BANNED USER: temperamental dysregulation
DaseindustriesLtd
late version of a small language model
Tell me about it.
User ID: 745
Banned by: @Amadan
Biafran independence activists in Nigeria blaming British colonialism for putting Muslisms (or non-Igbo in general) in charge of Nigeria, or making it an unwieldy artificial state project
I think those complaints are much more legitimate. Direct material exploitation is, speaking long-term, easy to recover from, but wrecked geopolitics in already-fragile regions can lead to long-term stability issues and consistent human capital flight. And that's far worse.
https://freaktakes.substack.com/p/bombs-brains-and-science?s=r
In total, Allied bombings completely destroyed about 18.5% of German homes. Inner-city homes represented an inordinately high chunk of these homes since inner-cities were the very rough target of these campaigns. Coincidentally, inner-cities also are where a high share of universities are located.
All of that is to say: there was a large sample of university research buildings that were partially or fully destroyed by Allied bombs without much rhyme or reason.
Would you rather lose 10% of your researchers or 10% of your labs?
Now, getting your academic building partially blown to shreds is obviously bad for departmental productivity. But, so is having up to 15% of your professors fired for something as arbitrary as having a Jewish grandparent or attending a communist party meeting. And, while it’s obvious that both of these will at least temporarily decrease departmental output, it is not clear at all which is worse, either in the short run or in the long run.
In the short run, a 10% shock to human capital—dismissing 10% of a department’s scientists—reduced departmental output by .2 standard deviations. A 10% shock to physical capital—the destruction of 10% of a department’s buildings—lowered output by .05 standard deviations. The effects of losing 10% of your researchers was 4X that of losing 10% of your buildings in the short-run.
In the long-run, the effects of dismissing researchers persisted. Departments continued to underperform up through 1980, when the data for the study stops. Meanwhile, by 1970, departments that were bombed were experiencing increased productivity, meaning that bombed departments may have benefited from upgrading during postwar reconstruction.
the dismissal of scientists in Nazi Germany contributed NINE TIMES MORE to the decrease in scientific output in Germany than did the destruction of a large percentage of its research buildings.
Do you not suspect that this lip service to the idea of freedom is only paid as long as there's a credible risk of you and others like you effectively or literally defecting to the far group, should the trust be thoroughly betrayed? And that, as soon as there is nowhere to defect to, the hegemony secured forever – the show's over, your carrot is taken away and into the meat grinder you go?
°
All in all, we trekked to the place for a long time and had fun, and Granny held her own.
And, at last, we reached it. The pine forest parted a little, a clearing peered through, and on it – a stone. A humongous boulder, twice as tall as a man. You can only find such boulders in the forest in the northern countries. It got tossed in here to all hells in the Ice Age. And my grandmother immediately flung up her hands: «My sweeties, there it is!» We came closer, went around the boulder, and in it – a niche, sort of like a cave. And in the niche – three busts, carved into this granite boulder. Sonya and I just opened our mouths. Three busts! Carved right out of the stone, as if protruding from the wall of this cave. And the work is quite detailed, filigree. For some reason, I immediately recalled the statue of Pharaoh Khafre, which struck me with the craftsmanship, pharaoh was also carved from granite, and on his shoulders sits some falcon, its wings shielding the back of his head from enemies. Wish I had such a falcon these days!
We and Sonya are standing there, as if in a slight astonishment, while our grandmother immediately walked over to the busts, bowed and said loudly: «thank you, Three Greats!» We came to our senses, went over to the busts, started to touch and examine them. And Grandma said:
«Wait a minute, kids, I'll tell you everything in order. My dear grandchildren, these are three statues of three fateful rulers of Russia, the Three Great Baldies in front of you, three great knights who have crushed the dragon-state. The first of them, that sly one with the small beard, crushed the Russian Empire; the second, with the glasses and the spot on his bald head, destroyed the USSR; and this one, with the little chin, ruined the terrible country called the Russian Federation. And all three busts were carved out sixty years ago by my late husband, a democrat, a pacifist, a vegetarian and a professional sculptor, in the summer when the dragon Russia finally died and stopped devouring its citizens forever.
And the grandmother started to come up close to each bust and put candies and gingerbread on its shoulders. And she was saying: This is for you, Volodyushka, this is for you, Misha, and this is for you, Vovochka. Sonya and I are standing watching, and she lays it all out, muttering something affectionate. Unusual! And our grandmother was an atheist at all times, she didn't worship anything or anyone. And this was straight up a temple with three deities. Sonya was smart, so she kept quiet.
And I, of course, burst with questions: Grandma, how and what is that? So she told me everything in detail, and then sort of summed it up. She said that Russia was a terrible anti-human State at all times, but in the twentieth century, this monster was especially ruthless, then there were rivers of blood and human bones crunching on the fangs of that dragon. And to crush the monster, God sent three knights all marked with baldness. And they, each in his own respective time, performed feats. The bearded one crushed the dragon's first head, the bespectacled one the second, and the one with the small chin cut off the third. The bearded one, he says, succeeded through bravery, the bespectacled one through weakness; and the third, through cunning.
And this last of the three bald men, by all appearances, was the one Granny liked best. She mumbled something tender, caressed him, put a lot of candy on his shoulders. And she kept shaking her head: how hard it was for that third, the last one, the hardest of it all. For, she said, he did his work secretly, wisely, sacrificing his honor, reputation, bringing wrath on himself. She says: how many insults have you suffered, what hatred of fools, the stupid anger of the masses, all the backbiting! And she pets him and kisses him and embraces him, calling him a little crane, and she bursts into tears. Sonya and I were taken aback a little. And she said to us: kids, he endured a lot and did a great job. My grandmother categorically forbade us to take pictures of the cave with the smarty, she said - it's not good for sacred things to photo and reproduce them. A pity! We agreed to come here next year.
And on the way back, we stopped at our beloved family Snowman, and I must say, we had a wonderful lunch.
– Telluria. Vladimir Sorokin, 2013.
I happen to agree with the framing of the basic conflict, that is, the war itself, as a clear case of good vs. evil.
Putin really is a cardboard villain, and if he doesn't assert his villainy like some Commodus but excuses it, this only underscores his low character. He's begun a war that has killed and harmed an insane number of Eastern Slavs, ruined the faint potential of the EU as a sovereign pole, and, what offends me near-infinitely more, doomed Russia herself to disintegration. Yea, that'll be worse than another ethnic cleansing in the ME – even though many among his detractors will pop open champagne. If not for disillusionment with paranoid narratives that have sent us into this deathtrap in the first place (e.g. the «Ukrainian attack on Donbass», which makes sense in the long term, seeing UA commitments, and which I had believed, but which had proved to be a fake casus belli in the early 2022) – I'd have said Putin is consciously playing the villain's role°, or is manipulated into it. But – Conquest's 2nd Law.
Still. This is only true about the war. Let me piggyback here with my own rant.
Russians are being canceled. Gleefully and unjustly, with all the dynamics of American cancellation, by a coalition of groups with nakedly particularist morality, jeering and exploiting SJ sophistry. Ruskies are learning for the first time what canceled Westerners have felt. I've always sympathized with those – in the abstract, worrying mainly about consequences of their disenfranchisement, from the perspective of a man expecting, unlike them, no fairness and reciprocity. Perhaps I can't feel what they (and many of you) feel, and the analogy is still flawed. But… it's probably a good deal more accurate then their own projections of cultural tribal warfare onto Russian-Ukrainian war.
Of course, current problems of Anglophone right wingers are, in my opinion, a joke compared to what's happening to Russians. Over a hundred million people, captive audience to Kremlin as well as their opponents, not just demonized, but – cut off from the financial infrastucture, put on effective no-flight lists in the first world, like some Fuentes or Torba, much of their property seized (likely for reparations), and that's only starting. Perhaps the whole culture war was rehearsal for this; and COVID for its institutional dimension.
That's cause for dread. But what enrages me is minor specific deceit.
The best exhibit is this story. A French Spanish girl of Ukrainian descent has created a viral thread on a hate crime:
❗️Breaking!❗️: Yesterday at about 10:30 pm in Roquebrune-Cap-Martin, #France, rue le Cheman blue, the Russians beat up two women from \Izyum, mother and daughter! They were walking, listening to a song in Ukrainian on their phone. A huge man ran up to them, 1/ #russians who was in the company of another one, a woman was following them, and started hitting them on the head. The daughter was hit twice on the asphalt with her head, the mother - three times. They have abrasions of hands and knees. 2/ #russiansagainstukrainians #eu #russia #france
[some details on the criminal passivity of French police etc.]
UPD: The well-being of girls is not very good: “… I'm lying in my bed my head hurts badly, my nose and eyebrows are all swollen, I can’t even go to police. Alinka went by herself.” “…It was all in the blood, my blood was running from the nose” #RussiaIsATerroristState)
Note the hashtags. She knows Twitter game well.
Our smart British friends, @doglatine or @BurdensomeCount, driven by the traditional hatred of Russia, tend to accept those outlandish victim stories at face value, as confirmations of a tendency, «what we always expected from those swine, uh, not YOU SPECIFICALLY, dear Ilforte, but… you know…»
I do. But I, too, am a Russian swine through and through, jaded as they come, from a caste so hated by smaller peoples of the Empire that our genocide is still OK to celebrate openly, and I know that this smells of more bull than Jussie Smollett, a Noose or Chanting Nigger or Indigenous Graves or some Toppled Tombstones. A Russian in France, now? 20 to 1 that he's driven from home by fear of potential mobilization or generic distaste for fascism, like me – and he's not keeping his eyes down and trying to blend with the crowd, but barbarically attempting a one-man genocide of ethnic Ukrainian culture, against women, and the cops are not doing enough?
What else, «This is SUKA country»?
❗️UPD: A man was arrested and taken into custody after the assault on Sunday of two #Ukrainian refugees in Roquebrune-Cap-Martin. According to @Nice_Matin information, he is of Ukrainian nationality.
(Other commenters say, he attacked those women because they were listening to Russian music and he assumed they were Russians, or perhaps wanted to punish them for betrayal of Volk; I can't check so will leave it at that).
106 likes, 27 QTs. The original: 5802/379, with a coordinated endorsement of #VisaBanForRussians hash tag. If you check, many have Doge profile pictures. That's NAFO, a growing pro-UA community with paid membership, headquarters in Discord and a rule against mentioning CIA («it doesn't exist», tee-hee); they credulously retweet all out-there stories demonizing Russia, like Galeev and Sumlenny’s «analysis» of Dugin sacrificing his daughter to Moloch. This is a typical one.
The hole in the narrative is downplayed by the author. A Russian with an anti-war flag says:
But there are no 2700 reposts and 5000 likes under this post. Everyone remembered that Ukrainian women were beaten.
And they splashed out another portion of bile on those who are from Russia.
And only few have learned the truth that he was a Ukrainian. You Maria are just acting ugly, playing on people's feelings.
Manipulator.
Her response? Classical ass-save:
This is far from the first case of Russian men attacking Ukrainian women, so don't manipulate either, it's ugly - that's the number of Russian criminals who are outside their country.
Might as well have gone with this.
…
There may be no pure good in this world. There are blemished things, and things massively worse. At times it's plain to see which is which. The war of aggression started by Russia under Putin is a cut-and-dry case of evil inflicted on people who are innocent in comparison, and specifically not guilty of this evil.
But they are not innocent in all matters. Ukrainians are famed for self-serving narratives with cute female touch, hiding their darkness; ask a Pole or a Jew if they own up to it enough. Northern Eurasia is a blood-soaked graveyard, and it won't become a happy-go-lucky communion of peoples if only The Prison of Nations is torn down at last and those imperialist ruskies are dealt with. Russia propped up South Ossetia and Abkhazia; democratic and NATO-aligned Georgians did ethnically cleanse Ossetians in the past. And the great Georgian thinker Mamardashvili, superstar so kindly treated by the (ostensibly Russocentric) Soviet regime, did pen this Hottentot-worthy masterpiece:
There is a situation where it is possible to solve the problem of human and national rights by giving the small, surrounded by the big, symbols or rights of the big. This can be a solution in the context of the Russian Federation, where some national territories are a product of Russian history and an ethnic minority is surrounded by the Russian population. This is a perfectly reasonable democratic position. But this principle of matryoshka is not applicable in the conditions of Georgia.
The word «Abkhazia» is synonymous with the word «Georgia». So to tell a Georgian that Abkhazia can exit Georgia is to say roughly the same thing as «Georgia can exit itself». Or to put a finer point on it: the same as showing red cloth to a bull and then being surprised that the bull is so undemocratic.
Armenia has committed war crimes, and sides with Russia&Iran. NATO-aligned Turks and Azeris have committed a genocide – the genocide, class-defining one – against Armenians, and are killing Armenians as I type; this is their hero.
Kamil Galeev, with his training in the Holocaust center and his coked-up wordcel power, can ape the rhetoric of Twitter Anti-Fascists and SJWs well, but in Russian he justifies continental-scale devastation effected by Genghis Khan, the deified champion-father of his race, and gloats at goreposting.
An Estonian fella with a cute doge pfp or a checkmark and bio of «expert», complaining of Russian barbarity, may be not some traumatized Anti-Communist but a bona fide Nazi, still butthurt about the Germanic Reich's failure to purge Slavs and Jews.
A self-appointed Russian Anti-Nazi may have powerful takes on the legitimacy of Baltic states...
So it goes. Civilization is skin-deep, there's dirt on every collective body, and the cheapest way to excuse one's group is to dogpile on the common enemy. In the US, that's white people. In Eurasia, Russian people. This is unjust in principle, and unjust in these specific cases. Let's not cancel peoples and races.
Okay?
There was a good writeup about that, years ago, probably in Russian, that I can't find now. Basically it's that niche journalism, and especially platforms like Kotaku and Polygon, is just testing grounds for Big Boy journalism, a place to polish and prove your wordcel technical chops and lack of squeamishness in producing essay-like content on a given topic. It's like being a technical writer before becoming Ted Chiang or Neal Stephenson – only an uninspired one. Would you, as an aspiring wordsmith, want to dedicate your life to anime reviews or video games, or do you hope to grow up into an Atlantic or New Yorker superstar who's paid well, gets invited to parties with Important People, and makes the world a better place with his blathering? Not much of a question, is it. And accordingly, many game journalists have disdain for their effectively captive audience with those infantile interests; and extreme distaste for more grassroots commentary that chips away at their relevance.
The same logic partially applies to creatives (writers and even designers) in big name studios.
Some links:
https://crappygames.miraheze.org/wiki/Blog:Top_10_Worst_Things_Game_Journalists_Have_Ever_Done
https://old.reddit.com/r/TwoBestFriendsPlay/comments/cjs1g3/worst_game_journalist_moments/
But as for the specifics of the transition from enthusiasts to careerists – that's harder. Maybe it has something to do with the dynamics of publishing houses buying gamers' outlets.
Another aspect is that AAA games have become inherently more «soulless», and the same is true for movies. The latter can be partially quantified by paying attention to the share of expenditure that goes towards advertising. Inflation-adjusted advertisement costs seem to be stable. Production costs are only stable or growing if we don't adjust for inflation, like here. The obvious inference is that studios are becoming more reliant on advertisement (I suspect there are better sources on this), which must have corrupting influence on the reviewer/moviegoer ecosystem. An in games: for example, bloggers must compete for receiving pre-release access to publish their piece ahead of time and get their share of clicks in the fast-moving attention economy, so they've got to be on good terms with studios. Concrete case of how this turns out in practice: meh game Metroid Dread getting 88% on Metacritic with 124 reviews, while the crowning achievement of the genre, Hollow Knight has 90% with 27 reviews (recently it was 87% with the same review count, I have a screenshot; not sure what changed).
Now there's also a concerted effort to «groom» fanbases, build franchises... the structure of movie industry as an environment for producing art, even just mass commercial art, is unraveling into streamlined revenue pipelines. But that's the normal stuff of a hyper-optimized economy (I think there was a good substack post on that).
You theoretically can, but probably won't do it in any way that matters; if you are inherently dishonest, you'll see specifics of the case justifying another deceit or swindle, your barrier for excusing transgressions is lower than in people with strict moral code. And it probably does not even have the pronounced negative component. In my experience, archetypal WEIRD/Hajnal-born people genuinely feel terrible when they are «forced to cheat» against the consensus morality. By the same token they don't experience exhilaration at discovering a clever hack there (even when they love to hack and tinker in the abstract or in mediums that are not morally laden).
Now, in a sense you're right. With large-scale intrusive social engineering, it should be possible to nudge the whole society towards greater effective cooperation and conscientiousness, in a way no education and nutrition beyond the basic can do for intelligence.
A year and a half ago, on reddit, I quoted::
A commenter in Steven Hsu's blog wrote 2 years ago on his recent visit to China:
I also took a trip to China recently. Had not been back since 2007. The infrastructure is certainly impressive. The airports and train stations are quite amazing. The biggest change had been the behavior of the people. Much more orderly. Traffic in Guangzhou and Shanghai could pass for any U.S. city. Beijing is still more chaotic. I think mainly due to the massive overload of the roads. In the tourist places, there were just throngs of people. If the driver needs to get through, he has no choice but to cut in front of pedestrians.
There are no longer any pick pockets. People have better manner than I expected in the subways. No one toss trash on the streets. The roads, even high traffic areas like the Bund in Shanghai, are quite clean compared to the U.S. big cities.
All this should be credit to the omnipresent cameras and the fact that people don't carry a wallet anymore. However, I went to a bank to exchange some currency and left my umbrella there for a couple of hours, It was still sitting in the same place after I return. This would not have happened in 2007.
Effective punishment also helps. People are not sent to jail when they violate the rules, they are barred from riding the subway. All the entrances of the subways now have check points to correlate the picture taken there against the file picture from the ID. Not being able to ride the subways is a major drag in a big city like Beijing.
I believe underneath, people are still basically the same animal. There were reports of a park losing all of its lotus flowers (acres and acres of them) to looters who scale the fence at night to steal the flowers. Camera caught them to be mostly women and older men. However, the high probability of getting caught and the effective punishment changed at least the behavior. This is the start of the march toward the Singaporean model. When the older people die off, the younger generation will take the law and order to their heart as they are brought up that way.
What struck me about the Chinese government is their ability to get things done. Try something, does not work, try a different approach until one works. replicate nation wide. In the U.S., our government has lost this ability and has become a hindrance to progress.
Isn't it wonderful?
But this is just pleb stuff. The Chinese are still cheating horribly in governance, in crucial business and in science. It seems to require specific pressures for every single strand of the social fabric.
That's a ton of friction. Conscientious societies, in contrast, are almost frictionless – to the extent that your worst roadblock there is some moral busybody or a worrywart with red tape.
Judging by genetic correlations with fertility, we'll see worse dysgenics if we look at the bigger picture. In fact, intelligence is being bred out largely on account of its contribution to tasks common for people high in conscientiousness, honesty etc.
Of course this is the sort of thing original eugenicists cared very much about; their program was explicitly dedicated to breeding a kinder, more prosocial man and eliminating the genetic basis for criminality and insanity, not maxxing cognitive test scores and exam passing rates. But the bulk of the discussion got reduced to IQ/g because... because cognitive psychometrics proved harder to cancel with accusations of Nazism, I think.
And this Old World interest in «good character» in general is suspect. Show your KPIs or walk, euro boy!
Are Mormons bad at scriptwriting, or just good at conscientiously following a script? Who makes decisions about the particulars of the ideological slant, really? Ultimately the power over the show lies with Amazon Prime execs I guess.
Incidentally, /u/anything links to a reddit username. @Minotaur, meanwhile, produces a proper ping/link here.
There was a problem with that too, but I guess Zorba fixed it recently.
Honestly, I'd like to understand the philosophy informing your schtick, is this some devil advocacy, Williams syndrome, or do you just like making people explain themselves?
What does it even mean to 'reduce' a desire or action to a primal drive? What does it tell us about that action?
Reduction implies the absence of inherent interest in the action. At a minimum it tells us that some other inputs satisfying that primal drive just as well could be accepted as full compensation in the case of the action becoming non-viable, not just in the sense of being a good trade offer, but literally satisfying the specific motivation to pursue that action.
I don't know much about Vaush and see no point to demonizing him, so let's discuss a hypothetical Traush. Traush says the same things as Vaush here, but is a fanatical leftist from a reactionary's nightmare, who values human-made art and despises AI art for one reason only: most people with marketable artistic skill are leftists, therefore their effective monopoly on art (i.e. means of indoctrination) advances his political agenda and AI jeopardizes that. Put another way, his motivation to protest AI art genuinely reduces to will to political power. Assuming that Traush is a rational actor, he'd agree to some credible offer that advances leftist agenda through no new effort on his part and to an extent that offsetts (or more than offsets) the political loss induced by the democratization of AI-based art-making tools,
For example: after working with expert committees, the state proposes two possible solutions. A) human art is subsidized on every level from special free courses to giant exhibitions, people who want to dedicate their lives to artistic pursuits are getting a premium UBI package, commercialization of AI art is prohibited. B) starting at the age of 2 years, all children go to boarding schools with robo-nannies and heavy ideological propaganda the slant of which is determined by Traush's party, but for the next 20+ years nobody subsidizes art nor regulates AI tools for art. There's a referendum to vote for one or the other option.
Under the assumptions stated above, I believe Traush would pick option B in a heartbeat.
Edit: in rationalist parlance, all that is to say that reducible goals are trivially instrumental, whereas non-reducible ones are either terminal, perceived as such, or it's hard to see how they could be substituted without compromising some terminal goal.
the leftist impulse, which has always been focused on the ceaseless improvement and elevation of man in his ascent towards godhood
We really need fewer sweeping generalizations. Leftism is not transhumanism, that's just a theistic reactionary's cudgel to attack the Neo-Babel of social progress and attempts to «immanentize the eschaton». Marxism certainly isn't transhumanism, despite some vaguely congruent mutterings of Trotsky and weird blood transfusion experiments, which I believe have more to do with the ideology having taken root in Russia and consuming Russian Cosmism, its inherent pull to be used later as an extra carrot in the space race.
What do you think "fully automated luxury gay space communism" is supposed to mean?
My turn: what problem do you think «socially necessary labour time» is supposed to solve in the Marxist framework? It's supposed to protect rights of laborers (a perennial focus of leftist movements) against relative devaluing by automation, by denying legitimacy to the notion of market value, and by forcing society into the path where things that take little human labor to produce have little cost for humans either, and things that take no human labor at all are value-less. While we're at it, what is alienation that Vaush has mentioned? It's the concept that's meant to prevent human laborers from being reduced to tools – and eventually deemed obsolete.
Vaush is, contrary to your impression, staying true to the Orthodoxy, which was always meant to handle this failure mode.
A somewhat related comment from January, on the matter of /r/antiwork:
This seems to me to basically be an admission that the antiwork ideology is a failure. They have to rely axiomatically on some future conception of technology where humans don't have to do anything because AI or machines can already do all the dirty work for us and we can just spend our time on art and philosophy and literature and whatever we please. This system just does not work in the idealised sense (advertised in these communities) in a non-technologically advance form. It's all especially ironic because the technology that supposedly rescues their ideology was the product of the industrial revolution and capitalism.
That's not only not a failure but the truest part of Marxism, which is of course not just a descriptive but primarily a prescriptive theory, conceived of to build a society that can survive alongside superhumanly productive economy (i.e. so productive that human labor cannot pay for itself). Moreover, Orthodox Marxists were always acutely aware that necessary advances will be forged by the engine of capitalism.
I'd go so far as to say that they rely on a near-inevitability, on a truism like «humans die» or «you get more of what you incentivize», whereas their opponents rely on blatantly dissimilar cases like industrialization, wishful thinking, discredited tabula rasa assumptions and inapplicable arguments like comparative advantage (that does not account for countless things, like common resource market and human inefficiency at utilizing resources). It is increasingly clear that market forces in technology make labor market largely, if not wholly obsolete. That not only can we make robots generally intelligent, cheap and nimble enough to automate most/all jobs currently manned by humans below ~95th percentile by IQ (and not in the business of selling their human body specifically), but that humans are not anywhere near flexible enough to learn qualitatively different tricks.
And that there won't be a compensating explosion in conveniently simple bullshit openings like «robo nanny consultant» or «pattern connoisseur» or whatever either, because there's no need for so many midwitted PMC parasites in a world of endlessly scalable knowledge.
It is the inevitable consequence of capitalism that humans increasingly need not apply (and that supply can easily outstrip demand limited by purchasing power of humans who need not apply). Antiwork is just a rejection of Landian/NRx accelerationism which resolves this conundrum with a simple, parsimonious and historically proven «let them freeloaders starve then», which, of course, is the unspoken instinct of every good Protestant, and especially a high-IQ one that works in STEM or finance and does not expect to starve anytime soon.
There exists a minority of SJers who like dunking on people enough and believe conservatives are evil enough that they will adopt a hostile approach to conservatives even when this is net-negative for the SJ movement
The evolution of fairness through spite:
Given the sacrificial nature of making fair offers and rejecting unfair offers, the evolution of fair behaviour is naturally linked to altruism [11,12]. By contrast, our study shows that the connection is not so straightforward—fairness may have darker evolutionary roots.
Positive assortment facilitates the evolution of altruism; if altruists tend to interact more frequently with other altruists, then such behaviour can avoid subversion by free riders and evolve by natural selection [3,13–15]. Similarly, negative assortment facilitates the evolution of spite, social behaviour that inflicts harm with no direct benefit to the actor and often at some cost; if harm is more frequently inflicted on different types, then spite can evolve [16–18].
we focus on a simplified version of the ultimatum game where the proposer may make only one of two offers, fair (d = 0.5) or unfair (1 > d > 0.5), and the responder has two thresholds for acceptance, any offer or only fair offers (figure 1). Unfair offers (when accepted) mean that the proposer receives d of the resource and the responder receives 1 − d. Rejected offers result in both parties getting nothing. A strategy in the game specifies what choice to make when in the role of the proposer (fair, unfair) and what choice to make when in the role of the responder (accept, reject). There are four possible strategies in this game: S1 = (unfair, accept any), S2 = (unfair, reject unfair), S3 = (fair, accept any), S4 = (fair, reject unfair).
There are a number of mechanisms that can generate positive or negative assortment of strategies: spatial structure [29,30], population structure [31] and conditional strategies based on kinship [13], greenbeards [32] or co-evolving neutral markers [33]. Finite population size also generates some degree of negative assortment [34,35].
Positive assortment promotes the evolution of altruism. The best-known instance of this is Hamilton's rule.
Negative assortment, on the other hand, promotes spite. Suppose that some strategy pays a cost c to inflict a harm h on another individual. The condition for the spread of the spiteful strategy is r− > c/h. The ultimatum game, while a standard for modelling fairness, has a connection to spite: when the responder rejects any positive offer, she pays a cost to inflict a cost. For the responder in the mini-ultimatum game, the cost of spite is the amount rejected (1 − d), and the harm done to the proposer is the demand lost (d). Without negative assortment, S2 is eliminated by selection, and for this reason, it is often ignored in evolutionary analyses of the ultimatum game. However, S2 becomes increasingly important as negative assortment is introduced. This opens the door for spite to evolve, and has some unexpected effects on the evolution of fair behaviour in the game.
Seeing as each side considers itself fair and the other unfair, a political opponent can be likened to a player who has accumulated «unfair advantage» by repeatedly screwing the other side out of their fair share; this is literally what the progressives/sjws accuse the other party of doing. The rational or evolutionarily optimal purpose of «spite» is an attempt to suppress unfair behavior in the future, by rejecting not only new unfair offers but even fair (=equal; merit doesn't enter into it) ones that do not go towards rectification of the assumed standing imbalance. By much the same logic, political capital may be burned to punish people who defected in the past.
It needn't be 4D-chess-tier-strategically-reasonable, because the perceived worthiness of spite follows from heuristics and gut feeling. When people say «Yeah, but on the other hand, fuck 'em», they don't really mean they're being self-defeating, they just shoot down what they concede is plausible sophistry and concern trolling in defense of a bad actor who's about to get his due.
It's a bit similar how Europeans can accept some of Russian logic around energy policy and consequences of tanking their economy but don't find it sufficient grounds to stop punishing an aggressor. In bloodless terms of game theory, it can be defined as spite, but it's spite motivated by the sense of justice.
Then again, of course,
For most evolutionary outcomes, only partial fairness exists at equilibrium, because many individuals both make and reject unfair demands.
P.S. This may have interesting implications in scenarios of mixing low-trust/egoistic populations/cultures and high-trust/altruistic ones. Evolution of strategies is not only biological, too.
Leaving probable nutritional deficiencies etc. aside: the next generation will have an IQ of like 120, and the third one, I'd bet, of 119.6. Regression to the mean has nothing to do with evolutionary pressures, it's just the issue of resetting beneficial non-hereditary effects (which we assume explain 30-50% of the deviation from median phenotype in these particular specimens). It's not some abstract global mean but just the mean of the island population's genetic value for the trait. Cochran himself explained this well to Edge, in a kinder era:
The kids get the good additive genes, but have average "environmental" luck—so their average IQ is 110. The luck (10 pts worth) goes away.
The 120-IQ parents drawn from the IQ-85 population have 35 extra IQ points, half from good additive genes and half from good environmental luck. But in the next generation, the luck goes away… so they drop 17.5 points.
The next point is that the luck only goes away once. If you took those kids from the first group, with average IQs of 110, and dropped them on a friendly uninhabited island, they would eventually get around to mating—and the next generation would also have an IQ of 110. With tougher selection, say by kidnapping a year’s worth of National Merit Finalists, you could create a new ethny with far higher average intelligence than any existing. Eugenics is not only possible, it’s trivial.
(...Does he actually hope to do this?)
In the long run, the trait may well be watered down, of course – unless they discover some fitness peak that normie island populations couldn't get to because of all the valleys; I think Scott had a short story on brilliant island eugenicists?
But this happens because of purifying selection.
...Do you have a better idea of Wakanda? I haven't availed myself of relevant comics. And your criticisms are really wild for a popular movie; they're, uh, not supposed to have worldbuilding, at best some cool imagery and a plotline that's not fully schizophrenic, and in this case, pandering to a racial group with things they know and care about.
Black Panther starts the movie rescuing some Congolese women from (presumably sexual) slavery and decides not to kill a child soldier. But he's unmoved and still wants to build the wall. Then he changes his mind after hearing what life was like in Oakland 1992
If the last three years have taught me anything, it's that this is a realistic thought process for a well-meaning politician.
Much of that is an issue of data efficiency. I wonder how it'll be improved for really big models, but expect general few-shot learning in SD-type system scaled even 10x. Of course a different architecture would help.
Apologies for low-effort response to your beautiful prose, but: how did you, back in 2001-2003, connect 9/11 (Saudis' effort, if anything) to invading Iraq and building a democracy by gunfire there? You say you still believe in the cause. Has it ever crossed your mind, now or back then, that the princess might have been in another mosque and the entire cause is, charitably, a bit of a cope, specifically displacement?
I think Americans will have a sort of a crisis of faith when they understand that this isn't about them – that they are no longer important enough to pander to; and their changing sentiment is largely explained by this fact and their subconscious sense of being disrespected.
Israel itself is changing, growing, militarizing, becoming more right-wing by the day (their conservative right-of center being on the level of fringe Western right-wingers), and less invested in maintaining the sympathetic image of a scared, scarred victim of abuse by overwhelming power and numbers. The modern Israeli identity is their own, decoupled from Western culture, regardless of what anyone says about «the only democracy in the Middle East»; they've learned what works well, and are in the process of discarding the rest. There are still mighty interest groups doing their jobs, think tanks dedicated to nipping substantial anti-Israeli efforts like BDS in the bud, the stigma of Antisemitism in general is still powerful enough to cover Anti-Zionism (and the accusation of «white supremacism» or other adjacent smears against isolationists is only getting more life-ending)... but ultimately modern Israel doesn't care quite as much what Americans or other nations think, and will care almost nothing in the coming years. Have they defunded those gaudy outreach programs with sexy IDF girls yet? They might.
Right now Israel is preparing for war. Washington is making somewhat noncommittal noises, but the truth is, it's just unable to do more than postpone the decision, drag their feet with demanded supplies. And if they tarry too much, it will be self-defeating. Israel is resourceful, they will make do with tools it has or can produce or procure by other ways – only further decoupling. All those complaints about $3 billion that right-wingers like to air – they're no doubt annoying to Israelis, and will be thrown back in American faces when this annoyance (and the political benefit of bringing it up) outweighs the utility of that chump change.
Further, in the briefings, Barnea said a new nuclear pact with Iran would not block his agency from acting against the Islamic Republic in the future to protect Israel’s security interests.
“Israel is not signed on to the deal. Israel is permitted to defend itself any way possible, and will act this way. We cannot sit quietly and just watch as the danger grows closer,” Barnea, who took up his post in June 2021, told Lapid and other Israeli officials.
Does this look like Netanyahu's cartoon bomb moment?
Democrat or Republican, if you identify with the Hegemonic Superpower Maintaining Rules-Based International Liberal Order, the paternalistic big brother watching over a seed of a fraternal culture in the hostile environment – this must sting.
Kyle Rittenhouse was put on trial in part for, functionally, being a nigger while armed
Come on man. Not only are you ruining an otherwise not-terrible post but it's not even an apt metaphor for the situation.
Also, if you're not hiding your power level, you could shill your Substack and book while you're at it.
EfficientSyllabus prompted a very interesting discussion back then.
Much has been said on that in the past. Me recently on exploiting the story to convey a different message, Pageau making basically the same point exactly 25 months ago, my first post here on the purpose of storytelling (and other discussions around those posts of course), that's just what's comes to mind on the spot.
What I want to know is, do black people even like this sort of diversity&representation?
Pandering to black people (and other minorities) is a legitimate tactic. There's over a billion of them globally, more than whites in fact, and over 40 million in the US. If they act like a classical self-interested minority with Talebian skin in the game, i.e. sleep on a yet another movie with a pretty white girl MC, whereas white people won't boycott black Ariel (white people are, as often shown, the only group with an almost-nonexistent general ingroup preference and have no skin in the game), then it's only prudent to give them what they want.
Do they want it? Clearly they were crazy about Black Panther. Black Panther is, aside from being a better-than-average and more imaginative capeshit title, a coherent movie inherently valorizing black people. Not something with random canonically white characters that got race-swapped to make a political point. I don't expect any mass demographic to have discerning tastes, but surely they ought to feel somewhat more connection to a story about their people than to a story featuring their phenotypes.
Same for other demographics. The Chinese were, if memory serves, turned off by Shang Chi and thought it's stereotyping them as ugly, and not too happy with Mulan either. On the other hand, there was some angry noise about Scarlett Johansson and whitewashing in that unfortunate GiTS adaptation, but maybe that was just woke journalists. Did «Pacific Islanders» appreciate Jason Momoa in Aquaman? (For what it's worth, I did. A superhero movie, it seems, can only be interesting when it's unapologetic silly kitsch on steroids, or a deconstruction/an almost classical movie loosely inspired by source franchise, like Nolan stuff or Joker.)
Did «Hispanics» love Alita? Did South Asians appreciate Raya?
A yet another New York story about the ultra-Orthodox goes into my collection (previous entries: The New York Post: I was a Hasidic Jew – but I broke free, New Yorker: When One Parent Leaves a Hasidic Community, What Happens to the Kids? and bonus entry Vice: The Child-Rape Assembly Line).
What's always fascinating about traditionalist Jews is that they're not doing anything special or clever, all the secret sauce apparently lies in the execution and commitment to the cause. What is novel here? Strict patriarchy and gerontocracy, meritocracy where it matters (rabbis are smart and also fiercely loyal to the tribe), rewarding cooperation and association with cooperators, punishing defectors and non-punishers (with an eye to long-term pruning of bad branches: denying marriage prospects to non-compliant individuals), guarding against infohazards, sieged fortress doctrine to bring out maximum ingroup sentiment, willingness to sacrifice opportunity for your principles and forgo temptations for long-term (reproductive) gain, cozying up to local authorities and making use of acquired resources until your group grows enough that you can boss those authorities around, exploitation of politically expedient memes, playing the victim; and or course perfect coordination like voting in bloc, with blind trust in the judgement of your tribal hereditary elite. If it takes that much today to stop young Ashkenazim from using TikTok, the Rabbis will do that much. They take their mission as stewards of the group seriously.
(By the way: «Grand Rabbi» sounds like Archbishop or something, but that's basically a clan leader, a dynastic head priest; I wonder if Americans comprehend just how alien those people's livestyles are. They are not represented at all by your favorite blogger, or some funny nerdy STEM professor from a sitcom, running in the morning to the BART station, half-eaten bagel in hand. It's not a matter of degree, not an issue of extremist outliers, nothing like some beautiful exotic superstitions your gf's granny from Hawaii knows: they really are living like old Qahals, by strict Mafia-type laws enforced with more consistency than your state laws, omerta and all. But I digress).
They don't do anything their ancestors didn't do in Russian Empire shtetls and European ghettos. This is how they have been surviving – and attracting hate – for centuries, sans minor details like voting, and their dress code looking more quixotic now, a frozen snapshot from 18th century. If we are to trust Romans and Greeks, this is how ancient Jews have been living even in the pre-Christian era. In some ways the Hasidim have become more archaic, almost desperately LARPing as old school Orthodox; but in most ways they're being true to the general mold of the tradition.
If the society has «evolved» in any sense except purely technological, why are their tricks so effective? Why is it so easy to exploit? This reminds me of Wyclif's great series on Universal Cultural Takeover:
Bryan Caplan:
Given a choice, young people choose Western consumerism, gender norms, and entertainment. Anti-Western governments from Beijing to Tehran know this this to be true: Without draconian censorship and social regulation, “Westoxification” will win.
How’s that story working out in Tel Aviv?
Ultra-Orthodox Judaism is not a one-off. As Eric Kaufmann points out in _Shall the Religious Inherit the Earth? r_eligious cultures which haven’t been “eaten by the demon” are doing fine.
In all parts of the world, fundamentalist fertility exceeds moderate religious fertility, which in turn outpaces secular fertility.
Sometimes explicitly, self-consciously so. Some of the most extreme fundamentalist groups eschew conversion in favour of reproduction. They have quit persuading people on to their ark, and are getting ready to float.
Anyway. Ethics of nakedly particularist rules-lawyering aside, are they unhappy? The NYT authors are certainly very opposed to the continuation of their lifestyle, because it's, well, not explicitly geared towards what we recognize as self-actualization (I don't believe they worry all that much about subverting local politics or the funding issue). And sure enough, there's plenty of abuse in that community. But are they neurotic? Wracked by climate fears and anti-racist remorse? Invested into the Culture War, frothing at the mouth about Beijing Biden or Trump, Pizzagate and COVID? What do they think about their brothers secular/Reform Jews, or about Gentiles for that matter? I recall they think the latter are soulless murderers (to the extent that staying with one in an isolated space is inherently dangerous), and Reformers are lost souls who are almost as bad. They probably feel immensely greater disgust towards modern innovations like trans rights than the staunchest reactionary here (those of them who are allowed and willing to expose themselves to the Chaos of external society, the courageous vanguard). So, do they want to be rescued?
One additional issue is the existence of AI. We have many pundits and thinkers discussing the dangers of automation, the loss of meaning that for now comes with hard work. That's a very Christian, even Protestant idea. This group, if no other, will make the transition just fine. They do not like to work, they try to work as little as possible, their religion promises them liberation from work at the end of history as reward for millenia of piousness and fulfilling mitzvot, they find meaning in their family, tribe and praising their God, and that'll be only easier to do with universal basic income. If the AI deity offers it to them, they'll gladly welcome the opportunity to multiply and prosper.
These days, that's worth something. I would like other groups to take notes.
And people tell me that Maurice Samuel is not 100% correct...
For the purposes of this discussion a raccoon is not that different from a human, it's a series of minor allometric changes really. (Raccoon body plan is also affected by reproductive needs, of course). And I suspect that making a raccoon-like plumber is about as hard as making a humanoid plumber (or even harder, because sometimes you need a ton of power in this line of work, and actuators we can produce cheaply and at scale are weak per unit of mass, compared to muscles; we could make a hydraulic raccoon with external power, but...) All creatures with such capabilities will be comparably hard to make. One additional aspect is that we have already made lots of specialized tools adapted for our hand grip and arm strength; it's probably much cheaper to make a robot who can wield them than reinvent the hand and all it holds.
(In the long run though, I agree, our infrastructure will change and so will robots who serve it. Probably a lot more cramped spaces, if nothing else).
Reproductively advantageus traits tend to also be helpful for general survival and capability, or rather, beneficial traits get reinforced by sexual selection (see koinophilia); exceptions are so striking exactly because they violate our intuitions about natural selection.

Maybe untrue but not unfounded. Leaving aside my opinion (no doubt biased by monarch envy and the illiberality of knife loicenses; oy mate, wot you mean I can't stab people in streets?) on many though not all Russians (notably but a fraction among STEM-focused ones) who go to the United Kingdom of all places, people I interacted with as well, that compradore elite class, haughty and simultaneously obsequious children of self-important scum artfully skirting the borders of criminal culpability, spawn of slimy post-Soviet strivers scurrying desperately to plug their dynasties into the lower rungs of your stiffy alien hierarchy as it grows fat on plundered wealth which was meant to uplift my base countrymen; and our near-perfect agreement with regards to the Russian state where even those people can be rightfully called elite and feel indignation over being spurned and threatened by the genuinely subhuman siloviks and their hoi polloi loyalists; and the matter that you delicately affirm the right to assume the worst about Russians so long as they're real Russians and not, like, exiled oligarchs in the City or Baltic citizens with Slav ancestry (in a manner understandable but so typical for Russian-European conflicts, where even the dastardly Huns can be recognized for fellow gentlemen, while us Tsarist Orc serfs evoke zoological disgust) – that swipe was based on specific interactions pertinent to this case, with both of you.
(phew)
For Count it was the case with some light armored vehicle deliberately ramming into a civvie car, and mutterings to the effect that ruskies always go out of their way to murder civilians, heck they even smirked at him over lunch in LSE or something (if memory serves, that specific vehicle proved to be Ukrainian one that lost control).
For you it was the discussion around Darya Dugina's assassination, and Dugin's old viral video distributed by Ukrainians, one where he was supposedly calling for genocide of Ukrainians, when you were in rather clear agreement with the reddit hivemind that there was no context changing the interpretation; or if you were not, there was no way for me to tell. I'll actually go and quote, with one small edit, what I wrote back then:
More options
Context Copy link