@Botond173's banner p

Botond173


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

				

User ID: 473

Botond173


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 473

Last day, an homicide made by a men towards his girlfriend happened in Italy

Can you please briefly describe the context? I suspect it may be relevant here.

5 years ago an interview with air marshal Arthur Harris from 1978, originally created as additional learning material for Royal Air Force cadets, and of course restricted material as such, was made public, and interestingly he addresses this specific issue. His response basically was: as many deaths as militarily necessary, stemming from the main consideration that the French didn't fight well at all when they had to in 1940, so trying to spare their lives out of some sort of benevolent political consideration is foolish.

https://youtube.com/watch?v=UCWK-O7cKvc?si=mRrlXuHGzsl7brSo

(at the 31:45 mark, for example)

To give a concrete example, he did oppose proposals to carpet-bomb the town of Bordeaux, but only because he judged that such an attack would have zero military value.

And when you were a little child, you too were a burden, nothing more than a little shit machine, yet your parents elected to take it on instead of handing you over to CPS so the government could take it instead.

Or they handed you over to the kindergarten and then elementary school + after-school, which is basically the equivalent to the elderly being handed over to retirement homes. And this has been the social norm for many decades.

I'd argue that lockdowns, in the way they were designed and enforced, didn't even end up protecting the elderly.

You're describing those elderly that are still in good health, can still walk, have clear and intact minds etc. They aren't really relevant to this discussion. There's a large spectrum between being completely healthy and being on your deathbed.

It’s not that I disagree with that assumption. But the (supposedly severe) shortage of retirement home staff in the US surely isn’t affecting just the childless, the careless and the unserious, the unconcerned etc. The current social reality is atomization and geographical family dislocation/dissolution. We can decry it as degenerate and harmful etc., but it’ll still be the social reality for many people in the future. You can be a loving, responsible mother and grandmother, and still you’re likely to end up in a situation where your children and grandchildren are unable to look after you regularly even if they want to, for whatever reason.

I doubt the problems with elderly care are that much different between the US or South Korea / Japan.

You need to define what "worth a damn" means.

Not having to lie in bed for hours waiting for the Filipino nurse to come and wash you after soiling yourself. Not lying on the cold floor at an isolated part of the retirement home after accidentally tripping and falling, because nobody comes to help. Not going hungry all the time when you're so frail lying in bed that you cannot sit up and eat, because nobody helps out by feeding you. Not living in complete solitude and social isolation. I'm referring to this sort of stuff, just off the top of my head.

In last week’s thread there was extensive discussion on the retirement home employee shortage in the US. It made me ask myself: is it fair to say that elderly care in the US and Western countries in general is based on the unstated rule that you as a frail and elderly person pretty much only deserve to have a quality of life worth a damn if you have loving, caring children and grandchildren living nearby, visiting you regularly and looking after you if needed? That is, whatever system of care that is set up is not designed and should not be designed to basically prop you up and coddle you otherwise? It may sound cynical or too far-fetched to say it out loud, but looking at this issue from the outside, it’d explain many things. I imagine this is a general rule most Boomers also take as given, as they grew up in an age when childlessness and family dissolution/dislocation was much less normal than today.

It's a misunderstanding on my part then. I thought the original comment was about retirement home employees and hospital staff in general.

Can you elaborate please?

That's understandable, but whatever alternative will be available to you, or to most people in that situation, at that point will probably be even worse anyway.

Society has kicked families out of their homes

Phrasing it that way is a tad too extreme and simplistic, I'd say.

Anyway, one reason I find this news a bit strange is due to one argument I've heard from normies about this, namely that so many elderly have supposedly died from COVID in nursing homes that those've become less crowded than before. To be fair, it does sound like BS.

I'd add that the 2021-22 period was also one of uncertainty for many service sector workers because governments promised that restrictions will be eased soon, but nobody knew if this'll last, or there'll be a policy reversal due to a new panic once the data arrives about supposedly growing COVID rates and whatnot. I'd assume many people decided that they can't just sit around waiting for times to get better sometime in the future, and left the sector.

a lot of the hospitality industry laid off staff

But why would they do that? Genuine question.

Thanks for the link. It seems to show one of the BLM rallies regarding George Floyd's death, with an anti-police message in particular, with Lee's statue being of secondary importance. I have no doubt that many of such protests happened there, as the park around the statue is a convenient and symbolic location for something like that. But this was in 2020, and the public campaign to have the statue removed was in full swing by 2016. Who came up with the idea? Who organized the campaign, wrote articles and petitions etc.? I'm very sure it was mainly white liberals.

They don't value global peace, because they don't know a world before it.

Maybe I'm a bit tired right now but I have no idea what this is supposed to mean. I guess the 'global peace' means the post-1945 world (or maybe the post-1989 one, I don't know), but surely the countries of the Global South all existed before 1945 and have a long history (and memory) in general.

I missed this comment when it was posted. I looked at the replies, and there's a very obvious problem with your statement that seemingly nobody addressed so far, namely that it's overwhelmingly white liberals, not black people, who campaigned and protested to have the statue removed, who vandalized it and generated publicity for the cause, and eventually succeeded in completing the official removal. To the extent that blacks were involved in the entire process, they did so as hangers-on and enablers of said whites, and were at least underrepresented in the entire thing. This is my observation, you can correct me if I'm wrong.

Again, the name of the monument was not 'Monument to the Liberators of Soviet Latvia and Riga' or 'Monument to the Liberators of Soviet Latvia and Riga from dictatorial rule'. It was Monument to the Liberators of Soviet Latvia and Riga from the German Fascist Invaders. Context is important.

I am not sure I understand the analogy. I think it is bad when protestors kill people and understandable when governments take action they think will reduce the likelihood it occurs.

We're talking about completely different government actions. When faced with an officially permitted protest against the removal of Lee's statue where, which eventually resulted in one fatality (which I refuse to believe was first-degree murder, as it's obvious it's all a show trial) they respond by declaring an emergency, giving out instructions to the police that very obviously had the ulterior motive of enabling counterprotestors to carry out violent attacks and eventually provoke acts of self-defense that later may be used as fodder for show trials, and eventually performing a humiliation ritual akin to Chinese Red Guards back in the day, which I described above.

Compare this to BLM protests, which caused God knows how much material damage and something like 40+ deaths, and the government response is the exact opposite i.e. appeasement.

I'm going to argue that it was celebrating the military victory on Latvian soil over, you know, literal Nazis ("garbage humans", "deplorables" etc.), alien occupiers, aggressors, oppressors etc. It's not a monument, as far as I can tell, to the reannexation of Latvia, or to the establishing of Soviet military bases in Latvia i.e. "occupation", or to Russianness, a Russian empire, or to Stalin.

he commanded armies which killed tens of thousands of his fellow citizens

Well, yes. Armies kill people; that's what they do. But anyway, I stand by what I said: if a military officer does not get sentenced for treason even in a political situation such as that we are discussing here, I see no good argument to call him a traitor.

Thanks for compiling this list. A couple of things:

Yes, I'm aware that the obelisk in Riga was demolished. I posted about it here in fact, although that was a year ago. I'll only comment here that stating that it "celebrated occupation of this country by Russia" is evidence of ideological bias so severe I find it almost comical. No, it was not erected to celebrate "occupation" by "Russia". Let's be clear about that.

Also, it'd have been commendable on your part to add that all these decisions listed were made in the context of the Ukrainian war. It's not like that's not relevant here. This is a political context that has absolutely nothing in similar with the one in Charlottesville.

Excuse me but somehow I don’t feel compelled by an argument based on a grand jury indictment that is described as “forgotten legal and moral case” that “went missing for 72 years” (Huh? What even?). Considering a case where a general of a defeated army isn’t found guilty by any court on the victorious side of treason, or anything of the same magnitude for that matter, I’m prone to accept their judgment, or rather lack thereof, instead of that of modern-day Red Guards 150 years later who’re obviously all cocksure in their own ability to always know better.

But anyway, I get your point, or at least I think I do, but keeping in mind that accusing someone, even in his grave, of treason is serious business, especially if he was held in high regard by Churchill, Eisenhower, Wilson and so on (see the link above) so I think we ought to word such accusations accurately. What exactly did Lee betray? A constitution that is explicitly anti-racist and forbids slavery? Clearly not. A federal system that clearly forbids the secession of federal states in all cases? As far as I know, that’s not the case either – again, I understand that that Confederate states technically didn’t secede in a legal manner. A president who wanted to abolish slavery? No.

At the end of the day, what he did betray in full is a political code which holds that a military officer, when appointed and ordered, is to march his men into his own homeland and wreak destruction on it as if it was enemy territory.

And General Lee was never charged with, nor found guilty of, "treason", so that doesn't count either.