@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

Never believe that anti-Semites are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. The anti-Semites have the right to play. They even like to play with discourse for, by giving ridiculous reasons, they discredit the seriousness of their interlocutors. They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert. If you press them too closely, they will abruptly fall silent, loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past. -- Sartre

Mockery of the sacred is a one way street. The religious can't beat atheist absurdism by beclowning themselves, because once the whole argument is perceived as absurd the atheist has won. Once onlookers say "Oh God, what are all those freaks at the capital arguing about?" It's the church that loses credibility, Satan never had any to begin with.

There were never circles where Christian rock was cool. I get your point you're trying to make and your misunderstanding as a trans Atlantic coastal elite, but it's misunderstanding both the concept of cool and the concept of Christian rock and indeed the concept of rock.

This. Several times this. WMD was a fake ass category invented as a piece of misinformation.

Re: Casual contact transmission of AIDS

One of the other great works of AIDS literature is of course Larson's Rent. Larson wrote many drafts over the years, and who had AIDS and how bad and how they got it varied throughout. In early drafts, which date to the late 80s, the hetero non addict characters are also infected, or assume that they probably are or will be from living in close proximity to infected persons. There's much more of a fatalistic tone to early drafts, everyone is going to die, even the heteros and lesbians and non addicts, and die soon.

As drafts progressed, Mark stopped having, then stopped assuming he would get, AIDS, and Roger's infection was more clearly tied to intravenous drug use and his dead ex rather than just sort of having it because idk reasons. Much of Mark's character arc becomes about surviving his friends, as Larson did, and documenting and immortalizing his dead and dying friends, but also the strange isolation of being the survivor, the normie of the group, the straight white non addicted ally.

Much of this reflected the progression of medical knowledge in real life, and the final script in turn has become more a period relic than a reflection of modernity, by the time the movie came out it had a totally different valence. Treatments were different, prognoses were different.

The song that really has the most currency to today's world, and best reflected how the world would progress, is probably Santa Fe, which predicted without realizing it the development of the restaurant industry in small towns across America.

The term doesn't really have legal meaning, just an inflation in language.

But in this case, it actually fits. The teacher isn't threatening the kid with beheading on a personal basis, because the kid is annoying him. He is threatening the kid for the kid's political views, telling him if you oppose Israel you should/will be beheaded, or at least that your teacher will scream such obscene threats at you. This would have the likely effect of preventing other students from expressing similar views, for fear of beheading/getting screamed at by their teacher. The purpose is terroristic: the threat was made to change the expressed political views and actions of the threatened person and the audience.

I would say threats with a political purpose or agenda behind them are strictly worse than threats with a purely personal Animus. For scalability reasons, because of the additional victims in the audience, and because of the added threat to freedom of speech/association/etc. If he threatened a kid because the kid annoyed him, that would only impact the kid. When he threatened a kid for the kid's views on Palestine, the kid is victimized, and any members of the audience who share that view of Palestine are equally victimized because they know their teacher is also threatening them if they speak out (probably throw in anyone who has views that also might cause controversy), and the rest of the group is victimized because their thoughts will tend to be restricted by the threat.

Harsh, signal punishment is necessary to let everyone know that society does not condone political violence and that they are free to speak and think what they will.

I don't think either group is all that clearly outlined, because the world in which Trump is Nominated+Convicted is a different world in more ways than just Trump's location.

Other important groups of people:

-- People who will commit or attempt terroristic violence after Trump is imprisoned.

-- People who won't vote for Trump after the above have committed their terroristic violence on principle. Cops and cop fans, mainly, are likely to fall into this category. While Cops are typically very red tribe, after a MAGA mad hatter kills a cop in cold blood, they will flip.

-- People who won't vote at all if Trump is in prison because they will lose faith in the system.

And the thing is, that upside doesn't just carry across the Presidential race, it carries all the way down ballot in all likelihood, as GOPers will be forced to bend the knee from Senate to City Council.

Tucker was probably just using irresponsible hyperbole. But I've been buying eggs every week for years. I've never paid more than $5 a dozen. There may be weird parts of the country where there were shortages, but that just wasn't a thing in most of the country, for ANY reason.

This is hitting Arrested Development levels out here people.

Eggs are not $11/doz because of price gouging or bird flu or operating costs or any other reason, they just aren't $11! Go to Target.com, search for a dozen eggs. Here's the large cage free ones: $2.59. Price fairly consistent across multiple locations.

Seriously. What are we even talking about here?

/images/1702553232279261.webp

I always found Richard confusing in that he seems so unlikeable, and is clearly the butt-monkey of the friend group, then he'll report just randomly pulling normie chicks as soon as he leaves the group, who disappear as quickly as they appear in the narrative.

Depending how heavily one finds his narration unreliable, it's not hard to imagine him lying about all sorts of things, that a lot of the positive things he gets are lies or hallucinations.

Oh man, I'd love to hear more of your thoughts on the book.

My theories:

-- Richard or Camilla killed Henry. Shooting yourself in the head, twice, is difficult. Not strictly impossible, but difficult. In favor of Richard: Richard changes distinctly after the murder, in ways that mirror and follow the path of what Henry talks about in the garden conversation, he is able to shut up his internal voices and successfully graduate, get into grad school, for a time carry on a normal relationship. Part of his symbolic accession to personhood and his inheritance from Henry is receiving Henry's BMW; throughout the story Richard is limited by his lack of a car, he is dependent on the goodwill of others in a way that is both very symbolic and very realistic to an isolated rural school, who has what car where is a constant source of tension in the work. He kills Henry, and symbolically inherits this grant of full personhood. He becomes more human after the murder, more functional, the rest of the group becomes less functional, drifts outward into their dysfunctions. In favor of Camilla: Camilla was much more involved and agentic than indicated in the work. She is the unsung glue of the group in a big way. Richard and the other boys are always vaguely frienemies, it is never clear which boys are closer and which boys are in competition or enmity, who is in and who is out, while Camilla is always in with all the other boys. Three out of the four are constantly besotted with Camilla, Francis is also shown to be closer with her as a friend. Everyone else is willing to lie about, cover up, or minimize her involvement in their accounts; both because they want to protect her and because they don't want to admit they were under her spell.

— Richard wrote the note from "Bunny," for the purpose of bringing the group back together. Richard feeds off the group, off feeling in on the secret. They’re all starting to drift apart, the group is tearing at the seams, so he creates another crisis for them to keep their secret to try to bring them together again. He liked the game of murdering Bunny, so he creates a new crisis, maybe they will murder Julian? It fails, spectacularly, with Henry’s death.

A lot of excellent posts here, making the point about a lack of intelligence and training. I'm going to argue a separate and related point: a lack of sangfroid, bloodthirst, psychopathy, a lack of willingness to kill.

Most ordinary humans, including gangbangers, have a reluctance to kill directly in cold blood. Most humans will kill in the right circumstances, will fight under pressure or in a group, but left alone to make the single decision to pull the trigger on a sniper rifle? Different mindset entirely.

A driveby, or a group of guys walking up, is high pressure, impulsive, when you get there you are in danger and must act to "defend" yourself or you might die, and it is a group activity your friends are there to keep you accountable. A sniper on a rooftop is solitary, is waiting and watching, he has to personally make the cold blooded decision to kill, he is in no danger and can choose not to act or to flee and avoid the danger.

If you are in a group of three guys in a Ford Explorer, all hanging out the window and shooting wildly, there is a sense in which you aren't necessarily responsible for any individual death on the other side. In the moment, there is a lack of certainty: maybe I shot him or maybe my friend did. If you are a sniper sitting on a rooftop, you are certain that you are the one who did the killing.

Training a human to kill in cold blood takes a lot of effort, a lot of training hours to program obedience to programming, it doesn't happen instantly or perfectly. Militaries drill obedience into their men to produce a soldier who will follow their training and do what they were told without thinking about what they're doing too hard. Muzzle-loader era armies emphasized firing in volleys both for effectiveness, and to allow the average soldiers to avoid feeling personal guilt for killing, instead the emphasis is on duty and coordination with your mates. Modern armies emphasize coordination, with soldiers mostly engaging in covering fire on specific targets, soldiers are rarely asked to kill individually outside of their training, instead the emphasis is on doing your job for your mates.

Gangbangers similarly maintain discipline, such as it is, and accountability to your mates by putting their street soldiers in situations where they are directly with their friends, in danger, and must act to look good and brave and protect their friends. That is psychologically easier for the average person.

It really is possibly the greatest unintentional period piece. It couldn't have been written five years in any direction and made sense.

@EdenicFaithful I just finished up Donna Tartt's The Secret History, which my wife bought for me after seeing it recommended by fashion girlies on social media. It is, at the end of the day, a high class thriller, John Grisham with literary pretensions. I enjoyed the book immensely, I wanted something relatively light after reading a lot of heavy non-fiction lately. And it felt made for me, it is a thriller following a bunch of weirdo pseudo-aristocratic classics students, and I'm the kind of guy who went to a northeastern undergrad school and wore a vintage camel hair sportcoat to a class studying Procopius' The Secret History. There's an effortpost brewing in my notes about the book's status as the progenitor of the "Dark Academia" aesthetic meme, and the memetics of online aesthetics more generally.

With the exception of classics (The Bible, Ovid, Dante, Shakespeare, etc.) which I can't avoid having an opinion on going in, I try to avoid reading about something while I am still in the process of reading the work itself. And because my wife bought it for me as a gift, and specifically referenced seeing it on social media, I kind of assumed that it was new fiction, from the past five years or so. Having finished it, I looked at a few reviews, trying to find things I hadn't caught on my read through. The setting felt vaguely 80s, but there weren't enough clear references to really pin it down, and it felt like an odd time period to pick if you weren't going to use it much and like reference Reagan or era-appropriate music...imagine my surprise when I found out the novel was written in 1992 and the reason it lacked a lot of period-references was because at the time it was written the novel was simply set in the present, with no need to let people know when it was because the underlying assumption was that elite liberal arts students would more or less always be like that, Tartt wouldn't have been able to imagine that two and a half decades later college would be so completely eaten by computerization that her novel would be rendered completely historical.

I had, of course, assumed that the novel was written today, and set in a vague past to avoid smartphones. It is tough to imagine much of novel's moody pacing working in the social media age, with characters texting or engaging in posting every event on social media. Indeed, I have trouble thinking of murder mysteries or thrillers that successfully integrate the smartphone into their plotting. Every modern novel in the genre seems to avoid them by various obvious crutches, such as lampshading that a character refuses to use cellphones, having the phone lose reception run out of batteries or be broken at every critical moment, or by the simple expedient of forgetting about it. I don't read a ton of new fiction, but I can't think of a thriller that handles cellphone usage well. Even the sci-fi novels I recall reading which featured greater communications advances failed to reflect how I actually use cell phones in reality.

So now to get to my Small Scale Questions: how does one successfully integrate the digital world into the classic murder mystery or thriller structure? What authors or works have done so? Is it even possible to do so, or does the digital age simply require that we maintain a higher willing suspension of disbelief? Does communications tech usage date any work to a particular five-year period, because communications tech is moving so fast (ie, in 2003 the gang of high school friends would have definitely used AIM, by 2008 AIM was lame and facebook messenger was everything, by 2013 nobody I knew in college used messenger for much of anything preferring snapchat, in the decade since we've seen the rise and fall of a half dozen social media services, data plans and wifi access have gone from very limited to universal, etc.)? Is there a similar literary discourse about prior technological transitions? Did the telegraph and telephone cause authors to go "oh, shit, so many plots out the window, better set this story in the past or in the wild west or something?" Did literary critics talk about how old plots were obviated by car travel?

Turkish coffee! The accoutrements are cheap, the product is good and universally loved, the ritual of sitting there carefully watching the coffee boil and getting it off the burner just before it goes over is meditative and relaxing.

That's why I wrote the TLDR, you can literally just choose to do that.

I agree with you broadly but you are overstating your case. It is perfectly consistent to state that factions have a limited ability to steal elections.

One dynamic you see in historical studies of stolen elections is that there are typically both honest and stolen locales, and the stolen locales vary in their willingness to lie.

In the famous and well studied cases of LBJ in Texas, rotten boroughs varied. From precincts where voters were handed $5 and a shot of tequila before voting in person, to places where voters were marched in by shotgun wielding ranch foremen and instructed who to vote for, to precincts where the ranch owners dropped off the identical filled ballots of all their employees, to precincts where no one seemed to show up to vote but all the registered voters were recorded as voting, to precincts where votes were filled out in alphabetical order for people who didn't live there or had died years ago.

In LBJ's first Senate campaign, he made use of all these methods as did his opponent, but LBJ announced his results first, and his opponent was able to steal enough extra votes to win. In his second, LBJ did not make that mistake again, and stole more aggressively and at the last minute, but still one by a tiny margin after tapping all his resources.

It's perfectly possible to say that faction can rig an election between a set margin, but not outside it.

The problem is that this isn't claimed by most election truthers, and certainly not consistently.

I'm not sure I'm seeing where anyone would gain additional subpoena power as a result of a guilty plea which closes all active cases and sends Hunter to club fed for a two year stretch? If anything significant discovery powers would be headed off, both legally and politically.

I've long believed that if Hunter had any decency at all, he would go to his dad and demand to go to prison. Even if, by some absurdity, he was factually innocent. The best thing he can do for his father, his family, his country, is to go to prison. Take the rap on tax stuff, get two years, read the Bible cover to cover and lift weights. Most Americans don't actually find tax fraud morally disqualifying anyway.

Then Joe can get up and give a speech about how in America no one is above the law, his son made mistakes and he's going to pay for them.

Write something vaguely related to the primary topic, then. I tried to flesh out something more detailed and provide a jumping off point this time specifically to address the complaint of vagueness. You're certainly welcome to argue against the prompt in your essay, to argue that the postulates underlying it are false.

I really don't see how one creates an essay contest they does not favor people who like words.

This whole analysis is off-base, because it fails to examine the reason why content warnings, and most other identity-based lobbying, are effective or not effective.

Thesis/TLDR: Content warnings aren't effective because they prevent exposure to a "triggering" stimulus, they are effective because by giving them society is acknowledging the power and importance of the individual/group that could be thus triggered. This is a salve to the wounds of most identity based issues, such as racism or sexual assault, because the primary harm of those issues is the feeling of the individual lacking power.

Imagine the following personal scenario by analogy. Albert has recently gone through a viciously bad breakup, his girlfriend publicly cheated on him, and has left him for the other man. Their mutual social circle is aware, his friends at work know and have probably gossiped to the rest of the office. Everywhere he goes, everyone he knows talks about it, he can't escape it, even if people don't bring it up, he suspects that they are talking behind his back. He goes fishing with his father Brian, Brian asks him how he's handling the breakup, Albert says hey dad, I'm tired of it, let's talk about literally anything else. But Brian wants to know about the breakup, he's curious, he keeps asking, says hey come on I'm your father you can talk about this with me. Albert snaps, says it is my life and I don't have to talk about it if I don't want to. Brian says you don't want to listen to me because you don't respect me. Albert says you don't respect me or else you wouldn't insist on talking about something I don't want to talk about. Both become angry, both feel that the other doesn't respect him.

Now is Albert primarily angry at the thought of talking to his father, or his he primarily angry at the loss of power, that he has been robbed of the power to choose what to talk about? Is his father primarily angry that he isn't hearing about the breakup, or is he angry that his son doesn't respect him enough to confide in him? After this struggle has become about power and respect, is Albert going to be happier to talk about the breakup, or will it feel worse than ever to talk about it?

Trigger warnings are the same. Who are the groups who advocate for trigger warnings? Subaltern ethnic groups, and rape victims. What is the psychologically harmful experience of being a member of a subaltern ethnic group or of rape? It is the experience of lacking power, the feeling that one lacks importance, that others can abuse or instrumentalize your existence towards their own ends. Trigger warnings are an effective salve, not because they prevent exposure to the bad thing, but because by giving a trigger warning society is saying to them: you matter, you are important, you have power, we will allow you to decide what we talk about. This improves things for such a person, because they feel that someone cares about their feelings, about what they think. This is a normal psychological dynamic.

At the same time, the majority or historically dominant groups will experience this loss of power and agency as a psychological harm. This is a normal psychological dynamic. Worse, they will experience the loss more keenly than they experience any gain. That's a natural flaw in human minds.

This is also why the concept of trigger warnings is such a mind-virus: the dynamic this creates makes viewing the purportedly harmful content more harmful, not less, because now being "forced" to view the content will seem like a greater loss of power than providing the trigger warning originally seemed like a gain.

So to zoom back out to the whole concept of "The Tolerable Level of Permanent Unhappiness" as you put it. The question isn't so much about unhappiness, it is about power and agency. Increasing the power and agency of subaltern groups, and concomitantly decreasing the power and agency of everyone else to determine their own lives.

I am, for the most part, the picture they put next to privilege in the SJWebster's Dictionary of Woke Terminology: blond, male, heterosexual, reasonably comfortable. Ceteris paribus, in the current system, left to my own devices I am capable of living a happy life pursuing my own interests. At some level of proximity and severity of unhappiness, that would be widely seen as inappropriate. If my mother was dying in the hospital, going on a climbing trip that weekend would widely be seen as wrong. If my sister and my nieces were out on the street, it would widely be seen as heartless for me to buy myself a new car. That balance of severity and proximity extends outward to some point, where it is inappropriate for me to do [X] while [Y] is experiencing [Z]. While someone close to me is miserable, I should not be left to my own devices to pursue my own happiness, I should be caring for them, to help them.

The argument here seems to be for a vast expansion of both the proximity at which I should be constrained in my actions, and the level of misery at which I should be constrained in my actions. To say I don't have the right to go on vacation the week my best friend's house burns down strikes me as a reasonable constraint on my freedom and agency, indeed helping him is an exercise of my agency and power as a person. Telling me that I don't have the right to have a comfortable life until everyone does, is to totally restrain my freedom and agency, it's to say I'm not allowed to do anything. Telling me I can't have an honest conversation about difficult topics in a college course until Black people are all happy, or until no one ever gets raped, is to totally restrain my ability to have a college education. At the same time, these arguments elevate the feelings of power of the powerless.

These arguments should always be about examining power and agency of the players involved.

I knew there was a reason I liked you. We did immediate family only, one surviving grandparent, siblings, parents, plus maid of honor/best man.

This seems in the same vein as things I’ve read about how simply not paying debts works a lot better than it should in terms of avoiding actual repercussions.

There's a problem in a lot of Americas formalized systems, the threats are largely effective to prevent you from living a normal middle class or above existence, which if you've already given up on or failed out of that goal, isn't very effective. Once people slip into the world where they'll never qualify for a mortgage, or get a really good job, or have a significant amount of savings in a bank, a lot of the threats of bankruptcy, collections, etc become ineffective. If you are never going to get a loan, you don't care about your credit score. If you work for cash under the table and never plan to get a formal job, you don't care about garnishment. You just hang up on the debt collectors, and you put all your bills in your girlfriend's name, and move on with your life.

When the rent/eviction moratoriums were in place, I understood the policy's goals and advantages, but I also understood the mindset of lower end renters in a way that was overlooked in a lot of analysis. If you're already never going to get a mortgage or have a decent credit score, and know you never will, then the obvious play if you won't be evicted for six months to a year is to stop paying rent and stack that cash on hand. Even if you're future oriented, not paying rent for six months gives you an opportunity to save money that you might never see again! Save $10-20k, and now move in with your girlfriend and put her name on the lease or maybe even use it as the down payment for a small house!

A lot of policy makers and bureaucrats didn't see a plan like that, because their credit score is really important to them, and they can't imagine a person for whom it isn't important. Something about Hawks and Rats?

The trouble with love is that dogs don't last long enough and people last too long.

Thank you for the link. Interesting blog. Scattered Thoughts:

-- I need to crunch the numbers, but to what extent is the "Sex Recession" narrative oversold after looking at this data, a reverse of the Coming Apart argument about economics/social class? It seems like what's really happening isn't that middle-class white kids are having moderately less sex than they used to, it's that impoverished Black kids are having massively less sex than they used to and middle class white kids are having a little less sex, and it all adds up to the total sample having moderately less sex.

Murray in Coming Apart argues that if you tease apart economic data and QoL data, the US white lower/middle/working class has not progressed at all since the 1960s, has in fact regressed for a variety of reasons, and that the positive trend of the data over that time is driven by bringing impoverished racial minorities towards parity with whites. In the same way, Blacks used to have a lot of teenage sex, now they are close to parity with white rates of teenage sex, and that shows up in race-neutral data as a big ol' sex recession, when really we're seeing a very mild sex decline.

That doesn't mean the sex recession isn't concerning, a mild decline is still a bad thing to my values, but it should impact the way we think about this more than it does. None of the responses to "What is causing the sex recession?" tend to have much to do with inner-city Black kids and their transition to the lower middle class over the past thirty years. All the responses about helicopter parenting, College Admissions min-maxing, etc seem to be asking entirely different questions.

-- I wish we had cross-cutting class data, as I always do with racial data.

-- I'm always curious about the impact of "last name sex" (oral sex, anal sex, manual sex [the technical name for the handjob/fingerbang], intercrural sex, and even I can't come up with a technical name for titty-fucking) on the data. I suspect that much of the gap between female and male reported numbers can be explained in that way. Men who have gotten a blowjob or a handjob or fingered a girl briefly but inconclusively are more likely to report it as sex, women who have given a blowjob or a handjob or been fingered briefly but inconclusively are more likely not to, to think of it as "fooling around" not as "sex." This could also explain some of the sex-recession data: oral sex was once seen as perverted, and hence "more" serious than vaginal intercourse, many youth today treat vaginal intercourse as more serious than other forms of sex, so they may be under reporting for that reason. Because that is largely a cultural question, I suspect it could have a larger impact on racial spreads, but I have no idea if there is any racial gap in sexual taxonomy. Any evidence for this one way or the other?

-- A lot of people point to an overall lack of independence in teens today, with fewer having jobs in favor of mix-maxing college admissions extra-curriculars. The obvious solution is to, by colleges engaging in best practices if possible but by government requirement if necessary, to make the college admissions min-maxing option to get a serious part time job. Make it priority for kids to have a work record in their application, with preferences given to employed students for admission and for financial aid. If it was well known that the best thing to put in your Princeton application essay is stories about your time as shift-lead at Taco Bell or working on a roofing crew in the summers, our talented upper class kids will be managing Taco Bells and nailing up shingles, instead of interning or doing ineffective traveling altruism. The incentives point away from youth independence, but we have the power to straighten out those incentives.

Getting a part-time job is the very best way to foster independence and freedom in youths. Having obligations and responsibility to adults outside of your family and school, having independent sources of money, having relationships to coworkers on a basis of equality outside the natural hierarchies of family and school systems, getting out of the house. All positives!

-- How much turnover has there been in the racial groupings outlined? To what extent are today's Black teenagers descendants of yesterdays Black teenagers, versus replacement by West Indian and African immigrants? I'm sure this data is available but I'm not sure how to look it up.

Re: condoms, this is also a secondary result of pornography which has erotocized (for lots of men and at least some women) the external cumshot. Coitus interruptus used to be an absolute last resort, bottom tier sex act in literature, with the presumption being that the semen would then be spilled on the ground or on the bed. Now it's erotocized, many would choose to finish on a woman's back/breasts/face even absent safety concerns with finishing inside her pussy.