@Botond173's banner p

Botond173


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

				

User ID: 473

Botond173


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 473

And this female authority has also been eroded by secularization and modernity to an equal degree.

Eugenics as invented by the social progressives of the day was clearly and decidedly involuntary though.

The current rearmament rhetorics are driven by a political desire to capitalize on anti-Trump and pro-Ukraine sentiments, not by any desire to actually increase the ability of Germany or Europe to wage war.

So what if the Americans or the Ukrainians or the Russians call their bluff?

The legitimacy of the IRBO/LIO was fatally undermined by the Kosovo War. What was left of it was then further undermined by the Libyan War. This damage cannot be undone at this point.

If your argument is that a unified German state, which has never existed before 1871, cannot be counted on to uphold peace and prosperity for her citizenry and European neighbours in the long term, what is your assessment of Berlin's current political line, namely that Germany should become the center of a new rearming European alliance which is decidedly anti-Russian and also freed from American influence? Because if my assumption is correct, you should be 100% against it.

A couple of months ago @Goodguy left the following comment here:

I think that in modern society the opinion that men should have more control over women's sexual decisions, other than potentially in the one case of abortion (because that one has potential moral implications beyond the woman) is just fundamentally loser-coded because the Internet has made it pretty clear that the majority of men who want to police women's sexual decisions are doing so out of sexual frustration. Of course there is a small minority of rationalist-types who genuinely care about the impact of women's sexual decisions on fertility rates or social cohesion out of a detached interest in supporting pro-social policies, but the modal guy online arguing for controlling women's sexual decisions is, assuming that he is not a genuine pro-lifer, pretty clearly doing it because he isn't getting laid as much as he wants.

I tried to initiate a discussion about this without success, with my argument being that single men „policing/controlling” the sexual decisions of single women (I'm including „slut-shaming” in this category) has actually only been a social reality in the minds of feminist culture warriors. It was never implemented as a tool of women's „oppression” anywhere. To the extent that such „policing” existed (if we want to call it that), it was mainly done by other women, mainly due to the simple and understood fact that it's such policing that serves the long-term sexual interests of women as a whole. And the men that did engage in this were mostly fathers with daughters, not single men in the current sense of the word. (One can argue that in traditional patriarchal communities it was normal for single men to band together and remove outsider single men through threats or force; I guess this may count as indirect policing, which isn't saying much.)

I'm open to reading any counterarguments but anyway, this is not the subject I want to address here. I think Goodguy touched on something rather important which didn't occur to me at first, namely that society used to have a different attitude regarding this issue before it became modern. There actually used to be a group of men who were basically deputized by society to morally shame women in certain contexts despite being technically single (as I alluded to this above): priests and monks. (And this doesn't just apply to Christendom.) They were also voluntarily celibate, which is another category that disappeared with the rise of modernity. (The cultural memory of this lingers on though, otherwise the people who came up with the „incel” label would simply have called themselves celibate.)

As I was pondering this issue, it also occurred to me that secularization meant that Western societies did lose something significant not just in this respect but others as well. It appears to me that secular society and the churches/denominations used to exist in a symbiosis with the terms never being openly stated. It's well-known that Christianity used to be in a culturally hegemonic/privileged position. But it's also true that the churches basically volunteered to take care of those social groups that nobody else wanted to look after because they're socially a pain in the neck:

  • singles who can't or won't get married (see: priests, monks, nuns)

  • generally adults lacking social skills to such an extent that they become shut-ins without outside assistance

  • sick/diseased people unable to pay for treatment

  • children sired by men who can't or won't become husbands and providers

  • poor people that are so helpless and lacking in agency that they die from poverty without the charity of others

  • children of married couples too poor to pay for any schooling

I think atheists and people hostile to religion in general emotionally get hung up on the former and lose sight of the latter. Some of them who did not lose sight of it came up with the doctrine of eugenics as a solution, but we know what reputation that has today. Instead we expect the state to pick up the slack and look after all these unfortunate groups, which only results in a multitude of horror stories about police departments, child protective services etc. being a useless bunch of uncaring buffoons.

I wonder what the rationalist point of view on all of this is.

Russia is only decreasing theirs because their Cold War stockpiles were insanely large

Didn't the same apply to the US as well though?

It makes sense. A memorandum, by its own nature, does not need to be ratified, because it's never binding.

Russia and China have increased their stockpiles

I'm pretty sure the opposite actually happened, at least in the case of Russia.

The NATO intervention in Libya was obviously intended to topple the regime from the start. Without it the civil war would have been ended by the government forces in short order, as the rebels never amounted to much by themselves and weren't getting outside help from elsewhere. This'd have also meant a refugee crisis but on a much smaller scale.

A couple of things.

  1. Don't you think that it's rather far-fetched to claim that Poland was "defending" her "eastern borders" in January 1919? From whom? The newly formed Ukrainian state that was claiming her independence at roughly the same time as Poland? Also, what "eastern borders" did Poland have? East ot Poland a civil war was raging, and the bolshevik regime was fighting for survival, not attacking Poland.

  2. Slovakia's actions after 1939 don't fit into your parallel at all. Nothing of this sort did happen or is ever going to happen in Ukraine. (You're not going to claim that Slovakian independence was illegitimate, are you?.) Regarding military potential, it's true that the Germans captured enough equipment to equip roughly 45 divisions, plus large armaments industry facilities intact. Again, this is something that's never going to happen in Ukraine at all. To spell it out: the area that remains under the control of the Ukrainian government never had and does not have an armaments industry comparable in scale at all (to spell ot out further, look at size of the Czechoslovak armaments sector as compared to the German in 1938, and that of the Ukrainian as compared to the Russian today), and even if it did, there's no chance of the Russians ever capturing it intact ever.

  3. No matter what went down in 1919, in 1938 Poland should have assisted Czechoslovakia against Germany even out of nothing else but self-interest. It was well known by that time that Hitler wanted to undo the Versailles Treaty, consequently to regain lands that were surrendered to a newly formed Poland, especially Danzig. It logically followed that if the Sudeten crisis ends with concessions made to the Germans, they'll be emboldended and make similar demands to Poland. It was evident. France and Britain were not in a geographical position to assist Czechoslovakia in a defensive war, but Poland was.

It's not that I'm asking for a link if that is what you're implying :). As far as I can tell, it has only rather recently been released in theaters outside Western Europe so I doubt it's available on streaming anywhere yet.

The title is simply 'Riefenstahl'.

I find it hilarious that EU members and North American states are not even in the top 3 (if you're correct).

I know. My point is that the rump Czech state had an armaments sector which was enormous by regional standards and was captured intact by the Germans, and without force. None of that applies to Ukraine. When Czechoslovakia surrendered territories, it was not given any security guarantee by any great power afterwards, as far as I know. That's also something that very obviously isn't going to happen to Ukraine.

A quick Google suggests that the median age in Germany during World War one was likely about 28; it's about 42 now. I think this matters even if Ukraine can absorb the same number of causalities on paper.

That's not the issue. The issue is what the current Ukrainian median age is compared to the imperial German median age at 1914. There are a myriad of other contentious issues which undercut this parallel completely. Like, how many people does the Kievan government actually have real sovereignty over as of now? How many of those are fighting-age men? How many men will it be able to draft in the coming years? I'm pretty sure nobody has an exact idea of any of those.

As long as they're want to keep fighting, we should support them.

The glaringly obvious problem with your argument is that the whole reason many of them are willing to continue fighting in the first place is their assumption that the US continues to support them, and will continue to assist European NATO states in their efforts to also support Ukraine. The causation is the other way around.

I'm just wondering if you're aware that in that particular crisis the Polish military regime, instead of offering military assistance to the Czechoslovak state to defend itself, actually decided to take part in the partition of it instead in order to pursue irredentist territorial aspirations of its own? They did this even though they were aware that they were the only state capable of realistically offering military assistance to Czechoslovakia in a potential defensive war, and that the Nazi government was staking a claim for Danzig for a long time, which meant that Poland was obviously going to be threatened in the future, that is, they were going to be next.

This is a repeat from 1938, where the Czechoslovakian military potential that could have subtracted the Germany potential, got added to them.

The remaining Czech rump state received no security guarantees or assistance from any great power, it had an enormous armaments sector that was completely intact, and was actually even beyond the range of the air forces of Germany's enemies. The parallel with Ukraine doesn't have legs to stand on in any of those aspects.

Panama violated those conditions.

?

Has anyone here seen the recent German documentary on Leni Riefenstahl?

As in 1914, they do what their friends do, they do what seems fun and adventurous, they do what society steers them toward lest they be a pussy.

Those boys weren't conscripted though, they were convinced to volunteer. Isn't that a crucial difference?

I had a vague notion that Norway was traditionally on rather cordial relations with the Soviets back then, so I assumed the same was the case in Sweden as well. It seems that it wasn't.

That's rather unexpected information, thanks.

Just no nitpick: was all that military aid delivered within the span of the Winter War, or during the Continuation War as well?

I think the glaringly obvious problem with this parallel is that Finland was already a neutral nation before the war started so the "forced neutrality" part wasn't that much of a thorn in their side; the government didn't display any inclination to join any military alliance and was not in any way hostile to the USSR, and was not helped during the war by any foreign country in any way. And it's not like any Ukrainian government is prone to accept Finnish-style neutrality either.

The Mongols did have armor, siege weapons and ranged weapons though.

It seems that sometime, somewhere society arrived at the unstated consensus that high schoolers and college students who perform low-wage jobs part-time or on a seasonal basis are the sort of people who grow up to do the same sort of jobs full-time.