Dude is a secular Jewish movie critic from Los Angeles who identified was a self-described marxist before he switched to identifying as "right wing" after he started working at Takismag.
Sounds like someone who understands what Marxism is, someone who understands why it is not a going concern at this time and place, someone who understands that yelling "THIS IS MARXISM!" at anything you do not like is not a winning strategy.
Likewise the whole time he's done so his schtick could be described as "the right wing needs to embrace left wing tactics/narratives if it wants to win"
What is your plan? Continue with tactics and narratives that always lose?
As myself and others keep pointing out, intersectionality/identity politics is basically just a re-rebranding of Marxism with a bunch race and sex stuff in the place of economic class.
Well, using this mode of analysis, everything is Marxism. When Ugg in they year 2,000,000 BC called his tribe to club heads of the other tribe on the other bank of the river, he was the first Marxist ever.
Other people keep pointing out that words mean something, including people like this lifelong Christian fundamentalist anti communist fighter Gary Kilgore North.
Cultural Marxism Is an Oxymoron
Ignore Anyone Who Says Marxism Is a Threat
But the postmodernist caravan goes on.
Maybe you don't notice because you grew up in the Soviet Union surrounded by literal Marxist so to you it's just the default
Unless @DaseindustriesLtd is really ancient, he grew in totally disilusioned society where it was easier to meet abominable snowman than "literal Marxist". If he remembers anything at all, he remembers indifferent teacher droning something about Lenin to indifferent class.
The teacher knew it was BS, the pupils knew it was BS, the teacher knew the pupils know it is BS (plus all possible permutations).
This makes sense if you consider that Yud takes Roko's Basilisk seriously. He's clearly realized this is his best contribution to its existence.
Well, how Big Yud reacted back then when Roko posted his idea on Less Wrong?
Called it wrong?
No, Yud went into full loud screaming mode.
https://basilisk.neocities.org/
I don't usually talk like this, but I'm going to make an exception for this case.
Listen to me very closely, you idiot.
YOU DO NOT THINK IN SUFFICIENT DETAIL ABOUT SUPERINTELLIGENCES CONSIDERING WHETHER OR NOT TO BLACKMAIL YOU. THAT IS THE ONLY POSSIBLE THING WHICH GIVES THEM A MOTIVE TO FOLLOW THROUGH ON THE BLACKMAIL.
and then put total ban on any further basilisk discussions on LW.
Not a reaction of someone who is not even slightly worried.
If big Y dissmissed this thing or just stayed silent, the whole idea would be forgotten in few days like other LW thought experiments. Streissand effect bites hard even if you are super genius.
But that applies even more to the Hitler-did-nothing-wrong Nazis — really, how many of the far-right are endangering themselves to spread the gospel of (neo-)Nazism, versus the ones who are in it because they think it‘s edgy, or because they have some vague grievance towards progressive politics and it was the easiest thing to latch on to? The lack of mind-reading goes both ways.
Even anonymous edgy neonazi posting can be dangerous thing. If you are doxxed as someone whose hobby is to shitpost as "Werwolf1488", your life is fucked (while not much will happen to "RedGuard1917", except friends laughing at him behind his back).
And that raises another point — isn‘t it pretty telling that people can get to say shit like “Mao is just misunderstood” and “the Great Leap Forward was the US’s fault for starving China” without getting overwhelming pushback (like someone would if they tried to justify the Holocaust, say) and making them reconsider?
Yes, it is pretty that communism is so completely dead that it can be treated as old unfunny joke and nothing else.
I guess what I'm saying is that certain religions have a sort of grandfather clause. Meanwhile, I'm less charitable to any blood spilt to build Flag Buildings.
Too plain work of architecture for your taste? When future Flag Houses will be magnificent marble buildings full of frescoes and golden icons of Ron Hubbard, would it change your mind?
Some are, like a quick read on the history of Penicillin would tell you. Out of the 4 or 5 big players in that story there is only one jew. To put in perspective how silly your position is, it would be like me saying the post-war cultural revolution in Japan was entirely jewish.
You did it, you called it a bad result of Jewish-American occupation of Japan. Not Anglo-German-Irish-Scandinavian-French-Italian-Black-Mexican-Slavic-Jewish-American occupation (no idea about precise ethnic composition of US forces in Japan at the time).
I'm not really sure if I should accept this as genuine. I mean, do I need to explain the importance of the legwork already put in place by gentiles that facilitated every single 'achievement' you link? All the co-authors and members of the various teams that worked on these problems?
Exactly, and the same thing is true about all bad things "The Jews" are usually blamed for.
Communism, for example, was invented by Gentile, spread and developed by many Gentile thinkers and embraced by masses of Gentiles worldwide, even in places where never were any Jews.
If it was not the case, if Jews and Jews alone were really responsible for all good and bad things that ever happened, it would mean that good rabbi Yosef is right and gentiles are nothing than herd of hopeless cattle.
I admit this is surprising. I would've predicted the Butlerian Jihad movement deprioritizing Yud as a crank who may blurt out some risky political take, but he establishes himself more and more as the Rightful Caliph. Have Yuddites discovered a stash of SBF's lunch money to buy a bunch of podcasters, including some crypto has-beens looking for a new grift? Or is this simply a snowball effect, where Yud is becoming more credible and attractive the more he goes to podcasts?
Yud was right, Kulak was wrong. Way to get things done is from above, through influencing elites and aspiring elites, not through impressing normies with handsome looks and smart fashion, not through doomed direct action.
This is only the beginning. The Katechon pact is coming, hide your laptop.
Because crime isn't tearing apart the (mostly-white) elite and wrecking our culture; the progressive religion which has as one of its chief tenets the evil of whiteness (always with the lower-case) and the corresponding martyrdom of Blackness (with the capital-b, of course), is.
Then, why not change this official religion, why not turn around propaganda both official and unofficial?
"Blackness good, Whiteness bad" is out.
New line is: "Americanism good, unamericanism bad. What is unamerican? Everything that divides Americans against each other over such minor details as color of skin, everything that splits our beloved Eagleland is unamerican and everything unamerican is treasonous."
"Why are lighter skinned Americans overrepresented among wealthy and educated professions, while darker skinned Americans are overrepresented in poverty and prison, you are asking? Only traitor would ask such question. Are you a traitor?"
If you have power to deprive of citizenship and deport millions of native born Americans, you have power to do this (and tell all media, education and entertainment complex to follow the new line, or else).
No need for full bore white supremacism, imagine normie conservatism with teeth.
I ask again then, what then is the discretion you would leave out of the state's hands? What are the choices that individuals and families are allowed to make?
We do not live in libertarian world where every adult is sovereign over his body, and will not in the foreseable future, and these decisions are political decisions.
Doctors will not replace your eye with glass one, your leg with wooden one and your hand with hook, not matter how how strongly you self identify as pirate, because pirate affirming health care is not recognized as legitimate medical procedure.
Why? Because transpiratical community is oppressed and persecuted, because transpiratism is not recognized as valid, because there is no respectable billionaire mafia family supporting transpirate rights. Sad.
"I love ancient trees, they are so majestic!"
"I hate little seedlings, they are so ugly! Stomp out these dirty weeds!"
Just have patience, it does not need more than century for delusionary doomsday cult to transform into respected ancient religion with magnificent art and architecture.
OK, so then my initial point that a parental rights argument is complete bullshit here is correct then?
Yes, it is bullshit. We are not in ancient Rome any more, parental rights have not been absolute for a long time.
Parents are, for example, not allowed to deny their children necessary health care.
Court Says Ill Child's Interests Outweigh Religion
The debate is not about parental rights. If you make it about parental rights, you lose, because this cause - absolute power of parents over their children - was settled long ago.
The debate is about gender affirming health care.
Is it medically necessary lifesaving treatment, or not?
And if it is not necessary for children, is it necessary for adults?
That the establishment doesn’t feel threatened by them doesn’t affect the sincerity of the belief.
How can you measure sincerity of belief? Only imperfect measure we have is willingness to sacrifice for the belief.
So, what are these "unironic" tankies doing? Do they spend their lives agitating and organizing workers IRL, while facing danger of harrassment, persecution, prison, torture and death, or are they shitposting on the internet?
No thank you. But your presence here is very helpful in illustrating just how easily people go from pretending jews don't exist in the negative to praising them for things they didn't even do in the positive. Maybe take a moment to think just how little bad a person could say of jews if all they ever did was good.
In the normie world yes, but this forum was never afraid of calling (((them))) in the slightest.
My point was, even if we accept that Jews and Jews alone are to blame for what are they most often blamed by people who are not fond of (((them))), inventing mass murdering totalitarian doctrines of communism and monotheism, their total tally (for people who insist on making such "tallies" of whole nations and ethnic groups) is highly positive.
Your argument fell flat because your original example of Jewish misdeed that started this exchange, stopping Japanese runaway population growth is something that would be seen by any reasonable person as good thing.
Every exponentional growth has to end some day (unless your vision of paradise is sphere of Japanese flesh expanding at the speed of light).
Even if of all the good things they do only half is true. As a cursory glance at any of the history of the topics you raised can show.
So, achievements I listed in my post are stolen from gentiles or complete fake? Tell me more.
Secondly, that doesn’t hold nearly as well when I hear people say that Mao was “misunderstood”, mm? I think that goes beyond “harmless pastime”.
Well, TPTB are not worried of world workers revolution, are not worried at all that people with hammer and sickle in their twitter handle are going to seize the means of production and expropriate the expropriators.
Communism in the West was not always perceived as harmless, but it is now.
Modern HBDers, by contrast, are at best indifferent and at worst hostile to the plight of non-whites. Their approach is not one of trying to improve race relations or the human race. They're tribalists, and HBD offers a convenient narrative why Our Tribe is superior and Their Tribe is awful.
"Modern HBDers" are anything but white supremacists, modern HBDers are IQ supremacists and their "tribe", if any, are all people who can pass the IQ tests.
You will not see a shred of sympathy for poor whites of Appalachia, Latin America, Balkans, post-Soviet countries etc. in this sphere. It is similar attitude that eugenicists 100 years ago had, only even more crass.
See, for example, Anatoly Karlin's attitude to ordinary "sovok" Russians, remember how he cheered when they died of COVID or alcohol poisoning, remember his open boasts he is not going to serve in Russian army, because heroic death for the motherland is for dumb cannon meat only.
edit: spelling mistakes fixed, so I can continue to pretend to be part of high IQ elite and avoid the fate that awaits the losers ;-)
Well that's just the thing isn't it? What places are those? Because I haven't been on twitter in a long time, but there were so many USSR fans on there a few years ago that people would refer to tankie twitter like black twitter or weird twitter. Radical leftists don't have to hide in forums for pedantic contrarians.
Tankie twitter is still there, while neo-nazi accounts are still mercilessly deleted.
Dunno why Elon does not put his big hammer down, why he does not give order to treat hammer and sickle accounts just like swastika accounts. Normie conservatives would be in high heavens, while normie liberals would have to tie themselves in knots explaining why banning Nazis is heroic fight against hate speech, while banning Communists is nazi censorship.
In a broader historical sense, when you take a look at the actions of 'Americans' as a whole, you can freely form an opinion on the history or 'net effect' America has had. Some come away seeing America as the greatest country in the world. Others come away calling it the great Satan. The important part here is that because 'America' can exist as a category, you can apply a broad opinion to it. Good or bad, America exists.
So, you want to debate whether "The Jews" as a whole, sum of all things every Jew ever did in all of recorded history, were on the net good or bad for all mankind.
Fine, let's go ahead.
Assuming you see saving human lives from premature death by hunger and disease as good:
Only from this top ten list of the greatest effective altruists who ever lived:
(((Fritz Haber))) of Haber–Bosch process.
2,300 million lives saved
(((Karl Landsteiner))) and (((Richard Lewisohn))), invention of practical blood transfusion.
2,200 million lives saved
(((Ernst Chain))) penicillin.
203 million lives saved
Even if you put blame on all premature deaths caused by monotheism and communism on (((them))), it is just tiny blip compared to these numbers alone.
Give thanks to your saviors and salute them every day.
I have never seen anyone in real life defend Hitler, like, ever. Not even outside of the West where it’s less of a taboo.
Of course - if you cheer for Hitler you are spitting on everything Western culture sees as sacred, you are the true counterculture and true rebel, and such rebellion has consequences few people are willing to pay.
Waving red flags with hammer and sickle can make you feel like rebel, but everyone knows it is harmless pastime.
It is also weird to see how more than half of the top 50 followed tiktokkers do not have Wikipedia pages. What does it take to be notable these days. Dominik Lipa (who is not a Mexican guy, as I presumed) has 65 million people who follow her and does not get a Wikipedia page. Perhaps people can't tell her apart from Addison Rae or Charli D'Amilio, or perhaps all girls of that age look vaguely similar to me.
Perhaps Wikipedia is not young thing any more.
Perhaps people editing Wikipedia are old geezers, relics from primeval times when people went to www to read things, not listen to music and watch videos, people who do not know what Tiktok is and do not care.
Perhaps the wrong side won in the most important war you never heard about - Wikipedia deletionist against inclusionist struggle. Had things went the other way, Wikipedia would today have 66 million articles instead of 6.6 million and nine tenths of them would be about Star Wars, Harry Potter, Pokemon, Dungeons&Dragons and similar nerd crap.
Perhaps it was about Tucker messing in Ukraine war and bringing anti-Ukraine talking points to the normie audience.
There's periodically a news story about someone who refuses to cooperate with police in ascertaining his identity being held until his identity can be ascertained. It seems like the system relies on its ability to get compliance even if that compliance is not always voluntary.
The law has a provision for it - if you refuse to identify yourself and there is no way to find who are you, you could be tried and convicted as "John Doe". It is not a secret trick to get out of prison.
It is less an issue today than in the past due to DNA, widespread documentation and omnipresent surveillance, but could still happen.
Make it illegal
You won war on alcohol, you won war on drugs, you won war on guns, war on contraception will be walkover.
Bring it on.
Particularly seeing as that genius, confined to the realm of the game, doesn't contribute anything tangible to the world. Assuming the fungibility of IQ, Magnus and others are an immense lost opportunity.
How many full time professional chess players are there in the world? If it is more than low five figures, i would be surprised (and large part of them are weird people who would not fit in professional scientific or engineering world, even if chess never existed).
If you want to be angry at waste of high IQ potential, better targets for your rage are things like this.

If "Seize the means of production to free yourself" is Marxism and "Chop off your dick to free yourself" is also Marxism, what is not Marxism?
Why cannot be "Go to church to free yourself" also Marxism?
More options
Context Copy link