Capital_Room
rather dementor-like
Disabled Alaskan Monarchist doomer
User ID: 2666
Outlining the story as was passed on to me by a family member, there was a recent case here in Alaska where there was a proposal to create a paved road connecting one of the rural villages to the broader highway system (such as it is). Well, some of the opponents of the proposal looked at the plan for how the road would pass through the village, found the name of the person who owns the property at the proposed endpoint, and then started arguing about 'why is the state proposing to spend millions of dollars to build a road to [name]'s house?'
Is there a name for this sort of argument? I mean, setting aside the whole 'ignoring everyone else who would benefit from the road in favor of focusing on the endpoint,' there's the fact that any proposed road would wind up ending at some person's property*. If not this guy, it would be some other guy… but then they'd just ask 'why is the state proposing to spend millions of dollars to build a road to [other guy's name]'s house?' instead. It's a sort of fully-generalizable argument disguised as a specific criticism.
*Unless you spend money building a segment out past where anybody lives into empty wilderness; in which case the opponents would instead be (rightly) asking why you're wasting money on a stretch of pavement that nobody is likely to ever much use.
Men outlive women by default
I thought it was the opposite: "Around the Globe, Women Outlive Men":
Women outlive men in almost every society. In more developed countries, the average life expectancy at birth is 79 years for women, 72 years for men. In less developed countries, where high maternal mortality reduces the difference in longevity, women can expect to live an average of 66 years, compared with 63 years for men.
Is there a term for the division of broad social/political views, going back to Plato vs. Aristotle, between “top-down” design and “bottom-up” evolution? Plato’s Politeía (“Republic”) tends to the prescriptive, focusing on designing a utopian ideal city-state from first principles, while Aristotle’s Politiká (“Politics”) is rather more descriptive, and views communities as growing out of humans’ social nature. The former view includes James C. Scott’s “high modernism” and his examples in Seeing Like a State. (It’s also the sort of thing that contributes to stuff like the Tanganyika groundnut scheme.)
It also seems to relate to a kind of view I like to describe as “creationist-adjacent”, in that it holds that unguided “evolutionary” processes are by nature so “crude,” “clumsy,” “random,” et cetera that their products are never anywhere near the trade-off frontier, and further, that a moderately competent intelligent designer is guaranteed to produce something far superior with only moderate effort. For one stark example, the idea that free-market competition and selection forces on firms, greed-driven and chaotic, can only give rise to an economy so inefficient that a few Marxist central planners would quite obviously be able to intelligently design a vastly superior and more productive economy from the top-down.
(Some of the people I’ve encountered with radically optimistic expectations of what human genetic engineering will achieve in the next few decades seem to me to derive those expectations from a similar view.)
In case you can’t tell, I’m with Aristotle on this one. Indeed, that’s one of the main reasons for asking: is there a good term for my position, opposing “high modernism” and “top-down” central planning (particularly of the “one-size-fits-all” variety), in favor of local, “bottom-up” evolved systems?
What exactly are you going to trade with those superior trade relations if not your own lives?
Exactly. There's a difference between the "on-paper" wealth that underlies the "America's economy is mostly Blue coastal cities" and actual material goods and production. But people like the guy who made this argument don't get that.
I bring this up as an example of the Blue Tribe's utter hostility to Red, that they'll openly show how much thought they put into scenarios of smugly enacting "flyover genocide."
It's not that I think something like this would work… but I wouldn't put it past them to try anyway.
to stoke up outrage over "those darn fascists trying to smear our guys with... stuff they really did..."
There's a reason that the term "malinformation" has been increasingly added alongside "misinformation" and "disinformation."
Then nothing will happen. Red Tribe is a paper tiger. Those in the military will obey their Blue Tribe masters, the others who can do organized violence are wholly infiltrated by the FBI, and the mobs will be easily beaten (partially by their own bretheren in red-staffed but blue-controlled police and military forces). That's the lesson of January 6.
I'm glad to see I'm not the only one who recognizes this.
supported by boots-on-the-ground
to commit ground forces to regime change operations
You seem to assume that the CIA actually wants this — that it is them, rather than politicians or the military, pushing for "boots on the ground."
I believe it was Jim Donald who, in speaking of rivalry between the State Department and the Defense Department, coined the phrases "blue empire of the consulates" and "red empire of the bases." He is far from alone in arguing that for Foggy Bottom, the foreign "enemy," — Al Qaeda, Saddam, the Taliban — is not the outgroup, but a fargroup, and their actual outgroup is the Pentagon. And now, I consider the connection between spies working overseas and embassies — how often the latter host and provide "diplomatic cover" for the former, and such. Thus, is it really inconceivable, then, that college-educated Langley boys might tend to prefer Foggy Bottom over the Pentagon, and thus not really want a bunch of uniformed rednecks trampling all over "their turf"? Particularly when, for the more military-friendly would-be spooks, there's the DIA to join instead of the CIA. That could add some selection effects into the mix as well.
(And now I'm reminded — yes, yes, fictional evidence — of multiple movies where the protagonists are some flavor of military special operations or such, and the villain is some shady CIA spook trying to screw them over for his own ends.)
The CIA prioritized the humiliation of Bush and Cheney, and the wider coalition effort,
I'm saying take this, and add the DoD on there as another target.
You've got to remember, post-2020-election the Republican machine did not declare "stolen election, government illegitimate".
Of course not; that would not be keeping in their role as the Outer Party; the Washington Generals to the Democrats' Globetrotters. It would threaten their cushy jobs and ongoing access to the proverbial gravy train.
if the Republican machine as a whole flips into "rebellion" mode
As the Spartan ephors said to Philip II, "if." I don't think they will, because enough of the long time party establishment are, to use wrestling terminology, jobbers. They're paid to make a show of opposition, to maintain "kayfabe," and then lose. And they likely know it. It doesn't matter how blatant any future "steal" is, they know their continued access wealthy donors, personal influence, and those famous "DC cocktail parties" depends on insisting that the elections were still free and fair.
the whole reason they are politicians
No, that's far from the whole reason. Again, there's the many benefits of the job itself — the pay, the perks, the status, the influence. I think it was one of Chris Rufo's essays that pointed out how the Democratic party has shown a willingness to accept short-term electoral losses in pushing through long-term legal and social changes, highlighting the particular example of LBJ. In contrast, the GOP, most especially the party establishment, trend very much in the opposite direction — they consistently prioritize protecting their phony-baloney jobs (to borrow from the great Mel Brooks) over "making a difference." There are benefits to being in the Outer Party. There are reasons that generally-competent basketball players play for the Washington Generals.
(Then there's the ones like Lisa Murkowski and Mark Begich (can you tell I'm Alaskan?), for whom politics is literally the family business. The latter was being "groomed" for his eventual Senate seat all the way back when he was in high school. They were raised to be politicians. There are reasons I say that an openly aristocratic system is just being more honest about the ruling class.)
Plus, even if the GOP establishment does want to accomplish things in office, those aren't necessarily the same things that their voters — especially the Trump base — want. As someone once put it on a lengthy youtube video I once watched (analyzing county-level maps and breakdowns of biennial Congressional elections from the end of WWII to the end of the 20th century), the Republican Party began as the party of New England bankers… and that's what it always will be. They only "picked up" white working voters because the post-Nixon Democrats "dropped" them, as Matt Stoller describes at length in his 2016 Atlantic piece "How Democrats Killed Their Populist Soul." The job of GOP elites is to falsely pander to the voter base when campaigning, then deliver for the elite donor class in office — and I remember sometime last year or so a quote floating around the web from an interview with a Republican campaign strategist where he pretty much said that.
Most of my hope is on "the SCOTUS nixes attempts to remove Trump from the ballot".
Assuming they aren't able to delay it from reaching them until after the election.
Probably would have succeeded if Pericles hadn't died of plague and been replaced by impatient morons keen on decisive battles.
I agree with this.
But as to the overall point, it was mainly
Use superior Athenian wealth, industry and trade relations to make up for reductions in available harvest by trading for food imports.
and
Target the Spartan agriculture to destroy their harvests
Specifically, they began by pointing out that the US has done a lot of biological and chemical weapons research, not all of it aimed at humans — there are ones targeting crops and livestock, too. And there's a reason it's called "flyover country." This, accompanied with a photo of a crop-duster plane in action.
So, they argued, if red states decide to stop selling the food they grow to blue states, to try to use hunger as a weapon, then the other side will use hunger as a weapon back, go "if we can't have it, no one can," and send out aircraft to drop as many herbicides, blights, livestock diseases, et cetera upon red state farms as necessary. At which point, food will then have to be shipped in from elsewhere… and look at which side controls the coasts, and especially all the big coastal port cities. Oh, yes, and as for the funds with which pay foreign countries for that food, isn't a large majority of America's economy and wealth concentrated in those very same big coastal cities?
How much political blood and treasure has the ruling class expended to kill Trump?
Probably very little — particularly relative to the amount at their disposal — given he's still alive.
Why spend all this effort when the average voter is a sheep just begging for slaughter?
Because their own self-understanding and self-image require the pretense of a casus belli before they can really stick it to the other tribe (like so many of my classmates at Caltech deeply wanted to).
Perhaps it's worth the expense to see how far they can push.
A person I follow on tumblr once reminisced about his college days and mentioned hanging out with students from upper-class backgrounds who would opine on "the world-historical necessity of Flyover genocide." What if that is how far they can push? Is it really still worth the risk?
I think conviction is less obvious as you will likely have trouble seating a jury unbiased enough to not instantly lose on appeal.
I think you underestimate how "game-able" jury selection is. And even if it's straightforwardly certain to be overturned on appeal, I again point to Ted Stevens — just secure conviction before the election, but make sure the overturning on appeal only comes after the election.
If Trump is removed, that would be pretty clear official interference.
According to whom? That is to say, who has the legal authority to rule what is or isn't "official interference"? And even if they do rule so, what remedy is available after the fact?
The real stake here wis whether said PMCs are prepared to pick that fight. Because if they are well...
And now I'm reminded of some comments Yarvin made on the Good Ol' Boyz podcast (I think it was this one). Like when he calls the "Vaisya"/"hobbits"/"chuds" "worse than Morlocks," because the Eloi at least needed the Morlocks to keep the machinery running, but "you can be replaced by immigrants and automation" (that's from memory, so it might not be a perfect quote). Or the point earlier, when he asserts the that chud resistance to inevitable "Brahmin"/"elf" rule is futile because, "What are you going to do, kill us? The mid-century Germans tried that, and look what happened to them. Enough smart elves got out ahead of things, and now their grandkids are back and running the place."
Or there's the left-wing fellow on what was then still Twitter, who, when someone pointed out that it's "red" areas that grow everyone's food, responded with dire warnings that the Red Tribe had better not go there, followed by a thread describing a particularly nasty modernized variant on the early Athenian strategy against Sparta, through which it would be Flyover country that all starves to death while urban coastal elites remain fed.
Also:
When our will to fight is broken.
If Emperor Shōwa had taken that position in 1945, instead of the one he did — consider the Kyūjō incident, or Onoda Hiroo — where would Japan be now?
Down in Argentina, I've been shocked at how quickly and decisively Milei has been moving.
Yeah, it surprised me, too. Because there were three main positions/narratives on Milei in the right-wing circles I frequent, and this pretty much seriously undermines one of them — at least with respect to Argentina — and somewhat weakens another.
letting his entire voting base know that they aren't allowed to pick their representative and their votes are worthless, is not going to be a decision without serious consequences.
Why not? What "serious consequences" do you have in mind, and what reason do our elites have to fear them (as opposed to, say, welcoming them as casus belli to crush the hated enemy tribe even harder).
the political and societal consequences that would ensue
Again, what consequences, other than his supporters giving up and quitting the political scene?
and think that the legal system in the US is actually functioning on legal principles?
So what if people stop thinking our legal system is principled (assuming they haven't already)? The Chinese, for example, rejected the entire concept of "rule of law" and "equality before the law" (the core positions of the "Legalist" school) a bit over 2200 years ago, and soldiered on as a civilization just fine.
Functioning democracies generally don't lock up and arrest the leaders of the opposition party!
Greece? Ukraine?
why should they continue to bind themselves by rules that their opponents are clearly not respecting?
Because the alternative is being subjected to severe punishment for no possible gain?
If the Biden administration announces that the Republican party doesn't get to contest the next presidential election, I don't think the republican base would just sit there and go "Aww shucks, guess that's what the law says! Nothing we can do." if it wasn't for Tucker Carlson whispering in their ears.
Except I think, based on my experience with my "republican base" family and friends, that is what most will do. After all, quite a few already think that 2020 was outright stolen, expect some manner of repeat in 2024, and have given up on voting in favor of one (or more) of three things:
-
Preparing for the imminent Second Coming/End of Days that is now guaranteed to happen in our lifetimes.
-
The "Benedict Option" (even if they don't use the term): preparing and strengthening their family and church in hopes their descendants a century or two from now will be better prepared to survive and rebuild in the inevitable Dark Age to come. (I think it was Dave "The Distributist" Greene who argued that the entire right needs to accept that we cannot and will not ever win politically any time this century, and the only possible politics for the right is either forming families or becoming a (Catholic) priest, then preparing said families and Church for the eventual collapse.)
-
Wait for "someone else" to "fix everything" for them.
This last — the immense "free-rider" problem — cannot be overstated. My Dad, for example, holds that, should this sort of situation come to pass, that "local church groups" will provide all the organization the American right-wing will need to "fight back" and win… while he's (AFAIK) never attended a church service in his life. (He's certainly never attended one in my lifetime. For that matter, he has no friends or social life at all outside our family.) Others confidently that our military will certainly step in and set things right… in between breathlessly repeating the latest thing they watched on Fox News about the Woke-ification of our armed forces.
This was one of the more common right-wing criticisms I used to see of all the Q-Anon nonsense — that, besides being an exercise in unbounded apophenia, it serves as a call to passivity, asserting that right-wing citizens need do nothing at all, because the "patriots" secretly at work behind-the-scenes will fix everything for them.
Others (like the people at Sarah Hoyt's blog comments) will go on at length about how doing anything but hunkering down is "playing into the Marxists' hands," and that we just need to wait until "Zhou Bai-Den's Marxist thugs" come busting down our individual front doors, at which point we need only shoot back in self-defense, and then we automatically win.
I would still have no trouble believing that his incredibly passionate base would get extremely violent if they were told that they weren't allowed political representation anymore.
I think that, for all their passion, very few of them will get violent. Sure, some will, but those that do will do so entirely in the form of "lone-wolf" terrorism, blind lashing-out so poorly targeted and sloppily executed as to make Breivik's assault on Utøya look good in comparison. They will accomplish nothing but giving our government even more excuses to crack down on the right and limit political expression further still.
There is also a similar church court system in many paleo-protestant communities.
Sure, but how powerful is the threat of ostracism/expulsion in those communities to provide enforcement of the court's decision, as compared to its effectiveness in maintaining an Amish Ordnung?
Well then - Step 1 is find a Mrs. Capital_Room, and make a bunch Secondary_Rooms.
I'm in my mid-40s and still no success there whatsoever.
Perhaps you can skirt it by not calling it marriage?
Except, for one, there's the various "common-law marriage" statutes vis-à-vis long-term cohabitation and "if it looks like a marriage." Then there's the sort of things that don't really fit on an "ordinary commercial contract between economic entities" and aren't really enforceable outside family law — most things involving the kids, for example.
This is not legal advice.
Yeah, you're definitely right on that.
So teach your children the ways of the Amish
I don't have any (it takes two to tango, after all).
I can't guarantee your descendants surviving, but if enough of us do it, some part of us may survive in those that do.
Again, I'm not sure anyone in "the West" — or East Asia, for that matter — survives the coming collapse; that is, if our species survives it at all. (And if so, for how long?)
So some sort of privately certified pre-nup?
The problem here — as with every "you can get a traditional marriage if you want one" argument — is enforcement. Indeed, I've seen people try to argue "a properly-written pre-nup is all you need to make your marriage as it would be before no-fault divorce" online — at which point everyone else points out Diosdado v. Diosdado, and they either fall silent or resort to 'well, the Diosdados must have not done it properly; it must be possible somehow' sputtering.
Generally, it looks to me like the sort of "parallel society" thing that only really works for Hasidim and Mennonites.
…idea floating around that woodenness is just…
I think you had an autocorrect issue here.
regime attempting to deny an electorate a free choice
And I'm again reminded of the various things I've read arguing that this is in fact the proper, "democratic" thing to do, to defend Our Democracy against the terrible threat of "authoritarian populism," and that refusing to provide the electorate the choice they want is just about morally obligatory.
The Republican and Democratic Parties have guaranteed spots on general-election ballots in every state, and the parties tell election officials whose name to put in their spot.
And one or more states doesn't bother "passing legislation requiring a clean criminal record… on legally shaky ground," but just says "Trump's been convicted, so we're not putting him on the ballot; the Republican party can either submit a different name to go in their 'guaranteed spot' or else we leave it blank"? Sure, a court will probably rule that this is illegal and unconstitutional… eventually.(And who enforces that ruling, anyway?) But if you time it right, you can probably have that decision only come after the election, and then what? (Or, failing that, come well after ballots are printed and too close to election day to print new ones.)
It’s clear a conviction wouldn’t remove him from the ballot
Why not? If some set of states indeed use it as an excuse to remove him from the ballot, "allowed" or not, what recourse is available? Particularly if it gets dragged out in the courts until after the election is held? (Again, I look at Ted Stevens.)

I'm about 1/3 of the way through Ezra Klein's Why We're Polarized. So far, it's been a bit better than I expected (not that those expectations were all that high).
More options
Context Copy link