site banner

Transnational Thursday for November 19, 2026

Transnational Thursday is a thread for people to discuss international news, foreign policy or international relations history. Feel free as well to drop in with coverage of countries you’re interested in, talk about ongoing dynamics like the wars in Israel or Ukraine, or even just whatever you’re reading.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

In The Gambia v. Myanmar, the ICJ (International Court of Justice) has ruled that the government of Myanmar "has committed genocide against the Rohingya group in northern Rakhine State". Specifically, it found that Myanmar has violated article II items a (killing), b (causing serious bodily or mental harm), and d (imposing measures intended to prevent births) of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. (Sufficient evidence for a violation of item c (inflicting conditions of life calculated to bring about physical destruction) was not found. Item e (forcibly transferring children) was not at issue.) You can read the 6-page press release, the 34-page summary, or the 191-page full opinion. Concurring and dissenting opinions, and summaries thereof, also are available.

The vote on this charge was nine to six, as follows. (There were several other charges.)

CountryJudgeVote
JapanIwasawaYes
AustraliaCharlesworthYes
BrazilBrantYes
MexicoGómez RobledoYes
United StatesClevelandYes
RomaniaAurescuYes
South AfricaTladiYes
JordanHmoudYes
The GambiaPillayYes
UgandaSebutindeNo
SlovakiaTomkaNo
FranceAbrahamNo
ChinaXueNo
GermanyNolteNo
MyanmarKressNo

¶¶ 318–319:

Turning to the circumstances of this case, the facts as previously determined by the Court establish that Myanmar’s security forces committed large-scale killings of members of the protected group during the course of the 2017 clearance operations. The Court concludes that the killings included, inter alia, the direct targeting of civilians, including women and very young children, and killings with knives and burning of people in houses. They also included killing by widespread indiscriminate shooting. Such killings are intentional within the meaning of Article II (a). Myanmar also concedes that its troops were involved in the killing of the ten captive Rohingya men at Inn Din, in violation of its rules of engagement.

The Court has already determined that the estimate of 10,000 Rohingya violently killed during the 2017 clearance operations is supported by the evidence. The Court is fully convinced that Myanmar’s security forces intentionally killed members of the protected group on a large scale in the course of the clearance operations, and that the actus reus set forth in Article II (a) of the Convention is established. The Court is not called upon, for the purpose of establishing the actus reus of killing, to list the specific killings or to make a conclusive finding on the total number of victims.

¶¶ 335–337:

With respect to the number of persons who suffered serious mental harm, the Court observes that the killing of approximately 10,000 Rohingya inflicted acute suffering on numerous surviving family members, including pain from loss and separation, from witnessing deaths and from uncertainty regarding the fate of family members whose whereabouts remain unknown. At least 1,834 acts of rape caused severe suffering for the victims, as well as suffering for their family members and persons who witnessed the acts. Approximately 326,000 Rohingya had their homes burned, leaving them with no place to return to, and many personally experienced the burning of their homes and villages. Finally, while not all of the approximately 700,000 Rohingya who were forced to flee experienced extreme hardship during the journey to Bangladesh, the evidence establishes that many of them did, and those who fled have not been allowed to return.

The Court does not consider that each of the above types of acts alone caused serious mental harm to every member of the Rohingya group who experienced them. Grave and long-term disadvantage to the ability to lead a normal and constructive life within the meaning of Article II (b) is determined pursuant to a holistic assessment of the evidence. Nevertheless, some of the acts inflicted on individual Rohingya were extreme enough to cause serious mental harm in and of themselves; for other members, serious mental harm resulted from a combination of acts. The Court therefore concludes that the 2017 clearance operations caused serious mental harm to a very significant number of members of the Rohingya group in northern Rakhine State.

The Court recalls that for the purpose of establishing the actus reus under Article II (b), it need not set out the precise extent of the injuries suffered or make a conclusive finding on the total number of victims. The Court is fully convinced that the 2017 clearance operations caused serious bodily and mental harm to a very significant number of members of the protected group and that the actus reus set forth in Article II (b) is established.

¶¶ 353–356:

In the present case, the evidence indicates that, for many years, numerous restrictions on the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine State, including with respect to access to citizenship and freedom of movement, prevented the Rohingya from being able to secure adequate food and medical care and to pursue livelihoods. Restrictions on movement increased following the 2012 sectarian violence and tightened further at the time of the 2016 and 2017 clearance operations, including with respect to access to humanitarian aid. The over 100,000 Rohingya who remained confined in IDP camps following the 2012 violence also were subject to severe limitations on their freedom of movement, overcrowded shelters and inadequate services. As a result of these and other measures, the Rohingya population of northern Rakhine State, and particularly its children, faced serious malnutrition in 2017.

Such measures, together with the events of the 2017 clearance operations, compounded the acute hardship and vulnerability of the protected group. The Court has recognized that many of the acts committed during the clearance operations were intentional and inflicted serious bodily or mental harm within the meaning of Article II (b), and therefore establish the actus reus of genocide.

The requirement of Article II (c), however, is not that the conditions of life must be capable of causing the death of one or more members of the group over time, but that they be capable of causing the death of at least a substantial part of the group over time. The Court is not convinced that the evidence sufficiently establishes that the restrictions on movement and deprivation of access to food and medical care described by the Applicant were objectively capable of bringing about the ultimate death of a substantial part of the members of the protected group in this manner. The Court further considers that the circumstances of the 2017 clearance operations themselves, which involved extreme violence over a concentrated period of time, did not impose conditions of life of the character contemplated by Article II (c).

The Court accordingly concludes that the evidence before it does not conclusively establish the commission of the actus reus under Article II (c) of the Convention.

¶¶ 370–372:

The Court finds that, taken together, the restrictions on marriages and births on Rohingya in Maungdaw Township, where nearly 500,000 Rohingya resided, the denial of legal registration for Rohingya children and the commission of at least 1,834 acts of rape targeting the Rohingya population during the 2017 clearance operations, when viewed in the context of the Government’s messages regarding uncontrolled Rohingya population growth, establish an intent to impact the capacity of members of the Rohingya community to reproduce normally and thus an intent to prevent births within the group.

The Court is therefore fully convinced that Myanmar imposed measures intended to prevent births within the group and that the actus reus of genocide within the meaning of Article II (d) of the Convention is established.


In sum, the Court considers that the evidence conclusively establishes that the Myanmar security forces and other State organs committed acts falling within the actus reus set forth in Article II (a), (b) and (d) of the Genocide Convention. The evidence does not, however, conclusively establish the commission of the actus reus set forth in Article II (c).

¶¶ 466–467 (mens rea):

The Court considers that, in the present case, the scale and nature of Myanmar’s actions and the methods it employed went well beyond what would be required to punish the population and are instead characteristic of an intent to destroy a substantial part of the group. Features of such intent include the large numbers of persons killed, injured or displaced and the widespread brutal attacks on women and children. In light of the reasons set out above, the Court finds that punishment of the Rohingya population does not constitute an alternative reasonable inference on the evidence before it.

Accordingly, the Court cannot conclude, from all the evidence taken together, that an intent to carry out counter-insurgency operations, an intent to forcibly displace or an intent to punish the Rohingya population are reasonable inferences to be drawn. In the Court’s view, the only reasonable inference that can explain Myanmar’s actions is an intention to destroy a substantial part of the protected group, namely the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine State.

News articles: Associated Press, Reuters