What is this place?
This website is a place for people who want to move past shady thinking and test their ideas in a
court of people who don't all share the same biases. Our goal is to
optimize for light, not heat; this is a group effort, and all commentators are asked to do their part.
The weekly Culture War threads host the most
controversial topics and are the most visible aspect of The Motte. However, many other topics are
appropriate here. We encourage people to post anything related to science, politics, or philosophy;
if in doubt, post!
Check out The Vault for an archive of old quality posts.
You are encouraged to crosspost these elsewhere.
Why are you called The Motte?
A motte is a stone keep on a raised earthwork common in early medieval fortifications. More pertinently,
it's an element in a rhetorical move called a "Motte-and-Bailey",
originally identified by
philosopher Nicholas Shackel. It describes the tendency in discourse for people to move from a controversial
but high value claim to a defensible but less exciting one upon any resistance to the former. He likens
this to the medieval fortification, where a desirable land (the bailey) is abandoned when in danger for
the more easily defended motte. In Shackel's words, "The Motte represents the defensible but undesired
propositions to which one retreats when hard pressed."
On The Motte, always attempt to remain inside your defensible territory, even if you are not being pressed.
New post guidelines
If you're posting something that isn't related to the culture war, we encourage you to post a thread for it.
A submission statement is highly appreciated, but isn't necessary for text posts or links to largely-text posts
such as blogs or news articles; if we're unsure of the value of your post, we might remove it until you add a
submission statement. A submission statement is required for non-text sources (videos, podcasts, images).
Culture war posts go in the culture war thread; all links must either include a submission statement or
significant commentary. Bare links without those will be removed.
If in doubt, please post it!
Rules
- Courtesy
- Content
- Engagement
- When disagreeing with someone, state your objections explicitly.
- Proactively provide evidence in proportion to how partisan and inflammatory your claim might be.
- Accept temporary bans as a time-out, and don't attempt to rejoin the conversation until it's lifted.
- Don't attempt to build consensus or enforce ideological conformity.
- Write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion.
- The Wildcard Rule
- The Metarule

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
It's odd that you'd criticize a book so strongly without actually reading it
Judging from other commenters replying, I do not think you did sufficiently understand the argument.
Books are very information dense in at least the key sections and also have the length to fully explain their arguments. You can get a summary of their ideas from a blog post, and if you agree with them you don’t necessarily need to read a full book so you understand every nuance and counter-counter-argument to the ideas. But if you disagree, I think criticizing a book without actually reading any of it is unfair to the book
I am with the OP and Hanania on this one:
https://www.richardhanania.com/p/the-case-against-most-books
Most books are not worth reading. Often, a 300 page book could be boiled down to a 10 page pamphlet without losing any information. Everything else is just argument through repetition or irrelevant details. The example Hanania gives is David Sinclair's "Lifespan" which I have also read and agree is more than 10 times as long as it should be.
I'm willing to concede that perhaps this specific book needs to be long for some reason.
Furthermore it's probably best for book reviewers to at "take one for the team" and read the entire book before criticizing it even if everyone else shouldn't bother.
I agree with you. I just think book reviewers need to actually read the book. Otherwise they might miss some critical information that underpins the argument, so they falsely think the argument is wrong.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Growth and economic development comes from endogenous and exogenous factors, not an individual pulling on a lever. Development needs human and financial capital and other macro conditions conducive to growth.
The book is not about individual actions. It is about group action, by elites -- govt, private elites, etc.
Yes, "[d]evelopment needs human and financial capital and other macro conditions conducive to growth." But that is a claim that those things are necessary for development. It is not a claim that they are sufficient for growth. The book is about something else that is also necessary for growth. Moreover, growth is not a binary outcome. Two countries with similar levels of human and financial capital and other macro conditions conducive to growth can nevertheless grow at different rates, and govt policy can affect that. China's growth did not suddenly accelerate beginning in the late 1970s because it suddenly acquired massive amounts of human and financial capital.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The book focuses on development in poor countries only, so Elon Musk is not a relevant example.
The argument is not that elites are insecure by default. You note youself that the argument instead is that development can create insecurity where it did not previously exist, because it carries risks for elites. The book argues: "One thing is clear: when those in the political and economicelite move towards longer-term growth and development, they are making a bet that may not pay off. The elite tend to gain from the status quo—that is, the politicalsystem and the economy are built to serve them. Elites that move towards growth and development, with the long-term perspective that it requires, tend to gamble that restraint and lower gains in the short term may pay off later. Vested interests are bound to be affected, and the risks to their own position are obvious. The elite are thus gambling on development." More specifically, pursuing development "may require the elite to accept new entrants, such as dynamic entrepreneurs who accumulate wealth and who over time may challenge the incumbentsin the elite. New institutions or organisations may then emerge. In short, movingto a development bargain is a serious gamble, and the outcome is not certain."
Then your understanding of insecurity is different than the concept used by the author,so your criticism doesn't work. You criticized the author for relying on a false premise, but his premise is not what you think it is.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I disagree with both views, from what you've written of them.
No one ever actually feels that secure in their power. Everyone powerful is (or should be) always in an existential panic about their power.
See this study on Roman Emperors from Augustus to Theodosius
This article compares to English Kings, Russian Tsars, and American Presidents on cause of death. For reference, although many Kings, Tsars, and Presidents faced political defeats and failures that stopped short of death. And these are the leaders of 4 of the most powerful and secure polities in all of human history, they faced relatively few outside predators compared to the mean European nation in that time. The low countries have never had the security and freedom that, say, England had after the Armada, let alone that of the United States or Rome. And, of course, that list measures leaders who made it to the top. I would hate to see the list for candidates for the leadership roles, especially in places like Constantinople where one of the few continuities between Byantine and Ottoman leadership was the ritual murder or mutilation of the new Emperor's brothers upon reaching the throne.
The average leader is under threat from abroad, and if he is strong enough that threats from abroad are obviated the threats from home begin to rise. As soon as Rome ran out of convenient places to conquer, as the god Terminus reached the Black Forest and the Parthian Empire and the Sahara, its generals turned back in upon itself.
I recently finished Healy's The Blazing World on the history of Civil War era England from James to the Glorious Revolution or thereabouts. And something it brought home to me was just how strong the chthonic forces of revolution underlying even the most apparently stable society can be. The levellers, the constitutionalists, the proponents of Merry England, the Catholics, the Presbyterians, the Quakers, the Puritans, Scottish and Irish and Welsh national feelings, they all seemed to erupt at once at the first opportunity. We tend to think of hereditary monarchs as rulers by fiat, in reality they are always balancing parties within their polity and within their state apparatus. Leaders are never secure, there is always an alternative, just barely being held down. There are always enemies, barely being held back, foreign or domestic.
Even if a leader is secure for his lifetime, he worries about his legacy, his children, his followers, his political projects and parties. How does he protect all that after he is gone?
Development is a gamble on using stability and power you have now to secure stability and power in the future. Development allows the current elite to install their friends and those who think like them at the top levels of new institutions. Think FDR expanding the Federal government, do you think a lot of Republicans were put in charge of those agencies? LBJ built his political career on his appointment to run the New-Deal-era National Youth Administration in Texas, he appointed or developed his own political loyalists in the NYA and used them to promote his Congressional campaigns. His congressional campaign enabled him to engage in development projects in his home district, which enabled him to court the support and loyalty of contractors and residents of his district, which enabled him to run for Senate, and so on and so forth. Development gives you more stability and more power. LBJ leveraged his power to become president, and in office he followed many of FDR's principles, FDR's development policies enabled him to promote the power of his followers and make them leaders decades after FDR's death.
TLDR: No elite is ever secure in their power, they always have something to fear internally or externally, development is a way to expand the power base belonging to oneself or one's supporters to secure against outside threats or internal threats.
That might have been true of that particular society, but if you look at the research on political violence, is is clear that civil war is very rare, and that stable socities tend to remain stable (which is why the single best predictor of civil war onset is recent civil war [civil war generally defined as 1000+ deaths in a given year]).
True, but civil war is an extreme example of the normal system breaking down, where the lead up to Charles I's execution was filled with the kind of royal rule-by-negotiation breaking down in the face of too strong and too obstinate power blocks.
That kind of negotiation happens in every country that doesn't break down into civil war, too. Charles could probably have been defeated short of execution by earlier capitulation, and that wouldn't have been civil war it would have merely been a weaker king and a stronger Parliament for a season.
Elites are replaced, or their efforts thwarted, or their power waxes or wanes. There's always an internal opposition: if your class isn't secure it's another class overtaking you, if your class is secure it's another family, if your family is secure it's another member of your family. There's always someone in your rear view mirror gaining on you and you've got to keep ahead by any means necessary. No elite is truly secure, only relatively secure. Xi is arguably the most powerful and secure ruler on earth today, I've no doubt that he spends part of every week keeping opposition in check or keeping people in his own circle from derailing his policies in favor of their own.
But, the original claim was specifically about "forces of revolution" -- i.e., the normal system breaking down. Not about internal opposition.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
But, STEM academics don't study the behavior or psychology of elites. So, if you only believe STEM studies, then you have no basis for your beliefs re elites other than your own personal opinion. You credit that more than you do the work of every non-STEM academic? That is very odd. Even more odd is that you think others should.
More options
Context Copy link
... Are you contending that they miscounted the emperors?
More options
Context Copy link
I don't think that's correct. The last byzantine emperor was a brother of the previous, Basil II's brother succeeded him, Manuel I Komnenos's passed over older brother Isaac wasn't killed, etc.
You're correct, that was a bit of an oversimplification and compression of long periods of history. Byzantine rulers routinely blinded or castrated erstwhile male relatives, for the purpose of removing them from possible succession and rebellion even involuntarily, but this was not consistently practiced across time periods.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_mutilation_in_Byzantine_culture?wprov=sfti1
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link