I'm sorry you're offended by me providing a single fact as context; it wouldn't have been necessary if you'd bothered to be even vaguely accurate or honest.
at this point I gather you want one of the following:
Actually, no. I left the topic alone, and let you have the last word. I was happy to leave it there.
Then you decided to bring it up again. And you decided to completely misrepresent it as two users being "snippy".
If you read my comment -- it's not long, so you can do that -- I'm not complaining about the ban. I'm correcting a factual error you made. That shouldn't hurt you.
You were both being dicks.
Pot, kettle. You're constantly a dick to other users when they dare to disagree with you.
your loss of composure
More things that didn't happen.
a) A formal apology and an admission of wrongdoing. This will not happen; you are not owed an apology and no wrong was done to you.
Nice strawman. I take it that you want a formal apology and an admission of wrongdoing? This will not happen; you are not owed an apology and no wrong was done to you.
For the mods to reconsider how we moderate and make some sort of change
I am already aware that you're not going to do this; naraburns said so, and I used this thing called "reading" to receive that information.
To continuously gripe every time the subject comes up because you can't let it go
You are the one deciding to bring it up, dishonestly. I let you have the last word, but apparently that's not enough for you.
So I won't tell you to stop complaining. I will only tell you that it is unlikely to benefit you, unless the complaining itself is the benefit.
I don't know what to tell you. If you're going to go around saying things that aren't true, and get offended by people correcting you, then... well, I won't say it's out of character, but you might find people won't take you as seriously as you want.
EDIT: And if, at any point, you want to actually cite where I was a "dick" -- you know, using evidence of my actual words -- then that might be a lot more effective than just throwing a tantrum in my direction. You've said it's too much effort to go through the discussion, but it's apparently not too much effort to write a long strawman comment when I correct your error. So maybe you could try connecting your feedback to actual concrete offences rather than this vague unfalsifiable vibes-based modding.
For context, when Amadan says he banned two users for "being snippy", he means a user literally yelled "FUCK YOU" at me, and I was mildly condescending in return.
(If Amadan is referencing some other ban, I'll retract this)
You don't like the way we moderate based in part on reputation
No, this isn't what I said. I absolutely think reputation should be a factor. I'm suggesting that in this case, it's being used excessively.
Ad hominem literally translates "to the man." ... [it is] a suggestion that you should spend less time casting aspersions on your interlocutor and more time addressing the substance of your discussion.
That's my point! My comments were full of addressing the substance of the discussion.
I'm fairly sure you don't actually know that I had an excessive focus on georgioz and his characteristics. I suspect you're assuming it from a light skim of the conversation, without really reading what I was saying in detail.
Which is reasonable! I know that reading through the comments in detail is a massive chore for mods. I don't expect you to do it. But now you're telling me that I was fixated on georgioz, and spending lots of time throwing insults and aspersions at him, and that's not true.
Well, it's an unforced error to insist on things that "I know"
Fair enough; I retract that. I felt it was reasonable that you would've understood that my complaint was the relative length of the bans -- otherwise I don't see why you'd bring up their supposed incommensurability -- but if you're telling me that wasn't clear, I accept that.
Your complaint has been noted. In hopes of managing your expectations: so far, the moderation team does not agree with your position on the matter, and has no plans to adjust our moderation approach in response to your complaints at this time.
Sure. At the risk of making another unforced error: I strongly doubt you're saying this to manage my expectations. I think you're doing a little snarky put-down.
And that's fine! It's even kind of funny; from your perspective, I am being a pain. But we could maybe be a little more consistent on whether being condescending is against the rules or not.
You just assert: "Laws of physics exist"
No, I didn't.
On its own this is an outrageous statement on par of saying that "God exists".
Good thing I didn't make that statement, then.
how do they exist
As I keep saying, you need to explain what this question means.
You said that you are empiricist
No, I didn't. You inferred that.
You know, that no amount of evidence can prove a thing
Sure, in the sense that literal 100% proof of anything is impossible.
Okay so I can say that God and unicorns work for me and thus they exist
Ok, then show me the unicorn.
reactivity is exactly what you've been moderated for in the past
I was previously modded for reacting with excessive heat.
When georgioz says "FUCK YOU", and I overlook it with nothing more than an "excuse me", I'm clearly not doing the same kind of reactivity as you've previously called out. I'm demonstrating a pretty significant level of restraint and non-reactivity.
(Also, "ad hominem"? I was condescending, but I didn't substitute insult for argument.)
you are drawing a false equivalence ... They are incommensurable
No, I'm not. I am criticising the kind of moderation policy that leads to this outcome. People are absolutely going to compare bans, and it's unreasonable to just declare that it's some kind of fallacy to do so.
Basically, you seem to be saying ... or maybe instead you're saying ...
No, you know exactly what I'm saying: these bans are absurd and unjust, relative to each other. Declaring the two incommensurable doesn't retroactively change what I'm saying.
Reputation should only go so far. If someone can scream "FUCK YOU" at me, and tell me I'm simple and stupid and illiterate, it's a crappy moderation policy that gives me the same punishment for not being an unlimited punching bag.
I had constant whiplash where you demanded plain English but at the same time claimed to have knowledge of Gödel and his proofs sufficient to understand it.
There's no contradiction there. I was asking for plain English because I think you are tripping yourself up using complicated phrases.
I'll do an analogy. Imagine you ask someone why the sky is blue, and they say: "Quantum decoherence causes the eigenfunction to scatter the ket vector of that wavelength". All of those are real words, and have real technical meanings. But the person saying that sentence is confused, and they're not giving a true or even meaningful explanation.
So a good approach is to ask that person: "Can you please explain what you mean in simple English?" If they have a coherent idea in mind, then they can go: "Sure! Basically, we can think of each atom as a cloud, and when a wave of light passes through that cloud, it interacts with ..." and so on.
I have sufficient knowledge of Godel and his proofs. I just think you're invoking him wrongly, and in order to argue that point, I'm trying to pin down exactly what you mean.
Please just explain your position again
- Your criticism of "atheistic materialism" was more a criticism of materialism; the atheism part wasn't really necessary
- If materialists don't have the "right" to comment on matter and the universe, then non-materialists certainly don't have any more "right" to declare the existence of an omnipotent, omnipresent, arbitrarily complex entity.
- Your description of Godel's ontological proof does not coherently mean anything; it's just a string of complicated words.
What is the nature of reality, visible (e.g. matter, energy, planets, galaxies) and invisible (math, logic, abstract concepts). How do they exist?
As I said before, I don't know what you mean by "how" a thing exists. What kind of answer does that question even invite? What do you mean?
Why do they exist?
You're presupposing that these things do exist, or that it's simple to declare that they do exist, which I think requires a bit more of a rigorous definition of "exist".
Let me split your entities into two categories: Type A (physical arrangements of matter/energy -- galaxies, planets, houses, apples, trees, etc), and Type B (everything else).
It's easy to answer why Type A things exist: because of the laws of physics acting on the prior state of the universe. A planet exists because a bunch of cosmic dust existed before it, and then gravity compacted it.
Why do Type B things exist? e.g. the universe, numbers, justice?
That's a confusing question, because the word exist was invented to describe Type A things. The meaning of "exist" concerning Type A things is clear: if you ask "does an apple exist?", you're asking whether a certain physical arrangement is present in the same universe as you. So there's a clear implicit meaning of "exist" concerning Type A things.
But when you start saying "numbers exist" or "the universe exists", it's not clear what that means. So before I can answer why these things exist, I need an explanation of what you mean by something like "numbers exist" or "the universe exists". (This is a similar issue to when you say "modal collapse": I think you're unintentionally smuggling a very complicated idea into the simple word "exists", and it needs to be broken down into simpler words.)
What is knowledge
The possession of an accurate model of a portion of reality.
what is "Truth"
The nounified version of the adjective "true". A claim is true if it accurately represents reality.
how can we justify something as true vs not-true
If a claim accurately models reality, then it is true to the extent that it does so. That's what "true" means.
We can be mistaken about calling a thing true, in the same way that we can be mistaken about literally anything.
My name is stoatherd and I know it to 2+2=4 to all there exists is just matter and energy. These are all dogmatic claims
They aren't. I verify my username by repeated observation and evidence. This is the same process I use to verify 2+2=4.
I haven't claimed "all there exists is just matter and energy". I'm entirely open to the idea of there existing additional things. But either they interact with the physical world, in which case they are physical; or they don't, in which case this is a very exotic use of the word "exist" that needs defining.
Now the ball is in your court, how do you justify your beliefs and how and why are they better?
Observation and testing. They are better because they work. I'm fine with that not being considered "justification"; I'll just enjoy my beliefs working.
Why and how do you posses the knowledge of the Truth and everything else?
I... don't?
I have some knowledge. Some of my knowledge is presumably wrong; I don't know which parts. I don't have complete knowledge of everything. These sentences are true of everyone.
Also I do not like ad hominess and other rhetorical tactics, but I will meet you where you are at.
I am not doing this, and I'd prefer if you didn't do it either.
It is considered a standard argument to say that "HAHAHA, stupid Christians believe in unproven and unjustified fairy-tales". Only to then act all indignant when in turn somebody asks them about their fairy tale cosmology and empiricist dogmas that one should take on face value. If you show basic philosophical respect, then I will show the same back.
Dude, I haven't done this. If you think I've done this, please point to where.
It seems other people haven't shown what you consider "basic philosophical respect", and you're using that as an excuse to be disrespectful to me. I don't think that's great.
No mod want to go through a thread and measure how many insult-units each poster scored
Yeah, and I recognise that it's a chore. I understand looking at the general tenor of the conversation and dropping bans based on that, rather than litigating stuff line by line.
But I object to telling me I'm "behaving terribly" without reading the thread. And given how egregiously rude "FUCK YOU" is, it's pretty galling for you to just declare we're behaving equally, when we're not.
What do you want, for me to reban him for longer so you feel justice has been done?
No.
georgioz has just reignited the argument, using the exact same kind of condescension and ad hominem that you just banned me for.
I'm fine with you either banning him or not banning him for that comment. But I suspect that if I reply to him, I'm going to be held again to a much higher standard, and get slapped with a ban unless I just let his insults slide. (Despite the fact that the "respective histories" argument should suggest that the guy who said "FUCK YOU" should probably be held to a higher standard if he immediately starts condescending again.)
I appreciate you taking the time to respond. And I basically agree with the stance as you've described it.
I just object to stuff like this:
But you seem to take other people's bad behavior as an excuse to respond in kind, but it's not.
You previously correctly called me out for this, and I modified my behaviour to not do this. When georgioz said "FUCK YOU", I didn't respond in kind.
I took your previous advice, as incredibly frustrating as that was. But you're still treating my behaviour as if I'm just going maximum heat in response to bait, which I'm not.
I agree with the reputation system, but it's absurd that it stretches to treating "FUCK YOU" + "you are stupid and simple and can't read" (not a quote) as equivalent to some calm, reactive condescension.
@Amadan, I'd appreciate some mod feedback on whether there's an appropriate way to reply to this, if you have time.
So far, georgioz has yelled "FUCK YOU" at me, called me simple and stupid multiple times, created strawmen of my position (including misattributing quotes from other users to me), and repeatedly evaded requests to just explain his position by insinuating that I can't read.
You gave him a one-day ban for the "FUCK YOU".
You then also gave me a one-day ban for responding to him with condescension and snark. (Subjectively, less condescension than he was throwing at me.) Which... fair enough, I guess, in isolation. I could've been a bit less patronising. (Though the most patronising thing I said, "ok buddy", is a phrase you yourself have also used in this thread.) There are also a few places where I'm being blunt and direct (e.g. calling a phrase "nonsense") for the sake of trying to clarify the conversation, but that could be read as part of a pattern of condescension, even when that's not the intent.
But a one-day ban for "FUCK YOU" + you're simple/stupid + condescension, and a one-day ban for being condescending in return, doesn't seem proportionate. After @naraburns banned me a month ago for responding to bait with too much heat, I've tried to learn that lesson (which required me to get over a lot of frustration at that ban). This time, I didn't escalate even after being told "FUCK YOU" -- I just said "excuse me?" -- but I still get the same ban?
I'm pretty sure that If I said "FUCK YOU" to Amadan out of nowhere, I'd get much more than a one-day ban.
Now georgioz is continuing the conversation. I think there are actually useful things to discuss here, which is why I kept trying to get him to explain his position. But I'm getting the same attacks:
At least I know how to read wiki page
Is this a novel linguistic lesson from Eastern European for you?
Thank you for your ad hominem
Yes, for somebody discussing in bad faith
Wow, we are getting into quite supernatural territory here
just argue with wiki page that is written in plain English and then give me further questions
I don't think we are symmetrically "behaving terribly". I'm asking georgioz to explain his positions in his own words, which is kind of the entire point of this place. In return, he keeps pointing me to wikipedia and telling me I can't read.
This isn't symmetric.
So, is there actually a way I can respond to this, that doesn't require me to be a punching bag? There are actually interesting discussions we can have around this. I want to have them. I'm trying to elicit that discussion (though yes, in a way that was too snarky). But it seems that I have to just accept being told "FUCK YOU", and being told I'm simple and stupid, and that I can't read; and that if I condescend at all in return, we're both "behaving terribly".
I'm frustrated because I did actually put effort into trying to make the conversation go somewhere useful. Yes, I could've (and should've) been less condescending. But if I'm going to be told I'm behaving terribly, regardless of how much effort or heat or aggression each person is putting in, it all just feels a bit pointless.
Just read what I said. I critiqued access to unjustified universal categories.
What you said was that I made a bunch of claims that I did not, in fact, make. I don't know why you're incapable of admitting you're wrong or apologising for making up things about another user.
So please do not leave me in a suspense and tell me what do you mean by "works" and "useful".
The ordinary everyday meaning. This isn't complicated. By "works", I mean: "If you use 2+2=4 when measuring out ingredients for a dish, you'll get the right proportions. If you use 2+2=4 when designing a plane, you'll get a plane that flies. If you use 2+2=4 when figuring out how much change to give a customer, you'll give them the correct amount of change".
This is obviously entirely different to the way you used "works" in your facetious unicorn analogy, where you mean something like "telling this story accomplishes my goals".
Now please define exactly what you mean by "so", "please", "do", "not", "leave", and so on, for every other commonplace word you used.
Do you know how to read?
Yes. Your English is poor. I assume your native language is something Eastern European (judging by how often you omit articles). While I recognise it's a feat to discuss complicated things in your second language, you could maybe have a bit more humility concerning whether the communication issue might be on your end.
It is unusual to describe "the abstract concept of numbers" as concrete, given that "abstract" and "concrete" are pretty close to antonyms.
the abstract entity of "2" is not identical to two clouds or two bananas
Agreed, of course.
But I am willing to go there if you wish as this is exactly touching the metaphysics: what are numbers
Already covered this. Mathematics consists of models, which you can think of as games or systems consisting of rules. Numbers are elements within particular mathematical models. Numbers are things like 5, 2.45, and 1,000.
how are they existing
I have no idea what this kind of question means, for any subject. "How is an apple existing" -- what does this mean?
where are they existing
You seem confused. Numbers are abstract concepts. They aren't like apples or horses; they're not in a location. That's like asking "where is justice existing?"
I do not have to explain words to you
I never said you did, nor would I think you capable.
But you said you were giving me a simple-word explanation of your analogy, and used the phrase "modal collapse". You're under no obligation to give me a simple-word explanation, but if you pretend to be giving me one while using nonsense phrases, I'm going to point it out.
Google it with conjuction with "modal collapse" in "plain English". I do not know what you want at this point - should I define the word definition in plain English?
You know exactly what I want, as I've said it explicitly twice now. You literally just offered what I want: a plain English explanation of your analogy, without using any bullshit phrases like "modal collapse". You don't need to define individual words or phrases, just say your analogy using normal words.
What are you talking about. There is literal wiki article about Godels ontological proof. Modal collaps is literally a subcategory with its own wiki page.
There's a literal wiki article on Transubstantiation. That doesn't mean that Transubstantiation isn't meaningless bullshit; the existence of a wikipedia page doesn't save it.
If you think your point is meaningful, you can explain it in simple words. You keep refusing to do this and pretending not to understand.
If you are too simple or lazy to grasp it,
Ok, buddy. Maybe learn to spell, as a bare minimum, before accusing other people of being stupid.
It does not matter in this case.
Actually it does matter that you're ascribing quotes to me that I never said, and positions that I don't hold.
And? Telling stories about unicorns to my daughter also works consistently
Not in the way that 2+2=4 "works". You're extremely confused if you think you can just conflate two entirely different meanings of the word "work".
why is "consistently works" any form of justification? What does it even mean and how did you came up with it?
Then first you need to justify why "justification" matters. What do you even mean by it?
Excellent. We discovered a difference of counting by identity vs division. However the realm of numbers is realm of counting by identity, so this analogy does not wok.
No, sorry, that's nonsense. You failed to understand. This has nothing to do with identity or division.
Mathematics consists of models. One such model is "here are the natural numbers, and we can use addition on them". This is good for counting things like pebbles, so we use it for that. This is bad for counting things like clouds, so we don't use it for that.
Nowhere has identity or division entered into it.
2+2=4 is either true or false, there is nothing like "kind of"
It is true, within the rules of the model. And we also use it as a shorthand for another true statement: "If you have two things, and another two things, and you group them together -- without breaking anything or fusing anything together -- you end up with four things".
We are talking about a concrete thing - abstract concept of standard numbers and not clouds
... in what world are numbers concrete and clouds not??
And here we are. A universal metaphysical game. Either you believe 2+2=4 or you are out.
You really need to use simple language. You're tangling yourself up. What do these statements even mean?
You reject the concept of justification of anything outside of 2+2=4, because presumably it goes against your presupposition
No, I don't. Stop making stuff up.
There are paradigms with no justification for 2+2=4, they have no grounding and even worse, they positively reject the only entity - GOD - that could provide such grounding. (...) Now you may have some inkling of my presuppositional argument.
Still meaningless. I have no idea what you're talking about, and neither do you. If I'm wrong, try and communicate it using plain English. No "meta", no "paradigmatic", no "metaphysical".
You yourself said that You can assume that I'm familiar with Godel's ontological proof
I did. I also explicitly said that phrases like "modal collapse" were meaningless and making you confused. You then decided to use "modal collapse" in your simple words explanation. If you actually understand what you're talking about, you can explain it without saying "modal collapse".
Do you want to explain the analogy or not?
I'd love an explanation. A genuine explanation that doesn't hide behind using complicated words to disguise the fact that there's no actual substance there.
Look, here's how you sound to me. Suppose I said something like this: "Here's an analogy: the atavistic ontological modalities of pseudo-presuppositionalist frameworks lack consanguinity with the indirect supplication of their co-philosophies."
And then you ask me to explain what that means, and I sneer and say "oh, I suppose if you're not smart enough to understand part of my analogy".
It is not crucial for my point. If you do not grasp it, that is still okay.
That's ok. Neither of us grasps it.
You used this argument:
No, I didn't. Go back and check the username you grabbed the quote from.
If you're going to be an asshole and call my arguments "stupid", maybe make sure you're replying to the right user.
So, I'm going to skip over defending an argument I never actually made.
You boldly claim that you are beyond presuppositions
Stop making stuff up.
How do you know that 2+2=4 as opposed to 5 and again in a justified manner that excludes "all" other possibilities?
I never claimed I did. Stop making stuff up.
2+2=4 is a useful, coherent model for counting discrete entities. I "know" it is true insofar as it consistently works.
2+2=4 is not universally physically true. If I add 2 clouds to 2 clouds, I don't (necessarily) get 4 clouds, because clouds are not a discrete entity that's appropriate for modelling via addition.
But within mathematics, within the rules of the game of addition, 2+2=4. If you think that's not "justified", then i reject your concept of justification as being useful.
It is basic question of presupposed epistemology and metaphysics
You're still making statements like this that don't mean anything.
Okay, analogy in simple words. Gödel's god (...) for modal collapse
This is a parody, right? I literally flagged up "modal collapse" as the primary example of nonsense phrases you're using. You're not using simple words in this explanation. I don't think you can use simple words, because you're not actually conveying any kind of coherent concept; you're just stringing together big words in a way that feels like an explanation to you.
And no, Godel's god doesn't "solve the problem of unprovable truths"; that's nonsense, and shows you don't understand Godel.
You say "Presuppositions wrong. It presupposes stuff"
No, I didn't. Please stop lying.
If you're going to be childish and rude, try actually reading the comment you're replying to.
You are deeply confused about many things. I strongly recommend you use simpler words, because you're tangling yourself up by slinging around complicated words in ways that don't actually coherently refer to anything. (Apologies for being blunt; I don't mean this as an insult.)
Again, this goes meta-level higher. It allows for God to exist.
You've already lost me. There is nothing about this that is a meta-level higher.
Beliefs do not exist in isolation, they have implications. And there are some fundamental and mutually incopmatible beliefs that lead to completely different paths
Yes, of course.
Are you a monist like idealist or materialist (...) These are fundamental paradigmatic pressupositions that you need to be aware of.
Yes, I'm aware of these things you're calling "paradigmatic pressupositions [sic]", but that could more accurately be called "beliefs".
Nothing in this paragraph actually addresses my point about your criticism of materialism.
what gives you a "right" to say that 2+2=4 as opposed to 2+2=24546534? (...) It is a paradigmatic level, a meta level argument
... no, it isn't. You need to stop saying "paradigmatic" and "meta" if you want to actually communicate anything. 2+2=4 isn't based on anything meta. And this entire avenue of who has the "right" to make philosophical claims isn't useful.
You cannot say just say that there is no reality except of subjective experience. FUCK YOU.
Excuse me?
That is a universal statement that CANNOT be proven by subjective ground-up justification
If you're going to claim a thing CANNOT be done, the burden is on you to supply a watertight proof. Just because you can't see a way to do it doesn't mean there's no way to do it. Though again, you're tangling yourself up with words like "universal" and "justification".
It is called an analogy. What exactly did you not understand from this?
I am aware of what analogies are, thanks. Your "analogy" is meaningless nonsense. "god in Gödel's ontological proof serves as an anchor that provides for a modal collapse that smooths away existence of unprovable truths" -- this doesn't mean anything.
If you think I'm wrong, you should be able to explain what you mean in simple words. I don't mean "dumb it down" -- you can assume that I'm familiar with Godel's ontological proof, mathematically capable, etc. I mean explain this in plain English, without hiding behind phrases like "modal collapse" that don't actually mean anything.
The point being, that none of these paradigms have any "right" to use any universal claim. E.g. if an atheistic materialist claims that nothing else exists except of matter - what is his grounding for this claim?
... but that has no bearing on whether a god exists.
If you want to use this as a criticism of materialism, dropping the "atheist" part, then you still have a massive problem:
There is exists an omnipresent and all-powerful being and all universals are anchored in this divine mind. By allowing for such an entity to exist, one does have justified grounds to use these universals.
What gives you the "right" to declare such a being exists? How you could you, a being who is not omnipresent or all-powerful, possibly verify its existence? You're stacking the deck by allowing one side to assume the existence of an arbitrarily complex entity that will fit into whatever shape hole they need; that's a far bigger issue than materialists trying to comment on matter.
I used an analogy before in form of how god in Gödel's ontological proof serves as an anchor that provides for a modal collapse that smooths away existence of unprovable truths
This is gibberish.
Why do you say that about the Tories? Genuinely interested -- though I'm also in the UK, I don't really have a feel for who's good at politics.
Off the top of my head, they did stay in power for a decade, which is definitely a feat. But they're also extremely unpopular (alongside Labour) right now, to the extent that Reform/Greens/other smaller parties are now a real threat to the Conservative/Labour paradigm. That kind of outcome doesn't seem like a party that's "good at politics", but maybe you have something more specific in mind.
I have no strong opinions here, I'd just be curious to hear your take.
There is no level of feminist takeover of the publishing industry where they'll stop complaining.
Literary agents and publishing houses can publicly brag about rejecting male authors for being male, and still you'll get this kind of bullshit.
It's just noise. There's no intellectual content here.
it seems close enough to defending his decision
Then I can only assume you're deliberately misreading what I've said. Let me try and be even more explicit, if that's possible.
If Ramyswamy has drunk poison, we should be able to describe that using true claims. Accusing him of holding the stance "The 12 year old must have had it coming" is not a true claim.
It matters what a person actually did. Even if Ramyswamy were the worst person in the world, you don't get to just make stuff up ("he killed a guy!").
If pointing out falsehoods counts as "defending" Ramyswamy's decision, then your concept of defence is meaningless.
Why would that matter?
If you're modelling this as "you're either with Ramyswamy, or against him", then I imagine it would.
I'm running out of ways to explain that I'm challenging this particular claim from mkc, rather than defending Ramyswamy as a person. Do you have any suggestions for how I could make that clearer?
Yes, exactly this. "The 12 year old must have had it coming" isn't something you call someone; that doesn't even make grammatical sense.
It's a deliberate attempt to avoid having to stand by an indefensible claim, without any loss of face from having to retract it. "Look over there!"
I did back it up, right here
That has literally nothing to do with the quote I'm asking you to back up.
In case you've forgotten, here's the quote again:
Support a child predator on accident? The 12 year old must have had it coming.
As you know, nothing you've said actually addresses that. You're free to keep throwing smoke bombs and pretending that your comments about other things have anything to do with the quote I'm asking you about.
If you follow the comment chain, I'm specifically objecting to where magicalkittycat says
Support a child predator on accident? The 12 year old must have had it coming.
In the comment you're replying to, mkc is trying to obfuscate this specific point, and pretend that we're arguing over the broad features of the case, which we're not.
I largely agree with your comment, it's just not what I'm trying to get mkc to back up.
Then back up your actual comment, instead of trying to distract everyone with generic outrage about things we agree are disgusting.
If you've forgotten, here's what you said:
Support a child predator on accident? The 12 year old must have had it coming.
And where exactly does he say the 12-year-old had it coming?
You can keep changing the subject to avoid backing up your claim, if you like.
... and where, exactly, does he say "The 12 year old must have had it coming", or words to that effect?
- Prev
- Next

Thanks for putting in the effort. To be clear, I wasn't contesting that I was being "snippy" -- of course I was! I just disagree with Amadan's assessment that I "behaved terribly" and was a "dick", which are stronger charges than just being snippy. For example:
Probably fair to call this "snippy". But "dickish" or "terrible"? I think this is a reasonable thing to say to someone who keeps putting quotes in your mouth, and who refuses to back down when you point out they're not your quotes.
(I'd also disagree with a few of these -- e.g. I don't think "this is gibberish" was snippy; it was a blunt non-hostile attempt to cut through some word salad. Notice that I said that at the start of the conversation, when I had no reason to be pissed off or hostile. But yes, you're right that several (most?) of these are snippy.)
Sincerely, I'll take your feedback on whether I was "kind of dickish": I think that's a little harsh, but I value your opinion, so I'll have a think about it. Thanks.
Regarding the ESL thing: I did explicitly go out of my way to acknowledge (and even compliment!) him for having a complicated conversation in a 2nd language. It's just incredibly frustrating to repeatedly ask someone to explain what they mean, and to basically get back "lol u are retarded, u can't read" each time, when they are objectively failing to use the language coherently.
More options
Context Copy link