AnonymousActuary
No bio...
User ID: 2163
Closing down an airport or adding additional security is the same as mandating everyone stay in their homes, actually.
Securing your borders is very different then securing someone's home. This should be obvious.
If there's a black death like plague close your borders and tell your population what is going on - people will be more careful (as indeed they were in early March, even with popular figures telling them to "go hug a Chinese person" and that "they really should be worried about the flu".
EDIT: Also, saying "would these actions be justifiable with a plague that was 50x worse" is again, not really addressing the point at hand. Is fascism justifiable if things are bad enough (Do you support Korematsu v United States) is a separate question from "Was fascism justifiable in this instance" which is clearly false, especially because everyone abandoned their commitment to it as soon as a more politically favorable current thing popped up at the end of May 2020.
AnonymousActuary
1mo ago
I guess people really love that LSU-Iowa rivalry?
Yes pretty much haha. Caitlin Clark drives huge ratings, and with LSU and Iowa meeting in the championship last year and driving a ton of interest, it was not shocking at all for it to have a seismic rating.
AnonymousActuary
4mo ago
Fair point - it's more just a "man Russia had a ton of people" then a "their sacrifice was not massive" obviously the casualties (both military and civilian) in Russia were insanely large.
AnonymousActuary
5mo ago
Lockdowns aren't on the pareto frontier of policy options for even diseases significantly deadlier than covid imo, just because rapid development and distribution of technological solutions is possible, but ... covid killed one million people in the united states. Yes, mostly old people, but we're talking about protecting old people here. No reason to pretend otherwise.
Whether the policies may or may not have protected any old people has nothing to do with whether they were fascist or not. I could deprive everyone of freedom of movements this holiday season and probably save several thousand people from the flu, but that does not mean it is not fascist.
AnonymousActuary
1yr ago
I think Stefferi is right if he is talking about expectations for the vaccine before the first trial results were released. Especially focusing on scientific expectations, not the partisan "If Trump release a vaccine before the election it'll be rat poison".
AnonymousActuary
5d ago
The story I heard was Milton Friedman came up with withholding...hated the idea of it as a more small government person, but thought it was the best way to get enough money to win WWII.
No idea how true that is.
AnonymousActuary
2mo ago
If you figure this out please let me know - similar situation with a file that has sentimental value and I have some idea of what the passphrase might be
AnonymousActuary
4mo ago
I think it is more likely a happy accident then a deliberate targeting, but it is hard to say for sure. There is much about what went on in March 2020 that is still very unclear to me. I think it is definitely possible it was more a general egregore that drove the shutdowns than any one specific thing (China is sometimes mentioned, though if so they were clearly drinking their own kool-aid rather than trying to sabotage anyone).
EDIT: I should say I'm referring to an "egregore" being responsible rather than directly the "state", as in my mind much of 2020 is better explained by some sort of social media/traditional media/political expediency/current thing/good 'ol fashioned hysterias then more concrete concepts such as "the state"
AnonymousActuary
6mo ago
if you like a relaxing form of travel, stay at top tier all inclusive resorts for 4-5 days at a time.
AnonymousActuary
3d ago
Divide and Conquer (LOTR) mod for Medieval II was tons of fun.
AnonymousActuary
4mo ago
Lockdowns are fascism because using a trumped-up emergency (whether or not it killed people it was obviously trumped up - particularily the threat to children, young, healthy, and "long COVID") as pretext to confine your population to their homes only to be let out when your approved political causes are up for support is bad, well working with the media and technology companies to censor any opposition to your views is like, basically the dictionary definition. Like what political system would it be if not?
AnonymousActuary
10mo ago
"Actions taken by the Biden Admin during the Covid pandemic were generally justified." Not enough info to sway either way
Always down to talk COVID. Prefer text only for op-sec reasons
AnonymousActuary
4mo ago
would you prefer authoritarian?
Forgot about the whole "yeah the 1st amendment doesn't apply anymore, no religious services or protests (except the state-sanctioned ones)"
AnonymousActuary
5mo ago
I did not run at a D1 University, but was fit in college, and got my Marathon done right before graduating to check off the box haha. Knew it was only going to get harder from there.
AnonymousActuary
8mo ago
AnonymousActuary
1yr ago
purely because I hated the other big champion that year so fucking much
Ok you can't just say that and not elaborate
AnonymousActuary
1yr ago
Ah - so then hardening the doors would be the fruit but that is substantially less low hanging.
AnonymousActuary
11mo ago
Reminds me of Kevin Williamson's support for hanging (though he opposes the death penalty). If we want the state to have the power of execution, we should have to confront the consequences. None of this pseudo medicalized stuff. Firing squad or hanging.
AnonymousActuary
1yr ago
I've always wondered if they realized:
-
Lockdowns aren't going to get rid of COVID
-
We've turned some decent percentage of the population paranoid
-
We need that population to start doing things again or we kill the economy
-
Masks work! Just wear a mask and you are safe to go around making and consuming Economics inputs and outputs!
But maybe that is too conspiratorial...it really was a huge switch though. The stated reason was that they realized the amount of presymptomatic/asymptomatic spread, but lots of illnesses have huge periods of presymptomatic spread (Influenza and RSV, notably), so not sure why that would have resulted in a change.
AnonymousActuary
1mo ago
If you are going to have kids and have parents who would be interested in being involved grandparents or have siblings who have kids who would be cousins (or are likely to do so), then I'd put living as close as possible (really, as possible, being 5 minutes away >>> being 25 minutes away >>> being a half-day drive >>> being a flight/full day drive) pretty highly on the list of things to prioritize.
Obviously depends on where people live as to how desirable those cities are, but something to strongly consider.
AnonymousActuary
8mo ago
- I really enjoyed this article and happily followed the substack
- I have a vague memory of reading an article online a long time ago that discussed the logistical differences between Japan and the US in terms of how quickly the US was building destroyers/escort carriers/etc by 1944 even. If anyone remembers that can find me the link, I will be eternally* grateful
*grateful for a few hours plus every few years when I think about the article again
AnonymousActuary
11mo ago
As an actuary in healthcare (arguably part of the problem) I heartily recommend that article.
AnonymousActuary
1mo ago
It’s absolutely wild how much sortition is involved in the U.S. For a New York resident to visit, I dunno, Dallas—that’s further than Paris-to-Warsaw. The trains are embarrassing, too. We’re firmly in road-trip territory. And the issue is much worse for those who don’t have the disposable income or time to cross the continent for a few days.
Or they could just take a 4 hour flight for less than $300 round trip?
AnonymousActuary
1yr ago
Tangential to the discussion, but immediately made me think of this classic article on how they build the spaceship code:
Once again, actually locking doors seems to be the anti-mass shooting low-hanging fruit
More options
Context Copy link