Actually, yes (and liberals etc.)...with the caveat that if they discriminate against conservatives they would not get government funding. Today's colleges may already fit this criteria, but I think it would be easier to negotiate with at least some of them (better than Trump; not getting rid of liberal-biased groups, but ensuring conservative-biased ones get equal treatment).
Should the government fund sports teams that discriminate or do not discriminate against trans girls? I think they should either way, and the difference is practical. I don't think it's as obvious whether discriminating (or not discriminating) against girls is as unjustified as discriminating against conservatives.
Alternatively, a more consistent policy: the government only funds states, who can fund whatever they want, and ensures people have freedom and ease of movement between them.
Introducing AlphaProof Code: a breakthrough in verifying complex software at depth
Today, we’re sharing a milestone in software security long considered to be a grand challenge: Google DeepMind researchers guided AI agents to mathematically prove key security properties of the actual code underlying the Signal protocol, the technology that protects billions of private conversations in apps like Signal and Google Messages.
Frontier LLMs are already finding and patching exploits before the public ones reach their capabilities. But what if they miss one that a future second-rate LLM finds? That’s becoming less likely, because LLMs are also greatly advancing formal methods, which can almost prove a program unhackable: technically only specific “key security properties”, and some unauthorized methods of entry will always remain (the $5 wrench and unknown unknowns), but formal methods would prevent most serious past vulnerabilities like Log4J (prevented by first-class capabilities) and memory errors (compare the amount in Rust to C or C++). We used to have infrequent exploits before LLMs, and formally verified servers may make exploits at least infrequent again.
Yeah, on further review, I agree having women playing sports regulating their own leagues is better, or at least their parents. The votes would also be anonymous, meaning only an entire region voting against trans women could be punished, which is harder and less accepted by general society.
Peer pressure is always inevitable, but I think here it works in the girls’ favor: the symbolic act of implementing “girls in sports should be voting on their own issues” changes people’s thinking, the difficulty of punishing them without targeting an entire region (including men, or will the punishment be misogynistic?), the inevitable seeking and getting explanations for the outcome (maybe anonymous)…I believe it would actually shift cultural perception to accepting that trans women should not be in women’s sports, vaguely similar to how they became widely accepted in the first place (or if women’s sports teams vote to allow trans women, it will persuade conservatives).
I still believe that happens not from people enjoying things consensually in their own home; schools are not homes, and the state taking your kids away is the same state that would control what people do in their homes, making the situation at least not better.
Moreover, I think the public shift towards liberalism then woke wasn’t causal. My understanding is that society became more liberal after WWII, and defended against rightist free-expression takeovers, but did not defend against a leftist free-expression takeover because it had never experienced one. So the solution is not to give up free-expression, but understand that it is separate from woke leftism, anticipate and defend against it.
The state championship should be decided by the state. But Seattle can have local leagues with trans girls, but they are excluded from state games; or not participate at all in state games, so the best competitive athletes move away (unless a majority of women in the state approves them, then it must not be an issue).
The voters for this policy could be further refined to “women who played in high school sports”, or even let the girls on the sports teams vote.
Let women decide. If girls are OK with trans girls in their sports, no issue. If girls aren’t OK with trans girls in their sports, worst case they will grow up and outvote them, more likely they will convince their mom and grandmom to outvote them.
Also, regional leagues should be decided by the respective region (i.e. locally), because I assume women in red cultures want to block trans girls and women in blue cultures allow them.
Any issues with that?
I think votes should be kept as-is, except fix "controversial" sorting (near-term), and put the controversial value next to the real vote count (long-term, speculative).
The current ranking prioritizes a post with 1 upvote and 1 downvote over one with 10 upvotes and 9 downvotes, or 99 upvotes and 10 downvotes.
controversial = (min(upvotes, downvotes)^2 + 1) / (max(upvotes, downvotes) + 1)
prioritizes the second, which I think makes more sense. With ^2, 99 upvotes overtakes the second with ~28 downvotes, which I think is ideal (graph). (Derived from this, which prioritizes the first.)
Why would we even have feudalism when the value of labor would also be low due to robotics?
We could just have less people, very optimistically, because most of those living in the AI transition stop having kids.
I think I agree with what you’re saying.
Fascism does tend to lead to collapse. Honestly, the main reason I think I dislike it is because it tends to act against my interests, since I’m an outcast: I think it’s very unlikely that anyone in power understands let alone cares about them, and I struggle to conform. But I don’t think I’m really an outlier, even in being an outcast; even if fascism adopts the median viewpoint, by only permitting a narrow set of behaviors, it only lets thrive a narrow set of the population.
Furthermore, with today’s mass surveillance technology and centralization, I think authoritarianism in general is too much power for any small (human) group. If a village had a dictator, it would be better at least, because it would be easier to leave or meaningfully challenge or overthrow them. Meanwhile, a dictator of millions or billions cannot keep track of even a small fraction of their citizens: they need autonomous layers, which introduce corruption and incompetence (one good dictator is hard to find, many…), or their citizens will literally starve waiting for instructions or corrections to obvious-at-ground-level problems.
Personally, I'll accept a fake job if and only if I can put in fake hours.
Right now, I think we should pivot to becoming artists, curators, athletes, piano players, researchers, etc. Status would be external popularity or internal achievement. Incentive would be that that you'll be shamed and bothered if you fall into a rut, at least unless you're an intrinsic stoner; maybe they are the people who don't respond to internal or external shame, so it works out. Transitioning to UBI would work by: people in the aforementioned "failed careers" initially manage a livable-but-basic lifestyle like starving artists, then gradually afford more luxuries, while rich people's incomes gradually revert to median by inflation, and/or the extras they can afford become more luxury and less essential (like decent healthcare or a safe neighborhood).
Furthermore, I think that's feasible.Who would object? And rich people who want to coerce the world into a worse dystopia must handle backstabbers, the AI becoming misaligned especially towards their children...I think it's easier.
But I say "right now" because I'm sure later there's a better solution. Ironically, finding it is another viable career, unlikely to be fully automated.
I agree there are no truly private actions. If something is truly sealed off from the world, we can't claim whether it did or did not happen.
But in practice, often I see people argue to regulate something that does not concern them (or anyone non-consensually) except in some plausible butterfly-effect scenario. For example, "this group cannot act in private because they will coordinate to take control of the public sphere and oppress other private groups". The problem is that any such regulation also has a plausible effect: the regulators themselves using whatever instruments were given to them to monitor and suppress others' private lives, to shape the public sphere more than necessary, even inadvertently by mis-targeting "suspicious" groups that were not plotting a coup. I just feel it's more "correct" and "natural" to intervene only when something creates a probable issue, and minimally; so we remain closer to anarchy than totalitarianism, although we try to reach some "center" where people have as much freedom as possible without infringing on others (by some widely-accepted metric).
Or a weaker, more specific scenario to this discussion: fascists wanting to regulate others' sex lives to protect and advance the nation. Some will claim, what's the point of "advancing" a nation without sex? And the actions that fascists take to protect their nation may cause it to collapse from internal revolt or demotivation.
Not all nosy societies are fascist, but every widely-accepted definition of fascism requires strict control over the individual's private life ("for the best interests of the nation"; and other details, like hierarchy and nationalism). A dictatorship that mandates strict public order and national pride, but allows citizens a decent amount of private time to live how they want, is not fascist (and close to Singapore).
Even though it's not yet fascist, I think it's fair to compare the UK with 1984: they've got key (bad) details, obsessive mass surveillance and "fun police".
I think cartoon depictions of CSAM should be allowed, and in practice they are in most places (has anyone in the US been arrested for it?) It’s actually important, because otherwise people may not recognize or expect real child abuse, which will happen regardless of depictions, and which stopping is the #1 priority (I’m reminded of the trope where a child is abused, and everyone shuns them and pretends abuse is not happening, because “decorum”). If anyone thinks it’s wrong, but gruesome cartoon violence and adult sex are OK, they should explain the difference.
But allowing realistic AI-generated CSAM effectively allows human CSAM, since it’s impossible to distinguish, and “innocent before proven guilty”. Plus, every big LLM is probably unintentionally trained on some CSAM, which won’t manifest in an unrelated photo but will when asked for. I don’t advocate banning local LLMs or client-side-scanning (just like we shouldn’t install government cameras in every house to prevent real child abuse…too much second-order effects), but I think real CSAM is immoral in a way that any fiction isn’t, and openly allowing realistic CSAM would have terrible second-order effects.
CSAM is unique such that restricting it is much easier and more justified: it's by definition non-consensual (IMO most important), shunned by nearly everyone, and provokes a visceral reaction in parents. "Face-sitting" and BDSM, though embarrassing and shunned by most of society, has none of these.
I would be shocked to see a pro-CSAM protest (and expect they would get beaten by counter-protestors), but there have already been two face-sitting protests in the UK for prior laws, whose public reception (even in the UK) was mostly amusement and encouragement. If someone is actually put on the registry for such a crime, I expect to see news articles defending them (the news prioritizing salaciousness over importance ironically helps here, and countries like Ireland and France can sell it as "look how much better we are than the UK"). I also doubt the law will be repealed soon, but the consequences and chances of it spreading will be far less.
Others have pointed out, so I was wrong to say that fascists are prudes.
But they still restrict what people do consensually in their private intimate lives, which seems very wrong to me. Why should anyone else care?
I still think we should disable Motte federation with mainstream Lemmy, at least because I'm sure they will get mad and immediately block us. But if there are more tolerant Lemmy (or Mastodon) instances, we can whitelist them.
I doubt the Motte or any spinoffs will grow that popular (sorry Zorba). Although even if they combined gained 10x as many posts and comments, that would still be niche, but more feasible.
Basically, I think federation is a middle ground between subreddits (which I echo others in thinking is a bad idea) and completely separate instances (which is OK, but loses the benefits of subreddits, like cross-community interaction and separate profiles under the same account): I think federation gives back most of these benefits without downsides, like brigading and central point of failure.
A problem in Reddit is brigading: members of other communities interfering one they don’t like. A more general form of brigading is when a subreddit reaches the frontpage, then average Redditors discover it, and inadvertently brigade it by making average-Redditor posts and comments.
I have not seen a single Reddit sub that hasn’t been destroyed this way, except for niche interests and local communities. And I hear stories of even those being infected with people outside the interest or the community.
This makes me hesitant to suggest federation, especially with the more radical Lemmy instances. I think we should, at least initially, only federate with Motte-platform and whitelisted communities. But in federation it’s easier than subreddits to distinguish and block outside servers: if a community is obnoxious and we block them and remove their users’ “contributions”, now they must make an account here and get past the spam filter…which is possible, but it’s a higher barrier at least good enough to filter “average Redditor” types.
In George Orwell's 1984, a key theme is sexuality in opposition to fascism. In real life, every fascist society is puritan regarding sex (exceptions?), because it's in the definition: fascism is nosiness, interfering with the citizen's private lives, even the most intimate. Fascists at best don't care about others' intimacy, at worst they have a control fetish. Why should anyone care about what degenerates do, consensually, apart from them?
In Project 2025, one of the most notable goals is banning pornography, along with other police state measures. Who knew it was actually a blueprint for the UK?
Meanwhile, I'm sure this will be selectively enforced (Andrew would still be a prince if he was merely caught with fake step-sister porn), and waste resources as prison cells get filled with "dangerous" (/s) screen-watchers. The UK could instead work on improving its economy, promoting national pride, or actually protecting women and children*.
* I support preventing children from watching degenerate porn, and only oppose most age-verification laws because of their privacy-violating yet ineffective implementation. UK lawmakers are probably aware that some children will see porn from their adults' screen...but should be aware that some children will see their parents having sex, and the correct course of action is obviously not to ban sex, but threaten such parents with neglect.
I suggest federation. The Motte basically stays as-is, except users here can crosspost to and comment on other instances of the Motte’s infrastructure, and vice versa, with some support for Lemmy and Mastodon (I think the Motte should stay a bit different than Lemmy, IME this site is more user-friendly). Zorba keeps running the Motte, but also starts a couple other instances for hobbies, and maybe others run their own instances for whatever niches this site is lacking (a philosophy-focused Motte? Hacker News 2.0?)
Although, other instances overlapping with parts of the Motte threatens to split the community into nothingness, hence crossposting and commenting should be practically seamless; and I would be careful introducing ones that aren’t very disjoint (like hobby or finance…we have Tinker Tuesday and Spending Saturday but they’re barely active).
(EDIT: and I don’t think subreddits should exist, at least yet; because I expect these instances will be so small, everything in the same feed would not be an issue, and attract more discussion from people in one interest glancing at another (like the Motte).)
Replace reddit.com with ueddit.com, or (for less wait) a specific redlib instance.
And x.com with xnotme.com or (for less wait) a specific shitter instance.
He's more than that.
I'm not aware of him hating Jews except not wanting to fund Israel or otherwise intervene in the middle east. And I expect that even if he's elected, Israel will keep getting funded and nothing major will come out of Epstein (like Trump). But he may actually manage to shrink the government, or at least improve the economy, and do less culture war.
Meanwhile, I don't expect the D candidate to be pro-Israel (at least publicly, but I'm also judging Massie by his public opinions). Look at their base: according to Pew, 16% have a "favorable" view of Israel's government.
My understanding is he's a "libertarian Republican", maybe more libertarian. Highlights from Wikipedia:
- Opposes domestic surveillance, civil asset forfeiture, government opacity [this is where I support him most]
- "America first": wants to basically end all foreign involvement (Israel, Ukraine, etc.), votes against any resolution for foreigners, even the "Hong Kong Human Rights and Democracy Act" and a resolution mourning Turkey-Syria earthquake victims
- Immigration views are mixed, just see Wikipedia's section
- Wants to reduce the deficit, voted against the BBB because of it
- Doesn't believe in climate change
- Frequently mocks Trump and other Republicans for not releasing the Epstein files (and in general)
- Believes in IP ("the one area I'm not a libertarian")
I don't agree with all (or most) of these. But he seems to actually have principles at least compared to other politicians, and importantly, these principles move the US towards libertarianism away from authoritarianism. So I support him more than any other big name (so far).
Kamala, on the other hand, I have no idea what her actual views are if she has any. But I don't get the impression she'd shrink the government, nor oppose UK-esque surveillance and censorship.
How do other commenters feel about Thomas Massie?
Apparently he's running for 2028 president with VP Joe Kent. I think he'd win, and depending on who the D's run (e.g. Kamala Harris) I would vote for him. But I expect like most politicians, he has a clean-shaven image, but disagreeable policies I'm not aware of.
- Prev
- Next

Smart contracts, homomorphic encryption, etc. can restrict humans with access to the system, allowing them necessary tasks (like customer support) while limiting how much they can break and how quickly.
More options
Context Copy link