@DaseindustriesLtd's banner p
BANNED USER: temperamental dysregulation

DaseindustriesLtd

late version of a small language model

78 followers   follows 28 users  
joined 2022 September 05 23:03:02 UTC

Tell me about it.


				

User ID: 745

Banned by: @Amadan

BANNED USER: temperamental dysregulation

DaseindustriesLtd

late version of a small language model

78 followers   follows 28 users   joined 2022 September 05 23:03:02 UTC

					

Tell me about it.


					

User ID: 745

Banned by: @Amadan

Have you looked into replit?

In fairness, colorism is a bit of a strawman promoted by people who oppose racial perspective and seek to make it appear more ridiculous. When Anglo racists with above room temp IQs say that Eastern Slavs are not white, they aren't literally trying to compete on fair pigmentation (and by the way Turks can have very Aryan skull shapes)... it's an unfortunate conflation of terms.

And what, you think this is muh IQ and education?

«Sinking ship» may be too strong a phrase but Jewishness does carry social benefits that Whiteness does not, namely access to resources and authority of an ethnic corporation. Can you imagine the reverse of Kanye's case, with some guy calling on Whites to drop Kanye or Nick Cannon?

People do care about ethnic and caste-based in-groups, even if Hajnal whites are on average a bit defective in this respect – even they can adapt. It is historically normal for upper-class (but not necessarily high income) people to think dynastically and seek to marry off their children into a higher-potential, better-protected, well-networked ethnically distinct demographic at the top of the current social hierarchy; this needn't be explained by random, thoughtless romance-driven breeding mechanics characteristic of plebs. Ambitious Jews did that as well when entering Anglo and German higher society, the result being many newly made Baron families mixing with Lutherans and e.g. Rothschilds all but dissolving among the British aristocracy. Now Clintons and Trumps may prosper in a way Kennedys have not, and Pelosis have a stake in the future too.

In fact I contend that for some families this is can be understood as a reward, a result of proving one's dedication over multiple generations. Trump's father had been desperate to demonstrate his and now Ivanka, after converting to Judaism, has become just about worthy of being accepted into the family of a mediocre convicted felon. Pelosi boasts of her father having been a shabbos goy; now some of Pelosi's grandchildren will have a solid defense if anyone calls them Nazi, Racist or Fascist. The story of Clintons and Bidens is probably similar.

Especially considering that the recent events have, indeed, demonstrated that antisemitism continues to exist - such as in the way that one of the most major musical artists, if not the most major, of the recent decades is willing to go to major medias to express clearly antisemitic views?

That's a breathtaking spin on a man with maximally high social capital getting deplatformed in real time. Everything else aside, do you honestly think Kanye's case reinforces your point? What could even have been evidence in favor of the opposite that you'd accept – antisemitism not existing, all antisemites having been rounded up and shot? Literally insane ultra-rich and confident men knowing better than to speak ill of Jews, or Kanye getting quartered in public?

Or are you also building your credentials with conspicuous gullibility, at Eetan's expense?

In an op-ed for the Financial Times, the Endeavor co-CEO wrote that there should be 'no tolerance anywhere for West's anti-Semitism' and encouraged brands to full-stop cease partnering and working with the designer.

Emanuel, himself a Jew, is widely considered to be one of the most powerful men in the entertainment industry. West has repeatedly blamed the 'Jewish media' and 'Jewish community' in the music industry for toying with him.

'This is a moment in history where the stakes are high and being open about our values, and living them, is essential. Silence and inaction are not an option.'

What does it matter if you or the rest of the dissident right deign to categorize Jews as your fellow Whites («enough»), if they are aware of still being Jews? Moreover, what do they gain from this recognition to consider accepting it? You say you're involved in WN circles. How much has changed since this 2011 note, sans the fact that Google doesn't find this page by its title now (even so, results are worth checking out)?

Arguments about definitions are usually interesting inasmuch as they reveal reasons people hold for drawing lines, or talking about those lines in public. It seems that most of the time questions about some group's Whiteness status on the far right are driven by two concerns.

The first is prestige; Whiteness is perceived as an elite club, or perhaps the preoccupation with its membership is meant to conjure this status into reality. A piece by a Cuban-Jewish-American M. Yglesias quoting Ben Franklin springs to mind:

Which leads me to add one Remark: That the Number of purely white People in the World is proportionably very small. All Africa is black or tawny. Asia chiefly tawny. America (exclusive of the new Comers) wholly so. And in Europe, the Spaniards, Italians, French, Russians and Swedes, are generally of what we call a swarthy Complexion; as are the Germans also, the Saxons only excepted, who with the English, make the principal Body of White People on the Face of the Earth. I could wish their Numbers were increased. And while we are, as I may call it, Scouring our Planet, by clearing America of Woods, and so making this Side of our Globe reflect a brighter Light to the Eyes of Inhabitants in Mars or Venus, why should we in the Sight of Superior Beings, darken its People? why increase the Sons of Africa, by Planting them in America, where we have so fair an Opportunity, by excluding all Blacks and Tawneys, of increasing the lovely White and Red? But perhaps I am partial to the Complexion of my Country, for such Kind of Partiality is natural to Mankind.

What's that about? (Incidentally, an American has recently said that I'm one of «Literally the palest people I've ever seen!»). Let's be charitable and assume that Benjamin spoke not of the Asiatic admixture you hint at, but of some less trivial measure of racial quality. East Slavs are low-quality, low-prestige people. Putting Tchaikovsky in your camp is a no-brainer, but you would happily do without hundreds of millions of less illustrious Ruskies throughout history. Likewise, Indians are mostly «Pajeets» but Ramanujan is kinda cool And Pichai runs Google so eh, fellow upper caste Indo-Aryans can get a second-class seat. This kind of discussion makes for a genre of an intra-right status game, where one gets to boast of historical and anthropological erudition, magnanimity appropriate of a superior breed, and/or also condescension and intensity of disgust reaction. This is rather uninteresting to those of us of Swarthy and Tawny Races of the World who don't buy into the idea that the acknowledgement of racist Anglos is a worthwhile thing to pursue. (We're more into acknowledgement of Teutons).

The second angle is instrumental. «Can those people be of use to our White Nationalist cause, and will they?» The pan-White narrative serves to build a maximally broad camp.

The problem, of course, is that they have no reason to come into your camp. Not Arabs or Slavs, and particularly not the Jews.

To put it mildly, in the current year being White is uncool. On average, you get to have some advantages such as on the dating market, but they're not conferred on you by the identity or by group membership; every single way in which Whites have it good is a product of positive individual traits correlated with being White, perhaps to some meager extent of Bayesian priors various markets have due to distributions of those traits. Meanwhile, bad things are inherent to the identity in the social context. Whiteness in the US, and by implication elsewhere, is a construct tainted by the history of slavery and racism, not just due to propaganda or real events, but even simply because of self-sorting. If you want to be on the strong team, you have Civic Nationalism, and therefore identify as an American Patriot, maybe a MAGA Republican or a «degenerate mutt» like Hlynka. (Similar dynamics exist in other majority white states, e.g. France). If you want TRVDITION, you have actual national and ethnic cultures of your forefathers beginning in Europe, the more specific, the better; not long ago, this meant affirming Anglo-Saxon supremacy but nowadays only Putin uses the term seriously. You can also put some other facet of your identity in the first place: from a Trans person to an Eco-Activist, the world offers you many lauded options. Who the hell needs White Nationalism? Only people who have not managed to escape from sanctions levied on Whiteness, or who have deemed such an escape unseemly for ideological reasons. Those are not cool or powerful people. Many of them go so far in repudiating sanctions that they justify past evils.

And the sanctions are severe. One could say that «Whites» are de facto disenfranchised to an extent. They cannot organize, research and lobby explicitly for anything like common white interests, and it is illegitimate to even discuss such interests in the political realm. This is unpopular to notice, but immutable group membership plus the doctrine of group equality allow to smuggle in any kind of demand, including bald extortion under the guise of redistribution to right historical wrongs or straight-up prohibition on critique directed at members of a group. So Whites qua Whites are second-class citizens in their own countries: they do not possess a crucial right to agitate and lobby for their collective interests, and are forced to resort to humiliating roundabout stratagems like economic reforms with desired second-order effects, while inefficiently coordinating to pretend they favor those policies out of some lofty general principle. Jews, of course, enjoy the exact opposite position, because they can simultaneously be praised for stalwart Jewish nationalism and also have legal rights of regular citizens of Western countries, including the right to lobby. Why on earth would they want to be seen as White?

You try to sell the narrative of a common geopolitical enemy. Do Jews need to face those «common enemies»? I don't think so. In fact this is just a rehashing of Islam As The Civilizational Threat To Our Judeo-Christian Enlightenment, a neocon take obviously peddled by Israeli Nationalists to secure Israeli interests. And today Abraham Accords are signed, Israel is improving relations with Arab countries, Militant Islam isn't looking too hot, Iran is on its last legs (as are Jordan, Lebanon) so the question is moot. Africans, lol? What do Israelis care? In general, Israel positions itself as a no-bullshit self-interested Middle Eastern nation that happily deals with other non-Western states, including hostile ones like China and Russia (why not fight them, by the way?); they do not need to be inserted into anyone else's delusional fights. Frankly this search for a threat to unite against looks like desperation.

And one corollary of the above is that strongly identifying Jews who nevertheless grace White causes with their support will be fundamentally unserious about it. They may see value to the «White» civilization, but they know they have their own thing to retreat into if things go badly or their new friends are ungrateful, and that thing's on a much more solid footing. It's a bit of a game.

whether I would support the removal of all Jewish individuals from positions of power in White countries

I believe that the appropriate answer is «What good would that do?»

The problem of WNs isn't that there are many Jews in positions of power. It's that Whites in similar positions have no agency, qua Whites. Chuck Schumer is a conscious, proud member of a millenia-old ethnoreligious community headquartered in Israel, and explicitly takes actions to advance their interests using his position as an American politician (including assistance in suppressing people who notice and take issue with this agenda). Mitch McConnell is just some turtle-looking Republican. If you remove Chuck, Mitch won't start caring about the continuity or glory of your race. Neither will Nancy.

What can be done with that? Not much, I'm afraid.

Obviously endogamy and in-group solidarity are not the same thing, although it's reasonable to assume a correlation.

But we're having this exact conversation every four-six months. The question always is, what's the baseline for comparison? Jews constitute 2.4% of the US as per your source; even adjusted for SES, they are outnumbered by non-Jewish peers in every stratum. Choosing Jews as marriage partners even 39% of the time suggests some preference for endogamy. This is measured by odds ratios in the relevant literature, as described here by, appropriately, Rosenfeld.

New Demographic Perspectives on Studying Intermarriage in the United States, Phillips 2013 in Contemporary Jewry explains further:

Interracial marriage continues to increase for all groups in America (Passel et al. 2010), and commentators on the Jewish scene commonly speak of high and increasing rates of Jewish intermarriage (Wertheimer 2001) as well. But what does this mean exactly? The implied comparison is with earlier time periods. Another way to think about intermarriage rates is in comparison with other groups. Jewish sociology exclusively uses simple individual rates of intermarriage, but for comparison among groups odds ratios are preferable because they control for group size (Kalmijn 1998). As Rosenfeld (2008) explains, ‘‘The odds ratio for endogamy is simply the odds of endogamy divided by the odds of exogamy (or out- marriage). An odds ratio of 1 would mean that the category in question had no significance in the marriage market, because the odds of marrying within the group would have to be the same as the odds of marrying someone from outside the

And there's the issue of, well, Jews not really constituting a homogenous demographic. Orthodox Jews overwhelmingly marry and even befriend each other.

Mixed-ancestry Jews have the lowest odds ratio (50), followed by White Hispanics (329). This means they are less likely to marry endogamously (and more likely to intermarry) than the other groups considered, controlling for group size. Single-ancestry Jews have the second highest odds ratio. [= 2,085].

Religious affiliation, unsurprisingly, interacts with descent.

Endogamy values for [non-Hispanic] Whites are not provided and are a PITA to calculate.

P.S.

The measurement of Jewish intermarriage in the literature on Jewish sociology diverges from the conventions prevalent in demography in significant ways and does not consider Jewish intermarriage in the larger context of American intermarriage. Instead, Jewish sociology tends to focus on interventions that can reduce intermarriage and on the impact of intermarriage on the American Jewish community. […] it combines first with second marriages and does not control for mixed-parentage. When both of these are applied, a different picture emerges from that of the unremitting increase in intermarriage widely portrayed in communal discourse.

I'm not particularly interested in trying to feed you sources to be judged by you on your standards on credibility to consistency standards you impose that helpfully weed out things other people might care about and could even be true.

Holy shit. In a place more lively and with lesser tolerance for loquacious casuistry this would have become an iconic copypasta, to respond with when called out on evidence-free bullshitting.

Of course, it's a perfectly valid meta-level take... assuming it rests on some substance, such as there having been some earlier interaction when sources one can reasonably deem high-quality had been presented; and that's a big assumption which does not match my recollection of this discourse. That said –

you can find the link yourself, thank you kindly, and if you can't then this goes back to competence rather than faith

My recollection is probably retarded anyway.

Thanks to you and @Dean both for lessons in Advanced English.

Right, same issue. I am an egalitarian voter when scores are visible. Too high a vote and, so long as the post, while net improving the forum, has any noticeable flaw – I won't add to it. Too low a vote – and I'll prefer to avoid participating in the dogpile. And of course if my opponent gets to zero while not being utterly insane, I upvote him to encourage engagement.

When scores are not visible, well... gotta vote on the merits. But perhaps it makes for a worse environment in the long run.

Well yes. But he promises turbo bonkers hypermagic with rainbow-shitting unicorns, and repeatedly swears it'll be released 2-5 years faster than turns out to be the case. And he totally milks his Iron Man/Weirdo Autistic Visionary/Space Messiah image for what are sometimes obviously small-minded purposes (and also to maintain absurd PE ratios). So he's a fraud relative to his own hyperbolic marketing, I guess?

Anyway, people just love to hate those who seem to have much more than them.

More subtly, some people here are blackpilled in a particular manner that prompts them to deny that in the current world (which they believe to be on net irredeemable) true doers and dreamers may achieve such abnormal prominence.

For my part, I have no problem accepting that Musk is exactly who he claims to be (but also not what he not-unsuccessfully attempts to hint at being). He's a strong, flawed man in the spirit of the greatest American capitalist champions – Rockefeller, Carnegie, Ford, Hughes... Fate strikes the strong man in the end. But it'll be an interesting ride.

This is hardly a one-off-- there was a nearly identical incident with an NBA player

? Some entertainment workers deleting tweets and so on under CCP's pressure suggests that it's plausible that the world's richest man may turn his company into an asset of a foreign propaganda?

The degree to which Americans accept their untouchability and superiority over the Chinese as the norm, and flinch when this assumption is punctured, is just astounding and unsettling. This NBA story would be a nothingburger, if not for the implicit «wait, those yellow monkeys got an Imperial Citizen to bend the knee?» gasp. (Notably, much greater and more thin-skinned crackdown from locally powerful parties, e.g. team ADL unbanking Kanye West, is received meekly and with nuanced understanding, or kowtowing approval).

I have not bothered to dredge up further examples, but seems like there's a lot of them

Nah, that's pretty much it, a few cases of low-level hysterics.

from incidents where China has exerted leverage in the past the response from American politicians has not generally been anything more than worried hand-wringing

Meanwhile, some fake news in Bloomberg have become a pretext to wholly eradicate China's premier corporation, and there isn't even a pretext claimed for the current round of sanctions devastating advanced sectors of Chinese economy. All this is accepted matter-of-factly by the entirety of the political class and general population, as the Empire's natural entitlement.

It's okay to approve of this, but please stop the underdog act.

I do not believe that you like Trump on the account of economic indicators during his tenure, nor do you try to make it plausible.

The Socialist Phenomenon discusses this, go through the subreddit with Camas – you'll find a couple of my posts in relevant threads.

AAQC material. Thanks for spelling it out.

The degree to which people are willing to twist their minds into knots out of sheer loyalty to Trump (loyalty that they claim is reciprocation of his promise to be loyal to them, despite his consistent inability and at times unwillingnessto deliver) is just sad. The sooner this band-aid is torn off, the better.

I'm not sure how that is technically different or better than the Russian system, or what «dead drop» in this context means. This site alleges that the product is deposited after the purchase, which is clearly suboptimal and more risky due to necessitating more frequent interaction with couriers – in Russia, stores with meaningful throughput just have a catalog of rough locations with already placed stashes, and sell you precise coordinates and instructions.

As for the Polish scheme, this is obviously only feasible when you don't have routine inspections of parcel lockers or people who use them. All that'd have achieved in Russia is crippling the logistics for law-abiding citizens.

We have those lockers. We have reports of people arrested when trying this clever trick. The best drug store in Moscow just leaves stuff buttoned to the undersides of benches of empty bus stops, or stuck with little magnets to some indistinguishable section of a wrought iron fence in a park. The point is that when you are doing something illegal it is preferable to keep a low profile.

Soft sciences are rather incapable compared to STEM stuff. Maybe 160 IQ focused into math does miracles, while 160 IQ focused into soft stuff lets you predict people to some impressive - but not that terrifying - degree?

Or maybe social scientists are just way dumber? Physical Sciences Masters are vastly superior to Social Masters in math AND superior in verbal (study). No wonder: adding to my thesis, it's so painfully clear that our progress in social sciences is kneecapped by the political power of people motivated to use them to obscure rather than discover truth, which repels anyone with half a brain from those fields. Every bit of social science that holds the promise of conclusive, replicable and useful results is politically fraught (of course one could say that safer fruit has all been picked, but was there a lot of it?). We could have had a predictive HBD-based science of economic productivity, criminality, cooperation and social cohesion half a century ago, to say nothing of this polygenic score era, but instead we're still wading through the morass of implicit bias tier fraud and «is freedom of speech worth the consequences»/«shut up scum you have freedom you just have nothing to say» pablum, with grants going into scientific stamp collecting. What do you think comes first, stupidity of the scientists or malice of their effective managers? Does it matter after incentives are, time and again, so clearly spelled out to early career scientists?

On a separate note, @4bpp doesn't seem to give enough credit to Napoleon. It's a somewhat popular idea, that maybe the field is so packed and competitive, our mediocrities would have been brilliant by the standards of yesteryear. Maybe it's powered by the progress in performance of professional athletes, or perhaps by tool-aided improvement in stuff like music. Admittedly I may underestimate Blinken, whose distinguishing features seem to be reliability, stalwart Zionism running in the family, and a history of activism – rather than anything IQ-related (then again, how would I be able to tell if he's hiding his power level?). But, well… this is normal. Napoleon was abnormal.

The more they tighten their grip in the form of economic sanctions, online censorship, social credit sanctions, and lawfare, the more they are validating the claims they are fighting against.

Apt reference to the Social Credit idea.

Would you say the same logic applies to Xi?

Yet he has become the most powerful Chinese leader since Mao, and all of the (doomed to be destroyed by the West) Chinese civilization now revolves around his whims.

There's a lesson here somewhere. Probably this one: power wins. Its exercise validates protests, but only up to the point where it can be plausibly resisted; past that, people fall in line and learn to excuse the blatantly inexcusable, or perish.

I don't know if the tech matters too much. There is only so much mind-reading that a computer can do. Any image generator has to be met halfway by someone that has played around with the generator enough to understand how to get useful images out of it.

But this is equally true of search engines and tagged galleries. When you venture out to find a picture, you have a description, at least in the form of a search query. Text to image models can minimize the difference between this text, treated as a caption, and the output; the ability to minimize FID is how they are evaluated. The best that Shutterstock can do is give you a set of similar images out of a necessarily finite pool of discrete samples. If we account for the time you waste on generations and shuffling through offered options, Shutterstock may have an edge for now due to curation and human common sense and the learned «style» of genericness that has become standard in corporate illustration, partially thanks to such platforms... but that can be learned as well. In the limit, generators will be strictly better at providing the same type of content.

The images aren't supposed to be special. They exist mostly just to break up what would otherwise be an ugly wall of text. We might all be fine reading sites like reddit, but apparently a bunch of people like more variety in their visual space.

Incidentally I prefer imageboards and would appreciate a reddit-esque forum with the AIB style of media attachments (also would be nice to add documents). But beggars can't be choosers. Wonder what's that «intelligent internet» Emad talks about.

Why I would use Shutterstock as a middleman for DALL-E instead of just using DALL-E myself, I'm not sure.

If this were Stability, I'd have suspected a finetune (or these days they seem to prefer using hypernetworks etc.) to produce that classical soulless stock image feel, with old men making the Harold grimace, smartly dressed black entrepreneurs crossing the finishing line, brain tissue looking like lava lamp clumps in a nondescript neon-lit emptiness, and so on. Not sure if OpenAI intends to offer customization of that kind.

Ad for your dashed hopes of regulatory action and the «Contributor Fund»: this looks very unsurprising to me, because as you say, relying on red tape when the models and techniques have proliferated and people run Stable Diffusion on their iPhones (literally) would be long-term disastrous.

I think corporations will try the embrace-extend-extinguish route with regards to content creation, and regulators will attempt to choke the next generation of AIs with preemptive X-risk framing.

One can buy drugs in Russia, iirc they pioneered the hard to disrupt crypto -> dead drop model of drug sales.

Incidentally the flagman of this industry, Hydra, got disrupted in April by Germans. There's not much to this whole darknet stuff, servers are still physically vulnerable. If you crack down hard enough on anonymous/privacy-respecting hosting, you can eliminate current platforms.

If it were true, Napoleon's romantic novel would be known as masterpiece

(anyway, political genius would pick other place to start his career than McGovern campaign)

Power? Job of modern politician is office job that consists of meetings and endless powerpoint presentations

People interested in raw up your face "powah" become cops, border or prison guards

Does non-existence of distinct specialized talents eliminate the role of experience, including experience of your and your family's network? Does the «job» of someone like Putin or Xi consist of powerpoint presentations? And since when is political power (a separate notion from «political office») a job at all, isn't this a hyperstition that commoners (very reasonably, but with incomplete success) try to force onto the class of masters? Do you assert that Derek Chauvin is psychologically the modern day Caesar, while the modern day's intellectual peer of Caesar is fiddling with Haskell monads, and there is no intersection of those categories?

You probably do not. But this is the level of your intellectually dishonest, motivated nitpicking that is not responsive to what I have said.

I wonder how black people will feel if this is what kills Kanye and not...y'know, going against the strongest racial partisan preference in the country.

I think they'll feel fear when they see that even their strongest champion (well, one of the strongest) is a powerless commoner, someone to be dragged through the mud and forced to apologize, in this scenario. It'll be a reality check of sorts, like what happens when Kadyrov's folks come to you to discuss your penchant for talking smack about Chechens on the internet. Thought you're a tough guy, huh? Thought we're powerless pussies? Surprise, we are the tough guys and you are the pussy; now display to all that you acknowledge that, and then hopefully we won't have to deal with really tough and much meaner guys than you in the future. It's a normal Asian practice of group self-defense, in fact it follows inevitably from the logic of honor culture. It permeates Israeli foreign policy and Jewish activism and it works well.

This happens to Black Americans and to other groups from time to time. How much has changed since 1996, really? Granted, some things have changed: for instance, we don't have Norm any more. Nor TV programs where his sort of routine, the gentlest, most plausibly deniable criticism of overreaction, the court jester's hint to the king, can be aired.

If we dispense with the individual will and look at this through the faux-Jungian lens of collective group unconscious, Kanye or Nick Cannon going off the rails in different directions is collective Black America testing and learning the boundaries of legitimate aggression. White people are anemic, weak and undefended – soft, allowed targets. Jewish people are so unallowed you'd best not even acknowledge you can distinguish them from Whites unless you're trying to offer some compliment – and this is, of course, one hell of a reason to learn to distinguish them.

an ancient would-be von Neumann turned Caesar would not prove that mathematical skill is formidable even in the absence of formal mathematics, but would just prove that political talent, whether accidental or ascribed to the hypothetical individual by correlation with his posited mathematical talent, can make you as formidable as Caesar even in the absence of legible political theory.

...Were you under the impression that I assert that a «political von Neumann» is a guy who can do mathematics well and excels in politics on the basis of that sort of ability?

I straight up do not believe in the existence of any specialized «mathematical talent» or «political talent» or any other talent for that matter. Barring the minor effect of subfactors, it's all just general intelligence, general ability to get things done, plus part-innate, part-taught fascination with math or with power over human affairs, respectively. The former fascination guides one into legible transparent domains like math olympiads and then STEM careers, where one's intelligence becomes easy to rank and be written about in textbooks if deemed remarkable. The latter leads elsewhere. Ed Witten could have continued on the track of politics and journalism; he didn't become any smarter after dropping it. I am not sure if he specifically would have made it big, but what I am sure about is that he wouldn't have become as much of a symbol of high intelligence.

Some people say that power over humans is just fundamentally not as interesting to intelligent people as playing with abstractions and earning six figures while being a vulnerable serf, which entirely filters out geniuses. I call them nerds and press (x) for doubt.

Are the "political von Neumanns" whose existence you are positing merely on the level of a Caesar or Napoleon?

Even if so, do you see a lot of those in the official politics? Does, like, Blinken or DeSantis (admittedly, sharp folks) strike you as an equal of Napoleon Bonaparte, with his near-eidetic memory and incredible breadth of competence?

Even if that is some fundamental ceiling, how many of them and their networks would there need to be to make discussions about «memetics», «parties» and «populism» laughably deluded and ignorant of the true power dynamics at play?

Moreover, why would they be «merely» on the level of those two? We have a much bigger population today, better-networked, with smarter smart fractions. And much easier, institutionalized means to hide behind the noise.

I think the argument still remains to be made that US success is at all surprising and in need of such an explanation.

I think we could make some other arguments about inevitabilities (about Heartland or about Old Europe or about the inevitable rise of East Asia or even about the promise of Africa), and also look at collapses of earlier civilizations. Those are mere narratives. The fact remains that American competition falls exactly to shooting themselves in the foot. Zero Covid is not a consequence of the country having issues with indefensible borders. Invasion of Ukraine probably is, but only because we accept the idiocy of Russian governance as a given. The European Union didn't ruin its energy policy because of being fractured more than the US of A is. It's clearly the difference in intelligence; the difference in being able to not make damning mistakes while your opponents mysteriously commit to them.

This is in my opinion a very consumer-like idea of intelligence. «Intelligence is useless unless you already have an infrastructure to plug it into». Or maybe nerdish «Returns to intelligence only scale in very legible technical domains». No, intelligence includes the ability to figure out and devise «sockets» for itself in any domain; and Fat Tony is not dumber than an IYI, for street smarts are a straightforward application of g. Without his scientific education, von Neumann would have plausibly become one of the most powerful bankers in history, greatly pleasing his father. But this should make us wonder why he was born into a banker's family in the first place; and how smart people of old banker dynasties (like Warburg are), seeing as there hasn't been a solid theory of financial capital until recently. In fact, their prominence has only declined with the increase of legibility and theory.

Far from helping design the atomic bomb, could he have even figured out the physics to accurately trebuchet a boulder into a castle on the first try, given no calculus? I think not, so how many grunts would an ancient von Neumann have been worth to Caesar's army?

With any luck, he'd have been worth a few generals, irrespective of his ability to improve on contemporary siege weaponry, and perhaps he'd have replaced Caesar himself in textbooks – which is, in fact, my point; Ceasar was a genius himself, from what we can tell. Intelligence has become a potent multiplier of power long before the industrial age or the dawn of science. Napoleon wasn't smarter than him, but he was smart enough even outside his domain, and he's still our symbol of military genius.

but I don't see the evidence that the same happened for the latter.

Maybe what you see is the result of the latter being flooded with adversarial stimuli. We discuss absolutely inane ideas for reasons that there is a social norm against rejecting them outright and that they are accepted by a significant percentage of the public. Add a little extra noise – and the discourse degenerates into incoherence, and then no progress in scholarship is possible.

But this allows incumbent actors to keep their advantage with no specialized scholarship, with little more than general intelligence, processing speed, access to new data, memory of historical precedents, and networks made of sane allies with healthy epistemology.

Your modus tollens is my modus ponens. The more mediocre «Joe Biden» gets despite the increasing hegemony of the US achieved by well-timed and savvy moves (like this devastation of Chinese IC industry), the more reason I have to suspect that inputs into his political behavior are produced by a sophisticated intelligence not unlike that of STEM geniuses, who are of course privy to the idea of information asymmetry and are happy to keep the spotlight on Biden.

Not the best by any means, but here's yours truly on belief regeneration pipeline (bonus) plus links to other posts (e.g. Sizzle50) there.

Sean Last on trusting academic experts.

Greenwald on expertocracy.

gwern on politics and deletionism in Wikipedia is also relevant.

Funny academic link: “Conspiracy theory”: The case for being critically receptive.

Very cool chart, and definitely satisfies my challenge.

For the sake of fairness, Hsu challenges it here but I believe that's where my anecdotal impression of latest achievements settles the uncertainty.

Do most Americans ever hear about Racine and Corneille, about Flaubert and his master work, Madame Bovary?

I've skimmed it in first grade. Soviets, like the pre-revolutionary elite, were fans of posh European literature and my house had a decent stack of that stuff. We could find other parallels, like the appreciation for High Modernism (some of Moscow architecture is in that style) or whatever.

Do you think that the Soviet Union was essentially similar to France on this account, if not others? I believe it was pretty much an alien civilization.

But there's a similarity, of course. It's the obsession with literature and formal school education as the fundamental frame of reference. Probably there are CCP stans too, who believe that learning Confucius is what makes Xi's PRC the heir to the ancient empire.

Not much to say here.