@07mk's banner p

07mk


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

				

User ID: 868

07mk


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 868

I watched S1 a while ago, and I just couldn't understand the hype. The basic premise and mystery seemed interesting enough, but they didn't really explore enough to carry an entire show. The cast of characters could've carried it, but they just didn't, and I found myself just not caring about them, especially involving that romantic subplot with Christopher Walken's character. The strongest part was probably with that woman early on in the season exploring the premise as sort of the audience-surrogate rookie entering the job for the first time, but even that felt stronger on shock value than actually playing with the premise interestingly. In the end, I think I wished that S1 had been the first third of a season, setting up things for actual story that used the premise in a fun way.

By the way, you can totally do that with current technology: take a hearing aid, set it to receive ultrasound. You'd still need to use some of your actual senses for receiving the input, like taking those ultrasound waves and translating them down to normal hearing range. That will unfortunately interfere with you hearing the usual sounds, and if you don't want that, you can use some of your less-used senses. Like, have it be a vibrating butt-plug or something. I'm sure one can train the brain to distinguish different vibration pitches after a while.

There's definitely a good porno plot in there somewhere about a world-class chess player who climaxes when hearing dog whistles.

That's definitely true, which I forgot to mention in my previous comment. Parrying with a slender offensive weapon like a sword, in such a way as not to damage the blade, is cooler than parrying with a large defensive tool like a shield. Somewhat similar to how having a sword a shield is less cool than just having a shield for both defense and offense.

Small weapon, two small weapons, and one big weapon all tie for coolest to me. Any amount of shields automatically reduces coolness due to the implication that the warrior can't just dodge every attack. However, the small shield, two small shields and one big shield probably tie for 2nd, due to the implication that the warrior doesn't even need a proper offensive weapon to defeat his enemies.

I'd say you're quite generous. As a baseline, I'm 0% for 1-5, and 15% for 6 & 7. I'll push it up to 20% sometimes if I'm feeling generous for some reason.

My interpretation of this and most uses of "utility monster" in this context is that these are people that certain people - "liberals" in the above comment - demand we treat like a utility monster. I.e. there is no circumstance in which routing resources towards anyone other than them comes out ahead in a utilitarian calculation. Of course, those people basically never think of these things in terms of utilitarianism.

Utility isn't the name of the monster; it's the name of the scientist who created him.

What's confusing to me is why people are calling this "telepathy," not "telekinesis." From scifi/fantasy, generally the former refers to communication between minds without a physical medium, while the latter refers to causing physical objects to move purely through one's mind.

(I felt like getting cheeky and using ChatGPT to draft a reply, and I'd bet you wouldn't notice, but I didn't, because I'm a good boy)

I suspect that ChatGPT isn't "clever" enough to insert this kind of line when prompted to write a forum comment, but any time I see a line like this in a comment, that's what my mind goes to first.

When you think about how many events they provide security to (it's way more than the president/presidential candidates), thousands of events per year, it does put things into perspective.

Not really, no. This is the Secret Service, not Joe's Friendly Private Security and Handymen. They're supposed to be the best of the best, and, IIRC from the hearings, they have an explicit zero-failure standard that they hold themselves to. That's a high standard, and anyone who isn't prepared to meet it should not have been employed by it and certainly not have been leading it.

A determined lone actor is hard to detect until it is too late. It requires constant vigilance.

This would be relevant if this was an instance where the shooter used some clever difficult-to-detect method to circumvent protections. I wouldn't describe the assassination attempt as that.

I acknowledge that "my terminal value is that I'm ok with reading 100% AI-generated text as long as human hands physically copy and pasted it into the textbox on themotte.org" is a clever counterexample that I hadn't considered. I'm skeptical that any substantial number of people actually hold such a value set however.

I don't understand where you're getting the idea that it's a terminal value; could you explain the reasoning? In any case, the fact that the text that was posted was filtered through a human mind is information about the text that makes the contents of the forum substantively and meaningfully different from an LLM simulation of the forum. My point is that, for anyone who considers the human thought and human input to be valuable to have in a web forum like this, this theoretical containment thread provides that value. Is it enough value to make it worth having it? That's a separate question.

Indeed, and that's why the above comment was suggesting a method in which we could get something that gets AI content in a way that keeps that quality - i.e. individual real humans making decisions using their minds with respect to what they post online - but contained in a way that allows people who still don't like it to avoid it. You've just circled back to the original point.

Like, it's reasonable to say that such prompting, filtering, and curating don't meet the bar that you want humans to meet when posting on this forum. I actually lean in this direction, though I'm mostly ambivalent on this. But the idea that you can literally already do what was suggested by just using an LLM on your own is simply false.

But an LLM simulating those humans is qualitatively different from those actual humans sitting at their computers or their phones all around the actual Earth tapping their fingers on the keyboards or screens in front of them.

But that's qualitatively different from such a containment thread. The posts in such a containment thread would be determined by things like: what type of person would enjoy posting/reading in such a thread, what type of prompts would such people use, what LLMs such people would choose to use, and what text output such people would deem as meeting the threshold of being good enough to share in such a thread. You'd get none of that by simulating a forum via LLM by yourself.

Local police departments make routine errors pretty frequently on a variety of assignments and they made a big one here. That shouldn't be surprising to anyone.

If cross department communications has always been an issue and local police departments make routine errors pretty frequently - to such an extent that this error shouldn't be surprising to ANYONE - then we should expect SS - who isn't merely ANYONE, but professionals - to be aware of such issues and prevent/circumvent the problems that could arise from them, since such issues and errors can (and almost did) cause them to fail in their primary goals. Thus assuming that the local police would properly secure that roof wasn't just a bad decision in hindsight, it was a bad decision at the time.

Again, I think this points to simple gross incompetence in SS, starting from the very top. But when the incompetence is this bad, it's pretty reasonable to suspect foul play.

So from my watching some of the hearings with the SS head right after the assassination attempt, I absolutely believe that this could be explained by stupidity/ineptitude. But all your point does is move things back a step. Why did the SS believe that the roof of that building was secured by the local police, when it evidently wasn't? Part of the SS's responsibilities in collaborating with local law enforcement is to make sure that the local police are given responsibilities that they're capable of fulfilling. Evidently, the local police weren't capable of securing the roof of that building, and SS was ignorant of this. This seems like gross incompetence to me, but I can understand the perspective that this level of incompetence is so high as to make it reasonable to suspect actual malice.

The characters make no sense, the songs are tuneless, and the plot is no only stupid but is actually kind of sick -- unless you choose to read this movie as deeply critical of transsexuality as a concept.

Perez is unable to shake "his" past, becoming jealous of his supposedly widowed wife's romantic life and employing "his" old tactics to run the new fiancee out of town. This backfires in a way that also brings the trappings of "his" old world back into "her" new life. The message? One can't escape their nature, and the attempt to do so will ruin the lives of everyone around them.

I know nothing about the people who made this film, but the way you describe the story, it makes me wonder if there's a decent chance that this was the intended message. Having seen clips of the car accident scene at the end and some of the songs, it definitely goes into Poe's Law territory for me, where I honestly can't tell if it's meant to be satirical or serious. It'd be a hilarious turn of events if this ends up winning Best Picture on the power of pushing the correct political message, and 5 years later some old communications comes out that the director always intended the film to be a harsh criticism of the delusional beliefs underlying much of the modern progressive ideology around transsexualism. Of course, by then, generative AI might be good enough that the veracity of the evidence of any such past communications will be in doubt.

My question for those people is, what does it mean if you're wrong about the election? If you learned for a fact the election wasn't stolen, and you had been shouting otherwise, you'd be forced to consider how you contributed towards lowering societal trust by lowering its faith in our democratic process unnecessarily.

I personally can't answer this, because I've always believed that none of the POTUS elections in my lifetime were stolen, 2016, 2020, 2024, and heck, even 2000. But there's a big leap in logic here in your statement. Let's posit that I'm correct that the 2020 election wasn't stolen; this doesn't imply that there was no good reason to believe that it was stolen. Sadly, our world isn't a clean and easily legible one, and it is often the case that there are many good reasons to believe things that turn out to be false. As such, it can be entirely reasonable to believe that questioning the election was necessary, even if it resulted in lowering our faith in our democratic process. Given that, it also appears to me that the reaction to the questioning was the actual point of lowering faith in our democratic process.

So the question actually hinges on whether it was reasonable to believe at the time that any of these elections were stolen, rather than whether it was the actual case that they were stolen.

The notion that that someone's life matters less if nature wants them dead.

Explain to me how my statement implied this. Is the contention here that triage by its very nature, of prioritizing the saving of lives that are more likely to be saved, pushes the principle that someone's life matters less if nature wants them dead? Are you against the very concept of triage?

This, again, just makes me think you're trolling, and I'm wasting my time.

The argument "We don't have enough resources to save everyone" falls flat when made by someone who had the opportunity to get enough resources and chose not to.

It would. Is the example we're talking about one such case? There's plenty of discussion that could be had about that.

The specific group isn't relevant to my argument, because when that lack of compassion is applied, it has a tendency to spread. That was the point Niemöller was trying to make.

If that's the point, then it's either a vapid one or an awful one. Society has routinely applied lack of compassion to groups without having it spread. Today, we show a lack of compassion to convicted 1st degree murderers with respect to their desire to live outside of a prison (we show them greater than zero compassion, of course, but, also of course, literally zero compassion was never in discussion - again, rounding up those who have promiscuous dangerous sex or use intravenous drugs into death camps was never in discussion), and I disagree with the contention that this means that there's a danger that it would spread. Of course, with a loose enough definition of "spread," you can argue that it would and does, but with such a loose definition, that "spread" is utterly meaningless and not worth considering.

Actually, there are anti-retrovirals which will make someone carrying HIV not spread it.

That's a fantastic point you could make for why we should give aid to the people in discussion. That point has literally nothing to do with the argument you made in the above comment relying on the slippery slope argument.

However, even if that were not the case, saving a life is good.

So, again, is your contention that triage just shouldn't be a thing? Literally everyone agrees that saving a life is good. We lack enough resources to save every life all the time, and the discussion here is about prioritization.

I'll also note here that not a single comment I made implies, in any way, that I would be for leaving these people to die. Personally, though I see where hydroacetylene is coming from, I find the notion of just letting these people die to be ethically... questionable at best, monstrous at worst, given the resources I believe we have at hand. But I find your objection to it to be even more detestable than hydroacetylene's comment.

It's rather just letting nature take its course

A principle which, if carried to its ultimate conclusion, leads to 40-50% of babies dying before their fifth birthday.

Given those grim statistics, I hardly think that Nature is a good guide to right and wrong.

I don't understand why you just put in this complete non-sequitur, especially given that it's also a blatant strawman. What "principle" is being pushed in the quoted part above? It wasn't saying that there was anything particularly desirable about letting nature take its course; the reasoning for taking nature take its course has nothing to do with the naturalistic fallacy, which you seem to be implying was part of my statement. The reason to let nature take its course here is, again, triaging; we have scarce resources that we have to distribute to a limited number of people, and letting nature take its course is the default that's left over.

There is a difference between "We're at 200% capacity right now, and getting more resources will take longer than our patients have" versus "We will be over capacity some time in the future, we can get enough resources to save everyone by the time they will be needed, but we don't feel like doing so"; there is also a difference between "prioritising Alice over Bob because Alice has a 90% chance of survival while Bob has a 2% chance" versus "prioritising Alice over Bob because Bob is a member of a group we don't like".

This, too, is a complete strawman. The comments were pretty specific about the people in question, and describing them as "member of a group we don't like" is simply a lie. They were, to quote, "people [who] will continue to have promiscuous dangerous sex and to use intravenous drugs." The reasoning wasn't spelled out, but based on the previous comment, my inference was that it has to do with the fact that people who continue doing those things both tend to catch and spread diseases regardless of the medical care thrown at them, and so the resources of that care could be spent better elsewhere, ie triage. There's plenty of area for discussion on just what the percentages are and where the threshold should be, but characterizing that as anywhere in the same stratosphere as disliked groups isn't even the Worst Argument in the World, it's, again, just a lie.

I must admit, this reply of yours has me questioning if you're commenting in good faith, or if I'm just being trolled.

I think the key advantage existing metaphysical systems have is that they've proven themselves to be capable to be followed by a civilization that survives longer than one generation (or X generations, depending on whatever new metaphysical system you're talking about). Past performance isn't a guarantee of future performance, especially in what appears to be a particularly volatile time like right now, but lack of past performance is even less of a guarantee. And certainly, with the power of our intelligence, we could fast-forward through the trial-and-error of tradition and get to a superior system that's equally based off of animal intuition but more refined and "better" for some meaning of "better," but it's also true that hubris is one of the most powerful forces known to man, and the empirical proof of this system at the very least allowing civilization to survive, even if not thrive perhaps, is a huge advantage compared to any new system. Probably not insurmountable, but certainly a huge one, given how many ways there are for civilization to crumble relative to how few ways there are for it to continue forward.

You start dividing humanity into 'upstanding citizens worthy of life' and 'sub-humans whose life and well-being is not worth any efforts', sooner or later someone will put you into the second category.

Isn't this just triage? I don't think anyone has suggested rounding up people who have promiscuous dangerous sex or use intravenous drugs to send them to death camps. It's rather just letting nature take its course while devoting scarce lifesaving resources elsewhere, which I think is a pretty standard thing to do in medicine.

You had to add on a whole lot of details to the chess example, though. What about someone who has only ever played chess in private against bots and continues to do so indefinitely? Do such people exist? How would we know? I certainly know that I play some single player computer games like that, in ways that literally no other human being on Earth knows that I've played that game, which means that I leave behind no evidence that I played these games regardless of social validation. And my stating that I play games like that could serve as a proof-by-construction that I actually played those games out of a desire for social validation, as a way to have something like this in my back pocket to bring up as an example in a social interaction with someone else.

To me, your analysis seems isomorphic to those who claim that literally everything is political, on the basis that, no matter what topic they're given, they're able to use some chain of logic to connect it to some form of politics. If the bar to cross for being "political" is that someone can make a logical chain that connects it to politics, then the term "political" becomes vapid. Likewise, if all that takes for someone playing some game to be "about social validation" is that you can create some logical chain that explains how that person could be influenced by social validation in some indirect way connected to the game, then "being about social validation" becomes vapid.

But these bot-players have surely been acculturated to believe that winning a chess game is socially validating

If this is enough to make the experience of playing a private chess game against a bot as being "about social validation," then wouldn't the playing of any game with a win condition be "about social validation?" You could even stretch the argument to something like Tetris, which has no win condition, by positing that players have been acculturated to believe that accumulating more points or surviving for longer time than before is socially validating, and therefore any time someone plays Tetris in private is about social validation.

It's sort of like dying in a game of chicken and saying "yeah but committing to that head-on collision helped me win in other worldlines"

This whole line of thinking looks taken straight out of the trilogy of visual novel/escape room/choose-your-own-adventure games 999: 9 Hours, 9 Persons, 9 Doors, Virtue's Last Reward, and Zero Time Dilemma. Especially that last one, which has a sequence where you are tasked with rolling a 3 with a roll of 3 standard dice or else you are shot to death, and the game progresses with the explicit note that this is one of the 1-in-216 timelines where you did roll 3 ones. ZTD is also where I learned of the Sleeping Beauty Paradox, IIRC.

For people who enjoy bizarre time travel/alternate universe shenanigans and/or classic point-and-click adventure game puzzles and/or anime trope characters, I recommend them highly, though the middle game, Virtue's Last Reward, stands out to me as the only one that's truly great. VLR has the prisoner's dilemma as a core gameplay/narrative device.