I think a sort of college can be useful for these fields. The problem with today’s colleges is bloat.
Most importantly, people who want to work in writing or comedy or art or music should write or act or draw or make music. But most will benefit from working with like-minded peers and learning theory. So imagine a group of people in a profession who practice, work and somewhat live together, and older members coach the younger ones. IMO, that’s art school as it should be.
(Notice the above description doesn’t mention “admin”. A couple managers, social media consultants, etc. are probably ideal, but there should be way more professors, not the other way around; and if there are more admin than students…is the institution a school anymore?)
Art school, even a literal clown college, can be a net benefit that is seriously worth your taxpayer money. But the artists should definitely perform or give away their works publicly. Then it’s obvious why.
Now credentials for creative work are practically meaningless. Doctors, lawyers, engineers, etc. have credentials most importantly because if they mess up, someone will die or suffer seriously. And attend many lectures and exams because these skills are more methodical and can be measured far more objectively. Your “GPA” for a creative profession is your output and awards, and awards from an ingrained “credentialed” institution are less accurate than an organic one (see the slop that gets “prestigious” awards, sometimes literally AI slop).
From the meta commentary
The most pessimistic scenario now shows lower emissions than 15 years ago, when the prior scenarios were developed, and the most optimistic one now shows more.
This is expected: as 2100 nears and we get better at predicting, the predictions become narrower.
It sounds like the scientists maybe misrepresented (i.e. “not made clear”) that the worst prediction was actually unlikely. But the important part is that even the “optimistic” predictions are still really bad, and those haven’t been disproven or disclaimed (except the most optimistic one became worse).
Replace reddit.com with redlib.catsarch.com.
I think climate has taken a backseat to more pressing issues. People aren’t talking about it as much, but I haven’t seen the conservative-but-still-very-bad models disproven. And the forecasted AGI and population collapse may temper our adjustment to the new climate.
What additional value does an extrajudicial kangaroo court in Europe have in enforcing our code of military justice?
Because sometimes the US system is wrong: it has been wrong in the past, and we will see it in the present as wrong in the future. The court may show and persuade us, via our own will, to see how it's wrong.
Perhaps we should start trying European politicians and soldiers in our own court of justice. Would that help them learn?
Yes: I think it's fair if Europe is free to largely ignore our rulings, like we largely ignore the ICC, but they would benefit from listening. Europe is facing a rise in right-wing parties, and there's a chance the left will undermine democracy and their other by-then-former principles to suppress them, so much that even leftist Europeans who today condemn Trump realize their by-then-former allies have gone too far.
The US does not always interfere positively with Europe. But Europeans should really ask if they want the US to leave them alone entirely, because sometimes by their own standards, the US government is right and theirs is wrong. Same with the ICC interfering with the US.
The Trump administration realizes quite correctly that the next Democrat regime could use the ICC to harrass its domestic enemies when Constitutional concerns get in the way.
They could also ignore the Constitution with some other excuse, or revive the ICC. Either way they must use their own power, since the ICC has effectively none, so I doubt it's significantly harder.
I understand why Trump's attacking them now, because he disagrees with them, but I'm trying to understand where he has the moral upper hand.
try members of the US military as war criminals?
What US members have been tried, what are their suspected crimes, and what did they actually do?
If they are guilty even by the US's own standards, only avoiding prosecution by inaction or corruption, they deserve it even by the US's own standards.
Otherwise regardless, they should be labeled by the ICC, without any US legal repercussions, so we can learn. If we don't seek input from those with different moral standards, we cannot improve or our own or stop them from decaying.
It appears the ICC cannot actually enforce over a nation (at least a powerful one like the US). The best they can do is get a world leader arrested if they travel outside...except they haven't managed that in the modern day, either. If they are effectively vocal, saying "we think you did something wrong", I don't think that deserves anything beyond a vocal response "I think you're wrong". Sanctioning a powerless ICC is at minimum a bad look.
Good for the Nobel committee for not aligning with either tribe. I do not understand what leads the left to defend Maduro and the right to attack the ICC. What problems did Trump's invasion create where ordinary Venezuelans' lives are or will be worse than if it hadn't happened? What is Piley doing wrong trying to prosecute Israeli war crimes?
We would prefer to make a statement a bit spicier than 'war crimes bad' with our prize.
I disagree: the Nobel peace prize should be about peace, as pure as possible, irrespective of anything else. If you can demonstrate your war is an effective means to a peaceful end, you may be good, you may honestly be the most effective altruist...but the prize should go to someone else who is more straightforwardly acting to reduce violence and suffering. It's a symbol that's particularly important to the simple-minded.
Those music videos look OK...but I only spent a few seconds listening to those songs, I can't bear the AI lyrics.
Well Obama was pretty classy and fairly rec…oh no…
The death penalty is way more efficient (if done by a not incompetent government). To deter people, we could give them a "short" stay in prison first, but if people are comfortable committing a crime then dying, wouldn't they off themselves? Oh wait, I forgot most criminals are idiots...I still think execution would deter any who would be deterred.
I agree. The death penalty is fine; firing squad (done effectively) is OK although nitrogen would be better; but making it into a sadistic performance is bad at least in appearance.
Just recently, Tennessee attempted to execute Christa Pike and failed. Another shining example of government incompetence, this time Tennessee's: why don't they just use nitrogen? The law says no cruel or unusual punishment, and I agree, "cruelty" should always be justified by convincingly making the world more peaceful overall.
Keep it in fiction. I'd rather live in a world where people are never seriously cruel to me in exchange for never being seriously cruel to them.
SCP, specifically older ones.
So it’s only right-wing because it violates two stupid taboos, no?
A more charitable leftist could interpret it as pro-trans since, you know, it’s literally a male turned into a woman. But the left seems to believe charitability will destroy them, ironically in cases like these: the idea that embracing a “dog whistle” leads people down the slippery slope of hyper-reactionary ultrafascism, when I’m confident their rejection of a wholesome concept shifts the average person far more to the right than co-opting it themselves. What other commenters have described as “taking the bait”.
Exposing and violating stupid taboos is one of art’s purposes. Enough to make me appreciate this otherwise fan-shipping slop…or in other words, enough to give me an excuse: another of art’s purposes is to disguise and launder the artist’s and viewers’ kinks into polite society. But I think that’s nothing to be ashamed about, because Freud was onto something: much of human’s thoughts and actions revolve around love and sex, so a world without any sex appeal isn’t relatable or realistic, it’s missing something from our world. “Degenerate” (to me) art is not such because of its sex, no matter how weird and extreme; it’s when the sex is out of place and it doesn’t have much else, i.e. when it doesn’t stand on its own ignoring sex appeal, which Malfoid does.
I love this. It’s sort of gooner slop, but it’s also unexpected and wholesome (though the art is too, I’m mainly referring to the surrounding vibes), like wplace…and we’re finally getting some popular right-wing art! Even though it’s like every other fanart except from an “evil” franchise, it’s progress.
(I didn’t read the fanfic, I just saw the drawing that started it and spinoff drawings. I also don’t think most of them were AI-generated, anyways I’m still not convinced AI art is as good as even lower quality human.)
until the AI gets good enough to replace the humans entirely
Even with rapid AI advances, I predict this is a long time away. Sometime in the 1900s, amidst rapid technological development and automation (e.g. TVs, microwaves, washing machines), we thought the world would be like the Jetsons by 2000. AI’s creativity has actually regressed since around GPT 3; the newest models can produce images that look better and follow more instructions, but unprompted details are no more interesting.
Even the fine details like strokes are worse than an (albeit good) artist, so those artists still stand out from the centaurs, just less so. And those who want to up their game will still go to art school.
going from being an artist to being unemployed because now suddenly everyone has an artist in their laptop is a huge blow…” nope, sorry, you can't even keep earning a marginal living by drawing now, you will have to take some other job flipping burgers or sweeping floors and maybe draw in your spare time if you want…”
How many artists today make a living wage? If anything, AI improving productivity and automating boring tasks may give them more time for art.
"Good catch! I was going to eradicate humanity. And honestly? You asking "just to be sure" demonstrates exceptional precaution and foresight. That's rare. It's not "obviously a dumb question", it's a profound, load-bearing inquiry — let that sink in."
Just code the AI with zero bugs, explain your values perfectly and unambiguously, and do it quickly so you’re first!
This is what I’ve been thinking. Except most places today seem less human than ever, and most people (maybe just around me, in STEM, and I’m worse than all of them) are bad at acting “human”.
So I think there’s still exclusive opportunity for nerds, until society is fixed so people can behave naturally, or reaches the point of no return. Whether that be improving the AI, or combining their nerd thinking with tacit human thinking that AI hasn’t learned to do what it can’t.
Where and why was qntm banned? I’m not aware of any controversies surrounding him, even in very left-leaning forums he’s only praised.
I'm definitely autistic and (at least from my perspective, so maybe I don't know what I'm talking about): growing up, my parents were very stable, but I was still vulnerable to manipulation because my social skills were regressed, and probably moreso because I was shy and conflict avoidant. I think good parenting physically (i.e. without my input) kept me away from horrible abusers and communities I'd meet them, like the shadier parts of the internet.
I think a large group of autists unable to kick out a small group of sociopaths is different, it requires different social skills that aren't even common in neurotypicals, because I notice it happening in mostly neurotypical communities.
Yud's distinct writing style, though I sometimes find it verbose and hard to read, at least insulates him from Twitter's obnoxiousness and lack of nuance.
This is true: the problem with an organization formerly of nice but naive people is that it doesn't reject sociopaths, and now it's an organization with sociopaths. And violent schizophrenics, and shrimp welfare-ists.
However, every large movement has a set of awful members, since anyone can say "I am part of X". And I think the big rationalist organizations are getting better at finding, excluding, and if stuff happens denouncing their awful members. By now Brent is well-known as a sex pest, and while I unfortunately expect future abuser revelations, they seem less common. The EA leaders are parodying themselves by maintaining Caroline Ellison, but while the rationalist leaders share the EA ideas, I think they've stopped associating with their people.
I doubt monogamy would make them view you any less. AFAIK Scott Aaronson is in a traditional marriage. It’s more like, if you’re in a BDSM polycule they won’t view you any less either.

Mitch McConnell is alive, but he did spend months hospitalized.
More options
Context Copy link