@07mk's banner p

07mk


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

				

User ID: 868

07mk


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 06 15:35:57 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 868

Despite my own inclination to completely accept gay people qua gay people, I find nothing objectionable about Johnson's statements and see them as a much more accurate model of reality than what the CNN crew is expressing. I have zero doubt that sexual preferences and predilections can be substantially altered through a combination of conditioning, cognitive therapy, and repetition. I'm agnostic on whether this could allow someone who has a natural inclination towards homosexuality (or heterosexuality) to groom attraction for the sex that they didn't initially prefer, but it's not obvious to me, and I don't think there's good reason to say that it's deboonked as though this is just a common stylized fact.

I'm 99% certain that, in writing this paragraph, you thought about this issue at least one order of magnitude more than anyone you saw on CNN has in all their lives put together. For at least the past 2 decades, the dogmatic consensus has been that someone's sexuality is a part of their inner essence, that someone doesn't become gay or straight, they merely discover it. If you think about it empirically, it becomes immediately clear that we simply lack the mountains of scientific research in order to conclude this, much less have any confid in the conclusion, but why think about it empirically when thinking about it empirically can get you accused of homophobia?

More generally, there's a tendency of people to reject the effectiveness of what they consider morally abhorrent. You see this with other CW topics like death penalty (obviously it's barbaric AND it doesn't deter crime any better than the alternative) or torture (obviously it's excessively cruel AND it doesn't give us good info). The mirror image is the case too, such as affirmative action (obviously it's morally correct to give individuals belonging to oppressed categories extra opportunities, AND this will enable schools/companies to be better/smarter/richer by being able to make use of previously overlooked individuals from those categories).

I don't know if there's some psych term for this, but it's just incredibly common in all realms of politics, I think. Very often, they're even true. But also very often, people just jump to unwarranted conclusions by falling prey to this pattern.

My guess is that the concept of scissoring predated actual real scissors, so this particular ironic execution might have been beyond the ken of these people.

Thing is, I don’t know why this would be limited to elder care. Was there a particular reason—COVID restrictions, or some regulatory regime—pushing staff to other industries? Or does every service job in Dallas have a similar level of churn? Is this post going to start another fight about inflation and lived experience?

Anecdotally, many service jobs I encounter on a regular basis have gone downhill in the past few years post-Covid. I'm thinking particularly servers and cafe clerks, but also public transport drivers. It's not that their individual performance has gotten worse - AFAICT, that's remained the same - but they're constantly understaffed, leading to just inevitably terrible service due to the long wait times. This also causes extra stress on the staff, which sometimes results in less-than-ideal performance that would have been better but for the extra pressure put on them due to the reduced staff.

My pet theory is that the Covid lockdowns made a lot of people in the service industries realize that these jobs generally weren't worth the pay in comparison to other ways they could be spending their time, whether that be staying at home or pursuing some other venue to make money, resulting in a shortage relative to what the economy was used to before. Perhaps it's a bit of a market correction, where these workers, for whatever reason, were priced below their market price, and suddenly a lot of the workers realized this at once and, in an uncoordinated fashion, simultaneously decided to quit the industry.

Underdog analysis can also be complicated by questions of scope

To me, this is one of the key issues of the whole thing which makes it just a non-starter. The degrees of freedom there are in determining who is the underdog and who isn't is effectively infinite, because human capability of self-deception is effectively infinite. So if one takes on the framework of the "righteousness of the underdog," then step 1.00001 that follows immediately after this is to deem [whoever I like] as the underdog, while twisting logic in any way required to reach that conclusion. By the time we reach step 2, step 1.00001 is long forgotten, and any scrutiny about that step is shut down as picking on the underdog who has been Firmly and Uncontroversially Determined to be the Underdog in this situation. It's just naked bias and favoritism with a particularly flattering narrative that makes it easier for people to believe even when they like to think of themselves as disliking naked bias and favoritism.

This is why when I hear "punching up" and "punching down" in the context of comedy or satire or the like, I always translate "up" to "direction I want punches to be thrown" and "down" to "direction I don't want punches to be thrown;" in practice, that's what they mean and only what they mean.

This gives me some ideas for a final solution for the incel problem by combining BLM with MAID.

Can someone remind me what the “2S”

2S is for Two-Spirit. I don't know exactly what it is, but I think I heard it's some sort of double-gender thing that some indigenous people of somewhere, I think, have or had.

Except I don't think "that bird has a Western, Anglo name" is what is keeping black, Asian, Latino etc. people out of birdwatching.

Yeah, this sort of thinking has always been puzzling to me--nobody studies biology without learning Latin names, nobody studies math without learning Greek letters. "Black people won't go birdwatching because all the birds are named Smith" is an utterly baffling take.

I think you're thinking about it backwards. The people who make this kind of criticism tend to be very open about their belief that any disparity* within any group is automatically and inevitably evidence of oppression, and it's just a matter of finding out what that oppression is. They also tend to be very open about their belief in the ability of terminology to oppress. And so when their search encounters this sort of terminology, i.e. disproportionately Western and Anglo names among birds, they conclude that that's the oppression that's responsible for the disparity. They're not trying to reason empirically about what kind of effects having so many Western and Anglo names among birds would have on birdwatchers in general and concluding that it would cause POCs to stay away from birdwatching.

* of certain kinds.

Is it possible to modulate the resulting vision of the target by modulating the laser in some way? I would think that the exact level of vision is primarily determined by the shape of the lens, whereas whether or not you have vision is primarily determined by the status of your retina, and a blinding laser weapon would be good at damaging the retina and perhaps the lens, but not so good at precisely choosing what shape the lens will take on. They're not strapping these folks into chairs like a LASIK procedure, after all.

However, this is not what we see. In ALL societies men are more violent than women. Therefore, it must be hereditary. The chances of thousands of societies all ending up the same way by chance are essentially zero.

According to the standard narrative of the patriarchy, this is merely evidence that patriarchy is that entrenched and so ubiquitous in our society that very disparate societies with very different customs and ways in very different environments all were influenced such that boys were socialized to be more violent than girls. Clearly this means that the rot goes in even deeper than even our most extreme activists were stating, and is an indication that we must double down on pushing even harder with the progress that our side believes in.

This is a highly malleable narrative too, able to easily adapt to even genetics if needed. If it turns out that there's some undeniably genetic element that influences men to be more violent than women on average and at the extremes, then that is proof of how far back the patriarchy goes, that it was able to influence our evolution to such an extent that it has left its imprint in our genes. This is not a commonly stated belief, but it certainly is a standard part of the standard patriarchy narrative, which, in practice, provides the optionality to support the notion that every pattern of difference, even genetic ones, between men and women is socialized.

I think you're thinking about it backwards. In the mansplaining case, it's that "this specific human being standing in front of me did something I find annoying, and I lose one useful tool for attack if I acknowledge that person as non-binary instead of a man; therefore, he's a man." In the transwoman rape case, it's that "this theoretical transwoman (even if a specific person is referenced, the person remains theoretical because she's presumably not in direct contact with that transwoman) did something awful and distinctly male, but that doesn't affect me in any way; therefore, we should take her at her word that she's a woman in every single way that she wishes to be acknowledged." It's a sort of "luxury belief" situation. Believing that the person in front of her is non-binary has immediate and harsh consequences to her, and thus she can't afford to believe it, but believing that a transwoman who raped someone is a real woman in every way has no consequences for her in any way, and thus she can afford to believe it.

Drones with cameras go for about $500 these days.

How practical are these things for navigating tunnels? I imagine you'd need a pretty good operator not to crash into walls in such an unfamiliar and cramped setting, and who knows how many of those they have, along with the crews required to maintain the equipment and protect the operator so he doesn't get attacked (I imagine the ping, the unreliable infrastructure during battle, and the blocking nature of tunnels makes it so that drone operators need to be somewhat close to the drones). And logistically, even if they cost just $500 each, do they have sheer shipping ability to keep replenishing them as quickly as they get destroyed?

I decided to just embrace streaming and use YT music now. It's good enough for my needs, since I'm not the type of person to listen to music much, and the few times I feel like putting something on, just a YT recommended playlist does the job well enough. I've also actually come around to not hating discoverability - i.e. YT recommending music to me that I hadn't listened to before.

I guess the possibility of extramarital relations on the part of her mother is not addressed

I seem to recall that this was the defense of Shaun King (I think? Some BLM activist) who was accused of Dolezal-ing. This seems like the perfect response to any accusations like this. The people who want to believe have a possible - perhaps even plausible - narrative they can latch onto, giving you the support you might need for facing the accusations. And the people accusing you have almost no recourse to actually verify your claims. DNA tests aren't common, and the father might be long gone anyway, and DNA tests are fallible too.

It can be when you're accustomed to not paying, and you see plenty of others not paying. If free riding is an option, why not take it? In this case, it's partly the extra convenience and the little warm and fuzzy feeling I get from doing things above board, but, again, that seems just like rationalizations that I'm telling myself so I don't feel too much like a sucker.

This is what I've been doing for years, starting back when Google Music became a thing, because subscription to that also came with a subscription to YouTube Red (a terrible name for their premium service, given the existence of RedTube - though still preferable to calling it YouTube One like every single brand in existence has been doing the last decade). Once Google Music got shuttered I just kept the YouTube Red subscription at the same price.

Of course, this makes me the sucker who got baited into a service I didn't initially want and stuck with it just out of laziness and inertia. I rationalize it that $10/mo is worth it for the hours I must save not watching ads on YT, to say nothing of the disruption and annoyance, but that rationalization is going to be harder for others depending on their circumstances, I admit.

My guess is that the CEO and the board wanted to sell beer to LGBT people, while the marketers tasked with the project wanted to increase trans acceptance.

Exactly. Someone who believes the Earth was created in 7 days, 6000 years ago is substantially less dangerous (and, indeed, I would argue is substantially less delusional) than someone who believes whitey's oppression of minorities is the source of disparate racial outcomes.

As a former obnoxious internet atheist who, unlike many such former obnoxious internet atheists, doesn't particularly regret that phase of my life or think I was particularly wrong about it, I find myself agreeing with this. On the one hand, YEC is absurd and idiotic, and it truly boggles the mind that an intelligent adult with a modern education could even entertain the idea. And someone buying into the whole oppression narrative while being intelligent is understandable in a way someone buying into YEC isn't, because the former is the dominant hegemonic narrative that gets reinforced in almost every sphere of public life.

And this results in that giving political power to someone who believes in YEC certainly seems far less dangerous than someone who believes in that oppression narrative. YEC is almost fully marginalized now, basically only brought up to be the punchlines of jokes. The idea that someone's belief in YEC could have some truly meaningful and negative consequences for the policies they put in place seems rather absurd given that marginalization of YEC. On the other hand, again, that oppression narrative is the dominant one in our society - if not the dominant one, certainly one of the top contenders. It has the backing of many massive political, economic, social, and even religious institutions, ready to steamroll whatever stands in the way of the policy changes they want to implement. These policy changes tend to have direct, measurable, noticeable effects on people's everyday lives. Someone who buys into this narrative is clearly much more capable of doing harm with their power. Hence, more dangerous.

Of course, things can and will likely change. The pendulum and all that. I'm just reminded of an essay I read back in 2002 or 2003 when some neocon was outlining his opposition to Bush in some policy, saying that when you're driving on a narrow bridge and you see the steering wheel is turned all the way to the right, the correct thing to do isn't to put the steering wheel back to the center, it's to sharply turn it to the left.

At any rate, I have tried working out consistently for about 6 months when I was in college. Sure, I lost weight and became more toned, but I certainly didn't look very muscular. I am aware I probably did a pretty bad job of it, especially when it came to nutrition, but it's not like I've never hit the gym.

I'd guess that you did a pretty good job of it if you noticeably lost weight and became more toned after 6 months of consistent working out. Unless you're starting from a baseline of already being very fit and toned, becoming actually noticeably muscular by the standards of what counts as muscular for men with 6 months of consistent working out would require doing an outstanding job of it, not merely a good job.

I have no idea who the non-Harvey-related Weinstein brothers are

I think it's a reference to Bret and Eric Weinstein (pronounced "Wine-Stine," in contrast to Harvey's "Wine-steen"). Eric has been a public intellectual for a while, whereas Bret came into prominence as a biology professor at Evergreen college some ago, where he pushed back against the college's annual "Day of Absence" which requested that white people remain off-campus for the day. IIRC, part of Bret's argument mentioned how his Jewish heritage made him more sensitive to policies where people are asked to not be present purely on the basis of their ethnicity or race. This led to some viral videos of him being confronted by angry students, eventually leading to him and his wife (another biology professor at Evergreen) resigning. They went on a bunch of podcasts afterward, and I believe they started their own podcast, becoming public intellectuals like Eric.

I don't think it's possible to know that Hamas's self-promotions using videos directly showing their terrorism in action had a net positive or negative effect for their support in the West, but I think it's at least clear that it didn't cause some major backlash. Which is still interesting in itself.

As someone who had a similar mentality on September 12, 2001, I think there's some truth to the "blank slate" explanation. The thinking was immediately, "How badly did Osama Bin Laden and his Musli compatriots be abused by the American empire that they felt helpless to do anything but to hijack planes and murder thousands of people? The depths of evil to which these people were pushed to do shows just how evil America is to the rest of the world, and perhaps those individuals who were murdered didn't deserve it, but America as a whole clearly deserved what happened yesterday." I see something similar happening with the narrative here.

But I don't think it's right to call it "blank slate," because that implies some sort of genetic explanation. I don't think it's a matter of genetics, but of religion. What I think I was missing as a teenager back then was the religious context and the understanding that many people take their religion VERY seriously, in a way that's almost beyond comprehension for someone like me who was raised atheist in a secular environment. That plus cultural relativism makes it easy to characterize anyone as a freedom fighter.

I'm also wondering what it would have been like if 9/11 happened in this era of smartphones and cheap Internet on planes. What if Al Qaeda livestreamed the events, including in-cockpit views of the planes all the way to the moments of the crashes? And passengers too would have livestreamed so many streams with different angles and such. It would also include the whole "Let's roll" incident that I believe led to the crash of one of the planes before it could hit a Washington DC target. I could see these being morale boosters both for the doves and the hawks immediately following the attacks, and I'm not sure what direction things would've changed, if at all.

To add to this, I think the unstated nature of it is not only that they don't state it out loud, they don't state it in their own conscious thinking, because their brains have protections in place against consciously thinking such things, regardless of what they believe. This isn't a particularly progressive thing though, it's just a universal human thing that acts on all aspects of life, not just sexuality or politics, and it's the rare human who can even notice when they do this, much less actually combat it.

But it's pretty easy to conclude this based on seeing the way the consent framework gets awkwardly shoved into any cases where a woman is dissatisfied with some episode of casual sex - or more broadly the patriarchy oppression/oppressed framework gets awkwardly shoved in where women are dissatisfied with a life that's filled with casual sex - that whatever they're getting at is something that's shaped very similarly to whatever the religious conservatives are getting at with their talk about "honor" and "disgrace" and whatnot.

If, in progressives' mind, conservatives are making everyone live miserable lives for generations for no other reason than to spite progressives, they should make that case to the population as best they can so that the population rightly shuns conservatism.

Yes, they (we) should make that case as best as they can, and if and when that case fails to convince people to shun conservatism to the extent required to actually defeat conservatism, then that is a failure on their (our) part. And indeed, as best as I can tell, we have tried this method for decades at this point and have largely failed to convince people; we do convince individuals and groups here and there, but we also lose people due to the same methods, and for what we're discussing, we need massive net wins, not wins and losses mostly offsetting each other or even just a slightly higher win-rate than loss-rate. We weren't failed by a populace that didn't rightly listen to us in shunning conservatism, we failed the populace by not giving them the arguments that convince them of the truth of conservatives making everyone live miserable lives for generations for no other reason than to spite progressives.

No, it's because I'm seeing it from a consequentialist standpoint that I see the notion of one's sociopolitical movement as having been failed instead of being a failure as wrong and, to be honest, rather absurd. To wit:

Whether the argument is accurate or not is different, but the accusation is of sabotage, not of facing resistance from the enemy.

Whether or not the accusation is of sabotage or resistance from the enemy, it doesn't change the fact that the colonel's soldiers are now dead, and the hill hasn't been taken. The colonel's job, in this metaphor, is do what it takes to take that hill, taking into account any obstacle that gets in the way, whether that be enemy combatants or sabotaging fellow colonels or incompetent underlings or anything else. If a colonel sends his men to rush a hill only to get shot in the back by people he assumed was friendly, then clearly that colonel failed due to believing that those people were friendly and wouldn't shoot his men in the back.

And in the realm of sexual sociopolitics, I'm rather skeptical that the progressives considered the conservatives to be people mostly on the same page and with similar ideas about what "victory" looked like, just with different ways to get there. From my experience as a progressive living around progressives, we tended to see conservatives, both in sexual matters and in others, to be closer to enemy combatants with very different - almost incomprehensible in its absurdity - ideas of what a good world looked like, than fellow-travelers who would sabotage us for just having some disagreements about the details. And, again, either way, if we only get 90% of the way there instead of 100% because of enemy combatants or sabotage that my movement didn't properly take into account and work around or defeat, and as a result we end up with a situation that's significantly worse than 100% (whether it's worse than 0% is another matter; it's certainly possible, and it's certainly true for some subsets of the population), then that's clearly the responsibility of my movement for failing to properly account for our adversaries, whether they're enemy combatants or sabotage.

I mean, if you view (a) and (b) as binaries that society is either like or not then sure, we aren't there. But if you view (a) and (b) as spectra that societal norms can be closer to or farther from I think it would be pretty hard to argue we're not much closer to (a) and (b) today than we were pre-Sexual Revolution. Sure, maybe the Sexual Revolution (in the sense of particular events that occurred in the 1960's and 1970's) weren't enough to get us all the way there, but my perception is they started us down this path that we continue on towards those outcomes.

I think it's less about the binary/spectrum binary and more about the possible/not possible binary. Placing (a) and (b) in a spectrum still presumes that a society in which (a) (I'll just use "(a)" from now on for brevity) achieved is possible. Or, more realistically, that a society in which we are close to (a) and therefore enjoy some of the fruits of (a) and do not suffer more pains than the fruits due to not quite being at (a), only close to it, is possible.

I see this sort of attitude as being very common in progressive circles. The idea is always that our movement was failed, not that we failed. The idea that it is the responsibility of any particular political movement to adjust its messaging and political power plays to acclimate to the sociopolitical landscape that exists so that more people are convinced to join the cause and to help it just never seems to occur to them. The argument is always some variation of "We did everything right, it's just those damn XYZ people holding us back." Which strikes me as akin to a colonel saying "I did absolutely everything right when I ordered my men to rush that hill; those damn enemy combatants with their machine guns in bunkers are the ones at fault here."