@Eetan's banner p

Eetan


				

				

				
2 followers   follows 2 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:19:45 UTC

				

User ID: 208

Eetan


				
				
				

				
2 followers   follows 2 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:19:45 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 208

I am afraid you are all way overestimating influence of school education, especially history education.

See one historical event that is very important to the TPTB, historical event that is widely promoted to the point that special classes in schools are dedicated exclusively to teaching about this event (in addition to enormous space in popular mass media dedicated to this event)

Now, how effective was all this effort?

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/survey-finds-shocking-lack-holocaust-knowledge-among-millennials-gen-z-n1240031

https://www.claimscon.org/millennial-study/

A nationwide survey released Wednesday shows a "worrying lack of basic Holocaust knowledge" among adults under 40, including over 1 in 10 respondents who did not recall ever having heard the word "Holocaust" before.

The survey, touted as the first 50-state survey of Holocaust knowledge among millennials and Generation Z, showed that many respondents were unclear about the basic facts of the genocide. Sixty-three percent of those surveyed did not know that 6 million Jews were murdered in the Holocaust, and over half of those thought the death toll was fewer than 2 million. Over 40,000 concentration camps and ghettos were established during World War II, but nearly half of U.S. respondents could not name a single one.

"America is best represented by a Latino daughter of lesbians," essentially.

Nah. America is best represented by transgender gun toting killer clown. This is how AI sees it, and AI is always right.

https://twitter.com/CryptoTea_/status/1611017412648001543

Also, Karlin's predictive abilitites have not exactly shown their worth in 2022, regarding, well, most aspects of the Russian invasion and its presumed successes.

Karlin was wrong together with the whole world. Everyone from Putin to Biden, from CIA to OSINT twitter expected replay of 2014 Mosul or 2021 Kabul.

Russian maskirovka worked perfectly, everyone saw the manly recruitment videos full of brick smashing and bear wrestling stunts and believed in world's second super power.

Was there anyone notable who predicted that Russians will disastrously fail to defeat Ukraine?

Except our commenter Ilforte/ @DaseindustriesLtd ?

https://old.reddit.com/r/TheMotte/comments/t0cnbx/ukraine_invasion_megathread/hyduv1l/

We're probably not. Kiev is not Baghdad, Ukraininans are not Iraqis (no offense to Iraqis). Last of all, Russians are not Americans.

Assuming that the goal is regime change in Moscow and discrediting of Russians on all possible levels, we have to commit a lot more pointless murder and destruction and then lose. So far, Ukrainian performance demonstates both goals are achievable.

Let's see how my conspiracist analysis fares against your common-sensical one.

https://old.reddit.com/r/TheMotte/comments/sxnftk/culture_war_roundup_for_the_week_of_february_21/hy70oxd/

Не всё. There are some very correct words and allegations thrown in, some correct analysis. Alas, there is no genocide in Donbass, at least nothing that deserves of the name, so it is a cynical pretext, validating everything that Americans were saying about this issue. As is the case of our broader WWII-inspired propaganda, narrow like a T-34 vision slit. It's not even a very good propaganda because it doesn't resonate with the people any more.

I don't have much to say. This is a crime against Russia and against Slavs in general. And if he believes his bullshit about freeing Ukrainians from the Junta or whatever, he's in for a suprise and it'll be even more of a fucking disaster for us than a regular war would have been, and I wonder who supplied him with info all this time.

If he doesn't, I shudder to think of what actually moves him now, near the end of his life, and whom he serves. Not my people, that's for certain. He never cared much about that.

Certainly in terms of raw numbers more Soviets than Jews perished, but there was a differing zeal to which the Germans pursued and killed Jews. Somewhat ironically they were aided in this by Soviet censorship of near-any information concerning their chief ideological enemies: most Soviet Jews were not aware the Nazis were anti-semitic.

Pro-Nazi propaganda lasted only two years before the war, propaganda line before was strongly anti fascist and anti-Nazi, and Nazi antisemitism was well publicized in Soviet Union. The problem was that all Soviet propaganda with its constant twists and turns was seen as not entirely reliable.

When you learn to disregard the boy who cries wolf all the time, you are out of luck when wolf really comes.

Community of your free choice, community you can always leave if you find better deal elsewhere, is as untraditional thing as there can be.

Strong communities of the trad past were created either by direct coercion (serfdom, Jim Crow laws etc...) or by fact that even if you were unhappy in your home village, there was nowhere to go.

Feature, not a bug if you are a lawyer. Otherwise, I do not see any benefit for anyone.

I think the whole demographic question (ie. what happened to the prewar Jewish population) is the crucial question here, much moreso than the concentration camp doors or camp memoirs etc., but this is also a month old subthread so it's probably not a good place to discuss such issues.

Yes, the revisionists do have answer. Here is the CODOH reply to mainstream historians. You see that they agree that holocaust happened, only Stalin instead of Hitler was the perpetrator.

https://holocausthandbooks.com/index.php?page_id=29

Walter N. Sanning: The Dissolution of Eastern European Jewry

Before the Second World War, Eastern Europe was the demographic center of World Jewry. After the war, however, only a fraction of it was left behind. What happened?

The “Holocaust,” of course, most will say.

The author of this book did not stop there, though, but thoroughly explored European population developments and shifts mainly caused by emigration as well as deportations and evacuations conducted by both Nazis and the Soviets, among other things. The book is based mainly on Jewish, Zionist and mainstream sources. It concludes that a sizeable share of the Jews found missing during local censuses after the Second World War, which have so far been counted as “Holocaust victims,” had either emigrated (mainly to Israel or the U.S.) or had been deported by Stalin to Siberian labor camps.

Anatoly Karlin predicted that this line will become official Western history line in 21st century as Second Cold War heats up. We will see.

edit: links added

Groups without the ability to inspire such mind-numbing fear are fucked. And I don't think anyone would fear a bunch of conservatives.

What group? Hasids?

If so, they have indeed an advantage that other mafias, gangs and cartels cannot even dream about.

Italian Americans once tried to learn from the best and emulate their success. Unfortunately, too little and about a century too late.

Branch Davidians

Obligatory twitter thread for people who want to crawl into this rabbit hole.

TL;DR: the official line on Waco is as accurate as official line on ... anything else.

https://twitter.com/mattakersmusic/status/1528054223254040578

edit: link

How many prominent conservatives (particularly politicans) openly advocate for getting rid of no-fault divorce?

https://gillespieshields.com/101-facts-about-divorce-in-2021/

Every 13 seconds, there is one divorce in America.

That equates to 277 divorces per hour, 6,646 divorces per day, 46,523 divorces per week, and 2,419,196 divorces per year.

If you wanted to give every divorce full due process, do the math how much new courts, lawyers and judges would you need for this gigantic agenda, and how much it will cost.

Nothing new, "public intellectual" just discovered ideas vigorously debated on youtube, tumblr and reddit at least for 10 years and feels very very smart.

Everyone here knows about antinatalism, now look at efilism.

Efil = life backward, recognition that all life is suffering, extinction of all life is the only way to stop all suffering and is therefore absolute moral necessity.

Yes, all comic book super villains who wanted to destroy the world were the real heroes, and the super heroes who stopped them were the real villains.

Efilism is the next logical step after understanding Anti-natalism.

https://francoistremblay.wordpress.com/2014/07/10/a-little-lexicon-childfree-antinatalist-efilist/

Now, let us look at the practical problems: is ending all suffering possible?

Yes, and it is easier and cheaper you would imagine.

Do not think about super plagues, nuclear weapons or asteroid hits - look at chemical compound called sulfur hexafluoride.

Ordinary non toxic, non flammable, non explosive gas, fully legal to buy and possess, useful for many industrial applications and goofy party tricks, that just happens to be 23,900 times more effective greenhouse gas than CO2.

It could be affordable for single billionaire to manufacture in secret enough HF6 to turn Earth's climate into Venus' one.

All life will cook out in few days/weeks and then all suffering will end for forever. Some bacteria might survive deep in Earth's crust, but they will not be complex enough to feel pain.

Mission accomplished.

You know what Ukrainian nationalists mean when they speak of "Europe", don't you?

What they want Europe to mean does not matter, what Europe really means does matter.

Look at Ukraininan laws that are actually passing now - these are not laws about defending "Aryan race purity", these are laws about deregulation, privatization, restricting labor rights and protecting LGBTQ+ rights.

It's fine if you want to argue against women's suffrage, but you should bring arguments in proportion to how far outside of the current Overton Window it is.

Smash Overton window.

OP is obviously for some reasons fine with men voting.

It would be good to hear his arguments for male suffrage, arguments why not noble blood or superior learning as in traditional societies, but mere possession of penis should entitle even most ignorant mudblooded commoner to meddle in public affairs?

Some arguments that would justify peasant man deciding about government that wouldn't apply equally to peasant woman.

Who needs "conservatism" or "traditionalism" that want to conserve gains of 18th century revolutions?

Were such statues erected there? If yes, are there still there, or were they removed on grounds that they are affront to the national heritage of the locals?

Statues of Stalin were built all over USSR and "brotherly countries" (without consulting the people), and were removed after 1956 (also without consulting the people).

Should they be brought back? If so, everywhere or only in cities founded by Stalin?

This sounds like POW-MIA conspiracy theory mangled in retelling.

TL;DR: many more Americans than officially announced were captured by North Vietnam. US government knew about it, and deliberately let them die in captivity.

Mainstream history take

Conspiracy theory take

A lot, as otherwise they wouldn't have their city.

Hundreds of towns and cities were founded all over former USSR during Stalin's time.

Should statues of the big moustache man be built in each of them?

That does change my opinion of this actually.

From evil to just mildly embarrassing.

Do you see any removal of statue as "evil", do you think that any statue anyone put anywhere must stay there undisturbed for perpetuity?

Was this an act of evil?

Was this also evil?

England was still the only nation willing to care about them i.e. she was willing to annex them, at least.

The Spanish are not amused with this answer.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ireland%E2%80%93Spain_relations#Early_relations

In 1554-58 Philip Prince of Asturias was married to Mary I and was named as titular King of Ireland in the Papal Bull Ilius ad quem. As a result, during the first plantations of Ireland what is now County Offaly was shired as "King's County", and Philipstown (now Daingean) was named in his honour, the first Irish place named after someone from Spain. Soon after Mary's death he succeeded as Philip II of Spain.

In 1601, Spain supported Irish rebels fighting against England during the Nine Years War, and especially during the Siege of Kinsale. At the time, the Catholics of Ireland saw Spain as a potential liberator of their country from Protestant England and in 1595 Hugh O'Neill offered the crown of Ireland to Philip II of Spain. Philip refused the offer, having already been the titular King of Ireland.

Color me shocked that nobody selected a peasant Anarchist who was easily duped by Bolshevik salami tactics to be the symbol of united Ukrainian nationhood. Instead they had to chose the cringe nerd for the sole but very obvious reason because they knew they could always portray him to the normies as a victim of Nazi repression, because "he was in a concentration camp". (In reality, he was under the equivalent of house arrest under comfortable conditions, because he had qualms about one aspect of the proposed National Socialist European New Order, namely that it didn't include an autonomous Ukrainian state.)

People who were on the German side in the second late unpleasantness are still considered sus (even if they eventually got on their wrong side) , and Bandera is, to use modern woke term, problematic figure, especially in Poland.

In addition of being much more charismatic, Hollywood blockbuster worthy figure, Makhno would not have any of this baggage. (well, the Mennonites might object)

Bandera was picked as Hero(TM) and Founding Father(TM) of Ukraine not only because CIA chose to support OUN, but also because Soviet propaganda made him into Big Bad and gave him in this way great name recognition. Not because of anything he personally did.

In contrast, Soviet propaganda was nearly silent about Anarchists - all Civil War books and movies portrayed it as exclusive struggle of Reds and Whites, with Blacks shown only as ocassional perpetually drunk comic relief guys (and Greens absent completely).

sure...lol. We'll see how much of a good political sell this will turn out to be. I suggest you don't hold your breath.

It worked excellently so far. Look outside of your bubble - general public in Western world loves capitalism and loves LGBTQ+.

Btw, why don't we have any records from the Persians?

Yes we do.

Persepolis Fortification Tablets

https://oi.uchicago.edu/research/projects/persepolis-fortification-archive

Just too many armies sweeping through burning all the libraries for the next two thousand years?

More like: too much new construction and excavation in the last 50 years, with all archaeological remains of the past bulldozed away and built over.

We learn China has been lying about their covid stats and the real numbers of deaths are horrendous and all their zero-covid strategy was a colossal atrocity

Way to verify it would be survey representative sample of mainland Chinese citizens, ask them how many of their family members died or vanished vithout trace during early 2020.

This is standard approach, but there are numerous possible problems with it (starting with different definitions of "family" in different cultures)

What does it mean “the Big Guy”?

If you want to learn about American scandals, British tabloid gutter press is the way to go ;-)

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11056505/Hunter-Biden-associate-referred-Big-Guy-SECOND-message.html

Who is Ray Epps?

Big Trump fan from Arizona, who traveled all the way to DC to meet his idol, and then, instead to listening to his speech, engaged in highly sus behavior.

Meet Ray Epps

Meet Ray Epps, Part 2

This means Epps came to the Trump speech early in the morning with the sole intention of recruiting a mob to follow on the heels of the Capitol breach team he would personally oversee while Trump was speaking—the very breach team we have covered in this report whose operators would remove the fencing, signage and barricades before the masses would arrive at the Capitol.

Let’s put this all in context:

Ray Epps flew 2,300 miles from Phoenix, Arizona to Washington, DC for a Trump rally, supposedly as a Trump supporter.

Epps arrived at the rally entrance more than two hours early, camped out to constantly shout recruiting instructions about coming to the Capitol after the speech, but then skipped out on the speech itself, because he was too busy personally orchestrating the Big Bang Breach Team that kicked off the riot and tore down the fencing, barricades and signage, which made rallygoers totally unaware of the legal booby trap they had walked into.

I read an article from Zerohedge recently that listed a bunch of conspiracy theories that will be proven true on 2023.

Top 10 Conspiracy Theories That Will Be Validated In 2023

Bad article, worthy of clickbait site full of ads and popup videos. Either subpar shitcoating attempt, or just something to get more clicks and retweets.

#1 is already proven beyond reasonable doubt, what else would you need?

Open confession on live TV "Yeah, we did it, we laid the trap and lured the MAGAtards in, it worked perfectly! MUHEWHEHEHEH!"

#2

The evidence is mounting that the vaccines themselves may have been as deadly and damaging as the virus

If true, we would observe it in on total excess death statistics. Do we observe it?

#3 Old Bircher stuff from 1950's with serial numbers filed off. (Dwight Eisenhower Joe Biden is dedicated and conscious agent of the international communist conspiracy!)

In real world, US is moving hard and fast to isolate China and deny them access to commanding heights of current cutting edge technologies. @DaseindustriesLtd wrote about it at length.

#4 Who cares?

#5 Nothing of importance for anyone, except for Donald's ego.

#6 Who cares?

#7 Even Russian propaganda moved forward from "biolabs" to satanism. Yes, Ukraine is developed country with universities, industry and research labs. If you were searching for Ukraine on map of Africa, you were looking at the wrong place.

#8 Pedophilia again. Conservatives talk about "liberal mainstreaming of pedophilia" for decades, while pedo panic grows stronger and stronger, "pedos" are universal and approved target of hatred while definition of "pedo" grows more expansive every year (when was the first time you heard about things like "age gap"?)

Future is not free love hippy commune where anything goes:

"25 years old man and 5 years old woman? Love is love! How sweet!"

Future is:

"45 years old man and 25 years old woman? Age gap is age gap! LYNCH THE PEDO!"

#9 Matrix is works of fiction unconnected to anything in reality. Human beings are not batteries. Of the grab bag of unrelated things cited here, some empower the state, most of them are opportunities to empower individuals(who know how to use them). There is no one big plan to "collectivize the world", there are many plans to privatize everything that is still for grabs.

#10 Everyone with basic awareness already knows it.

(it does not include wannabe domestic terrorists )

edit: link fixed

Yes it could happen.

"Donald Trump had his faults, but he was great leader and statesman, always dignified, honorable and presidential. He would never ever imagine someone like Nick Fuentes raising Nazi flag over White House and holding catboy sex orgies in the Oval Office!"

England was supposed to be loving and caring mother of Ireland?

Obligatory Soviet joke is in order.

Teacher: Lil Peter, who are your parents?

Petya: Our great leader Stalin is my father, and our great Soviet country is my mother!

Teacher: You are smart boy. What you want to be when you grow up?

Petya: An orphan.

edit: link fixed