@DaseindustriesLtd's banner p
BANNED USER: temperamental dysregulation

DaseindustriesLtd

late version of a small language model

78 followers   follows 28 users  
joined 2022 September 05 23:03:02 UTC

Tell me about it.


				

User ID: 745

Banned by: @Amadan

BANNED USER: temperamental dysregulation

DaseindustriesLtd

late version of a small language model

78 followers   follows 28 users   joined 2022 September 05 23:03:02 UTC

					

Tell me about it.


					

User ID: 745

Banned by: @Amadan

Zelensky was and remains a nepotistic, peace-loving, PR-obsessed, meddling clown (which is, of course, still an immensely better background for a national leader than «KGB officer»; Russian people's love for tryhard strongmen characters, culminating in this obscene Sorokin-esque siloviki regime, is a disaster). If Zelensky is to be called a hero, that must prompt us to reassess the very notion of heroism. But eh, not the first time in this war. Very few people have not had to rethink some basic notion, probably.

I reject the premise that him or his top aides fleeing was a priori likely or could determine the outcome of the war. In my opinion, this is all grounded in hubristic and ignorant imperialist attitude, whether native or imported by osmosis from Russia, an attitude that cannot tell Ukrainians from Afghans.

Ukrainians are stubborn. Obstinate. Pig-headed even. They're the type to say «Fuck me!? No no buddy, fuck you» to any perceived slight (e.g. offhand mention of pigs) and think about details later. Maybe that is sufficient to make heroes? In any case, this trait is not dependent on political leaders and, in fact, is the age-old bane of their political leaders. Were he to pull a Ghani, he'd have earned contempt of his electorate (and maybe eventual assassination); army, nationalists and very soon other sections of society would have rallied around, I dunno, Zaluzhnyi to say their fuck you to Putin and the rest of Ruskie Swine. They don't depend on Strong Leaders. They create them out of the crowd. The latest iteration of their culture had begun with telling a spinelss president to go pound sand. In a conflict with a competent power capable of penetrating Kiev in under, say, five hours that'd not have been good enough. But they had to fight Russia, and Russia gave them more than enough time.

This is ethnic psychology. There were more mundane reasons as to why Zelensky was unlikely to flee. Chief among them is that the AFU is (de facto) not that subordinate to the political authority and has had a lifetime of nationalist upbringing and 8 years of war to gain skills and dig in; hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians have gone through the war zone, probably as many were exposed to some extent to territorial defense training. Also important was Europe and USA supplying them with defensive weaponry guaranteed to blunt the first wave of armor and aviation, and of course with intel. The attack was not shocking to them. This fact was shocking to Russia. That's about all. Zelensky or not, they'd have responded because that's what their job was and soldiers rarely just ditch their job.

I don't remember, was it you or someone else early into the war, there was a post with phrasing like «I'm sure Russians too have analytic centers with very smart people dedicated to planning this stuff, and we're seeing the result of one hyperintelligent network beating another, but it's a high-level play, full of feints and moves we cannot comprehend with our limited info». And well, no. Russians don't have anything like that. I'll fully believe if after the war they publish evidence showing that Putin didn't even consult with his «folders» but just watched Evening With Vladimir Solovyov to stay informed. Accordingly, his gamble was not grounded in realistic assessments of his or Ukrainians' forces.

They only needed to be slightly less delusionable to get the upper hand.

ASML is valued like 50% less (it shouldn't be, though); in terms of revenue, TSMC is closer to Apple than to ASML. Also TSMC is only the frontrunner of an entire pleiad of electronic businesses (admittedly more replaceable) – from Asus to Foxconn to Mediatek to Synology, they control many world-class enterprises.

Europeans have a few more extremely successful and entrenched legacy companies of that sort (Zeiss etc.), and of course they're strong in other fields (e.g. pharmaceuticals), but AFAIK no European nation has such an impressively high-tech export structure, pound for pound.

Plus Europeans have other problems. The Dutch, for instance, have imported roughly a quarter of their current population, which the Taiwanese would not even consider.

USA works in most respects, having a healthy well-rounded economy, resource independence and food/energy/everything security, affordability of goods and housing, and protection of rights (especially negative rights, which are poorly comprehended by European legal systems), retaining its unrivaled attractiveness for world-class talent and the virtuous cycle leading it to hegemony. Days when the EU could be seriously discussed as a peer partner/competitor are far behind us, now it's just a poor brain-drained province.

Taiwan works in most respects, having a humane culture (by East Asian standards, and very much unlike the Mainland), functional democracy and some capacity to innovate in governance, good affordable healthcare, and an economy that benefits from virtual monopoly on the most valuable industry near the top of the global supply dependency graph.

Israel works in nearly every respect, especially considering geopolitical, natural resource etc. challenges it faces; it's truly jarring how its dubious liberal creds are emphasized by lobbyists and sycophants, yet nobody among policymakers cares about its most unlikely successes, unthinkable in the EU (chiefly, the ability to harmonize the economy of a first-tier developed country with tradition and reproduction). Pretty much all bad things about their system are either inherent to the ethnostate model (which is non-negotiable) or not very concerning to locals (bad visual design, accelerating shift towards right-wing ideology).

Those are, I think, the most successful and well-run countries on the planet, insofar as we leave aside European anomalies like Liechtenstein and other memes.

Within the EU, there are also more and less well-run «real» states, e.g. Finnish policymaking is, from what I can tell, generally devoid of bizarre unforced errors or even causes for culture war outrage (@Stefferi is that your handiwork?), but they're not that impressive or globally significant.

Thanks, interesting character, this Kriss.

I disagree with you both; it looks you are pulled in opposite directions by biases on the level of temperament. For you, tech feels like a natural and comfortable environment; for him it's noise, distraction, cognitive pollution. I'll take your word on him being tech-illiterate to boot, but as other responses show, that's not a necessary prerequisite for such an attitude at all.

He's probably very wrong on the future of internet. Cycles exist on different scales, and there's no law dictating that booms and busts happen synchronously, amounting to constant total engagement. It may be that there's systemic exhaustion with our current modes of online interaction; this will only make the next boom phase, prompted by some technological shift (near-inevitably it'll be AI-related) more insane. Maybe it'll even be about Zuck's Metaverse, or some less boomerish innovation.

He's very right about ephemeral online activity having very real opportunity costs. Most online happenings are nothingburgers, and they detract from purposeful socialization which disproportionately happens in person or, at least, though legacy, meatspace-centric networks such as one's professional community or political organizations.

But that's just another tax on akrasia and having low standards.

Regarding the loss of agency – you understate this. It's not a minor thing; we are getting scammed out of agency. With fancy UIs and castrated gadgets prompting zoomers towards software illiteracy, corporate mainframes encouraging one to outsource increasingly high-level cognitive operations and surreptitiously becoming adversarial, blessings of scale and specialization patching holes on one side, legitimizing de facto exploits on the other and disempowering even an above-average tinkerer, the Wild West Web has definitely come to an end. A month ago, @FCfromSSC has spoken on Gibson's Neuromancer and... I bet there was some more developed post, damnit. Anyway, what I want to say (and what was in that hypothetical post) is that Cyberpunk was not dystopian at all. It was full of hope, hope for the sovereign individual cutting through the mayhem and inept anarcho-tyranny of the near future, armed with nothing more than his trusty terminal, hacker mindset, high IQ and massive cajones. A solo console cowboy who can have a multi-year career running circles around major players of his economy (albeit knee-deep in the muck of the underworld, living on the edge of ruin and poverty) is a blindingly heroic image today, when Hackernews regulars are all employed by big tech, cultivate their CVs and race to affirm woke rhetoric of their HR betters, just like any other disposable blue collar serf – despite their ludicrous compensation packages and apparent prestige. They have no power within the system and no power without it, plenty of enthusiasm for geeky cooperation and no capacity for guild-building and lobbyism.

They sneer at artists who are getting impoverished by their tech – and fair enough, artists' Gnostic condescension of the higher spiritual caste has been insufferable and unmerited, a case of obvious but still obnoxious ressantiment. That said... artists are at least fighting for their turf. Do developers truly believe that helpful low-level tools like Copilot are where it stops, or are they just broken serfs? In my impression, these first-generation AI assists are akin to DeepDream in image generation. Maybe DALL-E 1. This means we're at most 7 years away from Imagen-for-code, and then the bulk of those folks go the way of middling coom accounts seething about Stable Diffusion right now. How much of their already gimped agency will remain in the world where they're as employable as artists or journalists? Will they still be meaningfully superior to boomers for whom even email is magic? Does it matter how well you understand email if nobody will ever write you and you can't host it yourself?

Tech is but a force multiplier. Political force is as easy to multiply as any other kind of force, and techies have not seized it while building the multiplier. Maybe we had missed the less centralized Cyberpunk option. Maybe the growth of tech couldn't have produced a meaningfully different world. It's like imperial centralization: I can dream of a beautiful Russian Empire ran by some constitutional meritocratic patrician monarchy... thing, leveraging vestiges of autocracy for common good projects spanning generations; commies can imagine much the same for their Politburo; Wolf Tivy can write about State Capacity Capitalism With Chinese Characteristics – but in practice we get what we get, probably what we deserve – lying, corruption, cynicism, idiocy, weakness, ruin, and NAFO types mocking the predictable result. Maybe those two domains are completely dissimilar.

Tech Pessimists have a point, regardless.

On a brighter side: Google has just thrown us a bone in the form of what looks to me like a very good open-source LLM. Thanks.

I think they're totally screwed, like Dotcom bubble losers, like Yahoo and MySpace and other dinosaurs. Dead company walking.

They have no unique advantage, no moat. No irreplaceable data (their own got scrapped already, as OP notes – and, ironically, poisoned datasets with their watermarks), no ML talent (much of the remaining publicly available and underappreciated talent has just been snatched by Emad, and there's no way Shutterstock can compete with MAMAA or what's the current abbreviation on compensation, or with Stability/LW-adjacent ML startups on agility and vision), certainly no specialized hardware access. They are the purest type of rent-seeking middlemen who's been cut out.

If anything, I guess they could rely on some lawyer-magic to strongarm companies into using their service. But they have never developed to that point, and now that Microsoft adds DALL-E to Office replacing their old Clipart, the bulk of their customers will just roll with that or some equivalent.

No. Did you miss that Russia (and particularly Moscow) has one of the highest proportions of cops to civilians in the world, whereas the Baltic sea is, well, a sea, and only significantly observed by NATO members and soon-to-be members?

More directly: this is a silly objection. There is no need to fill the sea with boats to carry out a small diversion, and there was apparently no need to involve local Ukrainians in any known operation in Russia. The presumption of complexity of such an operation is unfounded. We can list reasons to argue that one or the other kind of attack is a priori "easier" till we're blue in the face, but ultimately both are trivial for a nation state like Ukraine, so this is not a helpful criterion to narrow down the list of suspects.

I believe it's fake. Haven't seen the posting. If you enter Musk into their search, it says he was not put up there yet but they are "working on that" (it's the standard form. The whole site is absurd).

Ukrainians are, individually, extremely rude and disinhibited in their nationalism, but this isn't institutionalized. SBU wouldn't just put an American benefactor like Musk on a kill list, even though many on Twitter would welcome it.

I agree that the lack of preregistered hypotheses is diminishing the value of this analysis, but

In which case, I could well imagine some Motte-poster

This is literally «imagining a guy, tricking themselves into believing that guy exists, trying to find a guy who might have said or done things they imagined and then getting mad about it.»

Ukraine shells Russian border regions, destroying power plants, and assassinates people near Moscow; at the moment, it's one of the most militarized countries on Earth with millions of fanatical defenders. Ukrainian representatives tell Musk who provides their state with critical infrastructure to fuck off. Ukrainian decision makers consider Europe not humoring Russian demands a matter of personal, national and perhaps ethnic survival.

Come now. Baltic sea isn't the Moon, 350 ft isn't that deep and 100 kg TNT isn't a lot.

Like, there's two possible futures. In one, the AI reads your mind so perfectly that you don't even need to ask it for what you want, and all you do is consume. That sounds pretty horrible to me, but I concede that there's probably a lot of people who'd happily take it. In this future, Artists are in fact dead. So are humans, in my view. If this is the desired future... well, hookers and heroin are already available, so what's keeping you?

Indeed, but what does AI have to do with it? The issue of fetishizing invested effort as the prerequisite for validation of end result, a la Marxists and PrimaX3, is wholly distinct from the issue of reward hacking. Cutting costs of procuring enjoyable art or another valuable product to almost nil is qualitatively different from cutting out products as unnecessary intermediate stage for dopamine hits. The former approach calls for a high-level conversation about our terminal values, between moralists, aestheticians, utilitarians, replicators and others. The latter one presupposes values, and resolves very quickly into the reduction of human telos to hedonic utilitarianism and human bodies to hedonium puddles, if even that.

But, that strawman aside – yes. Yes, please. Self-expression is better than raw chemical high. AI reading my mind to directly instantiate beauty that seems contained therein has been my dream since… maybe 5-8 years? As soon as my ideas outpaced my ability to express them. Rigorously imagining is a hard enough job for the artist. It was back then that I realized the impossibility of getting good in every domain that feels aesthetically pleasing, and hard limits to human skill. Were I provided some sort of Neuralink (and there finally are some successes – 1, 2) … With age, all of it shriveled and turned to dust, vague sketches of symphonies, images, dreams, whole worlds, making space for dry rasp of texts. Most likely, little of value has been lost in this case. But something is lost with every child growing up, and it adds up to a substantial sum of unrealized humanity.

It's eerie how problems predicted decades ago in science fiction are coalescing into topical conversation these days, soon to be matters of life and death. In 1964, Strugatsky Brothers have written a novelette tititled «Predatory things of the century» about the oversaturated society where people start to die after finding how to use a commodity radio detail plus some household chemicals to resonate with one's inner desires and conjure an imaginary world beyond anything one can live through. The main character, an archetypal Golden Age Sci-Fi/Social Realist hardboiled hero, takes the drug and then, in his head, debates his predecessor who's succumbed to it:

[…] Rimmeyer, I said. Because this world is illusory after all, it is all in you, not outside you, and everything you do in it remains in you. It is the opposite of the real world, it is hostile to it. People who go into the illusory world die to the real world. They are effectively dead. And when everyone goes to illusory worlds - and you know, that may be the end of it - the history of mankind will cease...

...Dzhilin, said Riemeier. History is the history of men. Every man wants to live his life not in vain, and sleg gives him such a life... Yes, I know you think you have lived not in vain even without sleg, but confess, you have never lived so bright and hot as you did today in the bathtub. You're a little ashamed to remember? You wouldn't risk telling others about that life? And you don't need to. They have their lives, you have yours...

...Rimmeyer, I said. That's all true. But the past! The space, the schools, the fight against fascists, against gangsters – is it all for nothing? Forty years I've lived for nothing? And the others? Was it all for nothing, too?

... Dzhilin, Rimmeyer said. Nothing in history is in vain. Some fought and didn't live to see sleg. And you have fought and lived...

... Rimmeyer, I said. I fear for humanity. This is the end. It is the end of man's interaction with nature, it is the end of the individual's interaction with society, it is the end of the bonds between individuals, it is the end of progress, Rimmeyer. All the billions of people in bathtubs, immersed in hot water and in themselves. Only in themselves...

... Dzhilin, said Rimmeyer. It's scary because it's unfamiliar. And as for the end, it will come only for the real society, only for real progress. But each individual person will lose nothing, he will only gain, because his world will become incomparably brighter, his connections with nature – illusory one, of course – will become more diverse, and his connections with society – illusory too, but he will not know about this – will become both more powerful and more fruitful. And there is no need to grieve about the end of progress. You know, everything has an end. This is the end of progress in the real world. Before, we did not know how it would end. Now we do. We couldn't comprehend all the potential brightness of real existence in time, maybe we would have reached that knowledge hundreds of years later, but now it's in our hands already. Sleg gives you a perception of the furthest descendants and earliest ancestors that you will never attain in real life. You're just a prisoner of the same old ideal, but be logical, the ideal that sleg offers you is just as beautiful... After all, you've always dreamed of a man with fantasy and a gigantic imagination...

Dzhilin ends up suggesting a «hundred year plan for restoring and developing human worldview in this polity» but never elaborates. Authors themselves believed that this is an abnormally «Western» book in their oeuvre, full of horror for the future of humanity and proposing no answers. Censors and literary authorities also took issue with it, including the eventual Minister of Culture of the RSFSR Melentyev – who helped bastardize the first print edition, but ultimately deemed his failure to guide this book to an idealistic resolution the only dark spot on his conscience.

…I think we haven't made a ton of progress since then.

Anyway, regarding technicalities. The «fine search» is very fine, about as fine as one's ability to put opinion in words – assuming a smart enough model. Stable Diffusion is pretty dumb, but there are ways to refine the search that look e.g. like this now (taken from 4chan, courtesy of an anon with apparently zero prior artistic experience; I'd contend he's a real artist or at least illustrator now). And of course text-guided img2img/inpainting is trivial; if this were part of some mature editor package, we'd have convenient tools to select, guide and mix features as such, without grasping for words (maybe based on some distant relative of cross-attention) . Will it be a tool? Naturally. But a tool allowing one professional («artist») to make dozens of artisans (and hundreds of Photoshop layers) obsolete.

We do not have unlimited appetite for stimuli, this isn't a game of positional goods. Not running out of music – or art for that matter – is largely due to art's social function, people's limited long-term memory and preference for novelty. We have, more or less, found all melodies, but we cannot listen to the same song on repeat forever. In a sense, content is a means of hijacking the basic reward system (porn especially is) – if you don't change the exact shape of the stimulus, the brain learns to dismiss it. But AIs do variations perfectly.

I'll freely admit that I didn't follow most of this passage, so maybe he's just that much smarter than me. But I don't see how "meaning has become an engineering problem" is a supportable statement, or even a likely prediction

He's smart indeed, but it's more of a matter of familiarity, and understanding this part is crucial to appreciate the rest of his rants about vectors and dimensionality; all of it makes technical sense. I suggest you start with Jurafsky&Martin's Speech and Language Processing, and see how «meaning has become an engineering problem» is a well-supported statement, not a prediction but a description of the current state of the art in NLP (pun intended). Check out ch.6 («Vector semantics and embeddings»; click this link too). 6.8 covers Word2vec, one specific (aged) engineering implementation of meaning related to the one used in Transformers, and specifically in the text encoder part of Stable Diffusion. Maybe you'll conclude that on its face it's a drastically less rich notion than the ineffable human «meaning», one limited to the space of our text corpora.

But in principle it can be made much, much richer. And I don't need FOOM for that.

Define copypasta. Anime-girl, like any "object", can be described as a projection in the plane of some three-dimensional model with superimposed textures and lighting. The girl, as a model, cannot be patented (unless it's a branded object like hello-kitty or Mickey Mouse). But even a branded object is assembled from geometric primitives – spheres, cylinders, triangulated surfaces – covered with commonly available textures and painted in standard colors.

OK, you'll do what they do now - make some verbal description of the style and a set of examples of that style in the form of pictures proprietary. But style is a point in a huge "style space." Some dots are now occupied by authors, some by corporations, some owned by no one (like tumblr noses, etc.) – but the vast majority of style dots are free. Neurobros will simply go and create new styles – or generate new ones as unlike the existing ones as possible by interpolating the old ones. And what do you do? Train a neural network that will assess the degree of coincidence of the author's and copycat's manners of writing? Well, it will start to register all the usual artists as thieves, most of whom will not even be aware that their way of drawing is similar to someone else's patented style – because there are a fuckin' million artists and it's impossible to know them all. As soon as the person starts to draw and posts the first picture, he'll get sued for stealing the identity of some obscure patented artist – because the picture will be similar to this artist's "naive_relism_№9714443" or "primitivism_№540235".

You can't patent a sphere. You can't patent the color blue. You can't patent a girl with a dick. Can't patent the slap. Can't patent the grass, the sky and the sun. The point of Transformers as ML models is that they have no ceiling on the level of abstraction and depth of image analysis (which you, for example, do have: below is receptor resolution, above is a ceiling on the complexity of the patterns being analyzed). It doesn't steal fragments of other people's images, it stupidly parses the world into ontologically real objects like people and trees, or geometric primitives, textures, shaders and lighting, and then mixes them.

The only thing you can do is to forbid using images of authors to train models. But then they would be trained on open datasets – and "styles" would be pulled from publicly available classics or the same interpolation of existing styles. Or, you can just set a reference point in the shape of a model trained on real photos, and define "style" as the sum of the deviations from photorealism, generate a million random deviations and set up a focus group to evaluate them and select a few of the best tens of thousands of them. And all of these styles cannot be considered "stolen" because they will have been created as transparently and honestly as possible.

You hope in vain that Uncle Styopa The Militsioner will come and protect you from nefarious thieves. Or that the Top Skills will raise a stink and show the arrogant technicians their place. But here's the thing: there was no theft. [...]

It's not the picture that's "stolen", it's the idea. How are you going to codify an idea? Here you have Beksinski, for example. You have a collection of his paintings - they are copyrighted not as sets of ideas, but as some instances. Each painting is protected as a unique object, but inside it are thousands of ideas, assembled into an original construction of universal yoba-blocks – both created by Beksinski himself and stolen by him from someone else. In theory, you can break down each picture into blocks, brands, logos and labels – that is, you can select a set of objects as "Beksinski's mickeymouses", select the original "Beksinski textures", the color palette "Zd_Beks_001", etc., and catalog it all in albums as prototypes. Then you can set metrics to estimate the similarity of other people's mickeymouses to prototypes in similar albums. And that's it, that's no more you can do.

Except that there are billions of such prototypes, and most of them are unoccupied and have never been used. A neural network will generate a bunch of mickeymouses and textures and palettes, check that they are far enough away from the prototypes (far enough away that you can't sue them) – and send them to production. Or it may prove that Beksinski himself looks like a lot of other dudes and stole half of his original style from them. And the shit will go down the tubes like never before in the history of art.


Copyright was created accounting for dishonest people and with technical means of editing in mind – but it's powerless against the technical means of the human level, which doesn't screw anyone over but just finds solutions similar to the ones people have the skill to find. And in addition to these already found solutions, it can find a million others.

The problem is, after all, not with the model itself, but only with a questionable dataset in terms of copyright. In a year it will all be the same, but trained not on garbage, but on open and clean data. And no lawyers can do anything about it.

Generally speaking, the main question every artist should ask himself is: what in my profession is really creative and what can be attributed exclusively to technical skills? The sad truth of life is that in the profession of artist, almost EVERYTHING can be attributed to technical skills and tricks around human cognitive bases and visual illusions (aka "academy", "shadier in the shades, lightier in the lights", "work not from the line, work from the blot" and so on), while the real "creativity" comes down to a dozen elementary combinatorial methods. And that the complexity of their production (in the sense of the length of the description of the structure of cultural artifacts – paintings, statues, etc.) is incredibly low and meets a clearly distinguishable upper ceiling, ceiling which generative models do not have at all.

That is, most artists are not creators, but designers, ordinary outsourced corporate servants, aesthetic engineers who «make it pretty» for the masses of workers. And in the long run all this stoned and drunk public will go straight to the streets, because a neural network can "make it pretty" much faster and better than all of them put together. And on top of that, it doesn't drink, it doesn't get high, and it doesn't fuck up deadlines. Unlike them.


Stop hiding behind semantics, wanker. The words «think» and «invent» mean nothing and function solely as mental plugs in everyday psychological discourse. SD works as a semantic archiver – something like a winrar, which effectively compresses data without the possibility of unambiguous retrieval. In terms of statistical learning theory, it reconstructs a hierarchy of probability distributions over a finite sample – that is, it solves the general problem of induction. From the point of view of information theory, it reduces the entropy of the data. From the point of view of computational theory, it splits the original data into data structures and algorithms. From the point of view of algebra – into a basis of initial elements and a basis of elementary operations. The same is done by neural network structures in your own head and social network structures consisting of creators, gatekeepers, fans and patrons analyzing, generating and filtering cultural content.

A neural net doesn't pilfer art. It fundamentally can't generate a single original object from the training dataset because its compression during neural net training was done with IRREVERSIBLE data loss. If you compare the prototypes from the dataset and the generated pictures pixel by pixel, there is nothing in common between them. At the level of complex textures and brushstroke and line techniques, the similarity will already be visible. At the level of gestures and compositions, the similarity will be 50-70%. And at the level of color schemes, it would be as much as 95%. Do you know why? Because artists have been using the same basic set of poses, angles, compositional techniques, color schemes and light sources for centuries. That squealing animal on Twitter didn't invent new poses, angles and lighting methods – he took them from catalogs, from the mainstream or from «how to draw bullshit X» type pulp manuals. And to prove this, just run a semantic search on the original dataset and you'll find tens of millions of supposedly «original» and «copyrighted» images, which in reality are virtually indistinguishable from each other. Because the Internet has long been choked with copypastes and generics. But it's not the neural network to blame, it's the artists who, instead of doing creative search and active experimentation with new styles, have sold their souls for likes and are generating monotonous mainstream millet around the clock.

All of your so-called «anime», from the neural network perspective, is nothing more than a dense clump of pixel distributions, a single object(Anime) - a limited, dumb, primitive set of visual schemes that activate dopamine receptors. It's not art, it's kawaii engineering. You don't solve creative problems and you certainly don't set them – you're just doing calculus and graphics work at the picture-building university in the department of anime glamour. Real artists are not threatened by anything – their product is authentic, material and forever fixed in real time and space, merging human tragedy, history and destiny. But you are not artists, you are decorators. The «derivativeness» of the neural network is just a mirror reflecting your own derivativeness. And don't blame the mirror if your face is crooked.

I'll take this as an invitation to translate a couple more of his posts. @FCfromSSC, @Primaprimaprima, @VelveteenAmbush, @07mk may find it interesting.


Blah hlah. «A neural network is just a tool». Instrumentality is not an essential characteristic, not a set of immutable and stable invariants – it is just a position in a net of relationships. Photoshop is your tool. You are a tool in the hands of the customer. The customer is a tool in the hands of media corporations clogging up the information space with hyperstimuli, pussytriggers, freakcodes, miyazaki-glitches, and other visual-advertising slop. In this hierarchy of tools, you're just a gasket. You are tolerated only for the time being, being used as a cow to milk for datasets. While corporations cling to their «know-how» with a deadly grip, the goyim are being sold on «sharing is caring» out of every newspaper. So, how'd it go, guys? You like it? You want some more, or you got it figured out already?

luckily there's me, who knows both neural networks and drawing.

Judging by the millet you've chewed up here, you know nothing about either. Even worse, you don't even know anything about yourself, and your doctrine about man is hundreds of years out of date. You see, the future is very unevenly distributed over mankind. Conditional modernity is an integral sum of anachronisms, the civilizational clock within different social strata is at times lagging, at times gaining by thousands of years, and while the fiery sparks of futurism are rising into the sky, somewhere deep under the silver amalgam of modernity the tectonic plates of archaicism, which roots dig into the Paleolithic, are heavily tumbling. I have seen [fields, Neo, vast fields] whole institutions filled with former-people, unable to grasp the moral obsolescence of their own discipline. They live, and sometimes even live very well – but their lives are as relevant to modernity as the life of a bushman poking the earth with a stick.

You are a former-person, a representative of the Paleolithic. You vastly overestimate both your own complexity and that of the culture that has produced you. You wave your pokestick menacingly and seriously believe that your so-called «academia» is something more than the mere escheated craft of projecting probability distributions learned by the visual cortex into a two-dimensional peephole. Hail to the great academia! Hail the ball of feces molded by the calloused hands of industrious dung beetles, a combination of kolkhoz hunches, try-anews and rules of thumb, carefully handed down from holey teachers to their equally penetrated students!

It doesn't even occur to you that instead of «building a nose» as a perspective projection of 3D into 2D, which some 3D humans force others to learn doing for years, you can «build a face» as a generalized object in 1000000D-space – and get all potentially possible, that is, all fitting into model-learned probability distributions, human faces as projections of this generalized object into the plane. The neural network does not need to «build a nose», it is already built within it as an element of some hyper-object in hyperspace – and, unlike you fool, it can project this nose into a subspace of any dimension: into a line, into a plane, into three-dimensional volume, into ten-dimensional volume, anywhere.

«Constructing» is not your forte, it's your bottleneck. The obligatory decomposition of the image into hundreds of layers of Photoshop, priming and underpainting is another bottleneck, a phoney and lifeless detour where a neural network can cut a straight path. The local, single-channel application of the picture using hand as the manipulator, slow and semi-random coverage of the plane with monotonous brushstroke patterns, all that stuffy, mothballed, chthonic horror, is just a creative disability in comparison to the neural network that builds an image globally, multithreaded over the entire plane of the canvas, and which, unlike you, is just as globally and multithreadedly able to build objects of any dimensionality.

And the point is that artists are actually paid in areas where this very consciousness is needed. So that there'd be a concept of a girl for a crappy mobile game, and she needs every string on her backpack and pocket on her jeans for some reason.

Oh so that's it, pockets on her jeans. A veiled attempt to appeal to the informality of pragmatism. The most flaccid argumentum ad props I've ever encountered. By the way, do you remember what year Ackoff's On Purposeful Systems came out? Was it '72 or something? Trapped in the shut-dead vault of their own stupidity and ignorance, members of the creative class still find even long-solved problems cognitively impenetrable.

To have her redrawn forty times in different angles and come up with every little detail of how she expresses emotion, how she is built, how she moves. ANNs, faced with such a task, will fart out a bimbo toilet with random strokes instead of details and that would be it.

Ten million «consciously done» entangled and crooked and forsaken paths, thousands of tons of glucose burnt in the cracked craniums of the creative class – and we end up with the same ten standard plots and a couple hundred classic archetypes. This is how functional-structural convergence works. This is how power law distribution works. This is how ethical and cognitive specialization of sapiens works. A finite number of basic emotions, a finite number of their variations, a finite number of forms of group interaction, a finite number of social conflicts, a finite number of characters in the actor network – «love» here, «treason» there, »family» to the right, «war» to the left. Locally, you're all incredibly individual and monstrously creative – but when you go out into the vastness of the Artstation or even the most obscure booru, one clutches his head. A woman with tits, a woman with a dick, a woman strong and independent – a foreign, eggplant flavor girl. What is obscured in small samples, becomes evident in big data. It's all the same shit.


So people have decided to make a project, +1 more tool to an already long list. What's the deal.

Fractal laughters. Sneers within sneers.

The deal is in the multimodality, in the virtually implemented possibility to reconstruct the latent model of «the world» from its two qualitatively dissimilar discrete projections. Instead of the natural language (or rather, its stripped-down version used for tagging) and a piece of N^n characterizing geometric and color space, you can take any two models of anything fixed in any arbitrary languages – and build a proxy-manyamirok [delusion-world] with them, guaranteeing a coherent inference in each half of this bicameral. This is the same «Geometric Machine» (?), only built on self-learning, providing x1000 in power, and in addition capable of running on any cardboard plug, not just a distant mainframe of the eggheads.

Multimodality enables you to avoid local roadblocks by changing the representation, allowing you to bypass the problem area along a parallel model, either by rising to another level of abstraction, or by decomposing the problem into subtasks within a more concrete and detailed representation. Connecting a hundred bicamerals on different pairs of models into an orgraph, we get the very thing the fathers of cybernetics dreamed of and about which St. Academician Ivakhnenko directly wrote half a century back: a multilayered hypersurface of layer-models connected by forward and backward connections of information archivation and inflation.

Considering the fact that such structures of models docked into polyads keep popping up in various fields related to reasoning, from mathematics to cognitive sciences and from Lotman's culturological essays to pedagogical articles, one may suggest that they are as universal as the g factor, cortical columns, deep learning models and other abstract motes like atomic theory in physics, set theory in mathematics or finite element method in engineering. In any of the local domains, sooner or later a universal methodological wunderwaffe capable of completely covering the problem field is discovered.

Understanding is a transformation of information within a network of models representing other models and themselves, a long branching tail-cyclic graph, a rhizome of algorithmic tunnels conveying through the system a long echo of mutual interpretations, a reverberation of meanings in autoreferential algorithmic corridors. Did you understand what I just said? I didn't either. But this is how it is. We implement this transformation every day, every second, within hundreds of parallel threads – and use its results in the form of object icons on the screen and a dull linguistic constructor, with which we desperately try to fight reality.

Attacking Vasya [who doesn't value true art] won't help you. It's not about bydlo, it's about the fact that «meaning» has become an engineering problem, literally just now, before your very eyes. And instead of assessing existential risks and opportunities to hedge them, you've taken a couple of dumb verbal devices and are trying to assemble either a butt plug or a virtual inner politruk out of them. Repent, simpleton – you'll get a discount.


cont.

It's clearly a reference to (geometric but perhaps also algebraic/differential) topology, but he wrote the word in English, which seemingly communicates sarcasm. I believe he didn't mean the genuine application of those mathematical domains to plain word games covered by the rest of the paragraph. It is possible that this is a nod to Lacan style postmodernism. Consider this passage from Alain Sokal & Jean Brickmont's Fashionable Nonsense:

These authors speak with a self-assurance that far outstrips their scientific competence: Lacan boasts of using “the most re­cent development in topology” (pp. 21-22) and Latour asks whether he has taught anything to Einstein (p. 131). They imag­ine, perhaps, that they can exploit the prestige of the natural sci­ences in order to give their own discourse a veneer of rigor. And they seem confident that no one will notice their misuse of scientific concepts. No one is going to cry out that the king is naked. ... Lacan’s mathematical interests centered primarily on topology, the branch of mathematics dealing (among other things) with the properties of geometrical objects— surfaces, solids, and so forth— that remain unchanged when the object is deformed without being tom. (According to the classic joke, a topologist is unable to tell a doughnut from a coffee cup, as both are solid objects with a single hole.) Lacan’s writings contained some references to topology already in the 1950s; but the first extended (and publicly available) discussion goes back to a celebrated conference on The Languages of Criticism and the Sciences of Man, held at Johns Hopkins University in 1966. Here is an ex­cerpt from Lacan’s lecture:

This diagram [the Mobius strip17] can be considered the basis of a sort of essential inscription at the origin, in the knot which constitutes the subject. This goes much further than you may think at first, because you can search for the sort of surface able to receive such inscriptions. You can perhaps see that the sphere, that old symbol for totality, is unsuitable. A torus, a Klein bottle, a cross-cut surface18, are able to receive such a cut. And this diversity is very important as it explains many things about the structure of mental disease. If one can symbolize the subject by this fundamental cut, in the same way one can show that a cut on a torus corresponds to the neurotic subject, and on a cross-cut surface to another sort of mental disease. (Lacan 1970, pp. 192-193)

Jacques Lacan: Analogy to what? “S” designates some­ thing which can be written exactly as this S. And I have said that the “S” which designates the subject is instrument, mat­ ter, to symbolize a loss. A loss that you experience as a sub­ject (and myself also). In other words, this gap between one thing which has marked meanings and this other thing which is my actual discourse that I try to put in the place where you are, you as not another subject but as people that are able to understand me. Where is the analogon? Either this loss exists or it doesn’t exist. If it exists it is only possible to designate the loss by a system of symbols. In any case, the loss does not exist before this symbolization indicates its place. It is not an analogy. It is really in some part of the re­alities, this sort of torus. This torus really exists and it is ex­actly the structure of the neurotic. It is not an analogon; it is not even an abstraction, because an abstraction is some sort of diminution of reality, and I think it is reality itself. (Lacan 1970, pp. 195-196)

etc.

Was that it? Who knows. I can go and ask of course, but don't feel like it.

Somewhat off topic, his dirge to lost playgrounds has reminded me of this blogpost by Hugo de Garis. I thought there was something directly on topology there, but alas.

There is another main motive I have. I call it “Building CATHEDRALS of mathematical logic” The CTFSG is the most beautiful and most powerful piece of mathematics I have ever seen. I call it a cathedral of mathematical construction. It is dense, tight, enormous, extremely rich in structure (e.g. look at the Monster with its 10 to power 54 elements) and has the capacity, for anyone with a good math brain, to become totally engrossed by.

I notice, that when I get heavily involved with it, I begin to feel a happiness that ordinary living, with all its daily frustrations, does not evoke. This total engrossing provides enormous satisfaction as one masters the CTFSG step by step, absorbing and memorizing its huge pile of definitions, and then playing with them, to build massive mathematical structures, i.e. “cathedrals” of logic, mathematical logic.

I never go on twitter. Like, at all.

Well you could go and see comments on AI-related tweets. Very often it's some cartoonish beg-mid level furry fetish coom pronouns-in-bio type artist, a politically involved one to boot, who's using /ic takes about soul and tech bros, and what's especially hilarious, who rails against «caputalist ethic inherent to tech assholes» while protecting his tiny patreon turf from the deluge of post-scarcity imagery. It's just an unthinking, cuckoo-like, instinctively self-serving attitude, something beneath human dignity in my book. I think I can find a few even starting here. (One hilarious find: pro-Ukrainian coom artists canceling their Russian peer for being pro-war and drawing Genshin's Venti Wagner style; artists are snakes and their intuitive sense for policing networks is uncanny). I mean folks like this and this and this and so it goes all over the place (it's not universal though. Counterexample: this guy). Goofy NSFW is the bread and butter of art scene. I didn't try hard here, it's really ubiquitous.

What I'm getting from this is that you don't like porn art.

I'm okay with porn art. I just don't see the point of having humans spend their lives on learning to do it, and to the extent that they go into Luddism to defend such a career choice, I believe they're selling out their essential humanity. I do not care to protect this incredible niche for aesthetic expression; if they have extra libido that somehow needs a release in the form of pictures, they can do it without getting paid. Otherwise they can use it on their partners or maybe wait for robo waifus. In the general case you know as well as I do that coom art is almost purely driven by market demands and not some self-guided aesthetic development, it's just a way to earn a living.

I originally wanted to learn how to draw so that I could make my own art for my video game projects. So I should be the exact target market for AI art, right?

Right. Exactly.

Which makes me think that your value system is even more alien and deserving of deeper oblivion than those of natural artists. Maybe it's a blessing that you won't apply this tech to more efficiently make games that send some message and influence other people's views.

I think Emad is substantially more intelligent than he lets on on twitter/discord, but also «visionary founder» is often to some extent an idiot; they both naturally exhibit those traits and learn this hot dog vendor chutzpah from the noxious superstimuli-ridden startup culture depicted in one famous sitcom*. (Does Musk's Twitter indicate intelligence?) It's good marketing at this stage of the project, if anything – followers love him.

In reality they are doing some clever things to work around their late comer disadvantage. For example, they're hiring all the memey Twitter ML stars who have been underappreciated by corporations; hardmaru is not Hinton or Le Cun, but he's good and also decades younger, so it's an interesting bet. I am also not sure if these nonsensical projects are not at least 50% real – everything he posts related to audiovisual generation is in principle doable and his hires ought to be chomping at the bit to do it, only hamstrung by compute.

He is also much colder and rational in business matters than the hyperactive tweeting indicates. This quid pro quo NovelAI-Automatic story is evidence enough; «community vibes» are very important but not as important as moneyed partnerships.

Ultimately, the idea seems to be «fuck it, we need compute, any ML talent we can get and visibility, the rest is easy». And even if the rest is still hard, I can see where he's coming from. It's jumping into the last door of the departing train. With what Stability has got, they are an entity at least theoretically capable of surviving the Purge by means of some of those galaxy brain business ideas. The second act, then, is triage.


April 24 / May 7, 1919

I’m rereading The Precipice [Goncharov’s Обрыв]. It is long but so intelligent and forceful. Still I have to force myself — given that I find these Mark Volokhovs so repulsive now. What a multitude of hooligans have descended from this Mark! “How can you creep into someone else’s garden and eat their apples?” “But what does this mean: ‘someone else’s garden or apples’? Why can’t I eat when I feel like it?” Mark is a brilliant creation, and here lies the remarkable business of artists: an individual captures, distills and reifies a type, one that has existed diffuse in the air, and does it so well that sometimes his presence and influence increase a hundredfold—in complete disregard to the purpose his portrait had. One wanted to poke fun at the remnants of knighthood, and has created a figure who never existed in life, but became the catalyst for hundreds of Don Quixotes to spring into existence. Another wanted to castigate all the things that were associated with Mark, but wound up giving birth to thousands of Marks whose origins were already not in life but in books.

Generally speaking, how does one distinguish between that which is real and that which books, the theater, and films give us? Very many living people who have taken part in my life have had, most likely, far less of an impact upon me than heroes of Shakespeare and Tolstoy. Others have allowed Sherlock Holmes to enter their lives, and some maid allows in some woman whom she saw in an automobile on the movie screen.

– Ivan Bunin, Cursed Days.

Incidentally, Thomas Gaiton Marullo's translation (at least my copy) is nonsensical, to the point he seems to confuse Goncharov in the author's speech with Cervantes and utterly mangles the passage about real people and characters. I tend to suspect that this is one reason for the weird reputation of Russian lit, which some Westerners adore and others take to be cryptic pretentious ravings of drunk madmen. Our prose is often philosophical, but it's more like philosophy of the naive Socratic and Western Moralist tradition and not any clever Postmodernist sort; a translator needs intelligence as well as common sense to work with it, not indecent infatuation with Ze Slavic Soul. One shouldn't let Muscovite culture pass through Brooklyn intellectuals on the way to the library.

Historically, people with "something to say" have gravitated towards literature, philosophy, and other forms of non-fiction writing because, well, words are how you say things.

As a wordcel I agree, but that wasn't my point (perhaps it could be better said, but again, character limit). You can still «say» things non-verbally. It's just that artists who scream the loudest now are mere illustrators – and pin-up and smut illustrators at that, especially if you go to twitter, to furry dens. They were of the (correct, up to a point) opinion that it was a good career fit for their natural talents, it wasn't a calling of the heart or whatever. I know a guy who went into coom drawing to build a capital to begin trading! They don't have any special mood (unlike, surprisingly, many low-skill sketchers whose content is vastly harder for the AI to grok), any really interesting ideas beyond technical gimmicks to their art, they're just cynically exploiting human degeneracy, and when they start to whine about AI being «demonic» and «satanic», man, it's so fucking funny. I have seen sagely advice like «don't bother with fingers anon, no commissioner scum looks there and it wastes time, on the other hand you have good anuses and cunts which is key to raking in cash, but they're too dry, put more liquids there, like calm does...», and to know that the same people then go and accuse AI of lacking comprehension or some other essential human quality because it draws hands badly is... hahaha, «get bent, clowns» is all that comes to mind.

Well there are a lot of people who think your "beauty and meaning machine" is blatantly evil and anything it produces is automatically disqualified from being meaningful and beautiful

«Something that's not in my material self-interest of maintaining market scarcity of certain products I possess the otherwise non-transferable means to produce is blatantly evil because, ehh, whatever» is not the profound insight you lot seem to believe it is. And such cavalier shallow moralism, in my opinion, disqualifies you, and all artistic guilds, from having an authority in this issue, and suggests that your outsized role in the distribution of content influencing emotions and attitudes remains a major threat to the polity.

Like @EfficientSyllabus says, in «the real world» artists aren't doing too hot, whereas techies are in great demand. But in their own frame of reference, artists are the master race. Moreover, it's not mundane conceit, like low-grade techies' own boasts of having high IQs or earning a lot while creatives flip burgers. It's more similar to Russian ressantiment-powered invectives directed at the West: artists have unusual, rich SOVLS, and their entire trade is about conveying their inner depths to the thankful audience (which is near-universally despised and considered to be scum with trash taste, however – especially in light of their interest in AI content), Techies are the complete opposite of artists: ignorant of SOUL, of beauty and love and other lofty categories, mere bugmen churning out code to make the corrupt machine of capitalism run smoothly, crushing the fragile wonder of the human heart etc. etc.

This is insulting on its face and, what's more, it's laughable chutzpah. There is of course art in STEM and specifically in coding, and it's not lost on developers who wander into artists' dens that there's astounding cynicism, small-mindedness and mercenary attitude among artists. It's a crab bucket where every crab gatekeeps his secrets of drawing some perverted fetish (often a sort of furry or dickgirl) to cater to a niche audience of degenerates.

Thus their scorn.

Excellent!

Incidentally, I do not post there. 4chan is banned in Turkey, my VPN is banned on 4chan and bying a passcode or investing effort into cheaper workarounds feels not worth it. Still, I've written an angry response for a yet another maddeningly arrogant thread – struggling to fit it into 2000 characters – the other week, before finding out that no two-bit hack works. This is as good an opportunity to share it as will ever come.

Please don't take it too personally. Ahem:

Some of you have the temerity to wonder why techies, whom you hold to be soulless drones, hate you. Hear me.

Your skill is wasted on you. Not «you» inept @furryfutart99, nor a handful of greats, but your trade collectively. You have NOTHING TO SAY.

You care not about the world, its complexity and regularity. You're incurious flesh dolls with shallow notions of life beyond your trade, perversions and substance abuse. This very topic is proof enough – none of you have an inkling of how ML works, else you wouldn't be parroting stuff like «a search engine!»; disdainful of truth, you bend words you can't grok into gotchas to get the upper hand.

Nobody outside your guild gives a fuck about your «creativity». You are artisans and 99% of your worth is technique: steady arm, patterns memorized, quirks, comprehension. You seethe because AI is better in 2 of 4 already. As for 3-4, spare me the nonsense based on seeing SD or MJ – since you don't understand the essence of the tech, you cannot tell transient shortcomings from signs of innate limits. Still I'll explain.

You may win this legal battle. But know that if you do, it will cost you the war. You will be consigned to oblivion.

AI learns image-text correspondence in the general case, thus it can compress a database of 100TB into GBs. To wit: your «styles» are vector strings of some KBs at most, superimposed on a 3D scene. For the AI, an artist's name = a single filter.

Should you deny us copyrighted content for AI training, we will still have real photo, video, older artifacts... The principle of «aesthetics» is easy to re-learn with that. «Creativity» too. Then we will navigate this space, and find features and styles beyond yours, and give them inhuman names, and forget you lot like a bad dream.

AI research is the apex of applied philosophy. We have turned ideas like «meaning», «novelty», «beauty» and others into engineering problems. Become deathless letters of the solution – or wither away.

You can choose.

...now, in a less 4channy mood, I need to admit that artists do have a point. Making them obsolete using their own work is a scummy move, regardless of artists' character flaws. And mundane considerations of fairness aside, we need a framework for the coming AI era where all jobs will yield to machine learning at some point. One option would be to institute a sort of collective entitlement, monetary and cultural, for members of guilds whose jobs have become automated, because the sweat of their brow, examples of their product, has enabled the creation of that automation to no lesser extent than the work of developers. A derivative «coom artist» can go pound sand on Twitter. Greg or Clive should have a stake in the pie of machine-produced visual content, and maybe some Prometheus Medal for their contribution.

But of course even their habits and egos are not worth hampering the greatest celebration in history.


@2rafa: no idea how the law will decide, it seems that purely by the letter of the law artists have no case, but the law may be changing soon. The logic above is why I tentatively approve of artists and other IP holders getting their wish come true and excising their stuff from training data. Spamming tags associated with generically high-quality pictures (which is all there is to «by greg rutkowski») is tasteless, and training models on Greg to learn his style along with his themes is silly and inefficient, but it's such an easy shortcut it may clog our creativity for an arbitrary span of time. With fat-soaked American IP like Mickey Mouse it's even worse, why keep clinging to it in the age of visual post-scarcity? It only ever got anywhere due to starting early. We need a clean break and an Aesthetic Space Browser, and the surest way to develop it is to begin with taking away the easy and cheap option. Now that the potential is known, the way there won't take as long.

Below is a translation from a Russian /ic/ equivalent, one of a series of texts that I consider to be some of the best writing on this subject available anywhere, from a man much smarter and a better writer than myself, and an obvious inspiration. (if anyone wants other texts, let me know).


Man, that's so funny fucked up.

«Artist growth». «Income». What income now.

The basic model understands Euclidean 3D in classical perspective. Why this particular space? Because this abstract model is the most efficient way to explain the presented set of data. Why does it understand «objects» and the orthogonal group of transformations? Because it is the most convenient way to compress the data through a hierarchical decomposition of the visual field. Why does it understand lighting? Because, just as in the previous cases, the model was able to reverse-engineer the scene and decompose it into surfaces, light sources, and color space. Why does it understand «style»? Because «style» is a microscopic speck in terms of information volume, a cosmetic superstructure overlay for the underlying geometry, textures and lighting.

And yes, «composition» is also an element of style. So are different kinds of perspective. For a mangaka, «fish-eye» means years of wrestling with built-in visual cognitive biases, painstaking fiddling in awkward 2D, selecting, combining and projecting primitives, generating and tracking pencil trajectories, iterating a loop of deliberately memorized algorithms with elements of pseudorandom – assembling a cognitive chimera from the elements of thought amenable to control. For the model, it is only a vector weighing a few kilobytes that directs the hierarchical blending of the base elements.

Shift by vector plus cosmetic rendering. Click – an orange grows a coat of feathers. Click – feathers become made of glass. Click – fisheye. Click – reverse perspective. Click – Kuvshinov. Click-click – Vrubel. Gumroads have never taught anyone anything. Creative work is a pipeline. 99% in the technical tricks – and a bit of lucky pseudorandom.

And it's not even the beginning, it's just a precursor. Text, pictures, music, video, speech. Sculpture, architecture, engineering. What even is genuinely complicated in our culture? Mathematics? But proofs of theorems are isomorphic to programs – and coding, too, is kind of, well.

Only meat and quale will remain for the market. You can't carry quale to the market. Hence, only meat.

...I'm just complaining. We've all been blackpilled to the point of being stiff a long time ago.

That's not the essence of it. Creativity is now officially a closed topic. Well, you know, not very long ago, among the linguistically oriented highly intelligent public (philologists, writers, language philosophers, mathematicians...) it was fashionable to do topology, play word golf, admire Hofstadter, and subscribe to "Word ways" magazine. All we have left from those glorious times are scraps, fragments, and vestiges in the form of ubiquitous arroword and crossword puzzles.

The end of the glorious era came almost immediately by historical standards. And not because the fashion has changed and people got bored with something there. Just because there appeared a cheap microchip, capable of closing all open problems and finding all the interesting structures in about an hour – even without any algorithms, just by brute force.

The topic was closed. And no one even noticed how it happened. It went down quickly, almost immediately. Flip-flop, and that was it.

Poets have been constructing palindromes for centuries. A microchip came along and found them all. Aristocrats played word ladders for decades. A microchip came and built them all. The thicket of texts was once home to the most fascinating pokémons – but a microchip came and collected them all.

Dickgirls, dickgirls on dickgirls, vegetables... Does it hurt, doesn't it hurt, is that really what it's about now? [Skill] ceilings don't decide anything anymore. There are no ceilings. That's it. Flip-flop on the scale of an entire culture. I haven't made it. I was too late. And there was only a little bit left to go. Oh, man.

This is sensible, but so is «rationalists should win», and you know which camp the bulk of those rationalists ended up in (neither yours, nor the winning one, except for half-hearted ones). Inasmuch as conflict theorists act rationally to succeed in their respective conflicts, they are just game theorists. Conflict theory is a somewhat more extreme mindset with stronger priors regarding specific interactions.

Also, it's a frame invented by Scott, who has an innate love of manipulating narratives.

Thanks for understanding my point, in any case.

In support of mistake theorists and against outgroup reification

There's even more drama in the AI art sphere than before. Actually multiple dramas, all around Stable Diffusion, as is customary now. Artists on Twitter are threatening class action, half-seriously rallying around Greg "by greg rutkowsky, trending on artstation, 8K" Rutkowsky, Palmers and others; Danbooru is being slowly purged of content on takedown requests, in the wake of NovelAI SD-based image generator release (drastically superior to earlier stuff, and allegedly tracing over whole pictures); StabilityAI Discord has banned Automatic111, a hero and pillar of the community, the developer of the leading UI, due to him being an asocial Russian asshole implementing means to handle the recently leaked (by a third party) NovelAI models and allegedly stealing like 20 lines from their proprietary code, apparently to placate NAI and send a message to future pirates and business partners about Emad's priorities; Voldy denies the theft and counter-accuses NAI of copying his prompt-weights code without license; Stability staff/mods, it is claimed, have taken over a community subreddit by guile, to no comment from higher-ups (update: Emad magnanimously agreed to concessions); Emad keeps postponing the release of an improved 1.5 citing great responsibility and «tweaks to handle extreme cases» which is taken to mean «castration on dataset level». It looks like another Open-for-profit company has been revealed as an embrace-extend-extinguish scheme, and we will have to learn, after all, to pool resources on our own. Or maybe it's all catastrophizing by excitable FOSS fanatics. The situation develops rapidly.

…But I'd rather leave the drama discussion to @Porean, seeing as he's posted it first, and talk about something less spicy. After interactions with Hlynka here, I want to share an observation about conflict theoretic lens and unhelpful labeling of the outgroup – such as artists on 4chan /ic board calling AI users «pajeet».

This has to do with Emad's origins and the racism-tinged contempt for «soulless tech bro nerds» pervasive among the 4chan creative intelligentsia, of course (the Twitterati attack soulless tech bro nerds as such, without racial qualifiers). No equivalent prejudice against South Asians exists in Russia. So, there AI users and people arguing in favor of this tech are labeled «neuroschizo». I wonder about other sectors of the Internet.

Yes, singular «pajeet», singular «schizo». It's not just a meme. They (well, many of them) report it to mods as such, they whine about a sleep-deprived obsessive fanatic who keeps pestering them in their strongholds (a not-so-implausible scenario, but clearly wrong in this case). And I posit that this is Indicative Of A General Failure-Prone Tendency Of Conflict Theorists, who have a powerful presence here. I have ridiculed Scott's Conflict-Mistake framing myself. But the core objection – namely that the Conflict model is evidently true, as well as people's willingness to lie in service of their terminal goals – may be a cognitive poison pill.

Anonymous imageboards have been a mighty forge of internet culture. What is often underappreciated is how strong they are pound for pound, in terms of active user or post count – even the biggest 4chan boards are like a middling subreddit or Discord/Telegram chat. Why is that? Freedom of expression, lack of reputation and all that jazz, you know it. But I think that they're a bit similar to latent diffusion models: they are more efficient, due to compressing the trappings of a social network into a lower-dimensionality space. By stripping identification and the complexity it can carry, they allow – nay, force – individual voices to be associated instead with archetypes of groups, in every individual interaction. You cannot be a token, like on Facebook or what have you: everyone is a type, but which type, depends on the mood and the topic. This inflates the effective population size to parity with a big society where full connectedness is impossible and knowledge about others must spread by rumors and vague stereotypes. It makes boards a self-running, accelerated social experiment. (admittedly this theory needs more polish)

Anons know, of course, that they are few in number (although a Legion). And they can see that people are pretty stable in their quirks. And they are aware that people can lie when it serves them. So they overcorrect into reifying recognizable opinions as marks of an individual or at most a small coherent group. Someone sneering at «Chuds» comes, in /pol/ mythology, from some specific discord – and needs to be reminded that he «will never be a woman». On /ic/, someone explaining how latent diffusion works is… «cool story pajeet».

It's an experiment that represents, at small scale, the superstitious nature of network age paranoia. In larger communities, the same assumptions are applied on group level. Everyone who disagrees with me is a Russian bot! Except if I'm a Putin loyalist, then it's gotta be ЦІПСО, Ukrainian propaganda division (that's what I am these days, according to many of my compatriots). If you're an American Right-Winger, it's some sort of GloboHomo WEF talking head. If you're a good progressive, it's probably a Fascist representing a unified anti-Lib front.

This is psychologically comforting for a few simple reasons.

First, such a problem is very legible and simple. There's no structural reason for the thing that oppresses you to exist and be the way it is, no grandiose system of incentives, just malign will of a finite set of human actors, fallible flesh and blood with a self-serving narrative.

Second, it's surmountable. Calling the enemy out is half the battle; getting him banned is another one fourth, after that you just gather up the boys and attack his turf. The hostile group is not representing the majority of the population (usually is puny), is easily identifiable and kinda ridiculous. Maybe just one weirdo, a «pajeet» or «chud» at that.

Third, and most importantly, it excuses ignorance. You can plug bananas in your ears because conflict theory predicts that the enemy will lie, or try to deceive you while not technically lying, to demoralize you. And why would he keep investing effort into that, coming up with arguments tailor-made for you? Of course because his onslaught isn't really going according to plan, in part, precisely because people are not falling for it! That's what those artists think too. AI proponents are lying collectively to break their spirit; they just need to wait it out while the pajeet runs out of steam; they don't need to adapt.

They're wrong.

It's unhelpful to have a dead wrong model of the conflict they really are in. One big and obvious reason: because it precludes communication with people who are different but not the enemy and are trying to help – or at least negotiate. In trying to not be a 0HPLovecraft-style quokka, such a conflict theorist ends up being simply a myopic rat, destined for being made marginal and obsolete. The great discovery that counteragents might lie is a point of a wholly unreasonable pride of a certain brand of reactionaries. It's also a source of a delusion as damaging as the inability to conceive of bad faith.

Tl;DR: Conflict theories have a failure mode or reifying the opposition, that can lead to cognitive closure and lack of response to arguments. The very assumption of bad faith, without extra precaution, bootstraps the development of theories on how bad faith propaganda is being delivered to you, for what reason and by whom. From then on, truth is ever harder to find. People should remember that, when assuming they can see through the opponent and dismissing opponents out of hand.

Duh, that's what the elites want you to think!

if we accept that the IQ numbers for Africa are the result of a culturally-unbiased assessment of intelligence, then Africa would be a society of actually literally retarded people, which it is not.

This is such an annoying and ignorant argument. Clinical retardation is not just the condition of having low IQ.

Has it ever occurred to you that you're just paranoid? «IQ is heritable from parent to child and this is why we need to brain drain East Asia, also my wife is Han Chinese» sounds more like it.

You keep strawmanning your opponents with an appeal to the Nazi-esque notion of racial purity. Maybe it has place in your internal version of ye Olde Worlde intellectuals. Maybe it even has merit. But it's a misrepresentation. Nobody here, far as I can tell, cares much for purity per se; HBD of the sort discussed in this thread is about quality (or rather, quantitative measures of specific qualities), and quality can be found in any race (albeit to unequal extent), and does not disappear upon admixture. Germano-Japanese mixes wouldn't have been inferior to the real unspoiled deal any more than your Anglo-Germanic pals proved to be. In fact one needs no genetics to recognize this truth.

if things like intelligence and personal discipline are primarily genetic why are the children of our elites so consistently idiots and drug addicts

First, citation needed (no, other than Hunter).

Second, it must also be shown that the process of becoming an «elite», i.e. a member of the political class, is substantially meritocratic. Perhaps political animals pass through some other pipeline than one requiring merit of the kind incompatible with drug addiction and stupidity. I do not observe high rates of idiocy and drug addiction among the progeny of liberal academic elite you love to sneer at so much; rather, children of tenured math profs tend to become math adjuncts or maybe quants at Jane Street, as the regression to the mean predicts. And they do more to build up a great nation than Bidens and Trumps.

Second, the axis would have won WWII. The Japanese and German militaries both entered the war with a substantial advantage in technology and training over their opponents.

Lmao no they didn't, and that's not starting to discuss industrial capacity and, more to the point, general human capital.

You are an undisciplined thinker, which I suppose is in your eyes a fair tradeoff for another kind of discipline. You seem to equate HBD with particular self-serving German National Socialist beliefs, which irrationally posited superiority of German stock over other peoples of the world (and Yamato subjects had their own sort of racial hubris, grounded more in their legitimate successes in recent major wars than in some theoretic HBD scholarship). By the end of the war Germans have «discovered» that not only are Anglos perfectly capable of matching their Teutonic spirit or whatever, but that even Slavs aren't inept Mongoloids like they came to believe.

Here's Himmler whining about it:

Then you hear the next prayer. This goes: "We were wrong about the Russians." This song is usually sung by men from some eastern province, who were over there in their youth, some of whom have written very good books and had a Russian mother, too, and now they tell stories. It is also sung by the little political vagabonds whom we first came to know in the eastern struggle against Poland, whom we rejected at home, and who have now been drafted as soldiers, officers and majors, and are still peddling their intellectual poison under cover of the uniform of our decent German army. Goaded on by this propaganda tendency -- I can't call it anything else -- they tell you so many stories, or write them home by military post (and the stories then trickle down from top to bottom): "Yes, we were wrong about the Russians. The Russians are not at all the robots" (this is the expression used most frequently) "that we thought they were in 1941. Now that we're over here in the East, our eyes have been opened. The Russians are a noble people”, and so on and so forth, “a collection of all virtues. We just have to educate them as National Socialists, the best thing would be to create a NSRAP or something similar. Then they would" -- this is the next bit -- "form the army of liberation under General Vlasov".

You're straight up wrong. Like the Nazis were.

If the HBD-Tards' and Woke-Cels' theories about race were accurate

Instead the racially diverse, hopelessly disorganized (IE decentralized), and utterly lacking in warrior spirit/tradition armies of the Aglosphere

Come on now, this is peak PoMo. Wokes predict that diversity breeds success, they have pseudo-mathematical papers on that.

P.S. How's that diversity and disorganization working out for Russian Federation right now?

P.P.S. A Borderer descendant talking about the lack of warrior tradition, that's rich.