FirmWeird
Randomly Generated Reddit Username
No bio...
User ID: 757
Dems lost the Twitter stronghold but if they can shill their narrative on TikTok and insta then they can get a momentum going.
Dems tried to shut TikTok down because of all the Gaza footage that was spreading on there, and Gaza is a toxic issue for the dems - their base hates what is going on but their donors and organisational leadership support everything that's happening. They're not going to have a good time on TikTok and I wouldn't be surprised if they try to go after it again.
And I'm not sure why they abandoned them.
There is an extremely obvious answer that jumps out at me from reading the text - discrimination laws. Even if you just want to keep out the riff-raff and the poor, class-based policies like the one you're suggesting are going to be an absolute goldmine for any lawyer who knows what the phrase "disparate impact" means. A policy which keeps out members of the societal underclass is going to disproportionately impact black people, which means it is then going to have the business which upholds that policy wiped out in court if seriously challenged.
Today, we don't do that kind of screening. That's a level of trust that you see, that is manifest, and it is raised, rather than lowered.
I actually disagree - there is in fact less trust. What happened is that the spread of insurance and large corporations mean that the costs of accounting for those problems that you're talking about are simply spread out and distributed across the rest of society and the rest of that corporation. They aren't trusting you or their customers - structural changes mean that there's just not really anything you could do to seriously inconvenience them. If you go into an Apple store and just wreck the entire place, destroying/stealing every single piece of tech in there, the costs of your actions aren't going to be added to the bills of people who shop there - those customers are already paying for that risk and have been for years.
I mean, how would you even measure this? What would it take to say "okay the temperature is going in the right direction, thanks left", do you think you would be able to recognize it or is it purely a vibes check?
I legitimately haven't thought about this because I didn't actually think there was any way to stop it - I assumed it would just continue to get worse over time until there's an irreversible reduction in societal complexity (good luck cancelling someone whose job is stealing copper wiring from abandoned buildings). Any kind of positive steps in this direction would be extremely negative steps, personally, for anyone on the left who actually wanted to make them. Furthermore, it isn't actually like there's a central authority figure who could speak for the entire left and announce that the days of cancelling people are over - and even if there was, making that kind of announcement would doubtless cause them to lose all that influence and authority. Second, the trust required for such an announcement to be taken seriously or in good faith just isn't there, either. You'd have to come up with meaningful consequences for this kind of behaviour, along with a reliable and trustworthy enforcement body, because a system like this would absolutely get gamed the second it was implemented.
The only workable alternative that I can see would be legislation that mandates incredibly harsh penalties for the employers who actually fire people like this, but that has consequences and a lot of complications as well - a left-wing political group should absolutely be able to fire someone because they found out that he was actually a secret nazi doing his best to sabotage them from within.
Of course, my dream goal would be for the world to adopt my preferred political system (non-catholic environmentalist distributism), which would mean that cancellation can't really happen due to the altered structure of the economy. But that isn't going to happen anytime soon so it isn't really a realistic proposal.
Forgiveness is a method of strength and leveraging the good traits of humanity.
I agree! But the concept is a lot more complicated than that and requires that the other person stop doing whatever it is you need to forgive them for. If I go to a concert and there's an active shooter murdering people in the crowd, preventing them from committing more murders is actually the moral course of action when compared to just forgiving them and letting them continue to shoot people.
That said in this specific case, while I think no cancelling would be ideal, I am not going to blame the people on the right for taking advantage of the new rules the left has set up until the left makes a serious effort to go back and dial down the temperature.
Should we just forget people’s utter hypocrisy? That’s the so-what. In my opinion, Tucker Carlson has been one of the handful of the top most norms-damaging individuals in the United States over the past 5 years. He has shown he is a liar and not trustworthy, so why should we take anything he says now at face value?
Nobody actually cares about people's utter hypocrisy. I have been extremely consistent in my belief that any news organisation or political figure which advocated in favour of the Iraq war permanently destroyed their reputation and legitimacy. The Trump years were full of the same - a mixture of both blatant falsehoods and artful deceptions. Nothing Carlson did even comes close to the WMD case, or the outright lies given professional gloss during the Biden Laptop saga.
That said, if you want to start holding media figures and organisations to account for peddling falsehoods and lies, I'm right there with you - as long as that's your actual motivation rather than some kind of partisan concern.
RationalWiki is (or was?) a legitimately good source on a lot of cranks, especially from way back in the days when things were simpler and the chief debate on the internet was creationism vs evolution. But at the same time if you look at their article on Trump or anything remotely connected to the culture wars you're just looking at the same kind of junk they're so great at calling out when the political valence is flipped.
As someone who saw his descent happen in real time and even helped push him along by trolling Rationalwiki a few times, I really appreciated this article. It was nice to read a confirmation of all the things I'd recognised about him years ago backed up by real evidence and investigation - though at the end it just made me want to give him a smirk and a "We're not so different, you and I" speech for our seemingly shared efforts at disinformation.
When Gamergate became a culture-war issue, the anti-Gamergate people started talking about ants (a Gamergate is actually a type of ant, as well as an internet argument) to prevent pro-Gamergate people from seeing what they were talking about.
Ok, great. So you agree with Purdue's materials.
This doesn't even reach the level of a bad faith attempt to understand my position or argue with the ideas I actually hold. If you think that's an honest estimation of my views on the topic then I don't think there's any point talking anymore because we clearly aren't communicating with each other.
But, still .... how the hell are either of these guys mad about anything?
Most people on the internet find getting into the weeds and dirty details of the various bad faith prosecutions of Trump to be unbearable - imagine having to live through them. I'm honestly surprised he isn't angrier when I picture myself in his position, sitting across from someone who knowingly lied in order to start a fraudulent criminal prosecution against me while threatening my family, reputation and legacy. Throw in the fact that he's now a constant target for mockery in public and in culture, and I can absolutely see why he's angry.
Ok, great! Quick question, though... how come Scott talks about adjusting the dose of various medications up/down, depending on how it's going? He's a doctor, and a trained medical professional to boot. Shouldn't he like, just "know" the appropriate amount of whatever drug to give to his patients?
No? Regular supervision and adjustment of the dosage is part and parcel of responsible medical care. If he gets it right on the first go, great, and if he doesn't part of his job is adjusting the dosage or even pulling the patient off the drug. Sometimes the patient's condition can change as a result of medication and they don't need as much of it as they recover - a patient recovering and thus not needing as much of a certain medicine as they did before is not evidence that they were never sick and never needed medication.
I mean, no? Did they, like, jump into the exam room, and when doc was "just knowing" the "appropriate" amount, they interfered and somehow made him increase it?
And because it covers the same ground...
What large financial incentives? Come on, man. Stop hiding the ball.
There's no need for scare quotes. Doctors are in fact legitimate medical professionals, and making decisions about dosage is part of their professional responsibility and skillset. There's nothing magical about an anaesthesiologist determining the appropriate level of painkillers for someone based on sex/weight/pre-existing conditions. But yes, they did actually interfere. To quote from one of the legal documents involved...
Purdue’s most powerful tool of deception was sending sales representatives to promote opioids to Massachusetts doctors, nurses, and pharmacists face to face. During sales visits, Purdue reps made false and misleading claims directly to the professionals who care for Massachusetts patients. Purdue assigned reps to specific territories in Massachusetts and gave them lists of Massachusetts doctors to visit.
They sent people out to lie to medical professionals in order to encourage them to sell more Purdue pharmaceuticals.
Each of these in-person sales visits cost Purdue money — on average more than $200 per visit. But Purdue made that money back many times over, because it convinced doctors to prescribe its addictive drugs. When Purdue identified a doctor as a profitable target, Purdue visited the doctor frequently: often weekly, sometimes almost every day. Purdue salespeople asked doctors to list specific patients they were scheduled to see and pressed the doctors to commit to put the patients on Purdue opioids. By the time a patient walked into a clinic, the doctor, in Purdue’s words, had already “guaranteed” that he would prescribe Purdue’s drugs. Purdue rewarded high-prescribing doctors with coffee, ice cream, catered lunches, and cash. Purdue has given meals, money, or other gifts to more than 2,000 Massachusetts prescribers.
And they were actually just paying and bribing doctors who prescribed large doses of opioids. Literal kickbacks! They actually made up fake case profiles and patients in order to convince doctors to hand out oxycontin even when it wasn't necessary or dangerous.
Purdue trained its reps to show doctors charts emphasizing Medicare coverage for its opioids and use profiles of fake elderly patients, complete with staged photographs, to convince doctors to prescribe opioids. As a Massachusetts sales rep observed, a fake patient profile “brings the heart into it” and helps get the doctor to say: “Yes, they need this medication.”
I mean, also no? They produced (maybe just promoted?) a concept that may, indeed, be wrong.
Could it be possible that they made an accurate and true scientific discovery while faking data in order to sell more of their product? I doubt it. The core idea of their marketing was that drug addiction was actually just something that happens to "untrustworthy" people when exposed to drugs, and that "trustworthy" people can be prescribed whatever dose of painkillers you want without any risks. They created numerous bodies to create the misleading impression that pseudoaddiction was a real concept and convince doctors to ignore their actual training. Furthermore, they knew they were lying!
Purdue knew its campaign to push higher doses of opioids was wrong. Doctors on Purdue’s payroll admitted in writing that pseudoaddiction was used to describe “behaviors that are clearly characterized as drug abuse” and put Purdue at risk of “ignoring” addiction and “sanctioning abuse.” But Purdue nevertheless urged doctors to respond to signs of addiction by prescribing higher doses of Purdue’s drugs.
And remember, the thing you're trying to show is that they "were ultimately responsible for and made substantial profits from a legal and corporate structure that heavily encouraged and even induced addiction in cases where it wasn't necessary". So, I'd definitely like to hear some things about their legal and corporate structure.
The Massachusetts document is the best source for that.
Hey, I missed this reply, but the answer to this is actually yes, contra to the reply you received.
Each of these in-person sales visits cost Purdue money — on average more than$200 per visit. But Purdue made that money back many times over, because it convinced doctors to prescribe its addictive drugs. When Purdue identified a doctor as a profitable target, Purdue visited the doctor frequently: often weekly, sometimes almost every day. Purdue salespeople asked doctors to list specific patients they were scheduled to see and pressed the doctors to commit to put the patients on Purdue opioids. By the time a patient walked into a clinic, the doctor, in Purdue’s words, had already “guaranteed” that he would prescribe Purdue’s drugs. Purdue rewarded high-prescribing doctors with coffee, ice cream, catered lunches, and cash. Purdue has given meals, money, or other gifts to more than 2,000 Massachusetts prescribers.
Edit: to clarify a bit, i dont think Biden did as bad as he has been portrayed in some circles, but after months of the official narrative being that "Joe's sharper than ever, anyone suggesting otherwise is a russian troll" his debate performance might've well been a public execution.
I agree with this and I think you gesture at an important point - a lot of credibility was put on the line and invested in the claim that Biden is doing just fine and any claims of mental health decline are just misinformation, and now that credibility is going up in smoke. Sure, a lot of people will just not care or forget, but some will remember this the next time the party needs them to believe something that doesn't quite seem true.
I guarantee that you, the plaintiff, the FDA, nobody has any sort of rigorous line on when it is "necessary".
As Armin pointed out what counts as "necessary" is dependent upon the situation, patient etc.
But, while it appears you have read the article, you didn't read the links contained within it. I don't blame you for not doing so, legal documents are really long and boring, but that's what you're actually looking for. The meat of the accusations is in fact contained within them. So when you make a comment like
And it's not like their marketing is ever going to be like, "Hey doctors, you should prescribe a higher dose even when your patient responsibly wants a lower dose,"
We can actually turn to the prosecution and see what they were doing.
Together, these drug manufacturers (the “Manufacturer Defendants”) collaborated to falsely deny the serious risks of opioid addiction generally, and high-dose opioid prescriptions specifically. At the same time, they created and promoted the concept of “pseudoaddiction”—a made-up term designed to re-cast familiar symptoms of addiction as signs that patients needed more opioid drugs. They falsely claimed that their opioid drugs could be counted on to improve chronic pain patients’ function and quality of life, and that their extended-release opioid formulations would provide effective pain relief for 12 hours, when they knew there was no scientific support for those claims. And they misleadingly suggested that other pain relief methods were riskier than opioids, while falsely claiming that opioid dependence and withdrawal could be easily managed and effectively prevented with unproven screening tools and management techniques.
Each Manufacturer Defendant spent millions of dollars over the following decade to push these fraudulent messages. They pushed their own name-brand drugs by “detailing” their sales representatives to target susceptible doctors with in-person visits, flooding medical publications with deceptive advertisements, and offering consumers discount cards to entice them to request treatment with their products. And they collaborated to promote the overall expansion of the opioid market by sponsoring misleading Continuing Medical Education (“CME”) seminars and manipulating seemingly independent organizations (“Front Groups”) that the manufacturers funded and disguised as “unbiased” sources of cutting-edge medical research and information. Both the Front Groups and CME seminars depended on co-opted doctors—so-called “Key Opinion Leaders” (“KOLs”)—that the manufacturers recruited and paid.
They were, in fact using aggressive marketing techniques and deception to convince doctors to prescribe higher doses when their patient responsibly wanted a lower dose. They took the symptoms of addiction and claimed that they were actually signs of a condition which required more opioids!
But in any event, what does your magic, yet-unknown line of "necessary" have to do with addiction? What's the model connecting this completely unknown thing to rates of opioid addiction?
There's nothing magic about the opinion of a medical professional. There's nothing unknown or mysterious about the idea that a trained medical professional or doctor would know the appropriate amount of painkillers to give to their patient. Purdue Pharma interfered with this and produced fraudulent research which gave both large financial incentives and a figleaf of justification to encourage inappropriately high doses of opioids (see the Pseudoaddiction concept above). That's the connection, and it is outlined clear as day in the charges against Purdue and the Sacklers.
Uh, sure? They used a variety of financial incentives to encourage doctors to prescribe higher and higher doses of Oxycontin even when it wasn't necessary, because that made them more money. They were directly(and indirectly) paying doctors to hand this stuff out even when it wasn't strictly necessary, taking advantage of the prestige and respect rightfully given to medical professionals in order to generate vast profits while directly fostering opioid addictions.
Maybe I'm missing your point, because I don't know what kind of intermediate steps you need to get from "Inducing doctors to unnecessarily prescribe high doses of opioids" to "Opioid usage epidemic".
Did you actually click the link? I didn't include the sordid details but they do actually explain what happened and how it worked. A magic sentence like that is totally fine when you include the explanation in another part of the text.
Rather than non-public information leaking in, I think this is actually just public information taking a while to leak in. I've been on the record as claiming that Biden was suffering from age-related cognitive decline since this site was on reddit - if you take off the partisan blinkers the decline is obvious, undeniable and easily predicted even without any video evidence of his gaffes.
Kamala might have a lot of problems, and might be historically unpopular -- but at least she doesn't come with these problems, and that may look attractive right now.
I think she actually does have a bunch of controversies. Nobody really cared to bring them up or make a big deal out of them before when she was just the VP, but there's no way Trump and his team are going to just leave all that ammunition on the floor. Right now the left have thoroughly demotivated their base with their support of Israel and what's happening there - appointing someone who fought to make sure non-violent and innocent prisoners stayed behind bars so they could be used for prison labour/fire camps as the representative of the left is going to be a huge demotivating factor for a lot of left-wingers as well... and I have a sneaking suspicion that Trump won't be too polite and gentlemanly to bring those up.
Someone else has already written this up for me, so I'll just quote them.
With the launch of OxyContin, in 1995, Purdue unleashed an unprecedented marketing blitz, pushing the use of powerful opioids for a huge range of ailments and asserting that its product led to addiction in “fewer than one percent” of patients. This strategy was a spectacular commercial success: according to Purdue, OxyContin has since generated approximately thirty billion dollars in revenue, making the Sacklers (whom I wrote about for the magazine, in 2017, and about whom I will publish a book next year) one of America’s richest families.
But OxyContin’s success also sparked a deadly crisis of addiction. Other pharmaceutical companies followed Purdue’s lead, introducing competing products; eventually, millions of Americans were struggling with opioid-use disorders. Many people who were addicted but couldn’t afford or access prescription drugs transitioned to heroin and black-market fentanyl. According to a recent analysis by the Wall Street Journal, the disruptions associated with the coronavirus have only intensified the opioid epidemic, and overdose deaths are accelerating. For all the complexity of this public-health crisis, there is now widespread agreement that its origins are relatively straightforward.
...
Her filing was studded with damning internal company e-mails revealing that, even in the face of a skyrocketing death toll from the opioid crisis, members of the Sackler family pushed Purdue staff to find aggressive new ways to market OxyContin and other opioids, and to persuade doctors to prescribe stronger doses for longer periods of time.
As someone who has gone into the weeds on this, I do not think you want to start getting into the origination of COVID, Peter Daszak and the ecohealth alliance et al. There aren't any wins for progressive politics in that direction.
The agenda is something else entirely (in the case of "cancel suffs," I strongly suspect that it's some combination of "How dare a musical about white women win a bunch of awards?" and some theater in-group fighting) and the claims of caring about factual history are a mask.
My personal read for a lot of these cancellation attacks is that the ultimate motive is freeing up a seat at the table for them or their friends. The protestor is here informing the culprits about their moral failings, which puts them in the position of having superior knowledge and adherence to left wing priorities. Obviously the people being protested have to go, and conveniently enough there are some people right here who know what they did wrong, and can recommend a replacement who won't be so problematic.
While I can actually agree with that, I think that such people are a very small minority - and I also don't think he closed the border in any way that matters. The situation is still a mess, and Biden can't even begin to offer a real answer because his donors and political cohort want to make sure that the problem stays a big problem (because that big problem is incredibly profitable for them).
Closing the border was a smart move. It neutralizes one of Trump's strongest arguments for moderates.
Was it?
There's no way that he can actually compete with Trump for the "no more illegal immigration" vote, and it is just going to hurt his numbers and dampen enthusiasm with his actual base. Furthermore, the manner in which he did it isn't going to convince anyone in the moderate camp - that claim will only last as long as it takes for someone to pull out a smartphone and google what he actually did.
What is very distinctive about Trumpism is that the loyalty is to Trump, specifically. Non-personalist political movements can and do regularly replace leadership figures when they become a liability, while their duller supporters are usually the least motivated and exert minimal influence over leadership selection.
I feel that a part of this is the sheer non-presence and lack of authenticity behind most modern politicians. Contrast him to any other conservative politician in the last two decades and it isn't exactly hard to understand why he does so much better in this regard. The fact that he is actually the best vehicle for that inchoate rage and sense of resentment that has taken over so much of America adds to that as well - there's no way that his base would accept another empty suit who gives off the impression that he will immediately betray them once he gets into power.
My point there is that the "grievance" is hollow. There's no material injury.
Where's the US manufacturing sector? Do you live in some kind of alternative universe where there's no fentanyl/opioid epidemic? I think that there's actually a serious case to be made that a lot of the people in Trump's base are noticeably poorer than they were before, and the exact policies that Trump has made clear his opposition to were responsible. You're the first person I've encountered who claimed that the economic problems his base have been talking about just don't exist.
Trump supporters have an inferiority complex and feel humiliated when college-educated liberals look down on them.
I feel like this is extremely uncharitable - this is the mirror image of the argument that Trump haters are simply immature people who hate their fathers, and that sense of childhood grievance is what actually informs their opposition to him. Deep down people who don't like Trump know that he's right and correct, but because they can't get over their daddy issues they just can't accept an authority figure who can tell them no.
Is there some yokel in a trailerpark somewhere who looked up from the crackpipe to vote for Trump due to some university educated SJW looking down on him? Sure, that dude probably exists somewhere, but you're doing yourself a disservice when you base your view of the world on people like that.
To the extent that these people have been abused (referring primarily to rural conservatives, rather than affluent exurbanites), it has generally been by their own leaders who they continue to support. The reason the town's factory closed down wasn't because of snooty Democrat journalists from NYC.
Their own leaders who they continue to support? No, the policies that have destroyed these communities were passed with bipartisan agreement. I think that the Republican leaders prior to Trump were corrupt ghouls who pursued policies responsible for untold suffering in order to enrich themselves and profit from the public purse, but it isn't like the left had anything better to offer. Many people in the Trump base actually voted for Obama because they believed in the message of change - and then they saw what they actually got (policies identical to another 8 years of Bush).
Though in fairness to the Republicans, even a maximally protectionist industrial policy isn't going to fix competition on the international market.
I honestly don't know how much this can be fixed - the big mistake was in growing China into the industrial and manufacturing powerhouse it is now, and it isn't like Trump could just hit the "undo" button on policies which lead to China having 232 times the shipbuilding capacity of the US. The promise of Trump is that he at the very least would be trying to improve things as opposed to just taking a nice cut from the people making the problem worse.
I won't go so far as to call it a lie, because while I think Greer probably knew it wasn't true he wasn't so much willfully misrepresenting facts as making an... emotionally satisfying statement.
I don't think that he's lying, but I'm perfectly willing to just go and ask him the next time he opens up for questions. He actually spent quite a while living in the areas he's talking about, and he's old enough that he actually has childhood memories of the 60s. He was actually there! While I'm open to the claim that you have a better understanding of the situation than he does, I'd want some actual evidence rather than just waving your hand in the direction of the evidence (especially seeing as how your opinion is conflicting with someone who was there at the time).
If you want to make a normative argument about the desirability of segregation and women's labor force participation, I'm going to have to pass on that discussion.
Not at all - if you're familiar with the rest of Greer's work, the actual reason (I think) he gives for this would be the combination of vast fossil fuel reserves, WW2 destroying the US' competition and the proceeds of empire all feeding back in to the prosperity enjoyed by America during those years. He's not advocating for some kind of GLORIVOS RETVRN, and he even explicitly makes the point elsewhere that he's not suggesting going back to the social values of those years.
For Trump's die hards? It's the sine qua non. They have other concerns, but they are either standard Republican things (tax cuts, abortion, nativism) that most Republican candidates would deliver on (and thus don't really explain Trump's particular appeal) or at odds with the reality of policy under the Trump administration (e.g. the Republican Party continues to be anti-labor).
Trump famously didn't give a shit about abortion and gave answers which embarrassed his base on the topic. Other republicans also don't give a shit about immigration (they make a lot of noise about it to get elected, but they don't actually do anything to solve the problem because too many of them financially profit from the illegal immigration situation). The strongest point you make there is talking about things that were "at odds with the reality of policy under the Trump administration", but the general belief in his base was that he was hamstrung by a Republican establishment that hated him as well as a deep state that was actively fighting against him at every turn. There's a decent amount of truth to those claims as well, enough that these people can maintain their faith in him.

I don't think you need any sort of third shooter conspiracy style thinking to get to the real problem here. I'm a big fan of conspiracy theories and love exploring them, but the facts on the ground are damning enough on their own. The secret service rebuffing multiple requests for additional security, ignoring multiple reports of the shooter, ignoring the call from the shooter's parents warning them about him, letting him get through the metal detector with a rangefinder, having a sniper aiming at him before he actually took the shot, ignoring the multiple people who are recorded on camera pointing him out, ignoring the police officer who went onto the roof and saw he had a gun... and worst of all, letting Trump go onto stage for ten minutes when they knew there was somebody with a sniper rifle taking aim at the stage!
The most straightforward conspiracy theory that is practically jumping out of the page and requires no mysterious phantom gunmen or bizarre codes of silence is that they wanted the shooter to succeed. They rebuffed Trump's requests for additional security and then allowed Crooks to take his shot before they did anything. This kind of conspiracy also doesn't require any extremely tortured codes of silence - nobody who isn't directly legally liable for what happened would know anything or need to keep their silence.
I can't see any argument against this other than incompetence, but claiming that this is incompetence not only beggars belief, it raises the immediate counterargument that every single person remotely involved needs to lose their job for gross misconduct. If they actually made all these mistakes earnestly I'm surprised they can put their shoes on in the morning and don't routinely shoot themselves in the head when looking down the barrel of their gun to make sure there's a bullet inside.
More options
Context Copy link