Two completely different historical contexts, those two are. To argue that those two are anything but completely different is indeed leftist revisionism in action.
Oh well. It seems there's indeed something new to learn everyday. But as a caveat, I'll say that the Prague monument appears to be so huge that explosives were the only suitable means of removal, and in the case of the Berlin monument, state secrecy appears to have been the most important consideration when deciding the means of removal i.e. the primary goal was simple removal, not destruction as such.
Again, this isn't about removing the statue.
Why should I even accept the premise that hereditarian, anti-egalitarian rule is uniquely bad and horrific?
They're melting it down for the purpose of creating some other art piece based on community input. At least, that's according to the proposal submitted by Jefferson School African American Heritage Center that the City Council accepted.
As far as I'm concerned, it'd be better to just throw all that metal in the ocean then.
Regarding your assessment of the Unite the Right rally, I find the notion ludicrous that public protests should be judged that way. How many deaths in total did BLM protests cause, for example?
Indeed, it's a humiliation ritual. Again, I cannot even name one statue of Stalin or Lenin that suffered the same fate.
The political issue with leaving the statue standing is that statues need regular cleaning and maintenance. The next thing you know, outraged leftists are posting photos all over social media of maintenance workers, many of them blacks, cleaning the feet of Lee and his horse under the instructions of the city government. That wouldn't go over too well.
I assure you that this will be followed by another act of teabagging, namely that some bougie black avantgarde artist will be paid big bucks by the city to use the melted-down iron to construct some hideous-looking crappy statue of some mythologized slave rebellion leader or some other black "hero".
I'm aware that it was a local decision, a product of a political milieu that, as far as I know, was one of the long-term consequences of a large and recent demographic shift in Northern Virginia, namely that a great number of white liberals have settled in the region after getting jobs in the enormously expanded federal bureaucracy in the capital.
I'm not surprised they don't want Lee around.
Regarding "myths", I'm not aware of any, I've only read that Lee was regarded as a true Southern gentleman his whole life. I don't see that as a myth.
I've read the discussion on the destruction of General Lee's statue in Charlottesville in last week's thread. I got the impression that many commenters here are prone to come up with explanations why the official removal of the statue was at least unsurprising or objectively justified from a culture war perspective, and I get that. But it seems they aren't focusing on the palpable difference between legally removing a statue and destroying it in a furnace. Because as far as I'm concerned, it's a big step from one to the other.
I'm reminded of the political transitions that happened in Central Europe in 1989-91, because many local monuments to either Soviet politicians/soldiers or local Communists or Marx/Engels were officially removed as a result. Anyone can correct me if they can, but I think all those new political systems were content with just removing the statues and putting them in "museums", which in most cases basically meant that these statues were put in open-air storage in remote and mostly abandoned memorial parks to just wither away, but not destroying them, cutting them up, melting them down etc. This hasn't even happened to Stalin statues in the Baltic states, for example, even though local anti-Soviet sentiment was definitely the strongest in the entire region, not something to understate. You can still find and visit those statues today.
And in this case, even this relatively close parallel doesn't really work, because it's not like there was a fundamental regime change in Virginia since the statue was erected.
And what happened to Lee's statue certainly cannot be explained by financial considerations either, as I'm sure that whatever arrangement that was on the table for putting it away as a museum piece was cheaper than melting it down in a furnace.
The only fitting parallel that comes to mind is Napoleon ordering captured cannons to be melted down to build a gigantic iron monument in Paris dedicated to the victory at Austerlitz. But again, I'm sure I won't have to explain in detail how that political context was completely different from this, even though I'm aware there are many hardline leftists today who would've preferred the evil Confederacy to be publicly humiliated in such ways back in 1865.
In the end, the only sufficient explanation I can come up with is that local authorities were afraid that Lee's statue, no matter where it were to be placed, was likely to become a site of pilgrimage for right-winger heretics opposed to the culture-warring leftist interpretation of race relations in the US, hence the statue's destruction.
Plus, and this is just pure speculation on my part, I think General Lee was such a perfect personification of the Southern patriarchal ideal of gentlemanliness that he invites leftist hostility like no other figure in US history. Plus, he had the cheek to candidly express views on slavery and the innate characteristics of Africans that are, from a leftist perspective, uniquely horrible, just too painful, and cutting too close to the bone, as they say.
No, because I don't have the habit of saving the URL of articles I read in a database in case someone asks me for the source on an online form 8 years later.
As far as i know, yes.
I remember that Trump brought up the rising violent crime rate as an issue during the campaign, and liberals were denying it out of hand. Earlier, in 2014 and 2015, I've seen articles on the issue, and there were people debating whether it can be indeed explained by the Ferguson effect or not.
That may very well be true. I'm talking about the national rate of violent crime.
Thanks for the detailed reply. Actually I did consider all that; that's what I was referring to when mentioning "cynical and mundane interpretations". No offense meant, but that's what they are.
I'll only nitpick on two issues. As far as I know, it's indeed true that 'in the last three years violent crime has surged upward in major cities', but this trend didn't start in 2020 (although it did escalate after that) but much earlier, before the Trump presidency, in fact, around 2012-15. And the same applies to the problems with the mentally ill homeless, I'm sure.
Regarding Western liberal narratives on the Gaza war, I’m noticing something I find somewhat odd. I see mainstream liberals arguing that clueless college students are indoctrinated by loony leftist propagandists to be rabid enemies of Israel, our greatest ally, the only democracy in the Middle East etc. And they seem to be saying this without any reflection on the past, where conservatives they hate, like Ben Shapiro and others, have been warning everyone of the same trend for basically two decades, at least since the early years of Bush Jr’s presidency. Now that the true extent of anti-Zionist agitation on Western college campuses is revealed on prime TV for the first time in almost a decade (the last major Israeli military operation in Gaza was in 2014, I reckon, not counting the mass shootings at the border in 2018 or so), targeted at a nation and a people they actually care about, suddenly it’s a real problem, a real concern to be tackled.
Now I understand that one can come up with all sorts of cynical and mundane interpretations as to why this is, how it’s unsurprising and so on, and I get that. But then I remember that there were violent anti-police protests in the summer of 2020, the campaign to remove Confederate monuments, the various protests against Trump’s rallies, and in these cases the tone of the protests were, as far as I can tell, pretty much set by the same leftist college agitators who initiate the current anti-Zionist protests, the ones who call themselves anticolonialists, social justice advocates, antiracists and so on. And the big difference was that they weren’t criticized by mainstream liberals the way they are now, even though all their agitation and messaging stems from the same ideological tenets.
On an off-topic note, the mention of Visual Investigations brings back memories to me. I remember finding that series on the NYT's Youtube channel a couple of years ago, and later watching a bunch of parts. I thought they were generally good, and the responses on YT were also generally favorable. But whenever they released a video on subjects deeply triggering to the Blue Tribe audience, like the Capitol "insurrection" and the Rittenhouse incident, it always ended up being obviously biased, and the responses on YT were accordingly dismissive and negative in usual.
The last part I've seen was the one on the Bucha Massacre, and while it seemed convincing and high-quality overall, I found it strange that 1. they identified an airborne unit as the perpetrators even though the overall mainstream consensus had been for months that a completely different unit was responsible 2. the entire argument of the video hinged on using one piece of supposedly captured Russian army document as evidence, which seemed suspect 3. they presented drone and CCTV footage as newly available sensational evidence, even though it was obvious that all that footage have been available to the Ukrainian authorities for almost a year at that point.
As far as I'm concerned, my view is that the Sexual Revolution was mainly driven by women, not men. It's not something I feel like discussing here in detail right now, but for now I will offer this as food for thought: I find it self-evident that men initiating casual/premarital/extramarital sex with women only becomes socially sanctioned behavior (within limits) if it becomes a socially accepted reality that at least a significant minority of women is down for something like that.
What does the average young woman in the modern West get out of having casual sex with strangers? Even from a purely secular, progressive, non-trad and non-religious perspective, what does she get out of it?
Hedonistic sex with an attractive man she otherwise wouldn't be able to have sex with? Just a wild guess. I get that women are mostly not interested in casual sex for its own sake, but I'm sure most/many of them prefer to live under social norms which at least provide that as an option.
The sexual revolution represented to some extent (as raggedy says) an offer from these older men to younger men of unlimited free pussy (and not just from docklands whores or slutty stage actresses or otherwise 'fallen women', but from all young women, or at least a much larger proportion), if they were willing to do what it took to get it.
I'd rephrase it thus: the promise of the Sexual Revolution to men was mostly that average men will get to have lots of fun sex, either casual or not-so-casual, with average women before marriage. That too turned out to be a lie, I think. I don't want to discuss that further here, because it's a subject for another discussion.
Again, I'm not a bit surprised that you haven't heard it from them - after all, 2rafa was describing unstated views. On my part, I've seen self-proclaimed progressives state such views, but only online.
Whatever the Sexual Revolution promised to men, I decided not to cover it, because I wanted to keep the comment somewhat concise, plus it's a big subject on its own, and because 2rafa was specifically discussing consequences for women, not men.
True, but that's not what I had in mind.
Religious traditionalists believe that the sexual degradation of young single women spiritually ruins them as prospective wives and mothers, which are their proper roles, plus it brings shame to their entire family, but especially their fathers and brothers.
Sex-negative feminists not only do not believe any of that, they are outraged by anyone even making such points.
Indeed. Very obviously they will not even address the Sexual Revolution, as such. They will pin the blame on the male sense of entitlement, toxic masculinity, consumerist pop culture etc. But that's not the point.

Do the people who decided on and supported the removal and destruction of Lee's statue adhere to something called the "American civic religion" as a supreme ideal?
Because I'm very sure they don't. In fact, pretty much the opposite of true.
Did the US exist under an un-American premise from her founding until 1865? Because that's what this entire argument entails. Which is rather nonsensical.
More options
Context Copy link