@Botond173's banner p

Botond173


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

				

User ID: 473

Botond173


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 06:37:06 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 473

Progressive women who come to hold this view usually don't do so until they're in their 30s, I assume, which is an important caveat here. With regard to progressive men, I'm sure the whole issue doesn't even occur to them unless they have younger sisters, or daughters.

I'll only add that religious conservatives and sex-negative feminists have rather different things in mind when they speak of the "degradation of women".

A week ago, in the context of a discussion on some NYT article, @2rafa commented that “there is an unstated (on the progressive side) premise among all people that casual sex is a bad deal for women and devalues or dishonors them in some way”. It generated a few replies but basically no further discussion, even though I’m sure it’s worthy of further discussion, and here’s why: as far as I’m aware, it’s certainly not the case that progressives had this attitude from the beginning of the Sexual Revolution, which is what the context is here. Obviously they used to have a different view in general, but sometime along the way, they changed their minds, because things turned sour, essentially.

Before continuing I think it’s important to qualify, as 2rafa also did, that other ideological groups also share this basic view, but the two main differences are that right-wingers tend to state this view openly, whereas progs are usually reluctant to do so, and that they do so on religious and moralistic grounds, whereas progs concentrate on women’s individual long-term interests, not on any other considerations.

So anyway, I said to myself: surely these people, being progressives, believe that the Sexual Revolution, while a laudable event, went haywire at some point, and didn’t bear the fruits it was supposed to. And I can tell that this is a relatively widespread view, because I can see it expressed in various online venues all the time, not just this forum.

What went wrong then? What did the Sexual Revolution basically promise to average progressive women, and why did that turn out to be a lie?

I’d argue that the more or less unstated promise of the Sexual Revolution to young single women was that: a) they will be sexually free without inviting social shame i.e. normalized sexual experimentation and promiscuity on their part will not have an unfavorable long-term effect on men’s attitudes towards them, and women will not sexually shame one another anymore b) they will be able to leave their constrictive gender roles to the extent they see fit, but this will not lead to social issues and anomie because men will be willing to fill those roles instead i.e. men will have no problem becoming stay-at-home dads, nurses, kindergarteners, doing housework etc.

And none of that turned out to be true.

Am I correct in this assessment?

Yes and yes.

The Ghosts of Tel Aviv they are, I suppose.

Letting Palestinian refugees in would in effect abet whatever Israeli aims there are to drive Arabs out of the West Bank and Gaza. I'm not sure the Egyptian or Jordanian regime would want to be seen as doing something like that.

I'd argue it's a favorable ethnic ratio, not resources, that Israel lacks to go full Xinjiang.

Regarding X/Twitter, as a dissident rightist I did a random thought experiment a couple of months ago but never posted in anywhere so far. It might be somewhat relevant here.

Let's suppose that whatever moderation policy X currently has is replaced basically by this:

  1. Any sort of political agitation, regardless of the party, movement, platform, umbrella organization, candidate, nominee, NGO etc. it is done on behalf of, or against, is banned.
  2. Any incitement towards political violence, or political use of the threat of violence as blackmail, is banned.
  3. Doxxing is banned.

How long would it take for X to be dismissed in mainstream discourse as a haven for Nazis? A couple of days?

That much is indeed true.

You're right.

Did progs always have that premise, or did it appear at one point? And why?

Wasn't that an ironic poem though?

Yes and yes, hence why I'd question conflating the two.

Yep. I find it somewhat strange that as (I suppose) a dedicated feminist she sees it as self-evident and unworthy of any criticism that the needy, scared etc. girl in question has a certain reputation, which is ruined if she is seen consenting to a sex act that is presumably a one-night stand at a house party, and that falsely accusing the fucker of rape is therefore a normal course of action to be expected of her. I only find this somewhat strange, but it's still strange.

I've actually come up with a name for this. I kinda had to because I'm seeing it more and more these days, and it's more aggressive than ever. I call it "Dark Femme". It's basically this mix of traditional and modern gender norms that always benefit one direction, and frankly, is often incoherent.

I've seen it beautifully summed up on the A Voice for Men website:

Feminists promote gender equality, as long as it benefits women. Anti-feminists promote gender inequality, as long as it benefits women.

How is the man supposed to carefully screen out "damaged" women though? Where is he supposed to gain that knowledge and experience? From whom and where?

Wasn't chaperoning a normal custom before the Sexual Revolution in the USA as well? At least among the upper classes, I assume.

People accused of Victim Blaming are often telling women not to dress in such and such a way, to go to such and such a place, to never drink to excess, to never trust a strange man, to never trust her boss, to never put herself in a position where a man might have leverage over her, at some point to never leave the house without male escort.

Except that this advice, no matter how well-intentioned, is entirely impractical in the context of the current mating marketplace where the usual course of action for many women is to compete with one another in pandering, or overtly promising to pander, to the sexual preferences of the top men. The sum of all this advice more or less amounts to telling women to voluntarily capitulate from the sexual rat race by avoiding any venue where sexually attractive men normally congregate and knowingly reducing her own attractiveness. It's no wonder that such advice is usually met with angry dismissal and obnoxious eye-rolling.

It seems that Moran is knowingly conflating three very different phenomena of the sexual marketplace. (Yeah, I just used that Manosphere phrase. For a good reason.) First of all, it’s true that there are many dads who will more or less advise their sons that “crazy bitches are always the best [fucks]”. But as someone who got this very advice, and has many male friends who claimed to ’ve gotten the same, I can say with certainty that this advice is normally given in the very specific context of assisting a hormonally charged teenage male virgin in order to experience memorable sexual pleasures in a way that leaves him with a positive view of women and sex so that he doesn’t turn into an “incel”.

Such advice stems from the assumption that this guy isn’t likely to gain such an experience from most of her female peers, because the average teenage girl will feel hesitant, scared and intimidated in that situation, and will just lie there like a dead fish or a log, just not being into the whole thing. The crazy bitch, on the other hand, will know how to give blowjobs and handjobs, take the initiative, be familiar with sex positions other than the missionary etc. Any girl with such an attitude will usually be considered a “crazy bitch” if the normal assumption is that women don’t experience sexual desire in the same way men do, and will not usually seek out casual sex for the sake of casual sex.

Now, it’s also true that “don’t stick your dick in crazy” is also an advice that is routinely given to young single men (Moran seems to allude to this being sound advice, but doesn’t use the exact phrase). In fact, I’m sure if you turned to 10 of the dads who used to suggest to their teenage sons to seek out crazy bitches 10-15 years later and asked them whether it’s a good idea to stick your dick in crazy, 9 of them would agree. This probably seems like a contradiction but it isn’t because the two pieces of advice are given in very different social contexts. As far as I can tell, the advice “don’t stick your dick in crazy” basically means “don’t make a move on some skanky-looking woman who obviously seems to be mentally inbalanced just because you think she’ll be a) good in the sack b) OK with casual sex”.

With regard to the spectre of needy, scared, insecure wallflower girls getting preyed upon at house parties by predatory men for a quick pump & dump, I don’t see how that has anything to do with any of this, and I think even objectively sexist men will mostly look at this as sleazy and cringe. Was there ever a society where such dishonest and manipulative behavior was condoned? I doubt it.

Anyway, the quoted part raises a couple of questions. Why does Moran seemingly equate being needy and drunk with being mentally ill? Why does she assume that anyone initiating sex with a drunk and “needy” girl does so with the manipulative aim of a pump & dump? What if the man is also drunk and needy? Why does she assume that such a girl will necessarily find the sex act hurtful and regrettable afterwards?

True, but I think it's important to try clarifying why that is. They could have the vocabulary for that only if they were willing to be flexible enough ideologically to say that women, unlike men, aren't prone to engage in sex for the sake of sex itself, but normally engage in sex as an act of exchange, basically.

In online media, they keep referring to her only as "German", which I think isn't entirely a coincidence. One article I've found about this but am too lazy to dig up right now did mention after multiple paragraphs that not only is she in fact a dual German-Israeli citizen but had in fact lived in Israel for 6 years. Some X post also claimed she's actually an IDF reservist, but I'm not sure.

But there are numerous historical examples of sovereign states abolishing slavery as well. Brazil too, for example.

Not enough cash-crop/resource value in the land?

Yes.

You left out the word "it" from the quote. I didn't say the state in question was dismantled, I said that slavery as an institution was dismantled/ended throughout peaceful steps everywhere in the world but the US. Whether that involved decolonization or not isn't relevant to that main point.

Wait a minute. Most of the "sparsely-populated, effectively undefended land" in the US is prairie, mountains, deserts etc., which is all unsuited for chattel slavery. On a different note, Brazil also has enormous quantities of sparsely-populated, effectively undefended land as well, and much more African slaves were trafficked there than to North America, and yet slavery ended there peacefully.

I understand that we can make all sorts of arguments on how US history could have turned out much worse this particular way or that particular way. But I think the important point to make in this context is that hundreds of thousands of war dead could have been spared.