@Botond173's banner p

Botond173


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

				

User ID: 473

Botond173


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 473

I've posted this before here, and it bears reposting here, with some edits meant as improvement:


This whole thing reminds me of the news stories about the children's mass grave in Tuam, Ireland, and of supposed mass graves in Tulsa, Oklahoma where racist mass-murdering demons buried the victims of the 1921 "race massacre", or so we're told.

When I try looking at these affairs without bias and prejudice, I try putting myself in the shoes of the average Western middle-class suburban white normie NPC, and frankly I realize that, unless some heretic specifically makes an effort to educate me on this, I'll probably have zero understanding of the following hard facts about the bygone days of the West:

1/ It was normal to bury people in unmarked individual paupers' graves, or even in unmarked mass paupers' graves (in the case of, say, an epidemic or some similar catastrophe) if nobody claimed the corpse, or if the relatives were too poor to, or unwilling to, afford a proper burial. This, in fact, was not rare.

2/ Back when national economies were yet too undeveloped to produce a surplus to be spent on, frankly, luxuries, there was exactly zero public support for spending tax money* to improve the material conditions of single mothers so that they have the same prospects in life as married wives**.

*Keep in mind, please, that, unlike today, milking the impregnators for child support under the threat of imprisonment wasn't an option either in most cases, because they were either dead, or already in prison/workhouse, or too poor to be milked for money.

**Again, let's be clear about this: back in the days of benighted Papist Ireland, or in any similar patriarchal society, I can assure you there were probably zero housewives willing to tolerate the spectre of the government basically confiscating a given % of her husband's income and giving it to unwed mothers in the form of state handouts. The extent to which Christian societies in such economic conditions were willing to go to look after the downtrodden was basically to shove them onto the Church and leave them to hold the bag. In the same way, the Church was basically expected to sweep up a portion of single men and women that were unmarriageable for whatever reason and train them to be monks, priests and nuns, so that they were no longer a problematic pain in the butt to their own families.

3/ Also, a society that poor is also unable to pay for lavishly equipped, professional, extensive police forces. This means extrajudicial punishment, communal vigilantism and mob justice was seen as normal and necessary by most people, at least to a certain extent.

4/ Stray dogs were normally slaughtered and their cadavers/bones were used for producing animal glue and other similar products, because you could be sure absolutely nobody was going to contribute material resources to founding and running comfy dog shelters. (I know this has nothing to do with these manufactured scandals, but I included it because we know that white liberals just love dogs.)

That depends on your definition of 'legitimate'. (Yeah, I actually just said that.) If 'legitimate grievance' in this context means 'grievances, when proven, used as justification to enact organizational reform of CPS so that no child abuse is committed under their watch in the future', then I think the answer is very obviously yes. Having said that, this is not at all what's happening in this particular case. Let's just be clear about this. This is simply pure culture war, nothing else.

I don't find that plausible at all.

Were those conditions more awful than the usual condition of native children in their own communities? Was their average death rate lower?

By the way, does anyone know what the current status is of the sensationalized "investigations" into the "mass graves" of the victims of the Tulsa "race massacre"?

I recently visited some friends in the north Dallas metroplex, which is about as close to the platonic ideal of detached-house suburbia as you can get sprawling in all directions, and they know their neighbors on all sides by name (and which tools and skills they regularly trade), and live within a few hundred meters of an HOA-managed playscape where they regularly encounter the same few dozen children and parents.

Maybe I'm too dense, but at the end of the day, does this metroplex actually offer what sociologists call third places?

Being a parent is hard for the first 5 or so years

And then it becomes even harder when puberty hits.

Good point. I think it's another example how different aspects of social atrophy form a vicious cycle. It's probably also safe to assume that you're likely to invite social disapproval and censure as a young PMC mother if you make too many obvious attempts to get away from your own children throughout the day one way or another.

New parents are isolated from most of their previous friends, as their paths suddenly never cross again unless they too have kids of their own.

I don't think that's a case of age segregation.

You are correct, their widespread adoption was first stopped by Stalin

And, I suppose, also introduced by him a couple of decades earlier. Or?

They have people to look after the kids if they want to go to a summer wedding in Italy, or to a week skiing in Aspen.

How does this actually work? (Genuine question.) Are there specific agencies that get involved in this?

The farce that was the Trayvon Martin scandal and the media circus that accompanied it was definitely a sign of things to come. In retrospect, that is obvious, and the trend isn't abating. That was in early 2012. And I'm sure one thing fueling it was culture warriors following the story on their smartphones all the time and triggering themselves.

This doesn’t necessarily mean those mental health and addiction aren’t highly important here are as well, but that there may be a demographic of fairly low functioning people who are able to take care of themselves, just barely, at low costs, but are simply unable to under heavier financial burdens.

So I suppose they're also low-functioning to the extent that they're unable to, you know, move to another state with a much lower average cost of living for whatever reason.

With respect to WFH I can only offer an anecdote. Young married couple in an apartment with two small children. The man is working from 'home', but everyday he needs to go to his mother's place to work from home, because the presence of the children make that impossible at their own home. Again, it's just an anecdote, but I'm sure there are many, many similar cases.

As far as I know, state-funded boarding schools from a young age weren't widespread anywhere in the Soviet bloc.

I'd add this comment from the old subreddit by Dangerous_Psychology. It brings up an important aspect to all of this. After all, I'm sure there are many couples who want more than two children but cannot afford an SUV.

Also, and this is pure speculation, I think the pool of potential reliable and good nannies is relatively smaller everywhere due to the opioid epidemic, just the overall abuse of drugs both illegal and legal, rising rates of alcoholism and mental illness among single women etc., and the few who are available aren't cheap.

I also assume that the elderly are much less likely to suffer from mental and physical decline if they're upper-class, which means they're more available to help out with childcare.

But anyway, I don't think it's realistic to expect any married couple to do the dirty work of childcare all the time by themselves. Because this has not been the case historically anywhere.

t's fun when you can go out drunk and party without fearing you'll run into your older relatives and they disapprove

Is it normal in Finland for pensioners to troll the local bar district late at night?

But anyway, what I'm actually somewhat curious about is whether you and your spouse have the social expectation that your children and your married friends' children will regularly play together in (maybe) a few years or not. (I suppose they're currently too young for that.) I'm sure this is a relevant question, as this'd be a large help for everyone involved. But again, I don't know what the social mores are there.

For example, when I visit my friends who also have kids of age similar to hours, I basically don’t need to do any child caring at all, they just play together and don’t need anything from me aside from occasional conflict resolution. This is a huge glaring contrast compared to times when we only had one, and it demanded constant attention, because it simply did not want to be left to play alone. As you get to 4-5+ kids, I imagine the older ones can be very helpful in caring for younger ones.

Thanks for pointing that out. It's a rather relevant issue in this context. I'd only add from experience that this, however, doesn't fully work when 3 or 5 children are together, as one will get ostracized or neglected by the others.

I see. Unfortunately I think that Derbyshire's criticism of that piece is entirely valid.

As Kevin Williamson argued upon Trump's election, not every poor white Appalachian deserved to succeed in modernity, even if Donald told them every failure wasn't their fault

I suppose you're referring to that these-communities-deserve-to-die article?

Thanks for the detailed explanation, although for the sake of those who know nothing about this tragedy, I'll point out that it's slightly misleading to state that fans "stormed the stadium". But anyway, my point isn't that, it's that this incident with the T-shirt appears to be rather different from the other ones listed in the original comment. After all, surely working-class Northern English football fans don't count as a protected group.

Recently a man was found guilty of wearing an offensive football shirt (a reference to the Hillsborough disaster over 30 years ago).

Huh? Care to elaborate please?

merely say he "had some interesting ideas about labor relations" or something

I argue it'd be relatively easy to press him on this. Surely his ideological investment in Marxism goes further than that.

the founding fathers were uniquely capable sages

Does Rufo actually go that far? I'm not familiar with his work so I don't know.

Is there any proof that Jefferson's personal views on blacks ever motivated any of his decisions as a politician and public servant? And if yes, did those decisions have a lasting effect on the political fabric of the nation? That seems to be an important question to me.

"Jefferson was racist, ergo a bad person and all of his works are now discredited."

Except that Robinson's leftist wagon fort never applies the same standard to Marx, or Engels, or Che Guevara, or any other leftist revolutionary who ever expressed racist views. I find it regrettable that Rufo seemingly never made that point.