@Botond173's banner p

Botond173


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

				

User ID: 473

Botond173


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 473

I'll ask you to explain how "doomsters" and "scaremongers" about immigration were proven wrong historically.

As your comment was a response to a response to the original comment, I’d say you weren’t the one to place the goalposts. You expressed your disagreement with @Butlerian, who expressed his disagreement with the claim in this particular ad that the US beer industry used to put women in bikinis, implying that they were somehow coerced or manipulated into posing for ad photoshoots in bikinis. This is where the goalposts are.

Let’s clarify a few things. If you want to discuss the human requirement to find a high-value mate, then go ahead, but I ask you to recognize that this is a completely different issue. Because it is.

Also, I’ll claim that differentiating “activities engaged in grudgingly [in exchange for money]” from "activities engaged in out of purely economic necessity [that is, in exchange for money]" is needlessly pedantic and pointless.

And also, please recognize the very crucial and clear difference between male office cubicle workers and instathots, namely that the latter are choosing an economic option which does not exist for the former.

I ask you not to move the goalposts. Nobody was discussing such other requirements here.

Yes, I maintain that most of the women modeling full-time on tiktok/insta etc. could also earn a living by doing mundane crappy office cubicle jobs or service jobs etc. What they're doing is a lifestyle choice, not a necessity. This differentiates them from the average man working that same type of job (to earn a living, and not for any ulterior motive), because he usually doesn't have that option.

I'd be happier with billboards reminding women their primary worth is as wives and mothers.

Which would very obviously prove to be even more triggering.

Trying to pander to women's desire to feel empowered and justified by doing whatever they decide to do is a losing game.

That's an incorrect comparison. Most of the men who work office cubicle jobs do so because there's no other way for them to make a living. This doesn't apply to insta/tiktok/etc models.

But we still have a large amount of African Americans who have failed to ever adapt to America.

Unfortunately they didn't arrive as voluntary immigrants though, which is a relevant difference. And Native Americans don't exist as an immigrant minority either, but as dispossessed and defeated aborigines.

Most migrants aren't committing violence, and it does seem cruel to kick out people who have been living somewhere for years or even decades.

They aren't likely to apply these two particular principles fairly and even-handedly though, in my experience. It's well to be skeptical about this.

According to the linked Wikipedia article, it seems it was a simple case of cancelling:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bachelor_(American_season_25)#Controversy

I'll not dispute this detailed writeup, I'll just add that yes, what I wrote is pessimistic in the sense that, based on what I've read and seen, the current reality for the middle-class and lower-class in developed economies is that it's increasingly difficult to avoid sliding down to the ranks of the precariat, and also to leave it. Basically one needs to master marketable and specialized skills in order to reliably secure a middle-class lifestyle.

Indeed it's more complicated. Generally I think that demographic collapse is a vicious circle i.e. when children are generally scarce, it erodes one's inclination to have children.

In a society that isn't demographically imploding, young people either have children, or are in committed relationships which will produce children in the near future, so they don't have time and energy to invest into braindead stuff like K-Pop fandom.

I suggest you put yourself in the shoes of a lower-class or middle-class member of the Korean precariat who leads a usual crummy existence as a parent. Not even trying to send your child to an idol audition is, I suppose, similar to not even sending him/her to cram school i.e. not even bothering to give him/her that very marginal shot of enrolling to one of the top national universities. It means that you’ve already internalized that your child will inevitably grow up to be another lousily paid miserable wagecuck in the hellworld of late-stage capitalism, just another nameless prole. You’ve already accepted this reality, even though your child is not even an adolescent. And if you happen to have two children, you and everybody around you already knows that you won’t be able to afford all the cram school curses, summer camps, private tutors etc. for both of them, which means you’ve condemned one or maybe two more children in the country to the prole life.

This is not a decision that is easy to live with.

What else are we supposed to do, invent all the local ideologies and policy points ourselves? There's just 5,5 million of us.

I'm sure multiple ideologies and political theories originate from polities even less populous than that.

Just to pose an uninformed question (because I can't be bothered), to what extent is 'Britishness' as a common identity even authentic now that the empire has been gone for decades, considering that the only commonality I can name among the English, the Welsh and the Scots (besides them sharing the same island as their homeland - let's ignore Ulster for a moment) was that all of them took part in maintaining the empire, with or without arms, and thus considered themselves 'British' in the sense of assuming an imperialist/colonialist identity? Ever since these 3 nations have formed a single polity, building an empire is the only thing they've ever known. As far as I can tell, they have nothing else in common, and since 1945, this is also gone. I guess Scottish aspirations to political independence prove that, as do the regional (if that's the correct word) results of the Brexit referendum.

I suppose you can say that it was an invasion 'only' targeting the ruling dynasty and not the nation as a whole.

several people from the 2017 torch-light march in Charlottesville on the UVA campus are being charged with felonies on the basis of burning an object with an intent to intimidate

Objectively speaking, how many BLM-adjacent rioters could have been charged with that after 2020?

I can agree with your points, but it seems clear that civil war couldn't be averted by 1936. The CEDA lacked the influence to marginalize the far right and to neutralize the violent far left.

I doubt that failed anti-government rebellions were ever normally put down by men in the 50-60 or 40-60 age bracket.

People who end up rejecting the system and seeing the establishment right for what it is – fake opposition – end up where we are now called something like ‘dissident right’.

This quoted part pretty much answers your question. The one political factor that was sorely missing in German in 1933, in Italy in 1922, in Spain in 1936, in Chile in 1973 etc., was a decisively large establishment right-wing party capable of drawing widespread support, even attracting large numbers of hardliner rightists, and persuasively presenting itself as a political force curbing the influence of the far left.

Indeed. Also, the armies, police forces and militias that successfully put down rebellions of angry young men in the past were themselves recruited from huge pools of young men living in fecund societies. And also, fecund but stable societies in the past drew their stability from masses of married or at least paired-up young men having an investment in the future stability of that society. In demographically imploding atomized societies, there won't be many of them around either, so the two factors cancel each other out.

I think we should stop pretending that we here on this page agree on Trump being uniquely bad.

There used to be leftist groups in the UK and elsewhere in Western Europe advocating the decriminalization and normalization of pedophilia / man-boy-love. After they failed to replicate the success of the Civil Rights Movement as they wanted, they faded away and their entire existence was memory-holed. The same happened to the wing of radical feminists advocating for lesbian separationism. The fact that gay rights groups didn't promote the legalization of gay marriage as their main goal until the early 2000s is also memory-holed. So yes, it can actually be done.

They believe in it in the sense that they hold it to be true i.e. they consider it a social reality that inexorably asserts itself. It's just like the fact that women are capable of lying about rape and domestic violence. 98 out of 100 people actually believe that, but 78 out of those 98 would never admit that even to themselves.

Probably not. But people will comprehend what you're talking about, and that you have a point.

@onepostmotte is right. As a man, the level of care you receive is generally dependent on the level of social status you built up for yourself through your own efforts. That doesn't apply to women, who have innate social value. 'Women are human beings, men are human doings'. If you ever lose your job, if your girlfriend ever leaves you, your family ever disowns you, you'll see that the amount of care you'll get collapses.