@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

I think pretty often about how many of the great novels and films of the 20s - 70s were about the emptiness and anomie of the suburban family lifestyle that is oft extolled as the height of human civilization.

-- Young men who are having trouble dating love seeing their theories proven by a promiscuous woman entering middle age having trouble dating.

-- Trad people have to point out that she's miserable because she's quite aggressively not trad. It's not hard to argue from the evidence provided.

-- Any time you post personal facts on the internet, you get mocked. She's probably a perfectly average woman, but on the internet people whose last five sexual partners average a full point below her will say she's hideously ugly. I once made the mistake, during a Covid discussion in /r/stupidpol (of all places), of mentioning that by BMI I was overweight and that I wondered if the BMI increased risk even though I lifted/climbed/ran a marathon that year. The whole thread turned into a dogpile of stupidpol-ers (of all people) telling me my lifts were dogshit and I was probably really fat and lying to myself. Say anything about yourself personally on the internet and you'll get shit on.

-- There is a contingent of people that just hates when other people try to do something in a "cheesy" way, especially if cheesy succeeds for that person.

-- The ad was almost certainly designed with hooks (spirituality? Really?) To get people to argue about it, therefore making it more likely to be spread, therefore getting more eyeballs on it. Once the doc is a spectacle, someone will reply to her, inevitably. If she's "pure" bi, possibly a woman, in which case a lot of the dynamics are quite different. Celebrities, even internet celebrities, who can't get laid don't exist.

Ode To The Kettlebell

I spent most of the winter on barbell lifting, with mild success, I was happy with how finally running Super Squats consistently went. But in the process, I bulked up a little bit. So to switch things up in the spring, I'm back to the kettlebells. (@PracticalRomantic will kill me for this) What I love about Kettlebell work is that it has all the things I love in any workout, the explosiveness and the challenge and the feeling of athleticism and the standards to measure my quantifiable numbers by; while encouraging me to work in ways that other weight workouts don't tend to. High reps, conditioning are things I normally prefer to skip.

-- Kettlebells encourage you to own the weight before you move on, for the simple reason that they're really expensive and go in big jumps anyway, so I tend to get them one pair at a time and only buy a new pair after I've totally run out of things to do with the old pair. My 50lbers lasted me six years before I bought the 62lbers, and those went through thousands upon thousands of reps before I impulse bought a single 36kg. Where with the barbell I am constantly trying to add weight, constantly trying to squeeze another 5lbs out of my muscles, with kettlebells I'm using the same weight in the same exercises for years at a time. This encourages me to really get my technique grooved, rather than to try to cheat up a weight bigger than I can actually use.

-- Kettlebells are great because they sit around my house, and it is easy to just grab them and pop out a few exercises. I can do at least a light set with any of my kettlebells with no warmup, maybe not a max set, but even with the 36kg I can pop out some swings or a few long cycle presses on a whim. I realize this is controversial among bro-scientists, but I do believe that it is possible to train the ability to have "on tap" strength as opposed to "warm up" strength. While I have a kind of respect for those who have consistent forty minute warm up routines before they start lifting, similar to the respect I have for champion bass fishermen, if all your strength is only accessible to you under ideal circumstances do you really own it?

-- Kettlebells stand for the idea of being "strong enough" conceptually, of seeking a balance between strength and endurance. Where the barbell urges you to bigger and bigger weights, forever and ever, until you hit the world record or, more likely, pull something. The classic kettlebell workout path for a man is work your way up the 24kg or the 32kg bells, then try to hit crazy reps with those. When I first got started the gold standard was 100 reps of the kettlebell snatch in 10 minutes to pass some mythical secret service test, nowadays it inflated to 100 reps in 5 minutes to make the grade as a Strongfirst instructor and on to absurd numbers for Kettlebell Sport. For the most part, if you can snatch a 24kg kettlebell and clean press two 24kg kettlebells, for reps, you're probably a pretty strong guy. I've never met anyone who could hit the old 100 snatches in ten minutes standard who wasn't in great all around shape.

-- On the other hand, as those rep standards at set weights have gotten higher and higher, we now have a new kettlebell sport even craze, the pentathlon! Where the Snatch/Jerk/Long cycle bi/triathlon have gotten crazier and crazier, the pentathlon goes the opposite way: five different 6 minute events with max rep numbers and the score is worth more per rep the higher the weight you use. Get to a good weight, then worry about reps. Then get to a max number of reps, and try to increase the weight. You always have something to pursue, but not too much of either, bring a balance to it.

Last year I tried to hit a 10m Biathlon with my 28kgs, and got up to a 131 at 190# bodyweight, which I was happy with, then I (finally) got Covid for the first time and that kind of blew up my cardio for a month which sucked. I decided to get back at it, and I'm eyeing up training the Pentathlon for a month to get back into it, then going back to trying to hit a cool number on the biathlon. I really want to hit CMS and get 160 total points on the Biathlon.

Side note: The one criticism of Crossfit I think is 100% valid is that the "American Swing" is the dumbest fucking thing in the world of fitness. Just learn the snatch you ingrates. Although every Easter I wonder if this is the year that some Crossfit gym will put together a "Stations of the Cross" WoD for Good Friday. Extra points for the Cross-Shaped improvised loaded carry implement.

Doesn't this very forum feature a strong contingent of programmers constantly lecturing the peanut gallery about how hard dating is?

I want to applaud your accurate use of the term scissor-x. As opposed to using it to merely mean controversial.

The Arabs preserved a Christian Roman bureaucracy, Christianity still forms a bridge of several centuries, and indeed it's not entirely clear that either the proto Muslims of the time or the Romans they conquered thought of Islam as a distinct concept versus a fresh sect of Christianity.

Yes but today, for every misunderstood genius, there's ten assholes who are just misunderstood. You're knee deep in Berkson's paradox, there is no correlation between being an ugly antisocial dweeb and brilliance, they're actually negatively correlated, rather the apparent correlation is because if you're that much of a loser and you're not brilliant no one ever notices you.

You should also consider why it has that Code rather than Common Law system, because Louisiana was a fully formed, settled, and important French colony before its addition to the United States in the Louisiana Purchase. While other states had prior European colonization before being added to the Anglo-American sphere, Louisiana is near unique in having a pre-existing French Creole social elite prior to colonization that survived accession to the USA; where Californian Spanish/Mestizos did not.

Engaging in Dissident Rightist's favorite game of Noticing, while decades of immigration and migration have slowly eroded the prominence of the old Francophone Creole elite and Cajun underclass, when you find corruption in Louisiana {and Mississippi} you'll find French names. There's a history of an insular local elite minority, that intermarries and excludes, dating back to Jefferson. Roman Catholicism, the French language, and devotion to preserving their culture. Combined with the legacy of slavery, which produced an unassimilated Black underclass, you had a legacy of a local insular Arcadian/Cajun white underclass which tried to preserve its local traditions, and a local insular Creole elite that tries to preserve its privileges. Even in a functioning democracy, if the locals all choose voting for other locals from "old families" and hiring for official positions from local old families with Creole connections, you have a spider's web of connections and corruption that it is difficult for immigrants to penetrate without acquiescing.

Applause for that, my friend. When I buy new books rather than downloading e-books of classics, I nearly always try to call my local bookshop and if they don't have it they can order me a copy. I'd rather spend the extra money in this time in my life.

I guess one way to assess this is to ask: would you rather live in (1) a society where your life expectancy is 80, but your lifetime risk of being murdered, mugged, or raped is 90%, or (2) a society where your life expectancy is 70, but your lifetime risk of being murdered, mugged, or raped is 10%? (As one data point, a 1987 article from the Bureau of Justice Statistics entitled "Lifetime Likelihood of Victimization" reported that the average American had an 83% chance of being a victim of violent crime at some time in their life. There is some debate about the methodology but tbh I did not spend any time trying to figure it out).

I'm just picking nits for funsies, but this is hitting near Feminist levels of over-inclusiveness of harms. Arson, Murder, and Jaywalking indeed! The three violent crimes listed are so wildly different as to be basically incomparable, the question comes down to what the percentages are for each of them. 90% chance of "victimization" that breaks down 88% chance of mugging 1% chance of rape 1% chance of murder is probably a better deal on its own than 10% chance of victimization drawn evenly 3.33% chance of murder, same for rape and mugging respectively.

I would happily take a near certain chance of getting mugged in exchange for ten years of extra life expectancy. I lose my wallet and whatever mobile wealth I had on me, I probably piss myself scared about it, maybe I'm upset for a while after, no big deal. In exchange for ten years of life? Hell yes, can I get mugged three times and live to 100? High chance of murder presumably means a more variable life expectancy, bad call, the years at the end are gonna suck anyway, don't want to risk getting cut down in my prime for ten more years with a walker. Rape itself is a term we need to define, of course, violent knifepoint stranger rape would probably be a risk I nearly want to zero out, while technical-consent-violation rape is probably closer to getting mugged in the grand scheme of things.

So in answer to your question:

I'm interested to know to what extent people agree that (a) the goal of society should be to increase happiness, and that (b) for that goal, achieving a very low level of violent crime and holding it there is probably more important than tackling air pollution, even if air pollution kills many more people.

I would agree that the odds of dying randomly or facing violence need to be minimized for a society to function, I think the term "Violent Crime" is itself over-inclusive. I'm less concerned with muggings than I am with murders, but I am also vastly more concerned with random crimes than I am with targeted crimes. Random murders of strangers are much much worse than murders of gang members by other gang members. Muggings of citizens in broad daylight are much worse than battery charges resulting from arguments between men.

Hell, in certain cases I would say that things like mutual combat assaults might even salutary, something we need more of between men in our society; but they fall into that same category of violent crime. I think a lot of people would be better behaved if they understood that saying or doing certain things might get them a punch in the nose, but that falls under "have you ever been the victim of assault?" if asked on a survey.

To really think about the question, I need to know the risk that I personally as an unconnected white man will be mugged/shot/stabbed/assaulted while passing through a town. These crimes are becoming horrifyingly more common! And need to be addressed! But they have little to do with the murder rate, which is primarily driven by a vanishingly small population of young Black men who move in certain circles. I'm trying to track down the article, but you can basically take a population of below 100,000 young men (a tiny minority within a minority) in Chicago and they will be the victims or perpetrators of the majority of Chicago murders. That number can be as high as it wants to be, they can have a 1% annual murder rate amongst themselves, I will have only vague humanitarian interest in it. I'd sooner 1,000 murders between gang members than 3 murders of random citizens on a night out. They are not both "violent crime" from a moral or from a societal functioning perspective. They are related only inasmuch as they correlate to each other.

There's a lot of roots there, something bad happening in Germany/Central Europe was very much overdetermined and I'm just going to mention them and you can look deeper yourself if you're interested. I don't really see "Culture Wars" as a valid comparison, the anti-semitism is largely an incidental superstition in my view of history, a random occurrence as a result of the ideas that were "lying around" circa 1920s Germany.

-- Western support for Fascism as a counterweight to the Red Menace of Communism, which was real and did exist. Visible most clearly in Spain, where the intention of the Republican forces was by late in the war very much to form a Stalinist satellite of Moscow, which they seemed to prioritize even over winning the war. British and American diplomats very much did think it was "Mussolini and Fascism or Stalin and Communism" in Italy, and chose Mussolini as the horse to back. You really can't overemphasize just how real a threat Soviet Russia was to everything in Capitalism countries, the number of socialists in the proletariat and in the educated classes. Very real cultural, political, and violent efforts were made to marginalize communist forces in the west after 1945, it wouldn't be until the 1960s that the threat of violent revolution could be safely put on the backburner. If Soviet Russia didn't exist, or were not an enemy of the West, it is highly likely that Hitler would have been prevented from ever reaching power. Hitler was accommodated in his violations of treaty obligations, in large part because his government had to be propped up to prevent a Communist revolution in Germany, which would have threatened the West. As it is, Hitler was in many ways a gamble by the West that didn't pay off.

-- Soviet support for Germany to obtain needed industrial goods to allow the Soviets to fend off the west. Read this

-- Deeper history of the German speaking peoples, including particularly the history of Prussia, the Holy Roman Empire and its Hapsburg successor states, and their spread further abroad a commercial minority into Russian and Slavic lands. Millions of Germans in 1919 found themselves living, for the first time in thousands of years, under a non-German speaking sovereignty. The Sudetenland wasn't a made up crisis, it really was a German community with roots stretching back centuries. This tends to get ignored in Whig history tellings in England and the USA, where you learn that Charlemagne founded the HRE and then it went into decline, check in at Charles, and we get back to it at Napoleon or all the way at WWI. The Germans living outside the boundaries of Germany and Austria got a raw deal after WWI, going from respected local minority as part of a broader majority in their state, to despised foreign minority within nation-states trying to build themselves anew as Czech/Polish/etc. It should be noted that there were actually relatively few places in Europe in 1900 between the Dnieper and the Danube where the historical gentry, the peasantry, a supermajority of the proletariat, the urban commercial classes, and the government all spoke the same language. The world post 1945 where Polish People live in Poland and speak Polish is the result of multiple physical, cultural, and spiritual efforts of ethnic cleansing. Where this didn't happen in 1945 (Yugoslavia) it had to happen later, and the brutality was often paid out with interest. {Grievance Identity-Based Nationalism is a disease}

-- The financial results of WWI, read Tooze on this one. The balance of payments crises created by the massive loans made by American banks to British and French govenrments which could not hope to pay them back without German indemnity payments influence policy during this period significantly.

-- The destruction or discrediting of so much of the prior German leadership by the results of WWI. The aristocracy collectively abdicated with the Kaiser, the loss of huge numbers of promising young men from the upper classes left a big hole in leadership. The British, French and Americans experienced this as well; but their governments came out the other end of the war intact. Germany had to cope with creating a whole new system of government, the loss of prior commercial contacts that were once within German speaking polities or colonies thereof but were now foreign, simultaneously with having much of its natural leadership destroyed.

So yeah, throw all that in a pot and stir.

If you make more than $100k, it's your civic, rational, economic, and social duty to do so.

You have skills that are valuable in the economy. Many people do not in the modern world. Cleaning your bathroom out of some misplaced sense of personal duty is inefficient, and depriving people of their livelihood whose highest and best skill is cleaning bathrooms.

All those stoic philosophers we admire who talk about personal responsibility? Had servants who cleaned for them. Yes including the one who was himself a slave, most likely.

People say it's a moral failing not to clean for yourself have it precisely backward.

I'm probably more philo than anti semitic, and a whole bunch of Jews certainly disappeared circa 1940-45, but I have written before about the ways that Holocaust education fails American and global students. Reposting old comment from last year:

The Russian war on Ukraine proves the uselessness of "telling everybody how bad the Nazis were and not to be a Nazi" as a Nazi-Prevention-Method

The Holocaust is one of the few things that are taught thoroughly in almost every American curriculum. Everywhere we learned the refrain "Never Again," I recall reading at least three books on the Holocaust from the perspective of Jews, we learned that the Nazis were the ultimate evil, etc. The only historical facts I recall learning in as much detail as many times growing up were the Declaration of Independence and The Walking Purchase.

For a long time, I've felt that we focus too much on the perspective of the victims and not enough on the perspective of the Germans (and on the facts of the broader European fascist movement and Western sympathy for it). If our goal is "Never Again" then we don't just need to see that the actions of the Nazis were wrong and bad, but how they came about, the perspective of the victims is irrelevant compared to making sure that we are never the perpetrators. Rather than Anne Frank and Night and watching Schindler's List we should be reading Hannah Arendt and Chomsky and watching Conspiracy. The result of learning the Holocaust only from the perspective of the victims is that we get everyone from the unvaccinated, to illegal immigrants, to <AEO claiming that their enemies are Nazis and about to put them into camps; and not nearly enough earnest self reflection about whether the people we're following are going in the wrong direction.

Well, I think we have the perfect test-case here. Russia has long made The Great Patriotic War and Russia's role in it the center of national history and pride. And leaving aside debates over severity of war crimes or long term motivations for the invasion, I think it is fairly self evident that Special Operation Z is the kind of thing that "Never Again" education is meant to prevent. Gary Kasparov memes are cute and all, but the fact that people can be inculcated with the message that "Nazis are Evil/The Worst" to such an extent that they'll follow a Charismatic National Leader and adopt a collective symbol on their way to launching a war of aggression and butchering civilians; well that pretty much indicates to me that "Nazis are evil" is somewhere between useless and counterproductive as a method of education if your goal is "Never Again."

Nor is this the first time an illegal war of aggression was justified by comparing an enemy to the Nazis. It certainly seems that merely understanding that Nazis are bad does not inoculate you from supporting wars of aggression. Nor does it immunize against oppressing national minorities, (I particularly like Maziyar Bizhani's contribution to the genre).

"X is Evil" is a thought terminating cliche. It removes nuance and flattens your ability to understand why people are acting the way they are acting. The more you can understand someone's motivations, the more you can enter their skin and think the way they think, the better you can predict their actions and get inside their algorithms. We should seek to understand the villains so that we can prevent ourselves from becoming them, not to understand the victims so that we can accuse our opponents of oppressing us. Nobody has ever understood themselves as evil, and pretending they did will prevent us from holding ourselves or anyone else to "Never Again." {End Prior Reddit Comment}

To expand a little bit and move away from the Russia question, the way we teach the holocaust tends to privilege the "Jews are special victims" and "Nazis were whackjobs" stories; I think a better way to teach it is to focus on the theme that: Humans have a natural and indestructible tendency to draw in-group vs out-group distinctions, this can be done in any number of ways, and under stress these distinctions tend to become more important. The in-group will frequently use historical grievances (The Treaty of Versailles, or Class Oppression, or the Holocaust) to fuel hatred against the out-group. Watch out for anyone trying to fuel those kinds of tensions, watch out for anyone talking about how "your" people have always been abused and oppressed and held back from their rightful glory, realize when you yourself are taking your stress out on class/national/political/religious enemies.

The Holocaust wasn't a one-off, nor was it whacky or strange or the result of one man's incarnation of Wotan, it was simply an extreme form of a natural human tendency, that we all carry and need to watch out for to keep it from growing too extreme. That goes equally for Stalinist purges, for Cambodian killing fields, for the Great Leap Forward, for witch panics. The out-group can be the Jews, or the Christians, or the educated, or the rich, or the poor. The reflex itself is no different from how law students at my school would complain constantly, around finals, about undergrads in the law library. The undergrads didn't really bother anyone, but they weren't supposed to be there, and finals are stressful, they became an outlet for people to hate. We have to teach kids that Naziism/Fascism were very much encouraged and allowed to flourish by the Western allies as a counterweight to the (very real) threat of Communist expansionism and revolution. Talk more about the Spanish Civil War, and Petain's France, and the phenomenon of Death Squads from Indonesia and Rwanda to El Salvador and Vietnam.

TLDR: Don't teach that Nazis were extraordinary for being villains, or that Jews were extraordinary for being victims. We are all capable of being either in the right context, teach how we avoid the sins of the past in concept not in specificity.

because used cars cost about the same as new ones.

This is true precisely because of my point: used cars today are about as good as new cars. This was simply not true twenty years ago, or even ten years ago. There used to be some really shitty cars on the market. Growing up the used cars were stuff like the Neon, the Cavalier, the first gen Ford Exploder, the Jeep Cherokee. Of course, being middle aged now, I'm growing nostalgic for some of those cars, but they were real junk in a lot of ways. Used to be that bottom end old cars got to 60 in "eventually;" had self changing oil by 80k, were junk or Ships of Theseus by 150k, were pigs on gas if they were larger than a Focus, were loud and uncomfortable and ugly. As a result they lost value quickly as better, faster, prettier cars came on the market. Sports cars went through such a revolution between 1995 and 2012 or so that every five years cars were noticeably faster and better handling.

Today that simply isn't the case. Even mom-mobiles are generally fast enough that the limitation is the driver's willingness to press down on the gas moreso than the car's capability to hit higher speeds. Most of the creature comforts like heated seats, ABS, bluetooth audio, GPS, rearview cameras were standard equipment on mid-high end models by 2015 so it's not something you need to go new for. Car design was in a much better place 2010-2015 than it was 1980-2005, so used cars look better than they used to, and improved paint prevents that sun-faded look old trucks used to get. ((Maybe I'm just crotchety, but I also think that car design has gone into decline in the last couple years as companies compete to be more EXTREME on the one end, more aggressive and less friendly all around, and all the SUVs start to look like fish.))

Nowhere in my comment do I use the word empathy or even imply that peasants were materially better treated. My argument is solely that the gentry of times past were aware that their lifestyle rested on exploitation of the lower classes in a way that today's PMC are often able to deny to themselves.

One could easily say, as you do, that it's worse to be aware of exploitation and live it anyway. But the nominal equality that the modern liberal upper classes grant the lower classes comes with precious few material benefits.

For what it's worth I also reject your trichotomy. Human relationships come in millions of forms, shades of transaction, friendship, duty, love, filial piety, hatred, self aggrandizement, manipulation, jealousy, and hierarchy come into each one.

There's no reason to buy a cheap new car today, you can buy a used car instead.

My wife, my parents, my sister, my brother in law, and myself all make six figures. The newest car in the group is a 2018. The average is roughly 2013. And I don't feel deprived in any way.

Cars used to break down at 100k miles. And features used to vastly improve every ten years. Now we all drive ten year old cars and they have Bluetooth and abs and airbags.

I'm just going to piggyback off this to make my own supplement statement. Being a basic bitch, I listen to the Huberman Lab, and I decided to get the "Hormone Support" bundle from Momentous, more out of a sense of wanting to support the podcast than anything. I've used random supplements reported to boost testosterone on sporadic occasions, but never noticed much difference.

Since taking it, I've definitely noticed a mild difference. I've bulked up some, and put on a good amount of muscle, even though my diet and sleep has been all out of whack for personal reasons, and my workouts haven't been great either. It feels like I'm getting more out of this than I should. I'm thinking in the future I plan to buy any supplements I want to take from them, maybe the problem all along has been using supplements that don't actually contain supplements.

Weak and fat may be relative terms here. I'm not super familiar with deep water but my second hand impression was that it would kill a noob.

Some of my friends tell me I'm weak and fat. Some of my acquaintances have seriously asked me if I'm on steroids. It's all in the mind.

A peasant village? Never. But up until the mid-late twentieth century, the rich had very personal relationships with their servants. Your maid was your maid, not the girl that the maid service you contracted sent over today. Feudal contracts vary across places and periods, but frequently included personal obligations by peasants to work at the manor house. Either a set number of days mowing the lord's fields, or repair work on the buildings, or personal domestic service. The nobles would very much, by the nature of their lives, interact directly with the peasantry every single day. Not on an equal footing, never as equals, but every single day they would interact directly.

Today corporate structures exist to insulate the leisure classes from personal relationships of exploitation. Even if I take Uber multiple times a day every day, I never have the feeling that I am personally exploiting any individual Uber driver. I sit in the backseat and scroll through Atlantic articles about how horribly Uber treats its drivers, but I am not personally responsible to my driver in particular. Rather Uber as an entity, or the CEO of Uber, or Venture Capitalists more generally take the blame. I don't exploit my cook or my waiter even if I eat out every meal, a variety of restauranteurs insulate me from that. I can avoid any personal repeated relationship with any of the people whose labor is exploited for my benefit.

Corporations and small businesses and city slumlords are the sin eaters of the American Professional and Managerial Classes. The nice liberal lawyers and engineers and bankers I work with can grumble about how awful the exploitation of the working class is, because other men are taking on that rough work so that their houses are cleaned and their meals are made and the cooks and maids have somewhere to live in the city.

Old feudal lords had to house their serfs, and order them around. They saw how they lived because they were the ones choosing how they lived. They had to pay them directly, when they needed them to work more they watched what that meant in real time. I can just grumble about rush pricing and how long I had to wait for my uber to take me home from the airport.

Whether we define racism as racial discrimination or "prejudice plus power" is a normative issue, as is whether it's ever okay to misgender someone.

So is your taxonomy primarily a theory of government power? These issues are appropriate issues for government action, these issues over here are not. I can presume, from your examples, that you are interested in rolling back Civil Rights law as an inappropriate place for government power to be applied. This lacks support from the American public.

81% agree that “the laws against racial discrimination in housing and employment should be strengthened” – 93% Dem, 89% Ind, 64% Rep;

91% agree that “government has a responsibility to prevent hate crimes and punish people who commit them” – 96% Dem, 84% Ind, 91% Rep;

77% agree that “laws should be strengthened to protect people from discrimination because of their sexual orientation or gender identity” – 94% Dem, 84% Ind, 53% Rep;

Now the devil is always in the details, but there is no broad democratic support for a firm red line between social and political issues on race and sex. What constitutes racism is a murky distinction once Civil Rights law is accepted as a category, it becomes a matter of degree and not of kind. This distinction does not exist in most people's minds. So if you want to start using this distinction, you are going to have to do a lot more to prove that the line is where you think it is, and not where other people think it is.

Man, I could put up a whole new effortpost about how bad Rom-Com TV shows are at writing happy marriages. Having written themselves towards a marriage that should be happy, the writers typically either need to throw up strange obstacles to create tension, toss one of the characters the idiot ball so they fuck it up, or they just draw out the process of getting together/marriage for so long that the audience gets restless.

GG suffers from the latter in the late seasons, Rory has met Logan and Lorelei is with Luke openly, but they can't just have happy marriages so they keep drawing it out with increasingly strange obstacles and weird reticence to commit. HIMYM did the idiot ball thing, from what I recall of friends complaining about it, with the couples creating drama by going off the deep end completely at random. SATC would have no idea how to write Charlotte's first marriage, so they just gave him terminal ED. The Office, I never watched in detail but people generally say it peaked at the Wedding and declined thereafter.

Even the Big Bang Theory, I will go to the mat arguing that the first season was brilliant (to me as a nerdy 16 year old with a group of friends fairly well described as a mix of Indians, Jews, and autists). But they had no idea how to write it once they coupled the characters up. The first season is a classic Rom-Com, and ends with the leads kissing, as a self contained story it works. After that the show went into terminal decline, they had no idea how to deal with the unrealistic aftermath.

Old Money has no strict, universally useful meaning. The difference between Old Money and New Money is one of reputation, history, and honor. It is the state at which you don't worry about having cash on hand, because someone somewhere will provide it to you because of who you are. Consider Tolstoy describing such a character and his role in the civil service:

Stepan Arkadyevitch had learned easily at school, thanks to his excellent abilities, but he had been idle and mischievous, and therefore was one of the lowest in his class. But in spite of his habitually dissipated mode of life, his inferior grade in the service, and his comparative youth, he occupied the honorable and lucrative position of president of one of the government boards at Moscow. This post he had received through his sister Anna’s husband, Alexey Alexandrovitch Karenin, who held one of the most important positions in the ministry to whose department the Moscow office belonged. But if Karenin had not got his brother-in-law this berth, then through a hundred other personages—brothers, sisters, cousins, uncles, and aunts—Stiva Oblonsky would have received this post, or some other similar one, together with the salary of six thousand absolutely needful for him, as his affairs, in spite of his wife’s considerable property, were in an embarrassed condition.

Half Moscow and Petersburg were friends and relations of Stepan Arkadyevitch. He was born in the midst of those who had been and are the powerful ones of this world. One-third of the men in the government, the older men, had been friends of his father’s, and had known him in petticoats; another third were his intimate chums, and the remainder were friendly acquaintances. Consequently the distributors of earthly blessings in the shape of places, rents, shares, and such, were all his friends, and could not overlook one of their own set; and Oblonsky had no need to make any special exertion to get a lucrative post. He had only not to refuse things, not to show jealousy, not to be quarrelsome or take offense, all of which from his characteristic good nature he never did. It would have struck him as absurd if he had been told that he would not get a position with the salary he required, especially as he expected nothing out of the way; he only wanted what the men of his own age and standing did get, and he was no worse qualified for performing duties of the kind than any other man.

Old Money is when a lack of liquidity, or even obvious wealth, wouldn't stand in the way of one being extended credit, a loan, a job opportunity, a business partnership, a friendship. You know you'll get your money or your favor paid back from such a person, because there is money and power somewhere in the family, or another connection will come through and help him through this rough patch, etc. It is an inevitability that a person such as this will succeed, so by doing them a favor you secure yourself a favor/influence/power in the future from him or his family. This of course is self-perpetuating, when everyone around you is doing you favors you probably succeed, and even if you don't you can borrow from Peter to pay Paul for quite a while before it catches up to you. You know that no matter what happens this person and their family will be around; and the fact that you know it balls-to-bones makes it true. New Money is simply the lack of such a widely-shared social certainty in your wealth's permanence. In God We Trust, all others bring cash.

Obviously this exists on a spectrum, your money isn't Old, or New; it is Old Enough that someone would X or it isn't Old Enough. Your family reputation is large enough that it is known to your interlocutor, or it isn't. The Windsors would be the most extreme example, the closest we get to universal Old Money, so we'll use them for a hypothetical, assuming that I am absolutely certain of the identity of the man I am talking to and no fraud or mistake is possible.

If I ran into Prince William on the Jersey Shore this summer, and he came up to me and said "FiveHour, old chap, I'm a little out of money right now, lost it all in Atlantic City at a craps table I think was crooked, could I borrow $1,000 cash to sort out some things, and give me a ride to the airport, I'll get it all back to you just as soon as I'm in London." I've never met the man in my life, but I would lend him the money without hesitation. Because I'm fairly certain that someone will lend him the money, or that he'll get out of this jam somehow, it's an inevitability, and whoever does will get the little bump of social credit for having done him a solid, and that might as well be me, why let that opportunity to do the heir a favor go to someone else? If the opportunity to lend him $1,000 and give him a ride to the airport were broadly offered, people would be crawling over each other to be the one to provide it.

At a less extreme and more local level, there are family names in my hometown where no local small business would ask for a credit check, where any local contractor would give any payment terms, because even if they didn't pay up you could go to their father/uncle/etc. and get the money. The family patriarch might take it out on the wayward son/nephew/etc.; but there is absolute certainty that you as a vendor will get your money from someone in the family. You might as well do the favor, you'll get your money back and curry favor with the family. That scales up to job offers, business partnerships, college admissions, everything. That is old money.

*The family must act to maintain this reputation, or it dissipates quickly, one dissolute cousin can tank the reputation of the whole clan. You have to be committed as a family to spending resources to prop up weaker members, getting them jobs or lending them resources, and those weaker members themselves can't be too dissolute or they will burn through reputation faster than stronger members can build it. It's a whole family commitment to respectability, it is rare in today's world but it can still happen in limited circumstances.

There was a (possibly fake) AMA years back on Reddit with an old timer who was in a 1%er biker gang, in answer to a question something like "How do you become a 1%er?" he said "Put a 1%er patch on your jacket, walk into a biker bar where other 1%ers hang out, beat the hell out of anyone who tries to take the patch off you." Nobility, or old money status, is the same way: you declare yourself Old Money and you defend yourself from any allegation that you aren't. When allegations against your family succeed, when someone lends money to your cousin and never gets it back, when they offer your nephew a salesman job and he doesn't deliver on using connections to secure sales, your family loses status. Lose enough status, the whole aura is dissipated.

To be honest, I think the intellectuals within either voting coalition are mostly monkeys riding the elephants of their uneducated or uninterested base. They think they're in charge, but they're mostly at the mercy of the dumb beast. Witness the RNC post trump, or the DNC after BLM.

But claiming that Democrats mostly or exclusively benefit from allowing stupid people to vote is a weak claim. College education might not require intelligence, and a lack of it might not exclude intelligence, but I think it's a good rule to follow that when a person/group claims that they only have the forms of positive traits that produce no outward evidence we should treat that claim with skepticism. They're like Aikido masters who claim that actually winning competitive fights is nothing compared to their imaginary ability to win fights that never happen.

Hon, I'm right there with you if you think pouring water out of a boot with instructions on the heel should be a prerequisite for voting. But Democrats hold a 13 point edge among college educated voters, if we start using intelligence as a test for voting, it's not gonna push the elections right wing.

We're just too pretty for the other rationalists, Fruck.