disqualified sex offenses.

Zero points. My god. I externed for a judge for most of law school, no one had zero points.

This is so weird. Of course people have zero points. Literally everybody in the entire world is born with zero points. All that zero points means in what you quoted is how many prior convictions that person has under USSG §4A1.2. That means that even hardened criminals at some point had zero points.

Very true, the Coase theorem relies on some unrealistic assumptions. However it's relevant regarding the discussion on reference points. If we're talking about a system where pollution is discouraged through taxes, that's not really any different from a system where non-pollution is encouraged through subsidies. That's why I found the talk about reference points to be a bit puzzling.

He was referring to what the protesters did, not what they were specifically charged with.

I'm not a mind reader. I asked him numerous times to clarify his position. If he chooses not to respond, I can't be blamed for the lack of clarity. I did my part.

You responded to this by interpreting these statements in a much more restricted way, declared them false based on a source showing actual sentences, asking why I believed these false things.

You are not being honest here.

My immediate reply was to ask you to clarify what you meant by "harsh punishments". I then showed my work about what I found after a quick search and asked you if this is what you meant, then again asked you for any specific cases you believed met your own definitions. You didn't respond. So my first top level post showed my work again, explicitly stated that I was relying on an incomplete database, explicitly admitted what you wrote could be interpreted in multiple ways, again asked you to provide any examples you knew about. You finally did reply by citing the Q Shaman guy's case, and I pointed out that your original claim appeared to have been much more expansive than just that guy, then again asked you multiple clarifying questions, to which you did not reply. When I badgered you again about this, it was to again ask you how you arrived at your position, and since at this point you didn't seem eager to defend it, I asked if it was actually based in fact. You responded, but not substantively, and instead implied that I would tie you into knots somehow.

Here's another question: What would you have me do differently? When your original claim was ambiguous, I asked you to define the terms you were using. When you didn't respond, I searched for examples on my own and asked you if this is what you meant. I continued asking you to clarify what you meant even after multiple unanswered prompts. I do not understand what purpose your evasiveness serves. If you're unhappy about being misinterpreted, you can't blame it on the guy hounding you for days repeatedly asking you to explain what you meant.

What you wrote directly above actually cleared up a lot of my original questions (finally!) and had you just said exactly this, we could have avoided much of the long and exhaustive trail of ask-ask-ask-ask I left behind. So once again, what would you have me do differently? I'm actually listening.

I am not the enforcer here, if Nybbler wants to broaden or modify their original claim that's totally fine! It's just bizarre to lament how something doesn't "count" because of contours they themselves created!

The various filings unfortunately don't include a sentencing guidelines rundown because they plea deal went around that

Here's the government's sentencing memo (I found it by googling "joshua bustle courtlistener"). The sentencing guidelines don't apply to misdemeanors.

Typically a person in position to get home confinement either has scammed people out of millions of dollars, or has a case officer report that details a laundry list of uncharged conduct. Home confinement is historically defined as a 1:2 ratio compared to prison. See. Chapter IV.

I appreciate that you included a link, but that's a report from 1987. Home confinement happens all the time nowadays, for both pretrial detention and sentencing, and is usually enforced by an ankle bracelet. It's the absolute norm for my misdemeanor cases (and sometimes felonies if I secure a good deal), and the ranking typically goes from community service > home detention > jail. Prosecutors are dismissive of home detention because they think it's akin to a vacation, which I kind of understand. I wouldn't expect you to know all this, but I'm confused as to where you got the impression that this is reserved to only multi-million scammers. For a recent reference, BOP released a bunch of federal prison inmates into home confinement because of the pandemic. It's a widely used sanction.

But since the actual charge wasn't "trespass", these cases "don't count".

That sucks, do you happen to know who made up these rules about which examples should "count"? Whoever they are, I hope they are held accountable.

True, but it doesn't change the fact that credibility is tarnished. How are we supposed to know which decisions are good and bad in the future? Being lied to once before means we can't accept it on a good faith basis.

Have you ever heard of the Coase theorem?

I think it's reasonable to be concerned about political violence. Have you ever heard about the book Days of Rage? This review from Status 451 was quite illuminating in highlighting just how crazy things were in the 1970s. I find it useful perspective:

In 1975, NWLF bombs went off in San Francisco once a week for nine months. They targeted local politicians, including Dianne Feinstein’s house. NWLF bombed a trial, country clubs, the opera. The bombings didn’t wholly stop until 1978. The reason NWLF bombings stopped: the guy who did most of them went insane and killed his girlfriend with an axe.

[...]

In Christmas 1980, a new group called the Puerto Rican Armed Resistance bombed Penn Station in NYC during rush hour. No one was hurt. In May 1980, the PRAR called in bomb threat to JFK. A Pan Am handyman found their bomb, and alerted people, but the bomb killed him. Two more bombs at the airport were found in the aftermath. It was all getting going again. And then, just like that, it ended two weeks later when Oscar Lopez Rivera and a new recruit got stopped for an illegal U-turn. Lopez Rivera got 55 years.

I vaguely remember seeing or reading articles claiming severe treatment of the J6 prisoners (held in solitary, etc), and vague claims of wildly disproportionate punishments for extremely minor offenses.

Well these things are true, at least for some defendants. The three names I highlighted above kind of fit the mold, especially Hale's sentence. The issue is how much of a trend you can draw from these individual cases. If someone is primed not to care or think about the criminal justice system and their first exposure is seeing people they feel a kinship with get hammered with several years in prison, it's reasonable to be aghast by what appears to be politically motivated. For basically everyone who had a passing familiarity with the system, the response was basically "lol welcome to america".

I completely agree that it would violate a fundamental element of fairness if otherwise identical situations were treated different for inappropriate reasons. I agree that in this context, the appropriate analysis requires a comparison, and I've tried to engage in exactly that in the post you're replying to. The part I take issue with is when this concern metastasizes into a self-fulfilling reality, where people adopt premises that are untethered from reality but do so because it confirms this unfair persecution narrative. If persecution does indeed exist, you can point it out without resorting to fantasy. I would personally disagree with you on pushing the lever towards throwing the book at people in general, but I at least can recognize you are holding an intellectually coherent position for J6/BLM, and one which appears to be reasonably based in fact. That significantly shrinks the field of objections I am able to levy.

I recognize at any given moment there's the possibility I will be engaging with a conflict theorist, but it seems like good practice to continue assuming otherwise.

The protestors who who attempted to disrupt the Kavanaugh hearings being arrested en masse and and spending months if not years in prison.

Well the 2018 protestors were accused of trespassing/crowding and were arrested en masse. But I don't get the second part, are you claiming that people accused of trespassing/crowding on January 6th were sentenced to months/years in prison?

I don't have any superpowers. There's nothing Herculean about saying "Yes my original position was based on false premises, I adopted those false premises because of X, Y, & Z". I don't get why you're so resistant, as you're not even challenging the premise of my question. Neither you nor anyone else has tried to defend the original "many" claim with fact, so why not just admit it was wrong? It's not a personal failing. I too sometimes hold erroneous beliefs, and it's ok when people call me out on it.

I remain intensely curious as to how you arrived at your original position, especially since you appear to have asserted it with some measure of confidence by claiming there were "many" such examples. Is it now reasonable to conclude your assertion was not based in fact? What is your best guess for why you nevertheless adopted this belief? I think these are relatively straightforward questions so I don't understand your apparent reluctance in answering.

So to recap, your original claim posited that we reached Debs level of political persecution, and that original assertion was based on what you believed were instances of people held without bail just for wandering in. It appears that you are now shifting away from that original position and instead arguing that precedent is broken in part because the ringleaders of January 6th are not offered light probation and because 90% of charges are not being dropped.

Am I incorrect to say that your position has changed? If not, could you explain the thought-process that led you to this change?

Not everyone on J6 punched a cop or broke stuff, the vast majority did no worse than just trespassing. So shouldn't that group be used as the baseline comparison to Portland fence-hoppers or Wisconsin protestors?

On its own it's a somewhat ambiguous statement to make because it is true whether vaccines are either 0% effective or 99% effective. The statement's ambiguity is a good reason to avoid saying it. I don't think I've encountered it much here but out in the wild the only times I really encounter this type of statement is as a prefix to why no one should get or is justified in not getting vaccinated. Given that association I don't think my initial impulse was unreasonable. I might update my priors to the extent it stops being associated with bona fide anti-vaxxers.

You can have a legitimate public health interest in vaccination, while having an overriding “sum total good” interest in keeping athletes and others in your city

I don't really understand this. The exemption applied to all athletes, artists, and performers, even the completely useless ones that brought in no money to the city. You can make this argument for exemptions about anyone who worked in "essential" industries, especially medical and sanitation.

I already said that Hale's political opinions should have absolutely no bearing on how he's treated by the legal system. Please notice that what you're responding to was only addressing American Gulag's needlessly obfuscating summary of Hale's YouTube channel.

Dressing up as Hitler is protected expressive activity under the First Amendment, not a valid reason to hold someone without bail.

I agree! You appear to be refuting a position you seem to have made up. I said exactly this already:

the government brief spends several pages describing how awful his politics are. I think that's protected speech that should have no bearing on whether he is released

The only reason I brought up Hale's facial hair preference was a comment on American Gulag's summary. The site didn't have to say anything at all about Hale's YouTube channel. The fact that they tried to describe his Hitler cosplay and "The Jews" rants as just a guy "sharing his political viewpoints on YouTube" makes me think they're intentionally trying to obfuscate and mislead people.

I think the norm breaking and hand waving of precedents is very similar in its problematic nature. The issue here isn't that any individual case cannot be justified on some grounds. The issue is that it is being justified for no other reason than the DOJ wanting to justify them.

I read this multiple times and I don't understand what it means. What norm is being broken? What precedent is being hand waved? When you say that treatment in individual cases are being "justified for no other reason than the DOJ wanting to justify them", what does that mean? Are you saying that DOJ is making up reasons in their sentencing memorandum? Like what?

I tried and could not find an equivalent database for the 2018 Capitol riot. As best I could see all but 5 were handled with "‘Post & Forfeit" procedures, with the other 5 being released the next Monday on bail.

I'm going to assume that J6 was more-or-less comparable to the 2018 Kavanaugh protest. Almost everyone arrested in 2018 was accused of trespassing/crowding. We already know that 70% of all J6 defendants were also released pretrial, so do you have any evidence to show that those accused of just trespassing/crowding were treated harshly? I highlighted three names that I think plausibly fit your original claim of "held without bail for wandering in", but they seem to be outliers.

I suspect a primary reason why Hale got punished so hard is that he was completely unsympathetic. If this was primarily politically driven, then I'd assume we'd see similar blood-thirsty retribution imposed upon the folks who were charged with just misdemeanor trespassing, but almost all of those just got probation and no jail. Hale embarrassed the establishment because he managed to get a security clearance and work at a naval weapons base while being a genuine and almost comical Nazi, so he had to be made an example of. I'm not saying this to claim the justice system had a good reason, but just describing the unfortunate reality of a heavy-handed system operated by heavy-handed humans. Here's the docket entry for his case if you're interested, and here's the sentencing memorandum filed by the government where they asked for 78 months.

Hale talked at length about wishing there was a civil war after J6 so that he could have a chance to arrest "the Jews" if they didn't immediately leave the country. Hale also testified in his own trial and tried to credulously claim he had no idea Congress was even in the Capitol that day. He was caught on video interfering with a police officer trying to arrest a rioter, but at trial he claimed he had no idea that was a cop. Both those factors and more slammed him head-first into the brickwall that is the United States Sentencing Guidelines and the government tried to argue various enhancements to put his offense score was 27, which put him within 70-87 months of prison. His aunt appears to have used Hale's notoriety and received at least $1M of donations under the name "Patriot Freedom Project" but seems to be hoarding the money since records are incomplete. Pg 42 of the brief also helpfully compares their requested sentence with what other J6 defendants got.

So he lied on the stand (badly), had grander motivations about violent revolution beyond just entering the building, and put a cop at risk by physically interfering in an arrest. I personally find his sentence to be egregiously high, but unfortunately it's well within the norm in a country known for eye-wateringly high prison sentences. If I was a criminal justice reform advocate that wanted to highlight an example from the J6 pool, Hale would be one of the last people I'd pick.

But I still see that we're not evenly applying this principle. Left-wing mobs invade Congress and hound legislators and the worst that seems to happen is they get removed. Months on end of assaults on the federal courthouse in Portland weren't taken this seriously.

What would be the falsification to this belief?

New York City has been ordered to reinstate with back-pay city employees who were fired for refusing to get the covid-19 vaccine. When I first encountered this story, the quote that was bandied from the judge was "Being vaccinated does not prevent an individual from contracting or transmitting Covid-19" and my initial impression was of a fringe anti-vax judge. But the judge meant this literally, as in "the vaccine is not 100% effective" and what he writes in the decision is much more nuanced and generally in support of vaccination.

I am not philosophically opposed to vaccine mandates. Vaccines are easily one of the greatest inventions of mankind, and I don't find it unreasonable to impose a cost on individuals to the extent it can potentially mitigate negative externalities. I'm also not someone who opposes other public health mandates in general, and I was OK with mask mandates for the most part, up until we had widely available vaccines. What never made sense to me was the incoherent overall set of rules. For example, some time around mid-2021, my gym instituted a vaccine passport system whereby you could show proof of vaccination and thereafter be able to work out without a mask. I was totally fine with this system, especially since it was a private entity finding a way to accomodate the needs of a varied clientele. A few months later however, the government ordered all gyms to require masks no matter what and I was fucking pissed. I had to now wear a mask at the gym despite being surrounded by vaccinated people, but meanwhile I could go maskless for several hours at a time at restaurants surrounded by unknown quantities. It didn't make any sense, and it just needlessly burned up whatever credibility public health authorities had. I made the same point at the height of the BLM protests/riots, when social distancing magically didn't matter anymore.

So back to New York City, in October 2021 the city ordered all public employees to be vaccinated. The judge in this case found the order to be "arbitrary and capricious" largely because of how nonsensical the implementation was. If the purpose of the mandate is to increase vaccination with the goal to decrease the spread of a deadly contagion, why exempt certain professions like athletes, artists, and performers? And why allow city employees who are appealing the mandate to continue working full-time as their appeal is pending?

The term "pretextual" comes up sometimes in legal contexts, and it's where a false reason is provided as a bid to hide the true motivations of an action. For example, a cop can say they stopped a vehicle only because the car was speeding, but their true motivation for the stop is to create an opportunity to investigate something else entirely. In Whren v. United States, SCOTUS unanimously decided that pretextual traffic stops were legal (they call them "mixed-motive stops" which is lol) and to date Washington and New Mexico are the only states that prohibit the practice. Because it is virtually impossible to perfectly comply with traffic rules at all times, the practical effect of allowing pretextual stops is that a cop can pull over basically any car they want to. They just need to watch them long enough.

New York City may claim their goal is purely public health related, but it's perfectly reasonable to be skeptical of their stated reasons when the implementation does not align with their goals. The judge in this case wrote:

The vaccination mandate for City employees was not just about safety and public he alth; it was about compliance. If it was about safety and public health, unvaccinated workers would have been placed on leave the moment the order was issued. If it was about safety and public health, the Health Commissioner would have issued city-wide mandates for vaccination for all residents.

Perhaps they can overcome this suspicion by providing a damn good reason for how art protects against transmission, or how pursuing an appeal makes one less contagious, but I have not been able to find one. In the absence of a good reason, I can conclude their stated goal is pretextual. Despite their claims otherwise, it's obvious that the stated goal of public health was not always an overriding priority. The city was apparently willing to let the Very Important Goal be subsumed by comparatively trivial concerns, like not pissing off Very Important People in the entertainment industry. So next time New York City or similar claims they are doing something in furtherance of public health, it's reasonable to assume they're lying until you see evidence otherwise. If the public trusts these bodies less, they can blame themselves.