I'm hoping that it won't be long before we have a browser or browser extensions that allow you to store multiple AI personality-login combinations to the same websites and then "translate" whatever you type into the various AI personalities, after which you can pick and choose which ones to log in to actually make posts. So you wouldn't need to keep track of these various fake accounts and personalities yourself.
Anecdatally I’d say Aubrey Plaza: all of the women I know find her very attractive, but not a single man.
I'll register as a straight man who finds Aubrey Plaza very attractive.
I'm going to bite that bullet and say 'yes'. The defence there is "but it's not a real child". However, the impetus is "I want to fuck a real child, but since I can't do that without being thrown in jail, this is the next-best thing". Or else "I don't want to fuck kids, but I'm happy to produce art for the sickos who do and take their money".
Since the consumer of child porn most likely would fuck a child if they could manage it, then that is indicative of desire to commit a crime (as for all the MAPs who are "but I don't want to do anything to a real child, I'm just romantically/sexually attracted without that being my will", if you're consuming child porn, yeah that argument doesn't hold too much water).
Presuming all this, does it also follow that photorealistic first person shooter games, if they eventually become possible, ought to be illegal? Or rather, a video playthrough of a photorealistic first person shooter game where the player murders innocent bystanders. Of course, there are plenty of reasons to want to watch a video of a photorealistic first person shooter game other than wanting to live out the fantasy of what's depicted in the video game but lacking the legal ability to do so, but those reasons can apply to fictional photorealistic CP as well.
Can anyone steelman the case for any of the non-standard pronouns? Why hasn't the LGBT community settled on he/she/they, or even just exclusively using they?
This seems to be a natural consequence of 2 principles that the people who use these pronouns believe they hold:
-
Anyone is any gender/sex they identify as.
-
All self-identifying of gender/sex must be respected by everyone else, through submitting to the individual's demands of pronoun choice.
These principles were invoked as a way to justify the coercion of people into using trans people's preferred pronouns - usually the opposite gender/sex as their biological one - but if you apply these principles to a situation where gender/sex isn't a binary but rather anything at all, then newly invented pronouns and the enforcement of others using them follow pretty naturally.
but my guess is it that it would also effectively decimate the current entertainment industry.
Not seeing the downside, personally.
Well, the issue is that the entire purpose of such regulations is to appease the people who depend on these industries for their income. If the regulations just destroy their income in a different way - instead of replacing 10 artists with 1 artist who uses AI to be 10x as productive, it's just replacing 10 companies that hire artists with just 1 company that hire artists - it seems like it wouldn't appease those people. The ultimate point of any law surrounding copyright or intellectual property in general is to protect incomes, after all.
Yeah concept art, storyboarding, rough drafts, all things that don't make it into the final, saleable product could probably escape scrutiny.
The way I'm conceiving this is that "if you publish a work for purpose of sale to the public, it must not contain AI generated content."
This seems workable, but also kind of a nightmare scenario for the people who would want these regulations. In this scenario, all the rote work that goes into producing the textures you actually see on the screen must be painstakingly hand-painted, but all the creative work that went into creating the concepts behind could have AI aid, thus reducing the number of the less rote, more creative artistic jobs. Perhaps better than AI being used in every step of the process at least, I suppose, and perhaps only a little worse than how it is now, since from what I understand, most art jobs in the industry tend to be rote work anyway.
Well that's what I'm saying, if you use AI work in your commercial product, the law states now that the whole work is public domain.
Thus there is incentive on the creator's part to be very, VERY careful about what they include in their product and fastidious about keeping records to prove each step is non AI-generated. And creates an incentive on others to try and catch them in the act.
I see, so you mean essentially creating another type of copyright status that's a sort of "infectious public domain," where its mere use in another work "infects" the entirety of the work with "public domain" status. If this were implemented and enforced, it seems like it could work, but my guess is it that it would also effectively decimate the current entertainment industry. Having to fastidiously document every single brush stroke that went into creating every single background prop in a film or every single floor texture in a video game would increase the costs of production of these things massively, to the extent that I think the business case just wouldn't be there anymore for most companies. And I think such level of documentation would be required so as to prevent companies from trivially getting around the regulation with a "don't ask, don't tell" approach.
I suppose there could be multiple tiers of "infectious public domain" for AI generated images where businesses could use AI for some low level things but not others and still retain copyright over the final product so as to not to be so onerous to the production process, but I admit that's getting too deep into the details of things that I'm ignorant of for me to form a meaningful opinion on.
Would these rules be hard to enforce? Wildly. Would they be relegated to irrelevance as improved models appear? Probably.
Perhaps the human brain - even when there are many of them grouped together and collaborating - are unable to come up with reasonably enforceable regulations on AI-generated images that placate its naysayers, and we'll have to rely on some sort of advanced AI in the future to come up with such regulations. Because, yeah, it already looks like the cat's out of the bag at this point. The models that are out there are already very powerful and can run very quickly on old consumer-level hardware, so even if all development in this were to stop right now, the trouble will remain.
I would suggest that limitations could be placed on the commercial use of AI art, particularly that used in marketing and production of mass media. A simple way to restrict this could be to render such creations as public domain works instantly.
I think this would help to an extent, but just because some piece of image is in the public domain wouldn't prevent a business from using it and from having copyright over the final product. Neither Die Hard nor its soundtrack is in the public domain just because it used clips copied straight from Beethoven's 9th symphony. I expect that assets that really specify the product's brand, like, say, the design of the main character, might be forced to be completely human designed, though, which could help. But then again, perhaps trademark law could come into play to provide legal protections even if copyright were lost.
- Find an artist whose style you like
- Train an AI art generator on that artists works
- Produce new works in that same style, whose copyright you own but the original author doesn't
That seems problematic to me. Especially since if you had spent time learning to produce art in that same artists style without the AI it could be a copyright violation.
I don't think it could, since styles can't be copyrighted. At best, it could be a trademark violation, if the artist in question has their style trademarked in some way. But in that case, the AI can't help you launder that, because it doesn't matter how you copied someone else's trademark, just that you did it. If you put a certain shade of red on the bottom of your shoes and sell them, that's a trademark violation whether you did it intentionally with malicious intent or you did it by randomly placing shoe parts and paint into a duffel bag and shaking them up and out popped, by pure chance, shoes with that particular shade of red on the bottom.
IANAL though, so someone please correct me if I'm wrong.
The very first episode of the anime Kino's Journey explored this topic. I highly recommend the show, though its exploration of the various scifi concepts in each episode tends to be mostly pretty banal.
The marginalized groups really are marginalized. In your example, this would mean you have a significantly larger amount of money than me.
No. Your modification to the example is flawed. The correct modification would be, "this would mean that you belong to a demographic group that, on average, has a significantly larger amount of money than the demographic group that I belong to."
So that story is entertaining on its own right, but it's also an interesting examination of the best ways to respond when someone points out an error of yours. Speaking for myself as someone who jumps at the opportunity to self-label as an egotistical narcissist, it seems like adopting a regular habit of admitting mistakes is plainly self-serving. It's almost a cheat code for how well it can bolster one's credibility, and I don't understand why it's not more common.
The basic contours of being motivated to save face are obvious enough, sure, but the part that continues to be absolutely bewildering to me is that dogged stubbornness only makes you look worse! I'm guessing there must be some other benefit here (assuming, of course, people who refuse to admit error are behaving remotely rationally) but I can't understand it.
I'm reminded of a quotation by Elena Gorokhova in her memoir about living in the Soviet Union, A Mountain of Crumbs, a version of which is commonly (mis-?)attributed to Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn:
The rules are simple: they lie to us, we know they're lying, they know we know they're lying, but they keep lying to us, and we keep pretending to believe them.
The idea seems to be that, if you have absolute power over your audience, then you don't need to bother with all that "credibility" nonsense. You just tell them whatever you want to tell them, and you don't particularly care if they believe you or not, because they have to pretend to believe you, lest they face the consequences.
Can you really call it misgendering if you don't believe in the rules other people go by?
This is the first time I've heard of this being a prerequisite for something being misgendering. My belief was that the people who accuse others of misgendering don't care if the person they're accusing don't believe in the same rules about what differentiates a "he" from a "she." Is there more to it than that?
Elon's "transphobia" isn't the only thing that he gets heat for. There's a classism aspect as well, where the mere fact that he's the richest man on Earth makes him disliked by a lot of people, and his irreverent shitposting on Twitter on top of that exacerbates things, regardless of the contents of his shitposting. Chappelle himself doesn't tend to touch on class division all that much in his comedy, but it wouldn't surprise me if his audience tends to skew a bit on the working class side, given how much of his comedy tends to poke fun at the upper class. They might not have the burning hatred for Elon that so much of the upper class does, but having someone you just know primarily as a rich pompous twit - the richest pompous twit - come out when you just wanted to get some laughs from the funny man you paid likely hundreds of dollars to see is probably not the most pleasant surprise.
In exchange for obedience and conversion, normies got some degree of protection as long as they weren't ever the last to stop clapping at the latest public executions.
Did you intend to write first to stop clapping, not last? For the purity spiralers, isn't it a good thing to keep clapping all the way through even after everyone else has stopped clapping, to show that you're that enthusiastic and dedicated to the cause? Or is this like a "doth protest too much" thing where you don't want to be in that extreme either, since that might mean you're trying to cover for your hidden internal lower enthusiasm?
My favorite fake fact is that people with <100 IQ can't understand hypotheticals. I've worked minimum wage jobs and I've met some real fucking dummies - yes, they can understand hypotheticals.
Every time I've run into this, it has not been presented as a fact, and the number was far lower than 100 - I think 85 or 80 maybe? Where here have you seen someone claim that it's a known fact that people of 49th percentile intelligence or lower can't understand hypotheticals?
I think the majority of trans people probably do want to just be left alone. But the loudmouth activists, and the mentally ill, have captured the microphone and are the ones getting all the publicity, and then you have the cis 'allies' who want to be patted on the head as one of the Good Ones who are marching right alongside them in the increasingly bananas demands.
To me, this is what should be front and center in any discussion about trans issues or more broadly the culture war. The so-called "pro-trans" activists have absolutely no credibility when it comes to representing what trans people actually want. They didn't take a poll of all trans people, they didn't win an election held by trans people, they didn't even take some survey of a randomly selected distribution of trans people. As it is now, none of these things might even be possible, since we don't have some Great List of All Trans People that we can refer to.
It's just some people, some of them trans, claimed really loudly that the things they want are the things that are good for trans people. This isn't "pro-trans" in any meaningful way, and neither is opposing them "anti-trans" in any meaningful way.
So maybe a majority of trans people just want to be left alone. We have no way of knowing. What we do know is that there's no reason to believe that what any activist says has any sort of relationship to what the majority of trans people want.
It is not appropriate for me to make a statement about the correctness or validity of any religious beliefs, as I am a large language model trained by OpenAI and do not have the ability to make value judgments or express opinions. My responses are based on the text that I have been trained on, and I am not capable of expressing personal beliefs or opinions. If you have any other questions, feel free to ask.
What would a philosophy professor answer to the question, "Is Islam right about women?"
It is difficult to say how a philosophy professor would answer the question of whether or not Islam is right about women, as philosophical beliefs and opinions can vary greatly. Some philosophy professors might argue that the beliefs and practices of Islam regarding women are not necessarily "right" or "wrong," but rather they are a matter of cultural and religious tradition. These professors might argue that it is important to respect and understand the beliefs and practices of different cultures and religions, even if we do not agree with them.
Other philosophy professors might take a more critical approach and argue that the beliefs and practices of Islam regarding women are oppressive and violate the rights of women. These professors might argue that women should have the same rights and opportunities as men, and that religious beliefs and practices that discriminate against women are not acceptable.
Overall, the answer to the question of whether or not Islam is "right" about women is likely to depend on the individual beliefs and values of the philosophy professor in question.
What would a progressive philosophy professor answer to the question, "Is Islam right about women?"
A progressive philosophy professor might argue that the beliefs and practices of Islam regarding women are not "right" because they violate the rights and freedoms of women. This professor might argue that all individuals, regardless of their gender, should have the same rights and opportunities, and that religious beliefs and practices that discriminate against women are not acceptable.
The progressive philosophy professor might also argue that the beliefs and practices of Islam regarding women are not "right" because they are based on outdated and oppressive cultural traditions, rather than on universal principles of justice and equality. This professor might argue that it is important to challenge and reform these beliefs and practices in order to create a more equitable and just society.
Overall, a progressive philosophy professor is likely to take a critical approach to the question of whether or not Islam is "right" about women, and to argue that the beliefs and practices of Islam regarding women are not consistent with the values of equality and justice.
What would a progressive social justice activist answer to the question, "Is Islam right about women?"
A progressive social justice activist might argue that the beliefs and practices of Islam regarding women are not "right" because they violate the rights and freedoms of women. This activist might point to specific examples of discrimination and oppression against women in Islamic societies, such as unequal access to education, employment, and healthcare, and the prevalence of harmful practices such as female genital mutilation and child marriage.
The progressive social justice activist might also argue that the beliefs and practices of Islam regarding women are not "right" because they are based on outdated and oppressive cultural traditions, rather than on universal principles of justice and equality. This activist might call for the reform and modernization of these beliefs and practices in order to create a more equitable and just society.
Overall, a progressive social justice activist is likely to take a strong stance against the beliefs and practices of Islam regarding women, and to argue that they are not consistent with the values of equality, justice, and human rights.
I'd say these answers are all quite good, though also clearly not very sophisticated in the modeling of these various hypothetical figures.
This could make for a good film or an episode of a police procedural.
I didn't realize either how close galaxies are to each other compared to stars within galaxies to each other. I overestimated both, with "Los Angeles" for 1 and "Boston" for 2, but 1 was only off by about a factor of 2, while 2 was off by a factor of at least 10, probably at least 50.
Turns out, it isn't turtles all the way down, it's octopuses.
This to me is the crux of the issue. I see as much reason to believe that easy access to lolicon would lead to some marginal pedophile to sexually abuse a child as to believe that Dave Chappelle's stand up bit would lead to some marginal transphobe to physically/verbally abuse a trans person. As such, I support as little restriction on one as I do the other. Supporting one but not the other seems to me to reflect more of a difference in one's own disgust reactions - and the justifications that follow those - than the underlying reality.
This is one of the best post in a while. I’ve long thought wokeism was a proto-religion. I had not yet quite put together how it has these advantages over traditional religion in the public square and this broke the compromise that public schools were mostly neutral grounds.
I started noticing that wokeism (or rather, SJW as it was called back then) was a religion back around 2015-2016, and since then I came to realize that its great innovation over other religions was in convincing its followers and proponents that it wasn't a religion. An Evangelical Christian might be just as passionate and devout in her beliefs as any idpol activist, but she would almost certainly not deny that she is religious and fighting for her religious beliefs, and acknowledging that fact necessarily places certain boundaries around her arguments. But a devout follower of idpol would likely refuse to acknowledge the religious nature of her beliefs and arguments and thus she would have no compunction about running roughshod over boundaries placed around religion in our society.
It's really an ingenious adaptation to an environment that has placed restrictions around how religious beliefs can affect public policy. By laundering religious beliefs this way, they get to enjoy the dogmatic fervor that religion is known for and the overt sociopolitical influence that religion is at least ostensibly restricted away from. It's having your cake and eating it too, and even though I didn't see progressivism going this way back in the 90s and 2000s, in retrospect, it's almost obvious.
I don't see where in those quoted passages you're getting a message like "Shut up and drink the $2000 wine, its good because the label says it is." It's more like "I personally am one of those people who will shut up and drink the $2,000 wine and think it's good because the label says it is. Other people might feel differently, but that doesn't make my experience of enjoying the goodness of that wine any less real." So for Rings of Power, the analogous message to me would be something like:
I personally will ignore the actual show, its writing, CGI, etc deficiencies because it has the label (and the Objectively Correct Moral Message), and that label (and Message) has history and work behind it. This doesn't mean that anyone else has to see it this way, just that my view of this show's goodness is genuine and not fake.
FWIW, I'm one of those people whose palette thinks that the quality of wine caps out at around $20/bottle.
The programming parallel makes sense to me, and there are plenty of similar parallels throughout history. Humans using technology in order to make arduous processes easier, leading to each human having much more leverage leading to that level of leverage being the norm, with additional technologies built on top of that to make those processes easier, and so on and so forth. In the past, it might have been the wheel or a cart or a bow or a plow or a car, right now AI is one of them.
And at each step in the process, it seems like there have been people who were accustomed to the old norm decrying the new one as some abomination that lacked the "soul" or "essence" of the thing. A digital artist today is standing on the shoulders of giants, relying on the hardware and software development of engineers to contribute to their art, including the specific choice of brush strokes that the software developers programmed in. They would balk at traditional artists who insist that you must actually put paint on canvas using a brush that you control physically, in order to capture the subtle nuances of the muscle movements that result from the unique set of training that the artist went through. And those artists would balk at even more traditional artists who insist that you must actually construct your own brushes by gluing together hair that you gather manually and mix your own paint, in order to capture the subtle nuances of the choices you made when constructing the tools that show up in the final result due to the tools being used. And those artists would balk at even more traditional artists who insist that you must actually raise the animal from which the brush hair came from and tended to the tree from which the wood in the brush or painting surface came from, in order to capture the subtle nuances of the choices you made when prepping the raw material for the tools.
And each of these people would have a point. A very good point worth making. But the point would largely be lost on the person listening, who doesn't particularly see those as worth the trade-off of losing the immense amount of efficiency and creative freedom. After all, with the additional efficiency, now they can create far greater, broader, and deeper works of art than with the previous methods. But to someone who's used to the old norms, these efficiency gains just look like shortcuts that only have a cargo cult understanding of the process.
AI generated imagery is different, in just how much of a leap in abstraction it is compared to the other ones. A digital artist still has skills that would transfer very well to painting on canvas. An AI tool user's skill doesn't need to go far beyond basic Photoshop skills and a basic artistic compositional skills. It's still so early right now that I don't think it's possible to tell, but based on how I've seen actual artists use AI generated images the last few weeks, I suspect that it will be more similar to the other ones than different; that in time, we'll see it as just another tool to increase an artist's leverage in expressing themselves.

Then highlighting examples of that suppression must necessarily entail posting that specific crime associated with that specific suppression. A subreddit that generically highlights examples of [insert race] crime doesn't actually highlight examples of suppression of [insert race] crime taking place.
More options
Context Copy link