@Botond173's banner p

Botond173


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

				

User ID: 473

Botond173


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 473

didn't have noticable effect (body cams)

Care to elaborate please?

But what I have been thinking is - are freedom of movement and affordable housing compatible at all? The communist regimes had something like city citizenship - you were allowed to move to the capital only with marriage/secured job in the city.

Those conditions didn't apply if you just rented, though.

That’d just lead you pointlessly down a rabbit hole in this context. First of all, you’re starting off from the assumption that genocide is defined by proportionate numbers of victims and not genocidal intent, which I’m sure many people will find objectionable, plus you’ll have to come up with accurate numbers of potential and actual victims, which again leave a lot of room for disagreement. If you want to argue with Holocaust revisionists, in most cases I’m sure it makes more sense to question their ideas about Holocaust remembrance being an industry, its memory being weaponized to further the goals of the Israel lobby and enforce ethnomasochism etc.

All the above said, “where did the Jews go” is the most persuasive anti-revisionist argument. Revisionist explanations, which involve a balanced measure of “to Russia”, “to the West”, “they died but not deliberately”, “they stayed in place but secularized and assimilated unbelievably quickly under communism” and “they never existed in the first place” are deeply unpersuasive.

I don't think this entire debate is about the numbers though. It's misdirection to say that it is. It's about a) the methods used b) the political and cultural legacy of it all.

Surgery data?!

Who would've thought.

That's actually pleasantly surprising.

I'll have to say I'm somewhat surprised. (Not regarding the part about Jewish sacred cows though, that's for sure.) One a scale of 1-10, my surprise is maybe level 3 or 4. After all, the 1918-21 period was crucial for the entire German nation, no matter how we slice it. Nationhood itself was at stake. But again, I'm not that surprised that awareness of this is basically suppressed.

(For example, I once came across descriptions about the Ruhr Uprising of 1920, which I actually never heard anything about before, and later found that only rather scant information is available about this even in German, even though this event had clear long-term political ramifications; also, the numerous leftist victims of the uprising's suppression by the Freikorps only actually have one obscure monument dedicated to them in Hagen, which I guess even local antifa never visit. And the monument dedicated to the suppressors actually still stands in Essen!)

But anyway, portraying the SPD as the gread force of good against the Nazis? Really? That's almost comical, consider just how useless that party actually was (and have always been), on balance, when it came to actually ever reaching its stated aims. Zentrum was arguably a much more serious opponent of the Nazis.

I'll give it a shot.

As far as I can tell, the rightist view was that Communists are the enemies of the German nation, which they explicitly wanted to dissolve together with all others, agents of chaos and degeneracy, with Jews overrepresented, and had to be fought by the means the German state still had on hand, which were the Freikorps (officers' detachments) and nothing else i.e. the struggle of the Freikorps was legitimate.

With respect to the KPD, the predominant criticism against them is, as far as I can tell, that their actions were a necessary (but not solely sufficient) prerequisite of the Nazi seizure of power. Also, their "anti-fascist action" was 1. a farce (as they considered Social Democrats and all right-wing parties to be fascists) 2. counterproductive (as it played into the hands of Nazis).

I'm not the OP but I'll take a stab at this.

The problem, so to speak, here is that the aspects of the Holocaust for which the case does not mostly rely on witness testimony are also the aspects that are, in the context of the 20th Century, mundane, and thus cannot be used to highlight the supposed uniqueness of it all. I'm taking about the pogroms committed by locals, mass shootings of the Einsatzgruppen, forced laborers dying due to hunger and typhus etc. There is material evidence of this: film footage, photos, written orders, telegraphs, official reports etc. However, that's not what people talk about when they make "the case" for THE Holocaust. They mean the gas chambers and Zyklon B, the fire of crematoria illuminating the sky, Jewish babies dumped alive into fiery pits etc.

Is there even a city where Stalin was specifically commemorated as its founder?

(Perhaps you might find people who are both Holocaust and Gulag revisionists in Russia?)

Well, maybe. I won’t speak for Holocaust revisionists, but their main argument regarding survivor memoirs does not appear to be that they’re just all unreliable/false and that’s that, it’s that even memoirs that contain more than obvious falsehoods, exaggerations etc. are given legitimacy and even get used as source material for TV series etc., and that the mainstream media is very reluctant to call their authors out, or even to discuss them.

But, now that you mentioned it, I’m reminded that yes, Gulag revisionists do exist, as should be pointed out here, although (as far as I know) almost all of them work in Russia, and their works are only rarely translated or even publicized in any way outside Russia. I’ve seen examples of their research, and most if it seems to be much more mundane stuff, like the following: someone claims their grandpa was arrested and baselessly charged with political crimes, and sent to the GULAG -> researcher goes to the archives and looks at the documents; it actually turns out that grandpa was arrested for robbery/burglary/theft/embezzlement etc.

There are other crucial differences, I’d say. With respect to the GULAG, one cannot claim that there are no written explicit orders or no clear evidence of death tolls, because undoubtedly there is, and it has been accessible for decades. Also, this whole issue has become completely politicized and interpreted in terms of Moskal imperialism and criminality, which hasn’t happened to the Holocaust in the same way.

You know what Ukrainian nationalists mean when they speak of "Europe", don't you?

Were such statues erected there? If yes, are there still there, or were they removed on grounds that they are affront to the national heritage of the locals?

I've read the discussions on the Holocaust. Maybe I didn't pay enough attention, but it seems nobody anywhere mentioned the various Holocaust memoirs and the role they play in the entire narrative. I find that odd.

I wonder to what extent does the following fall into the category of "right-wing wrongthink" in Germany?

  1. Right-wing interpretations of the various Communist uprisings in Germany between 1918-1921

  2. A similar examination of the policy of the Communist Party of Germany in the Weimar Republic

I'm asking because I think there is a possibility in the future that Die Linke will have to be invited to the governing coalition after a federal election in Germany.

Well, it isn't. I was just completely surprised that you'd come up with that hypothetical among all possible ones, considering that, as far as we know, Hitler planned to erase cities in occupied Russia, not found them.

But I'll say this: had the Nazis ever actually founded new settlements in present-day Ukraine, and at least one of these still existed, there's only one political group that would ever conceivably honor its founding, and that is Azov symphatisers.

For the sake of fairness, I'll point out that what has happened here is, strictly speaking, not vandalism (or at least not yet), although it really isn't much better.

(If news reports are to be believed, the monument will be moved to the park of a new local museum dedicated to the memory of the Moskal yoke, purportedly as an object of scorn and ridicule.)

That's just great. So the founding of Odessa was an irrelevant sidenote to Catherine's rule, and what's actually important is that she is "associated with murderers" (huh?). This is basically comedy level. Was the Russian government supposed to condemn the dissolution of the Zaporozhian Sich (which is supposedly Catherine's main great crime committed against Ukraine) in order to undo that association, or what?

I think it's fair that if someone is primarily famous for his bad deeds, or if his statue there is primarily to commemorate his bad deeds, then yes, tear his statue down.

What would even count as one, though? The closest examples I can think of are the Stalin statues that used to stand near the Moscow-Volga and Volga-Don canals, both of which were mainly constructed by GULAG prisoners, but even that is a bit of a stretch.

Does he have a statue anywhere? If yes, it's a valid argument to start.

And if Mao Zedong happened to create shelters for dispossessed landlords...

...no, wait, he has done exactly the opposite.

That's not what I said, and you know that.

I object to the notion of it being smart.

It's actually worse than that. It's supposedly based on them actually being the true Rus, whereas "Russians" claimed the label for themselves without basis, because they're just Asiatic mongrels.