@DaseindustriesLtd's banner p
BANNED USER: temperamental dysregulation

DaseindustriesLtd

late version of a small language model

78 followers   follows 28 users  
joined 2022 September 05 23:03:02 UTC

Tell me about it.


				

User ID: 745

Banned by: @Amadan

BANNED USER: temperamental dysregulation

DaseindustriesLtd

late version of a small language model

78 followers   follows 28 users   joined 2022 September 05 23:03:02 UTC

					

Tell me about it.


					

User ID: 745

Banned by: @Amadan

Are you envisioning a future where you just tell the AGI "make me something" and it handles everything from conceptualization to planning the story beats to the final rendering?

This will be done at some point, assuming no political hurdles. Taken literally, this will amount to a gacha roll, hardly any different from current prompt combinatorics. «Make me something with the quality of Netflix slop, but a better fit for my data-mined profile» plus a few tags to taste – I'd say it's more commendable than consuming Netflix propaganda, but it's not an artistic act on your part, indeed any more than ordering a dish and asking for it to be extra spicy makes one a chef.

There is some limit, somewhere, to how much visual information you're able to encode in text

Technically there isn't; after all, images are 0s and 1s as well. But my point is more that natural languages do not lend themselves naturally to describing very specific visuals. Imagine Syd had his hands crushed in a road accident, but was otherwise intact. Would he be able to create an equal piece of art using an «art slave» as you put it, or simply a very responsive AI, talking about tones and shapes and reflections and such, especially not referencing prior work? I get that text is the universal interface, but eh... sounds bothersome. And leaving aside subtleties lost in translation – how much of the original image even was in Syd's head, imagined ex nihilo, versus discovered serendipitously through actual work of drawing the piece, stroke by stroke, both «at inference time» and over the decades of «training the network»? Also, how well could that iterative process be substituted in collaboration with a command-interpreting «slave»? Great painters offloaded much of their work to assistants, but they could do the job of any given assistant even better… Then again, high-level imagination can be lost in the work, or perhaps exposed as a half-baked incoherent dream…

Those are not obvious questions to me. I do not wish to look down on manual technique, no matter how much /ic/ type artists beclown themselves with shitty arguments. It's a travesty that humans have to do art in such an inefficient manner (animation is the worst sort of bullshit – 1D acts to construct a 4D object!), but in practice it appears to be either very important or fully necessary to build one's creative ability.

It isn't sufficient, though, so some crabs clearly have no legs to stand on while they bash prompters.

Do you have any projects in mind that you want to accomplish with SD? Have you been playing around with it?

I have, but playing around is the right way to put it.

My excitement was vicarious, on behalf of young people who haven't had the time or the insanity to acquire technique, yet believe they have something to show. It'll be more than a bit ridiculous to ape being a Creative now. This was a self-deprecating use of the term; I used to be an Idea Guy, but my Ideas are shriveled up and dead, visual or otherwise, just a dust-collecting folder with drafts. I'm not good at technique either. Sometimes I test it. For example, two months ago when I was dining out and saw this writingprompts thread «When humanity went extinct... Earth is now dominated by sentient trees» obviously baiting environmentalist nuts, and quickly wrote this , in the dry style of gwern prose.

It'd be relatively easy to expand my sketch into a larger-scale story, and illustrate with SD or Midjourney; I can envision most separate pieces. It'd communicate some of my politics and philosophy too. What would be the point, though? Even for better concepts of my own invention – who would need it? This tech is wasted on me, I admit it freely.

But there are other people.

I think crypto isn't dying, it's being killed, and its killers have names like «Sam Bankman-Fried». You don't get more centralized than this goofy fuck pontificating on regulation while misappropriating your funds to help out his buddies. It's dressed-up anarcho-tyranny. FTX was scarcely any more legitimate an institution than 2014 style exit scam exchanges ran by Eastern European anons, but the impact is vastly greater precisely due to those pretensions of being the responsible backbone to the system. It doesn't matter that he has the markings of a trustworthy radical bro and signals the «spirit of crypto». What matters is what he does.

SBF was either grossly unethical, beyond incompetent or conspiring with the incumbent powers; seeing his EA affiliations and apparent nonchalance in the wake of the disaster, I believe the latter is very probable and hope not just crypto but EAs get the spillover reputation damage they deserve.

We do not need more Bankmans. We have TradFi already, @2rafa and@BurdensomeCount are doing their jobs there just fine, it has more than enough reach in the society. The whole point of crypto was to establish from first principles an alternative, trustless transaction ecosystem they are not involved with. Roon is another sellout to EAs, but he puts it well:

i've been too anti-crypto so i'll say that i've always liked the piratical create new legal/financial system ethos of it all. towards 2021 end, what we actually saw was the 11th noncollateralized algorithmic stablecoin (ponzi) or people remaking normal apps with worse technology

the problem was always that the good use cases for crypto require random people in poor countries without extradition to build insane free market cypherunk neal stephenson network states and instead we got harvard graduate institutionally backed money grabbing nonsense

Crypto, as conceived of by Satoshi, is intrinsically incompatible with the USG hegemony, and with people like SBF as its champions; it was one of the few non-hopeless attempts to challenge the singleton and increase the richness of potential outcomes. Villain League leaders (Russia, China, Iran etc.) reveal their lack of vision, or complicity, in not throwing their weight behind it.


More generally.

You've asked me the other day:

What does moving past this sweet spot look like in practice? Are you saying the goal is to make us terrified of the incumbent Western state actors, so much so we lose the will to resist?

Adding to those posts: I think that this, in part, will be implemented as the infantilization of the populace framed for midwits as interdependence in modern economy, and the disappearance of people with «fuck you money».

Ironically, it may look like the spread of practices typical for the super-rich down the social strata, but with one significant nuance: as your dependence on connections increases, your own agency and ability to decide whether someone else is connected does not, and indeed it degrades. Thus, a two-class system emerges: people who are connected and people who connect. Even the extremely rich plebeians, like Kanye, are but leafs of the graph; every link between them and the world with which they can affect it can be trivially snapped with or without a formal cause by even the lowest member of the patrician class, who is, in turn, able to fall back on an antifragile support system working on informal «understandings». Plebeian wealth is tied in contracts that can be canceled unilaterally if they misbehave, their social capital – on platforms with censors and politruks, hosted on vulnerable servers owned by people either terrified of another set of politruks or agreeing with them; their money in banks, ran by Bankmans, or in cargo-cultish meme assets like Bitcoin in a Coinbase wallet. We are being made into perpetual children, evaluated, tested and judged by the nebulous Adult Society, granted good boy points, credentials and access tokens which can be revoked at will.

If the realization of having been made into such a child is not terrifying, I don't know what is. My belief is that people gloating at the troubles in crypto, such as the Hacker News audience, are domesticated to the extent they cannot feel this terror and instead skip to obedience instantly, eagerly swallowing the bluepill cope about interdependence, regulations, «consequences of speech» and such. Maybe that's the historically normal mentality for a plebeian.

In any case, Crypto was our shot at resisting this atomization and subjugation trend. But it got infiltrated, discredited, devalued and now is being brought to heel, because, as I always say, social technology >>> technology.

I realized that if I actually were a trained illustrator, my ability to exploit this AI tool to generate high quality images would be improved several times over.

The best video concerning this issue is still on the metaphor of Lace.

bargaining. Listen, from the beginning, you've had people trying to propose that there could be this kind of hybrid market of prompt engineers who were working with the AI, and I reckon that in some cases that will be true.

But there's a bit of bargaining going on here. This happened with lace as well. In another history of lace, they discuss how both the handmade and machine made lace industries were benefited by the combination. They could work together. Think Terminator 2, but lace. And it's true that even today lace makers will often inspect machine made lace for errors and they'll do work to clean it up, but it seems a little desperate, doesn't it?

That brings us to: depression. Okay, honestly, I'm not sure if we're in the depression stage for AI generated art yet. Uh we're probably still bargaining a bit.

Or as Kasparov said: let us become centaurs! Let the computer handle tactics, and I'll oversee the broad strokes of the Strategy! He has always been arrogant.

But this metaphor is lacking, isn't it. Because there's only so much you can do to make lace fancy. It's always been a pure show of skill. Art is deeper.

What you're discovering with Stable Diffusion is that it's a low-level skill prosthesis: very good at rendering, silly at composition, near completely unable to work with concepts. This is the rough pattern of automation in a given field: the technology begins with eating the routine technique. Abstractions follow. Technique on the level that is aesthetically pleasing is so hard for humans to master, it's the subject of such envy and crab mentality, that the development of style (in gwern's definition, «some principled, real, systematic visual system of esthetics») is, among serious artists, from what I can tell, roughly synonymous with the mastering of techniques, and artists have come to scorn «idea guys». For the most part I believe they're stupid doomed crabs who struggle to trace coomer "art" over photos of their onlyfans colleagues of the opposite gender, Stable Diffusion is the great equalizer, and ideas matter a lot more than technique; but with passage of time, the role of centaurs and chimeras and man-machine collaboration will shrivel up, as stronger models master radically more abstract and large-scale skills – from rendering technique to composition to coloring to «taste» to... As in chess and go, so in art: at some point, one machine makes the Move 37 and that's it.

So in writing. I've read this today, a work of greentext prose by GPT-3, prompted by Connor Leahy (h/t gwern). It's perfect «metamodernism», oscillating from clownery to sincerity, scarily compelling, at times haunting. At times painfully lame – but I've seen flesh-and-blood writers fail harder, especially in sci-fi. I recommend you check it out.

...it's crucial, though, that real ideas aren't «options». They aren't even «choices». They are, to put it naively, transcendent events, grasping entire insights from beyond the distribution. Artists have a point. There is a difference between pro-consuming, deigning to snap together a minimal viable element of novelty, a medium-tiddy anime PLUS impressionism DOG! girl with BURGERS in some harder pose, like most anons on 4chan are content to do, – and a creative act, even if expressed in largely the same behaviors. Perhaps creative acts can be mastered starting with this play. Perhaps artists are right and you need the pain of the grind to earn the key to creativity. Perhaps it's only given to some, but is given irrevocably. This almost feels Gnostic. As an Idea Guy, I'd like to believe the latter. But even if I arrive at a visual idea – how do I prompt it? How does one summon into existence this, before it is drawn by Syd Mead? Is spoken language humans can realistically use even expressive enough?

Most «artists» are illustrators, and most illustrators can be replaced by a guy who's mastered Stable Diffusion (realistically, SD+ that's been pumped to Midjourney V4 level) plus a couple of inpainting/img2img/prompt2prompt techniques, like me and you, because most illustrations are trash. But that's not very interesting. There does exist original art, it's qualitatively different from this, and it remains to be seen if AI tools will reveal any Idea Guys as real artists who have been merely technique-deficient. As far as patterns go... The prior art is not encouraging.

(Both «Idea guy» and «creative choice» are terms @FCfromSSC has used a couple of weeks ago. I've written half a post, been procrastinating to respond to him and now it's probably too stale.)

Defending one's country is very different from participating in a bullshit war of aggression, even if one is the type to stan based $TEAM from the couch regardless of morality. And being forced by circumstance to defend your county makes this country more real in your mind. This is the issue Putin (and those loyalist commenters) have cynically and irrationally dismissed. In my opinion, Ukraine was a country of comparable «realness» with Russia before the war, but now it's a living movement. Nothing new since Machiavelli. All this pseudo-historical essentialist analysis about the origins of Ukraine, how could it persuade anyone that Ukrainians will fold? Nations are in fact imagined communities and so long as Ukrainians themselves don't imagine themselves to be meaningless Austro-Hungarian chimeras, they will act like people belonging to a nation.

That said, even back in 2013 there have been opinions stressing the fragility of Russian identity:

Washington political analyst Paul Gobl, the author of the blog Window on Eurasia, shared with the Russian service of Voice of America an analysis of the processes taking place in Russia and assessed American-Russian relations.

PG: When you observe the processes in Russia from a remote position, the unexpected growth of regionalism within the Russian Federation is striking. Revival and strengthening of Siberian identity, Eastern identity, Pomeranian - in the North, Cossack - throughout the south of Russia. This identity revolution reflects two important trends and points to a third.

First, this is a reflection of the fact that, contrary to the beliefs of most people, the Russian national identity is the weakest in Eurasia. Self-identification, for example, among Avars, Armenians or Ukrainians is much stronger than among Russians. In many ways, the Russians turned out to be the main victims of the state named after them. They were allowed to govern, but only at the cost of abandoning their own development as a nation. As a result, fragmentation occurs.

Geography and poor management are also contributing. You cannot drive by car from one end of the country to the other, because there are no normal highways, the railways are rusting, most airlines are squeezed out of business and are no longer functioning - huge parts of the country are isolated from each other. As a result, regional alliances are formed. The same type of regionalism that was brutally suppressed by Boris Yeltsin in the middle of the 1990s is being reanimated.

Combining and restraining the growth of regionalism and sub-ethnic Russian nationalism will be a serious challenge for the center. In the medium and long term, the growth of Russian sub-ethnic nationalism is a much more serious threat to Moscow’s ability to control the situation than any other “non-Russian” national movement.

(This is, of course, just wishful thinking. But in a way, it's gentle. Russians do not start to identify as «Siberians»: they just learn English and leave).

I have not read "credible" literature on this subject but there's plenty of literature on it. Pinging @eetan. I spoke more of the above-ground long-term social engineering, even detailed by Scott, like the success of the Fabian Society.

Are you saying the goal is to make us terrified of the incumbent Western state actors, so much so we lose the will to resist?

Perhaps not «us» in the broadest possible sense, but yes, the goal is to make e.g. unsurveilled communications on badthink topics, and crypto business that's not entirely fetishistic (like "waow I'm paying for Mossad VPN in Bitcoin from my Coinbase to discuss Elon Musk's racism on Mastodon! this is the future of freedom!") as mentally taxing as building FGC9's in your garage in Europe.

Stable diffusion's inability to produce non-trivial and correct composition on demand is entirely expected from its text encoder's properties, expecially after Imagen's paper, and the model is in fact grossly outperforming initial expectations; hell, it runs on smartphones with 6Gb memory, it has no business understanding compositionality even on small scale. Midjourney v4 seems better already; Imagen, parti and now eDiff-i are vastly better; SD 2.0 (assuming that's what it's called) will probably wipe the floor with Midjourney.

In any case, have you looked into RunwayML inpainting model? It's much more capable of parsing the context of the image.

What do you mean by social technology here?

I mean practices which are to «memes» as ASML engineering is to redneck engineering. Mature practices not to produce random flashy effects on the social tissue or have a few crude immediate-term uses, but to steadily and reliably expand your domain and degrees of freedom, and suffocate your competitors. Such as exacerbation of fear of unapproved non-state actors and normalization of anarcho-tyranny. Things behind campaigns like this one.

what has to happen for mass adoption of decentralized currencies?

Widespread fear of incumbent Western state-affiliated actors, which is strong enough to negate all of their propaganda about monster-of-the-week threats like islamchinarussianazis, but simultaneously not so strong as to be mind-numbing.

Their goal is to move us past that sweet spot as quickly as possible.

Unforced error of their opponents who have escalated the attack to potentially-internet-breaking levels (again, via social technology).

It is. I admit this is perfectly plausibly deniable.

On the other hand, this guy, ex-director of IARPA and ex-Assistant Director of National Intelligence, he spoke on EA Global, leads RAND, writes recommendations of semiconductor restriction policies for White House, and checks every box of EA zeitgeist.

But hey! Maybe he's JuSt A SmArT WoNK and we shouldn't assume anything beyond that!

@bro

Not that I know of.

EAs ought to have acquired enough momentum via their PR in major outlets (rather, this PR seems to indicate the momentum) to not care that much about Sam now, I believe. They're getting their AI safety and longtermism discussions, they've got their China chip ban, and they'll keep getting more stuff. Aren't they already plugged into networks much more valuable than anything crypto bros had to offer? Like, national security council tier?

Off topic, but China making crypto illegal and thus giving up their stake in the digital economy the US cannot control by decree has been the first of many ruinous, small-minded mistakes of Xi era (I mean, outside the obvious geopolitical ones like their handling of Hong Kong and Xinjiang) and they haven't shown the ability to reverse any of those.

Crypto is being pretty thoroughly neutered, no wonder its value is dropping. Ruskies who enabled much of the privacy side are suiciding or getting arrested, and Ethereum is ensuring that blocks are kosher now.

It's darkly amusing to be proven right. People thought that technology will disrupt traditional governance, and instead we're seeing bureaucratic sanctions effectively enforced against abstract cryptographic protocols. Social technology and human networking keep trampling over nerdy bullshit. How about a nice central bank digital currency? It's very high-tech, like in China, but without the scary Social Credit! Just a little oversight from your friendly democratically elected government, to make sure you don't use any of that nasty anonymous fake money like XMR or financing something evil... like Kiwifarms (more evil things are best left unmentioned and dealt with professionally).

I suppose we'll see Tor and i2p and other such bastions of net freedom dismantled completely in a few years, maybe blocked on the level of hardware, with forced upgrades under the guise of onshoring the supply chain and ensuring safety from RussiaChina threat and AGI risk. What a time to be alive.

Just how good do you think those Ashkenazim ought to be?

Israel's economy is growing rapidly and is actually really good in several industries – they've famously got world-class military hardware and medicine, and they do have a ton of startups. Can't quantify this, but I'm seeing an exponential increase of high-profile AI papers from their universities, as of the last few years (though it seems they're getting spoiled by access to Google tech). Israel is also extremely good in high-tech spying, perhaps better than the US, as we've recently learned. They're doing all that without the US, the EU or East Asia around.

It may also be the issue of priorities. Israel is the only developed country with a developing country fertility, and not just because of the Haredim; the only one where nationalism and tradition coexist peacefully (for now at least) with modernity and tolerance; and the only functional ethnostate. Ashkenazim who don't find all that very attractive have an easy time moving elsewhere, but we shouldn't presume they're smarter than ones who stay and quietly keep building up Israeli might.

I predict Israel will be routinely classified as an economic superpower, or even just a superpower, by 2060s (in the not exactly very likely world where AGI doesn't flip the table, wiping out such extrapolations), when its population approaches or surpasses 20 million (current projections are still conservative).

Granted, but I protest Hlynka's confrontational attitude on this issue. You could have modded him for darkly hinting and not speaking clearly in this case.

This is one of my big issues with those do-gooder «world government» type organizations, whether incumbent or aspiring like the Effective Altruism blob. «Frightfully distant they are from the people»; they aren't just echo chambers as a result of their evolution, but they are born out of the disconnect with the hoi polloi. Their attitudes and aesthetics turn out alien to most of their subjects and one must wonder whether their values – not just formalizations, but deepest moral intuitions – are as well. They are unaligned collective intelligences.

I wonder if you, Hlynka, will ever get to reveal something new and surprising about yourself to your own mind.

Such as the fact that your credentials of a no-nonsense Southerner tough guy who's calling out literal Nazis and Monarchists on their "blue tribe leftism" are making an increasingly funny combination with your support of censorship and propaganda by big government agencies, committed in service of an extreme Marxist egalitarian theory.

This wasn't an attack on your attitude, which if anything is refreshing in its boldness and consistency. Even an explicit Varna system where our neo-Brahmin Judeo-Hapa CEOs are recognized as spiritually (and racially) superior but are also expected to fulfill certain paternalistic prosocial obligations befitting their greater capability would be preferable to the current having-the-cake-and-eating-it-too arrangement, where Whites both underperform and carry the inexhaustible moral burden of transgressions, real and imagined.

Note, however, that in the West you feel noblesse oblige towards, and intend to save, «the West» as an abstraction and a communal cultural legacy. As you have indicated many times in the past, ignorant, wretched lower-to-middle-class Anglos can only inspire an almost-genocidal contempt on your side. You justify this by pointing out their unmerited pretension of equality. Fine. But if we compare values, they are, on average, superior to the median member of your nation (if not your lineage) in all respects one could care about – work ethic, intellect, honesty, fucking cleanliness – except maybe knowing their place; they provide the substrate for your flourishing; and they are not afforded the opportunity to lord over those lesser people in their countries, nor do they seek it – as opposed to their, or rather their upper classes', forefathers of the Colonial era. And indeed both in the US and the UK they calmly accept even the political leadership of your kin; a situation unthinkable in any South Asian nation, no matter the respective merit.

In my eyes this largely redeems their superficial arrogance, and brings the ball back into your court.

So much has been said on this topic over the centuries, it's tedious.

The long and short of it is that Jews truly have «systemic power» that the left accuses White-cishet-male-etc. outgroup of having; perhaps this accusation is better understood as a deflection. They are overrepresented in positions of power, they are substantially coordinated specifically as Jews, including in those positions of power, via a rich and dense network of Jewish organizations focusing on outreach to/bargaining with/pressuring people in power – well, this «they» necessarily excluding those who neglect their ethnic identity or its illegible political terms (e.g. Greenwald), and the fruit of in-group preference that those factors provide, but in terms of total influence this isn't a noteworthy caveat – and their coordinating structures are dedicated to maintaining and furthering this power, first of all by means of promoting the doctrine of Jewish victimhood (to the point of it having become a kneejerk quasi-religious dogma, with Hitler impersonation being about as taboo as Devil worshipping was in the Middle Ages – at least the medievals could have their Festivals!), and secondly by eroding the capacity of other peoples to coordinate, except to again erode the bigger and stronger group's capacity. So we have Civil Rights support and assorted pro-Black activism including BLM, but the moment Blacks begin to build their identity on the Black Hebrew Israelite/Nation of Islam ideology (admittedly a complete schizo clown show), Jews pull the plug and we see those performative lustrations.

This isn't new. I think the difference this time is that Western elites are progressively becoming, well, less Western, and more tolerant of explicit ethnic casteism, especially when powered by genuine differences in capability: for a good illustration, see @BurdensomeCount here. Due to all people nominally having the same rights and obligations, there is no notion of noblesse oblige either, the useful bits of Western egalitarianism being combined with useful bits of Eastern might-makes-right logic.

I think in my lifetime, even with moderately pessimistic estimates (i.e. the next 15 years) I'll see the flip-flop on this topic, a sharp transition to normalization of the belief that Jews, as a politically represented ethnic fraction, are just inherently better and have more rights than Gentiles. Those demands of admitting the advantage, with the promise of recognizing it as valid, are not as clever as people like Roko may imagine.

Russia will be more isolated and treated worse than «North Corea» anyway, but at least Koreans have their Juche bullshit to explain what they're accepting this sacrifice and antagonizing the planet for. So would have the White&Christian Russia. Likewise for some other antagonist races of history who after their demise become fuel for fetishistic fantasies.

What about the real Russia? Духовность? Антифашизм? So profoundly phony.

Global Ancestry and Cognitive Ability

Note that the anti-HBD crowd (i.e. the Turkheimer side of the debate) have put in some effort to make the author of this publication Bryan J. Pesta, a tenured professor (!), unemployable. I've mentioned this in my first response to tailcalled, but some choice quotes from a Chronicle article praising the cancellation, to understand how the perception of ambiguity in this topic is maintained, indeed how the sausage gets made. It reads very much like a 30's Pravda report on courageous pioneers catching and handling a villain wrecker kulak to the authorities, Scooby Doo style, but that's the clownish reality of the American academia.

Liam O’Brien was a master’s student in political science at Cleveland State University in 2019 when a screenshot from a new article, titled “Global Ancestry and Cognitive Ability,” crawled across his Twitter feed.

To the untrained eye, the abstract was highly technical. “Using the ancestry-adjusted association between MTAG eduPGS and g from the monoracial African-American sample as an estimate of the transracially unbiased validity of eduPGS (B = 0.124),” the authors wrote, “the results suggest that as much as 20%-25% of the race difference in g can be naïvely explained by known cognitive ability-related variants.”

The argument dressed up in that statistical jargon? That Black people are genetically disposed to be less intelligent than white people.

O’Brien was disturbed to see that debunked racial-hierarchy arguments popular in the late 19th and early 20th century had a toehold in modern academe. Scientifically rigorous research arguing that intelligence is inherited is itself controversial, but few geneticists take seriously the claim that intelligence is racially linked.

His dismay turned to outrage when he discovered that one of the authors, Bryan J. Pesta, was a tenured professor in Cleveland State’s business school. His home institution was essentially providing a soapbox for racist pseudoscience.

O’Brien had a history of political activism, so he did what came naturally, talking to students and professors about Pesta’s article, and trying to get him censured. [...]

A look at Pesta’s RateMyProfessors page shows students generally rated him very highly, describing him as “hilarious,” “interesting,” and “easy.” One warned: “If you’re easily offended, you might not like some of his jokes, especially when he compares certain graphs to phallic symbols.” But none of the 74 reviews complains about racism.

The Chronicle reached out to 10 Black students who graduated from the business school with bachelor’s or master’s degrees in 2022. Of the three who replied, none said they were familiar with Pesta.

“Literally 100s of Black students have taken my classes,” Pesta wrote in an email to The Chronicle. “I’ve won merit pay for teaching many times. I was regard [sic] as among the best teachers in the business college.”

“If I were racist, or even overly political,” he wrote, “I submit I would have been exposed by now.” [..]

Many racial hereditarians present their claims as widely accepted but deliberately suppressed facts in the scientific community. They blame the political correctness of academe for their difficulty publishing in well-respected journals.

Their critics argue that shoddy scholarship and a refusal to account for developments in the study of genetics keep racial hereditarians marginal. Even respected scholars who believe genes play a role in intelligence argue that the role of environmental factors is too complicated and profound to disentangle. Behavioral geneticists like Kathryn Paige Harden and Eric Turkheimer repudiate the idea that IQ differences between races are rooted in genetics. [..]

For “Global Ancestry and Cognitive Ability,” in 2019, Pesta had three co-authors: Jordan Lasker, John G.R. Fuerst, and Emil O.W. Kirkegaard. The Chronicle attempted to contact all of them via publicly listed email addresses, but received no replies.

[a section on trying to find their vulnerabilities]

Thomas E. Schläpfer, a research clinical psychiatrist at Germany’s University of Freiburg who studies interventional biological psychiatry, took charge of the journal in 2020. He said he had been unaware until contacted by The Chronicle of Pesta’s publication or any problems with his brief tenure as editor.

After reading Pesta’s article, he wrote, “While the scientific methods sound impressive, I find the hypothesis both ludicrous and demeaning.” [...]

O’Brien, the political-science graduate student, tried not to let Pesta’s work go ignored. He gathered students from various activist groups to make an action plan. One group put out an email blast inviting interested students to a Zoom meeting on the subject.

Many of the attendees were familiar faces. But one, who joined the call under a pseudonym and left his camera off, made organizers wary. He said he was an undergraduate but offered little else by way of introduction. After some prodding, he messaged one of the organizers his CSU email address, which contained his last name: Fuerst. The organizers shut down the meeting, then reconvened among themselves. They had been infiltrated. If Fuerst knew they were going after Pesta, then Pesta himself surely also knew.

But across the country, geneticists at other universities had set in motion institutional processes focused not on Pesta’s racist claims but on his violation of the norms and regulations of academe.

He had already been on one geneticist’s radar when “Global Ancestry and Cognitive Ability” was published in Psych.

Luke Miller (a pseudonym) is an early-career scientist who has long been rankled by racial hereditarians. As a geneticist, he said, he feels a responsibility to combat the harm done by the fringes of the scientific community. (The Chronicle has used a pseudonym for Miller and left some other early-career researchers in this article unnamed because they fear professional repercussions.) [...]

More alarmingly, the paper cited data from the National Institutes of Health’s Database of Genotypes and Phenotypes (dbGaP). The federal agency has strict controls governing who may use its data and how. It struck Miller as improbable that the NIH had given Pesta’s paper the green light, or would have even given him access to the data, if the agency had known what he planned to do with it.

Miller was tapped into a network of researchers across the country who felt similarly about hereditarianism. Together, four of them combed the methodology section of Pesta’s article and compiled evidence that he had violated NIH policies.

According to the paper’s methodology section, the data was uploaded to at least two servers: the Michigan Imputation Server, a University of Michigan program that deduces genes that haven’t been included in a sample; and HIrisPlex-S, a web application that deduces phenotypes like eye, hair, and skin color from genetic data. While only Pesta received permission to use the NIH data, and named none of his co-authors in the requests, Miller said he and the other whistle-blowers had inferred that others would have had to have access to it to do the analysis the paper described. [...]

Taylor works on an NIH-backed project called the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis. His work uses genetic data from across ethnicities to look at risk factors for cardiovascular disease. The painstaking approval processes he and his colleagues must go through — applying for IRB approval for every study, taking yearly refresher courses on the ethics of using human subjects, and signing data-use agreements — is “cumbersome in many ways,” he said.

”We complain about it to each other as well, but it’s necessary,” he added. Such safeguards in human research came about because of past abuses that poisoned many people’s faith in medical research. They’re designed to ensure that scientists don’t use subjects’ personal information in ways they would find abhorrent.

The letter set a June 2021 deadline for the university to destroy all initially approved copies of the genetic data and find out whether any unapproved copies of the data had been made. The agency also revoked Pesta’s permission to use NIH data for any existing projects, and banned him from obtaining any NIH data for the next three years. [...]

According to a letter sent to Pesta by the then provost, Laura Bloomberg — who has since been tapped as CSU’s president — the university confirmed the NIH’s findings. It also found Pesta had lied to a staff member in CSU’s research office when he said the data would be kept in a university-owned laptop and he would be the only one with access.

Pesta said he had requested and received approval from both Cleveland State and the NIH to store the data on a home computer.

“Those bastards totally ignored me when I pointed it out,” he added.

Bloomberg ultimately found that Pesta’s conduct had damaged the university’s reputation and could impede other professors’ ability to do research.

Cleveland State declared that Pesta had been incompetent or dishonest in teaching or scholarship; neglected his duty, and engaged in personal conduct that substantially impaired the fulfillment of his institutional responsibilities; and interfered with the normal operations of the university. The letter declared Bloomberg’s decision to fire Pesta.

Pesta was officially fired on March 4, 2022, two and a half years after his article was published.

etc.

Due to some issues I haven't had the opportunity to engage with the HBD/PNH discussion or indeed to read themotte recently.

Is it? If it's only as much as Germany, France and so on, then why is Raskin singling us out on the account of whiteness?

I disagree. Russia isn't ideologically white or Christian, which is what seems to be alleged here. There are more divorces and abortions and fewer Church visits in Russia than in those countries, and as for whiteness, well, we stand with the people of Zimbabwe in their anti-colonial struggle. Raskin can rest easy.

Hey now, this memo wasn't supposed to be for public eyes.

Russia is white and Christian

I wish.

Confabulation is an amazing thing. Often I see people make clever points referring to such idiosyncratic memory farts (or not very clever but just curious, like my token plasma metaphor). LoGH is fictional evidence anyway, so I think we should cut Kulak some snack.

Phenotypic null hypothesis isn't an obscure methodological limitation, it is a fundamental property of concepts like "heritability" and "genetic correlation"

To be blunt: «Phenotypic null hypothesis [for the genetics of personality]» is a 2013 review paper by Eric Turkheimer, with 162 citations.

Turkheimer, like Lewontin before him with his «apportionment» and, more to the point, with his corn plants (cited by Ned Block here), is making a mountain out of a common-sensical molehill, in his case to bury the monster of HBD implications that have sprang forth (as he asserts, unreasonably) from his own First Law that he now seeks to reframe (as much is stated in the paper). Moreover, you both are sufficiently obscurantist and informal that it's hard to tell if you're gesturing at the same mountain:

The phenotypic null hypothesis integrates what we have learned from multivariate behavior genetics: Until demonstrated otherwise, complex heritable behavioral traits should be the result of psychological processes defined at a high level of analysis, rather than at the level of genes or neurons. Although such complex traits are never independent of genetic variation, they cannot be defined by genetic processes. Genes and behavior are a single entity, a single organism observed at two levels of analysis. Some traits are better understood using low-level concepts (genes, neurons, structures), whereas others require high-level constructs (organizations, algorithms, beliefs).

vs yours:

Put simply, the phenotypic null hypothesis is this: Heritability tells you that if you go up through the chain of causation, then you will often end up with genes. However, there may be many ways that variables can be connected to each other, and there’s no particular reason to expect that every step along the chain of causation from genes to outcomes is best thought of as biological.

Ok, and?

….The problem you talk about in your Substack post is real, although not nearly as damaging with regards to the sort of HBD beliefs most salient in the culture war and pro/anti-HBD debate (i.e. not the issue of bullied gays) as one could assume from careless reading of your initial post. (Besides, we have plenty of data such as admixture and, as of late, GWAS confirming simple additive model for the group difference – qualitatively similar to the case of height, not similar to gay-bullying and personality research). Measurement error is a fundamental problem; though as better-informed people remind us, there are methods, e.g. common pathway models, which help against it, and HBD research using those methods has yielded largely the same conclusions. It is also possible to directly test for AE vs ACE, precluding the sort of erroneous assumptions you warn against.

This is what is recommended is a textbook, literally, in crypto-HBDer Plomin's «Behavioral Genetics» 2012 edition (that is, anticipating Turkheimer's paper by a year). Consider p.157:

«In addition, recent work suggests that careful attention should be paid to claims of causality, measurement error, and environmental factors that can influence both the endophenotype and the final outcome (Kendler & Neale, 2010). … Another issue is that the goal of behavioral genetics is to understand pathways among genes, brain, and behavior. Genes found to be associated with brain phenotypes are important in terms of the brain level of analysis, but their usefulness for behavioral genetics depends on their relationship with behavior (Rasetti & Weinberger, 2011). In other words, when genes are found to be associated with brain traits, the extent to which the genes are associated with behavioral traits needs to be assessed rather than assumed».

Or in a section about model fitting, pp. 380-390:

« Although we will not follow the proof here, researchers have demonstrated that we cannot ask about additive genetic effects, dominance genetic effects, and shared environmental effects simultaneously if the only information we have is from MZ and DZ twins reared together. In virtually every circumstance, we will wish to retain the nonshared environmental variance component in the model. We wish to retain it partly because random measurement error is modeled as a nonshared environmental effect and we do not wish to have a model that assumes no measurement error (it is unlikely to fit very well). Most commonly, we would then model additive genetic variance and shared environmental variance. As mentioned earlier, such a model is called the ACE model […] Table A.2 shows that the AE model is unable to account for this particular set of observed values. Such a model is said to be underidentified. This condition is not necessarily problematic: In general, underidentified models are to be favored. Because a saturated model will always be able to fit the observed data perfectly, the goodness of fit does not really mean anything. However, if an underidentified model does fit the data, then we should take notice—it is not fitting out of mere statistical necessity».

Plomin practices what he preaches, too – here's an example of a paper.

So yeah, those are real problems with real countermeasures. «Phenotypic null hypothesis» is a meme, and there are apparently only two people forcing this meme.

Again, what Turkheimer is doing here is not different from Lewontin's tricks, which are known to have been motivated by politics. It's uncanny how similar these situations are. In the entry-level «Making sense of Heritability, pp. 60:-62:

Lewontin’s criticism of ANOVA is often presented as making a purely the- oretical point about inherent limitations in any attempt to derive causal conclusions from statistical data by using the analysis of variance. This interpretation is supported by the way he himself describes the upshot of his argument at the outset: “I will begin by saying some very obvious and elementary things about causes, but I will come thereby to some very annoying conclusions” … The strange thing about (a) is that, despite defending an extreme methodological claim that measurement of human norms of reaction is impossible, Lewontin neither discusses nor so much as mentions what were then most important contributions to the literature on that issue. At the time, the most sophisticated analysis of methodological prob- lems in human behavior genetics was undoubtedly the paper by Jinks and Fulker (1970), which was an important step in the development of powerful model-fitting methods that dominate the contemporary scene. Moreover, John Jinks and David Fulker did suggest how G–E interac- tions could be empirically detected without testing the same genotype in a variety of environments (see below), which directly contradicted Lewontin’s impossibility claim. It is hard to explain why Lewontin fails to address their argument, or at least inform the reader about this “landmark paper”…

By all means, do promote statistical literacy and demand intellectual honesty among HBDers, do shame us for our sloppiness. Keep discussing this in terms of phenotypic null hypothesis, if you must. But do not gaslight. This argument, and in this specific formulation, is not Behavioral Genetics 101, but your recent contribution to the debate, and it's more of a rhetorical nature.

*my impression of the topic is still best described in this quote:

[…] Well, OK, I could believe that; visible traits consistent over entire populations like skin color might differ systematically because of sexual selection or something, but why not leave IQ following the exact same bell curve in each population? There was no specific thing here that made me start to wonder, more a gradual undermining (Gould’s work like The Mismeasure of Man being completely dishonest is one example - with enemies like that…) as I continued to read studies and wonder why Asian model minorities did so well, and a lack of really convincing counter-evidence like one would expect the last two decades to have produced - given the politics involved - if the idea were false. And one can always ask oneself: suppose that intelligence was meaningful, and did have a large genetic component, and the likely genetic ranking East Asians > Caucasian > Africans; in what way would the world, or the last millennium (eg the growth of the Asian tigers vs Africa, or the different experiences of discriminated-against minorities in the USA), look different than it does now?

It’s worth noting that the IQ wars are a rabbit hole you can easily dive down. The literature is vast, spans all sorts of groups, all sorts of designs, from test validities to sampling to statistical regression vs causal inference to forms of bias; every point is hotly debated, the ways in which studies can be validly critiqued are an education in how to read papers and look for how they are weak or make jumps or some of the data just looks wrong, and you’ll learn every technical requirement and premise and methodological limitation because the opponents of that particular result will be sure to bring them up if it’ll at all help their case.

In this respect, it’s a lot like the feuds in biblical criticism over issues like whether Jesus existed, or the long philosophical debate over the existence of God. […]

But having said that, and admiring things like Plantinga’s free will defense, and the subtle logical issues in formulating it and the lack of any really concrete evidence for or against Jesus’s existence, do I take the basic question of God seriously? No. The theists’ rearguard attempts and ever more ingenious explanations and indirect pathways of reasons and touted miracles fundamentally do not add up to an existing whole. The universe does not look anything like a omni-benevolent/powerful/scient god was involved, a great deal of determined effort has failed to provide any convincing proof, there not being a god is consistent with all the observed processes and animal kingdom and natural events and material world we see, and so on. The persistence of the debate reflects more what motivated cognition can accomplish and the weakness of existing epistemology and debate.[…]

I don’t know when the definitive paper will come out, if it’ll be this year, or by 2020, although I would be surprised if there was still nothing by 2030; but it will happen and it will happen relatively soon (for a debate going on for the past century or more). Genome sequencing is simply going to be too cheap for it to not happen.

Incidentally, this can no longer be found on the author's website.

The manner is recognizable enough, of course.

Hi again. You may not know it, but the author of the text in the vault, JB, is a bit of a meme here, an avatar of pig-headed intransigence and hubris, which lends credence to your words. Nevertheless, I can't see how your arguments justify disagreeing with him on this issue and indeed coming to a «totally different conclusion».

If HBDers are going to boost these kinds of studies and ignore critique of them, then why should anyone listen to HBDers?

To begin with: because for most would-be listeners, supporting the opposite camp equals approval of one's family and one's people getting discriminated against (the nigh-inevitable alternative to HBD being acceptance of unredeemed racial guilt). Some are turned off by this; others are quite happy.

And because whatever the faults of HBDers, the other side remains epistemologically worse. Turkheimer may have some legitimate scientific argument against between-group genetic diffs on g; his bottom line was still arrived at through moralizing. «We can recognize a contention that Chinese people are genetically predisposed to be better table tennis players than Africans as silly, and the contention that they are smarter than Africans as ugly, because it is a matter of ethical principle that individual and cultural accomplishment is not tied to the genes in the same way as the appearance of our hair.»

HBD/Blank Slate is a political question more than it's a scientific one, a question of whether a civic religion founded on this stated promise of equal innate potential (or at least absence of substantial between-group differences) is needed for the prosperity of a polity and reduction in individual suffering; it's a question of oughts. Turkheimer et al. wear their oughts on their sleeves, adversarially, so it's a bit of a double standard to dunk on HBDers for failing or refusing to understand a peripheral aspect of «is».

Now to be clear, the faults of HBDers are not big. I have read a decent amount of your writing on the topic today, debate and adjacent content; the more I was reading, the stronger was the feeling that this'll be a fruitless debate. Your writing over the last year displays a trend towards isolated demands for rigor against HBD outlook (for unknown reasons that I assume, for now, are self-preservation and career strategy, a la Abdel The Backstabber, but might be just autistic perfectionism and purity spiraling; take your pick at which is less charitable). Your two examples aren't damning.

Your thread on effort and application of instrumental variables seems to sidestep the problem of scores influencing perception of effort, and anyway it doesn't affect the debate in absence of good evidence for differences in incentives&effort (and, well, whatever happens with low-stakes online IQ testing, people try «as hard as they can» in contexts relevant for long-term life outcomes or even on serious IQ tests).

Your triumphant post on the environmental null hypothesis is… inconclusive, since it doesn't bother comparing models following from theories on their predictive merits (and also other twins and pedigree schemes). You can't just «call» ENH like you so often do on Twitter, and certainly can't just assume that nobody accounts for measurement error, that all causal effects will generate genetic correlations, and thus that the usual HBDer touting of gen correlations/gen confounding is invalid. Take any actually published model emphasizing environment (i.e. an X factor creating race differences – I mean, okay, the gay-bullying-mental illness stuff at least proposes a half-legible causal pathway), and subject it to scrutiny next to a genetics-first one – most likely, it'll fall apart first.

Like Bryan Pesta's career did: it took years of digging by concerned people, but this HBDer got caught on a technicality and made unemployable. He had tenure, too. As for the non-tenured faculty, we can have Turkheimer spell it out. Like Bird says, there is reason to be optimistic about the eventual result of such policies:

Over the last decade the Pioneer Fund appears to have emptied most of its accounts and is at a low level of activity, and the Ulster Institute is similarly operating on slim budgets (Saini, 2019). […] Instead of Nobel Laureates and respected tenure track faculty, the new generation of race scientists on the Pioneer Fund dole are untrained post-graduates.

So there's no money in it; databases are getting closed off too; getting published is near-impossible (note that all those would-be publications deal with weaknesses of HBD research program that you lament). The paradigm is shriveling up and dying (though Hyde would beg to differ). HBDers' incompetence is the intended outcome of censorship. In time, you'll have every self-respecting scientist firmly in the blank slate camp; forget structural equation modeling, unrepentant HBDers won't understand trivial correlation coefficients, and will be wholly undeserving of attention. Won't this make your argument so much stronger? And I think this means your argument is ultimately uninteresting, as far as science or policy are concerned.

So, what view would I suggest? A far more symmetric view: Leftist inclined people want to create racial equality of outcomes, and they therefore boost whichever kinds of rationalizations they can come up with for the achievability and justification of such equality. Rightist inclined people want to preserve racial inequality of outcomes, and they therefore boost whichever kinds of rationalizations they can come up with for the unachievability of equality and justification of inequality.

You seem to use a coarse-grained notion of politics involved, in stark contrast to your (not necessarily correct but hard-to-critique*) analysis of the technical side. Most «HBDers» are the opposite: laymen beliefs both in the heritability of human behavioral traits and in between-group differences owing to genetics overwhelmingly come from raw life experience, not from data analysis and literature; approval of papers is driven by priors and the general vibe. Likewise comes the understanding of political implications; the sense of unfairness in this debate; and the will to signal-boost arguments-like-soldiers of your allies. This sounds low-IQ, and it is, but consilience can be pretty powerful, and HBD is anything if not consilient; so they're justified in not worrying a lot about minor nitpicks.

As for what happens on the other side – let's say that your model doesn't follow from your text and may conflict with the data. Emil sums it up nicely:

Leftists prefer studies where groups are equal, and if not, then where Africans do better. Moderates and conservatives both show a preference for equal-outcomes, and if not, then Europeans do better. As such, based on these results one might say that leftists show pro-African or anti-European preference, and moderates/conservatives show pro-European or anti-African preference. […] The leftist effect was very clear showing up 19 out of 20 times with effects against Europeans and against men. So pray you don't do any research that makes these groups look good and have leftist readers!

Call me a misanthrope, but it's a priori implausible for people en masse to have consistent abstract preferences such as «equality» and «inequality». Equality is an obvious compromise; beyond that, people just root for the team and want their side to be on top or at least not trampled upon. Bluntly, white «rightists» want to not be punished for the underperformance of Blacks, and thus prefer an HBD narrative that puts them solidly below some groups, above others, and absolves them of their purported sin of systemic racism. «Leftists» have other ideas, so they obstruct research into between-groups genetic differences and enforce the conclusion of racism being the leading causal explanation by fiat.

But this obstruction, when perpetrated by knowledgeable people such as Kaplan or Turkheimer or Rutherford, is telling enough, and cancels out all incompetence HBDers and even run-of-the-mill racists may show.