@ymeskhout's banner p
BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				

				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

				

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				
				
				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

You can't acquire wealth from jail

How does posting bond make someone less dangerous? I know the putative argument is that people are encouraged to be on good behavior on pain of forfeiting their bond, but I haven't seen good evidence this actually works. Bail companies exist and they can front the full amount in exchange for paying 10%, and if you have Fuck You levels of money you can just post bond and jet set to the Philippines or whatever. For those who can't afford it, do you have any concerns about making liberty conditional on wealth?

An update, largely for the sake of visibility, about my post below on January 6th defendants.

I received a number of very helpful responses pointing out some things I missed. I was wrong when I said @anti_dan 's claim about J6 defendants "held without bail for wandering in" was fictitious. At least three different people reasonably fit this qualification: Timothy Louis Hale-Cusanelli, Karl Dresch, Michael Curzio, and possibly others. All three had their bail denied, meaning they were going to remain behind bars no matter what, and no amount of money would get them released ahead of trial. Dresch and Curzio ended up getting released about 6 months later after pleading guilty to misdemeanors. Hale was convicted at trial and was sentenced to 48 months of prison.

The reasons why their pretrial release was unconditionally denied are not that surprising, especially in light of how unforgiving US legal standards are in this area. Hale was frantically trying to destroy evidence by deleting his accounts and disposing of clothing & javelin flag pole. His coworkers at the naval weapons base he had a security clearance for thought he was crazy because he'd regularly show up to work with a Hitler mustache and make holocaust jokes. Curzio spent 8 years in prison for attempted 1st degree murder conviction, and within two years of his release he perhaps demonstrated some poor judgment by traveling from Florida to be on the frontlines of the J6 riot. Dresch is someone whose case I wrote about before within the discussion of pretrial detention. He had bad criminal history (multiple law enforcement obstruction charges, and a number of felonies from when he led cops on a high-speed chase reaching speeds of 145mph) and despite his felony convictions, he was caught with multiple guns after J6.

So going back to @anti_dan 's original claim:

That you can be held without bail for wandering in, without them even proving that you knew it was illegal to be there (for most people the barricades had been long abandoned by the incompetent, Pelosi directed, Capitol Police), is Eugene Debbs shit.

In case you don't know, Debs was a prominent and unusually eloquent socialist (Freddie DeBoer is a big big fan) who was sentenced to ten years for sedition for protesting America's participation in WW1. If you've ever heard the phrase "can't yell fire in a crowded theater", it's because that was used by Oliver Wendell Holmes to justify the imprisonment of another socialist WW1 protestor in Schenck v. United States, and so Debs' SCOTUS appeal was rejected for the same reasons. First Amendment jurisprudence was pathetic back then.

I don't know if anti_dan still holds their belief on comparing some J6 defendants to Debs, but now that we have some identifiable cases of people who were held without bail for wandering in, perhaps this can prompt a more fruitful discussion on the legitimacy of this comparison. Some questions for everyone: Are you surprised by the reasons why these people were denied pretrial release? Is denial of their release indicative of politically-motivated retribution?

This is a good resource that is easy to navigate and with plenty of links, but I'd just be cautious about accepting their summaries at face-value. Their page on Timothy Louis Hale-Cusanelli simply says "The government indicates Hale shares his political viewpoints on YouTube." which is a surprisingly terse way to describe someone whose schtick was to dress up as Hitler and make videos about how we should finish the job he started.

This is a solid response. You took the time to examine a resource I linked to but used it in a way I didn't consider by unearthing past cases. You are absolutely correct about both Karl Dresch and Michael Curzio, they were indeed held without bond for wandering in.

Dresch is someone whose case I wrote about a while back but I completely forgot about it. That his release was unconditionally denied was not surprising, the guy had "escape from law enforcement" felonies and he was twice caught with guns he wasn't supposed to have.

Curzio was not accused of any violence, the government complains that he "cursed" at officers. What likely sunk him is that he was convicted of attempted 1st degree murder in Florida and was released in early 2019 after 8 years behind bars. It definitely reflects poorly on his decision-making ability that he travels from Florida to DC to be on the frontlines of a riot just a couple of years after getting out of prison.

But the reasons why both were denied release are orthogonal to @anti_dan 's original claim. anti_dan can squarely make this claim about both cases and I would have no objections.

but a dumbass who intentionally torches a building should also be held or at least be posting a large bond.

Earnest question but what do you think the purpose of pretrial detention should be?

Well that's really kind of you to say. I generally appreciate reading your stuff and you don't strike me as particularly unkind overall. A critique coming from you is something I'm inclined to take seriously by default, so don't take me off your target list.

I fully admit you are a better lawyer than me and will always be able to find a wording by which the actions against the January 6 rioters look perfectly in line with the actions against left-wing rioters, or which somehow distinguish the actions those left-wing rioters from those of the right-wing ones.

I appreciate the kind words but I don't have any superpowers and what I did wasn't special. My real-world experience does give me some anchors and generalized awareness, but what I did above just boiled down to googling. If I make an argument that is unsupported by the evidence, I think anyone has the power to demonstrate that. I can't claim that how the J6 defendants are treated is "perfectly in line" with left-wing rioters. I do think it's a reasonable conclusion, but I remain open to evidence demonstrating otherwise.

Regarding Q Shaman, I personally think 41 months is an unconscionable amount of prison time, especially one without even the trial tax applied, and especially given what seem to be clear mental health issues. But your original claim was much more expansive than just the Q Shaman. You said:

"many of the "rioters" who committed no crime worse than trespassing (in some cases not even entering the building, just supposedly-forbidden parts of the grounds) are getting harsh punishments for political reasons"

So I remain very curious to know how you arrived at this belief. Pointing out that the person who was most visibly at the center of the riot got a ridiculously high prison sentence is not going to be representative of the rest of the participants, most of whom did indeed commit no worse than trespassing. So how did you arrive at the claim that "many" of those trespassing were getting "harsh punishments"? Do you still hold this belief? Where did this belief come from?

I appreciate that you included specific names! The window you're referring to Zachary Alam breaking with a helmet was at the Speaker's Lobby doorway, the exact same window Ashli Babbitt immediately tried to jump through before getting shot. So when I asked about defendants who are held without bail for "wandering in", obviously Alam's case does not qualify and you knew that.

You can also skim through the government's brief for some of the reasons he was denied release. They were concerned he was a flight risk, because immediately after J6 he changed his phone number, cleared out his storage unit, and fled to another state. When he was finally arrested, he was driving a vehicle he never registered and had multiple stolen license plates. He also has a history of using multiple fake names and was caught with multiple ID cards. His to-do list that included buying crypto and stashing a burner phone probably didn't help. Then of course, when he's in jail and talking on a recorded phone line, he's asking people if they talked to the FBI. The brief goes on and on.

Regardless, I think pretrial release should be the presumptive default, even for extreme flight risks like Alam.

Thanks! I watched enough of the stream to hear Kelly mention Timothy Louis Hale-Cusanelli. This guy was indeed held without bail and then sentenced to 48 months in prison after a jury trial. I was very curious about why he was denied bail and why his sentence was so high. His motion for release was litigated around Mar 2021 and the government brief adds some potentially relevant details.

I think the only valid concern the government had was that Hale would try to destroy evidence or intimidate witnesses. He apparently was frantically trying to delete all his accounts and also dispose of clothing from that day and a flag pole used a javelin. Hale worked at a naval weapons center and had a security clearance, but his coworkers said they feared retaliation from reporting his antics because he was "crazy", probably because he would regularly show up to work in a Hitler mustache and make jokes about the holocaust.

Beyond that though, the government brief spends several pages describing how awful his politics are. I think that's protected speech that should have no bearing on whether he is released, but unsympathetic defendants make bad laws, and this guy sounded especially unstable and unhinged. The government successfully argued that his enthusiastic talk about "civil war" (see starting pg 19) should be considered in context of his clear Nazi political ideology.

But the reasons he was denied bail are largely orthogonal to the original issue I raised. Even a charitable reading of the statement of facts filed against him by the government doesn't really accuse him of engaging in violence on J6, but apparently "coordinating" other rioters to advance and also cussing at police officers. I think @anti_dan can plausibly argue that Hale was someone "held without bail for wandering in" but not "without them even proving that you knew it was illegal to be there".

Isn't it possible that the American powers-that-be is just so firmly rooted and secure that it doesn't actually perceive the January 6th rioters as a real threat?

I'm inclined to agree with this. Enough of a disturbance to Teach A Lesson, but not enough of a threat to whip out the death squads.

In the thread below about the WNBA player who was sentenced for weed possession in Russia, the discussion dovetailed into how January 6th defendants are treated and a couple of people made what to me were eyebrow-raising claims. @anti_dan worried about the fact that J6 defendants could "be held without bail for wandering in", and @The_Nybbler was concerned about how "many of the "rioters" who committed no crime worse than trespassing (in some cases not even entering the building, just supposedly-forbidden parts of the grounds) are getting harsh punishments for political reasons".

As the token defense attorney who cares about criminal justice reform, both concerns piqued my attention. But as far as I can tell, the concerns are fictitious [EDIT: see notes below]. I've previously written about the difficulties inherent with collecting representative data about state crime statistics (tldr: lots of scattered jurisdictions + lack of court record transparencies), and while I've previously whinged about people here being sloppy with their claims about state crime trends, I fully appreciate the reluctance in committing to what can amount to a thesis-level research endeavor.

But it's different with the J6 prosecutions because they're all happening in a single jurisdiction with a lot of people paying attention. Information is surprisingly easy to find. Just googling "january 6th defendants database" will lead to dozens of hits.

Regarding the people held without bail just for wandering in, I did a quick google search but couldn't come up with an updated number of how many defendants are still held in jail (either with no bail or with unrealistic bail). There was a DC Appeals Court decision a while back that instructed magistrates to release people unless the government can demonstrate a specific threat. This means that anyone who is "held without bail for wandering in" would be contrary to that court's order. It's possible I missed something, but I couldn't find any evidence of this happening [EDIT: see notes below].

For the claim that "many" of the J6 defendants were facing "harsh punishments" (in fairness, this is ambiguous) for doing no worse than just trespassing, this too was easy to quickly google. This database from Politico is out of date but was at least searchable. Most of what I was familiar with for misdemeanor J6 pleas was just probation with no jail time. I plugged in "entering a restricted building" in the full table and sorted by incarceration and saw only three people got jail time (reminder that the database is incomplete) with the highest being 50 days for William Tryon. I quickly googled and easily found the guilty statement that was filed in his case. I would guess that the aggravating factors that made his case stand out was that he asked police to enter the building, was denied, tried to enter anyway, was pepper-sprayed, created an opening at another location by removing broken glass, encouraged other people to enter the building, and then confronted another line of police. He couldn't have claimed a plausible defense of "I didn't know I couldn't enter" based on those facts. Given what I know about misdemeanor sentencing, 50 days of jail for this fact pattern did not strike me as out of the norm. Maybe The_Nybbler knows about "many" other cases that I somehow missed, or perhaps they have a specific definition of "harsh punishments" which would encompass probation.

I responded to both with my concerns but neither replied. Maybe either/both have some evidence to showcase, in which case they now have another opportunity to do so (yay!). I think this is an illuminating exercise because it can shed light on our biases and how we can process information. In my last whinge on this topic, I had an enlightening exchange with adamsb6, where they initially suspected that J6 defendants were treated especially harshly. I asked some basic Bayesian questions (how many J6 defendants? what % of those were released? what % of all federal defendants are released?) and they were surprised at how off-base some of their assumptions were. This does not mean that J6 defendants are not treated especially harshly, but the exchange was instructive because it plainly demonstrated how even a conclusion arrived at in earnest can be muddied up if you are led by inaccurate premises.

I hope we can have a similarly enlightening exchange with the above examples. It's possible that both @anti_dan and @The_Nybbler 's claims are true, in which case I remain eager to see their evidence. If neither claim is true, then I would be very curious to know how they arrived at these conclusions. I anticipate that the likely issue is feeding inaccurate premises into the system, which can befall anyone and is not a personal failing. You don't always know what you don't know after all. In either case, I hope I've shed light on just how easy quickly googling shit can be (I swear I am not sponsored by the search engine company).

Edit1: @DradisPing helpfully pointed me to the case of Timothy Louis Hale-Cusanelli. As further explained in my post below, I think this is someone @anti_dan can plausibly argue was "held without bail for wandering in", but not "without them even proving that you knew it was illegal to be there".

Edit2: @JarJarJedi had a solid response and pointed out Karl Dresch and Michael Curzio to which I responded to below. Both were indeed "held without bail for wandering", although arguably they knew it was illegal to be there.

I don't know how that's responsive to my question. You'll notice that I never claimed that none of the J6 defendants were held without bail. I explicitly acknowledged them when I wrote about "defendants are still held in jail (either with no bail or with unrealistic bail)". I even linked to an article explicitly staying "Yes, several people are being held without bail in the D.C. Jail"! What I was asking for was about the people who are "held without bail just for wandering in" as @anti_dan claimed they are. Do these people actually exist?

I don't exactly see the criminal justice reform advocates lining up to release the Jan 6 crowd without cash bail or whatever.

I did, when I wrote about one guy's case a while back:

I ultimately strongly disagree with her conclusion, but only as a matter of policy because I believe the default stance of reflexively jailing individuals who haven't even been convicted yet is an atrocious practice that needed to be retired long ago. But from a legal standpoint, I can't really find much fault.

That you can be held without bail for wandering in, without them even proving that you knew it was illegal to be there (for most people the barricades had been long abandoned by the incompetent, Pelosi directed, Capitol Police), is Eugene Debbs shit.

Can you point out anyone who was "held without bail just for wandering in"? About 1000 have been prosecuted so far, but the vast majority (~70%) were released without bail. The vast majority of the remaining defendants had bail imposed. I did a quick google search but couldn't come up with an updated number of how many defendants are still held in jail (either with no bail or with unrealistic bail). There was a DC Appeals Court decision a while back that instructed magistrates to release people unless the government can demonstrate a specific threat. This means that anyone who is "held without bail for wandering in" as you claim they are would be contrary to this court's order. The subset of defendants should be small enough that you should be able to point out someone who fits the concerns you've just described. Can you?

Your original claim remains pointlessly ambiguous because you can argue you're technically correct whether the drop in incarceration was either -100% or -1%. If you're describing what happens to the "common criminal", what's your definition of that class? What portion of criminals? How common is this experience? How many people need to be released without bail for this to be considered "common"? How many charges need to be quietly dropped for this to be "common"? It's such a vague claim to make.

  • -10

Right, you tried to hand-wave away the 400,000 or so people in pretrial detention by claiming they are there for murder. It would be helpful if you were more precise with your claims, and maybe if you brought forth actual evidence.

bailey: "common criminals get released without bail and then have their charges quietly dropped"

motte: "the incarceration rate has gone down in recent years"

In fairness your original comment was rather ambiguous, but had you just claimed the latter I wouldn't have taken any issue.

I think pointing out the potential biases of an organization and their methodological reasoning is a good thing and kudos for doing that, I just wasn't exactly clear what your overall point was.

You made a claim about "common criminals". Are you implying that the 2 million people currently behind bars are by definition "uncommon"?

  • -10

A new consensus formed, especially in blue states, that prior sentencing laws were too strict. Many localities elected district attorneys and judges who took an extremely lenient stance on crime. This was also exacerbated by the Covid epidemic when jailing criminals was seen as unsafe to their health. The per capita prison population peaked in 2008, and the murder rate reached a low in 2014.

I don't deny that incarceration rates have significantly dropped in recent years (esp pandemic-related), but that doesn't support claiming that common criminals get "released without bail and then have charges quietly dropped". If that's how "common criminals" are being treated, is the implication that the 2 million or so people currently behind bars are by definition uncommon?

where many of the "rioters" who committed no crime worse than trespassing (in some cases not even entering the building, just supposedly-forbidden parts of the grounds) are getting harsh punishments

What's your definition of "harsh punishments"? There are a bunch of databases of Jan 6th cases, and this one from Politico is at least searchable (though hasn't been updated since January). Most of what I've seen for misdemeanor pleas was just probation with no jail time. I plugged in "entering a restricted building" in the full table and sorted by incarceration and saw only three people got jail time, with the highest being 50 days for William Tryon (keep in mind that the database is incomplete though). Reading the guilty statement that was filed, I would guess that the aggravating factors that made his case stand out was that he asked police to enter the building, was denied, tried to enter anyway, was pepper-sprayed, created an opening at another location by removing broken glass, encouraged other people to enter the building, and then confronted another line of police. He couldn't have claimed a plausible defense of "I didn't know I couldn't enter" based on those facts. 50 days of jail for this type of misdemeanor does not strike me as out of the norm.

Can you link to any specific cases where you think the sentence imposed was outrageous?

If this is how common criminals are treated, how does the US end up with one of the highest incarceration rates in the world?

Was this intended as a refutation of the 400,000 number? It seems like you're suspicious the number is real but all you've offered is pointing out that the organization has a leftist agenda.

btw I think it's funny people downvoted a factually true comment that took some effort to dig up, and didn't even bother refuting it