FiveHourMarathon
a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop
And every gimmick hungry yob
Digging gold from rock n roll
Grabs the mic to tell us
he'll die before he's sold
But I believe in this
And it's been tested by research
He who fucks nuns
Will later join the church
User ID: 195
Yes. It seems pretty clear to me. Last name sex. It's status as consolation prize is kinda irrelevant, and skill dependent, to the question. You certainly can't have sex any other way afterwards until the refractory period concludes.
To me handies are less relevant to the WLW question than they are to the evasive evangelical girl question. Given that our NHIE questions tended to "punish" slutty behavior. So consider "Never have I ever... Had sex with a man!" If a guy gave a man a hand job to completion he should clearly drink. Or a kings rule like drink if you've had more than five sexual partners. A girl who's had PIV with three guys and gave five others hand jobs should clearly drink there.
In reply to both your replies to me, yes you have it exactly right. That is exactly why FMF threesomes are more common. Though I think the "equality" is a lot less common than you seem to think, it's more a of a platonic ideal that is only rarely reached than the average. A lot of FMF threesomes degrade into some mix of one person watching the other two fuck" or "theoretically Bi unicorn is a pillow princess" or something like that. But that's why they at least make it far enough to fail, yeah.
Once again, though, it is perfectly possible for any other motivation to free-ride on that "normal" motivation, so a shameful fetish motivation doesn't need to be exposed to daylight. Defining Fetish here as "Needing X stimulus to get off" (where X isn't something banal like physical stimulation of the genitals or whatever), we quickly reason that the Fetishes are only detectable or necessary to confess where they are weird, because if you required X to get off but it was something fairly normal it would never be apparent unless it was from inside the person's mind. If I had a fetish for Brunette white girls no one would ever notice because that is a solid percentage of my dating pool to begin with, I could date ten brunettes in a row and at most it might get a giggle from people who were close to me; if I had a fetish for Asian girls or Ebony-Skinned African girls it would probably be noted eventually by my friends as those women are a little rarer in my social circles, maybe if I dated three or four in a row people would notice; if I had a fetish for dwarves or women three inches taller than me it would be immediately apparent to even casual observers after the second in the series and strongly suspected/mocked at the first.
My argument is that precisely because FMF are more common, and because there are all these other reasons why women might be engaging in them, any woman that likes the "watching my partner fuck another woman turns me on" aspect of it never has to talk about it, she just gets what she wants. Where a man enjoying that is rarer, so he needs to explain it in a way that protects (lol) his heterosexual bona fides.
The idea of two men and a woman all having sex with each other (including the men with each other) almost has a kind of Byronic libertinism to it, I don’t think it describes a lot of sex that happens today.
And it is a damn shame it doesn't. RETVRN
I thought of "Cuckold Fetish" as just "I like watching someone else fuck my partner." Whether the motivation/arousal is a result of the fetishist being aroused by humiliation of watching someone better fuck his partner ("I could never fuck her like that"), or by the competition aspect of it ("I can fuck him better than she can"), or by compersion ("I like that this is making my partner happy"). I'm gathering that it refers specifically to the humiliation variety. The more you know, I guess.
It combines Law Students favorite activities: drinking and arguing about precise terminology and definitions. Somehow alcoholics will engage in a five minute debate to avoid taking a tequila shot if someone tries to make them drink it.
Anyway it's the most fun at 22-26 when people have diverged significantly in their experiences. Freshman year of college everyone is pretty close together with a few outliers, after 30 everyone is pretty close together with a few outliers, at 25 there's a huge spread between the top and the bottom.
You're just describing the Amish. They do just fine.
Instead, the narrative is that her husband is so masterful that he can maintain a harem, look how much other women envy what I have, etc.
That makes sense, I guess I didn't see the humiliation as central to the definition, but if it is a central factor then I agree I've never been in an FMF that qualified.
Not directly related, but a similar definitional debate that was had many times during games of Never Have I Ever in grad school: What counts as "Sex" for the purpose of determining Body Count, [Loss of] Virginity, practice of sexual orientation, etc.?
Classically, the heteronormative definition of sex (PIV intercourse to male completion) pretty much covered the concept. But sexual orientation complicates this, it seems ridiculous to say that a woman who has had sex with many women but no men is a virgin. Equally the variety of sex acts can complicated it, and the use of "loopholes" like oral or especially anal sex to claim technical virginity strikes most as intensely silly.
Dan Savage has generally been a proponent of labeling "Last Name Sex" (Oral, Anal, Manual, etc.) as equivalent to intercourse. But standard cultural practice has been to treat them at least slightly differently at different times.
At the same time, you have men who want to claim to have had sex with women when the thing they did seems to have stopped well short of sex. Does masturbating in front of someone constitute sex? Ejaculating on a dance floor with a partner who was just dancing with you?
So we have two major failure modes: the nice Babtist college girl who claims to be a virgin despite the high school nickname Oral Audrey, and the male desperate to pump up his numbers who claims he had "cyber" sex with a camgirl because he paid her to watch him masturbate.
The definition we settled on for purposes of determining who should drink/lower a finger in a game of Never Have I Ever was this: Sex occurs when a person 1) achieves orgasm through the 2) intentional 3) physical 4) acts of another person. When those criteria are met, both the party who orgasms and the party who caused the orgasm have had sex.
-
Orgasm by one party is necessary to establish that a complete sex act has occurred. It is not relevant if the other party orgasms or not. Sexual acts that don't result in orgasm for any party are categorized as "fooling around." Normally, in hetero relationships, it will be the case that the male orgasms and the female may or may not, but the reverse works as well. I have trouble picturing a complete sex act in which nobody orgasms. If neither could get it done, while theoretically it could have been the whole nine yards but they couldn't hit the target, it seems more likely that it was abortive or farcical, involving physical impotence or alcohol.
-
The acts have to be intentional, they have to be intended to produce orgasm. So the dancing example, that isn't sex. Or a guy who rubs against a woman in a crowded subway car.* An accidental orgasm doesn't count.
-
The acts have to be physical, they have to involve touch. Talking someone through masturbation, watching someone, or cyber sex aren't sex.
-
The acts have to be those of another person. Masturbation doesn't count, if another person is merely present and observing. There is some debate here, if the orgasm is ultimately self-initiated during acts with another person, I tend to lean towards that counting as long as the physical acts are contributing to the orgasm. So masturbation does count if the other person is playing with the masturbator to achieve and intensify arousal and orgasm.
This definition has the advantage of covering all sex acts across all sexual orientations and genital configurations. But there are definitely some "edge"ing cases where it might deliver odd results.
The alternative definition, proposed for purposes of answering the question to partners and friends about Body Counts, is that if you want to claim a high number only penetrative sex to orgasm counts, while if you are trying to claim a low number everything even mildly adjacent counts. So an 18 year old boy claiming to his buddies that he lost his virginity doesn't get to claim anything but PIV to completion; but an 18 year old girl trying to trim her partner count to sound less slutty to her boyfriend should be forced to include anyone who met even 3/4 of the above criteria. This definition is good in that if you follow it, you'll never be accused of lying or hiding anything; it is bad in that everyone wants to lie all the time and will anyway.
What other definitions would TheMotte propose? Are there different definitions useful in different situations?
*This is where we'd fit in an argument about consent.There's no good way to handle it, hopefully it's not that big an issue for any indiviudal.
I don't think FMF is primarily or only about being a woman being aroused seeing her partner with another woman in most cases, but there are definitely women (personal experience) who get off on that aspect of it. If your personal experience of it is different, you/[r] partner simply may not be in that aspect of it.
My point is that because FMF is a very normal male fantasy in 21st century secular western culture, your cuckqueen doesn't need to go out of her way to make a big thing out of her desires, she simply does a thing her husband probably wanted to do anyway. There is no cultural or moral block to navigate. If she just tells her male partner she is open to it, he won't ask motivation questions.
Whereas a male cuckold is very much going against normality, and so he has to make a big production out of it or it won't get done at all. He has to have a talk with his partner and tell her specifically that this turns him on, or she won't go along with it because it doesn't make any sense.
It's more common in women, just less extreme because everyone involved can satisfy that desire quite easily (if they are hot enough and/or willing to pay).
FMF threesomes are an incredibly common fantasy, and a woman fulfilling it for her husband is barely transgressing normality, while getting most of the cuckqueen jollies. Similarly, a woman with an "understanding" attitude to her husband's affairs might secretly eroticize it, but she has no need to verbalize it or make a big production of it.
Male cuck fantasies have to be verbalized because they are more transgressive.
Unless there's government regulation, the deaths will if anything make the whole trip more popular in the future. Risky sports are cool because they are risky, they allow men who never face any required risk to show their mettle. Repeat deaths on Everest have not slowed climbing on the mountain.
I don't think they can entirely be separated. The brain is the largest sex organ. Disgust reactions to many things are taught, as are arousal reactions, and can vary completely based on culture.
I have no idea, and our general understanding of bisexuality strikes me as primarily misunderstanding sexual market forces.
True, but civil war is an extreme example of the normal system breaking down, where the lead up to Charles I's execution was filled with the kind of royal rule-by-negotiation breaking down in the face of too strong and too obstinate power blocks.
That kind of negotiation happens in every country that doesn't break down into civil war, too. Charles could probably have been defeated short of execution by earlier capitulation, and that wouldn't have been civil war it would have merely been a weaker king and a stronger Parliament for a season.
Elites are replaced, or their efforts thwarted, or their power waxes or wanes. There's always an internal opposition: if your class isn't secure it's another class overtaking you, if your class is secure it's another family, if your family is secure it's another member of your family. There's always someone in your rear view mirror gaining on you and you've got to keep ahead by any means necessary. No elite is truly secure, only relatively secure. Xi is arguably the most powerful and secure ruler on earth today, I've no doubt that he spends part of every week keeping opposition in check or keeping people in his own circle from derailing his policies in favor of their own.
It's pretty obviously true, there's a marginal bisexual boy who if market forces make being gay difficult might just marry a woman and never really think about men that hard; who finds out it's an opportunity be can take and sexual market forces lead him to be mainly gay.
The utilitarian question being, is that percentage more or less than the marginal really really gay guy who marries a woman and they're both miserable due to lack of awareness of alternatives.
The stats probably understate Muslim (and East and South Asian) income numbers because so many are students. The vast majority of Muslims near me are still in that middle-upper middle class demographic.
It's a funny reverse from my Euro family to my American family, "I don't get why Americans/Europeans are upset about Mexican/Muslim immigration, all the Mexicans/Muslims I know are smart professionals and small business owners, much more like 'us' than the Muslims/Mexicans WE have to deal with. I'd love to trade our immigrants for your immigrants."
I'll take the Con side of 34 if you'd like.
You have to realize on the internet, when you arrive in a space your first original idea has probably been done a hundred times before and become annoying.
If I go on a Sixers fan forum and suggest trading Tobias Harris, the regulars will jump in with a million jokes about my ability to sustain an erection or mocking me for thinking they'll trade him straight up for Ja Morant. Trading Harris is super obvious and most sixers fans kinda want to see it, but it's been gone over a hundred million times already anywhere fans congregate.
Patterns emerge of bad content, even if it seems fine to a newbie eye, which will get noticed by mods.
You should stop expecting people to grieve in predictable ways that you find coherent and legible.
I've never faced anything like the public tragedy of having a family member notably murdered, but my reactions to even relatively minor tragedies are often regarded as inappropriate. People process strong emotions in different ways.
It's easy to imagine, in my mind, a grieving individual focusing intensely on the racism question specifically because their brain cannot process the grief and they wish to find a productive outlet that they have a voice and a choice in.
But they sent way more money to businesses and the donor class. The theme of COVID money was: we're going to let the little guys steal a little (stim checks, unemployment, small PPP loans) so they won't notice the big guys stealing a lot (big PPP loans, asset bubbles, ARP money to municipal governments pissed away on corrupt contracts, corrupt contracts). By making the public complicit in looting the Treasury they protected themselves from criticism.
You're correct, that was a bit of an oversimplification and compression of long periods of history. Byzantine rulers routinely blinded or castrated erstwhile male relatives, for the purpose of removing them from possible succession and rebellion even involuntarily, but this was not consistently practiced across time periods.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_mutilation_in_Byzantine_culture?wprov=sfti1
I have weirdly romantic associations with The Gulag archipelago because I proposed to my wife at a used book store, and bought the book later that day.
I'd compare his treatment of the material with McCourt's in Angela's Ashes, always picking humor over self importance, even in tragedy. It makes the book compelling and readable, where it could be a real slog.
... Are you contending that they miscounted the emperors?
I disagree with both views, from what you've written of them.
Genuine elites feel and know that they are the elites. They aren't in an existential panic about how they might lose their power. Sure they would be careful in managing their power (much like a wealthy person would be careful in managing their wealth), but it is unlikely that they would allow this be a big bad overpowering fear which dictates what they should or shouldn't do.
No one ever actually feels that secure in their power. Everyone powerful is (or should be) always in an existential panic about their power.
See this study on Roman Emperors from Augustus to Theodosius
Of the 69 rulers of the unified Roman Empire, from Augustus (d. 14 CE) to Theodosius (d. 395 CE), 62% suffered violent death. This has been known for a while, if not quantitatively at least qualitatively. What is not known, however, and has never been examined is the time-to-violent-death of Roman emperors. This work adopts the statistical tools of survival data analysis to an unlikely population, Roman emperors, and it examines a particular event in their rule, not unlike the focus of reliability engineering, but instead of their time-to-failure, their time-to-violent-death. We investigate the temporal signature of this seemingly haphazardous stochastic process that is the violent death of a Roman emperor, and we examine whether there is some structure underlying the randomness in this process or not. Nonparametric and parametric results show that: (i) emperors faced a significantly high risk of violent death in the first year of their rule, which is reminiscent of infant mortality in reliability engineering; (ii) their risk of violent death further increased after 12 years, which is reminiscent of wear-out period in reliability engineering; (iii) their failure rate displayed a bathtub-like curve, similar to that of a host of mechanical engineering items and electronic components.
This article compares to English Kings, Russian Tsars, and American Presidents on cause of death. For reference, although many Kings, Tsars, and Presidents faced political defeats and failures that stopped short of death. And these are the leaders of 4 of the most powerful and secure polities in all of human history, they faced relatively few outside predators compared to the mean European nation in that time. The low countries have never had the security and freedom that, say, England had after the Armada, let alone that of the United States or Rome. And, of course, that list measures leaders who made it to the top. I would hate to see the list for candidates for the leadership roles, especially in places like Constantinople where one of the few continuities between Byantine and Ottoman leadership was the ritual murder or mutilation of the new Emperor's brothers upon reaching the throne.
The average leader is under threat from abroad, and if he is strong enough that threats from abroad are obviated the threats from home begin to rise. As soon as Rome ran out of convenient places to conquer, as the god Terminus reached the Black Forest and the Parthian Empire and the Sahara, its generals turned back in upon itself.
I recently finished Healy's The Blazing World on the history of Civil War era England from James to the Glorious Revolution or thereabouts. And something it brought home to me was just how strong the chthonic forces of revolution underlying even the most apparently stable society can be. The levellers, the constitutionalists, the proponents of Merry England, the Catholics, the Presbyterians, the Quakers, the Puritans, Scottish and Irish and Welsh national feelings, they all seemed to erupt at once at the first opportunity. We tend to think of hereditary monarchs as rulers by fiat, in reality they are always balancing parties within their polity and within their state apparatus. Leaders are never secure, there is always an alternative, just barely being held down. There are always enemies, barely being held back, foreign or domestic.
Even if a leader is secure for his lifetime, he worries about his legacy, his children, his followers, his political projects and parties. How does he protect all that after he is gone?
Development is a gamble on using stability and power you have now to secure stability and power in the future. Development allows the current elite to install their friends and those who think like them at the top levels of new institutions. Think FDR expanding the Federal government, do you think a lot of Republicans were put in charge of those agencies? LBJ built his political career on his appointment to run the New-Deal-era National Youth Administration in Texas, he appointed or developed his own political loyalists in the NYA and used them to promote his Congressional campaigns. His congressional campaign enabled him to engage in development projects in his home district, which enabled him to court the support and loyalty of contractors and residents of his district, which enabled him to run for Senate, and so on and so forth. Development gives you more stability and more power. LBJ leveraged his power to become president, and in office he followed many of FDR's principles, FDR's development policies enabled him to promote the power of his followers and make them leaders decades after FDR's death.
TLDR: No elite is ever secure in their power, they always have something to fear internally or externally, development is a way to expand the power base belonging to oneself or one's supporters to secure against outside threats or internal threats.
Why wouldn't it explain anything else? Why is our ability to measure it according to science which has been hostile to these conclusions for decades conclusive evidence of existence or non existence of phenomena? Why would behavior be uniquely free of genetic influence, when in fact we can point to numerous examples of behavior being influenced by genetics on an individual level?
HBDers argue over and over the it's absurd to assume that genetics influences an abundance of physical characteristics but not the brain; why is it intellectually fine that the first ranked NBA player who isn't Black or Balkan is in the 30s, but racism that there aren't enough Blacks at Harvard law? Further HBDer arguments require that American folk racialization categories are accurate, that the world can be divided into White/Black/Asian and produce useful insights, why wouldn't other even more prevalent folk racial theories be correct?
It seems like if you open up to HBD, the burden is heavy to claim that it implicates only part of the brain.

How was it certain death? Hadn't they done quite a few prior dives with the same equipment that didn't result in catastrophe?
In retrospect we can all giggle, but it wasn't certain to fail in advance.
More options
Context Copy link