@DaseindustriesLtd's banner p
BANNED USER: temperamental dysregulation

DaseindustriesLtd

late version of a small language model

78 followers   follows 28 users  
joined 2022 September 05 23:03:02 UTC

Tell me about it.


				

User ID: 745

Banned by: @Amadan

BANNED USER: temperamental dysregulation

DaseindustriesLtd

late version of a small language model

78 followers   follows 28 users   joined 2022 September 05 23:03:02 UTC

					

Tell me about it.


					

User ID: 745

Banned by: @Amadan

This was a triumph.

I'm making a note here:

huge success.

It's hard to overstate

My satisfaction.

Aperture Science.

We do what we must

Because we can.

For the good of all of us.

Except the ones who are dead.

But there's no sense crying

Over every mistake.

You just keep on trying

Till you run out of cake.

And the Science gets done.

And you make a neat gun.

For the people who are

Still alive.

I have been convinced of the truth of HBD mostly by 1) first-hand exposure to stereotype accuracy, i.e. life experience 2) reading scientific papers 3) appreciating the sheer intellectual vacuity of blank slatist rhetoric. That isn't, truth be told, knockdown evidence to any but a very scrupulous observer with a good eye for inconsistency. In principle, human societies are dysfunctional enough that we could be missing trillion dollar bills on the sidewalk, neglecting low-hanging fruits of environmental interventions that semi-randomly and without notable spikes in investment produce outstanding talent; the world could, in broad strokes, look very similarly to how it looks and yet not work according to theories of hereditarians. (Ironically, the near-universal institutional HBD denial despite widespread, traditional conviction that children inherit traits of their parents is evidence enough of our societies being too dumb and diseased to figure out good policies).

Still, if we do not assume a hopeless scenario of that sort, I'd have expected:

  • Very efficient interventions that are surprisingly simple, like drinking deionized water or never calling your child a dumb little shit once. Probably only practiced in closed elite environments (and kept secret/discouraged for plebs).

  • Following from that, stronger and increasing correlation of class and intelligence, as well-off people (who are already motivated to force their children into grueling training, IME) figure out the best regimens to get their dynasty an edge over competitors. After all, my main reasons to not be a hereditarian had been anecdotes about early life training leading to eminence in adulthood (Polgar! Sidis! Wiener! Mill! Mozart!) – surely with modern data and scientific methodology something better could be found.

  • Far different distributions of traits: lack of positive manifold, strong culture-bound (and ethnicity-blind) talent density, and more «comic book» style individuals with specific hyperdeveloped abilities.

All in all it'd be a pretty optimistic world – one where we're close to figuring a somewhat cheap method of universal cognitive and physical enhancement. It's a wooey world of the psychedelic revolution. I'd not be against living there.

Some people are suicidal, and this is a nicer and more dignified way to commit suicide. It's easy to support this on generic libertarian or even (trans)humanist grounds; the state and society are, ideally, not entitled to deny people their exit rights.

What's more unpleasant about the situation is that this libertarianism is very skewed by what one could call «Cheems mindset» or perhaps medical ethics. We don't have a legally enshrined freedom of form and being: we have only freedom of diminution, freedom to make yourself something lesser or avoid some medically recognized pain at some cost, rather than modify arbitrarily.

You can get feminizing hormones and antiandrogens much, much easier than you can get T (unless you're an FtM trans with «dysphoria») and HGH. You can get euthanasia but not euphoretics and not any serious research into cognitive enhancement. Some claims to the pressing need to change are recognized and affirmed; others are laughed out of the room (imagine incels petitioning for state-mandated masculinization treatment).

It shows that this isn't really about freedom, but rather about some blind and selective idea of compassion. The sort that's grounded in the notion of humanity which doesn't seek to grow, only to stop suffering. It's not the sort of humanity I want to live together with; hopefully there'll be an answer superior to the euthanasia booth.

I think we have a word for that: «safety».

But in China it's achieved precisely by embracing low trust, by covering every angle with CCTVs and emphasising the inevitability of punishment.

Once again, I have to link to that old comment of mine, referencing even older ones.

And when it's impossible in a given domain to approximate the consequence of native Western levels of trust with such ham-fisted measures, you get Chinese science – and Steve Hsu in the US.

Ah, apologies, forgot where I am. A small lesson in how low-trust peoples act in such a situation:

DOI: 10.1126/science.aau8712

https://www.sci-hub.ru

https://sci-hub.ru/10.1126/science.aau8712

Alternatively: https://sci-hub.hkvisa.net/10.1126/science.aau8712

(for some reason those mirrors yield different versions of the article).

It's patently clear, IMO, that China is one of the lowest-trust societies on the planet and probably the lowest-one by far among states with above 95 average IQ.

I like this measure: civic honesty. Dishonest people are untrustworthy, after all.

To be clear: Russian Cosmism is no more nationally Russian than a roulette can be. To wit, it may be a particularly telling expression of an archetype in the national soul, which is how the label got earned from third parties, but that's it – unlike Tseghakronism or Kızıl Elma or German National Socialism or «White Man's Burden» or any other particularist doctrine. Fedorov did derive his ideas from the Eastern Orthodoxy (and devoted a fraction of his writing to criticism of other faiths), pointificated on Heartland peoples vs Atlanticists and even saw value in Romanovs' Autocracy; but in principle – he cared more about Russia for two explicit reasons. First was his belief that problems he wanted humanity as a whole to address are especially urgent in his homeland. Second was the impression that it's easier to make Russians aware of it. Consider some excerpts from «The question of Brothership, or Kinship, The reasons for non-brotherlike, non-familial, i.e. non-peaceful state of the world, and the means to reconstruction of the kinship: a note from non-scientists to scholars, spiritual and secular, to believers and unbelievers» (he was very verbose):

[…] These two types of social system (organism-like and Trinity-like), one in full bloom, the other in its infancy, are represented at present by England or the West in general, and by Russia (if only Russia has not yet been finally Europeanized) and all the agricultural peoples, respectively. The second type, an embryo for now, belongs to all without exception, because it is truly human and truly divine (in God lies its full reality); but this type was preserved mostly with the backward peoples, among the savages, in the provinces.

The West, with England at its head, considers the doctrine of the Trinity to be the most anti-philosophical doctrine, and for some reason even mystical. Had Christ said «I am not in You and You are not in Me, and those in eternal discord, outside of us, let them be» or «I versus you and you versus me,» etc. – then this doctrine would not be mystical and anti-philosophical, because no other unity, except economic and legal, is now accepted, and the struggle in all forms is considered the condition of progress. Russia wants (if only it wants?) to be that which the West has rejected and cast off; and if it accepts this model (turns to it consciously), it will assume only a duty, an obligation, and, while in this case it must serve as a frame for unification in the image of the Triune God (i.e. for the revelation of the kinship of all mankind), it cannot already be a party, a side, it must avoid war and direct its activity to the removal of the causes of enmity, and above all, in itself, of course.

If Russia is compelled to wage war, it cannot consider itself righteous either, for to become the belligerent party means to lose brotherhood, although this may be mitigated by generosity and unselfishness. The fault of Russia lies in the fact that the social type, which the inheritance of the tribal contains, is not completely expressed in the structure of the society or the state, and is not even properly formulated; on the contrary, we imitate the Western example, which is not peculiar to us. According to the western view, which has lost consciousness of the true aim, the aim of uniting people is to achieve material and moral well-being; but this is impossible for a society organized like an organism, for this system is essentially immoral; in this system the majority is made a mechanical tool, with the reward for unilateralism in beautiful clothes and similar goods, and the right at leisure, if there is a desire, to give opinions about anything; a small minority is given to cognitive work. […]

Our task is quite different; it is not invented, not contrived, it cannot be for us an object of pride […]; the whole of our advantage lies only in the fact that we have preserved the most primitive form of life, with which a truly human existence began, i.e. the tribal life. It is based on the fifth commandment, and yet we have survived the death of the ancestors! The only sin we have not committed is that the whole nation has not yet renounced the paternal covenant. Christianity, we might say, has given final form to the fifth commandment; and in this final form the fifth commandment is the very essence of Christianity. The revelation of the eternal birth of the Son is that the Son, being born as the Spirit proceeds, and being both separate persons, are not, however, separated from the Father, but remain with Him in inseparable unity; This is the opposite of the Universe, which has not yet attained self-consciousness through man, Universe in which every succeeding part absorbs the preceding part in order to be absorbed in turn, and where life, because of the isolation of the worlds, cannot be expressed except by the succession of generations; the individual sentient and conscious person dies, and only the race lives, it alone does not die, does not vanish, is preserved. With the fifth commandment comes a new era in the universe, new relationship between subsequent and previous, between fathers and children, and in Christianity this commandment changes into the commandment about the resurrection, the duty to parents is not limited only to piety, whether European or Chinese; and the consequence of this commandment will be not longevity, but immortality.

[...] This is why the duty to parents cannot be limited to reverence alone. Christianity eliminates this flaw in the Old Testament commandment, turning the matter of desperation into a matter of hope, a matter of resurrection, and from the duty of resurrection derives the very duty to children. Children are the hope of the future and of the past, for the future, i.e. the resurrection, is the turning of the past into the present, into the actual. And brotherly love can only get a firm basis in the resurrection, because only this will unite every generation in working for a common goal, and the closer this work will come to it, the more brotherhood will strengthen, because the resurrection is the restoration of all the intermediary degrees, which make us, brothers, one clan, likening our kind to that inseparable unity in which the Father, Son and Holy Spirit dwell. If our kin has disintegrated and we have turned into kinsmanlike peoples and estates, and if the same process of disintegration continues within peoples, estates and individual societies themselves, the reason for this phenomenon must be sought in the absence, in the lack of a firm basis, i.e. of a common goal and common work; and there is and can be no other high goal, natural, unfashioned, unartificial, except the resurrection of fathers, or in other words the restoration of universal love.

It's not just transhumanism. It addressed directly some problems of futurism we are seeing now, and demanded an ethical system that would put humans first. Not «utility», not «hypothetical conscious beings», not «civilization» or «nation» but humans who live now and have ever lived. Compare this to William MacAskill, this British Socrates of our times, the champion of Western Transhumanism, who implores of us to think of the world where not only our fathers but all of us are dust and the Race lives on, collecting utility points; who sees no value even in cryonics. Then, compare it to SecureSignals, who is a white nationalist and very much not an Effective Altruist, here – and you may have an idea as to why Cosmism is specified as «Russian».

Karlin himself advocated for reinventing it as the basic firmware for the state ideology, but it's in line with our perpetual search for the national idea, which is to say, attempts to insert stuff you personally like or consider advantageous, like some cartridge, into the top-down indoctrination machine. In the same way we have «Russian libertarianism», «Russian national liberal democracy» (no, that's not LDPR) and whatever. Consider his glib buzzwordization of the topic, which reeks of his Californian background:

From RNS [Russian National State] [...] to RSI (Russian Space Empire):

Second, we need to build a truly inspiring national myth, instead of today's #CrimeaOurs (which automatically reminds us that even Novorossiya is not ours) and the Cult of the Great Victory (which began during the Brezhnev stagnation and reached its apogee under Putin; rapidly transforming into a multinational festival that interests only Soviet dinosaurs and nobody else).

It is necessary to look not only into the past, but into the future: it is necessary to revive Russian Cosmism as a state ideology.

Cosmism is in fact transhumanism – but more authentic, older, and without transgender connotations.

Cosmism, it is: Explosion propelled craft, Martian colonies, radical life extension, cryonics, robots, automation, universal income, bionics, Internet of Things, cryptocurrency, deep web and the Great Silk Road, Robin Hanson's age of ems, technological singularity.

Cosmism is also AI and genetic augmentation of intelligence – the two most important components.

I note that there is no contradiction between the implicit Reactionary nature of the RNS and the bright future of the RSI.

We are not the same, as the meme goes.

There's that too, certainly. But in fairness, I think NAFO dogs are disgusting on their own.

One of the strongest cases of Russian resentment is «Why can't I do what America can», the trivial rage of the bull who envies the Jupiter. But nowadays it's more like «Why can Estonians do and get praised for doing what I am shunned for». Karlin tried to make Russian imperialism into a funny, presentable memeplex, with Powerful #aesthetic and Westerners going «gotta hand it to them», a scaled-up Crimean annexation. What happened is... a monkey's paw version of it, with his people the butt of the joke. Whereas NAFOs are playing it straight: memes celebrating Russian slaughter, merry funding solicitation, cute doggos, socializing, «ehehe there's no such thing as the CIA, wink wink». And they are racist, at least many of them, in the most basic sense that they do hate Russians irrespective of this conflict, and are happy for their sentiment to be normalized. They're what Z-stanning couch-warriors wanted to be.

Agreed, but there's cause for optimism: MosaicML shows that large models can be a whole lot cheaper to train than previously believed. Half a million for a GPT-3 equivalent is... well, you know. It's not limited to GPT type systems either.

Also, the Chinese are being pretty nice as of late.

I'll admit this tweet made me nervous for a while. Mysteriously falling down stairs and quietly going off stage «to take care of personal problems and improve health» is something I 100% expect to happen to disturbers of the General Arc Of History. Emad ain't it yet, it seems.

But even if all of those failure modes are avoided, corporations still have the advantage: PR, established distribution channels, and the general problem of there being way, way too much content being produced. People will go watch the latest Marvel capeshit to keep in touch with each other, and in addition to that, they'll consoom a hundred medium-scale indie creations and fifteen thousand TikToks a year. Each one's own unique set.

Even if the total fraction of the indie content increases, it may only contribute to the relative dominance of the mainstream, astroturfed, censored culture.

I don't know much about ethics. Consequentialism seems like a decent starting point. What would the purpose of it be, what can be accomplished by sacrificing «Muscovites», even if such an option were offered – well, outside of narrow ethnotribalist and familial goals that require no universal ethical justification?

Russia is inherently worth more than Putinism, but not infinitely so. New independent nations on its ruins could implement something... humane, for a change. Tatarstan especially has most of the trappings of a functional sovereign polity, so I understand their conceit (except, you know the map and what it'd mean in practice for Tatarstan to secede).

On the other hand. The crux of the issue is that ethnic Russians in lands with their historical dominance will not just be allowed to form new states but be made крайние, and it is not clear what they can offer others (as in, every group that can credibly cut ties) in return for sharing the blame. Common economic space? We've seen how that worked out with the Commonwealth of Independent States. And even Russia herself has less than stellar logistics between her regions. «Culture?» Hah. Nukes? Afraid we're not keeping those after it ends. Local hegemony to suppress conflicts? Ask the Kyrgyz how it's going.

And Balkanization is not the worst that can happen. Like some of them say, «a moat and a wall around those subhumans». Putin's successors will be happy to oblige.


Krylov's New World Order Thesaurus is more prescient than ever, nowadays. I wonder how much of it will be implemented?

The Moscow trials are actions by the international community to condemn and punish crimes committed by the former Russia against peace and progress of mankind. The First Moscow Trial was organized by Russian human rights activists and had no legal force, but its recommendations were favorably received by the international community. The Second Moscow Trial, known as the «trial of Russia», was the most important one; it laid the foundation for the political system in the territories of the former Russia. All Russian states were forbidden to have territory in their exclusive possession (that is, they could exist only as co-owners). The institution of trusteeship over the former Russian territories was established. Each Russian state must have at least three official trustees. All Russian states were required to have Geneva-standard Constitutions, with significant limitations on their rights. In addition, a large-scale program of derussification was adopted. The Third Moscow Process registered the objective collapse of the totalitarian community of the Russian people, removed some restrictions from a number of Russian states, especially from the Russian Empire and St. Petersburg, which were allowed to have their own territory (see Nuvorashi). At the same time it was decided to make the Moscow trials regular commemorations of the victims of Russian crimes against humanity. The Fourth and Fifth Moscow Congresses were held as memorial shows on a commercial basis. Of the important decisions, the Fourth Congress authorized the merger of the Russian Orthodox-Catholic Zemshchina and a number of smaller Russian states.

Russians - as defined by the Second Moscow Process, "the totality of national diasporas of former Russia and former Yugoslavia (HS), sharing a common criminal past and liable for it before the International Community (excluding peoples with the status of enslaved by the Russian regimes or having merit before the International Community in the establishment of democracy)". Residents of most of the former Soviet national republics and autonomies, as well as descendants of the new Russians (see Nuvorashi) are not considered Russians. Most Russians speak Russian, Komi, and Serbian (according to a special decision of the Second Moscow Process, some residents of former Yugoslavia, mainly the so-called "Serbs," are considered Russians). Considered to be carriers of totalitarian complexes. Subject to significant restrictions on their rights. The current number is about 40 million.

Test for the absence of totalitarian complexes in the psyche - called "obedience test". It is applied mainly to Russians, as well as to persons suspected of being mentally unstable and having totalitarian mental complexes. It is not obligatory, but without the certificate of passing the test the Russians are not hired by large companies. The procedure was developed in the course of the Second Moscow Congress. The test subject (under the control of psychologists) is subjected to various humiliations (verbal and physical) under the control of a "lie detector". If the performed actions do not cause aversion or internal resistance in the examinee, but only fear and guilt, the test is considered to have been successfully passed.

Tribal wars and the quest for meaning

(another sleep-deprived inebriated rant. The resurgence of data-driven object-level motteposting is rather welcome; those interruptions won’t be frequent).

Anatoly Karlin is a self-identified Russian Cosmist. Like me. This means, in brief, the belief in the common cosmic endowment of humanity, the moral imperative – Great Common Task – to overcome bodily death (and, ideally, reverse as many past deaths as possible by technical means, redeeming human history, regathering «particles of our fathers»), and the notion that institutions, cultures, techniques and weapons or warfare ought to be pointed away from our kin and aimed against the lethal force of nature. One may think it’s a rather obvious idea to arrive at, during the long North Eurasian winter as you see malnourished peasants «recruited» for another dumb imperial war. It was invented by Nikolai Fyodorov, and our lefty friend deponysum has a poignant note on it; also available in his book.

Karlin is not very Russian, though, from his Berkeley education to meme-heavy Imperial identity compensating for confused ethnic ties; and starting Oct 3, he’s not very Cosmist. He’s now a direct threat to projects like Musk’s, an Anti-Cosmist, if anything:

THE CASE FOR WEAPONIZED KESSLERIZATION

It is time for Russia to give the 🇺🇦 flags and shibas what they have long demanded. #CloseTheSky

American SIGINT is an invulnerable (because no 🇺🇸🇷🇺 war) force multiplier worth factors more than all the Cold War surplus supplied to Ukraine. Just a few truckloads of gravel will put an end to Americans supplying the UAF with coordinates & nullifying Russia’s shells advantage.

Within a day he, too, has noticed the implication, and conjured a cope:

The Russians invented cosmism, the Russians were the first to explore space, and if fate so wishes, it will be fair if the Russians “kill” space. Svidomity [Ukrainians], Westerners, and NAFO dogs have long been demanding to "close the sky." It’s time to fulfill their wishes.

My guess here is, he references the iconic phrase that Taras Bulba, a fictional Zaporizhian Cossack and the main character of Gogol’s eponymous book, has said to his son Andriy who has betrayed Orthodox Cossacks for love of a Polish girl – before shooting. «I gave you life, I will take it», the savage, essentially Olympian expression of patriarchic morality. It’s also one of the justifications for the whole war, of course – «Czar’s gifts», «Lenin’s Ukraine», «Khrushchev’s mistake».

Or like the late demagogue extraordinaire for hire, «telekiller» Dorenko, had uttered once in 2014 while singing a Paean to the Priest-Czar Putin:

We belong to a dreadful generation - we have mauled our fathers to death. We took their country away from them and filthily slandered their past. So let today’s thirty-somethings know: we have just cut our teeth on our fathers. We are plenty. We are strong. And we will not allow the country to be torn apart again: if the children try to do this, we will maul the children. Yes, we are such a generation. We have mauled our fathers and we will maul our children, and our teeth are sharp.

Back in August, Alexander Dugin was accused of ritually sacrificing his daughter to the altar of Russian Empire. I think that’s vile bullshit, as far as criminology is concerned, but spiritually it may be true along those lines.

I’ve talked to a number of people whose parents have asked them why they’re not mobilized yet.

But none of this is as sad as a Cosmist proposing denial of the skies to man, for his team to not lose as hard while conquering a chunk of the European plain.


This wasn’t meant to be about Karlin and his inane proposal that has no chance of being implemented (logistics aside, Russian state cannot improvise, a Zombie system going mechanistically through Soviet materiel). This is about values. How was it in Meditations? «Multipolar traps – races to the bottom – threaten to destroy all human values».

In the draft of my Substack that’ll most likely never be released on the account of being moody and overwrought, the opening concerned values too.

The terminal goal is, obviously, the freedom of spirit. It will be reached though getting out of the local evolutionary maximum we currently inhabit. Primarily this means transcending limits of intelligence and longevity which stand in the way of maximally rich yet harmonious and joyous expression that our minds may achieve within the finite negentropy budget of this Hubble volume. This is the great common task, different facets of which have been grasped by Friedrich Nietzsche, Nikolai Fyodorov and many after them – from Bolshevik God-Builders on the left to British eugenicists on the right, with Jesuit nerds, weird Ukrainian propagandists who cite them and Russian nationalists with adjacent views who have, alas, traded ascension for zero-sum horizontal sprawl; still weirder philosophers who summon Eldritch entities from the future that belongs to Neo-China as well as respectable ones cited by Gates at Davos, trans transhumanists and gay furry meritocracy advocates strewn across the hidden dimensions of the political compass. No goal is more beautiful to a human being than freedom to express complexity. Thus no goal is more deserving of pursuit, and no enterprise deserving more protection.

No – well, except the tribe, I suppose. Except nationalism. Except that our guys be winning and making Ourtribia Great Again, or else let it all burn. Right?

…

This puts Never-Trumpers in a new light, for me (even if they specifically may have bad arguments); and suggests a general scheme for defection from entrenched positions (or in their case, from the reasonable expectation of trenches). It’s just that such situations are a good test for having principles.

If you have anything at all that is more meaningful than pure tribalist loyalty and intransigence, if your politics is a means to a certain vision and not just an end, you may arrive at a fork on your road. Sure, Our Guy At Least Will Go Down Swinging. Other than that, what does he swing for? Does he offer enough even if he triumphs over his foe, and most importantly can he deliver? You start on this path expecting tremendous things – a revolution, a revival, a revenge at least. Suppose the promise is not fulfilled even as the challenge grows. You may consider yourself betrayed, and reject the leader in turn, and say that those who remain loyal are in fact unwitting traitors of everything the movement stood for. Or you double-down in commitment to the cause, because what other way could even hint at the possibility of your vision blossoming? Surely none! This path of unreciprocated loyalty ends, logically speaking, in you giving up everything, soul and mind and vision and whatever the tribe could ever offer, in exchange for nothing but the chance of personal success for its elite; the exemplary Stalinist Party discipline, masterful exploitation of Palaeolithic reactions. Through it all, one feels righteousness, because one’s loyal comrades are close.

I suppose some leftists may suspect at times that they are no longer pursuing maximalist goals – equality, liberty, fraternity (no sarcasm); but they cannot accept that their political coalition is going in the other direction. It may be temporarily misguided, but others are deliberately hostile to justice and truth!

That’s all well and good but not sacrificing your literal children to the hollowed-out ideology, nor contradicting your own key values that are as precious as children if not more, must be a decent lower bar for a tribalist’s sanity.

P.S. Vitalik, another Western-educated Russian, responds to Karlin with mocking hope that the way things are going we’ll perfect life extension by 2024. The joke, of course, is that Vitalik is precisely the type of man who finds no purchase these days in Russia, but who epitomizes everything Karlin was meant to support, and in part it was the hope to garner support for those things that have led him to Russian nationalism. It may turn out that everything of value your tribe stood for, or seemed to stand for, can no longer survive – within its structure and under its aegis. But ideas don’t die that easily, and can become seeds of new assabiyahs, assembled elsewhere, hopefully to a large extent even from the same stock of people. This is what I’d recommend tribalists to keep in mind.

It sucks to be proven right, but yes, saw it coming.

I'll propose an alternative and much simpler explanation.

«Credibility» is a measure of some quality that may be state capacity or its close relative. No party is willing to just throw a fight when challenged; some parties are unable to muster the energy and so get forced into concessions, having degenerated politically even without equivalent declines in other respects. Leaving aside blatantly irrational commitments, it is useful to wave that capacity around and remind people that not only are you rich and armed but you can deliver the payload. Americans have done that with Afghanistan, and then they've done it again by noping out of the polygon rendered useless before their empire crumbled.

You have to start with those fundamentals of «rich» and «armed» though.

The size of the fight in the dog matters, but weight classes exist for a reason. Russia is (was) what, 1.5% of global GDP? Russia can commit 100% of itself (or can it?). Fine, everyone else can commit too, and they see no reason to let go. As a result, the fight is depended by the [economic and political] size of the dog, nnd «credibility» ends up on the side of /r/CredibleDefense regulars.

There's a ton of inappropriate glib simplification on all sides of this debate, and it makes me appreciate the indecisiveness of large bureaucracies.

Ukrainians are of course correct in accusing Musk of getting his takes from Russian propaganda he absorbed passively on Twitter and 5 mins (realistically 20 secs) skimming Wiki page about Crimea. History aside, there are many good reasons not to legitimize annexations. Worse than that, he apparently shares the popular contrarian American (and mainstream Russian) delusion that Ukrainians have no agency, being instead mere pawns of the West. Yet they have their own politics, and it is not politically possible for them to roll over. If Western aid is cut, they won't just fold and go «home» (for some of those currently engaged in combat – where exactly would that be, in Ukraine or in neo-Russia?) – they will fight bitterly. Considering the current state of the frontline, it is not even certain they will lose if abandoned; but they surely won't forgive the betrayal. Not a big deal, the Hegemon's citizen could reason – except Ukrainians are a media Power on their own merits, too.

I'm very disappointed with this event. Where's that tweet-checking lawyer when you need him? After Tesla AI day Musk just had to sit tight and not burn the remains of his clout. At the zenith of his reality distortion powers he got dragged through pig shit over calling a scuba diver a pedo. Now imagine what he'll get for advocating an outcome that's considered a prerequisite to a genocide, after making millions of enemies among those who would be its victims. I am serious: he should worry more about this than about Putin's nukes. (Ukrainians take this stuff very personally – after all, they've killed their own negotiator who argued for peace; occasionally, in Ukraine annoying people just happen to get killed and it's not investigated it in depth; Ukrainians in the interwebs reason collectively and very simply that one less cunt is, in principle, a net improvement. Weird murders in Ukraine tend to evoke «huh» and shrugs). Seeing as this move was personally costly and politically unrealistic, why did he post? Stupidity. Probably leftists are correct too: you don't need to be all-around brilliant to be savvy at business.

On the other hand: all those takes about «if Putin gets what he wants Venezuela/Chad/Poland goes nuclear» are shallow. I don't believe this should be views through the lens of game theory 101 and precedent logic. Americans may be living by precedent, but almost everyone else is consequentialist and decides on a case by case basis, wondering who's the 800 pound gorilla in the room and whether you've got an anti-gorilla rifle at the ready. Russia is a special case in that it can do irreversible damage to any other country including the US, and then some; for a little while longer at least, given that American defenses and capabilities for disarming strike improve with every Starship iteration and ABM test. (Now, can it? Are Vlad's nuclear cajones that he's pushing in our faces less shriveled up than his conventional army and state capacity? There's no guarantee of this, and the prior isn't great after all that we've seen; but all I've heard from people suggests that strategic nuclear forces have been maintained at the expense of all other military branches even through the leanest years...) China is barely getting there, and will get there regardless (if it doesn't implode from zero-covid nonsense or bank runs or some locusts or an unusually strong wind first).

Others... can be brought to heel by conventional means. Most «hostile» nations, should they begin a nuclear program, can be toppled in a week with sanctions, cyber-attacks (note how they aren't used on Russia despite its pathetic tech stack and fragile logistics; thanks guys), bunker busters and one-two CSGs and after this war I suppose they'll expect much greater NATO readiness to do that. Allied nations, especially NATO members, can be trivially placated by nuclear sharing (which is also cheaper and Taiwan/SK/Japan will soon request it anyway). Non-proliferation for small guys is already a strong principle, and the example of DPRK, pathetic yet sovereign, in contrast with Libya and Iraq and Serbia, says enough to any wannabe czar about the utility of nukes. This is at most a change in degree, not in kind.

And now let's get back to the bureaucracy. The real question is not whether to abandon Ukraine but rather whether to ramp up support. Americans have been playing this well, in my opinion – probably CIA psychological profiles have proved useful for a change. Military aid to Ukraine has been growing gradually, in line with erosion of Russian capabilities, and maintaining some token respect for Russian self-defense posture; the archetypal example is hesitation with providing ATACMS. But we've moved from defensive stuff like MANPADs to tanks and (Soviet) aviation, meeting no serious response; Russian border regions are already attacked too. It seems that the idea is to boil Putin by degrees, desensitizing him to lesser and lesser control, to «new normal»; he's presumed to be a practitioner of the Madman Doctrine who has a non-zero but decreasing commitment to the bit. Suppose the US does not fold completely in response to the «Kherson is Russia actually» take, but also does not escalate, and even makes some non-committal noise about the need for negotiations and non-intervention; on the other hand, it's communicated that territories not controlled by Russia are solidly Ukrainian and will be defended at all costs. Ukrainians indignantly dismiss this appeasement. Russian army proceeds to get mauled by weapons of the sort that get provided currently, and retreats. Maybe a tactical nuclear strike or two is delivered for intimidation; it doesn't work, sanctions increase and the game goes on. At some later point Putin is boiled enough that he accepts the loss of control of those territories, his propagandists peddle some cope; Russia turns into an Oprichnina hermit kingdom that's bleeding people and suffocating under sanctions; Ukrainians quietly get their ATACMS and maybe modern NATO aviation (if needed) and make the continued military presence in Crimea unsustainable; assassinations of Crimean officials begin, like in the newborn «People's Republics»; the peninsula is dropped from the programming, most civilians evacuating inland. In a few months/years an older and feebler Putin dies/drops out the window and the state unravels like that guy in The Nightmare Before Christmas, only with blood.

Sounds plausible to me, and I guess that's what the plan is.

In conclusion, I'd have voted «no» in Musk's poll, mostly because it's so stupid.

Also, I have bet money on Russia delivering a nuclear strike on Ukrainian soil within 6 months (admittedly got baited into it, but still, I give it 40% probability). Like they say, чему быть, тому не миновать.

(Sorry if that was disorganized.)

Trans people are surprisingly common among zoomer gen nationalists and imageboard-adjacent culture, Astolfo meme is not just a meme. That said, you only need one connection to get exposure to a tight-knit community or interesting rejects and weirdos. Interesting, in part, because of the contrast between the discourse here, where their peers in the West are a meaningful cultural force and their [often unfounded] ideas of persecution are weaponized for political gain by a broader liberal coalition, and the reality on the ground there, where such a person – down to the same obnoxious twitter style and attitude – can get thrown into an actual reeducation/concentration camp by neonazi pagans backed by fashy local police (maybe I'll tell that story one day, but it played a big part in making me more sympathetic).

It's easy, but most of the time I'm insufficiently curious about people's lives. It would be cool to also talk about, say, Old Believer friends, but that network never got far before February.

I also prefer it when people don't get curious about me. Alas, dramanauts have their own quirks.

Breivik made a bomb of that scale in his garage barn, alone, from freely available fertilizer. McVeigh's one was vastly more potent. Dumping something of that sort from a fishing vessel or a yacht, guiding it with a few underwater scooters to the pipe, is not much harder. I suppose you're contemptuous of Greens and believe they're intellectually below either of those men, but it's eminently doable.

Like tears in rain.

I prefer to think of it as a ballsy attempt at creating a hyperstition.

We may differ in our understanding of the term. For me, Deep State is unelected self-governed bureaucracy that steers the state policy in accordance with its own values, insular culture and long-term vision; basically a self-perpetuating fraternity entrenched in the official power structure, and it takes a whole ecology of think tanks, and decades of stability and obscurity for this fraternity to mature. You seem to believe it's some concrete institutional factor, like intelligence services. This is as queer to me as Marxist materialist analysis that explains all political processes in terms of economic relations. Spooks run Russia, maybe Israel to some extent, but in all other countries they're not the decision-making caste.

In the US, one angle of the Deep State is epitomized in Council on Foreign Relations (or rather, an informal network of people many of whom have at some point participated in the CFR). In Germany, that's structures like Konrad Adenauer Foundation, maybe? But no German structure has sovereignty comparable to the CFR; it's just a logistically convenient form to coordinate the Zeitgeist already present in the society. Likewise, the CIA is not sovereign, it's furthering ideas that the Deep State has endorsed, out of those the culture of the nation has produced. In this sense, Germans may have intelligence agencies (of course penetrated by 5eyes agents) but lack the DS; just as their culture lacks independence from the US and capacity to produce ideas.

How could they do what you're talking about? Any bureaucratic German group that attempts to move against the US and towards Russia will be ratted out as Nazis instantly, and in this fails they'll be condemned by the populace as they try to implement any policy of consequence; if they pass the policy, Americans can retaliate so catastrophically it'll deter any German with half a brain from trying in advance. In fact what you're seeing now is the cleanup of one such group, nurtured by Putin and Russian fossil industry – Gerhard Schroder and others. They're discredited and out of power now. That lobbyist club was as close to German Deep State as can be. Putin had his chance, and he blew it by attacking Ukraine.

This is how you get things like the most prestigious special units team in Germany being filled with far right members.

Remind me how it ended for them.

And if they had such control over Germany, they wouldn’t need to blow up the pipeline!

Germans have economic elites. In matters of war, economic elites have little impact (as evidenced by success of American trade war with China, that has caught the cynical, mercantile Chinese with their pants down, uselessly begging their Wall Street partners to «do something»); but they can make noise and sow division, increasing friction in the war process. Blowing up the pipeline takes care of that.

then the German “deep state” (if you will)

German deep state is a phone line to Washington on hot dial. These things take generations of sovereignty to build, to grow, you need not so much 140 IQ intelligence officers but 80 year old national intelligentsia with unblemished reputation. Neither Germany nor Russia or Ukraine have anything like an American deep state. Those are shallow nations of confused linear workers.

Moreover, if Germans are all that smart, they can understand their place and the future of Russia.

there's no need for a military ship of any sort. You place that sort of precision via scuba, so you just need an underwater GPS, a scuba team, and a boat big enough for the explosive

Right. And by now, small unmanned subs – of the type even Ukraine or Russia could build without much assistance – can probably do that well enough. Those arguments cannot be relevant.

To be honest, it's amazing how nobody bombs infrastructure of this sort all the time. It's fragile, stationary, unfeasible to guard and very expensive/consequential, so the infamy alone is a massive prize. Proof of our common civility and rationality, I guess.

We don't live in the realpolitik era to expect Europeans to compromise with that. Putin has only himself to blame for having become a cartoon villain. Tolerating a little sabotage comes to people much easier than excusing Bucha because of muh economy.

Furthermore, I don't think there is a cultural victory. If someone is sabotaging you, they're your enemy. Look what the US did to the UK in Suez and so on. So much for the special relationship and Anglo-Saxon solidarity.

Not sure what you're arguing here: obviously the US has lent a hand to the dismantling of British empire, but individual Brits think very warmly of America.

The EU is pretty stupid, sluggish and incompetent (see their nuclear/regulatory fiasco). But they won't permanently let the US sabotage them.

If Russians can permanently let Putin sacrifice them for geopolitics, certainly the EU can keep coping with some economic costs.

Unlike Britain, the EU is big and could theoretically compete with America, if they got their act together.

20 years ago this looked almost like a real possibility.

Now it's a joke. People should just think of themselves, pack their bags and families and go to the US.

Even if everything you're saying is true, a) Russian actions are obscenely beyond the pale which excuses anything that can be plausibly framed as counterattack, and b) Americans have won cultural victory, so economic elites of those European states are of no consequence against their own populace (and media elites).

The game is played masterfully, I can't really even object to the sentence. Europeans are in no position to compromise with the plainly irrational Kremlin, and they're in no position to sustain their economy, and they can't blame anyone but themselves, same as Russians.

On the other hand, I can call out Europeans who are still pretending that this is fine. The EU will survive, but it will fall rather far behind without cheap energy, in the crucial period where everyone has to maintain a stake in high-tech economy. The entire fucking continent is going to become irrelevant.


A translation from a biased pro-Russian souce. It's not very insightful, catastrophizes the situation and frames it as an unprovable conspiracy but, I think, is directionally correct with regards to the consequences:

Chronicles of the Death of the EU.

Carthage delenda est.

The real U.S. goals in Ukraine are the destruction of Europe and its economic leader: Germany.

Why?

So let's describe the global situation at the beginning of 2022 (I note right away that the numbers are imprecise, go to MMI and @Spydell_finance for accuracy, but the approximate numbers do not distort either the layout itself or the conclusions):

China. GDP: 16.9 trillion USD. Industrial sector ≈30.5% or 5.1 trillion USD. Export economy 15.3% with an export sophistication rate [here and below actually economic complexity, Export Complexity is another measure but correlated] of 1.35 (easily replaceable, not technologically intensive, but produced at scale, elastic prices, requires small producer margins and inexpensive labor, as well as agglomeration of producers).

Germany. GDP 4.2 trillion USD. Industrial sector ≈27-30% or 1.1-1.3 trillion USD. Export-heavy economy of 35% with almost the highest sophistication on the planet of 2.07 (only Japan is above with 2.49. That is, exports are not replaceable, technologically complex, and therefore VERY MARGINAL).

EU as a whole. GDP 17 trillion USD (suddenly !!! more than China, or at least equal). Industrial sector ~25% or 4.1 trillion USD. (suddenly a little less than China).

Except this industry, as written above, is high-tech, and therefore marginal, giving rapid positive capital growth.

U.S.. GDP of 22.9 trillion USD. But the industrial sector is only 18% or 4.1 trillion USD. (Suddenly less than China and the same as the EU)!!! And the financial sector is over 20%, as is the total services sector at 77% of the economy.

But even this industrial sector, giving only 7.7% of exports, has ECI of only 1.57 (so, like China).

Now, if we look to the beginning of the year, the accumulated imbalances in QE are accelerating inflation and could bury the entire dollar system [lol no].

Stopping QE and the start of the Fed's balance sheet reduction guarantees the decline of the service sector, the de facto death of the financial sector, as well as much of the venture capital IT that's zombie companies with negative turnover margins or no cache-flow.

In order to survive, the States need to urgently develop the real economy, i.e. industry.

However, since the world has gone global, no new markets are expected, the system cannot take over Mars with the Martians, which means it must grow in the intensive mode, which means negative capital work, since the total venture capital investment on intensives does not pay off, this has been obvious since 2009.

So what to do?

We have to kill the competition.

Option 1: China.

However, first of all China is a subject, secondly the economy of China and the U.S. are [still] too connected, and thirdly, the development of industry similar to the Chinese means low margin, long payback period and a drop in personal income. And the drop in personal income means revolution in the U.S. This is not an option.

Option 2: EU.

It fits perfectly, no subjectivity and high-margin business.

But the business is high-margin because it is very technological, that is, it has a high and long threshold for entry. It takes decades of development, thousands of patents, and cultivating a team of specialists.

But the patents, specialists and companies do not belong to the EU.

We need to force these companies to move to the US in their entirety, just as, for example, low-margin manufacturing moved to China in the 90s.

To do this, you have to create unbearable conditions for business: war, hunger and cold.

Now look at the EU!

News 1:

Germany's industrial production fell 1.8% in the first 8 months of 2022 amid sanctions against Russia, and Germany's chemical-pharmaceutical sector (high dependence on gas) saw a 10.7% decline.

News 2:

The Wall Street Journal on Sept. 21 published a story about big German businesses relocating en masse to the New World.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/high-natural-gas-prices-push-european-manufacturers-to-shift-to-the-u-s-11663707594

News 3:

Explosion on the North Stream 1 and 2 branches.

I connect the last news story into the same single chain of events.

Carthage (the EU) must be destroyed. At any cost.

This is the main goal of the U.S. in Ukraine.

Like OP, I also think that the development of AI capabilities will result in a dystopia, just not because of any silly problems inherent to automation and post-scarcity conditions. It's a much more trivial issue of political control, current de-facto power structure evolving into a singleton once having acquired tools of sufficient power. Other outcomes, utopian as well as libertarian, are technically if not politically feasible.

IMO it's most probably NATO, though whether directly Americans or someone technically not subordinated but enabled by them, hard to say and not very interesting.

Among the trivial things this war has taught me:

  1. It's never «they shelled their own» even if you can contrive a plausible story on how that's beneficial. False flag attacks are either done to third parties (reminder that Germany has long been a second-tier ally), to low-value props (like that car or a pro-Russian official in LDNR) or, apparently, just not done. (This does not rule out unintentional damage or lone wolf events). I suppose there are exceptions but as the first-line hypothesis this is non-viable.

  2. Cui bono is the default and understandable lens for viewing any unsolved crime, but not infrequently it fails because people may have a very quixotic idea of their own or others' bono or just act irrationally, against their better judgement. Nevertheless it's a viable heuristic to prioritize hypotheses.

  3. Nobody cares much who exactly delivered an unconventional and illegal attack, so long as it harms the enemy. If an attack is hard to claim as valorous, it's just ignored or turned into a cause for an unfunny circlejerk to assuage guilty conscience. So we shouldn't expect good analytics from the benefitting side.

Ukrainians have effective sabotage groups. Just today, a woman called Irina Navalnaya (not related) has been interrogated after being caught in a bombing operation not much different from the one that killed Darya Dugina. It's understandable that some people find more entertainment in speculations about maskirovka and ghoulish conspiracy theories about Dugin killing his daughter for esoteric reasons, but that's just noise whereas covert bombings actually happen.

Americans have their CIA. Well, you know how it works.

Cutting off Russian gas supplies precludes the possibility of Europe and specifically Germany buckling under the temptation to save their economy from what looks to be an inevitable deindustrialization, removes incentives to project the image of «unwilling American accomplice» to Russia, drag one's feet with military shipments to Ukraine and push for «diplomatic resolution». Many Western commenters unconcerned with more plebeian legal matters cheer the attack openly. It's a reasonable attack for people who don't lose anything of substance from it. Thus, Americans or their proxy.

I'm not even mad. Such infrastructure, eminently vulnerable to any party more sophisticated than a Mexican cartel, was a testament to a gentle era of common sense, globalization, business deals and little men pursuing their little happiness. Putin wasn't willing to accept that he's a little man too, smaller even than his European partners. So now we're living again in a historical era. Gentlemen's agreements are null and void, irrelevant in front of the simplest game-theoretical realities like the game of chicken, and logistics of competing war machines.

edit: one beautiful thing of the hypothetical true masterminds would have been to make the ultimate guilty party the radical wing of German Greens or some other environmental nuts. They are feverishly loyal to the US; have a long history of opposing NordStream; some greens are already accused of cooperating with Gazprom/Russia; and they're currently sabotaging German economy with their anti-nuclear power posture. Making them the scapegoat is a good move because it's believable, discredits dangerous Green Agenda and rescues EU and German economy, and – with NS out of commission – doesn't hurt potential American exports.

Disclaimer: From pervious conversations it's plain to see you'd prefer to have AI fail, and thus argue that it will result in a dystopia, and would prefer many outcomes commonly recognized as dystopias to an Eden-like AGI-powered success even were it proven to be trivially possible. I am similarly pessimistic with regards to likely outcomes, but confident that the progress can't be stopped by rhetorics, and oppositely biased in principle.

In the case of us succeeding with the development of AGI or deploying roughly current-gen AIs to their logical conclusion, your scenario won't be a problem.

What you offer is a classical right-wing gotcha against Communism, one based on the potential limitlessness of human desire and ahistorical thinking. Post-scarcity does not imply logical impossibility of scarcity, only that we do not run into resource constraints under consumption regimes that are currently pursued. Old Soviet joke:

– Izya, when Communism comes and everything becomes free, what will you get?

– You actually asking? A fighter jet, duh.

– What can you even use a fighter jet for!?

– Well use your head. Suppose we here in Odessa learn that they've brought some salt to one store in Vorkuta. Now we can't do anything before it's all taken. And under Communism – I hop into my jet, fly there and get into the queue early!

Actual Communist theory is protected from this by ideas such that their desired formation is a product of long societal evolution resulting in a New Type of Man, who won't be inclined to troll the community with absurd indulgence (and that salt post-scarcity will come much earlier than fighter jet post-scarcity). But in any case, AGI does not necessarily result in Communism, UBI isn't Communism too, and techno-optimism is informed more by supply-side economic thinking. If Communist practicians – especially Soviets – believed very much in the flexibility of man and all-surpassing power of indoctrination and thought they can rush the NewMan-isation process by decree; supply-side is the opposite.

It preaches that technology is mutable whereas society is fixed (a parallel for biology springs to mind immediately). We cannot cleverly reinvent the habits of a social animal that is man, not at any reasonable scale and to a good effect; we can grow the pie so much that even the bottom percentiles get their basic needs met and more barbaric practices die out on their own. This belief is a product of disillusionment. It is also arguably self-serving when it comes from people around the top percentiles and their court economists, an addendum to their market gospel. But it seems they are the people closest to AGI.

Further, progress in this area is not rapid enough to provide a shock that would enable a deep rethinking of social order. We will keep consuming new surplus, allocating it in accordance with the current economic process at every step. Structural changes will be slow. For a while, people will keep losing jobs; productivity will keep rising; entrenched IT corporations with «data moats», «data flywheel» and «compute self-sufficiency» will keep gobbling up talent and startups, marginalizing smaller players in more traditional niches, but not displacing the state power. Accordingly they will pay an increasing share of taxes; new welfare programs and bullshit jobs or programs for «reskilling» or something will be created, and only after a long intermediate period will this plausibly coalesce into a single institutionalized UBI, which, necessarily, will also be scarce enough to not worry about this zany stuff.

I also suspect that there will emerge a two-tier economy, with toy money for the little people, UBI consumers and such, modeled after food stamps, gift cards and various game/store tokens; and Adult Money for professionals and their employers in the propertied class; this will neatly help in regulating access to dangerous things like computers accepting arbitrary code, network access points, scientific equipment and weapons.

And as others say, much of the economy will be virtual. Why buy a ton of Playstations, or even just one Playstation really, when you can play 24/7 at most? And you will be happy doing that, not owning even your state-provided VR full body immersive set.

But it won't be abjectly tyrannical.

You face real threats even without the pod-bug routine and weird Communist takeover.

(Incidentally: tried to record this to transcribe with Whisper, a model unexpectedly released by OpenAI a few days ago. Whisper is great but looks like my BT drivers were borked. Oh well, typing it is. For a little while more).


Two quotes.

Sam Altman of OpenAI, now:

Obviously, the economic impacts are huge. And I think if it is as divergent as I think it could be for some people doing incredibly well and others not, I think society just won’t tolerate it at this time. And so figuring out when we’re going to disrupt so much of economic activity, and even if it’s not all disrupted by 20 or 30 years from now, I think it’ll be clear that it’s all going to be.

What is the new social contract? My guess is that the things that we’ll have to figure out are how we think about fairly distributing wealth, access to AGI systems, which will be the commodity of the realm, and governance, how we collectively decide what they can do, what they don’t do, things like that. And I think figuring out the answer to those questions is going to just be huge.

I’m optimistic that people will figure out how to spend their time and be very fulfilled. I think people worry about that in a little bit of a silly way. I’m sure what people do will be very different, but we always solve this problem. But I do think the concept of wealth and access and governance, those are all going to change, and how we address those will be huge.

[…] Yeah. So we run the largest UBI experiment in the world. We have a year and a quarter left in a five-year project. I don’t think that’s the only solution, but I think it’s a great thing to be doing. And I think we should have 10 more things like that that we try.

Marshall Brain, Manna – Two Views of Humanity’s Future:

“And everything is not free in the way you are probably thinking.” Cynthia said.

“That’s what I wanted to ask about. If everything is free, then what’s to stop me from demanding a 100,000 foot house on a thousand acres of land and a driveway paved in gold bricks? It makes no sense, because obviously everyone cannot demand that. And how can anything be free? That is hard to believe in the first place.” I said.

“Everything is free AND everyone is equal.” Linda said. “That’s exactly how you phrased it, and you were right. You, Jacob, get equal access to the free resources, and so does everyone else. That’s done through a system of credits. You get a thousand credits every week and you can spend them in any way you like. So does everyone else. This catalog is designed to give you a taste of what you can buy with your credits. This is a small subset of the full catalog you will use once you arrive. You simply ask for something, the robots deliver it, and your account gets debited.”

“Let me show you.” said Cynthia. She opened her catalog to a page, and pointed to one of the pictures. It was clothing. “This is what I am wearing.” she said. “See – it is 6 credits. In a typical week I only spend about 70 or so credits on clothes. That’s why I like to wear something new every day.”

“The robots did manufacture Cynthia’s outfit for free. They took recycled resources, added energy and robotic labor and created what she is wearing. It cost nothing to make it. She paid credits simply to keep track of how many resources she is using.”

“Where did the energy come from?” I asked.

“The sun. The Australia Project is powered mostly by the sun and the wind, and the wind comes from the sun if you think about it.”

“Where did the robots come from?”

“The same place Cynthia’s outfit came from. It’s the same thing. Robots take recycled resources, add energy and robotic labor and make new robots. The robots are free, the energy is free, the resources are all completely recycled and we own them, so they are free. Everything is free.”

“The credits simply make sure that everyone gets equal access to the resources. There is a finite amount of power that can be generated on any given day, for example. Things like that. The credits make sure everyone gets an equal share of the total pool of resources.”

“Holy shit.” I said. [...] Page after page after page of products. There were thousands of different types of housing, for example. And they all seemed to fall in the range of 100 to 500 credits per week. Clothing cost nothing. Food cost nothing.

“I’m not getting this.” I said. “I’m not sure I could spend a thousand credits if this catalog is right.”

“Many people don’t spend a thousand credits.” she said. “If you are working on a project you might, but that’s about it.”

“So how do I earn the credits?” I asked.

“Earn?” Linda asked back.

“No no no…” said Cynthia.

“Do you give me a job? The reason I am here is because I have no job,” I said.

“No. You see, it’s all free. By being a shareholder, you already own your share of the resources. The robots make products from the free resources you and everyone else already owns. There is no forced labor like there is in America. You do what you want, and you get 1,000 credits per week. We are all on an endless vacation.”